The St Clair Land Swap Because They Worked As Members of Staff for ALP Ministers And/Or ‘Have Appeared on Labour [Sic] Party Promotional Material’

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The St Clair Land Swap Because They Worked As Members of Staff for ALP Ministers And/Or ‘Have Appeared on Labour [Sic] Party Promotional Material’ Ombudsman SA Investigation into the City of Charles Sturt Final Report November 2011 Ombudsman SA PO Box 3651 Rundle Mall SA 5000 Telephone 08 8226 8699 Toll Free 1800 182 150 (outside metro SA only) Facsimile 08 8226 8602 Email [email protected] CONTENTS SUMMARY 1 OPINIONS 2 Conflict of interest 2 Bias and open mind 2 Code of conduct 3 The consultation process 4 Confidentiality of meetings and documents 5 Prudential requirements 6 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AMENDMENT OF THE LAW 8 Register of interests 8 Conflict of interest 8 Code of conduct 9 Valuation of community land 10 1. INTRODUCTION 11 1.1 NAMING OF WITNESSES 12 1.2 JURISDICTION 13 Ombudsman Act 1972 (SA) 13 Meaning of ‘agency’ 13 Meaning of ‘administrative act’ 13 Power to investigate 14 Referral for investigation from a House of the Parliament — section 14 14 Own initiative investigation — section 13(2) 14 My investigation 15 Whistleblowers Protection Act 1993 (SA) 17 1.3 MY INVESTIGATION 18 Commencement of my investigation 18 Scoping my investigation 18 Conclusion of scoping the investigation and notifying council members 19 Defining the administrative act and the issue of legal representation 20 Legal proceedings initiated by the council 21 Mediated settlement of the legal proceedings 22 Resumption of my investigation 23 Further challenges to my jurisdiction 23 Release of my provisional report 23 i Responses to my provisional report 24 Conduct of elected members of the 2006-2010 council 26 Standard of proof 28 Total evidence taken 28 Consultation 28 Acknowledgement of the CEO and staff of the council 29 Observations of the evidence of some council members 29 2. CONTEXT OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE ACT 30 2.1 ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES — COUNCILS AND ELECTED MEMBERS 31 Principal role of a council 31 Functions of a council 31 Objectives of a council 31 Role of council members 32 Declaration on taking office 33 General duties of elected members 33 Council members are fiduciaries 34 Abuse of public office 34 Register of interests 34 Remuneration 35 Conflict of interest 35 Bias 36 Code of conduct 36 Other relevant statutory provisions 37 2.2 OVERVIEW OF THE REVOCATION AND LAND SWAP 38 Introduction 38 Background to the revocation and land swap 39 Revocation of the community land classification of the St Clair land 41 TODs 42 SA government policy objectives and the 30 year plan 44 2.3 PREVIOUS INVESTIGATIONS ABOUT THE REVOCATION AND LANDSWAP 48 2.4 COUNCILLORS’ MEMBERSHIP OF THE ALP 52 Background 52 Councillors’ membership of the ALP 52 Assistance given by ALP councillors to state and federal ALP candidates and MPs 53 Assistance provided to ALP councillors by MPs and their electorate offices 53 Being a councillor and a member of the ALP 54 ii The Member for Croydon 55 Meeting at Parliament House for ALP councillors after the 2006 elections 58 Croydon electorate office assistance — councillors’ street corner meetings 62 Croydon electorate office assistance — councillors’ land swap letters 65 Comment 66 3. DECISION-MAKING IN RELATION TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE ACT 67 3.1 CONFLICT OF INTEREST, BIAS AND THE ADMINISTRATIVE ACT 68 3.2 CONFLICT OF INTEREST 69 Background 69 What is a conflict of interest? 69 Conflict of interest under the Local Government Act 70 Conflict of interest and the code of conduct 74 Whether council members had conflicts of interest 74 Whether Councillor K had an interest — employment in the DPLG 74 Whether 12 councillors had an interest — membership of the ALP 79 Whether Councillors J and P had an interest — engagement in the Enfield electorate office 84 3.3 BIAS AND OPEN MIND 86 Background 86 Whether the ALP councillors brought an open mind to their decision-making 88 ALP councillor discussions outside the council 89 Member for Croydon 90 Voting pattern of the ALP councillors 92 ALP membership 93 ALP councillors’ motivations in voting on the revocation 93 4. CODE OF CONDUCT 98 What is the code of conduct? 