Legally Binding Separation Agreements and Private Ordering in Family Law in Scotland

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Legally Binding Separation Agreements and Private Ordering in Family Law in Scotland Edinburgh Research Explorer All Settled? Legally binding separation agreements and private ordering in family law in Scotland. Citation for published version: Mair, J, Wasoff, F & Mackay, K 2013, All Settled? Legally binding separation agreements and private ordering in family law in Scotland. CRFR, Edinburgh. <http://www.crfr.ac.uk/projects/current-projects/all- settled-a-study-of-legally-binding-separation-agreements-in-scotland/> Link: Link to publication record in Edinburgh Research Explorer Document Version: Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Publisher Rights Statement: © Mair, J., Wasoff, F., & Mackay, K. (2013). All Settled? Legally binding separation agreements and private ordering in family law in Scotland.Edinburgh: CRFR. General rights Copyright for the publications made accessible via the Edinburgh Research Explorer is retained by the author(s) and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy The University of Edinburgh has made every reasonable effort to ensure that Edinburgh Research Explorer content complies with UK legislation. If you believe that the public display of this file breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 04. Oct. 2021 All Settled? A study of legally binding separation agreements and private ordering in Scotland Final Report Dr Jane Mair Dr Kirsteen Mackay 1 2 Contents Acknowledgements List of tables Summary Chapter 1: Background to the study: research, social and policy context Background to the study: changing law and legal practice The social context Aims and objectives of the study Research questions Research methods Chapter 2: The law relating to minutes of agreement Marriage contracts Clear statutory framework Registration Limited challenge Concluding comments Chapter 3: A profile of minutes of agreement: their content, extent and the parties who make them The number of agreements What type of agreements? Who makes agreements? In-depth interviews Property The family home 3 Pensions Capital sum or consideration Spousal support and periodical allowance Children The legal process Chapter 4: Property: the family home The legal context Owner occupation Who stays who goes: the status quo The initial arrangements Agreements about the home Occupancy rights The place of third parties Consideration and capital sums Tenants: the missing dimension? Chapter 5: Property: pensions and their redistribution Pensions in the earlier study The visibility of pensions in 2010 agreements Reasons that pensions are shared (or not) Trade-offs Trade-off risk Equal pensions Relationship objectives Chapter 6: Property and ongoing support: other assets and debts: periodical allowance Statutory context Other assets 4 Debts Periodical allowance Equal sharing Chapter 7: Children: residence, contact and child maintenance Legal framework: residence and contact Legal framework: child maintenance The number and ages of children in the data set Relationship type and children Residence Contact Parties’ perspectives on fixed contact times Child maintenance Durability of private agreements on child maintenance Amount of child maintenance and how it was calculated Termination of maintenance payments for children A note on adult dependants Chapter conclusion Chapter 8: Parties’ perspectives on their minute of agreement When parties seek legal advice Separate legal advice Nature of the advice received Parties’ assessments of ADR Role of lawyers in reaching agreement Cost of legal advice Sticking to the agreement Life after agreement Satisfaction with the agreement Concluding thoughts 5 Chapter 9: Solicitors’ perspectives on minutes of agreement Reaching agreement with and without the use of courts Bargaining in the shadow of the law Explaining the law The matrimonial property pot Fair share of matrimonial property: ss9(1)(a) and 10(1) Economic advantage and disadvantage: s9(1)(b) Cost of caring for the children: s9(1)(c) Post divorce hardship: s9(1)(d) & 9(1)(e) Durability of agreements Solicitors’ perspectives on alternative dispute resolution (ADR) Benefits of ADR Chapter 10: All settled? A clean break? Fair and equal In the shadow of the law All settled? Appendix 1: Research methodology Appendix 2: Data collection sheet Appendix 3: Interview Questions for parties Appendix 4: Interview Questions for solicitors Appendix 5: Checklist Appendix 6: Sample minutes of agreement (separation) Appendix 7: Sample ante-nuptial agreement Appendix 8: Information leaflet 6 Acknowledgements The authors wish to acknowledge the support they received in producing this work from: The Economic and Social Research Council which funded the research; Jane Brown and her colleagues at the National Records of Scotland for their generous help with data collection; The Family Law Association of Scotland for their help with publicising the research and the family law solicitors who agreed to be interviewed and who shared their experience of minutes of agreement; The men and women who were interviewed for this study to whom thanks are given for telling us about a difficult period in their lives. 