Regional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board Sardar Patel Bhavan, Rameshwarnagar, Jamnagar, 361 008

Public Hearing Proceedings

It is hereby informed that as per the Ministry of Environment & Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its Notification no. S.O. 1533 dated September 14, 2006; Public Hearing is fixed for following project covered under Category B. M/s Saurashtra Calcine Bauxite & Allied Ind. Ltd. (SCABAL), has proposed Hadmatiya Bauxite Mining Project (Lease Area: 12.95 HA) located at Survey No. 121/P, Village Hadmatiya, Taluka Kalyanpur, Dist Jamnagar as mentioned in their request application received.

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment report and the Summary of Environment Impact Assessment report was sent to the following authorities or offices to make available the draft EIA report for inspection to the public during normal office hours, till the public hearing is over.

1. The District Magistrate (Collector) office, Jamnagar, Dist. Jamnagar 2. District Development Office, Jamnagar, Dist. Jamnagar 3. District Industry Centre, Jamnagar, Dist. Jamnagar 4. Taluka Panchayt Office, Kalyanpur, Dist. Jamnagar 5. The Chief Conservator of Forests, Ministry of Environment & Forests, GOI, Regional Office (West Zone) Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan, E-5, Arera Colony, Link Road 3, Ravisankar Colony, Bhopal, 462016 6. Regional Office, GPCB, Sardar Patel Bhavan, Rameshwarnagar, Jamnagar, 361 008

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects were requested to send their response in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities, they were requested to send their comments to the regulatory authorities as under:

The Secretary, State Environmental Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA), Paryavaran Bhavan, Sector 10 – A, Gandhinagar – 382 010.

The Public Hearing is scheduled on 26.02.2010 at 11.00 hrs. at Lohana Mahajan Wadi Hall, Kalyanpur, Taluka Kalyanpur, Dist Jamnagar.

An advertisement in English was published in Times of India, Ahemdabad edition dated 24.01.2010 and Gujarati in Jai Hind in Rajkot editions dated 25.01.2010.

The District Magistrate, Jamnagar has supervised and presided over the entire public hearing process. A statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing is enclosed as Annexure A.

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing is enclosed as enclosed as Annexure-B.

A statement showing response and comments received in writing from other concerned is enclosed as Annexure- C.

Encl: Annexure A, B & C with Video CD of Public Hearing.

(A.V. Shah) (Shri Sandip Kumar, IAS) Regional Officer, GPCB, District Magistrate & Collector Jamnagar as representative Jamnagar of the Member Secretary GPCB.

Place: Kalyanpur Village: Kalyanpur Taluka: Kalyanpur District: Jamnagar Date: 26.02.2010

Annexure A

Annexure B

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing.

As per the Ministry of Environment & Forest Government of India, New Delhi vide its notification no. S. O. 1533 dated September 14th 2006 Public Hearing was fixed for project covered under Category B, M/s Saurashtra Calcine Bauxite & Allied Ind. Ltd. (SCABAL), has proposed Hadmatiya Bauxite Mining Project (Lease Area: 12.95 HA) located at Survey No. 121/P, Village Hadmatiya, Taluka Kalyanpur, Dist Jamnagar & M/s Saurashtra Calcine Bauxite & Allied Ind. Ltd. (SCABAL) Ran Bauxite Mining Project (Lease Area: 5.27 HA) located at Survey No. 403/P, Village Ran, Taluka Kalyanpur, Dist Jamnagar. The Public Hearing is held on 26.02.2010 at 11.00 hrs. at Lohana Mahajan Wadi Hall, Kalyanpur, Taluka Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar.

Shri Sandip Kumar, IAS Hon’ble District Magistrate & Collector, Jamnagar presided over the aforesaid public hearing and also briefed about the public consultation & public hearing as laid down in the notification dated 14.09.2006

Shri A. V. Shah, representative of the Member Secretary, GPCB and Regional Officer, RO, GPCB, Jamnagar explained about the background of the environmental clearance required by the project proponent and opportunity being provided to the affected people residing in and around project site as per aforesaid Notification, on the consent of Hon’ble District Magistrate & Collector, Jamnagar, a representative of M/s Saurashtra Calcine Bauxite & Allied Ind. Ltd. Asked to make presentation covering summary report of draft EIA prepared by the project proponent.

