SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS as at 31 DECEMBER 2006

Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) Peter Robert Harrison ND Marine employment, housing, 14 July 05 I WITHDRAWN P/199/05 1997 retail, public house/restaurant, 13 Oct 06 B Settlement hotel, new quay wall – adj , Mr M Coventry R Agricultural workers dwelling; 12m 14 Sept 05 H DISMISSED 34 P/1663/04 high wind turbine – Lower Luton 6 Jun 06 21 July 06 Farm, Pallance Lane, Cowes E/10723/J Mr Coventry E Change of use from agricultural 2 Nov 05 H DISMISSED 37 land to agricultural and residential 6 Jun 06 21 July 06 – Lower Luton Farm, Pallance Lane, Northwood P/001584/05 Mr M Pittard R Change of use from 3 holiday flats 1 Nov 05 WR ALLOWED 36 to 3 permanent residential flats – 21 July 06 Old School House, Church Road, P/00482/05 Mrs S Woodford R Demolition of house; construction 7 Nov 05 WR DISMISSED 37 of 12 dwellings – 66 Foreland 26 July 06 Road, E/11503/F Mr J Smith E Formation of vehicular access and 11 Nov 05 WR ALLOWED 36 hardstanding – 17 Star Street, 21 July 06 P/01224/04 Mr D Moore R Demolition of garage; construction 24 Nov 05 WR DISMISSED 32 of bungalow – Monkton Mead, 11 July 06 Tennyson Road, Freshwater P/1478/05 Roseberry (Yarmouth) Ltd R Conversion of lower ground floor 27 Jan 06 I WITHDRAWN parking areas into 4 6 Oct 06 apartmentments – Fort Warden Heights, Hurst Point Road, Bay

1 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/649/05 Properties R Demolition of building, erection of 7 Feb 06 WR DISMISSED 24 Ltd 3-6 storey block to form 8 flats – 25 July 06 Beachlands, Esplanade, P/1948/05 Mr & Mrs P Sellers R Single storey extension – The 16 Feb 06 WR DISMISSED 23 Cedar House, Hamstead Road, 25 July 06 Cranmore P/01885/05 Barratt (Southampton) Ltd R Residential and employment 8 Mar 06 I development – Kingston Farm Lane/Cadets Walk/Kinslea Park/Beatrice Avenue/ Power Station, East Cowes P/1903/05 Mr G Boynton R Garage – 2 Close, Ryde 15 Mar 06 WR DISMISSED 19 25 July 06 P/4325/05 Mornington LLP R 3 pairs of semi- detached houses, 16 Mar 06 H DISMISSED 18 1 detached house and 4 storey 12 July 06 31 July 06 block of 11 flats – site of Mornington, Mornington Road, Cowes P/2043/05 Mr A Johnson R End of terrace house – adj 9 17 Mar 06 WR DISMISSED 18 Orchard Mews, Staplers Road, 25 July 06 Newport P/2278/05 Ms K Truelove R Bungalow – land adj Silver 17 Mar 06 WR DISMISSED 16.5 Birches, Main Road, 18 July 06 P/1489/05 Mr K Priest R Dwelling – adj Collingtree, Alum 20 Mar 06 WR DISMISSED 15.5 Bay New Road, Totland Bay 12 July 06 P/131/06 Property Management R Bungalow – adj Lake View, Main 29 Mar 06 WR ALLOWED 16 Services (South) Ltd Road, 18 July 06 P/1678/05 Dr D Mairs R Single storey extension, balconies 7 Apr 06 WR DISMISSED 16 – West Afton, Wilmingham Lane, 25 July 06 Freshwater P/2096/05 Mr S Howe R Dwelling – between 308 and 316 7 Apr 06 WR DISMISSED 15 Road, Newport 21 July 06