7 List of tables Table 3.1. Types of property mentioned in minutes of agreement Table 3.2 Standard clauses used in minutes of agreement Table 4.1 Residence in the family home at time of agreement Table 4.2. Agreements made about the family home Table 4.3 Method of payment Table 5.1 Percentage of agreements that mention pensions and discharge claims to them by length of relationship Table 6.1 Division of furniture and plenishings Table 6.2 Other significant assets Figure 7:1: Whether residence is mentioned by age of youngest child at time of Registration Table 7:2: Who the child lives with by age of youngest child at time of registration Table 7:3 Whether child support agreed by age of youngest child at time of registration 8 Chapter 1 Background to the study: research, social and policy context Background to the study: changing law and legal practice In Scotland, as in other jurisdictions, the great majority of families organise the aftermath of separation, without recourse to the courts, through a process of private ordering typically supported by legal and other professionals. This report presents the findings of a research study of private ordering in one family justice system, and its outcomes in the form of minutes of agreement (MoA). Scots family law seeks to encourage parties to negotiate and reach agreement on ancillary matters, in the context of the breakdown of adult intimate relationships, without recourse to the courts. The objective of reaching private agreement has been promoted as a means of lessening conflict, encouraging settlements, which accommodate and reflect the diversity of families and the needs of individuals, and contributing to the reduction of pressure on the civil court system and associated public funding. Changes in both family law and practice are likely to have influenced the extent to which individuals choose to conclude private ordering with a MoA rather than to pursue judicial action. However, there has been only limited research evidence to date upon which to assess and analyse the extent to which such individual agreements and the actions of the parties are influenced or informed by the legal provisions and practice, that is, how much these agreements are made “in the shadow of the law”.1 In Scotland, if consensus results from the private negotiations of the parties, it is likely to be recorded in a formal written agreement, known as a minute of agreement, which will usually be registered for preservation and execution in the Books of Council and Session. Such agreements are documents of public record and are stored centrally in the National Records of Scotland, and they are legally enforceable. Earlier research into the substance and outcomes of such minutes of agreement was conducted by Wasoff, McGuckin and Edwards in the mid-1990s2 but since then there have been a number of significant changes which are likely to have had an impact on the nature, scale and outcomes of private ordering on separation. 1 Mnookin and Kornhauser, “Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: The Case of Divorce” (1979) 88(5) Yale Law Journal 950. 2 Wasoff, McGuckin and Edwards, Mutual Consent: Written Agreements in Family Law, 1997. 9 The use of MoA in Scotland, in the context of the breakdown of family relationships, is set against the background of the Family Law (Scotland) Act 1985. Section 9 of that Act sets out a clear and detailed framework of principles by which financial provision on divorce can be justified, and in terms of which the courts can make orders for the division of property and financial provision. It is thought that making “the rules of the game” clear in this way, and reducing judicial discretion, will encourage parties to reach agreement without recourse to the courts, as this case note comments: “The 1985 Act has been successful mainly because awards are fairly predictable so that couples can settle their claims without litigation.”3 While the courts retain power under section 16 of the 1985 Act to vary or set aside terms of a MoA, they may only do so in certain limited circumstances and this also encourages the use of private agreements. The agreements studied in the earlier research 4 were made in 1992 and although the section 9 principles for financial provision on divorce were in force at that time they were relatively new. Since then there have been many judicial decisions concerning the principles and family lawyers are now very experienced in their operation. It was anticipated that this would lead to an increase in the use of MoA and may also have influenced their content. In recent years there have been other statutory reforms, which are likely to have increased the use of and influenced the nature of MoA.
