Evaluation of Rapid Diagnostic Tests: Syphilis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EVALUATING DIAGNOSTICS Evaluation of rapid diagnostic tests: syphilis WHO/TDR Sexually Transmitted Diseases Diagnostics Initiative Syphilis is a curable sexually transmit- countries2,3. Approximately 30% of preg- I. DIAGNOSTIC TESTS FOR SYPHILIS ted infection caused by the bacterium nant women with syphilis will give birth to T. pallidum cannot be cultured in the labora- Treponema pallidum. The infection can a stillborn baby, and another 30% to a live tory, but can be identified in lesions using also be passed from a mother to her fetus baby with congenital syphilis, a condition dark-field or fluorescent microscopy or by during pregnancy. As a cause of genital ulcer which has a range of severe effects, includ- molecular techniques. As most infected indi- disease, syphilis has been associated with ing growth retardation, and which can have viduals are asymptomatic or have transient an increased risk of HIV transmission and a mortality rate of up to 50%. These condi- lesions, serological tests are the diagnostic acquisition. tions are preventable if infected mothers test of choice for detection of syphilis9. The Most infected individuals have no are identified before the third trimester of characteristics of the commonly used sero- symptoms and therefore a serological test pregnancy, and treated appropriately. logical tests for syphilis are shown in TABLE 1. must be used to screen for infection. The Early detection and treatment is crucial Simple flocculation assays, such as the WHO estimates that 12 million new cases for preventing severe long-term complica- rapid plasma reagin (RPR) test, are widely of syphilis occur every year, most of which tions in the patient and the adverse preg- used for serodiagnosis of, or screening for, are in settings where there is limited or no nancy outcomes detailed above. syphilis. These tests detect antibodies to access to laboratory screening services1. Treatment also prevents further trans- phospholipid antigens such as cardiolipin. Left untreated, syphilis can eventually mission of the infection. The World Anti-cardiolipin antibodies can occur in a cause severe granulomatous lesions and Development Report cites antenatal screen- range of tissue-damaging diseases in mam- cardiovascular or neurological damage. ing and treatment for syphilis as one of the mals; these tests are therefore not specific Syphilis in pregnancy is a major cause of most cost-effective health interventions for T. pallidum infection and are commonly adverse pregnancy outcome in developing available4–8. referred to as ‘non-treponemal’ tests. Table 1 | Characteristics of serological tests for syphilis Non-treponemal tests Treponemal tests Test characteristic RPR VDRL Rapid test EIA TPPA/TPHA FTA-ABS Specimen Serum or plasma Serum or plasma Serum or whole Serum or plasma Serum or plasma Serum or plasma blood Sensitivity 86–100% 78–100% 84–98% 82–100% 85–100% 70–100% Specificity 93–98% 98–100% 94–98% 97–100% 98–100% 94–100% Ease of use Easy Easy Easy Moderate Complex Complex Level of use Exam room, Exam room, Exam room, Intermediate lab, Reference lab Reference lab on-site lab on-site lab on-site lab reference lab Equipment required Rotator, Light microscope, None Incubator, microwell Incubator Fluorescence refrigerator refrigerator plate washer and microscope reader Training Minimal Minimal Minimal Moderate Extensive Extensive Average cost US$ 0.5 US$ 0.5 US$ 0.19–3 US$ 3 US$ 3 US$ 3 Comments Reagents require Reagents require Most tests can be Allows high- Used as Used as refrigeration refrigeration stored at room throughput confirmatory confirmatory test; temperature for screening; test; does not does not distinguish 9–18 months does not distinguish distinguish between prior between prior between prior treated and active treated and active treated and active infection infection infection EIA, enzyme immunoassay; FTA-ABS, fluorescent treponemal antibody-absorption test; RPR, rapid plasma reagin test; TPHA/TPPA, Treponema pallidum haemagglutination assay/ Treponema pallidum particle agglutination assay; VDRL, venereal diseases research laboratory test. NATURE REVIEWS | MICROBIOLOGY DECEMBER 2006 | S33 © 2006 Nature Publishing Group EVALUATING DIAGNOSTICS | SYPHILIS (TPHA) or the closely related T. pallidum high prevalence settings where large num- particle-agglutination assay (TPPA). These bers of the target population have already confirmatory tests are more technically been screened and treated. Some suggested demanding and are not widely available in algorithms for use of rapid tests are shown in most developing countries outside reference FIGURE 120,21 and are discussed below. laboratories. In settings where RPR is not available, an RDT can be used to increase access