DOCSLIB.ORG

Nuclear Heresy: Environmentalism As Implicit Religion By

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Nuclear Heresy: Environmentalism As Implicit Religion By Nuclear heresy: environmentalism as implicit religion By: Caroline McCalman A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Sheffield Faculty of Social Sciences Department of Urban Studies and Planning November 2018 Nuclear heresy: environmentalism as implicit religion By: Caroline McCalman A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Sheffield Faculty of Social Sciences Department of Urban Studies and Planning November 2018 Abstract | Nuclear heresy: environmentalism as implicit religion This thesis is a discourse study of environmentalism in the UK. The research indicates how reframing environmental issues using religious concepts and language can deepen our understanding of people’s relationship to the environment and environmentalism. The thesis suggests that this process of reframing may be important for the social sciences, by illuminating new ways to engage with and understand the controversies and debates at hand. The data supporting this reframing analysis was obtained through in- depth, semi-structured one-on-one interviews with individuals identified as being ‘environmentally concerned’ and was analysed first thematically, and then using the researcher’s ‘discourse toolkit’. Nuclear power is treated as an emblematic issue to provide a concrete focus for a topic prone to abstraction; viewing environmentalism as a form of religion encouraged interdisciplinary working. By developing ideas from Bailey’s implicit religion (Bailey, 1997) I provide a language for environmentalism-as-religion, wherein pro-nuclear heretics challenge an anti-nuclear orthodoxy. Linking environmental discourses to enduring cosmologies shows that ‘superficial’ conflict over climate change mitigation is acrimonious precisely because it deals with manifestations of deeper convictions on the human-nature relationship. Updated versions of existing ‘nuclear discourses’ are analysed in combination with environmental-religious discourses, showing that ideas about public understanding and acceptance of nuclear power, even when rebranded as ‘sustainable’, are still best understood in terms of ancient cosmological ideas about the ‘natural’ or ‘proper’ way for humanity to approach and interact with the environment. Key environmental discourses were overtly religious and or even direct reformulations of Christian mythoi, with important implications for the movement’s stagnation and inherent contradictions. This thesis argues for the social sciences to take religion seriously, as the religious impulse – both implicit and explicit – is an important social phenomenon which shows no sign of fading and remains an important factor in modern society. Acknowledgements Thanks and acknowledgements go to the following people who have tirelessly supported the completion of this thesis: My supervisors Dr Steve Connelly and Dr Russell Hand; My husband Dr Nikolay Ogryzko and my parents Kevin and Carol McCalman; And all those who were so kind as to host me in Sheffield during the last three months: Dr Anna Krzywoszynska and Dr Kevin Marples; Matthew Cooper; Dr Lauren Buck; Holly Feast and Robbie Burrell. Contents Abstract | Nuclear heresy: environmentalism as implicit religion ....................................................................... 3 Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 List of Figures ............................................................................................................................................................... 9 Chapter 1 | Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Foreword ............................................................................................................................................................ 1 1.2 Key Concepts ..................................................................................................................................................... 3 1.3 The Research ..................................................................................................................................................... 5 1.3.1 Research aim and Premises ...................................................................................................................... 5 1.3.2 Justification of the research ..................................................................................................................... 6 1.3.3 Approach to the research ......................................................................................................................... 7 1.4 Structure of the Thesis ..................................................................................................................................... 9 Chapter 2 | Discourses of Religion ........................................................................................................................ 11 2.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 11 2.2 Discourse: loquela tua manifestum te facit ................................................................................................. 11 2.2.1 Doing discourse analysis ......................................................................................................................... 13 2.2.2 Contested concepts ................................................................................................................................. 14 2.3 (Implicit) Religion ........................................................................................................................................... 18 2.3.1 Defining (explicit) religion: a creed, a code, a cult ............................................................................. 18 2.3.2 Implicit Religion ...................................................................................................................................... 22 2.3.3 Environmentalism as Implicit Religion ................................................................................................ 25 2.4 Cosmologies ..................................................................................................................................................... 