Explosive phenomena in complex networks Raissa M. D'Souza,1, 2 Jesus G´omez-Garde~nes,3, 4 Jan Nagler,5 and Alex Arenas6 1Department of Computer Science, Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Complexity Sciences Center, University of California, Davis 95616, USA 2Santa Fe Institute, 1399 Hyde Park Rd Santa Fe New Mexico 87501, USA 3Department of Condensed Physics, University of Zaragoza, Zaragoza 50009, Spain 4GOTHAM Lab, Institute for Biocomputation and Physics of Complex Systems (BIFI), University of Zaragoza, Zaragoza 50018, Spain 5Deep Dynamics Group & Centre for Human and Machine Intelligence, Frankfurt School of Finance & Management, Frankfurt, Germany 6Departament d'Enginyeria Inform`atica i Matem`atiques, Universitat Rovira i Virgili, 43007 Tarragona, Spain (Dated: July 24, 2019) The emergence of large-scale connectivity and synchronization are crucial to the structure, func- tion and failure of many complex socio-technical networks. Thus, there is great interest in analyzing phase transitions to large-scale connectivity and to global synchronization, including how to enhance or delay the onset. These phenomena are traditionally studied as second-order phase transitions where, at the critical threshold, the order parameter increases rapidly but continuously. In 2009, an extremely abrupt transition was found for a network growth process where links compete for addition in attempt to delay percolation. This observation of \explosive percolation" was ulti- mately revealed to be a continuous transition in the thermodynamic limit, yet with very atypical finite-size scaling, and it started a surge of work on explosive phenomena and their consequences. Many related models are now shown to yield discontinuous percolation transitions and even hybrid transitions. Explosive percolation enables many other features such as multiple giant components, modular structures, discrete scale invariance and non-self-averaging, relating to properties found in many real phenomena such as explosive epidemics, electric breakdowns and the emergence of molecular life. Models of explosive synchronization provide an analytic framework for the dynamics of abrupt transitions and reveal the interplay between the distribution in natural frequencies and the network structure, with applications ranging from epileptic seizures to waking from anesthesia. Here we review the vast literature on explosive phenomena in networked systems and synthesize the fundamental connections between models and survey the application areas. We attempt to classify explosive phenomena based on underlying mechanisms and to provide a coherent overview and perspective for future research to address the many vital questions that remained unanswered. arXiv:1907.09957v1 [physics.soc-ph] 23 Jul 2019 2 CONTENTS I. Introduction 3 A. Percolation, synchronization, and phase transitions 3 B. Percolation and synchronization on complex networks 4 C. Overview of Review 5 II. Explosive percolation (EP) 5 A. Percolation on random graphs 5 1. Static formulation 5 2. Kinetic formulation 6 3. Discontinuous percolation transitions 7 B. EP from competitive percolation 7 1. Achlioptas Process (AP) 8 2. AP with m-edge rules on random graphs 9 3. AP with m-edge rules on lattices 13 4. AP with k-vertex rules on random graphs 13 5. Thermodynamic formulations of EP 14 C. EP from alternate processes 15 1. Suppressing the largest component 15 2. Tuning edge rejection rate (The BFW model) 16 3. Cluster aggregation 18 4. Correlated processes 19 5. Hierarchical lattices 19 D. Categories of EP transitions 20 1. Type I: Anomalous continuous transition 20 2. Type II: Discontinuous phase transition 22 3. Type III: Discontinuity at the end of the process 22 4. Type IV: Single-step-continuous discontinuity 23 5. Type V: Hybrid phase transition 23 6. Type VI: Devil's staircases and non-self-averaging 24 E. EP phenomena in real-world systems 26 1. Non-Self-Averaging and the emergence of molecular life 26 2. Finite size of real systems 26 3. Modular network structure in the real-world 27 4. Disordered materials 28 5. Explosive Immunization 28 6. Optimal Dismantling 29 7. Information spreading 29 F. Other interesting EP phenomena 29 1. Node arrival mitigates abruptness 29 2. APs with directed edges 30 3. Degree-based rules 30 4. Explosive Ising from an AP 31 5. Discrete Scale Invariance 31 G. General insights 31 1. Mechanisms and processes underlying EP 31 2. The role of order parameter 32 3. Reversible versus irreversible transitions 33 III. Explosive Synchronization (ES) 33 A. Introduction to the Kuramoto model 34 B. The Kuramoto model in networks 36 C. Explosive Synchronization in networks 39 D. The correlated degree-frequency (CDF) framework 39 1. Analytical characterization 41 2. The star