Draft Shoreline Characterization Report 1 1 Introduction
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CITY OF SEATTLE MARCH 2009 Shoreline Characterization Report DRAFT contents 1 INTRODUCTION 2 1.1 Understanding the Shoreline Characterization 2 1.2 Overview of Seattle Area Water Bodies 2 1.2.1 Watercourses and Streams 3 1.2.2 Lakes 3 1.2.3 Estuaries 3 1.2.4 Marine Waters 4 1.2.5 Seattle Shorelines Under Shoreline Management Act Jurisdiction 4 2 A BRIEF PRIMER ON AQUATIC ECOSYSTEMS AND ECOSYSTEM-WIDE PROCESSES 6 2.1 Lake Ecosystems 10 2.1.1 Lake Ecosystem Description 10 2.1.2 Lake Watershed Processes 12 2.1.3 Lake Biological Processes 17 2.1.4 Lake Shoreline Habitats and Associated Wetlands 19 2.2 Estuarine and Marine Ecosystems 21 2.2.1 Estuarine Ecosystem Description 21 2.2.2 Marine Ecosystem Description 22 2.2.3 Estuarine and Marine Watershed Processes 23 2.2.4 Estuarine and Marine Biological Processes 29 2.2.5 Estuarine and Marine Shoreline Habitats and Associated Wetlands 33 3 ASSESSING SHORELINE CONDITIONS 36 3.1 Regional Water Body Habitat Assessment 36 3.2 Watershed Processes Used in the Assessment 36 3.3 Data Collection and Compilation 38 3.3.1 Lake Washington, Lake Union, and the Ship Canal 39 3.3.2 Duwamish River Estuary 40 3.3.3 Puget Sound 41 3.3.4 All Areas 42 contents 3.4 Assessment Methods 43 3.4.1 Overview 43 3.4.2 Analysis Structure and Scoring 43 3.4.3 Defi ning Reaches and Data Aggregation 44 3.4.4 Assumptions and Limitations of the Analysis 46 4 CONDITIONS IN SEATTLE’S REGIONAL WATER BODIES 48 4.1 Lake Washington 48 4.1.1 Area Description 48 4.1.2 Hydrology 49 4.1.3 Water and Sediment Quality Conditions 52 4.1.4 Shoreline Habitat 54 4.1.5 Biological Communities 65 4.2 Lake Union and the Ship Canal/Ballard Locks 69 4.2.1 Area Description 69 4.2.2 Hydrology 71 4.2.3 Water and Sediment Quality 72 4.2.4 Shoreline Habitat 74 4.2.5 Biological Communities 79 4.3 Duwamish River Estuary 81 4.3.1 Area Description 81 4.3.2 Hydrology 82 4.3.3 Water and Sediment Quality 83 4.3.4 Shoreline Habitat 84 4.3.5 Biological Communities 87 4.4 Marine Nearshore of Puget Sound, including Elliott Bay and Shilshole Bay 89 4.4.1 Area Description 89 4.4.2 Hydrology 90 4.4.3 Water and Sediment Quality 91 4.4.4 Shoreline Habitat 92 4.4.5 Biological Communities 104 4.5 Green Lake 108 4.5.1 Area Description 108 4.5.2 Hydrology 108 4.5.3 Water and Sediment Quality 109 4.5.4 Shoreline Habitat 114 4.5.5 Biological Communities 115 contents 5 SEATTLE WATER BODY SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS 119 5.1 Summary 119 5.2 Hydrology 119 5.2.1 Lake Washington/Lake Union Hydrologic Modifi cations 119 5.2.2 Duwamish River Estuary Hydrologic Modifi cations 119 5.2.3 Other Tributaries 120 5.2.4 Stormwater and Wastewater 120 5.2.5 Green Lake 120 5.3 Water and Sediment Quality 120 5.4 Shoreline Habitat Summary 121 5.5 Biological Processes and Community Summary 125 5.6 Climate Change and Large-Scale Events 125 5.6.1 Sea Level Rise 125 5.6.2 Other Projected Changes 126 6 REFERENCES 127 contents LIST OF TABLES Table 2-1: Human-caused Stressors on Lake, Marine, and Estuarine Watershed Processes 7 Table 4-1: Stressors Affecting Shoreline Conditions in Lake Washington 56 Table 4-2: Stressors Affecting Shoreline Conditions in Lake Union and the Ship Canal 75 Table 4-3: Stressors Affecting Shoreline Conditions in the Duwamish River Estuary 85 Table 4-4: Stressors Affecting Shoreline Conditions in the Marine Nearshore of Puget Sound 93 Table 4-5: Green Lake Sediment Metals Concentrations Compared to Freshwater Sediment Guidelines 112 Table 4-6: Green Lake Sampling Stations with Exceedances of Freshwater Sediment Guidelines 113 Table 4-7: Stressors Affecting Shoreline Conditions in Green Lake 114 Table 5-1: Summary of Process Impairment and Overall Impairment in Freshwater Reaches 123 Table 5-2: Summary of Process Impairment and Overall Impairment in Marine Reaches 124 Table 5-3: City of Seattle’s Sea Level Rise Assumptions 126 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 2-1: Conceptual Model of Watershed Processes, Stressors, and Habitat 6 Figure 2-2: Lake Structure Zones 11 Figure 3-1: Example of the Relationship Between Processes, Elements, and Components 44 Figure 3-2: Original Gridded Data and Simplifi ed Point Data Along the Shoreline 45 Figure 3-3: Example Graph of Aggregated Scores and Distance with Interpreted Reach Breaks 46 Figure 4-1: Lake Washington Drainage Basin Before and After 1917 51 Figure 4-2: Postcard Showing Mt. Rainier over Lake Washington, circa 1903 55 Figure 4-3: Lake Union and the Lake Washington Ship Canal System 70 Figure 4-4: Lake Union and Salmon Bay circa 1890 71 Figure 4-5: Green Lake Sediment Sampling Stations 111 LIST OF APPENDICES Appendix A: GIS Source Notes 148 Appendix B: Scoring for GIS Based Analysis 153 Appendix C: Map Folio (separate document) contents LIST OF ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS Anchor Anchor Environmental, L.L.C. BEHP bis(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate CAD Computer Aided Design cfs cubic feet per