DOCSLIB.ORG

Donald Dinnie: Scotland's Jim Thorpe - 2010-08-27 14:31:34 by JWCIII - USAWA

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Donald Dinnie: Scotland's Jim Thorpe - 2010-08-27 14:31:34 by JWCIII - USAWA Donald Dinnie: Scotland's Jim Thorpe - 2010-08-27 14:31:34 by JWCIII - USAWA - http://www.usawa.com Donald Dinnie: Scotland's Jim Thorpe by JWCIII - 2010-08-27 14:31:34 http://www.usawa.com/donald-dinnie-scotlands-jim-thorpe/ by Thom Van Vleck In 2006 I visited Scotland and while there made a visit to the "Dinnie Stones" to take a crack at lifting them. The stones have a become part of the legend of Donald Dinnie. A legend that is long and complicated and not unlike the American sports legend, Jim Thorpe. Both men seemed gifted to do just about anything they wanted to athletically. They were strong, fast, and agile and could seemingly adapt to any sport in a quick manner. In other words, they were ATHLETES! Dinnie was born at Balnacraig, Birse, near Aboyne, Aberdeenshire in Scotland in 1837. He competed in over 11,000 athletic competitions in a 50 year span. Thorpe was born near Prague, Oklahoma in 1888 very near where my father was born and he and I share a birthday of May 28th and Thorpe likely competed in 1000's of different athletic events in a career that lasted over two decades. A strict comparison of these two athletes would be difficult. I do know that Jim Thorpe and Donald Dinnie both threw many of the same implements, such as the 56lb Weight for Distance, the hammer, the shot, the javelin, and ran in many of the same types of distance events. But in many ways it's like comparing Muhammed Ali with Joe Louis....they weren't at their best at the same time. page 1 / 2 Donald Dinnie: Scotland's Jim Thorpe - 2010-08-27 14:31:34 by JWCIII - USAWA - http://www.usawa.com I like Dinnie because he's a legendary figure, but was a real man that may have actually been able to live up to that legend. Fittingly, he was born the son of a stone mason. He won his first event when he was 16 and beat a strongman in a wrestling meet and won 1 pound sterling. He had a reign as Scottish Champion from 1856 to 1876 and when his best track and field performances are compared with the 1896 Athens Olympics (the first modern Olympics) he could possibly have won 7 Gold medals, a Silver, and a Bronze. This would have indeed put him in a class with Thorpe! Thorpe had a lengthy list of amazing wins and feats in basketball, football, track & field and baseball. Dinnie won over 2000 hammer throwing contests, over 2000 wrestling matches, 200 weightlifting meets, and some 500 running and hurdling events. I read that in 40 years he was undefeated in the caber toss in 1000's of contests. Another area they have in common is their images endure today and sell products! Dinnie, while still alive, endorsed a soft drink in the United Kingdom called Iron Brew or today is know as Iron Bru. His image is still regularly seen as is Thorpe's. Dinnie, like Thorpe, did barnstorming to earn money while displaying his athletic prowess. Dinnie first toured the United States in 1897 and earned a small fortune doing it and was still touring New Zealand and Australia at age 60....and winning! William Wallace is a legendary patriot, maybe the greatest patriot, of Scotland and when a statue was done of him, they used Dinnie as the body model as he was considered the perfect man. Thorpe was studied extensively by Doctors at one point who were trying to figure out just why he was such a great athlete. Finally, these two great athletes share a similar end. During their day, they were often hates as much as they were loved. Other athletes hated them because they often made them look bad and took all the prize money. Thorpe earned a fortune in his lifetime but died broke. Dinnie, it is said, earned what would be equal to 2.5 million dollars in today's money, but also had to rely on charity at the end of his life. I don't think this takes away from the luster of their careers, indeed, to me it only adds to it. These men lived big and stayed that way. I read of a famous person who was suffering from Parkinson's and was still working as hard as ever. A reporter asked them, "Shouldn't you rest more in your condition"? The man looked at her and said, "Rest for what.....so I can die well rested". I think these men lived with that same sentiment, and I can respect that. page 2 / 2.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Dinnie Steens Or the Stones of Dee
