Arxiv:2004.14391V2 [Cond-Mat.Str-El] 22 Sep 2020
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Deconfined Metal-Insulator Transitions in Quantum Hall Bilayers Liujun Zou1 and Debanjan Chowdhury2 1Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 2Y5, Canada 2Department of Physics, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853, USA We propose that quantum Hall bilayers in the presence of a periodic potential at the scale of the magnetic length can host examples of a Deconfined Metal-Insulator Transition (DMIT), where a Fermi liquid (FL) metal with a generic electronic Fermi surface evolves into a gapped insulator (or, an insulator with Goldstone modes) through a continuous quantum phase transition. The transition can be accessed by tuning a single parameter, and its universal critical properties can be understood using a controlled framework. At the transition, the two layers are effectively decoupled, where each layer undergoes a continuous transition from a FL to a generalized composite Fermi liquid (gCFL). The thermodynamic and transport properties of the gCFL are similar to the usual CFL, while its spectral properties are qualitatively different. The FL-gCFL quantum critical point hosts a sharply defined Fermi surface without long-lived electronic quasiparticles. Immediately across the transition, the two layers of gCFL are unstable to forming an insulating phase. We discuss the topological properties of the insulator and various observable signatures associated with the DMIT. Introduction. Understanding quantum criticality in important to note that none of these transitions can metallic systems remains one of the outstanding chal- be described by the conventional framework of cou- lenges in the study of quantum matter, largely due to pling an order-parameter field to an electronic FS. Re- the abundance of gapless excitations near the electronic cently, we have argued that the DMIT can be used as Fermi surface (FS). Describing an interaction-driven a building block to describe such experimentally rel- continuous metal-insulator transition is especially chal- evant continuous transitions between distinct metallic lenging, and a mechanism for an abrupt change of a phases, simply by including additional spectator elec- generic electronic FS (at a fixed electron density) across trons in the low-energy description that do not alter a transition to an insulator in the absence of disorder any fundamental aspects of the criticality itself [5]. is necessarily novel. Critical theories for continuous A general mechanism for DMIT based on \emergent metal-insulator transitions, involving the disappear- color superconductivity" [11] was proposed in Ref. [5]. ance of an entire electronic FS, have been formulated In this work, inspired by the recent experimental ad- when the insulator is a quantum spin liquid with a FS vances in realizing quantum Hall (QH) physics in the of neutral excitations (e.g., \spinons") coupled to emer- presence of a periodic potential at the scale of the mag- gent gauge fields [1,2]. Pressure-tuned experiments on netic length (e.g., in moir´eheterostructures) [12{15], certain spin liquid candidates [3] have reported indi- we theoretically study a concrete setting for DMIT. rect evidence for such a transition [4]. One of the most Setup and framework. Consider a QH bilayer sepa- challenging and unsolved problems in the field is to rated by a distance, d, with a periodic potential in each describe a continuous metal-insulator transition where layer (Fig.1); we will refer to this setup as a \Chern the insulator has no remnant FS of any excitations, bilayer". To be concrete, we fix a unit flux quantum which we dub a “Deconfined Metal-Insulator Transi- threading through each unit cell (UC) of the periodic tion" (DMIT), or a Deconfined Mott Transition in the potential. We will consider spinful electrons in each terminology of Ref. [5]. Such a transition necessarily layer, such that spin-up electrons in the Sz-basis have falls outside the purview of the conventional Landau- a fixed density ν" = 2 + ν with ν = C=(C + 1) per Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm, even though the phases on UC per layer (C 2 integer; C 6= 0; −1), while spin- either side of the transition can be conventional. Find- down electrons have a fixed density ν# = 1 per UC per ing concrete theoretical examples of a DMIT in a solv- layer. We will focus on C > 0, but the phenomenol- able limit is therefore of paramount importance. ogy will be similar when C < 0. We further assume arXiv:2004.14391v2 [cond-mat.str-el] 22 Sep 2020 There are indirect signatures of continuous transi- that the electron number in each layer is conserved1, tions between distinct metallic phases in numerous sys- the total Sz-spin is conserved, and the system is sym- tems. For instance, in certain rare-earth element based metric with respect to exchanging the two layers and (\heavy-fermion") compounds there is evidence for en- with respect to an inversion within each layer. We are tire Fermi surface sheets disappearing [6,7], accom- interested in the situation where the electrons interact panied by a diverging effective mass near the putative critical point [8]. Perhaps the most notable example of a similar transition arises in the cuprate supercon- 1 This assumption on particle number conservation in each layer ductors [9], where a Fermi liquid (FL) metal evolves can be relaxed, as long as the total particle number is con- into an unconventional \pseudogap" metal [10]. It is served. 