2 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/306/06 Mr R Latter E COU from art gallery to wine bar, 2 May 06 WR Foresters Hall, High Street, Yarmouth P/306/06 Mr P Price E COU from art gallery to wine bar, 2 May 06 WR Foresters Hall, High Street, Yarmouth P/00347/06 Mr B Harvey E Renovation works to derelict 21 June 06 H building – Couthy Butt, Downcourt 1 May 07 Farm, St Catherines Down, Whitwell P/130/06 Cromwell Country Homes R 4 flats – 49 Cambridge Road, East 27 April 06 WR ALLOWED 15 Ltd Cowes 11 Aug 06 P/1747/05 Cromwell Country Homes R 4 flats – 49 Cambridge Road, East 27 April 06 WR DISMISSED 15 Ltd Cowes 11 Aug 06 P/2161/05 Ms T Morris R Continued use of land for 19 April 06 WR DISMISSED 16 expansion of contractors depot – 7 Aug 06 Park Place Farm, Road, Newport P/1574/05 Mr D Gladwin R Vehicular access and hardstanding 8 May 06 WR DISMISSED 14 – 110 Adelaide Grove, East Cowes 11 Aug 06 P/2455/05 Mr & Mrs S Dyer R Two maisonettes – adj 21 and 23 25 May 06 WR DISMISSED 20 School Lane, Newport 11 Oct 06 P/00397/06 Mornington LLP R 3 pairs of semi-detached houses, 1 20 April 06 H ALLOWED 13 detached house and 3 storey block 12 July 06 31 July 06 of 8 flats – Site of Mornington, Mornington Road, Cowes P/01755/05 Mr & Mrs Payne R Alterations and enlargement of 2nd 10 May 06 WR DISMISSED 15 floor window on west elevation to 24 Aug 06 include balcony – Sunset View, Marsh Road, Gurnard

3 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02185/05 Miss L Johnson R Alterations and two storey 12 May 06 WR DISMISSED 14 extension to provide two bedrooms 16 Aug 06 – 11 Alvington Manor View, Newport P/01714/05 Mrs & Mrs N Mills R Bungalow and garage, alterations 12 May 06 WR DISMISSED 21 to vehicular access – rear of 53 5 Oct 06 Horsebridge Hill, Newport P/01819/05 Mrs B Reeves R Single storey extension to form 18 May 06 WR DISMISSED 21 annexed living accommodation – 16 Oct 06 Rose Cottage, Newport Road, P/01741/05 Mr & Mrs Wavell R Variation of condition restricting 25 May 06 WR WITHDRAWN use of accommodation for holiday 12 July 06 purposes only – west of 1 & 2 Old Bakery Mews, High Street, Yarmouth P/02319/05 Mr S Kennedy R Retention of play equipment – 30 May 06 WR DISMISSED 20 Waverley Hotel, 2 Clatterford 16 Oct 06 Road, Newport P/01904/05 Mr K Benham R Demolition of conservatory, single 2 June 06 WR DISMISSED 19 storey extension to enlarge lounge 16 Oct 06 – The Laurels, High Street, Seaview E/11271/F Mr & Mrs Kent E Change of use of land to multiple 2 June 06 WR residential through siting of 2 caravans – Providence Cottage, , Ventnor P/00321/06 Mr B Harvey R Retention of agricultural storage 7 June 06 H building – Couthy Butt, Downcourt 1 May 07 Farm, Whitwell