    The Dinnie Steens or the Stones of Dee “…and took our second rest close to the Bridge of Potarch where we had tea at the little hotel on the right bank of the river‖ 1 It is a strange thought that the celebrated author of the cult “Dracula” novel had like so many others, visited that iconic bridge of Potarch and one can only assume that when Bram Stoker visited in the 1890’s he may well have been told the story of those two massive immovable stones. Unlike Stoker, many others have visited to view these stones as a pilgrimage of strength that has no equal. What can be written about the Dinnie Stones, the most notorious and indeed best known lifting stones in the world of strength? The stones mean so much too so many and their iconic status is reflective of their popularity amongst all strength disciplines. Whereas many who visit Scotland to tour and test their mettle with other known stones of strength; there are many who are simply satisfied in attempting the Dinnie Stones and adding their individual name to the short list of those who have been fortunate enough to have achieved an accepted “Dinne Lift”. The Dinnie Steens with the singular authority on the stones - Mr David P Webster OBE The stones have invoked argument, discussion and emotion with regards to what is and to what is not acceptable and much rhetoric has been written regarding previous known lifts, 1 Page 138 Mystery of the Sea. Bram Stoker (1902) comparisons and judgements have abounded and quite simply a book on its own could in fact be drawn over the attempts on these stones.
    [Show full text]
  • History of the Skye Games
    The Isle of Skye Highland Games History of the Skye Games By ROGER HUTCHINSON The first ever Skye Games were held on the dry, bright Thursday of 6 September 1877. A weather pattern was established on this auspicious day, which would continue (with one or two rule-proving exceptions!) for over a century, on the Wednesday before the Games it rained incessantly, but the day of the Games dawned clear and bright, and perfect sunshine illuminated the spectacle from dawn to dusk. The Skye Games were established by the great and good of the island in this heyday of high Victorian confidence. For many years the Skye Gathering Ball in Portree had been an essential part of the Highland country house itinerary, a couple of sleepless nights of reels and kilts and sparkling gowns, enjoyed by those who retired afterwards to the lodges and stately homes of Skye: those same buildings which now, in their later incarnation as hotels, still bed and board the visitors to the Gathering and the Games. In the summer of 1877 a meeting took place of elevated persons. Lord Macdonald of the Isles and MacLeod of MacLeod buried past differences; Captain Macdonald of Waternish, Mr Macdonald of Skeabost, Mr Robertson of Greshornish, Mr Lachlan MacKinnon of Duisdale, Mr Stewart of Duntulm, Mr MacDonald of Tormore, and brothers Alexander Macdonald and Harry Macdonald, both of Portree, all assembled and formed a committee with the expressed purpose of giving Skye an annual Highland Games to match those of Inverness and Oban. Of this assembly, it was Harry Macdonald of Viewfield in Portree whose family would become most associated with the Games.
    [Show full text]
  • The Amazing Donald Dinnie: the Nineteenth Century’S Greatest Athlete Frank Zarnowski
    MAY 1998 IRON GAME HISTORY The Amazing Donald Dinnie: The Nineteenth Century’s Greatest Athlete Frank Zarnowski Ed Note: Special thanks are due David Webster for permission to reprint several images from his classic text, Scottish Highland Games. Watch for Webster’s response to this article in a future issue. the English speaking world creating a sensation wher- Donald Dinnie’s comin’ here, ever he appeared. There seems to be no lack of local Donald Dinnie’s comin’ here, newspaper accounts of his visits. After competing at all Spread the news baith far and near, the important Highland gatherings in Scotland and Eng- That Donald Dinnie’s comin’ here.1 land, Dinnie tramped the world displaying his strength and versatility. He started at Caledonian Games, which When Donald Dinnie initially toured the U.S. featured events native to Scotland, but just as frequently Caledonian circuit in 1870 he created a sensation and he wrestled in tournaments or simply gave dumbell-lift- earned a small fortune. At thirty-three, Dinnie was already ing (and later Highland dancing) demonstrations at dance acknowledged as Scotland’s greatest athlete, having com- halls. He toured Canada and the U.S.A. on three occa- peted for sixteen Highland Games seasons in his native sions, then steamed off to Australia and New Zealand in land. Such was his reputation for feats of strength and the 1880s, and later touted South Africa. At one stretch versatility that American Caledonian clubs amended their he was away for sixteen years, returning to Scotland in calendars and paid heavy appearance fees to Dinnie to 1898 at age sixty-one.
