DOCSLIB.ORG

Penland Courtmartial

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Penland Courtmartial VERBATIM RECORD OF TRIAL OF PENLAND SYNEEDA L. LCDR / O-4 (LAST NAME) (FIRST) (MIDDLE) (SSN) (RANK/RATE) UNITED STATES NAVY NAVAL COASTAL WARFARE GROUP ONE (ARMED FORCE) (UNIT or ORGANIZATION) BY GENERAL COURT-MARTIAL CONVENED BY COMMANDER NAVY REGION SOUTHWEST SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92132-0058 TRIED AT WESTERN JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURTHOUSE NAVAL BASE, SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92136-5025 ON 22 JANUARY 2008 22 FEBRUARY 2008 10, 23 APRIL 2008 14, 19, 21, 22, 23, 24 MAY 2008 ENCL (2) INDEX Introduction of counsel . 3, 25, 266 Challenges . 594 Arraignment . 34 Motions . 35, 43, 50, 52, 150, 155, 165, 168, 185 219, 226, 585, 594, 608, 660, 663, 664, 952 Pleas . 213 Findings . 946 Sentence . 1007 T E S T I M O N Y Direct Cross Name of Witness Redirect Recross Court Motions: LCDR Syneeda L. Penland 44, 102 74 98 CAPT John Sturges, III (RET) 104, 119 115, 120 -- LCDR Mei Ling A. Marshall 122 142 -- LCDR Syneeda L. Penland 186 -- 189 Prosecution case-in-chief: PS1 Jeffrey Crawford 376 -- 378 SKC Stacy L. Zogaib 379, 385 384, 386 -- Brian Duffy 387 396 -- CDR Brendon X. Doud 399 -- -- PS1 Cheston A. Lee 418, 427 424 426 CDR Matthew J. Masi 428, 433 432, 434 -- LCDR Kristen McCarthy 438, 444 442 -- CAPT John Sturges, III (RET) 453, 461 457, 463 462 LCDR Thomas P. Moninger 464 476 -- NCC Kimberly Lewis-Wiggan 478, 581 576, 582 -- Brian Duffy 632, 649 646 -- NCC Kimberly Lewis-Wiggan 650 656 -- Defense case-in-chief: LTJG Mark Wiggan 673,731,737,741 681,735,739,742 738, 741 CDR Larry D. Milner 744, 756 747 -- CAPT Michael H. Johnson 757 761 -- CAPT Jack S. Noel, II 765, 774 770 -- Steven H. Arnold 776, 785 781, 787 786 PS1 Cheston A. Lee 788, 790 789 -- T E S T I M O N Y [CONTINUED] Direct Cross Name of Witness Redirect Recross Court Prosecution case-in-rebuttal: SKC Stacy L. Zogaib 797, 802 801 -- CDR Matthew J. Masi 803, 808 806, 810 809 LCDR Thomas P. Moninger 811, 820 818, 820 -- Defense case-in-surrebuttal: [None] Prosecution case-in-sentencing: NCC Kimberly Lewis-Wiggan 964 -- -- Defense case-in-sentencing: CDR Larry D. Milner 974 979 -- E X H I B I T S Number/ Letter Description Offered Received PE 1 Printout (2 pages) of thumbnail images (52) recovered from LTJG Wiggan's computer 542 558 PE 2 52 8" x 11" color printouts of above thumbnail images 542 558 PE 3 Gov't cell phone records for LCDR Penland, (619) 921-5073, SEP 23 '06 to FEB 23 '07 382 383 PE 4 PE 3 sorted by phone number -- -- PE 5 Home phone records for LCDR Penland, (619) 271-7954, DEC '06 to MAR '07 390 391 PE 6 E-mail from "the other woman," 26 SEP '06, Subject: MAKING CONTACT 491 492 PE 7 E-mail from "the other woman," 28 SEP '06, Subject: Pics 496 496 PE 8 8" x 11" printouts of 2 attached PowerPoint files to the 28 SEP E-mail 498 498 PE 9 Screen shot printout of properties field for 2 photos referenced in PE 6, showing the author as "Syneeda Penland" 502 503 PE 10 E-mail from LCDR Penland to ENS Wiggan, 29 SEP '06, Subject: RE: LET'S SAY 510 511 PE 11 Word document attached to E-mail referenced in PE 10 512 512 E X H I B I T S [CONTINUED] Number/ Letter Description Offered Received PE 12 Screen shot printout of properties field for Word document referenced in PE 11, showing the author as "Syneeda Penland" 645 646 PE 13 E-mail from "the other woman," 23 DEC '06, Subject: TRUTH 524 524 PE 14 E-mail from "the other woman," 24 DEC '06, Subject: RE: TRUTH 527 527 PE 15 E-mail from "the other woman," 1 JAN '07, Subject: RE: TRUTH 531 531 PE 16 E-mail from Syneeda