28 2.4.1 Classical Cosmologies: Divine Order, Organic, Mechanistic ........................................................... 29 2.4.2 Modern Environmental Cosmologies: ecocentric versus technocentric ........................................ 32 2.4.3 Christian Cosmologies: Dominion vs Stewardship ............................................................................ 34 2.5 Chapter conclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 36 Chapter 3 | History of Science and Religion ........................................................................................................ 39 3.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 39 3.2 Foundations of Western Thought ................................................................................................................ 40 3.2.1 Schism! ...................................................................................................................................................... 42 3.3 The last 500 years ............................................................................................................................................ 44 3.3.1 The Protestant Reformation .................................................................................................................. 44 3.3.2 The Scientific Revolution ....................................................................................................................... 45 3.3.3 The Enlightenment ................................................................................................................................. 47 3.3.4 The Industrial Revolution ...................................................................................................................... 49 3.4 The secularisation thesis................................................................................................................................. 50 3.4.1 Irrational religion ..................................................................................................................................... 52 3.4.2 Remaining religion ................................................................................................................................... 55 3.4.3 Necessary religion .................................................................................................................................... 56 3.5 New Atheism and scientific authority ......................................................................................................... 58 3.6 Chapter conclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 61 Chapter 4 | Modern Environmentalism & Nuclear
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Contextual Examination of Three Historical Stages of Atheism and the Legality of an American Freedom from Religion
    ABSTRACT Rejecting the Definitive: A Contextual Examination of Three Historical Stages of Atheism and the Legality of an American Freedom from Religion Ethan Gjerset Quillen, B.A., M.A., M.A. Mentor: T. Michael Parrish, Ph.D. The trouble with “definitions” is they leave no room for evolution. When a word is concretely defined, it is done so in a particular time and place. Contextual interpretations permit a better understanding of certain heavy words; Atheism as a prime example. In the post-modern world Atheism has become more accepted and popular, especially as a reaction to global terrorism. However, the current definition of Atheism is terribly inaccurate. It cannot be stated properly that pagan Atheism is the same as New Atheism. By interpreting the Atheisms from four stages in the term‟s history a clearer picture of its meaning will come out, hopefully alleviating the stereotypical biases weighed upon it. In the interpretation of the Atheisms from Pagan Antiquity, the Enlightenment, the New Atheist Movement, and the American Judicial and Civil Religious system, a defense of the theory of elastic contextual interpretations, rather than concrete definitions, shall be made. Rejecting the Definitive: A Contextual Examination of Three Historical Stages of Atheism and the Legality of an American Freedom from Religion by Ethan Gjerset Quillen, B.A., M.A. A Thesis Approved by the J.M. Dawson Institute of Church-State Studies ___________________________________ Robyn L. Driskell, Ph.D., Interim Chairperson Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Baylor University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts Approved by the Thesis Committee ___________________________________ T.
    [Show full text]
  • Hidden Nature, the Startling Insights of Viktor Schauberger
    Contents Foreword by David Bellamy 11 Introduction 13 Part One: An Alternative Worldview 1. Schauberger's Vision 25 The water wizard 26; Log flumes 29; Water, source of life 31; Motion is crucial 32; Temperature controls 34; Evolution 34; Balance 35; Implosion 35; The visionary 36. 2. Different Kinds of Energy 39 Subtle energies 39; Schauberger's worldview 39; Why the mystery? 40; Degrees of energy 41; The vortex as the key to creative evolution 42; Energies as creative process 43; Spiritual science 44; Different dimensions 45; Changing octaves 47. 3. The Attraction and Repulsion of Opposites 49 The Sun as a fertilizing entity 49; Polarities 51; Opposites working towards balance 52; Gravity and levity 53. 4. Nature's Patterns and Shapes 55 Sound as resonance 55; Resonance is about qualities 58; Plants have perception and memory 59; Cymatics 60; Patterns and shapes 61; Patterns in motion 62; Rhythms within the solar system 62; The confrontation of two geometric systems 63; Sacred geometry 64; The golden mean 66; The magic of the egg form 67. Part Two: How the World Works 5. Energy Production 73 The inefficiency of modern technology 73; Entropy and ectropy 74; Scientific 'laws' 74; Energy pollution 75; The choice before us 77; Energy defines quality 79; The creative energy vortex 80. 6. Motion — the Key to Balance 85 We use the wrong form of motion 85; The 'original' motion 87; Types of motion 89. 7. The Atmosphere and Electricity 93 Earth's atmosphere 94; Electricity 96; The terrestrial biocondenser 97; Earth as an accumulator of energy 99; Electricism and magnetism 100; Storms, water vapour and climate 101.