4 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/02042/05 Mr & Mrs Oxley R Extension to residential curtilage, 12 June 06 WR DISMISSED 16 retention of driveway and parking 2 Oct 06 area, closure of existing access, landscaping and post and rail fence – Summers, Atherfield Road, Atherfield P/00480/06 P Airey R Detached chalet bungalow – 13 June 06 WR DISMISSED 16 former Southern Water tower site, 3 Oct 06 Mill Road, Bembridge P/00386/06 Westmont Properties Isle R Demolition of dwelling and garage; 19 June 06 WR DISMISSED 16 of Wight Ltd 2 houses and 4 flats, alterations to 4 Oct 06 vehicular access – 23 Terrace Road, Newport P/00525/06 Mr & Mrs D Rouse R Conversion of roof space to form 19 June 06 WR ALLOWED 15 en-suite bedroom – 29 Golden 4 Oct 06 Ridge, Freshwater P/00427/06 J Bartlett R 2 dwellings, alterations to vehicular 19 June 06 WR DISMISSED 16 access off Marlborough Road – 4Oct 06 land adj 91 and rear of 89 Marlborough Road, Ryde P/01429/05 Tescos Stores Ltd R Retail store, vehicular access 20 June 06 I alterations – land at junction of 28 Mar 07 High Street and Rectory Drive, Wootton P/00717/06 D Jeapes R Extension to form end of terrace 21 June 06 WR ALLOWED 16 house, 2 Maple Drive, Newport 10 Oct 06 E/25835/C Mr M Pittard E Non compliance with holiday 22 June 06 WR WITHDRAWN occupancy condition – The Old School, Church Road, Shanklin E/27194 A Wheeler E Erection of timber shed – 1 Albany 26 June 06 I Road, East Cowes

5 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) P/00644/06 Mr B Corbin R Conservatory/garden room – 26 June 06 WR DISMISSED 22 Knighton Barn, Knighton Shute, 30 Nov 06 Newchurch P/00529/06 Mr B Corbin RL Listed building consent for 26 June 06 WR DISMISSED 22 conservatory/garden room – 30 Nov 06 Knighton Barn, Knighton Shute, Newchurch P/01940/05 Mr C Jago R Removal of condition relating to 27 June 06 WR ALLOWED 16 opaque screening – 22 Shore 17 Oct 06 Road, Cowes P/01726/05 Mr C Torrens R Demolition of garden room; 28 June 06 WR DISMISSED 22 detached building to form annexed 30 Nov 06 accommodation to No 20 Castle Road – land rear of 18-20 Castle Road, Cowes P/00388/06 Hepburns Town & Country R 2 pairs of semi-detached houses; 30 June 06 WR DISMISSED 16 Planning Partnership footpath and parking area – 18 Oct 06 Horseshoe Inn, 353 Newport Road, Cowes E/10010/B Mr & Mrs Oxley E Formation of vehicular access and WITHDRAWN hardstanding – Summers, Atherfield Road, Atherfield

6

NEW APPEALS LODGED FOR HALF YEAR 1 JULY TO 31 DEC 2006

Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) P/00863/06 Mr P Jones R Privacy screen and safety railings 3 Jul 06 WR DISMISSED 20 on existing one storey flat roof – 21 Nov 06 33 Cambridge Road, East Cowes E/7426/M Mr & Mrs Marshall E Vehicular access and driveway – 6 Jul 06 I House, Blythe Shute, Chale P/00499/06 Mr L Booth R End of terrace house; vehicular 6 Jul 06 WR DISMISSED 17 access and parking – Land adj 67 1 Nov 06 Broadway Crescent, Ryde P/00550/06 Rotapoint Ltd RL Listed building consent for 11 Jul 06 WR ALLOWED 21 demolition of part of roof; 7 Dec 06 replacement room and conversion of part of building to form flat – Roundhouse Hotel, 61 George Street, Ryde P/00625/06 Mr & Mrs S Hall R Conservatory – Watergate Farm, 11 Jul 06 WR ALLOWED 21 Marvel Lane, Newport 7 Dec 06 P/00626/06 Mr & Mrs S Hall RL Listed building consent for 11 Jul 06 WR ALLOWED 21 conservatory – Watergate Farm, 7 Dec 06 Marvel Lane, Newport P/00846/06 Lightwood Property R Demolition of dwelling and outline 13 July 06 WR DISMISSED 18 for 14 houses with parking – 17 Nov 06 Kentstone House, Road, Ryde P/00285/06 Dr M Patterson RLDC Siting of mobile home – Wolverton 14 Jul 06 WITHDRAWN Manor, P/00545/06 Miss J Houghton & Miss L R Alterations; 2nd floor extension to 18 July 06 WR DISMISSED 22 Ramsden provide additional living 20 Dec 06 accommodation – 8 The Strand, Ryde