Penland, 5 JAN '07, Subject: Hang in there 533 534 PE 17 E-mail from LCDR Syneeda Penland, 23 FEB '07, Subject: PERSONAL BELONGINGS 474 475 PE 18 Sprint phone records for Syneeda Penland from 1 to 28 FEB '07 for (619) 862-1559 394 394 PE 19 E-mail from Dread to Syneeda Penland, 3 JAN '07, Subject: Re: 536 536 PE 20 Military protective order dated 9 JAN '07 440 440 PE 21 E-mail from [email protected], 16 DEC '06, Subject: FW: Hey 651 651 PE 22 Word document attached to E-mail in PE 21, "I wanted to send you a few words" 653 653 PE 23 Certification of marriage, dated 16 MAR '01 481 481 PE 24 Continued Sprint cell phone records for (757) 822-3579 634 635 PE 25 Continued Sprint cell phone records for (619) 862-1134 634 635 PE 26 Personal Data Sheet 982 982 DE A FITREPs, evaluations, LOR and diploma 982 983 AE I Motion for docketing -- AE II Grant of immunity and order to testify to LTJG Wiggan, USN, dated 1-14-08 24 AE III Deposition order to LTJG Wiggan, USN, 1-14-08 24 AE IV Letter 5813 Ser No. OJA/028, 17 JAN '08, Subject: Appt. as Deposition Officer ICO U.S. v. Penland, SC, USN 25 AE V Letter, 14 FEB '08, Excusal of detailed counsel, LT Head 32 AE VI Defense motion to dismiss, 4 APR '08, w/attachments, unlawful command influence and Article 32 improperly convened 42 AE VII Defense motion to suppress statements made by LCDR Penland to CAPT Sturges, with attachment PIO, 7 MAR '06 41 AE VIII Defense motion for appropriate relief, compel production of verbatim Article 32 transcript 42 E X H I B I T S [CONTINUED] Number/ Letter Description Received AE IX Defense motion to dismiss per R.C.M. 707, speedy trial requirements 42 AE X Defense motion to dismiss pursuant to R.C.M. 907 and 707, docketing invalid and speedy trial requirements, with E-mail attachments 42 AE XI Gov't response to AE VI, motion to dismiss based on unlawful command influence 42 AE XII Gov't response to AE VII, Defense motion to suppress 41 AE XIII Gov't response to AE VIII, Defense motion to compel production of Article 32 transcript 42 AE XIV Gov't response to AE IX, Defense motion to dismiss based on failure to comply with R.C.M. 707 42 AE XV Gov't response to AE X, Defense motion to dismiss based on invalid motion for docketing 42 AE XVI Notes from Military Judge's file IRG to 802 conference held on 7 NOV '07 177 AE XVII E-mail dated 4/18/08, MJ's ruling on motions to suppress; motion to dismiss pursuant to R.C.M. 707 speedy trial; unlawful command influence; and compel production of Article 32 transcript 178 AE XVIII E-mail dated 4/23/08, MJ's ruling on motion re Article 32 improperly convened 178 AE XIX Defense motion for continuance, 12 MAY '08 184 AE XX Gov't response to AE XIX, motion for continuance, with attachment, 13 MAY '08 184 AE XXI Grant of immunity and order to testify, U.S. v. Penland, 6 MAY '08 206 AE XXII Members' questionnaires (10) 242 AE XXIII Gov't response to Defense request for continuance from 5/18/08 215 AE XXIV Gov't response to MJ's questions about charges 227 AE XXV Defense response to motion to amend charges 216 AE XXVI Gov't supplemental response regarding changes to charge sheet 215 AE XXVII Gov't motion to amend charges 215 AE XXVIII Gov't request for judicial notice 216 AE XXIX Defense witness list 216 AE XXX Defense proposed voir dire 216 AE XXXI Government witness list 216 AE XXXII Government proposed voir dire 216 AE XXXIII Defense motion for continuance, 5/16/08 E-mail 215 AE XXXIV MJ's response to Gov't motion to amend charge sheet 255 AE XXXV Time line, opening statement Gov't demonstrative aid 257 AE XXXVI Cleansed charge sheet 256 AE XXXVII Gov't request for judicial notice 259 AE XXXVIII PSD document on LCDR Penland 