    [Show full text]
  • Publications Catalogue 2015–16
    Publications Catalogue 2015 –16 Vogue 100 New titles A Century of Style Robin Muir While principally a fashion magazine, Vogue has never been just that. It has assumed a central and vital role on the cultural stage, with a history that spans the most inventive decades in fashion and taste, and in the arts and society. Published to mark the magazine’s centenary, and accompanying a major exhibition, this book celebrates the twentieth century and beyond with an authoritative and discriminating eye. In more than 2,000 issues, British Vogue has acted as a cultural barometer, putting fashion in the context of the wider world – how we dress, how we entertain, what we eat, listen to, watch, who leads us, excites us and inspires us. The century’s most talented photographers, Lee Miller, Norman Parkinson, Cecil Beaton, Irving Penn, David Bailey, Snowdon and Mario Testino among them, have contributed to it. In 1916, when the First World War made transatlantic shipments of American Vogue impossible, its proprietor, Condé Nast, authorised a British edition. It was an immediate success, and over the following ten decades cover Provisional of uninterrupted publication continued to mirror its times – the austerity and optimism that followed two world wars, the ‘Swinging London’ scene 310 x 254 mm, 304 pages of the sixties, the radical seventies, the image-conscious eighties – and in Over 300 illustrations its second century remains at the cutting edge of photography and design. ISBN 978 1 85514 561 0 Decade by decade, Vogue 100 celebrates the greatest moments in Price £40 TBC (hardback) fashion, beauty and portrait photography.
    [Show full text]
  • Copyrighted Material
    1 Atheism, Agnosticism, and Theism Non - Religious Ethics is at a very early stage. We cannot yet predict whether, as in Mathematics, we will all reach agreement. Since we cannot know how Ethics will develop, it is not irrational to have high hopes. (Derek Parfi t, 1984) 1 He has told you, O man, what is good; and what does the Lord require of you but to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God? (Micah 6:8) Let us start with what people most often associate with “ the secular outlook. ” If with anything at all, they associate it with atheism. But what is atheism? Sometimes atheism is presented as a coherent worldview, encompassing all the other traditions supposedly associated with the secular outlook. On this basis the Christian theologian and physicist Alister McGrath (1953 – ) writes: “ Atheism is the religion of the autonomous and rational human being, who believes that reason is able to uncover and express the deepest truths of the universe, from the mechanics of the rising sun to the nature and fi nal destiny of humanity. ” 2 The fi rst thing that strikes us is that atheism is presented here as a “ religion. ” A second point that is remarkable is that McGrath depicts as “ atheism ” beliefs that most people would associate with “ rationalism. ” In clarifying his defi nition the author even introduces other elements, such as optimism. Atheism, so McGrath writes, “ wasCOPYRIGHTED a powerful, self - confi dent, and aggressiveMATERIAL worldview. Possessed of a boundless confi dence, it proclaimed that the world could be fully 1 Parfi t , Derek , Reasons and Persons , Clarendon Press , Oxford 1984 , p.