7 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) P/00266/06 Mr & Mrs P Sibley R Chalet bungalow and vehicular 20 Jul 06 WR DISMISSED 16 access – Hi Profile, Cranmore 7 Nov 06 Avenue, Yarmouth P/02574/05 Mrs V Taylor R Demolition of garage; outline for 31 July 06 WR DISMISSED 14 detached house and alterations to 6 Nov 06 vehicular access – Edvale, The Shute, Newchurch E/8694/H Mr D Vale E COU from garden centre to motor 15 Aug 06 H vehicle sales & office – 27 Mar 07 Car Sales, Fighting Cocks Cross, Road, , Arreton 00584/06 Mr & Mrs Flux R Demolition of house and 17 Aug 06 WR DISMISSED 21 construction of replacement 10 Jan 07** dwelling – Holden Farm House, Roud, 00887/06 Hamble Homes Ltd R COU of agricultural land to private 17 Aug 06 WR DISMISSED 21 garden – Nos 1 & 2 8 Jan 07** Farm Barns, Main Road, Chillerton 00796/06 Mr M Lawton R Demolition of dwelling; outline for 25 Aug 06 WR DISMISSED 15 replacement dwelling – Riverside 7 Dec 06 Paddock, Dodnor Lane, Newport 00371/06 Mr D Barwell R Outline for block of 3 flats – land 29 Aug 06 WR ALLOWED 15 rear of West Wight Chiropractic 11 Dec 06 Clinic, Tennyson Road, Freshwater 00318/06 Mr S G Holden IC Appeal against condition 6 – l/a 24 29 Aug 06 WITHDRAWN Pallance Road, Cowes

8 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) 00954/06 Mr R Smith R Alterations; single storey side 1 Sept 06 WR DISMISSED 19 extension to form workshop & 8 Jan 07** garage; conversion & alteration of roof including additional dormer windows on front & rear elevations to provide additional living accommodation; provision of metal fencing on front boundary – 43 Cambridge Road, East Cowes 00884/06 Mr & Mrs M Payne R Removal of condition 8 on 18 Sept 06 WR DISMISSED 19 TCP/02908/E, obscure glazing – 4 Jan 07** Sunset View, Marsh Road, Gurnard 01339/06 Hamble Homes Ltd R Enlargement of 2 windows – 1 19 Sept 06 WR DISMISSED 16 Chillerton Farm Barns, Main 8 Jan 07** Road, Chillerton 00957/06 Mr & Mrs Bruce-Smith R 2 storey side extension to form 2 20 Sept 06 WR DISMISSED 16 flats – 109 St Johns Road, Ryde 9 Jan 07** 02481/03 Wadham College R Outline for residential 22 Sep 06 I development – Road 14 Mar 07 P/00513/06 Mr S O’Sullivan R Demolition of dwelling; 29 Sept 06 WR DISMISSED 16 construction of 2 storey block of 6 17 Jan 07** flats to include accommodation within roof space, parking and alteration to vehicular access – 21 Carter Avenue, Shanklin 01050/06 Mr A Parr R Alterations, extensions Stonefold, 29 Sept 06 WR Hamstead Road, Cranmore, Yarmouth 01077/06 Mr N Underwood R Detached dwelling with garage; 29 Sept 06 WR DISMISSED 16 vehicular access – The Chalet, 17 Jan 07** Worsley Drive, Wroxall