    [Show full text]
  • List of Photographs Held by Aberdeen City and Aberdeenshire Archives Photographs
    LIST OF PHOTOGRAPHS HELD BY ABERDEEN CITY AND ABERDEENSHIRE ARCHIVES PHOTOGRAPHS The collection consists mainly of photographs taken by the Photographers of the Technical Services Unit (now Publicity and Promotions Division) of Aberdeen District Council, largely between the years of 1950 and 1985 with copies of earlier photographs included. The collection has been kept in its original order which was alphabetically in subjects but a new numbering scheme has been adopted within this order. Negatives are extant for some of the photos and a list is available in hard copy format in the Search Room. PPD/1/ 1/ Aberdeen: Airport 1-12 General views of aircraft and airport buildings at Aberdeen Airport. Not dated. [1960-1970]. (12 photographs - 3 in colour). 2/ Aberdeen Council 1 Aberdeen Councillors in Old Council Chamber. Not dated. [1976]. (4 photographs). 2 New Council Chamber in Town House. 1977. (1 photograph). 3 New Council Chamber with councillors in their seats. Includes press cutting for its opening. 1977. (1 photograph). 4 District Council employee Mr Ronnie Hall retires. Includes press cutting. 1976. (1 photograph). 5 Welfare Benefits Officer interviewing public outside Langstane Kirk. 1985. (1 photograph). 6 Councillor Fraser. 1982. (2 photographs). 7 Council dance. Not dated. [1960-1970] . (1 photograph). 8 Lord Provost Fraser. 1982. (1 photograph) OUTSIZED. 9 Lord Provost Smith. Not dated. [1971-1975]. (1 photograph) OUTSIZED. www.aberdeencity.gov.uk/archives - 1 - PPD/1/2/ Aberdeen Council (con’t) 10 Lord Provost Lennox's Presentation Book showing events and exhibitions attended by him. Not dated. [1960-1970]. (1 volume). 11 Councillors in Town and County Hall.
    [Show full text]
  • The Old Vale and Its Memories
    The Old Vale & Its Memories The Old Vale and its Memories 1 The Old Vale & Its Memories Reproduced from Original Drawing by Duncan Ferguson 2 The Old Vale & Its Memories 3 The Old Vale & Its Memories 4 The Old Vale & Its Memories FOREWORD IN submitting these incidents, events and reminiscences of the Vale, No attempt has been made to give them in anything like consecutive order. Merely in haphazard way are they compiled: the one desire is that they may yield a pleasant hour. With the compliments of James Ferguson and J. G. Temple. September 3rd, 1927 QUEEN VICTORIA AND PRINCE ALBERT WITH PRINCESS ROYAL AND PRINCE OF WALES (AFTERWARDS KING EDWARD VII) LANDING AT DUMBARTON CASTLE, MONDAY, 16TH AUGUST, 1847 5 The Old Vale & Its Memories TO THE MEMORY OF DUNCAN FERGUSON AND HIS CLOSE FRIEND AND COLLEAGUE JAMES GRAHAM TEMPLE “When to the sessions of sweet, silent thought I summon up remembrance of things past, I sigh the lack of many a thing I sought, • • • • • • • • • —But if the while I think on thee, dear friend, All losses are restored, and sorrows end,” —From Shakespeare’s Sonnet on “Memory” 6 The Old Vale & Its Memories THE VALE OF LEVEN FROM DUMBARTON CASTLE From the painting by Alexander Jamieson in the collection of James Ferguson, London 7 The Old Vale & Its Memories The Old Vale and its Memories THE OLD VALE! When one hears or reads these words, he naturally associates them with the Old Vale of Leven Football Team, quite forgetful of the fact that they also include the men and boys who lined the ropes—ay, and the women-folks who were ever eager to hear the results and stirring details of the play.