    [Show full text]
  • Atheism in the Ancient World
    Also by Tim Whitmarsh Beyond the Second Sophistic: Adventures in Greek Postclassicism Narrative and Identity in the Ancient Greek Novel: Returning Romance The Second Sophistic Ancient Greek Literature Greek Literature and the Roman Empire: The Politics of Imitation THIS IS A BORZOI BOOK PUBLISHED BY ALFRED A. KNOPF Copyright © 2015 by Timothy Whitmarsh All rights reserved. Published in the United States by Alfred A. Knopf, a division of Penguin Random House LLC, New York, and in Canada by Random House of Canada, a division of Penguin Random House Ltd., Toronto. www.aaknopf.com Knopf, Borzoi Books, and the colophon are registered trademarks of Penguin Random House LLC. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Whitmarsh, Tim. Battling the gods : the struggle against religion in ancient Greece / Tim Whitmarsh.—First Edition. pages cm Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-307-95832-7 (hardcover)—ISBN 978-0-307-95833-4 (eBook) 1. Atheism—Greece—History. 2. Greece—Religion. 3. Christianity and atheism. I. Title. BL2747.3.W45 2015 200.938—dc23 2015005799 eBook ISBN 9780307958334 Cover image: Marble bust of Apollo. Regent Antiques, London, UK Cover design by Oliver Munday v4.1 ep Contents Cover Also by Tim Whitmarsh Title Page Copyright Dedication Preface A Dialogue Part One: Archaic Greece Chapter 1: Polytheistic Greece Chapter 2: Good Books Chapter 3: Battling the Gods Chapter 4: The Material Cosmos Part Two: Classical Athens Chapter 5: Cause and Effect Chapter 6: “Concerning the Gods, I Cannot Know” Chapter 7:
    [Show full text]
  • Mark Lynas's Lecture to Oxford Farming Conference, January 3, 2013
    Mark Lynas’s Lecture to Oxford Farming Conference, January 3, 2013 Reprinted from: (with video) http://www.marklynas.org/2013/01/lecture‐to‐oxford‐farming‐conference‐3‐january‐2013/ I want to start with some apologies. For the record, here and upfront, I apologise for having spent several years ripping up GM crops. I am also sorry that I helped to start the anti‐GM movement back in the mid 1990s, and that I thereby assisted in demonising an important technological option which can be used to benefit the environment. As an environmentalist, and someone who believes that everyone in this world has a right to a healthy and nutritious diet of their choosing, I could not have chosen a more counter‐productive path. I now regret it completely. So I guess you’ll be wondering – what happened between 1995 and now that made me not only change my mind but come here and admit it? Well, the answer is fairly simple: I discovered science, and in the process I hope I became a better environmentalist. When I first heard about Monsanto’s GM soya I knew exactly what I thought. Here was a big American corporation with a nasty track record, putting something new and experimental into our food without telling us. Mixing genes between species seemed to be about as unnatural as you can get – here was humankind acquiring too much technological power; something was bound to go horribly wrong. These genes would spread like some kind of living pollution. It was the stuff of nightmares. These fears spread like wildfire, and within a few years GM was essentially banned in Europe, and our worries were exported by NGOs like Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth to Africa, India and the rest of Asia, where GM is still banned today.
    [Show full text]
  • Case 1:17-Cv-00173-CSM Document 1 Filed 08/22/17 Page 1 of 187
    Case 1:17-cv-00173-CSM Document 1 Filed 08/22/17 Page 1 of 187 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NORTH DAKOTA WESTERN DIVISION ENERGY TRANSFER EQUITY, L.P., and Case No.: ___________ ENERGY TRANSFER PARTNERS, L.P., Judge: ___________ Plaintiffs, COMPLAINT vs. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED GREENPEACE INTERNATIONAL (aka “STICHTING GREENPEACE COUNCIL”); GREENPEACE, INC.; GREENPEACE FUND, INC.; BANKTRACK (aka “STICHTING BANKTRACK”); EARTH FIRST!; and JOHN AND JANE DOES 1-20, Defendants. Plaintiffs Energy Transfer Equity, L.P., Energy Transfer Partners, L.P. (collectively “Energy Transfer” or “Plaintiffs”), as and for their complaint against Greenpeace International (aka “Stichting Greenpeace Council”), Greenpeace, Inc. (“GP-Inc.”), Greenpeace Fund, Inc. (“GP-Fund”) (collectively, the “Greenpeace Defendants”), BankTrack (aka “Stichting BankTrack”), Earth First!, and John and Jane Does 1-20, allege as follows: PRELIMINARY STATEMENT 1. This case involves a network of putative not-for-profits and rogue eco-terrorist groups who employ patterns of criminal activity and campaigns of misinformation to target legitimate companies and industries with fabricated environmental claims and other purported misconduct, inflicting billions of dollars in damage. The network’s pattern of criminal and other misconduct includes (i) defrauding charitable donors and cheating federal and state tax authorities with claims that they are legitimate tax-free charitable organizations; (ii) cyber- attacks; (ii) intentional and malicious interference with their targeted victim’s business Case 1:17-cv-00173-CSM Document 1 Filed 08/22/17 Page 2 of 187 relationships; and (iv) physical violence, threats of violence and the purposeful destruction of private and federal property. Energy Transfer is the latest legitimate business targeted by this network.
