DOCSLIB.ORG

Style Specifications

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Style Specifications Ethics and Animal Welfare in Organic Animal Husbandry An interdisciplinary approach Vonne Lund Department of Animal Environment and Health Skara Doctoral thesis Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences Skara 2002 Acta universitatis Agriculturae Sueciae Veterinaria 137 ISSN : 1401-6257 ISBN : 91-576-6394-7 © 2002 Vonne Lund Print: Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences/ Repro Alnarp Abstract Lund, V. 2002. Ethics and animal welfare in organic animal husbandry – an interdisciplinary approach Doctor’s dissertation ISSN 1401-6257, ISBN 91-576-6394-7 Farm animals make important contributions to organic farming systems. This thesis deals with the values and aims of organic farming in relation to animal welfare concerns. The organic standards and other publications from the organic movement are analyzed to define basic values. These are related to ethical theory, and ecocentric ethics is suggested as an ethical position for organic farming. It is concluded that although the main concern is to develop sustainable and environmentally friendly farming systems, animal welfare is an important aim in organic farming. Two studies have been made of Swedish organic livestock farmers to examine their values and beliefs about animal husbandry and animal welfare. The first study comprised 15 qualitative in-depth interviews. The second study was a quantitative questionnaire study., where answers were analyzed using principal component analysis (exploratory factor analysis). Both studies showed that the ecocentric position can be identified among Swedish organic livestock farmers in their perception of animal welfare. An important finding is that the animal welfare concept is understood differently in organic farming from what is usual in conventional agriculture. It is interpreted in terms of natural living, which includes the possibility of performing a natural behavior, feeds adapted to the animal’s physiology and a natural environment. Thus, it is important for the organic farmers to be explicit and communicate their view of animal welfare to other groups. A literature study was performed to learn about the actual animal welfare situation in organic animal husbandry. Only 22 peer-reviewed articles were found. There were no indications in the literature that overall health is worse in organic than in conventional herds. A very careful conclusion was that animal health in organic farming is as good or perhaps better – with the important exception of parasitic diseases. The thesis also analyzes conflicting values and dilemmas in organic animal husbandry, e.g., between the ecocentric position and aspects of animal welfare. The questionnaire study revealed two groups with partially differing values: farmers who see organic farming as a life style and who believe environmental issues and natural living are important, and entrepreneurial farmers who consider making money and new challenges more important. An ethical contract is proposed as a tool to handle the dilemmas. It is concluded that it is important for organic farmers and for the organic movement to take animal health and welfare issues seriously. Key words: Ecocentric ethics, ethical contract, animal welfare, natural behavior, organic farming, organic livestock production, organic animal husbandry Author’s address: Vonne Lund, Department of Animal Environment and Health, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Box 234, SE-532 23 Skara, Sweden LIVET är förunderligt – är så starkt och mäktigt Livet är förunderligt – är så svagt och bräckligt Som en vårflod spränger alla dämningar Gör sig fri Som en blomdoft smyger tyst i skymningen Drar förbi ditt hus – så kan en människa aldrig fånga livet! (LIFE Is wondrous – so strong and powerful Life Is wondrous – so weak and fragile Like a spring flood smashing all restrains Breaking free Like a scent of flowers sneaking silently Past your house at dusk A human can never capture life!) To Sven and Tryggve Contents Appendix 6 Introduction 7 The relationship among ethics, animal welfare and interdisciplinarity 8 What is organic animal husbandry? 