Shri Pushpin Shah (Consultant) representative of M/s Saurashtra Calcine Bauxite & Allied Ind. Ltd. Made presentation about their proposal of Hadmatiya Bauxite Mining Project at Village Hadmatiya, Taluka Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar & Ran Bauxite Mining Project located at Village Ran, Taluka Kalyanpur, Dist Jamnagar. The forum declared opened for representation made by local people issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing is as under; Sr. Reply by representative of Issue raised by Remarks No. Project Proponent 1. Shri Malti Vedant Mer, Representative of Company Village Navadara Shri M. K. Choubey, • He had informed that company is not (Manager Mines) had replied carrying out 5% work as mentioned in that mining activity is not their presentation. Company is not being carried out below the carrying out water sprinkling. ground water level, hence salinity ingress problem will • Due to movement of company’s not occur. They are carrying vehicles problem of dusting arises due mining activities as per the to which nearby farms crops is approved IBM plans and damaged. carrying out backfilling activities. The rain water gets • Nearby villages are having about 5000 accumulated in mine out pits, to 10000 sheeps & goats & grazing which will recharge the area for the cattle’s will be removed . ground water, also this accumulated water is used for • Mines pounding area are not having agriculture activities in nearby safety measures due to which cattles areas. He further informed that fall down in the pounding area. necessary measures are taken during the transportation for prevention of dusting. 2. Shri Bela Jagdish Rambhai, Representative of Company Village Kalyanpur Shri M. K. Choubey, • Due to mining activity deep pits are (Manager Mines) had replied occurred which leads to more & more that mining activity is not saline water ingress, which results being carried out below the increase in salinity which damages the ground water level, hence water quality & also affects the salinity ingress problem will agricultural land. not occur. They are carrying mining activities as per the • Gas Line is passing through nearby approved IBM plans and mining areas hence there are chances carrying out backfilling of disasters. activities. Presently there no gas pipelines nearby the lease area, hence there is no chances of damage. 3. Shri Deva Arjan Bharvardia, Representative of Company Village Jamkalyanpur Shri M. K. Choubey, • Company is not carrying out water (Manager Mines) had replied sprinkling which results in dusting and that mining activities will be due to which results in damage of carried out above the ground crops. water table. Due to mined out pits water reservoir will be • Agricultural land is damaged due to formed due to which water pits developed by mining activity. table will be recharged. He had given an example of a • Dusting is occurred due to blasting reputed company in which the activity in mines therefore cultivation water table in the nearby area Sr. Reply by representative of Issue raised by Remarks No. Project Proponent in nearby farms get damaged. recharged and local people are benefited. • Due to movement of company’s vehicals roads are getting damaged.

• Grazing area is affected due to dusting of mines which results in decrease of cattles in the area.

• He had represented that their area is dependent on agricultural activities & due to the company they face damage in farms. He had informed that they are opposing the project. 4. Shri Sonagra Nanji Meghji, - Village Jamjodhpur. • He had given an example of Village Jodhpur in which a windmill company had acquired 54 Acres of Gauchar Land.

• He had informed that they are facing more problems in low level areas in the nearby areas of mines. And the same should checked. 5. Shri Muljibhai Baghabhai, - Village Ran • Due to the company their crop cultivation is increased. He had further informed that they are welcoming the project 6. Shri Jesa Vira Dalvadi, - Village Ran • The area is facing famine and due to the company they are getting jobs & earnings. Therefore they are welcoming the project. 7. Shri Mula Raya, - Village Ran • Due to the company they are getting jobs & earnings. Mining activities should be carried out in non agricultural areas. He had welcomed the project. 8. Shri Ramsingh Dadu, Representative of Company Village Navadra Shri M. K. Choubey, • He had represented that nos. of people (Manager Mines) had replied are dependent on farming are more as that instead of damage in the Sr. Reply by representative of Issue raised by Remarks No. Project Proponent compared to nos. of people working in farms, they are benefited due the company hence the damage in the to water accumulated in mined crops is more as compared to out pits. He further informed opportunity of jobs & earnings. He had that more jobs opportunity further informed that his farmland is will be generated in the nearby nearby the company in Hadmatiya areas Village & they are facing the damage in farming.