377 AE XXXIX Question by member, CDR Kelsch 425 AE XL Question by member, CDR Tucker 425 E X H I B I T S [CONTINUED] Number/ Letter Description Received AE XLI Question by member, CDR Good 462 AE XLII Medical document on LCDR Penland 589 AE XLIII Mr. Duffy's notes 641 AE XLIV Question by member, CDR Galvez 737 AE XLV Question by member, CDR Good 737 AE XLVI Question by member, CDR Good 737 AE XLVII Question by member, CAPT Booker 740 AE XLVIII Question by member, CDR Grundy 786 AE XLIX Question by member, CDR Kelsch 786 AE L Instructions on proposed findings 825 AE LI Question by member, CAPT Booker 809 AE LII Findings worksheet 847 AE LIII Instructions on findings, first revision 833 AE LIV Instructions on findings, second revision 848 AE LV Instructions on findings, final draft 852 AE LVI Question by senior member, CAPT Gentile 906 AE LVII Question by member, CDR Grundy 932 AE LVIII Question from members (findings deliberations) 936 AE LIX Question from members (post-findings) 948 AE LX Question from members (post-findings) 948 AE LXI Sentencing worksheet 951 AE LXII First draft Sentencing Instructions 951 AE LXIII Second draft Sentencing Instructions 983 AE LXIV Final draft Sentencing Instructions 993 AE LXV Appellate and post-trial rights statement 1010 COPIES OF RECORD One copy of the record of trial furnished to the accused as per the attached certificate of receipt.
Load more

  1021
Copy Link
Recommended publications
  • Proquest Dissertations
    MAKING WAR: EMBODIED INTERACTIONS, MEANING-MAKING AND THE WAR IN IRAQ By Jesse Paul Crane-Seeber Submitted to the Faculty of the School of International Service of American University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in International Relations Chair: tU iJUM- LL Patrick Thaddeus Jackson llllv-y/ 1 \ srf <eline-A/Iarie Pascale / - ^ f* Raymond Duvall kJUM) C9^ruA^ Dean of the School of International Service if 3 Qo Date (J 2009 America University Washington, D.C. 20016 -AMERICAN UNIVERSITY LIBRARY UMI Number: 3410326 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. UNIT Dissertation Publishing UMI 3410326 Copyright 2010 by ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This edition of the work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. uestA ® ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 © COPYRIGHT by Jesse Paul Crane-Seeber 2009 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED For the better world we all long for and those who need it most MAKING WAR: EMBODIED INTERACTIONS, MEANING-MAKING, AND THE WAR IN IRAQ BY Jesse Paul Crane-Seeber ABSTRACT The invasion and occupation of Iraq has been the center of numerous political and theoretical disputes, and as the war heads into its seventh year, U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • A Comparative Analysis of the 1991 Gulf War and the 'War on Terror'
    Durham E-Theses Virtual wars : a comparative analysis of the 1991 Gulf War and the 'War on Terror' Mendel, Jonathan Michael How to cite: Mendel, Jonathan Michael (2007) Virtual wars : a comparative analysis of the 1991 Gulf War and the 'War on Terror', Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/1319/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk 2 Virtual Wars: A ComparativeAnalysis of the 1991 Gulf War and the `War on Terror' JonathanMichael Mendel PhD 2007 The copyright of this thesis rests with the author or the university to which it was submitted. No quotation from it, or information derived from it may be published without the prior written consent of the author or university, and any information derived from it should be acknowledged. r ý17 APR2008 260 Bibliography Note re.