9 The development of organic farming 11 Aims 20 Materials and methods 21 Results 23 Paper I 23 Paper II 24 Paper III 24 Paper IV 25 Paper V 26 General discussion 27 Methodological considerations 27 Papers I and II 29 Paper III 30 Paper IV 31 Paper V 31 Synthesis of papers I-V 32 Is animal welfare a concern for organic farming – or should it be? 33 The animal welfare concept in organic farming 40 Animal welfare in practice 45 Organic farmers' attitudes to ethics and animal welfare – a Swedish example 51 A proposal of an ethical approach to the organic dilemma 53 Conclusions 55 Svensk sammanfattning 57 References 59 Acknowledgements 70 Appendix This thesis is based on the following papers, which will be referred to in the text by their Roman numerals: I. Lund, V. & Röcklinsberg, H. 2001. Outlining a concept of animal welfare for organic farming systems. Journal of agricultural and environmental ethics 14, 391-424. II. Lund, V., Anthony, R. & Röcklinsberg, H. The ethical contract as a tool in organic animal husbandry. Accepted for publication in Journal of agricultural and environmental ethics after revision. III. Lund, V. & Algers, B. Research on animal health and welfare in organic farming – a literature review. Accepted for publication in Livestock production science. IV. Lund, V., Hemlin, S. & Lockeretz, W. 2002. Organic livestock production as viewed by Swedish farmers and organic initiators. Agriculture and human values 19(3), 255-268. V. Lund, V., Hemlin, S. & White, J. Ethics and natural behavior - Swedish organic farmers’ view on animal issues. Submitted to Journal of agricultural and environmental ethics. Papers I, II and IV are published with kind permission of Kluwer Academic Publishers. Paper III is published with kind permission of Elsevier Science B.V. Introduction Organic farming has developed from a sub-cultural protest movement in the 1970’s to a more or less established part of contemporary farming (Christensen 1998). The movement has added color and flavor to the agricultural debate, to the extent that it has reached far beyond the usual scenes for agrotechnical disputes. In several countries it has engaged many sectors of society, including trade and commerce, politicians, and, in particular, the consumers. It is probably no overstatement that the organic movement is one of the successful alternative movements from the days of radical protests, at least measured in commercial terms. In 2000, the world market for organic food products netted an estimated US$17.5 billion in retail sales and it is likely that there will be a further increase in organic agricultural production in the near future (International Trade Centre, 2002). One striking feature about this debate is the many and strong opinions that have been raised. While the consumers have been consistently positive (although this is not always reflected in the sales records of organic products [Magnusson et al., 2001; Te Velde et al., 2002]), representatives from conventional agriculture have been remarkably critical – even now, when organic farming is turning profitable. The question may be asked: Are agricultural people really so slow in adopting new trends, is it just reactionary stubbornness, or do they, empowered by knowledge and experience, realize the “real truth” about organic farming? Or are there other explanations to the different attitudes among organic farmers, consumers, and the agriculturalists? Although most of the debate has been focusing on technical issues, one might suspect that the big differences among the antagonists lie in basic values and beliefs. That is, it may be a question of ethics. It has been suggested that organic farming represents a paradigm shift in agriculture, that is, a new world view, and in this case a new way of understanding farming. A discussion between two competing paradigms is never quite satisfactory, as theories are incommensurable (‘having no common standard of comparison’ [Macquarie, 1981; in Wynen, 1998]) and proponents of each camp base their arguments on different assumptions and priorities (Wynen, 1998). Animal welfare is one of the debated issues. While veterinarians often consider welfare to be unacceptable in organic systems, consumers are delighted to see pictures of happy outdoor pigs, and calves suckling their mothers on a green pasture. This thesis is looking behind the clichés, trying to scrutinize values and beliefs in organic farming that are relevant to animal welfare, both in theory and practice. It has also studied the actual welfare situation in organic animal husbandry. As a conclusion, it is suggesting ways in which to deal with some problems and dilemmas connected to animal welfare in organic farming. The outlook in the thesis is Scandinavian, with special emphasis on Sweden. This is an interesting example since organic farming, including livestock production, has transcended the pioneer stage and to a considerable extent become part of the agricultural establishment. 7 The relationship among ethics, animal welfare and interdisciplinarity Practical ethics is the study of specific moral problems, and moral theory is the attempt to answer all the specific moral questions raised in practical ethics (McNaughton, 1988). The moral problems traditionally studied in ethics are always about humans: how we morally should relate to each other and, sometimes, to society. Already in 1789 the English philosopher Jeremy Bentham asked why animals not should be included
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 1 Rethinking Bioenergy from an Agricultural