    [Show full text]
  • Copyrighted Material
    The Secular Outlook: In Defense of Moral and Political Secularism Cliteur, P.B. Citation Cliteur, P. B. (2010). The Secular Outlook: In Defense of Moral and Political Secularism. Boston: Wiley-Blackwell. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/16692 Version: Not Applicable (or Unknown) License: Leiden University Non-exclusive license Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/16692 Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable). 1 Atheism, Agnosticism, and Theism Non - Religious Ethics is at a very early stage. We cannot yet predict whether, as in Mathematics, we will all reach agreement. Since we cannot know how Ethics will develop, it is not irrational to have high hopes. (Derek Parfi t, 1984) 1 He has told you, O man, what is good; and what does the Lord require of you but to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God? (Micah 6:8) Let us start with what people most often associate with “ the secular outlook. ” If with anything at all, they associate it with atheism. But what is atheism? Sometimes atheism is presented as a coherent worldview, encompassing all the other traditions supposedly associated with the secular outlook. On this basis the Christian theologian and physicist Alister McGrath (1953 – ) writes: “ Atheism is the religion of the autonomous and rational human being, who believes that reason is able to uncover and express the deepest truths of the universe, from the mechanics of the rising sun to the nature and fi nal destiny of humanity. ” 2 The fi rst thing that strikes us is that atheism is presented here as a “ religion.
    [Show full text]
  • Viewing the World (Dfid)
    Department for International DFID Development issues Viewing Department for International Development the The Department for International Development (DFID) is the British government department responsible World for promoting development and the reduction of poverty. The government elected in May 1997 increased Viewing the its commitment to development by strengthening the department and increasing its budget. The policy of the government was set out in the White Paper on International Development, published in A studyofBritishtelevisioncoveragedevelopingcountries November 1997. The central focus of the policy is a commitment to the internationally agreed target to halve the proportion of people living in extreme poverty by 2015, together with the associated targets including basic health care provision and universal access to primary education by the same date. DFID seeks to work in partnership with governments which are committed to the international targets, and also seeks to work with business, civil society and the research community to encourage progress which will help reduce poverty. We also work with multilateral institutions including the World Bank, UN agencies and the European Commission. The bulk of our assistance is concentrated on the poorest World countries in Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. We are also contributing to poverty elimination in middle income countries, and helping the transition countries in Central and Eastern Europe to enable the widest number of people to benefit from the process of change. As well as its headquarters in London and East Kilbride, DFID has offices in New Delhi, Bangkok, Nairobi, Harare, Kampala, Dar-Es-Salaam, Pretoria, Dhaka, Suva, Kathmandu and Bridgetown. In other parts of the world, DFID works through staff based in British Embassies and High Commissions.