99 City of Charles Sturt’s code of conduct 100 The principles in the code of conduct 100 Behaviour contrary to the code of conduct 101 Recording of complaints 103 Whether councillors may have breached the code of conduct during the revocation process 103 1. Whether Councillors K, P, A and G may have breached the code of conduct — the Member for Croydon and the councillors’ letters supporting the land swap 103 2. Whether Councillor M may have breached the code of conduct — writing a letter to the press 109 iii 3. Whether Councillor M may have breached the code of conduct — writing to a St Clair protestor’s employer alerting the employer to the fact that his employee was using her work email address for communications unrelated to her work 111 4. Whether Councillor M may have breached the code of conduct — asking another to obtain information about the employee 114 5. Whether Councillor B may have breached the code of conduct — providing a community member’s email to the Member for Croydon 117 6. Whether Councillor G may have breached the code of conduct — forwarding a community member’s email to the Member for Croydon 125 5. THE CONSULTATION PROCESS 127 The council’s consultation obligations in the revocation process 128 Background 128 Whether the council complied with the requirement in section 194(2)(a) to prepare a report 131 Whether the council complied with the requirement in section 194(2)(b) to follow the steps in its public consultation policy 133 Whether the council adopted good administrative practice in carrying out its public consultation 138 1. Whether the timing of the consultation process was appropriate 138 2. Whether the council took sufficient action to publicise the consultation process 143 3. Whether the council made enough information available to the public 145 4. Whether the council misleadingly described the land area as ‘same for same’ 146 5. Whether the council should have accepted submissions after the deadline 150 6. Whether the council properly considered the results of the consultation when making the revocation decision 152 6. CONFIDENTIALITY OF COUNCIL MEETINGS AND DOCUMENTS 161 Council meetings of 28 April 2008, 11 August 2008 and 9 June 2009 162 Whether the council acted in accordance with section 90(2) and (3) 164 Meeting of 28 April 2008 — whether the council acted in accordance with section 91 166 Meeting of 9 June 2009 — the council’s report and resolutions 168 Whether the council acted in accordance with section 90 — 9 June 2009 170 Whether the council acted in accordance with section 91 — 9 June 2009 170 Whether the council should have alerted the public to the release of the 9 June 2009 report and minutes 172 7. PRUDENTIAL REQUIREMENTS 174 Section 48 Local Government Act 175 Meeting of 9 June 2009 — the prudential report and the Deloitte review 176 iv Whether a report was required to be prepared by the council under section 48(1) 177 Whether the council adequately addressed the risk of ‘conflict of interest’ 179 Whether the council complied with section 48(4) in preparing the prudential report 182 Whether the council should have sought valuations of the St Clair and the Sheridan land 184 8. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR AMENDMENT OF THE LAW 189 8.1 REGISTER OF INTERESTS 190 Changes to information on the Register of Interests 190 Ready public access to the Register of Interests 191 8.2 CONFLICT OF INTEREST 192 Addressing perceived conflict of interest 192 Conflict of duty — extending section 73(3) 193 Conflict of duty — being a council member and an electorate officer 195 The interests of the council and interests of the state government 196 Conflict of duty - Local Government Act 1989 (Vic) 197 LGASA response 198 Prohibition in the code of ethics 198 Disclosure of political affiliation 200 Remove the requirement to abstain from voting in some circumstances 201 Councillors’ lack of understanding of conflict of interest 202 Past benefits / inducements 202 8.3 CODE OF CONDUCT 203 Lack of enforceability of the code of conduct 203 Elected members’ perceptions of their role — training and the oath of office 203 8.4 VALUATION OF COMMUNITY LAND 206 9. CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS 207 10. MAP 217 11. APPENDIX A — Mediation Heads of Agreement 218 12. APPENDIX B — Further description of the administrative act 220 13. ABBREVIATIONS 222 v Summary SUMMARY In December 2009, the City of Charles Sturt revoked the community status of land in St Clair Reserve under the Local Government Act 1999, in order to swap this land with land from the former Sheridan industrial site owned by the state government’s property arm, the Land Management Corporation. This swap enabled the council and the state government to deliver on a significant target in the new planning strategy set out in the 30 year Plan for Greater Adelaide, through the establishment of one of the first of fourteen proposed transit oriented developments (TOD) near the Woodville Railway Station adjacent to the St Clair Reserve. The Land Management Corporation had earlier purchased the Sheridan land from developers for $15.8m (exclusive of GST) with the intention of achieving the land swap and establishing the TOD. Some sectors of the council’s community expressed concern about the influence of the ALP (in particular the Member for Croydon) in the council’s revocation decision, as 12 out of 17 of its councillors were members of the ALP and six were employed within state government. Concerns were also raised about the council’s lack of genuine community consultation about the revocation and its inattentiveness to prudential risks about conflict of interest. The matter was referred to me for investigation by the Legislative Council; and I resolved to use my own initiative investigation powers under the Ombudsman Act 1972.
