Mark O'connor's Fiddle Concerto Texas-Style Fiddling, Classical Violin, and American String Playing by Beth Youngblood a Resea
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by ASU Digital Repository Mark O'Connor's Fiddle Concerto Texas-Style Fiddling, Classical Violin, and American String Playing by Beth Youngblood A Research Paper Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Musical Arts Approved November 2016 by the Graduate Supervisory Committee: Danwen Jiang, Chair Katherine McLin Kay Norton ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY December 2016 ABSTRACT Classical violin playing and American fiddle music have traditionally been seen as separate musical worlds. Classical violinists practice and study long hours to master a standard repertoire of concertos and sonatas from the Western European school of art music. Fiddlers pride themselves on a rich tradition passed down through generations of informal jam sessions and innovation through improvisation. Mark O'Connor's Fiddle Concerto, premiered in 1993, sounds like a contradiction at first: a quintessential classical form combined with traditional fiddle playing. Examination of the Fiddle Concerto will show that the piece contains classical and fiddle-style elements simultaneously, creating an effective hybrid of the two styles. This document will explore how the history of the classical violin concerto and American fiddle music converge in Mark O'Connor's Fiddle Concerto. To gain an understanding of O'Connor's composition process, I submitted to him a list of questions, via email, in the summer of 2016. O'Connor’s responses provide a unique insight into the genesis of the Fiddle Concerto and his vision for musical compositions that originate from multiple genres. Chapter four of this document will discuss the melodic themes, formal makeup, and techniques presented in the Fiddle Concerto and show how both classical and fiddle elements coexist in the piece. The result of the mix is an exciting work that appeals to a broad audience of music lovers. The final chapter of this document will explore the growing repertoire of music created by cross- pollinating from different styles to create a new style, including selected O'Connor compositions completed since the Fiddle Concerto, as well as similar works by other composers who combined classical elements with other musical styles. i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS First, thank you to Mark O’Connor, who took time from a busy performance schedule to help with this project. His thoughts and explanations made this document possible. Thank you to Katherine McLin for her help and support during my degree. Thank you to Kay Norton for her encouragement and hours of editing and advising on this document. Thank you to my dear teacher, Danwen Jiang, for her patience and persistence in our lessons and her love and support during my years at ASU. Thank you to my parents, Andrew and Susan Youngblood, for unconditionally supporting me since my very first violin lesson. Thanks to my brother Bern, for fiddling by my side and teaching me how to improvise under the pressure of a performance! Finally, thank you to my husband Artur, who helped me through this process while completing a DMA degree of his own. His hard work and dedication have been an inspiration to me. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................................... iv LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................. v INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER 1 THE CLASSICAL VIOLIN CONCERTO ............................................................... 4 Origins of the Violin Concerto .................................................................. 4 The Baroque Violin Concerto .................................................................... 5 The Classical-Era Violin Concerto ............................................................ 9 The Romantic Violin Concerto ................................................................ 11 The Modern Violin Concerto ................................................................... 14 2 A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF AMERICAN FIDDLING .............. ............................. 18 Early American Fiddling ......................................................................... 18 Benny Thomasson’s Life and Career ...................................................... 21 Mark O’Connor’s Early Training ............................................................ 25 Mark O’Connor’s Studio Work ............................................................... 29 3 THE FIDDLE CONCERTO: GENESIS AND COMPOSITION ........................... 31 Genesis ..................................................................................................... 31 Composition ............................................................................................. 33 Overview .................................................................................................. 34 4 THE FIDDLE CONCERTO: MUSICAL ANALYSIS ........................................... 38 Movement I Themes and Formal Construction ...................................... 38 iii CHAPTER Page Movement I Solo Techniques and Style.................................................. 42 Movement I Orchestral Part ..................................................................... 46 Movement I Harmonic Language ............................................................ 49 Movement II Themes and Formal Construction ..................................... 51 Movement II Solo Techniques and Style ................................................ 53 Movement II Orchestral Part ................................................................... 54 Movement II Harmonic Language .......................................................... 55 Movement III Themes and Formal Construction .................................... 56 Movement III Musical Techniques ......................................................... 61 5 INTERTEXTUALITY ............................................................................................. 65 Premiere and Reception of the Fiddle Concerto .................................... 65 American String Playing .......................................................................... 65 The O’Connor Method ............................................................................. 66 Selected O’Connor Compositions Since the Fiddle Concerto ............... 67 Other Intertextual Works ......................................................................... 70 CONCLUSION ....................................................................................................................... 74 REFERENCES...... ................................................................................................................ 78 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH .................................................................................................. 83 iv LIST OF TABLES Table Page 4.1 Movement I Formal Construction ................................................................ 41-42 4.2 Movement II Formal Construction .............................................................. 52-53 4.3 Movement III Formal Construction ............................................................. 57-58 v LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 2.1 “Sallie Goodin’” Performed by Benny Thomasson .......................................... 23 2.2 “Sallie Goodin’” Performed by Mark O’Connor .............................................. 27 2.3 “German Waltz” Performed by Mark O’Connor .............................................. 28 4.1 Hoedown 1 ........................................................................................................... 39 4.2 Hoedown 2 ........................................................................................................... 39 4.3 Waltz 1 ................................................................................................................ 39 4.4 Waltz 2 ................................................................................................................ 39 4.5 Coda Melody ...................................................................................................... 40 4.6 Movement I Solo Figuration With Hemiola ...................................................... 42 4.7 Movement I Solo Double Stops ......................................................................... 44 4.8 Movement I Solo Waltz Embellishment ........................................................... 44 4.9 “Yellow Rose Waltz” Performed by Mark O’Connor ...................................... 45 4.10 Movement II Solo Melody 1 ............................................................................. 51 4.11 Movement II Solo Melody 2 ............................................................................. 51 4.12 Movement II Solo Embellishment ..................................................................... 53 4.13 Movement II Composed Rubato ........................................................................ 54 4.14 Movement III Jig Melody ................................................................................. 59 4.15 Movement III String Section Bowings ............................................................. 62 vi INTRODUCTION Musicologists have traditionally viewed classical violin compositions and American fiddle music as separate musical