• Dusting results from the company activity spreads about 10 K.M. area and damages the nearby areas & they are not willing to continue the same 9. Shri Gojiya Bhavesh Jesabhai, Representative of Company Village Kalyanpur Shri M. K. Choubey, • Due to pits developed mining activity (Manager Mines) had replied salinity ingress is increased & due to that instead of damage in the air pollution nearby crops are getting farms, they are benefited due damage. In compare to jobs & earning to water accumulated in mined from the company the amount of out pits. He further informed damage in nearby area are more. that more jobs opportunity will be generated in the nearby areas 10. Shri Mishri Pidha Gagher, - Village Hadmatiya • He had represented that his farmland is situated at survey no. 125 near the company area . He is cultivating the farm land with the water of mine pits, which results in more production of crops and presently he cultivated 250 ( x 20 kgs) Wheat. He is welcoming the project.

(A.V. Shah) (Shri Sandip Kumar, IAS) Regional Officer, GPCB, District Magistrate & Collector Jamnagar as representative Jamnagar of the Member Secretary GPCB.

Place: Village: Kalyanpur, Taluka: Kalyanpur District: Jamnagar Date: 26.02.2010 lok sunavÌ loksunavÌma> wag lenar shwagIAo ¹ara ]#avel muá Ane p/ojeK3 na p/itin2I ¹ara Aapvama> Aavel p/Tyu_²ar. wart srkarna pyaRvr` Ane vn m>t/aly, nvI idLhIna jahernama kma>k Aes. Ao. ÉÍËË tarIq ÉÌãÒÑãÊÒÒÎ he#5 ke3egrI “bI” ma> AavrI levayel me. sOra*§ keLsa[n boKsa[3 AeND Aela[D [NDS§Iz lImI3eD ¹ara p/ayo+t hDmaitya boKsa[3 ma[n(ÉÊ.ÑÍ heK3r) sveR n> ÉÊÉãpI, gam hDmaitya, taluka kLya`pur, ijLlo jamngr Ane me. sOra*§ keLsa[n boKsa[3 AeND Aela[D [NDS§Iz lImI3eD ¹ara p/ayo+t ra` boKsa[3 ma[n(Í.ÊÏ heK3r) sveR n> ÌÒËãpI, gam ra` nI loksunavÌ tarIq ÊÎ.ÒÊ.ÊÒÉÒ na roj ÉÉ.ÒÒ klake lohaà mhajn vaDI hol,kLya`pur, taluka kLya`pur, ijLlo jamngr mukame raqvama> Aavel.

7I s>idp kumar Aa[. Ae. Aes. mannIy ijLla me+S§e3 Ane kleK3r, jamngr Aa loksunavÌna A@y9S4ane rHya Ane sdr no3IfIkexn he#5 loksunavÌ Ane lokp/Tyu_²ar (pBlIk kNsl3exn) nI maihtI jaàvI t4a S4anIk lokone teAona p/XnonI rjuAat krva jàvel.

7I Ae.vI.xah sWy sicv7I +. pI.sI.bI. na p/itini2 Ane +. pI.sI.bI. jamngr na p/deixk Ai2karIAe k>pnI ¹ara sdr no3Iifkexn he#5 pyaRvr` m>jurI me5vva ma3enI j½rIyat t4a Aa suict p/ojke3nI Aaspas rheta Asr he#5na lokone Aa p/ojeK3 s>b2It rjuAato krva ivxe maihtgar kyaR Tyar bad mannIy ijLla me+S§e3 Ane kLaeK3r7I nI AnumtI4I me. sOra*§ keLsa[n boKsa[3 AeND Aela[D [NDS§Iz lImI3eD na p/itini2ne teAona suict p/ojeK3 temj te A>gena D\/aF3 [. Aa[. Ae. rIpo3R nI s>i(aPt ½pe rjuAat krva j`aVyu>. me. sOra*§ keLsa[n boKsa[3 AeND Aela[D [NDS§Iz lImI3eD na p/itini2 7I. pu*pInxah kNsL3N3 ¹ara hDmaitya qate p/ayo+t hDmaitya boKsa[3 ma[n(ÉÊ.ÑÍ heK3r) Ane ra` boKsa[3 ma[n(Í.ÊÏ heK3r) sveR n> ÌÒËãpI, gam ra`, taluka kLya`pur, ijLlo jamngr na p/ojeK3 ivxe rjuAat krI.

