On Rādha and Views ― a Translation of Saṃyukta-Āgama Discourses 111 to 138 (Fascicle 6)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
On Rādha and Views ― A Translation of Saṃyukta-āgama Discourses 111 to 138 (Fascicle 6) Bhikkhu Anālayo Research Fellow Dharma Drum Institute of Liberal Arts 法鼓佛學學報第 17 期 頁 1-42(民國 104 年),新北市:法鼓文理學院 Dharma Drum Journal of Buddhist Studies, no. 17 pp. 1-42 (2015) New Taipei City: Dharma Drum Institute of Liberal Arts ISSN: 1996-8000 Abstract This article translates the sixth fascicle of the Saṃyukta-āgama, which contains discourses 111 to 138.1 Contents CONNECTED DISCOURSES ON RĀDHA 111. Discourse on the Conduit to Becoming 112. Discourse on Penetrative Knowledge 113. Discourse on Eradicating the Dukkha of Bodily Form 114. Discourse on Understanding Dukkha 115. Discourse on Worry and Sorrow 116. Discourse on Viewing as a Self or as Belonging to a Self * Date of submission: 2014/12/29; date of review: 2015/05/19. I am indebted to Mike Running, Shi Syinchen, and Ken Su for their collaboration and to the journal's proof readers for helpful suggestions. 1 The translated text is found at T II 37c6 to 42c8, this being the sixth fascicle in the Taishō edition corresponding to the sixth fascicle in the reconstructed order of this collection according to, e.g., Choong 2000: 243, Bucknell 2006: 686, and Chung 2008: 23. Yìnshùn 1983, however, places the present and the next fascicle at a con- siderably later point in his edition, as a result of which SĀ 111 to SĀ 138 in the Taishō edition correspond to discourses nos. 1652 to 1790 in his edition. The present fascicle contains two Saṃyukta-āgama sections: SĀ 111 to SĀ 129 correspond to the section on Rādha, whereas SĀ 130 to SĀ 138 correspond to the first part of the sec- tion on views (which continues into the next fascicle). In what follows, my identifica- tion of Pāli parallels is based on Akanuma 1929/1990 and Yìnshùn 1983, in the case of Sanskrit fragment parallels I am indebted to Chung 2008. Here and elsewhere, I adopt Pāli for proper names and doctrinal terms in order to facilitate comparison with the Pāli parallels, except for terms like Dharma and Nirvāṇa, without thereby intend- ing to take a position on the original language of the Saṃyukta-āgama manuscript used for translation. In the case of reproducing Sanskrit texts from romanized editions, I follow the conventions of the respective editors (except for capitalization). My re- construction of the respective titles is based on Akanuma 1929/1990, in the case of the same title being repeated I add "first", "second", etc. 2 法鼓佛學學報第 17 期(2015) 117. Discourse on Being with Influxes and Obstructions 118. Discourse on Lust, Hatred, and Delusion 119. Discourse on Desire, Craving, and Delight 120. First Discourse on Māra 121. Discourse on Being of a Mortal Nature 122. Discourse on the Living Being 123. Discourse on Craving, Delight, and Lust 124. Second Discourse on Māra 125. Discourse on What is Made by Māra 126. Discourse on Being of a Mortal Nature 127. First Discourse on Being of the Nature to be Abandoned 128. Second Discourse on Being of the Nature to be Abandoned 129. Third Discourse on Being of the Nature to be Abandoned CONNECTED DISCOURSES ON VIEWS 130. Discourse on Seeking Out the Great Teacher 131. Discourse on Becoming Habituated 132. Discourse on Not Becoming Habituated 133. Discourse on What is the Cause 134. First Discourse on Abandoning Doubt 135. Second Discourse on Abandoning Doubt 136. Discourse on What Matter is the Cause 137. Third Discourse on Abandoning Doubt 138. Fourth Discourse on Abandoning Doubt Keywords Saṃyukta-āgama; Rādha; Views On Rādha and Views-A Translation of Saṃyukta-āgama Discourses 111 to 138 (Fascicle 6) 3 111. [Discourse on the Conduit to Becoming]2 Thus have I heard. At one time the Buddha was staying at Mount Ma- kula.3 Then an attendant monk by the name of Rādha,4 rising from meditation in the afternoon, approached the Buddha, paid respect at the Buddha's feet, withdrew to sit at one side, and said to the Buddha: "As the Blessed One has taught, there is a flow of becoming. What is called the flow of becoming? What is called the cessation of the flow of becoming?" The Buddha said to Rādha: "It is well for you to be asking this. I shall explain it to you, namely what is the flow of becoming. A foolish un- learned worldling does not understand as it really is the arising of bodily form, the cessation of bodily form, the gratification in bodily form, the danger in bodily form, and the escape from bodily form. Because of not understanding it as it really is, he craves for and de- lights in bodily form, he commends it, he grasps it, and is defiled by attachment [to it]. In dependence on craving and delight for bodily form, there is clinging. In dependence on clinging, there is becoming. In dependence on becoming, there is birth. In dependence on birth, old age, disease, death, worry, sorrow, vexation, and pain increase. In this way this entire great mass of dukkha arises. Feeling … perception … formations … consciousness is also like this. This is called the flow of 5 becoming. 