    Rethinking bioenergy from an agricultural perspective: Ethical issues raised by perennial energy crop and crop residue production for energy in the UK and Denmark Orla Shortall, MSc. Thesis submitted to the University of Nottingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2014 1 Abstract The aim of this project is to explore the social and ethical dimensions of the agricultural production of perennial energy crop and crop residues for energy. Biomass – any living or recently living matter – is being promoted in industrialised countries as part of the transition from fossil fuels to an economy based on renewable energy. Various challenges face the use of bioenergy however. One particularly controversial and high profile example has been the use of food crop biofuels in transport which are seen to conflict with food production and to cause significant environmental damage. Suggested ways around these controversies is the production of perennial energy crops such as grasses and trees and crop residues such as straw, which are seen to require fewer inputs and less prime land. Some have analysed the controversies raised by biofuels in terms of controversies around industrial agriculture more broadly: biofuels are perceived to be large scale, monocultural, environmentally damaging and pushed by agri-business and energy interests. This project asks what type of agriculture system perennial energy crops and crop residues are seen as developing within, if at all. This was considered worth exploring because the type of system will have a large bearing on how they are received in future. To this end a theoretical framework of different paradigms of agriculture ranging from industrial agriculture at one end to alternative agriculture at the other was developed and applied to the data.
    [Show full text]
  • Agricultural Science in Philosophy
    Agriculture & Philosophy Agricultural Science in Philosophy Lindsay Falvey TSU Press © Copyright retained by the author. The text words may be copied in any form in context for educational and related purposes. For other purposes, permission should be requested from the author. Title: Agriculture & Philosophy: agricultural science in philosophy / J. Lindsay Falvey (author). Published: Thaksin University Press, 2020. Content Types: Text Subjects: Philosophy & Religion Technology, Engineering, Agriculture. Australian Target Audience: specialized Summary: Agriculture and philosophy have been integrally linked across history and remain so. Philosophy, defined as wise means of humans being at ease in nature, has been fundamental to humans from pre-historical times and expressed in various forms. Those philosophical forms have included myths and legends that explained unfathomable matters to our forebears, and which informed the later development of written philosophy in the form of religious scriptures. Scriptures have thereby been the major written vehicle of philosophy for most of history and across cultures. The language employed in such philosophy relied on agricultural metaphor and used agriculture itself as the means of understanding humans as part of nature, rather than an element standing apart and observing or manipulating. With the development of natural philosophy, which became known as science, it became a major modern contribution to useful knowledge - knowledge that increased contentment and wellbeing, or philosophy. Combining myth, religion, and other knowledge from the world's major cultures, philosophy is discussed using examples from the longest and most widespread human interaction with nature, agriculture. The Enlightenment's philosophical product of agricultural science thus unifies the theme, and supports the ancient conclusion that humans' thoughts and actions form part of nature, and may even be components of a wider interaction than can be comprehended from current approaches.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 4, No. 1, Spring 1993 General Announcements
    Volume 4, No. 1, Spring 1993 General Announcements The Society for Conservation Biology, Annual Meeting, will be held at Arizona State University, Tempe, June 9-14, 1993. ISEE has a session. This is a first-class occasion for philosophers (and others) to interact with conservation biologists. Contact Jack Weir (on leave at Rice University), Graduate House, 6500 S. Main Street, # 146, Houston, TX 77030. Phone 713/630-9333. The Royal Institute of Philosophy 1993 Conference is "Philosophy and the Natural Environment," to be held at the University of Wales College of Cardiff. The keynote conference address is Holmes Rolston, III, "Value in Nature and the Nature of Value." Other speakers: Alan Holland, "Natural Capital," Mary Midgley, "The End of Anthropocentrism," Robert Elliot, "Ecology and Environmental Ethics," Tim Hayward, "A Critique