    [Show full text]
  • Greek Chapters Select Council Leaders Missile Defense Accord Unlikely
    f\ TCU Daily Neighborly concerns Muggles & magic Despite the protest of some neighbors, Fort Worth The Harry Potter craze that has swept through City Council unanimously passed a zoning America remains strong and has even found a change for a new baseball stadium. place in the hearts of college students. See Sports, page 10. NowSKIFF in its 100th year of service to TCU See Trends, page 6. Thursday, November 15, 2001 Fort Worth, Texas Greek chapters select council leaders Election Results By Sam Eaton named the new treasurer. For the first time, Sigma Phi Ep- of Fraternity and Sorority Affairs Tom 2002 IFC Officers STAFF REPORTER All officers elected Wednesday to silon voted as a full member of IFC, Sullivan said. Bailey, a junior Pi Beta 2002 Panhellenic Officers Although the fraternities of Interfra- the Panhellenic Council will be new current IFC President Kyle Gore said. Phi, ran unopposed for the presidency. President Bryan Perkins President Krista Bailey temity Council elected two experi- to their leadership roles. Sig Eps were given first awarded Sean Cleland, a Phi Kappa Sigma Vice President Mike Cothran VP of Recruitment Lisa Andersen enced officers for 2002, both the IFC Krista Bailey was elected 2002 full membership with IFC last Feb- member, was elected director of VP of Rush: Austin Dickson VP of Management Rebecca Hensley and the sororities of Panhellenic Coun- Panhellenic president during elec- ruary after being granted their full service. He said it was important for Treasurer. Travis Adams Director of Finance: Emily Marriott cil will have plenty of fresh faces. tions Monday and Wednesday.
    [Show full text]
  • SENATE—Tuesday, September 16, 2008
    19098 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD—SENATE, Vol. 154, Pt. 14 September 16, 2008 SENATE—Tuesday, September 16, 2008 The Senate met at 10 a.m. and was THE ECONOMY a gallon of gasoline. It is not strong for called to order by the Honorable JON Mr. REID. Mr. President, on the the cities and towns that have been TESTER, a Senator from the State of morning of October 30, 1929, President forced to cut back on police, schools, Montana. Herbert Hoover awoke the day after and firefighters because their tax base the biggest one-day stock market crash is shrinking. Certainly it is not strong PRAYER in American history, surveyed the for the millions of families who have or The Chaplain, Dr. Barry C. Black, of- state of the U.S. economy and declared: may soon lose their homes, or the tens fered the following prayer: The fundamental business of the country, of millions who are seeing their home Let us pray. that is production and distribution of com- equity plummet. Almighty God, who inhabits eternity, modities, is on a sound and prosperous basis. No matter what George Bush, JOHN whose throne is in Heaven, whose foot- In the coming weeks and months MCCAIN, or the ghost of Herbert Hoover stool is Earth, You are worthy to re- after that, President Hoover remained may think, this economy is not strong, ceive our gratitude, worship, and in an economic bubble, unaware of the and the American people deserve bet- praise. We thank You for Your gracious extreme suffering of ordinary Ameri- ter. mercy and forgiveness when we fail and cans—even declaring that anyone who This is not a time for panic, but it is sin.
    [Show full text]