Recommended publications
  • Whose Place Is It? Examining the Socio-Spatial Geography of Obesity in Young Adults for an Australian Context
    Whose place is it? Examining the socio-spatial geography of obesity in young adults for an Australian context Natasha J. Howard Bachelor of Health Sciences (Honours Public Health) Discipline of Geographical and Environmental Studies Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences The University of Adelaide Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy February 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS................................................................................................................ ii LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................................ vi LIST OF FIGURES ....................................................................................................................... ix ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................. xi DECLARATION .......................................................................................................................... xii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .......................................................................................................... xiii THE NOBLE STUDY ................................................................................................................. xiv ABBREVIATIONS ....................................................................................................................... xv PUBLICATIONS AND PRESENTATIONS ..............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Department of the Premier and Cabinet Annual Report Chief
    ANNUAL REPORT 2012-2013 Department of the Premier and Cabinet State Administration Centre 200 Victoria Square Adelaide SA 5000 GPO Box 2343 Adelaide SA 5001 ISSN 0816-0813 For copies of this report please contact Finance and Business Performance Corporate Operations and Governance Division Telephone: 61 8 8226 5944 Department of the Premier and Cabinet Annual Report 2012-13 Contents Contents ................................................................................................................................ 1 Chief Executive’s Review ........................................................................................................ 3 Our Organisation .............................................................................................................. 6 Achievements in 2012-13 ........................................................................................................ 9 State Government’s Seven Strategic Priorities ................................................................ 9 Three approaches to how government does business .................................................. 12 Program 1. Cabinet Office .............................................................................................. 12 Program 2. State Development ...................................................................................... 15 Program 3: Integrated Design Commission .................................................................... 17 Program 4: Capital City ..................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Papers Laid Before Parliament and Petitions Presented to Both Houses, 1962-1975
    P.P. 107 SOUTH AUSTRALIA INDEX TO Papers Laid Before Parliament and Petitions Presented to Both Houses, 1962-1975 (to 30th June, 1975) Ordered by the House of Assembly to be printed, 7th December, 1976 By AurHoRITY: D. J. CONIGRAVE, Acting Government Printer 1—Price 55c 1977 [P.P. 107 INDEX TO Papers Laid Before Parliament and Petitions Presented to Both Houses, 1962-1975 Subject Matter No. of Year Particulars Paper ABATTOIRS, METROPOLITAN AND EXPORT Accounts and Balance-Sheet. See No. 69 in each year up to 1973. See also South Austra- lian Meat Corporation I NVESTIGATIONS INTO EFFICIENCY AND OPERATIONS OF THE BOARD 96 1969 Report to 24th June, 1969 ABORIGINES— Aboriginal Affairs Board Report. See No. 20 in each year up to 1971-72 Lands Trust 94 1967 Report and Accounts, 1966-67. See No. 34 in each year from 1968-69 Aborigines Protection Board 20 1962 Report, 1960-61 20A 1962 Report, 1961-62. (See also Aboriginal Affairs Board) Statement concerning Common- wealth Policies 1967 ABORTION— See under Committees—Select Committee on Criminal Law Consolidation Act Amendment Bill ABORTIONS, Committee appointed to examine and report on Abortions notified in South Australia 119 1971-72 Report, 1971 146 1973-74 Report ADELAIDE FESTIVAL CENTRE TRUST 113 1972 Report, 1971-72 113 1973-74 Report, 1972-73 158 1974-75 Report, 1973-74 Ad hoc COMMITTEE ON ALCOHOL IN RELATION TO ROAD TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS 93 1972 Report ADULT PROBATION SERVICE Report. See No. 58 in each year up to 1970-71 ADVANCES FOR HOMES ACT See State Bank Report TO SETTLERS ACT.