LaoksunavÌ drMyan rjuAat krnar S4aaink AsrktaR lokonI rjuAat ma3e m>c quLlo mukvama> AaVyo. loksunavÌ drMyan wag lenar ¹ara ]#avvama> Aavel muáAo t4a tena k>pnIna p/itini2 ¹ara p/Tyu_²ar Aapvama> AaVyo je nIce mujb 0e.

rjuAat krnarne p/ojeK3na no> An muó ccRnar nu nam p/itini2 ¹ara Aapvama> 2 Aavel p/Tyu_²ar 1. 7I maltI veda>t mer, k>pnI na p/tInI2I 7I gam nvadra cObe+AeÜ\ma[Ns menejr • teAo Ae jàvel ke k>pnI ¹ara Ýp/Tyutr Aapta kHyuke krvama> Aavel p/ejN3exn k>pnI ¹ara ma[NSana ma> dxaRvel maihtI mujb nI qodkam vqte paÌna t5 su2I Í% kamgIrInu p` paln p` n4I qodvama> Aavtu n4I je4I 4tu> n4I.k>pnI ¹ara paÌ qara paÌ Aag5 v2ta n4I. t4a 0a>3vama> Aavtu n4I. qodkam kyaR p0I bek fIlI>g krvama> Aave 0e. je • k>pnI na vahnona Avrjvr4I Aa[.bI.Aem. Planma> Aaspas na qetroma> 2u5 dxaRVya mujb krvama> ]Dvane karè nukxan 4ay 0e. Aave 0e.ma[Nsna qaDaAoma> vrsadI paÌ wrvava4I paÌnu t5 su2re • Aaspasna gamma> A>daje 0e.t4a Aa paÌ Aas pasna ÍÒÒÒ 4I ÉÒÒÒÒ 6e3a qetroma> ]pyogma> bkraAo 0e jeAo ne crva levama> Aave 0e.k>pnI ma3enI jGyaAo rhexe nhI. ¹ara vahnonI Avrjvr4I ]DtI 2u5na s>dwRma> yoGy • PaaÌna poNDma> slamtI pgla> levam>a Aave 0e. ma3enI VyvS4a nhova4I tema> pxuAo pDI jay 0e. 2. bela jgdIx ramwa[, k>pnI na p/tInI2I 7I gam kLya`pur cObe+Ae Ü\ma[Ns menejr • ma[Ns na karè }>Da qaDa Ýp/Tyutr Aapta kHyuke 4ay 0e,jena karè drIyanu k>pnI ¹ara ma[NSana paÌ v2une v2u A>dr 2sI qodkam vqte paÌna t5 su2I Aave 0e.Ane 9ar v2e 0e. je4I qodvama> Aavtu n4I je4I rjuAat krnarne p/ojeK3na no> An muó ccRnar nu nam p/itini2 ¹ara Aapvama> 2 Aavel p/Tyu_²ar paÌnI smSya v2e 0e.t4a qara paÌ Aag5 v2ta n4I. t4a qetInI jmIn bgDe 0e. qodkam kyaR p0I bek fIlI>g • Aaspasma> 4I ges nI krvama> Aave 0e. je pa[pla[no psar 4ay 0e, je4I Aa[.bI.Aem. Planma> du6R3na 4vanI xKyta rhel dxaRVya mujb krvama> 0e. Aave 0e.ma[Nsna qaDaAoma> vrsadI paÌ wrvava4I paÌnu t5 su2re 0e. gesnI pa[pla[n k>pnI nI jGya4I 6Ì dur hova4I du6R3na 4vanI xKyta n4I. 3. deva Arj` warvaDIya, k>pnI na p/tInI2I 7I gam jamkLya`pur cObe+Ae Ü\ma[Ns menejr • k>pnI ¹ara paÌ 0a>3vanI Ýp/Tyutr Aapta kHyuke xrtnu> paln krvama> Aavtu paÌna wugwR na Str nI ]pr n4I jena4I DS3I>g 4va4I qa`nu> qodkam krvam>a qetIma> nukxan 4ay 0e. Aavxe.qa`na qodkam4I 4ta qaDama> j5axy bnxe, jena • ma[Nsma> krvama> Aavta karè ma[nI>gnI Aaspas na ]>Da qaDaAone karè jmIno paÌ rIcajR 4xe.v2uma> bgDe 0e. temè ANy Aek ]·ogno daqlo AapI jàvel ke • ma[Nsma> krvama> Aavta Aajubajuna ivStarma> paÌ BlaS3I>gna karè rjkò ]De na Str su2rel 0e.jena4I 0e, jena4I AaspasnI qetIma> Aaspasna S4anIk loko ne nukxan 4ay 0e t4a pak in*f5 faydo 4ay 0e. jay 0e.

• k>pnIna vahnonI Avrjvrne kar`e rStaAo bgDI gyel 0e.