9 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) P/01271/06 Mr A Bound R Outline for detached house and 2 Oct 06 WR terrace of 3 houses with vehicular access and parking – land at and forming part of 7 & 8 Hope Road, Ryde 01806/06 Mr MJennings R Retention & completion of chalet 02 Oct 06 WR bungalow; retention of changes to ground level – land between Bouldors & 3 Undercliff Drive, Ventnor 00610/06 Mr R Demolition of conservatory; 2 12 Oct 06 WR storey rear extension to form lounge and bedroom – 136 High Street, Wootton Bridge 01359/06 Mr B Domoney R Outline for 2 detached houses – 12 Oct 06 WR land off Barn Close, Ventnor 00394/06 Mr & Mrs Lord R Alterations to roof to provide 16 Oct 06 WR additional living accommodation & area for Water storage tanks to include dormer & balcony – 10 Zig Zag Road, Ventnor 01452/06 Mr M McNulty R Demolition of building; outline for 16 Oct 06 WR 9 dwellings – 106 School Green Road, Freshwater 00453/06 Mr & Mrs Bailey R Detached house & double garage; 18 Oct 06 WR vehicular access – l/r/o Hatherwood & fronting Heatherwiood Park Road, Totland Bay

10 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) 01245/06 Mr I Murray RL LBC for internal alterations to 19 Oct 06 WR provide office accommodation, reception & stores; installation of under floor heating – St Thomas Church, St Thomas Street, Ryde 01036/06 Miss G Fletcher R Alterations; 2 storey extension to 23 Oct 06 WR provide additional living accommodation–Pear Tree Cottage, Pallance Lane, Cowes 01324/06 Miss S Begley R Continued siting of mobile home – 20 Oct 06 WR l/a Bramhope Cottage, Cleveland farm, Sheepwash Lane, Godshill 01930/06 Mrs Davey-Sinclair R Demolition of house & studio; 2 26 Oct 06 WR storey block of 4 flats – Douglas Studio, Town Lane, Sandown 01712/06 Mr P Tyson R Demolition of garage & store; 30 Oct 06 WR extension to form end terrace house – 60 Nodes Road, Cowes 00825/06 Harold Cudmore Ltd R Demolition of dwelling; 30 Oct 06 H construction of 4/5 storey building 13 Feb 07 to form 13 flats, basement parking, landscaping, detached house; vehicular access – Yeomans, 4 Queens Rd, Cowes 00828/06 Harold Cudmore Ltd RC Conservation Area Consent for 30 Oct 06 H demolition of dwelling; 4/5 storey 13 Feb 07 building to form 13 flats, basement parking, landscaping, detached house; vehicular access – Yeomans, 4 Queens Rd, Cowes 00665/06 Mr & Mrs Pilgrem R Outline for dwelling; vehicular 31 Oct 06 WITHDRAWN access – land adj 3 Dairy Lane, 20 Nov 06 Newport

11 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) 02208/07 Mr D Welsh RLDC Continued use of building as self- 1 Nov 06 WITHDRAWN contained living accommodation – 7 Dec 06 rear or 33 High Street, Cowes 01957/06 Mr D Bedding R Alterations; 2 storey extension for 3 Nov 06 WR additional living accommodation – 4 Alexandra Cottages, Westhill Lane, Norton 01567/06 Mr & Mrs Hutchins ND Conversion of hotel into guest 8 Nov 06 WR accommodation and single dwelling house – Windsor Carlton Hotel, 4-5 Alexandra Gardens, Ventnor 01279/06 A M Structures Ltd R COU from food distribution (B8) to 14 Nov 06 WR general industrial (B2) – Woodlands House, Embassy Way, Sandown 01721/06 Mr A Bound R Outline for detached house with 17 Nov 06 WR parking & vehicular access – land at rear of 4 Hope Road, Ryde 02170/04 Mr & Mrs O’Keefe R Conversion of redundant barn to 20 Nov 06 WR unit of holiday accommodation with terrace on south west elevation; alterations to vehicular access – Gladices Barn, Gladices Lane, 00619/06 Mr G Debenham R Demolition of bungalow;outline for 24 Nov 06 WR proposed semi-detached and chalet bungalow; vehicular access off Beech Road and Robin Hood Street – 21 Beech Road, Newport 01656/06 Mrs G Andrew R Proposed end of terrace house – 28 Nov 06 WR land adjacent, 37 Parkland Avenue, Cowes