Recommended publications
  • SCOTLAND Prof. Jane Mair School of Law, University of Glasgow Scotland August 2008
    NATIONAL REPORT: SCOTLAND Prof. Jane Mair School of Law, University of Glasgow Scotland August 2008 A. General Questions 1-7 p. B. General rights and duties of Questions 8-14 p. spouses concerning household expenses, transactions with respect to the matrimonial home and other matters irrespective of the single matrimonial property regime C. Matrimonial property regimes C.1. General issues Questions 15-19 p. C.2. Specific regimes I. Community of property Questions 20-56 Not relevant II.Community of accrued Questions 57-90 Not relevant gains/Participation in acquisitions III. Deferred community Questions 91-128 Not relevant IV. Separation of property Questions 129-160 Not relevant V. Separation of property with Questions 161-190 p. distribution by the competent authority D. Marital agreements Questions 191-201 p. Property relationship between spouses - SCOTLAND NATIONAL REPORT: SCOTLAND Prof. Jane Mair School of Law, University of Glasgow Scotland August 2008 A. GENERAL 1. Are there special rules concerning the property relationship between spouses (explaining what is meant by spouses)? If so, briefly indicate the current sources of these rules. a. upon marriage Scots law has a system of separate property during marriage and consequently marriage in itself has no effect on the property of the spouses. This general principle is currently set out in S. 24 of the Scots Family Law Act 1985 which provides that marriage in itself does not affect the property of either spouse. In general, the approach of Scots law is to treat husband and wife as ‘strangers’ 1 in terms of their property, focusing on their property rights rather than on their matrimonial relationship.
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical Evaluation of the Rights, Status and Capacity of Distinct Categories of Individuals in Underdeveloped and Emerging Areas of Law
    A Critical Evaluation of the Rights, Status and Capacity of Distinct Categories of Individuals in Underdeveloped and Emerging Areas of Law Lesley-Anne Barnes Macfarlane LLB (Hons), Dip LP, PGCE, LLM A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of Edinburgh Napier University, for the award of Doctor of Philosophy May 2014 1 Acknowledgements I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my supervisors, Dr Richard Whitecross and Dr Sandra Watson, for giving me their time, guidance and assistance in the writing up of my PhD Critical Appraisal of published works. I am indebted to my parents, Irene and Dennis, for a lifetime of love and support. Many thanks are also due to my family and friends for their ongoing care and companionship. In particular, I am very grateful to Professors Elaine E Sutherland and John P Grant for reading through and commenting on my section on Traditional Legal Research Methods. My deepest thanks are owed to my husband, Ross, who never fails in his love, encouragement and practical kindness. I confirm that the published work submitted has not been submitted for another award. ………………………………………… Lesley-Anne Barnes Macfarlane Citations and references have been drafted with reference to the University’s Research Degree Reference Guide 2 CONTENTS VOLUME I Abstract: PhD by Published Works Page 8 List of Evidence in Support of Thesis Page 9 Thesis Introduction Page 10 (I) An Era of Change in the Individual’s Rights, Status and Capacity in Scots Law (II) Conceptual Framework of Critical Analysis: Rights,
    [Show full text]
  • '… and for 39 Years I Got on with It.'