    [Show full text]
  • How to Become a Weight Thrower
    FOR OUR CUSTOMERS. HIS ORDER BlA IS FOR YOUR CONVENI£NCE. YOU PURCHASED THIS BOOK AT We also sell a complete line of Spalding Athletic Goods as well as all the books of the Spalding Athletic Library. :ONSULT THE FULL LIST FOR OTHER BOOKS ON ATHLETICS When ordering Athletic Goods use this sheet. Simply tear it out along dotted line, fill in your wants on the reverse side. and mail it with the price as noted. ~EE THE OTHER SIDE Gentlemen: Enclosed please find $ - for which send me the articles listed below: N;'::~er rQuantity Description of Article ----- - - -- - -------1----=1 - 1 _ I - ---~ ------ ~------ I SPALDING ATHLETIC LIBRARY SPALDING OFFICIAL .ANNUALS No. I. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL BASE BALL GUIDE••• Price lOe. No, 2. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL FOOT BALL GUIDE. ••• Price lOe. No, 6. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL ICE HOCKEY GUIDE. •• Price lOe. No.7. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL BASKET BALL GUIDE. • Price lOe. No.7A. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL WOMEN'S BASKET BALL GUIDE. Price lOe. No.9. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL INDOOR BASE BALL GUIDE. • Price lOe. No. 12A. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL ATHLETIC RULES•• Price lOe. No. IR. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL ATHLETIC ALMANAC. •• Price 25c. No.3R. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL GOLF GUIDE. •••• Price 25c. No. 55R, SPALDING'S OFFICIAL SOCCER fOOT BALL GUIDE. • Price 25c. No. 57R. SPALDING'S LAWN TENNIS ANNUAL. ••••• Price 25c. No. 59R. SPALDING'S OFFICIAL BASE BALL RECORD•••• Price 25c. Speclall,. Bouud Series ot Athletic Handbooks Flexible bInding. Mailed post[lald on receipt of 50 cents ellch nUDlber. No.50IL. 8TROIiES AND SCIENCE OF LAWN TENNIS No. 5021... HOW TO I'I.AY GOI.F No.Mal •• HOW TO I.'I.AY JfOOT BALL No.504L.
    [Show full text]
  • Donald Dinnie
    The ‘Scottish Play’ with which we are all familiar, is in fact a total reversal of the truth, written to please James VI who had recently become James I of a new United Kingdom. Shakespeare appealed to James’ obsession with witchcraft and the supernatural, weaving a romantic origin for the Stuarts in A knight wears plate armour, chainmail and a Banquo whom the witches prophesy ‘Thou wilt get kings, though thou be helmet; the classic image we all associate none.’ The play proved one of the most popular of Shakespeare’s ‘histories’ with medieval warfare, yet this particular despite it being mostly pro-Stuart fiction. So why did the Bard get it so representation is featured on a grave slab in wrong? His main historical source, Raphael Holinshed, was relying on the ruins of Kinkell Church by the Ury’s misleading accounts of Macbeth written over centuries as Celtic Alba evolved banks. This was Gilbert de Greenlaw as he into Anglo-Norman Scotland. The real tragedy is that these accounts were was in life, riding into battle at Harlaw in 1411 written by Scottish chroniclers from a time when the Stuart dynasty was in never to return home alive. He was a the ascendancy. cavalryman fighting for the Earl of Mar, the same Alexander Stewart who in the previous Three centuries after Macbeth’s reign, John of Fordun’s Scotichronicon decade had seized his title by forced marriage describes Duncan’s death in battle as murder and invents the character of to Countess Isabel Douglas. Mar was now a Macduff as a former friend of Macbeth.
    [Show full text]
  • A Historic Annual Meeting!