12 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) 02065/06 F B Construction Ltd R Proposed 2 storey bock of 2 flats 29 Nov 06 WR – land rear of Bakewell Café fronting, Tennyson Road, Freshwater 01648/06 Hall & Woodhouse R Proposed 6 low level lighting 23 Nov 06 WR columns with lanterns to access drive – Clarendon Hotel & Wight Mouse Inn, Church Place, Chale, Ventnor 01423/06 Peter Ferns R Outline for dwelling; vehicular 28 Nov 06 WR access – land rear of 33 Woodvale Road, Cowes 01360/06 Mr & Mrs Kindred R Outline for a dwelling; formation of 29 Nov 06 H vehicular access – land between St Martins & Dundas West, Afton Down, Freshwater 02149/06 Mr A Button R Change of use of barn from 30 Nov 06 WR agricultural to storage and distribution - Noke Common Dairy, Noke Common, Newport 00938/06 Mr & Mrs T Wells R Widening of vehicular and 1 Dec 06 WR pedestrian access into Elm Grove with new double gates - 1 Woodbine Villas, St Johns Road, Newport 01931/06 Mr D Walters R Outline for residential 4 Dec 06 H development and alterations to vehicular access – Kingston Works, Kingston Road, East Cowes 02263/06 Eileen Jacobsen R Conservatory – 14 Place Side, 5 Dec 06 WR Cowes

13 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) 00868/06 Mr M Denness R Conversion of barns (1 & 2) into 2 5 Dec 06 H units of holiday accommodation to include bedrooms within roofspace – barns at Farm, Road, Queen Bower, Sandown 01550/06 Mr & Mrs M Medway R Retention of alterations to widen 5 Dec 06 H existing vehicular access – Old Chapel House, High Street, Whitwell 01434/06 Mr N Julian R Single/2 storey extension to 6 Dec 06 WR provide additional living accommodation and integral garage – 15 Strathwell Crescent, Whitwell, Ventnor 00968/06 Mr & Mrs L Goulden R Two storey extension to form 18 Dec 06 WR garage with hobbies room over; two storey extension to provide additional living accommodation - Ferndale, Newport Road, Apse Heath, Sandown 01221/06 Mr A Attrill R Demolition of bungalow; proposed 20 Dec 06 WR terrace of 3 houses – 80 Horsebridge Hill, Newport 02618/06 Mr R Stanley R Proposed semi-detached house – 20 Dec 06 WR land adjacent 24 Sibden Road, Shanklin 01986/06 Mr J Bewick R Outline for residential development (revised scheme), 21 Inglewood Park, St Lawrence

14 Overall Appeal Appeal Procedure/ duration decision Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I of appeal and (if known) (in date weeks) 02580/06 Mr A Bound R Demolition of extension, construction of two storey detached dwelling – 8 Hope Road, Ryde 02509/06 Village Developments R Demolition of side extension and garage, construction of terrace of 3 houses (revised scheme) E/23336/B Mr & Mrs M Medway E Retention of alterations to widen existing vehicular access – Old Chapel House, High Street, Whitwell E/13764/C Mr& Mrs P Sibley E Siting of residential mobile home at Hi Profile, Cranmore Avenue, Cranmore, Yarmouth

KEY

Type Appeal Procedure

R = Refusal of planning permission WR = written representations RL = Refusal of listed building consent H = hearing RC = Refusal of conservation area consent I = public inquiry RA = Refusal of advertisement consent IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period E= Enforcement notice RLDC= Refusal for lawful development certificate

15

SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR HALF YEAR ENDING 31 DECEMBER 2006

Number of new appeals 67

Number appeals still in progress 119

Number of appeals withdrawn/invalid 9

Number of appeals determined 50 NB decisions marked ** not included within these figures as issued after end of Dec Dismissed 38 (76%) Allowed 12 (24%)

16