2 Parallel: SN 23.3 at SN III 190,26. 3 SĀ 111 at T II 37c6: 摩拘羅山. The same rendering recurs in T 194 at T IV 144b4 in a reference to the place where the Buddha was held to have spent the sixth rainy sea- son retreat after his awakening, which the commentary on the Buddhavaṃsa, Bv-a 3,25, allocates to Mount Maṅkula, alternatively referred to as Mount Makula; cf. Rhys Davids 1877/1911: 70f, Bigandet 1858/1914: 211, and Mochizuki 1940: 30. SN 23.3 at SN III 190,26 instead takes place at Sāvatthī. 4 Malalasekera 1938/1998: 730 note 1 explains that Rādha appears to have been an at- tendant of Sāriputta. 5 SN 23.3 at SN III 191,1 does not present a contrast between the unlearned worlding and the noble disciple, but simply points out that desire, lust, delight, craving, cling- 4 法鼓佛學學報第 17 期(2015) "A learned noble disciple understands as it really is the arising of bodily form, the cessation of bodily form, the gratification in bodily form, the danger in bodily form, and the escape from bodily form. Because of understanding it as it really is, he does not give rise to craving and delight in regard to such bodily form, to commending it, to grasping it, or to being defiled by attachment [to it]. Because of being without craving and delight, commending, grasping, and being defiled by attachment, craving for bodily form ceases. With the cessa- tion of craving, clinging ceases. With the cessation of clinging, be- coming ceases. With the cessation of becoming, birth ceases. With the cessation of birth, old age, disease, death, worry, sorrow, pain and vexation cease.6 In this way this entire great mass of dukkha ceases. Feeling … perception … formations … consciousness is also like this. "This is called the flow of becoming and the cessation of the flow of becoming, as taught by the Tathāgata." When the Buddha had spoken this discourse, hearing what the Buddha had said the monk Rādha was delighted and received it respectfully. 112. [Discourse on Penetrative Knowledge]7 Thus have I heard. At one time the Buddha was staying at Mount Ma- kula.8 Then an attendant monk by the name of Rādha, rising from meditation in the afternoon, approached the Buddha, paid respect at the Buddha's feet, withdrew to sit at one side, and said to the Buddha: "Blessed One, as the Blessed One has taught, there is penetrative un- derstanding of bodily form, penetrative understanding of feeling … ing, adherence, and underlying tendencies for the five aggregates constitute the con- duit to existence, bhavanetti. 6 Adopting a variant that adds 滅; cf. also Yìnshùn 1983: 484 note 5. 7 Parallel: SN 23.4 at SN III 191,8; the same exposition, although not addressed to Rādha, can be found in SN 22.106 at SN III 159,23, which has a parallel in SĀ 72 at T II 19a4 (translated Anālayo 2013: 32). 8 SN 23.4 at SN III 191,8 instead takes place at Sāvatthī. On Rādha and Views-A Translation of Saṃyukta-āgama Discourses 111 to 138 (Fascicle 6) 5 perception … formations … consciousness. Blessed One, what is penetrative understanding of bodily form, penetrative understanding of feeling … perception … formations … consciousness?"9 The Buddha said to Rādha: "It is well for you to be asking this. I shall explain it to you. The eradication, fading away, cessation, appease- ment, and vanishing of worry, sorrow, pain and vexation in relation to bodily form, this is called the penetrative understanding of bodily form. The eradication, fading away, cessation, appeasement, and van- ishing of worry, sorrow, pain and vexation in relation to feeling … perception … formations … consciousness, [38a] this is called the penetrative understanding of feeling …perception … formations … consciousness."10 When the Buddha had spoken this discourse, hearing what the Buddha had said the monk Rādha was delighted and received it respectfully. 113. [Discourse on Eradicating the Dukkha of Bod- ily Form] Thus have I heard. At one time the Buddha was staying at Mount Makula, with an attendant monk by the name of Rādha.11 Then a group of heterodox wanderers approached the venerable Rādha. Having exchanged polite greetings, they withdrew to sit at one side. They asked the venerable Rādha: "For what sake have you gone forth to cultivate the holy life under the recluse Gotama?" 9 In SN 23.4 at SN III 191,10 the Buddha broaches the topic himself, without being prompted by an inquiry by Rādha.