    [Show full text]
  • Logo Philosophy and Implementation TABLE of CONTENTS
    Logo Philosophy and Implementation TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION What is Logo? Who Needs It? by Seymour Papert ................................................... IV THE COMPUTER IN COSTA RICA: A New Door to Educational and Social Opportunities Photographs accompanying each chapter are used by Clotilde Fonseca ........................................................... 2 with permission of the authors. THE SAINT PAUL LOGO PROJECT: The samba school photograph in the Brazil chapter is used with permission An American Experience of the photographer John Maier Jr. by Geraldine Kozberg and Michael Tempel ............................ 22 THE RUSSIAN SCHOOL SYSTEM AND THE LOGO APPROACH: Two Methods Worlds Apart Graphic design by Le groupe Flexidée by Sergei Soprunov and Elena Yakovleva ............................... 48 © Logo Computer Systems Inc. 1999 A LOGO POSTCARD FROM ARGENTINA All rights reserved. by Horacio C. Reggini .................................................................... 78 No part of the document contained herein may be reproduced, stored LOGO IN AUSTRALIA: in retrieval systems or transmitted, in any form or by any means, A Vision of Their Own photocopying, electronic, mechanical, recording or otherwise, without by Jeff Richardson ............................................................ 96 the prior approval from Logo Computer Systems Inc. THE CONSTRUCTIONIST APPROACH: Legal deposit, 1st semester 1999 The Integration of Computers ISBN 2-89371-494-3 in Brazilian Public Schools Printed 2-99 by Maria Elizabeth B. Almeida
    [Show full text]
  • Diverse on Screen Talent Directory
    BBC Diverse Presenters The BBC is committed to finding and growing diverse onscreen talent across all channels and platforms. We realise that in order to continue making the BBC feel truly diverse, and improve on where we are at the moment, we need to let you know who’s out there. In this document you will find biographies for just some of the hugely talented people the BBC has already been working with and others who have made their mark elsewhere. It’s the responsibility of every person involved in BBC programme making to ask themselves whether what, and who, they are putting on screen reflects the world around them or just one section of society. If you are in production or development and would like other ideas for diverse presenters across all genres please feel free to get in touch with Mary Fitzpatrick Editorial Executive, Diversity via email: [email protected] Diverse On Screen Talent Directory Presenter Biographies Biographies Ace and Invisible Presenters, 1Xtra Category: 1Xtra Agent: Insanity Artists Agency Limited T: 020 7927 6222 W: www.insanityartists.co.uk 1Xtra's lunchtime DJs Ace and Invisible are on a high - the two 22-year-olds scooped the gold award for Daily Music Show of the Year at the 2004 Sony Radio Academy Awards. It's a just reward for Ace and Invisible, two young south Londoners with high hopes who met whilst studying media at the Brits Performing Arts School in 1996. The 'Lunchtime Trouble Makers' is what they are commonly known as, but for Ace and Invisible it's a story of friendship and determination.
    [Show full text]
  • NAFSO News Wildlife in the City Page 11
    ISSN 0 309 8451 Volume 101 Autumn 2012 Preparing the ground Sowing seeds for NAFSO news Wildlife in the City page 11 Pages 16—17 Woodlands Clearing the air working Pressing flowers Pages 25 Page 14 Page 30 The Journal of the National Association for Environmental Education (UK) National Association for Environmental Education (UK) The key network for all concerned about our relation with the natural and built environments; promoting sustainable education NAEE UK has, for over fifty years, provided support for educators and education professionals to supply and deliver all aspects of environmental education across all levels of the curriculum. Membership Freshly re-launched NAEE online at Membership is open to those directly involved www.naee.org.uk in environmental education or those with a + new home of Environmental related interest. Education; + Events, resources, factsheets; There are different categories of membership. + members’ area being developed; + links to excellent websites and all Student: Free our partners! Individual: £20 FREE membership to students! School or other organisation: £30 (Requires proof of student status.) + Environmental Education termly University: £40 journal; + advice and information from Overseas membership is available and payment experienced teachers and should be made in GBP only. advisors; + excellent for your research Europe: £40 Elsewhere: £50 needs! APPLICATION FOR MEMBERSHIP I wish to join NAEE (UK) Name: ................................................................... Institution (if applicable):
    [Show full text]