of Ecological Metaphysics," Ruth Chadwick, "Geneticism and Environmentalism," Peter Wheale and Ruth McNally, "Environmental Bioethics," Frederick FerrÇ, "Personalistic Organicism: Paradox or Paradigm?", Barry Wilkins, "Exploitation, Natural Resources and the Third World," Robin Attfield, "Rehabilitating Nature and Making Nature Habitable," Andrew Belsey, "Environmentalism: Totalitarian or Libertarian?", Peter List: "Ethical Aspects of Environmental Civil Disobedience," Keekok Lee, "Awe and Humility: Intrinsic Value in Nature," Roger Crisp, "Well-Being and Environmental Value," Stephen Clark, "Theology of the Environment," Dale Jamieson, "Global Environmental Justice," and Nigel Dower, "What is Environment?" Contact Robin Attfield and Andrew Belsey, Philosophy Section, University of Wales College of Cardiff, P. O. Box 94, Cardiff CF1 3XE, UK. Ernest Partridge will become professor of philosophy, in an endowed chair, teaching environmental ethics at Northland College, Ashland, WI, beginning June 1993.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethics and Animal Welfare in Organic Animal Husbandry
    Ethics and Animal Welfare in Organic Animal Husbandry An interdisciplinary approach Vonne Lund Department of Animal Environment and Health Skara Doctoral thesis Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences Skara 2002 Acta universitatis Agriculturae Sueciae Veterinaria 137 ISSN : 1401-6257 ISBN : 91-576-6394-7 © 2002 Vonne Lund Print: Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences/ Repro Alnarp Abstract Lund, V. 2002. Ethics and animal welfare in organic animal husbandry – an interdisciplinary approach Doctor’s dissertation ISSN 1401-6257, ISBN 91-576-6394-7 Farm animals make important contributions to organic farming systems. This thesis deals with the values and aims of organic farming in relation to animal welfare concerns. The organic standards and other publications from the organic movement are analyzed to define basic values. These are related to ethical theory, and ecocentric ethics is suggested as an ethical position for organic farming. It is concluded that although the main concern is to develop sustainable and environmentally friendly farming systems, animal welfare is an important aim in organic farming. Two studies have been made of Swedish organic livestock farmers to examine their values and beliefs about animal husbandry and animal welfare. The first study comprised 15 qualitative in-depth interviews. The second study was a quantitative questionnaire study., where answers were analyzed using principal component analysis (exploratory factor analysis). Both studies showed that the ecocentric position can be identified among Swedish organic livestock farmers in their perception of animal welfare. An important finding is that the animal welfare concept is understood differently in organic farming from what is usual in conventional agriculture. It is interpreted in terms of natural living, which includes the possibility of performing a natural behavior, feeds adapted to the animal’s physiology and a natural environment.
    [Show full text]
  • Russell Lord and the Permanent Agriculture Movement
    Russell Lord and the Permanent Agriculture Movement: An Environmental Biography By Margaret L. Eppig A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Environmental Studies Antioch University New England Committee: Alesia Maltz, Ph.D (Chair) Rachel Thiet, Ph.D Allen Dietrich-Ward, Ph.D 2017 1 Dedication Dedicated to my family on the land in Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, Vermont, and New Hampshire. Your good work and stewardship inspired me to take a closer look at why we love our land and why, perhaps, it may love us back. 2 Acknowledgments This work would not have been possible without the commitment and assistance of numerous historical societies and archives. The Historical Society of Harford County, Bel Air, Maryland served as my research home, and I thank Maryanna Skowronski, executive direction, most sincerely for her friendship, years of encouragement, generous access and ready assistance. Thanks to the volunteers at the Baltimore County Historical Society my research table was always loaded with files on the Sparks High School, county 4H history, farm clubs, and news items from the farm papers. This research took me beyond archives close to home, to explore the places where Russell Lord and members of the Society of the Friends of the Land farmed, traveled, and worked to inspire a holistic restoration of America’s degraded agricultural landscapes of the 1930s and 40s. I especially thank the staff of Malabar Farm State Park, former home and farm of Louis Bromfield, and the Ohio History Connection in Columbus, for several weeks of access to the living landscapes and archival resources of the Friends of the Land in Ohio.
    [Show full text]