Parasitic Diseases and Psychiatric Illness
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Harvard University - DASH Parasitic Diseases and Psychiatric Illness The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Weiss, Mitchell G. 1994. “Parasitic Diseases and Psychiatric Illness.” The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 39 (10) (December): 623–628. doi:10.1177/070674379403901007. Published Version doi:10.1177/070674379403901007 Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:33894953 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA PARASITIC DISEASES AND PSYCHIATRIC ILLNESS* MITCHELL G. WEISS, M.D., PH.D.' Distinguishing parasitic diseases from other infections programs in Ethiopia provides a recent example ofthe adverse and tropical medical disorders based on microbiological effects of uprooting on health (3). The degeneration of health classification is a matter ofconvenience. Organic brain syn services from 1983 to 1987 in Nicaragua, the resurgence of dromes are associated with both protozoan and helminthic malaria and other diseases and the prevalence of infections; side-effects of drugs commonly used to treat post-traumatic stress syndrome among refugees fleeing the parasitoses may impair mood and cause anxiety. agitation or conflict show the impact of civil war on physical and mental psychosis. Emotional states may in turn affect the experience health. of medical illness. Psychiatrically significant features of medical illness are determined both by pathophysiology and Adjustment ofResidents from Abroad by the personal and social context in which they occur. Many Medical disease, temperament and both social and factors affect mental health in the tropics where the synergy environmental stressors may complicate the emotional of infection, emotional strengths, vulnerabilities, social sup adjustment of visitors to the tropics and long term residents ports and stressors is critical. This review discusses parasitic from abroad. Attention to mental health should complement diseases of psychiatric interest by virtue of their effects on routine advice about recommended vaccinations, malarial thinking, mood and behaviour; and it distinguishes issues that prophylaxis and the use of immune globulin to prepare long apply mainly to indigenous populations and visitors to en term travellers for the stressors they are likely to encounter demic areas. In some paradoxical instances the psychiatric and to promote effective coping strategies. Depression and influence ofparasitic diseases does not require infection; the burnout among some specialized groups, like volunteers and review concludes by considering the prime example, delu missionaries, may be complicated by ideas that such feelings sions ofparasitosis, which is a primary psychiatric disorder. are inappropriate (4). T. Rowland Hill coined the term "tropical neurasthenia" The squalor, malnutrition and routine adversity of life in in 1943 to describe a syndrome affecting Europeans admitted slums and impoverished rural areas where parasitic ill to a tropical hospital. The syndrome was characterized by ness is widespread impede the development ofhealth services restlessness, irritability, poor concentration and fatigability. and limit their impact. Catastrophic childhood illnesses, pri Although recognizing it was not a fashionable diagnosis, its marily infections, account for a greater proportion of the clarity was irresistible. Picturesque labels had previously morbidity seen in pediatric neurology in developing countries described the condition locally as "Punjab head", "Bengal compared with birth defects in industrialized countries (I). In head", "furor tropicus", and "West Coast memory." Hill attempts to explain characteristic features of psychiatric dis argued that tropical neurasthenia was a greater source of orders in sub-Saharan Africa, some clinicians argue that disability among the British colonials than tropical diseases, through subtle effects on the central nervous system, medical although they were related Among the 50 patients who had illness, especially malnutrition and malaria, interacts with the condition he studied, about ten percent had endured cultural influences and together explain distinctive features of repeated bouts of malaria and feared it would persist as long psychopathology (2). as they remained in the tropics. He attributed symptoms Social conditions may also facilitate the maintenance and among another 12% to the debilitated state associated with spread of many diseases and enhance their emotional burden. malarial cachexia. Where they exist, famine, political instability and civil war Other military medical officers have maintained interest in devastate the local ecology and the health system and they the relationship between particular tropical diseases and also constitute an additional burden of psychological stress. mental health. During World War 11 the incidence of organic The poor performance ofgovernment-sponsored resettlement psychosis associated with malaria increased among British troops during the monsoon, and treatment of anemia, splenomegaly and helminthiases relieved psychiatric symptoms (5). Among the Indian troops, chronic malaria, *Manuscript received September 1993. amebic dysentery and hookworm infection were commonly t Associate Professor of Psychiatry, Culture, Community, and Health Studies, associated with complaints of weakness, dizziness, vague University ofToronto;and Department of Psychiatry, The Toronto Hospital, aches and pains, but less frequently with psychotic symptoms Toronto, Ontario. Address reprint requests to: Dr. Mitchell Weiss, Clarke Institute, 250 College (6). Street, Toronto, Ontario M5T IR8 Stigma ofParasitism in Nonendemic Regions Where they are a rarity, parasitic infections may be more CAN • ..J. PSYCHIATRY, VOL. 39, DECEMBER 1994 highly stigmatized. The social meaning of a socially 623 624 CANADIAN .JOURNAL OF PSVCHlAlRY VOL. 39. No. 10 unacceptable illness, like being infected with wonns, is cerebral malaria in Liberia. His discussion also considers the frequently more troubling than the medical risk of the evidence that environmental stress can precipitate an attack particular helminthiasis to which the label re(ers. Uninfonned of malaria. A recent case report (19) ofa 30 year old woman medical personnel may unwittingly magnify the risk of admitted to a psychiatric unit with a diagnosis of atypical contagion and reinforce associated stigma by unnecessarily depression indicates the complexity of interactions between isolating such patients and requesting inappropriate malaria, personality, life events and depression. Episodes of precautions in the course of clinical management (7). fatigue and exhaustion without fever, which compelled her to remain in bed for two days at a time, recurred every three Protozoanoses to four days. A detailed travel history led to a diagnosis and treatment of malaria and her condition improved. But the Malaria depression resolved subsequently only after a course of An extensive literature documents the impact of malaria antidepressant medication. on mental health and behaviour and its influence on the social Travellers to areas with endemic malaria lack immunity history of endemic regions (8). Anderson's (9) detailed and are especially vulnerable to more severe disease when monograph on the "malarial psychoses" reviews the infected. Noncompliance with recommended prophylaxis literature and presents 201 cases, emphasizing the diversity exposes many to unnecessary risk. A recent study found 41 % of psychiatric effects. Turner (10) argues that it was the of travellers under 40 years of age were noncompliant (20), physical and psychic asthenia resulting from malaria that which indicates a need for research to explain why produced psychosis. A more current analysis (11) of acute recommendations for prophylaxis are ignored and to organic mental disorders associated with malaria detennine the consequences. Side-effects of low-dose distinguishes 1. neurasthenic syndromes that may be chloroquine used for prophylaxis are usually not troubling but intennittent or associated with fever; 2. delirium and coma; psychosis is a rare complication (21). Increasing use of and 3. malarial psychosis, usually with acute paranoid or mefloquine to treat chloroquine-resistant malaria indicates manic symptoms and depression later. Psychiatric that psychosis as a side-effect at therapeutic doses may be a impainnent usually reverses completely but among long tenn problem (22). residents of endemic areas who have endured many infections, psychopathology, deficits in memory and Trypanosomiasis intelligence, seizures and neurologic symptoms may persist. African trypanosomiasis is frequently associated with Cerebral malaria may be the most significant cause of psychiatric symptoms, especially mania and depression. acute encephalopathy in the tropics (l2):Nadeem and Younis Irritability, insomnia, mood disturbance and personality (13) found it to be the most common organic mental disorder changes are typical early signs ofthe illness, especially among in the Sudan, a factor among 44% ofthe 39 patients they Europeans. The daytime drowsiness of sleeping sickness studied. Most of these patients were excited,