    [Show full text]
  • 2012 a Record to Commemorate the Seventy–Fifth Anniversary of the Club
    WOODVILLE DISTRICT CRICKET CLUB 1937 – 2012 A RECORD TO COMMEMORATE THE SEVENTY–FIFTH ANNIVERSARY OF THE CLUB INTRODUCTION In September, 2012 the Woodville District Cricket Club celebrated its seventy-fifth anniversary. This publication includes references to the early Woodville Cricket Club first formed in 1874, and a history relating to the establishment of the Club in 1937 and its progress to admission to the South Australian Cricket Association District Cricket Competition. I have drawn on two publications that I have previously produced: - June, 1976 titled “ History of the Woodville District Cricket Club Inc. 1937-1976 “ prepared in conjunction with the centenary celebrations of the City of Woodville (1), and - September, 2009 - “Woodville District Cricket Club- Performances, Statistics and Other Club Records: 1937/1938 - 2008/2009” (2). The 75th anniversary has provided the opportunity to consolidate Club records. As a consequence this publication includes a comprehensive record of office holders, the significant achievements and performances of players along with other statistical details of Club performances. Parts II-VI includes these records and represents a collection established, added to, and maintained since 1973. The records and statistics do track the path of history. In some instances the date of creating the particular record is shown. What is produced in relation to player performances and State representation do not include the separate State and A Grade One Day and Twenty20 competitions. The contribution that many individuals have made to the establishment and performance of the Club, and its enduring existence over its 75 year history can, to some extent, be measured by what is recorded in the various parts of this publication.
    [Show full text]
  • The Life Cycle of Migrant Hostels Established in South Australia Post WWII (1948-1955) with an Emphasis on Those Run by the Commonwealth
    The Life Cycle of Migrant Hostels Established in South Australia post WWII (1948-1955) With an emphasis on those run by the Commonwealth by Jamie Varacalli Output produced for National Archives of Australia (SA Branch) in fulfillment of the requirements of the Arts Internship Scheme 2009 (ARTS 2001), University of Adelaide, South Australia. Table of Contents Page Table of Contents .................................................................... i Acknowledgements.................................................................. iii Introduction ............................................................................. iv List of Abbreviations .............................................................. v Figures ....................................................................................... vi Brief Background to the Establishment of Migrant Hostels in South Australia ............................. 1 Commonwealth Administered Hostels ................................. 3 Finsbury/Pennington .......................................................... 4 Gawler ................................................................................. 6 Gepps Cross ........................................................................ 7 Glenelg ................................................................................ 8 Mallala ................................................................................ 9 Mannum .............................................................................. 10 Mt Barker ...........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Planning Excellence 2012 SOUTH AUSTRALIA AWARDS
    Planning Excellence 2012 SOUTH AUSTRALIA AWARDS Recognising, Promoting and Celebrating Good Planning Practice Commemorative Booklet PIA Awards for Planning Excellence The PIA Awards for Planning Excellence leadership. The category line up now has a recognise, reward and celebrate outstanding more holistic coverage of those unique goals planning achievements. This is a highly some planning projects set out to achieve and regarded industry awards program that to better represent the multidisciplinary nature provides a forum for planners and planning of planning practice. Additional categories teams within the profession to showcase their were created to celebrate planning leadership excellent work and promote planning to the by both planners and non-planners. We will wider community. continue to improve the