Arxiv:2105.14067V2 [Gr-Qc] 24 Jun 2021

Phenomenological implications of modified loop cosmologies: an overview Bao-Fei Li 1;2∗, Parampreet Singh1y, and Anzhong Wang3z 1 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803, USA 2 Institute for Theoretical Physics & Cosmology, Zhejiang University of Technology, Hangzhou, 310032, China 3 GCAP-CASPER, Department of Physics, Baylor University, Waco, TX, 76798-7316, USA (Dated: June 25, 2021) In this paper, we first provide a brief review of the effective dynamics of two recently well-studied models of modified loop quantum cosmologies (mLQCs), which arise from different regularizations of the Hamiltonian constraint and show the robustness of a generic resolution of the big bang singularity, replaced by a quantum bounce due to non-perturbative Planck scale effects. As in loop quantum cosmology (LQC), in these modified models the slow-roll inflation happens generically. We consider the cosmological perturbations following the dressed and hybrid approaches and clarify some subtle issues regarding the ambiguity of the extension of the effective potential of the scalar perturbations across the quantum bounce, and the choice of initial conditions. Both of the modified regularizations yield primordial power spectra that are consistent with current observations for the Starobinsky potential within the framework of either the dressed or the hybrid approach. But differences in primordial power spectra are also identified among the mLQCs and LQC. In particular, for mLQC-I, striking differences arise between the dressed and hybrid approaches in the infrared and oscillatory regimes. While the differences between the two modified models can be attributed to differences in the Planck scale physics, the permissible choices of the initial conditions and the differences between the two perturbation approaches have been reported for the first time. All these differences, due to either the different regularizations or the different perturbation approaches , in principle can be observed in terms of non-Gaussianities. I. INTRODUCTION problem of cosmological fluctuations 1. The second problem of the inflationary paradigm is more severe. It is well known that inflationary space- Despite offering a solution to several fundamental and times are past-incomplete because of the big bang sin- conceptual problems of the standard big bang cosmology, gularity [10], with which it is not clear how to impose including the flatness, horizon, and exotic-relic problems, the initial conditions. This problem gets aggravated for the cosmic inflation in the early universe also provides a low energy inflation in spatially-closed models which are mechanism to produce density perturbations and primor- slightly favored by current observations where the uni- dial gravitational waves (PGWs) [1{3]. The latter arise verse encounters a big crunch singularity and lasts only from quantum fluctuations of spacetimes and produce for a few Planck seconds [11]. not only a temperature anisotropy, but also polarizations Another problematic feature of inflation is that one in the cosmic microwave background (CMB), a smoking often ignores the pre-inflationary dynamics and sets the gun of PGWs. However, the inflationary paradigm is Bunch-Davies (BD) vacuum at a very early time. But, incomplete without the knowledge of key elements from it is not clear how such a vacuum state can be realized quantum gravity. First, it is well-known that the cosmic dynamically in the framework of quantum cosmology [6], inflation is sensitive to the ultraviolet (UV) physics, and considering the fact that a pre-inflationary phase always its successes are tightly contingent on the understanding exists between the Plank and inflation scales, which are of this UV physics [4{6]. In particular, if the inflationary about 103 ∼ 1012 orders of magnitude difference [2, 6]. arXiv:2105.14067v2 [gr-qc] 24 Jun 2021 phase lasts somewhat longer than the minimal period re- While these problems of inflationary paradigm demand a quired to solve the above mentioned problems, the length completion from quantum theory of spacetimes, they also scales we observe today will originate from modes that open an avenue to overcome one of the main obstacles in are smaller than the Planck length during inflation [4]. the development of quantum gravity, which concerns with Then, the treatment of the underlying quantum field the- the lack of experimental evidences. Thus, understanding ory on a classical spacetime becomes questionable, as now inflation in the framework of quantum gravity could offer the quantum geometric effects are expected to be large, valuable guidances to the construction of the underlying and the space and time cannot be treated classically any theory [13{15]. more. This is often referred to as the trans-Planckian 1 It has been conjectured using models in string theory that the ∗E-mail address: [email protected] trans-Planckian problem might never arise [7], which results on yE-mail address: [email protected] severe constraints on various cosmological models (See [8, 9] for zE-mail address: Anzhong [email protected] more details). 