Inspector's Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BROMSGROVE DISTRICT COUNCIL BROMSGROVE DISTRICT LOCAL PLAN – PROPOSED MODIFICATIONS REPORT OF THE INQUIRY INTO OBJECTIONS TO THE PROPOSED MODIFICATIONS OF THE LOCAL PLAN Inspector: CLIVE A RICHARDSON BA(Hons) MCD MRTPI Dates of Inquiry: 22-25, 29-31 May 2001 1, 6-8 June 2001 5, 6, 10-13, 17-20, 24, 25, 31 July 2001 1-3 August 2001 Throughout the report I have used abbreviations for matters that appear regularly in the text. These comprise: BDC Bromsgrove District Council WCC Worcestershire County Council BDLP Bromsgrove District Local Plan BDLPPM Bromsgrove District Local Plan including Proposed Modifications HWCSP Hereford and Worcester County Structure Plan 1986-2001 WCSP Worcestershire County Structure Plan 1996-2011 EiP Worcestershire County Structure Plan Examination in Public RPG Regional Planning Guidance PPG Planning Policy Guidance SPG Supplementary Planning Guidance CD Core Document VDS Village Design Statement ADR Area of Development Restraint LPA Landscape Protection Area RTS Round Table Session SAM Scheduled Ancient Monument DoE {Department of the Environment DETR {Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions DTLR {Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions GOWM Government Office for the West Midlands dph Dwellings per hectare AOD Above ordnance datum Bromsgrove District Local Plan (Proposed Modifications) Inquiry 2001 – Inspector’s Report Summary of Inspector’s Recommendations 1. DISTRICT STRATEGY . I recommend that land be designated as ADRs and excluded from the Green Belt at: the former Brickworks site, Alvechurch; south of Kidderminster Road, Hagley; Bleakhouse Farm, Wythall; Church Road, Catshill; and Kendal End Road, Barnt Green. Recommendations 1.2.51 That Paragraph 8.19 of the explanatory text be expanded (or a further Appendix introduced): (i) explaining that ADR provision is being made to satisfy requirements to about 2021. (ii) setting out how the total quantity of ADR land has been derived. This should equate to approximately 140ha. (iii) outlining the factors that have determined the broad geographical distribution of ADRs. (iv) identifying the criteria used in the selection of ADRs. (v) specifying the ‘exceptional circumstances’ that necessitate a revision of confirmed Green Belt boundaries. 1.2 Policy DS1 – Green Belt Designation [Proposed Modification No DS/MOD5] Recommendations 1.3.91 (a) That the Plan be modified in accordance with Proposed Modification DS/MOD5, subject to the following additional modifications: Issue 2: (i) the former Brickworks site, Scarfield Road, Alvechurch be designated as an ADR. i Bromsgrove District Local Plan (Proposed Modifications) Inquiry 2001 – Inspector’s Report (ii) the Green Belt boundary be redrawn in accordance with Plan 1 of the Appendices to the Chapman Warren proof O/DS1- DS/MOD5/60/1018/ACB/1-APP, subject to the omission of land west of the canal and south of the Brickworks. (iii) a new strategic open space protection policy be applied to the field east of the canal and west of the railway line. (iv) the Proposals Map and Appendix 3A be modified accordingly. Issue 8: The explanatory text at Paragraph 8.19 be expanded (or a further Appendix introduced): (i) to justify the level of ADR provision made. (ii) to explain the general principles on which ADRs have been selected. (iii) to clarify how PPG3 advice has been addressed in terms of: a) urban capacity b) the sequential approach to site assessment c) the best use of land d) achieving sustainable residential environments e) the role of the ‘plan, monitor and manage’ approach (b) That no further modifications be made to the Plan in respect of these objections (Issues 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15). 1.3 Policy DS4 – Other Locations for Growth [Proposed Modification No DS/MOD8] Recommendations 1.4.5 (a) That the Plan be modified in accordance with Proposed Modification DS/MOD8. (b) That no further modifications be made to the Plan in respect of this objection. ii Bromsgrove District Local Plan (Proposed Modifications) Inquiry 2001 – Inspector’s Report 1.5 Policy DS5 – Village Envelope Settlements [Proposed Modification No DS/MOD9] Recommendations 1.5.14 (a) That the Plan be modified in accordance with Proposed Modification DS/MOD9. (b) That no further modifications be made to the Plan in respect of these objections. 