network 42 3. Effect of structural properties 44 3 4. More general CDF scenarios 45 5. Noisy degree-frequency correlations 46 6. CDF with time delay and frustration 47 E. The correlated frequency-coupling (CFC) framework 48 1. Independence of network properties 48 2. The Sakaguchi-Kuramoto model under the CFC framework 50 3. Loss of rotational invariance 50 4. Including frequency mismatch 51 5. Effective Synchronization centrality 51 F. The frequency gap conditioned (FGC) framework 52 G. The adaptive framework 52 H. Other paradigmatic dynamical models 55 1. Second-order Kuramoto model 55 2. Oscillators with amplitude dynamics 56 3. Neural models 58 4. Rossler chaotic oscillators 59 I. Experiments and real-world applications 60 1. Implementations in the lab 60 2. Spontaneous synchronization in real systems 60 J. ES in a nutshell 62 IV. Connection between EP and ES 63 V. Other models with explosive behavior 65 A. Explosive congestion in complex networks 65 B. Explosive epidemics in networks 67 C. Explosive phenomena on multilayer complex networks 69 1. Abrupt structural transitions 70 2. Abrupt percolation transitions 71 3. Abrupt synchronization transitions 73 VI. Conclusions and Open Challenges 75 Acknowledgments 76 References 76 I. INTRODUCTION This review of explosive phenomena in complex networks is an attempt to provide a coherent overview of an area with vigorous activity and extensive literature dating back to 2009. We discuss the paradigms of Explosive Percolation (EP) and Explosive Synchronization (ES) in complex networks, surveying the broad range of phenomena observed in models that display these types of abrupt transitions. We identify that these models share a common underlying mechanism with a microscopic evolution dynamics that delays the formation of a macroscopic (connected or synchronized) component. We show that similar underlying cluster dynamics can be associated with many real systems displaying abrupt transitions. We also discuss examples of explosive phenomena in a variety of scenarios such the emergence of globalization from local individual decisions, epileptic seizures, explosive epidemics, and the emergence of molecular life. A. Percolation, synchronization, and phase transitions Percolation theory is used to analyze the extent of connectivity in an underlying random media such as a lat- tice or a random graph. It has been used extensively for many decades to model phenomena ranging from flow through porous media to connectivity and spreading on random graphs [Stauffer and Aharony 1994, Sahimi 1994, Dorogovtsev et al. 2008]. It was first formulated as a lattice model where each of the \bonds" between adjacent neigh- bors could be occupied with probability p or unoccupied with probability (1 p) [Broadbent and Hammersley 1957]. − 4 A cluster of adjacent occupied bonds is considered to be connected, allowing a fluid or an epidemic to spread through- out that cluster. Of great interest is the percolation phase transition that describes the sudden, but typically smooth, onset of large scale connectivity at a critical value pc. While percolation focuses on the structural properties of a system, synchronization constitutes a paradigm for analyzing its dynamical behavior. Synchronization is a fundamental phenomenon which is pervasive in systems ranging from coupled mechanical clocks to neuronal firing patterns in the brain. Although percolation and synchronization consider different aspects of a system, both phenomena are traditionally known to emerge via a second-order phase transition. In other words, starting from a disconnected system, long-range connectivity (i.e., percolation) emerges smoothly at a critical point when increasing internal system density. In turn, starting from a system of uncoupled identical oscillators, global synchronization emerges smoothly at a critical point when increasing the coupling between oscillators. In both cases, the global behavior (percolation or synchronization) arises as a consequence of increasing the strength of local interactions and are, in general, second-order phase transitions. Thermal equilibrium phase transitions are typically classified as first-order or second-order based on how the order parameter changes at the critical point, with a discrete jump in the value for first-order, and a sharp but smooth change for second-order. Second-order transitions are additionally accompanied by a range of interrelated scaling behaviors, whereas first-order transitions typically display instead other phenomena like phase coexistence and hysteresis loops indicative of irreversibility. See, for instance, [Stanley 1971], and the discussion therein. In the scope of percolation, several examples of first-order transitions were known before the introduction of EP, such as