A Comprehensive and Novel Analysis of the Chandra X-Ray Observatory Data for the Pictor a Radio Galaxy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Comprehensive and Novel Analysis of the Chandra X-ray Observatory Data for the Pictor A Radio Galaxy A PhD Dissertation by mgr Rameshan Thimmappa [email protected] presented to The Faculty of Physics, Astronomy and Applied Computer Science of the Jagiellonian University Krak´ow,Poland Supervisor: dr hab.Lukasz STAWARZ March 2021 Dedicated to My mother Padhmamma and my father Thimmappa A Comprehensive and Novel Analysis of the Chandra X-ray Observatory Data for the Pictor A Radio Galaxy by mgr Rameshan Thimmappa Abstract Pictor A, recognized as the archetypal powerful radio galaxy of the FR II type, is not only one of the brightest radio sources in the sky, but is also particularly prominent in the X-ray domain. Importantly, the extended structure of Pictor A is characterized by the large angular size of the order of several arcminutes. This structure could be therefore easily resolved by the modern X-ray telescopes, in particular by the Chandra X-ray Observatory. As such, Pictor A is a truly unique object among all the other radio galaxies. The main goal of my scientific research carried out during the last years, and summarized in this dissertation, is a comprehensive and novel re-analysis of all the available archival Chandra data for Pictor A. One of the main difficulties in this respect, is that the Chandra observations spread over the past decades have targeted different regions in the source with various exposures and off-axis angles. In addition, those regions do vary dramatically in their X-ray output and appearance, from the extremely bright and point-like (unresolved) nucleus, to the low-surface brightness but considerably extended lobes. Keeping in mind the above-mentioned difficulties and challenges, for each region within the Pictor A system and each pointing selected for the analysis, we studied in detail the Chandra point-spread function, and the emission spectrum within the 0:5 − 7:0 keV range, performing, whenever possible, image deconvolution, timing analysis, and spectral modeling. In particular, in our studies we have focused on the following three main research problems: (I) an approach to the X-ray spectroscopy of the active nucleus in Pictor A radio galaxy, carried out in a regime of a severe instrumental pile-up; (II) investigating the X-ray structure of the termination shocks of relativistic jets in Pictor A, the so-called \hotspots", by means of detailed image deconvolution and timing analyses; and (III) investigating correlations between the X-ray and radio emission features within the extended lobes of the source. The main novel results of our comprehensive analysis, regard (i) a possibility for a presence of a broad fluorescent iron line in the nuclear spectrum of the source, (ii) a sub-structure of the Western hotspot in Pictor A in X-rays, as well as (iii) the discovery of the tens-of- kpc long X-ray filament within the Eastern lobe of the radio galaxy. For the hotspot, we present for the first time the deconvolved total intensity, revealing clearly the Mach disk- structure of the termination shock at sub-pixel (' 0:25 arcsec) scale, and indicating that an efficient acceleration of ultra-relativistic electrons (up the TeV energies and more), takes place exclusively within a rather thin layer of the very front of the termination shock. For the lobe's X-ray filament, we demonstrate an anti-correlation between the X-ray surface brightness and polarized radio intensity, suggesting a presence of a magnetized thermal plasma only partly mixed with the non-thermal radio-emitting particles within the lobe, combined with the reversals in the lobe's net magnetic field. Contents Abstract iii Acknowledgments xviii 1 Introduction1 1.1 The Instruments.................................3 1.1.1 Radio{to{Submillimeter Range.....................3 1.1.2 Infrared and Optical Ranges......................7 1.1.3 X-ray Range...............................8 1.1.4 γ-ray Range................................ 11 1.2 Chandra X-Ray Observatory........................... 13 1.2.1 The Advanced CCD Imaging Spectrometer (ACIS).......... 14 1.2.2 Standard Data Processing (SDP).................... 16 1.2.3 Data Analysis Software......................... 18 1.3 Active Galactic Nuclei.............................. 19 1.3.1 AGN Phenomenology.......................... 19 1.3.2 Broad-band Emission Spectra of AGN................. 22 1.3.3 Radio Galaxies.............................. 24 1.4 Radiative Processes................................ 29 1.4.1 Synchrotron Radiation.......................... 30 1.4.2 Inverse-Compton Scattering....................... 32 1.4.3 Thermal Bremsstrahlung........................ 