• ma[Nsna kar`e 4ta DS3Igna lI2e 6ascarane Asr 4ay 0e, t4a 2Ime 2Ime pxuAo nax pame 0e.

• temè rjuAat krel ke Amaro ivStar qetI pr Aa2arIt 0e jema> k>pnI ne karè nukxan rjuAat krnarne p/ojeK3na no> An muó ccRnar nu nam p/itini2 ¹ara Aapvama> 2 Aavel p/Tyu_²ar 4ay 0e. te4I temè jàvel ke teAo Aa k>pnI kam kre tem [C0ta n4I. 4. sonag/a nan+ me6+, - gam jamjo2pur • temè ]dahr` Aapta jàvel ke jo2pur ivStarma Aavel Aek pvncKkIna karqana ¹ara gOcrnI jmIn l[ levama> Aavel 0e. A>daje ÍÌ heK3r je3lI jmIn l[ levama> Aavel 0e.je4I gOcrnI jmIn Ao0I 4[ gyel 0e.

• tem`e j`avel ke Aa ma[NSana nIca`va5a ivStama> v2u p/ma`ma> tklIfo 4ay 0e, jenI tpas krvI j½rI 0e.

5. mu5+wa[ ba6awa[, - gam ra` • K>pnI ¹ara teAone faydo 4yel 0e t4a Aaspas na +½na ]wa pakne faydo 4ay 0e.v2uma> tem`e j`avel ke k>pnI calu rhe tem teAo [C0e 0e.

6. jesa ivra dlvaDI, - gam ra` • Aa ivStar m>a wuqmra nI piriS4tI 0e jema> k>pnI ¹ara ro+ m5I rhe 0e. te4I Aa K>pnI calu rhe te ma3e temè jàvel. 7. mularaya, - \gam ra` • K>pnI na karè teAone ro+ro3I m5I rhe 0e. je ivStarma> qetI n4I,Tya> rjuAat krnarne p/ojeK3na no> An muó ccRnar nu nam p/itini2 ¹ara Aapvama> 2 Aavel p/Tyu_²ar kamgIrI krvI jo[Ae. 8. ramis>h DaDU, k>pnI na p/tInI2I 7I gam nvadra cObe+Ae Ü\ma[Ns menejr • temè jàvel ke karqanama> Ýp/Tyutr Aapta kHyuke kam krta> ma`so krta qetI k>pnI ¹ara krvama> Aavta kam krta ma`so v2are 0e je4I qodkamne karè qetIne ro+ro3I m5va krta> qetIma> nukxan 4xe nhI. Ta4a qa` nukxan v2are 4ay 0e. temè na qaDama> paÌ wravva4I jàvel ke teAonI jmIn qetI su2rxe. V2uma> temè hDmtIyam>a k>pnI nI jàvel ke Aaspas na n+kma>j 0e, t4a k>pnI Ae ivStarma> rojgarI nI tko krel rjUAat p/maè qetI 4tI v2xe. n4I p` nukxan 4ay 0e.

• k>pnIma>4I ]dwvtI 2u5 Aaxre ÉÒ ik.mI su2I jay 0e, jena4I Aa ivStarma> nukxan 4ay 0e. te teAone m>jur n4I. 9. go+ya wavex jexawa[, k>pnI na p/tInI2I 7I gam kLya`pur cObe+Ae Ü\ma[Ns menejrÝ p/Tyutr Aapta • ma[Nsna qaDaAone karè kHyuke k>pnI ¹ara krvama> Aaspas na ivStarma> Aavta qodkamne karè jmInma> qarax Aave 0e, t4a qetIne nukxan 4xe nhI. hva p/du8`na karè Aaspas Ta4a qa` na qaDama> paÌ na pak ne nukxan 4ay 0e. wravva4I qetI su2rxe. 6à Ao0a ma`sone ro+ m5e V2uma> temè jàvel ke 0e, tenI same nukxan v2are Aaspas na ivStarma> 4ay 0e. rojgarI nI tko v2xe. 10. mIsrI pI!a 6a6er, - gam hDmtIya • temè jàvel ke hDmtIya gamna sveRn> ÉÊÍ ma>j k>pnInI n+kma> teAo nI qetI nI jmIn 0e. qa`na paÌ4I qetI krva4I ]Tpadn v2u 4ay 0e t4a halma> teAo ¹ara ÊÍÒ m` 6} pkvvama> Aavel 0e. t4a qetI ma> faydo 4yel 0e.

