SOCRATES in the CLASSROOM Rationales and Effects of Philosophizing with Children Ann S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SOCRATES IN THE CLASSROOM Rationales and Effects of Philosophizing with Children Ann S. Pihlgren Socrates in the Classroom Rationales and Effects of Philosophizing with Children Ann S. Pihlgren Stockholm University ©Ann S. Pihlgren, Stockholm 2008 Cover: Björn S. Eriksson ISSN 1104-1625-146 ISBN (978-91-7155-598-4) Printed in Sweden by Elanders Sverige AB Distributor: Stockholm University, Department of Education To Kjell with love and gratitude. Contents Contents ........................................................................................................ vii Preface ............................................................................................................ 1 1 Introduction ............................................................................................ 3 1.1 Philosophizing and teaching ethics ..................................................................... 4 1.2 Some guidance for the reader ............................................................................ 5 1.3 Considerations ................................................................................................... 8 2 Research Goals and Design .................................................................. 9 2.1 Classroom interaction ......................................................................................... 9 2.2 Studying Socratic interaction ............................................................................ 10 2.3 Research questions .......................................................................................... 10 2.4 Research design and data collection ................................................................ 11 2.4.1 The literature review .............................................................................. 11 2.4.2 The seminar study ................................................................................. 12 2.5 Ethical considerations....................................................................................... 18 2.6 Validity and reliability ........................................................................................ 19 SECTION I Literature on Socratic Interlocution Review and Analysis .......... 23 3 Catching the Spirit of Socratic Dialogue .............................................. 25 4 Dialogues as Maieutike ........................................................................ 27 4.1 The allegory of Socrates ................................................................................... 27 4.1.1 Socrates and the voice of Plato ............................................................. 28 4.2 Dialogues as elenchus, maieutike and aporia .................................................. 30 4.2.1 Socratic ignorance and knowledge ........................................................ 30 4.2.2 Events in Socrates’ interlocutions .......................................................... 31 4.2.3 Teaching by elenchus ............................................................................ 31 4.2.4 Dialogic “rules” of conduct ..................................................................... 32 4.2.5 The role of Socrates’ questioner ............................................................ 33 4.2.6 Socrates: the gadfly, the midwife and the stingray ................................. 34 4.3 Socratic dialogue in Platonic pedagogy ............................................................ 35 4.4 Perplexity and virtues in Aristotelian pedagogy ................................................ 35 4.4.1 Aristotle’s habits, virtues and practical wisdom ...................................... 36 5 Progressive Education and Dialogue as Education in Democracy ..... 38 5.1 Progressive education ...................................................................................... 38 5.2 Freinet and dialogue in community meetings ................................................... 39 5.3 John Dewey and dialogues as recitations ......................................................... 40 5.3.1 Deliberative democracy ......................................................................... 41 6 Dialogue as Folkbildning-Swedish Popular Education ........................ 42 6.1 Bildning ............................................................................................................ 42 6.2 Swedish popular education .............................................................................. 44 6.2.1 The ideas of Hans Larsson, Ellen Key, and Oscar Olsson ..................... 45 6.3 The methods of dialogue as study circle ........................................................... 46 6.3.1 The circle leader .................................................................................... 47 6.3.2 The goals and functions of the circle ...................................................... 47 6.4 The methods of dialogues as discussions ........................................................ 48 6.4.1 “Rules” and steps of the discussion ....................................................... 49 7 Dialogue as Das Sokratische Gespräch .............................................. 50 7.1 Leonard Nelson and das Sokratische Gespräch ............................................... 50 7.2 The methods of das Sokratische Gespräch ...................................................... 51 7.2.1 The role of the teacher ........................................................................... 51 7.2.2 Demands on the student ........................................................................ 51 7.2.3 The steps of das Sokratische Gespräch ................................................ 52 8 Dialogues as Great Conversation ........................................................ 53 8.1 Mortimer J. Adler and Robert M. Hutchins ........................................................ 53 8.2 Dialogues as shared inquiry ............................................................................. 56 8.2.1 The methodology of shared inquiry ........................................................ 57 8.2.2 “Rules” in shared inquiry ........................................................................ 58 8.2.3 The steps of shared inquiry .................................................................... 58 8.3 Dialogues as Paideia seminars ........................................................................ 59 8.3.1 The goals and methodology of the Paideia seminar .............................. 60 8.3.2 The steps of the Paideia seminar........................................................... 61 8.3.3 “Rules” of the Paideia seminar ............................................................... 62 8.3.4 The role of the facilitator in the Paideia seminar .................................... 62 8.3.5 Assessing the outcomes of the Paideia seminar .................................... 63 9 Dialogue as Sokratiska samtal ............................................................ 64 9.1 Lars Lindström and Sokratiska samtal .............................................................. 64 9.1.1 The role of the facilitator in Sokratiska samtal ........................................ 64 9.2 Identificatory reading ........................................................................................ 65 9.3 The context of Sokratiska samtal ...................................................................... 66 9.3.1 “Rules” and dialogical virtues ................................................................. 67 10 Dialogue with Children ......................................................................... 69 10.1 Should children be exposed to Socratic dialogue? ...................................... 69 10.1.1 Are children too immature to philosophize? ........................................... 69 10.1.2 Is the Socratic method dangerous to society? ....................................... 71 10.2 Gareth B Matthews philosophizing with children ......................................... 71 10.3 P4C and PWC ............................................................................................. 72 10.3.1 The methods of P4C and PWC .............................................................. 73 10.3.2 The steps of P4C and PWC ................................................................... 73 10.4 Philosophizing with children in the earlier presented traditions .................... 74 11 Results of the Literature Review .......................................................... 75 11.1 The major goals of the presented traditions ................................................ 75 11.1.1 Sorting out the “Socratic” traditions ........................................................ 76 11.2 Abilities trained in the Socratic seminar ....................................................... 78 11.2.1 Intellectual character .............................................................................. 79 11.2.2 Moral character ...................................................................................... 79 11.3 The context of the seminar .......................................................................... 80 11.3.1 The methodology of the seminar............................................................ 80 11.3.2 The role of the facilitator ........................................................................ 82 11.4 Critical events and possible breakdowns .................................................... 83 SECTION II The Seminar Study ..................................................................