    OLDER WOMEN AND DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN SCOTLAND ‘… and for 39 years I got on with it.’ 2021 3/2004 2021 Prepared for Health Scotland by the Centre for Research on Families and Relationships. Published by Health Scotland, Woodburn House, Canaan Lane, Edinburgh EH10 4SG. ISBN: 1-84485-111-7 © Centre for Research on Families and Relationships and NHS Health Scotland, 2004. The views expressed in this report do not necessarily represent those of Health Scotland. Authors: Marsha Scott, Linda McKie, Sarah Morton, Elizabeth Seddon Fran Wasoff. Design: Clear Design Scotland Limited. Photography: Angus Bremner. All photographs use models. CONTENTS SUMMARY 3 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 The issues 4 1.2 The questions 4 1.3 The data 6 1.4 The analysis and key themes 6 2. DATA ON PREVALENCE AND DATA SOURCES 2.1 Sources of statistical information 8 2.2 Statistics on domestic violence from the Scottish Crime Survey 10 2.3 Homelessness statistics and domestic violence 10 2.4 Scottish Women’s Aid statistics 11 3. WHAT THE LITERATURE SAYS: A THEMATIC SUMMARY 3.1 Looking at the literature 12 3.2 Sexism, ageism, elder abuse and domestic violence – framing the issues 12 3.3 Age and/or life stage in definitions of the older woman experiencing domestic violence 15 3.3.1 Attitudes 16 3.3.2 Dependency 17 3.3.3 Prolonged trauma 18 3.4 Prevalence 19 3.4.1 Visible incidence 19 3.4.2 Regional figures 20 3.4.3 Same-sex relationships 21 3.5 Service and programme models 21 3.6 Policy 24 3.7 Information from the web 25 4.
    [Show full text]
  • The Future Impact and Effect of Brexit on Scots Law and the Scottish Legal System
    The Law Society of Scotland The Future Impact and Effect of Brexit on Scots law and the Scottish legal system I Chapter1 The Law Society of Scotland: The future impact and effect of Brexit on Scots law and the Scottish legal system Contents Foreword 1 Executive summary 2 Introduction 4 CHAPTER 1 The development of the Scottish legal system 7 CHAPTER 2 The courts and tribunals in Scotland 12 CHAPTER 3 The United Kingdom’s decision to leave the European Union 18 CHAPTER 4 The consequences of the United Kingdom leaving the European Union 25 CHAPTER 5 The EU impact on Scots Law 40 CHAPTER 6 Common frameworks 59 CHAPTER 7 Teaching EU Law in law schools post-Brexit 67 CHAPTER 8 Conclusions 70 Bibliography 74 III The Law Society of Scotland: The future impact and effect of Brexit on Scots law and the Scottish legal system Chapter IV 1 The Law Society of Scotland: The future impact and effect of Brexit on Scots law and the Scottish legal system Foreword In 2016 the United Kingdom voted to leave the European Union. In the three years since that historic vote there has been much debate on Brexit and the impact it will have throughout the UK and in Europe, however a great deal of uncertainty remains over our departure and future outwith the EU. What we can be certain of is that leaving the EU will We are very grateful to the Legal Education Foundation have a profound effect on Scots Law and on the legal whose funding has allowed us to dedicate the time and profession.
    [Show full text]
  • FAMILY LAW | University of Stirling
    09/28/21 LLBU9FL / LAWU9LF : FAMILY LAW | University of Stirling LLBU9FL / LAWU9LF : FAMILY LAW View Online Professor Elaine E Sutherland 2 items Please note : (2 items) 'Students are required to use the Library Catalogue and Legal Databases to search for books, journal articles and legislation on this reading list. Access to these resources is available via the Library - http://libguides.stir.ac.uk/law' The following items are the main secondary sources that will be used in Family Law (LLBU9FL/LAWU9LF) in spring 2015. However, students should consult Lecture Outline I: Concepts and Child Law and Lecture Outline II: Adult Relationships (both available on Succeed) for the reading associated with each lecture. These documents also refer to statutory material, cases and specific articles in journals. No automatic link is provided to these sources because developing your research skills is one of the learning outcomes of the module. Essential Course Text: Mair, Avizandum Statutes on Scots Family Law 2014-2015 (12th edn Avizandum, Edinburgh 2014) Highly recommended reading: Elaine E Sutherland, Family (LawBasics 3rd edn W. Green, Edinburgh 2014) Other material: Books: Elaine E Sutherland, Child and Family Law (2nd edn W. Green, Edinburgh 2008); 1/4 09/28/21 LLBU9FL / LAWU9LF : FAMILY LAW | University of Stirling Alison Cleland and Elaine E Sutherland, Children's Rights in Scotland (3rd edn W. Green, Edinburgh 2009); P.G.B. McNeil and M. Jack, Adoption of Children in Scotland (4th edn W. Green, Edinburgh 2010); K. McK. Norrie, The Law Relating to Parent and Child in Scotland (3rd edn W. Green, Edinburgh 2013); K.