quality and credibility of the PIA Awards for Planning Excellence The annual Awards program allows planning each year. professionals from all states and territories the opportunity to have their work critically judged Those who participate in the PIA Awards for by local peers with winning projects from each Planning Excellence make a small but important jurisdiction later judged at the PIA National contribution that demonstrates a commitment Awards ceremony. Planning projects winning to advancing the planning profession. Through at state or territory level have the opportunity this program the community can see the to be acknowledged nationally as the best of enormously important and positive contribution what planning and planners in Australia have the Planning profession makes to the future of to offer. human settlement. The program is designed to encourage continued excellence in planning achievements in an industry that applauds leadership, creativity and best practice.
    [Show full text]
  • 2004 Annual Report
    ANNUAL REPORT 2003DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT– AND 0URBAN PLANNING4 Level 12 Roma Mitchell House 136 North Terrace ADELAIDE SA 5000 DX407 PO Box 8197, Station Arcade ADELAIDE SA 5000 Telephone (08) 8204 8200 Facsimile (08) 8204 8216 www.dtup.sa.gov.au Department of Transport & Urban Planning Annual Report - DTUP (Print) ISSN 1448-7357 Annual Report - DTUP (Online) ISSN 1448-742X Annual Report - DTUP (CD-ROM) ISSN 1448-7365 Front Cover Dynamic photograph of traffic entering the Heysen Tunnels DTUP 2003-2004 Annual Report The Honourable Trish White MP The Honourable John Hill MP Minister for Transport Minister for the Southern Suburbs Minister for Urban Development and Planning Level 9 Level 12 Chesser House Roma Mitchell House 91-97 Grenfell Street 136 North Terrace ADELAIDE SA 5000 ADELAIDE SA 5000 The Honourable Rory McEwen MP Minister for State/Local Government Relations Level 9 Terrace Towers 178 North Terrace ADELAIDE SA 5000 Dear Ministers, I have pleasure in presenting the annual report of the Department of Transport and Urban Planning for the year ended 30 June 2004. The Department continues to change to meet the diverse needs of the Ministerial portfolios and the Government’s strategic directions. The report details the work, achievements and relevant statutory and financial information of the Department and provides an insight into the priorities for 2004-05. The Department looks forward to a challenging and exciting year in which it will continue to contribute to the growth and prosperity of South Australia. This report is for submission to Parliament and complies with the requirements of the Public Sector Management Act 1995 and the Public Finance and Audit Act 1987.
    [Show full text]
  • Residential Historic Conservation Zone
    Local History Factsheet: A brief history of the suburb Woodville From left: City of Woodville gardening staff 1963, Woodville town hall 1950, the Brocas c1912, Woodville Road 1976. Woodville is commonly believed to have been settled as a result of it being located at the mid- way point between the Adelaide and the Port. The first building recorded in the locality was the ‘Halfway House’ an inn (near the Woodville Hotel and not be confused with the Halfway Hotel). This Inn opened in 1839. Woodville was formally laid out in 1849. Woodville Road was originally called Main Street and the commercial centre was situated along Port Road. Until 1975 when the District Council of Woodville was proclaimed, Woodville was a part of the District Council of Hindmarsh. The first part of the Brocas was built in c1852 believed to be by Henry Giles. Shipping agent John Newman bought the property in 1854 and, between 1869 and 1872, transformed the property with front and rear extensions including the 2-storey mansion style façade with central tower and balcony. Another large Woodville homestead, ‘St Clair’ (demolished) was purchased by John Bristow Hughes (of Bundaleer Station fame) in 1854. Hughes was responsible for the construction of a number of iconic properties in Woodville including St Margaret’s Church. Under his ownership, St Clair became one of the largest mansions in Adelaide at that time. An underground kitchen and a second storey were added and the entire ground floor was converted into a ballroom. In 1962, Woodville proudly opened the St Clair Recreation Centre, South Australia’s first major youth centre and indoor sports stadium on the St Clair homestead site.