second CSO combined sewer overfl ow DPD Department of Planning and Development Ecology Washington State Department of Ecology GIS Geographic Information System GPS Global Positioning System GSA General Service Administration Herrera Herrera Environmental Consultants LiDAR Light Detection and Ranging LWD large woody debris mg/kg milligrams per kilogram mg/L milligrams per liter MLLW mean lower low water NOAA National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration NPDES National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System OHWM ordinary high water mark PAH polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon PCB polychlorinated biphenyl PSAT Puget Sound Action Team PSNERP Puget Sound Nearshore Ecosystem Restoration Project PSNP Puget Sound Nearshore Partnership RCW Revised Code of Washington SLR Sea Level Rise SMA Shoreline Management Act SMC Seattle Municipal Code SMP Shoreline Master Program SPU Seattle Public Utilities SQT Sediment Quality Triad SR State Route TBT tributyltin TMDL total maximum daily load μg/L micrograms per liter USACE U.S. Army Corps of Engineers USEPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency USGS U.S. Geological Survey WAC Washington Administrative Code WDFW Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife WDNR Washington State Department of Natural Resources WRIA Water Resource Inventory Area acknowledgements This report is the product of the effort and hard work of many people within the City of Seattle and assisting consultants. The contributions of the following authors and reviewers are acknowledged and appreciated: SEATTLE DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT Margaret Glowacki Brennon Staley Dave LaClergue SEATTLE PUBLIC UTILITIES Julie Hall Michele Koehler Scott Reese Beth Schmoyer ANCHOR ENVIRONMENTAL, L.L.C. Paul Schlenger John Small Ali Wick KING COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND PARKS Sally Abella Ken Rauscher Kollin Higgins overview THIS REPORT CONTAINS THE FOLLOWING SECTIONS: Section 1 - Introduction Explains the purposes of developing the Shoreline Characterization Report and the importance of understanding both historical conditions and present conditions in Seattle’s water bodies, and the underlying causes of changes that have occurred. Section 2 - A Brief Primer on Aquatic Ecosystems and Ecosystem- wide Processes Describes how hydrology, water quality, and physical conditions work together to shape shoreline habitat and the plant and animal communities that use it. Section 3 - Assessing Shoreline Conditions Describes the methods used to evaluate conditions in Seattle water bodies for the purposes of this report. Section 4 - Conditions in Seattle’s Regional Water Bodies Describes the water quality and physical habitat conditions in Lake Washington, the Lake Washington Ship Canal (Ship Canal)/Lake Union, the Duwamish River, Seattle’s portions of Puget Sound, and Green Lake. The section also describes low-quality and high-quality habitat areas identifi ed in the shoreline characterization assessment. Section 5 - Seattle Water Body Summary and Conclusions Summarizes and compares current conditions throughout the city. Section 5 also provides conclusions about the overall state of Seattle water bodies. A map folio (Appendix C) accompanying this report presents shoreline maps, and Appendices A and B provide additional technical detail about the methods and results of the analyses of aquatic conditions. DRAFT SHORELINE CHARACTERIZATION REPORT 1 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Understanding the Shoreline Characterization This Shoreline Characterization Report, prepared by Seattle Department of Planning and Development (DPD) and Seattle Public Utilities (SPU), documents the conditions of Seattle’s shorelines. This Shoreline Characterization Report will be used by DPD to update their Shoreline Master Program (SMP). This report describes the current hydrologic, chemical, physical, and biological conditions of the larger lakes, estuaries, and marine shorelines located within the city limits of Seattle. These conditions defi ne aquatic health and the ability of the city’s shoreline habitats to perform critical functions and services, such as fi ltering water and capturing sediment, moderating fl oods, and forming aquatic habitat. Based on a number of research, monitoring, and assessment reports, this information has been collectively compiled and organized for the fi rst time to be readily accessible to City of Seattle staff and interested citizens. Interconnectedness between terrestrial and aquatic environments is among the most important concepts for managing watercourses, lakes, estuaries, and marine environments. Physical, chemical, and biological changes in a watershed can lead to changes in nearby and distant areas, sometimes with unintended or unexpected consequences. The variability of impacts often creates diffi cult challenges in managing land, drainage, development, and other watershed uses without leading to adverse effects on the ecosystem as a whole.