    [Show full text]
  • Spousal Maintenance in Scots Family Law
    SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN SCOTS FAMILY LAW John M. Fotheringham* I.THE ROLE OF PERIODICAL ALLOWANCE ................................... 602 II.THE MODERN LAW OF FINANCIAL PROVISION IN SCOTLAND .604 A . Section 9(1) ................................................................. 606 B . The R elevant Date ...................................................... 607 C. Quantum ... s9(1)(a) ................................................. 608 D. Quantum ... s9(1)(b) .................................................. 611 E. Quantum ... s9(1)(c) .................................................. 613 F. Quantum ... s9(1)(d) & (e) ........................................ 614 III.CHANGE OF CIRCUMSTANCES - VARIATION ........................... 620 IV .PRIVATE ORDERING ................................................................ 620 V. CHALLENGES TO PRE- OR POST- MARITAL AGREEMENTS BETW EEN SPOUSES ............................................................ 623 VI.STATE FUNDING OF SEPARATED PARTIES ............................... 625 VII.C ON CLU SION ......................................................................... 627 Scots Law is proud of its system of financial provision on divorce. The system put in place by the Family Law (Scotland) Act 1985 has remained in place, minimally amended, since it came into force in September 1986. This has not been the result of Consultant at Flexiaw ltd, Edinburgh, United Kingdom. HOUSTON JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW [Vol. 41:3 legislative inertia but rather the effect of the strength of the statute
    [Show full text]
  • The Law Society of Scotland Examination Guidelines, Syllabus and Reading List
    THE LAW SOCIETY OF SCOTLAND EXAMINATION GUIDELINES, SYLLABUS AND READING LIST CONTENTS Pages GUIDELI NES 3-5 PUBLI C LAW AND THE LEGAL SYSTEM 6-7 CONVEYANCING 8 SCOTS PRIVATE LAW 9-1 0 EVIDENCE 11 SCOTS CRIMINAL LAW 12-1 3 TAXATION 14-1 5 EUROPEAN UN ION LAW 16-17 SCOTS COMMERCIAL LAW 18-1 9 BUSINESS ORGANISATIONS 20-21 *ACCOUNTING 22 * PROCEDURE 23-24 * PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY 25 BOOKS PERMITTED IN EXAM INATI ON HALL 26-27 MARKING SCALE AND DESCRIPTORS 28-33 * These subjects are examined as part of PEAT 1 (the Diploma in Legal Practice course) For a general introduction to the study of law, students might find it helpful to read Learning the Law" by 1 Glanville W illiams (13 h ed. 2006 - Sweet and Maxwell) and "Studying Scots Law" by Hector MacQueen (3rd ed. 2004) (Tottel) While the text books cited on the reading lists are the latest editions there are often case or statutory developments subsequent to the publication of the text. Candidates will be expected to be aware of any such developments. 2 LAW SOCIETY OF SCOTLAND EXAMINATION GUIDELINES Candidates undertaking the Law Society of Scotland examinations as part of their pre-Diploma/pre PEAT training or requalifying procedure have four years from the date of the first exam on which to pass all the Law Society examinations. • References and Sources For general read ing, candidates may find it useful to have to hand a copy of Glanville Williams "Learning the Law" (13th ed, 2006 - Sweet and Maxwell) and Hector MacQueen's "Studying Scots Law" (3rd ed, 2004) published by Tottel.