33 v 1.5 Pictor A: From Radio to γ-rays......................... 35 1.5.1 Radio emission.............................. 35 1.5.2 IR & Optical emission.......................... 38 1.5.3 X-ray emission.............................. 39 2 Active Nucleus in Pictor A: Data Analysis in the Regime of Instrumental Pile-up 41 2.1 Introduction.................................... 41 2.2 Data Analysis................................... 42 2.2.1 Spectral Modelling............................ 43 2.2.2 Surface Brightness Profiles....................... 49 2.3 Conclusions & Future Work........................... 54 3 Western Hotspot of Pictor A: Image Deconvolution and Variability Anal- ysis 55 3.1 Introduction.................................... 55 3.2 Chandra Data................................... 57 3.3 Data Analysis................................... 58 3.3.1 Spectral modeling............................ 58 3.3.2 PSF modeling............................... 60 3.3.3 Image Deconvolution........................... 63 3.4 Discussion: Results of the Analysis....................... 64 3.5 Conclusions.................................... 69 4 Eastern Lobe of Pictor A: Spectral Analysis and X-ray/Radio Correla- tions 73 4.1 Introduction.................................... 73 4.2 X-ray and Radio Data.............................. 75 4.2.1 Chandra Observations and Data Processing.............. 75 4.2.2 VLA Observations and Radio Maps.................. 78 4.3 Analysis Results................................. 80 4.3.1 Chandra Spectral Analysis....................... 81 4.3.2 The Surface Brightness Profile..................... 84 4.4 Discussion and Conclusions........................... 85 5 Summary and Main Conclusions 89 References 93 List of Figures 1.1 The accessible range of the electromagnetic spectrum. Note that the bound- aries between different ranges are not well defined. (Credit: Bradt 2004)...3 1.2 The electromagnetic spectrum { the atmospheric band view (`windows'). (Credit: Burke & Graham-Smith 2009).....................4 1.3 Schematic diagram of the Chandra spacecraft with the main components labeled. (Credit: NASA/CXC/SAO & J.Vaughan).............. 13 1.4 The structure of the ACIS (Credit: NASA/CXC/SAO)............ 14 1.5 A schematic diagram of the ACIS focal plane. Note ACIS-S (S3) and ACIS-I (I3) are the aimpoints............................... 15 1.6 The encircled fractional power versus the radius of point source with HRMA plus ACIS at 1 keV observation of PG 1634-706................ 16 1.7 Schematic mapping of the AGN phenomenon. (Credit: Blandford 1990)... 20 1.8 Basic types and classes of AGN based on observational criteria. (Credit: Dermer & Giebels 2016).............................. 20 1.9 Schematic representation of the AGN phenomenon in the unified scheme. (Credit: Beckmann & Shrader 2012)....................... 22 1.10 A sketch of the broad-band continuum observed in many types of AGN. (Credit: Carroll & Ostlie 1996).......................... 23 1.11 A zoom to the AGN accretion disk X-ray continuum (Credit: Fabian & Mini- utti 2005)...................................... 24 1.12 Left:: Chandra X-ray image of the M 87 radio galaxy with the X-ray jet extending to the right. Right: The zoom toward the central 10 rg (where, rg is the gravitational radius of a black hole) obtained by the EHT. (Credit: X-ray: NASA/CXC/Villanova University/J. Neilsen; Radio: Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration.)............................ 25 ix 1.13 Left: The Chandra X-ray image of the distant radio quasar PKS 1127{145, revealing the jet that extends at least a million light years from the core. (Credit: NASA/CXC/ A.Siemiginowska / J.Bechtold). Right: A compos- ite image of Chandra X-ray (blue) and VLA radio (red) observations show- ing the inner 4,000 light years of a jet in the nearby radio galaxy Centau- rus A. (Credit: X-ray: NASA/CXC/Bristol U./M. Hardcastle et al.; Radio: NRAO/AUI/NSF/Bristol U./ M. Hardcastle.)................ 26 1.14 Top: Cygnus A X-ray contours obtained with the ROSAT HRI, superim- posed on the 327 MHz VLA color image (Harris et al. 1994); Bottom: Cygnus A X-ray image by the CXO (Wilson et al. 2000)............ 28 1.15 Synchrotron radiation produced when relativistic electrons gyrate in a mag- netic field. (Credit: NASA/CXC/SAO).................... 30 1.16 A power-law spectrum of the synchrotron radiation produced by a power-law energy distribution of ultra-relativistic electrons. A single electron spectrum is shown at the top right (Credit: Carroll & Ostlie 1996)........... 31 1.17 Inverse-Compton process: low-energy photon gains energy when scattered off energetic electron. (Credit: NASA/CXC/SAO)................ 32 1.18 Bremsstrahlung: emission resulting from the interaction of free electrons with the fluctuating electrostatic potential of background protons. (Credit: NASA/CXC/SAO)................................ 33 1.19 Top: The radio