(Ae. vI. Xaah) p/adeixk Ai2karI, +. pI.sI.bI. (7I s>idpkumar, Aa[. Ae. Aes) j_amngr Ane sWy sicv7I ijLla me+S§e3 Ane kleK3r7I +. pI.sI.bI.na p/itini2 jamngr

S45: gam: kLya`pur taluka: kLya`pur ijLlo: _amngr ta. ÊÎ.ÒÊ.ÊÒÉÒ

Annexure C

A statement showing response and comments received in writing from other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environment aspects in writing, and replied by the project proponent M/s Saurashtra Calcine Bauxite & Allied Ind. Ltd. has proposed Hadmatiya Bauxite Mining Project at Village Hadmatiya, Taluka Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar & Ran Bauxite Mining Project located at Village Ran, Taluka Kalyanpur, Dist Jamnagar , as per the Ministry of Environment & Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its Notification no. S. O. 1533 dated September 14th, 2006

Sr. Response of comments received in Reply given by the project Remarks No. writing form to the concerned persons proponents Shri Karshan Ratna Kanjaria, Reply given through Letter No. Affected Farmers, Village Ran, Taluka SCABAL/PH/2010/1 1. Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar, Dtd: 26 February 2010 Dated 20.02.2010 Sr. Response of comments received in Reply given by the project Remarks No. writing form to the concerned persons proponents Shri Dare Markhibhai Vejanbhai, Reply given through Letter No. 2. Affected Farmers, Village Navadra, Taluka SCABAL/PH/2010/2 Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar Dtd: 26 February 2010 Affected Farmers, Village Juvanpur, Reply given through Letter No. 3. Taluka Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar, SCABAL/PH/2010/3 Dated 20.02.2010 Dtd: 26 February 2010 Shri Salabhai Lakhdharir Chakhalia, Reply given through Letter No. Affected Farmers, Village Devalia, Taluka SCABAL/PH/2010/4 4. Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar, Dtd: 26 February 2010 Dated 19.02.2010 President, Reply given through Letter No. 5. Bhartiya Kishan Sangh, Jamkalyanpur, SCABAL/PH/2010/5 Dated 19.02.2010 Dtd: 26 February 2010 Shri Naran Sajan Gorajiya, Reply given through Letter No. Affected Farmers, Village Gangdi, Taluka SCABAL/PH/2010/6 6. Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar, Dtd: 26 February 2010 Dated 19.02.2010 Shri Chavda Malde Merag, Reply given through Letter No. Affected Farmers, Village Sattapar, SCABAL/PH/2010/7 7. Taluka Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar, Dtd: 26 February 2010 Dated 19.02.2010 Shri Sanabhai Alabhai Chetaria, Reply given through Letter No. Affected Farmers, Village Lamba Bunder, SCABAL/PH/2010/8 8. Taluka Kalyanpur, District Jamnagar, Dtd: 26 February 2010 Dated 19.02.2010 Mantri, Reply given through Letter No. 9. Bhartiya Kishan Sangh, Jamkhambhaliya SCABAL/PH/2010/9 Dated 22.02.2010 Dtd: 26 February 2010 Mantri, Reply given through Letter No. 10. Bhartiya Kishan Sangh, Jamkhambhaliya SCABAL/PH/2010/10 Dated 16.02.2010 Dtd: 26 February 2010 Sr. Response of comments received in Reply given by the project Remarks No. writing form to the concerned persons proponents Paryavaran Mitra, (Centre for social justice Reply given through Letter No. – Janvikas) – NGO Ahemdabad. SCABAL/PH/2010/11

11. Letter Ref.: #PM/MP/484/2010, dated 25/02/2010 Dtd: 26 February 2010 (Hadmatiya) Letter Ref.: #PM/MP/482/2010, dated 25/02/2010 (Ran) Paryavaran Mitra, (Centre for social justice Reply given through Letter No. – Janvikas) – NGO Ahemdabad. SCABAL/PH/2010/12 12. Letter No. PM/MP/481/2010 dtd. Dtd: 26 February 2010 25.02.2010 Reply given through Letter No. Shri Bela Savdas Lakhmanbhai, 13. SCABAL/PH/2010/13 Village Jamkalyanpur, dated 26.02.2010 Dtd: 26 February 2010 Reply given through Letter No. Shri Bela Savdas Lakhmanbhai, 14. SCABAL/PH/2010/14 Village Jamkalyanpur, dated 26.02.2010 Dtd: 26 February 2010