    [Show full text]
  • ADVOCATE Lewis & Clark Law School
    Fall 2008 TheADVOCATE Lewis & Clark Law School Law School Hosts Federal Judicial Center Conference Featuring Retired Justice Sandra Day O’Connor and Associate Justice Anthony M. Kennedy Inside: Animal Law Moot Court Victories China Study Abroad Program Contents Board of Visitors James Richardson ’76 Features 2008-09 Jordan Schnitzer ’76 Law School Hosts a Professor Thomas Ambrose ’75 J. Mack Shively ’79 John Bates Henry Skade ’77 Gathering of Luminaries . 2 Matthew Bergman ’89 Nancy Tauman ’78 Animal Law Evolves . 6 Bowen Blair Jr.’80 Jeffrey Teitel ’73 A Lawyer’s Journey . .13 Brian Booth Mark Tratos ’79 Keeping Up a Tradition Monte Bricker Professor Michelle Travis of Moot Court Victories . 16 Thomas Brown ’80 Isao Tom Tsuruta ’89 Commencement . 18 Hon. Alexander Bryner Steven Wildish ’85 David Case Michael Williams Honor Roll of Donors . insert Jonathan Cole ’76 Lawrence Wilson ’75 Pioneering Women Lawyers. 26 Bruce Crocker ’76 Russell Winner Learning in China . 29 Jeff Curtis ’86 Tributes to Retiring Faculty . 30 Stephen Doherty ’84 Alumni Board of Directors Luis Dorn ’94 2008-09 Departments Professor Henry Drummonds Thomas Bittner ’89, Vice President Barnes Ellis William Brunner ’53 Law School News . 23 David Ernst ’85 Hon. Ronald Cinniger ’73 Faculty and Staff News . 41 M. Carr Ferguson Adam Cornell ’01 Class Notes . 45 Paul Fortino Gilion Dumas ’92 In Memoriam . 48 Hon. Julie Frantz ’75 Dennis Elliott ’74 Chris Fulmer ’09 Jeannette Fisher-Kouadi ’96 Hon. Susan Graber Adina Flynn ’96 Edwin Harnden Steve Hammond ’01 Christie Helmer ’74 Heather Hippsley ’84 Robert Hirshon Craig Jacobson ’95 Volume 28, Number 1, Fall 2008 The Advocate Steven Hopp ’75 John Kodachi ’92 Matthew Huarte ’93 Krista Koehl ’99 Lewis & Clark Law School James Hubler ’72 Hon.
    [Show full text]
  • Lord Hope at the Family Law Association
    Family Law in the UK Supreme Court Family Law Association Conference, 18 Nov 11 Lord Hope From the point of view of the Scots family law practitioner the UK Supreme Court, where I work, must seem rather remote. Very few Scottish cases find their way to London. Appeals in Children’s Hearings cases cannot go there because the statute tells us that the Court of Session is the court of last resort1. And much of modern Scottish family law has been laid down by statute, following years of detailed work by the Scottish Law Commission. The policy choices that have been made for us are relatively recent, and you might well think that there is no need to look to the other UK jurisdictions for guidance or even for inspiration. You might indeed wonder why I am here at all. I should like to suggest however, with all due modesty as it is many years since I was in active practice here, that there are good reasons for keeping an eye on what is happening in London. There is much about the Scottish system that we can be pleased with. But no system of law can ever be perfect and, as time moves on and life’s patterns change, solutions that seemed right, say, 20 years ago may not seem quite as right as all that today. Also there has been a very significant increase in the number of family cases reaching the Supreme Court in comparison with the number that the House of Lords was dealing with when I first went there in 1996, 15 years ago.