2 via a repulsive two-body long-range density-density in- [18] on transitions between distinct fractional Chern teraction V (r) ∼ 1=r1+, with r denoting the (three- insulators, we can describe a continuous transition be- dimensional) separation. The case with = 0 corre- tween a FL and a to-be-introduced \generalized" CFL sponds to Coulomb repulsion. We focus on 0 < < 1 (gCFL) in our setup (Fig.1b); the universal critical for most of our discussion, and comment on the cases properties can be understood in a controlled manner of = 0 and > 1 at the end. We stress that the when C 1. For the bilayer (Fig.1a) coupled via the condition 0 < < 1 is introduced purely for technical long-range repulsion, we show that the corresponding convenience, and it should not be viewed as a funda- gCFL phase is unstable to an insulator without FS of mental limitation of our proposal. any excitations [19{22]. Moreover, when C 1, we An equivalent description of this system is to view will show that the couplings between the two layers each layer as being made of spin-up electrons with fixed are renormalization-group (RG) irrelevant at the FL- density ν0 = 1 + ν and spinless Cooper pairs with fixed gCFL transition. Therefore, our Chern bilayer hosts an density νB = 1. Below we will adopt this view since it example of a DMIT (Fig.1c), where each layer under- is more convenient for our purpose. So each layer has goes a FL-gCFL transition (the latter being unstable \valence" (spin-up) electrons at a density of 1 per UC, to an insulator). Furthermore, the critical point hosts a and \conduction" (spin-up) electrons at a density of ν. non-Fermi liquid (nFL) with a sharply defined critical In fact, we will consider a scenario where the actions FS [23]. associated with the transitions mostly take place in the More specifically, denote the annihilation operator conduction electrons, while the valence electrons and of spin-up electrons and spinless Cooper pairs on the Cooper pairs are gapped spectators that are coupled `-th layer by c` and B`, respectively. We express c` in a special way to enable the transitions to be direct. in terms of partons as c` = b`f`, where b` and f` are Our proposal will thus serve as a proof-of-concept setup bosonic and fermionic partons, respectively, that sat- 0 for realizing DMIT in an electronic model. isfy a constraint on their densities [24], nb` = nf` = ν . The low-energy theory for this parton construction of the spin-up electrons can be written in terms of the partons coupled to an emergent dynamical U(1) gauge gCFL FL field, a`. We let b` carry the global conserved U(1) m charge associated with the `-th layer and f` carry the B Single layer spin (see TableI), such that the schematic Lagrangian (b) for the `-th layer takes the form: L = L + L + L + ··· ; (1) d ` [b`;A`−a`] [f`;a`+As] [c`;B`] INS FL m where A` and As are the probe gauge fields correspond- Bilayer ing to the conserved charge on the `-th layer and total (a) (c) Sz-spin, respectively. The interlayer couplings will be discussed later. In the remainder of this paper we will take L` to yield no net flux for a` and to describe a FS of f` at the mean-field level; we tune L[b`;A`−a`] to FIG. 1. (a) Schematic illustration of our proposed bilayer drive the transition. quantum Hall setup in an external B field and a periodic potential. The layers are separated by a distance d. Phase b f c B diagram as a function of m for (b) the single layer (or ` ` ` ` ` equivalently, two fully decoupled layers), and, (c) the bi- A` 1 0 1 2 0 layer. The FL-insulator (INS) transition is an example of As 0 1 1 0 0 a DMIT. a` −1 1 0 0 0 To understand the DMIT in this setup, consider a α` 0 0 0 0 1 single layer first. An earlier work [16] studied the pos- sibility of a continuous transition between a FL and TABLE I. Charge assignment of the matter fields on the a composite Fermi liquid (CFL) of spinless electrons `-th layer under the different gauge fields. [17]. However, it is our understanding that the re- sulting transition can only be accessed by tuning two One may wonder whether it requires fine-tuning parameters (instead of one) in order to avoid an in- to fix the flux of a` at the transition.