2 In particular, when applying the techniques of loop µ¯ scheme [19], which is known to be the only possible quantum gravity (LQG) to homogeneous and isotropic choice in LQC, and results in physics that is independent universe, namely loop quantum cosmology (LQC) [16], from underlying fiducial structures used during quantiza- it was shown that, purely due to quantum geometric ef- tion, and meanwhile yields a consistent infrared behav- fects, the big bang singularity is generically resolved and ior for all matter obeying the weak energy condition [70]. replaced by a quantum bounce at which the spacetime Lately, the studies of [66] have been extended to theµ ¯ curvature becomes Planckian [17{20]. The robustness scheme [71]. of the singularity resolution has been shown for a vari- In the two modified LQC models, mLQC-I and mLQC- ety of isotropic and anisotropic spacetimes [21]. Interest- II, since different regularizations of the Lorentzian term ingly, there exists a reliable effective spacetime descrip- were used, the resulting equations become the fourth- tion, which has been used to confirm a generic resolution order and non-singular quantum difference equations, of all strong curvature singularities [22]. Various phe- instead of the second-order difference ones obtained in nomenological implications have been studied using this LQC. In these two models the big bang singularity is also effective spacetime description, whose validity has been generically resolved and replaced by a quantum bounce. verified for isotropic and anisotropic spacetimes [23{27]. In addition, the inflationary phase can naturally take For low energy inflation models with a positive spatial place with a very high probability [72{76]. In addition, curvature, the singularity resolution and a successful on- the dynamics in LQC and mLQC-II is qualitatively sim- set of inflation for classically inadmissible initial condi- ilar in the whole evolution of the universe, while the one tions have been demonstrated [28{30]. in mLQC-I becomes significantly different from LQC (as In the last couple of years, several approaches have well as mLQC-II) in the contracting phase, in which an been proposed, in order to address the impacts of the emergent quasi de Sitter space is present. This implies quantum geometry on the primordial power spectra. that the contracting phase in mLQC-I is purely a quan- These include the approaches of the deformed algebra tum regime without any classical limit 2. [31{33], dressed metric [34{36], and hybrid [37{41] (For An important question now is what are the effects of a recent discussion about similar ideas in anisotropic these models and approaches on the CMB observations. Bianchi I LQC spacetimes see Refs. [42{45] and refer- The answer to this question requires the knowledge of ences therein.). In particular, the last two approaches how the quantum fluctuations propagate on a quantum have been widely studied and found that they are all con- spacetime in LQC and modified loop cosmological mod- sistent with current cosmological observations [46{59]. In els. In particular, in the framework of the dressed metric addition, within the framework of the dressed metric ap- approach the power spectra of the cosmological perturba- proach recently it has been also shown that some anoma- tions for both mLQC-I and mLQC-II models were inves- lies from the CMB data [60{62] can be reconciled purely tigated [78]. In the same framework but restricted only to due to the quantum geometric effects [63, 64]. the mLQC-I model, the power spectra of the cosmological In addition to the standard LQC, in which the perturbations were studied in [79]. More recently, the hy- Lorentzian term of the classical Hamiltonian constraint brid approach was applied to mLQC-I [80{82], for which is first expressed in terms of the Euclidean term in the time-dependent mass of the perturbations was stud- the spatially flat Friedmann-Lema^ıtre-Robertson-Walker ied in detail [83]. The primordial scalar power spectra (FLRW) universe, and then only the quantization of the obtained in the three models, LQC, mLQC-I and mLQC- Euclidean term is considered, the robustness of the singu- II, were also investigated in the hybrid approach [84], and larity resolution with respect to different quantizations of found that the relative differences in the amplitudes of the classical Hamiltonian constraint in the symmetry re- the power spectra among the three models could be as duced spacetimes have been extensively studied. Two no- large as 2% in the UV regime of the spectra, which is table examples are the so-called modified LQC-I (mLQC- relevant to the current observations. Interestingly, in the I) and modified LQC-II (mLQC-II) models, which were above work, differences in primordial power spectra were first proposed by Yang, Ding and Ma more than a decade found between the hybrid and dressed metric approaches ago [65]. In a recent study, Dapor and Liegener (DL) in the infra-red and oscillatory regimes in mLQC-I.

Load more