    [Show full text]
  • Religion in Scots Law: Report of an Audit at the University of Glasgow
    1 RELIGION IN SCOTS LAW: THE REPORT OF AN AUDIT AT THE UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW Sponsored by Humanist Society Scotland Written by Callum G Brown, Thomas Green and Jane Mair Published by Humanist Society Scotland Edinburgh 2016 2 This Report has been written by Callum G Brown, Thomas Green and Jane Mair. Commissioned by Humanist Society Scotland, it is published in the public domain for general consultation and reference. It may be freely copied, distributed and quoted on condition that its authorship and sponsoring organisation are acknowledged, that the DOI is cited, and that citation uses the format given below. In the case of any queries, these should be directed to either Callum Brown on [email protected] or Jane Mair on [email protected]. Format for citation: Callum G Brown, Thomas Green and Jane Mair, Religion in Scots Law: The Report of an Audit at the University of Glasgow: Sponsored by Humanist Society Scotland (Edinburgh, HSS, 2016) 3 CONTENTS Humanist Society Scotland: Chief Executive’s Preface 11 About Humanist Society Scotland 12 Author’s Preface 13 About the authors 15 PART I: The context 16 Chapter 1: Introduction 17 1.1 Where might we find religion in law? 17 1.2 The Scottish background: the historical origins of religion in 19 Scots law 1.3 The impact of secularisation 22 1.4 What this project has done 24 1.5 The structure of this report 25 PART II: Three case studies 28 Chapter 2: The Church of Scotland 29 2.1 How do we identify an Established Church in Scotland? 30 2.1.1 The nature of establishment 30 2.1.2
    [Show full text]
  • SHARED PARENTING BETTER for SCOTLAND’S CHILDREN Page 2
    SHARED PARENTING BETTER FOR SCOTLAND’S CHILDREN Page 2 Families Need Fathers Scotland - Both Parents Matter is a Scottish charity that provides support to parents facing contact problems after separation and promotes shared parenting. We publish a wide range of legal and parenting information and handle individual enquiries as well as supporting five monthly self-help support groups across Scotland. 10 Palmerston Place, Edinburgh EH12 5AA, 0131 557 2440 [email protected] www.fnfscotland.org.uk Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisation SC042817 SUMMARY This year, both the SNP Manifesto and Scottish parental rights and responsibilities should be Parliament’s Justice Committee have stated that retrospectively allowed for unmarried fathers. Scots family law should be reviewed. Families Need This report collates existing research into the Fathers Scotland (FNFS) suggests that any benefits of shared parenting. It also includes forthcoming review of family law should include a information from our own 15 questionnaires and statement in favour of shared parenting. interviews with families who have experienced We believe all children should have the opportunity shared parenting first hand. to benefit from having both of their parents actively There is overwhelming evidence of the benefits to involved in their lives and that both parents should both parents and children of shared parenting from share responsibility in all decisions about their a broad range of studies and reports around the upbringing. We want this to be the starting world. Children in shared parenting families have presumption in Scotland rather than an outcome significantly better outcomes in terms of emotional, that has to be argued for often with great difficulty behavioural, and psychological well-being, as well and at financial and emotional cost within the as better physical health and better relationships adversarial court system.
    [Show full text]
  • Scots Law 2021
    SCOTS LAW 2021 edinburghuniversitypress.com SCOTS LAW Contents Scots law 3 Scottish legal history 12 Roman law 15 Energy law 17 Scots law textbooks 19 How to order 26 Letter from the team Our Scots Law list that has grown considerably in recent years resulting in our wonderful 2021 catalogue. As the only dedicated Scots Law publisher based in Scotland, we are committed to delivering exceptional texts to advance your studies, research, teaching and practice. Let’s delve into this year’s offerings! We’ve been busy updating and developing our textbook range for the next generation of legal practitioners. Check out Roman Law for Scots Law Students from Craig Anderson (page 21) and don’t miss the long-awaited new edition of Delict: A Comprehensive Guide to the Law in Scotland (page 20). You’ll find new updates and additions to the Edinburgh Law Essentials series: new editions of our guides to delict, criminal law and the Scottish legal system plus a brand-new guide to environmental law (pages 24–5). And last but not least, we have the latest batch of Avizandum Statutes – now also in ebook to support remote learning (page 23)! If you’re teaching, you can request your inspection copies on our website: https://edinburghuniversitypress.com/scots-law For working lawyers, we have new guides for 2021: Evictions in Scotland by Adrian Stalker (page 3), Scottish Arbitration Handbook from David R. Parratt, Angela Grahame and Peter Foreman (page 7) and McGowan on Alcohol Licensing Law in Scotland by Stephen J. McGowan (page 8). As well as keeping you up-to-date for the present, we continue to delve into our legal history.
    [Show full text]