    Recieve The Gazette in Email Form, for this quarter’s features section on Highland Athletics ISSUE 11 / SPRING ’11 Bill Parsons, Editor 6504 Shadewater Drive Hilliard, OH 43026 513-476-1112 [email protected] THE NEWSLETTER OF THE CALEDONIAN SOCIETY OF CINCINNATI In This Issue: Women In @ AGM 1,4 A HISTORIC ANNUAL MEETING! Burns Night Recap/Pix 2,19* Scholarship.Report 2 he President opened the meeting *Schedule of Events 2 asking if ‘Proper Notice’ had *President’s Letter 3 Tbeen sent, Robert confirmed it. CSHD 3 Ted presented the treasurer’s report. He provided comparison data Cinti Highld Dancers 3 for the past several years. Mr. Clipson Gazette N’Email Form 4 asked when money or donations are *Resource List 4 received where is it allocated? All Payback /Westminster 5 monies are directed to the funds for Why an Email Gazette 6 which the monies are received, should money arrive without any direction *Email PDF Issue only 7-21* it is placed in the General Fund. A conduct such as to make a desirable The General Annual Highland Ath. 7-12 total of $2,000 has recommend by the member.” Meeting was a crowded Q&A High Ath. 13-17* board CCP&D-$1000, HDance-$300, Proposed Text: “To be eligible event. Both members and guests were High. Ath. Resources 18* OVSS-$300, GMG-$250, KSW-$150. to membership in the Society, Robert announced the new members, a candidate must be a native of in attendance at as Out of the Sporran 20-21* historic amendments they were: Ewen Cameron and Stephen Scotland, or of Scottish descent.
    [Show full text]
  • AAA Club Newsletter No. 20, November 1967
    JOHN SHERWOOD (Birchfleld Harriers/Loughborough College A.C.) ISSUE No. 20 NOVEMBER, 1967 Olympic record holder ‘Ovaltine’ is the only food drink which What makes ‘Ovaltine’ the cho­ has been officially recognized for serv­ sen drink of champions ? Only ing to competitors at every Olympic ‘Ovaltine’ gives you all the good­ Games since 1932—and at every ness of barley malt, milk, eggs British Empire Games since they and added vitamins. No other began. During the 1964 Olympics over drink can match the way 'Ovaltine' 500,000 cups of ‘Ovaltine’ were served helps to build up energy, strength to athletes and officials—more than at and stamina. So j oin thechampions any other Olympic Games. in a regular cup of ‘Ovaltine’. OVALTINE the drink of champions Photographs were supplied by Mark Shearman, 23, Lynwood Drive, Worcester Park, Surrey. Anabolic Steroids Dr. I. G. P. WILLIAMS HE sporting press, both the daily and weekend newspapers and the technical T journals, during the past few months have carried articles and reports about the use of drugs called Anabolic Steroids for the promotion of strength and physique in various types of athletes, particularly those involved in the power events. In track and field athletics the use of these drugs seems to have been particularly prevalent among shot putters, discus throwers and track athletes. A number of particularly outstanding examples have been reported, including those of Randy Matsun and Parry O’Brien and the two great American decathletes. Interest in the use of Anabolic Steroids for the preparation of field event athletes for competition was particularly stimulated last year when field events men and coaches from various countries met and discussed their methods at the European and at the Commonwealth Games.
    [Show full text]
  • James Morrison, Partick Police. Double World Record Holder
    James Morrison, Partick Police. Double World Record Holder, and “a fit successor to . Donald Dinnie” On Saturday 15 June 1901, Jim Morrison earned himself the title of World Record Holder for the 16lb Hammer Throw when he defeated the old record by 1ft 6½ins in front of a crowd of 5,000 at the Vale of Leven Highland Games; he threw 120ft 7ins. Thirteen days later at the Drumblair Highland Games he set another World Record, this time for Throwing the 56lb Weight by Ring, 7ins further than the previous record, and in doing so defeated the holder (George Hardy Johnstone) into 2nd place; Morrison’s new World Record was 29ft 8ins. Prior to Morrison’s success Johnstone had also been the World Record holder in the Hammer. During the 1900-1901 seasons Jim Morrison was described as “undoubtedly, Heavy-Weight Champion of Scotland”, indeed he had been awarded the silver belt for the Championship of Scotland in 1901. By 1906 he had won over 200 prizes for Caber Tossing alone, and was also a highly successful Hammer thrower and wrestler. His athletic career spanned nineteen years, in fourteen of which he was one of the finest Heavy Athletes in Scotland, and, indeed, the world, and 1905 he was described as “a fit successor to . Donald Dinnie.” There can be no greater praise for any heavy athlete, nor indeed, for any athlete in any event, at any time. And yet, Jim Morrison’s athletic story is not well known, partly because William McCombie Smith’s The Athletes and Athletic Sports of Scotland was written in 1891, before Jim Morrison came on the scene, and even in 1901, when Charles Donaldson, wrote Men of Muscle, Jim Morrison’s best years still lay ahead of him.