1.6 Policy DS8 – Areas of Development Restraint [Proposed Modification No DS/MOD12] Recommendations 1.6.163 (a) That the Plan be modified in accordance with Proposed Modification DS/MOD12, subject to the following additional modifications: Issue 1: (i) land south of Kidderminster Road, Hagley be designated as an ADR and excluded from the Green Belt. (ii) the Proposals Map and Appendix 3A be modified accordingly. Issue 3: (former Brickworks site, Alvechurch) See recommendations at Paragraph 1.3.91. Issue 4: The following be added to Paragraph 8.19 of the explanatory text, after the words “….. Areas of Development Restraint (ADRs)”: “They represent sustainable locations for development whilst having regard to Green Belt objectives. The identification of such areas will reduce the likelihood of the need to redefine Green Belt boundaries before 2021.” Issue 16: iii Bromsgrove District Local Plan (Proposed Modifications) Inquiry 2001 – Inspector’s Report (i) land at Bleakhouse Farm, Wythall [shaded brown on G L Hearn Planning drawing J6915/1 dated May 2001, but excluding the 2 middle fields immediately north of the farm buildings] be designated as an ADR and excluded from the Green Belt. (ii) the Proposals Map and Appendix 3A be modified accordingly. Issue 20: See recommendations at Paragraph 1.3.91. Issue 24: (i) land at Church Road, Catshill be designated as an ADR. (ii) the Green Belt boundary be drawn as shown on Plan 3 accompanying the main hearing statement of Stansgate Planning Consultants (Docs O/DS8 – DS/MOD12/1019/1420/PGH/1 and O/DS8 – DS/MOD12/1020/1421/PGH/1). (iii) the Proposals Map and Appendix 3A be modified accordingly. Issue 28: (i) land at Kendal End Road, Barnt Green be designated as an ADR. (ii) the Green Belt boundary be redrawn to follow the line of Cherry Hill Road and Kendal End Road. (iii) the Proposals Map and Appendix 3A be modified accordingly. (b) That no further modifications be made to the Plan in respect of these objections (Issues 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 17, 18, 19, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26, 27, 29 and 30). 1.7 Policy DS11 – Planning Obligations [Proposed Modification No DS/MOD15] Recommendations 1.7.4 (a) That the Plan be modified in accordance with Proposed Modification DS/MOD15, subject to the following additional modifications: iv Bromsgrove District Local Plan (Proposed Modifications) Inquiry 2001 – Inspector’s Report (i) The explanatory text at Paragraph 8.22 be expanded to make reference to the advice on planning obligations set out in Circular 1/97. (ii) Sub-section a) of Policy DS11 be altered to read: “on or off-site facilities directly arising from the development such as additional educational, community, recreational or other infrastructure which may reasonably be required as a result of the scheme; or” (b) That no further modifications be made to the Plan in respect of these objections. 1.8 Policy DS13 – Sustainable Development [Proposed Modification No DS/MOD16] . Recommendations 1.8.5 (a) That Proposed Modification DS/MOD16 be not made. (b) That Policy DS13 be modified to read: “The District Council will take full account of the need for future development to be sustainable so that present demands do not compromise the ability of future generations to meet their own demands or enjoy a high quality environment. All development must reflect the need to safeguard and improve the quality of life of residents by: maintaining high and stable levels of economic growth and employment ensuring social progress which recognises the needs of everyone conserving energy resources, and protecting the Plan area’s essential character and environmental assets, including: a) the general attractiveness and diversity of the landscape b) the open and undeveloped nature of the countryside c) the Green Belt d) areas of wildlife and ecological value e) the setting, form and character of settlements f) the quality of air and water resources v Bromsgrove District Local Plan (Proposed Modifications) Inquiry 2001 – Inspector’s Report g) buildings and areas of special townscape, historic and architectural interest h) sites of archaeological importance i) land of recreation and amenity value, and j) the best and most versatile agricultural land.” (c) That Paragraph 8.24 be modified to read: “It is the District Council’s intention that this local plan should reflect concern for the present and future quality of life of its residents. Defining broad sustainable development aims and criteria is essential for providing the direction and essential yardstick in later appraisals of development plan policies and proposals.” (d) That the Council includes references to Village Design Statements in the relevant settlement chapters of the Plan. (e) That no further modifications be made to the Plan in respect of these objections. 1.9 Policy DS14 – Enforcement [Proposed Modification No DS/MOD17] Recommendations 1.9.7 That the Plan be modified in accordance with Proposed Modification DS/MOD17, subject to the following additional modification: Paragraph 8.25 to read: “The District Council will publish a policy document on the enforcement of planning controls. It is intended that this document will be adopted by the Council as supplementary planning guidance and reviewed on a regular basis.” 2. HOUSING 2.1.1 This chapter of the report considers the relationship of Stoke Prior to Bromsgrove town. It examines the detailed wording and scope of policies relating to new dwellings within and outside the Green Belt, plot subdivision in urban areas, and the replacement, extension and change of use of dwellings in the Green Belt.