    [Show full text]
  • PIRSA08 Annrep0708art.Indd
    ©Primary Industries and Resources South Australia (PIRSA) 2008 This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cwlth), no part may be reproduced by any process without prior written permission from Primary Industries and Resources SA. Requests and inquiries concerning reproduction and rights should be addressed to the General Manager, Communications and Marketing, PIRSA, GPO Box 1671, Adelaide SA 5001. The information in this publication can be provided in an alternative format or another language on request. Please contact David Primer on (08) 8226 0539. Distribution This report is available online at this website www.pir.sa.gov.au. Comments about this report are welcome and should be directed to: Communications Offi cer, Communications and Marketing PIRSA Level 17, 25 Grenfell St, Adelaide GPO Box 1671, Adelaide SA 5001 Phone National (08) 8226 0539 International +61 8 8226 0539 Fax National (08) 8226 0027 International +61 8 8226 0027 Email [email protected] ISSN 0 7590 1386 1 (Online) Compiled by Communications and Marketing, PIRSA PIRSA Annual Report 2007-08 2 Hon. Rory McEwen MP Minister for Agriculture Food and Fisheries Minister for Forests Hon. Paul Holloway MLC Minister for Mineral Resources Development Minister for Urban Development and Planning Hon. John Hill MP Minister for the Southern Suburbs Hon. Gail Gago MLC Minister for State/Local Government Relations Dear Ministers, I am pleased to present the PIRSA annual report for the year ended 30 June 2008. The report has been prepared under section 66 of the Public Sector Management Act 1995, in accordance with the Act’s accompanying regulations as well as the fi nancial reporting requirements of the Public Finance and Audit Act 1987.
    [Show full text]
  • PIRSA Annual Report 2005-2006, Appendixes
    Appendixes APPENDIX 1 PIRSA MINISTERIAL RESPONSIBILITIES Legislation The principal legislation, for which PIRSA has administrative responsibility through the Minister for Mineral Resources Development, Minister for Urban Development and Planning, Minister for the Southern Suburbs, Minister for Agriculture, Food and Fisheries, Minister for Forests, Minister for State/Local Government Relations, is listed below. In some instances these Acts are supported by Regulations, Notices and Indentures or Directions. AGRICULTURE, FOOD AND FISHERIES Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals (South Australia) Act 1994 Agricultural and Veterinary Products (Control of Use) Act 2002 Aquaculture Act 2001 Barley Marketing Act 1993 Biological Control Act 1986 Branding of Pigs Act 1964 Brands Act 1933 Chicken Meat Industry Act 2003 Dried Fruits Repeal Act 2003 Fisheries Act 1982 Fisheries (Validation of Administrative Acts) Act 2002 Fisheries (Gulf St Vincent Prawn Fishery Rationalisation) Act 1987 Fisheries (Southern Rock Lobster Fishery Rationalisation) Act 1987 Fruit and Plant Protection Act 1992 Genetically Modified Crops Management Act 2004 Impounding Act 1920 Livestock Act 1997 Noxious Insects Act 1934 Phylloxera and Grape Industry Act 1995 Primary Industry Funding Schemes Act 1998 Primary Produce (Food Safety Schemes) Act 2004 Primary Producers Emergency Assistance Act 1967 Rural Industry Adjustment and Development Act 1985 Seeds Act Repeal Act 2002 South Australian Meat Corporation Act 1936 South Australian Meat Corporation (Sale of Assets) Act 1996 Veterinary
    [Show full text]