to II. THE NEED FOR EVALUATION OF testing or for prenatal screening to prevent SYPHILIS RDTs congenital syphilis. Until recently, serological testing for syphilis In settings where non-treponemal tests, required a laboratory with trained person- such as the RPR test, are available, it might nel, refrigeration for the storage of reagents be possible to use RDTs as a screening test, and electricity to run equipment such as a and then perform quantitative non-trepone- refrigerator, centrifuge and shaker. As such mal tests to determine whether the patient facilities are generally not available in remote has an active infection. This approach is areas, blood or serum samples must be trans- useful in areas of low disease prevalence. By ported to regional or central facilities for test- selecting combinations of RDTs, it might ing. The results are therefore only available also be possible to use a sensitive RDT as a days or weeks after testing10 and specimens screening test and a more specific RDT as a or results can sometimes be lost in transit. It confirmatory test. is common for individuals who are tested not Targeting syphilis screening to at-risk to return for their test results or treatment, individuals is cost-effective. Given the resulting in adverse clinical outcomes, con- potentially serious sequelae of syphilis and tinued transmission of infection and wasted the increased risk of HIV transmission, the resources. following groups should be targeted for Simple, point-of-care Treponema-specific screening: rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) are now com- • Pregnant women (to prevent congenital mercially available11–20. These tests can use syphilis) whole blood from a finger prick as well as • Individuals with, or at risk of, contracting, serum or plasma. They might be suitable for sexually transmitted infections (STIs) use in primary healthcare settings for the • Sex workers diagnosis of syphilis but until recently, there • Clients of sex workers were only limited data on their performance • Men who have sex with men characteristics. Evaluating the performance • Intravenous drug users of both current and future tests, their utility Consecutive patients of the desired in a disease control programme and their target population presenting to clinics at acceptability to patients and healthcare pro- the evaluation sites should be informed viders will improve the diagnosis of syphilis about the study and asked to participate. in primary healthcare settings in developing Patients who give consent should undergo countries and reduce unnecessary treatment. an interview and a physical examination Figure 1 | Suggested rapid diagnostic test according to the routine clinic protocol at algorithms and treatment decision points for III. GENERAL ISSUES IN STUDY DESIGN the site. Participants can be asked ques- syphilis. Treatment includes treating patients 1. Reference standards tions concerning their age, gender, history and contacts, counselling, recommending con- dom use and offering HIV testing. RPR, rapid The reference standard test for Treponema- of STIs, recent STI treatment history and plasma reagin test. specific tests should be TPHA, TPPA, pregnancy status, as suggested in the sample enzyme immunoassay (EIA) or the fluores- data-collection form shown in APPENDIX 1. cent treponemal antibody absorption test A sample informed consent form is shown False-positive results are often encountered, (FTA-ABS). Each test should be performed in APPENDIX 2. especially in pregnant women, leading to on sera by laboratory staff, according to the unnecessary treatment. Some common manufacturer’s directions. IV. FACTORS AFFECTING TEST conditions associated with false-positive PERFORMANCE test results are malaria, tuberculosis, viral 2. Local epidemiology, choice of study 1. Specimen sampling and preparation fevers, trypanosomiasis, leprosy and other population and sampling RDTs can be used with whole blood, serum treponemal infections in addition to syphilis. The local epidemiology of syphilis is impor- or plasma. However, TPHA, TPPA and other Non-infectious causes of cross-reactivity tant in selecting the appropriate test. Once reference tests must be performed on serum include drug addiction, connective tissue positive, Treponema-specific tests, including and will require specimen transport to a disease, pregnancy and advanced age. the new point-of-care RDTs, usually remain laboratory. The stage at which the serum is Positive RPR results therefore need to positive throughout the patient’s life and so removed from the clotted blood will depend be confirmed with treponemal tests that cannot distinguish between past syphilis, on the circumstances. If the reference labo- use Treponema-specific antigens such as treated syphilis and syphilis that requires ratory is distant, it might