    [Show full text]
  • Études Écossaises, 19 | 2017, « Scotland and the Sea » [En Ligne], Mis En Ligne Le 01 Avril 2017, Consulté Le 23 Septembre 2020
    Études écossaises 19 | 2017 Scotland and the Sea L’Écosse et la mer Cyril Besson (dir.) Édition électronique URL : http://journals.openedition.org/etudesecossaises/1151 DOI : 10.4000/etudesecossaises.1151 ISSN : 1969-6337 Éditeur UGA Éditions/Université Grenoble Alpes Édition imprimée ISBN : 978-2-37747-001-3 ISSN : 1240-1439 Référence électronique Cyril Besson (dir.), Études écossaises, 19 | 2017, « Scotland and the Sea » [En ligne], mis en ligne le 01 avril 2017, consulté le 23 septembre 2020. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/etudesecossaises/ 1151 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/etudesecossaises.1151 Ce document a été généré automatiquement le 23 septembre 2020. © Études écossaises 1 Si une grande part de l’identité, de la culture et de la politique écossaises sont informées par la relation qu’entretient l’Écosse avec l’Angleterre, cette polarisation a résulté de leur proximité géographique immédiate, les deux nations partageant une frontière terrestre au sein d’un même territoire. Par conséquent, on trouve, à la base de cette relation comme de bien d’autres domaines en ce qui concerne l’Écosse, la nature maritime d’un territoire partout ailleurs entouré d’eau. Bien sûr, l’insularité de la Grande-Bretagne, qui entraîne en quelque sorte une « péninsularité » de l’Écosse, ne devrait pas être envisagée de manière négative, dans la mesure où elle a permis un tissage de connections multiples, à une époque où la mer offrait un moyen privilégié d’établir des échanges culturels, diplomatiques et commerciaux. Qu’il s’agisse des marchands de tabac de Glasgow avec les États-Unis, des administrateurs écossais aux Indes, ou des brigades écossaises en Suède au cours de la guerre de Trente Ans, tous dépendaient de la mer pour faire avancer leurs projets personnels, qui participaient au rayonnement et au renforcement de l’influence de l’Écosse.
    [Show full text]
  • Cars Removed to Restore Upper Dee Banks 31 Old Vehicles Have Been Excavated from Dee River Bank Upstream of Braemar
    CatchUpDee Catchment Partnership news Autumn 2015 Cars removed to restore upper Dee banks 31 old vehicles have been excavated from Dee river bank upstream of Braemar Thirty one old cars, tonnes of gravels that are home to many concrete, boulders and railway species, including salmon and sleepers have been removed freshwater pearl mussel. from the banks of the Dee. With The new bank, rebuilt using its corrugated iron facing, this natural materials, is lower 60m structure was damaging and has a gently sloping face, the river and was an eyesore which will alllow the area to on the otherwise unspoiled flood more often. This will landscape, clearly visible from The ‘car bank’ was an eyesore and benefit natural floodplain pollution risk. the Linn of Dee road. habitats, which need to be The ‘car bank’ was built to wetted regularly. On the day repair the embankments that the works finished high between Mar Lodge Estate and flows nearly overtopped the Braemar that were built in the embankment and we look 1700s to protect deer calving forward to seeing this happen grounds from flooding. In 1937 more often in future. a flood broke through the Many of our partners worked embankment and this breach The vehicles were in remarkably good together to remove the waste: remained open for 50 years. condition. Aberdeenshire Council, the In 1984, the gap was filled with Cairngorms National Park the cars, as well as spruce trees, Authority, the James Hutton railway sleepers, fencing wire, Institute, the Dee District large quantities of concrete, Salmon Fishery Board, River and boulders.
    [Show full text]