Territorial Ranch Houses of Southern Arizona 1663-1912
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Territorial ranch houses of southern Arizona 1863-1912 Item Type text; Thesis-Reproduction (electronic) Authors Stewart, Janet Ann, 1925- Publisher The University of Arizona. Rights Copyright © is held by the author. Digital access to this material is made possible by the University Libraries, University of Arizona. Further transmission, reproduction or presentation (such as public display or performance) of protected items is prohibited except with permission of the author. Download date 04/10/2021 03:37:57 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10150/566373 TERRITORIAL RANCH HOUSES OF SOUTHERN ARIZONA 1663-1912 by . Janet Ann Steivart A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of the DEPARTMENT OF ART In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS WITH A MAJOR IN ART HISTORY In the Graduate College THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA 1 9 7 0 STATEMENT BY AUTHOR This thesis has been submitted in partial ful fillment of requirements for an advanced degree at The University of Arizona and is deposited in the University Library to be made available to borrowers under rules of the Library. Brief quotations from this thesis are allowable without special permission, provided that accurate acknowledgment of source is made. Requests for permis sion for extended quotation from or reproduction of this manuscript in whole or in part may be granted by the head of the major department or the Dean of the Graduate College when in his judgment the proposed use of the material is in the interests of scholarship. In all other instances, however, permission must be obtained from the author. SIGNED: S4- kdaftT APPROVAL BY THESIS DIRECTOR This thesis has been approved on the date shown below: GORDON HECK Professor of Architecture ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Appreciation is extended to Professor Gordon Heck whose outstanding lectures in Architectural History became the inspiration for this study. Professor Heck’s constant constructive criticism and generosity of communication aided in bringing a diversified investigation to fruition. The extensive files of the Arizona Pioneers’ Historical Society were of inestimable help in providing both photographic records of the houses and documentary material. So varied a study would have been impossible without availability of these files and the aid of the Society. The generosity of the ranch owners in allowing me to inspect and photograph the houses and in extending in formation by means of interviews and correspondence is greatly appreciated. It is only hoped that unavoidable errors in documentation will be understood. ' Without the plans executed by John Lesniewski and John Leece, this work would be colorless and incomplete. The reproductive photography of Vicky Shelpman enlightened the study. It is hoped that this investigation will be of use to those seeking documentation of territorial domestic archi Lecture of southern Arizona. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS................................. vi ABSTRACT ..................................... .. xl PART I. THE ARCHITECTURAL ANTECEDENTS OF THE TERRITORIAL RANCH HOUSES OF SOUTHERN ARIZONA ................... 1 CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION ........... 2 II. THE SPANISH-INDIAN SOUTHWEST .............. 5 Pueblo Architecture .............. 5 The Spanish-Indian Idiom at Santa Fe . 8 III. THE PATIO P L A N ......................... 13 IV. THE RAISED COTTAGE ............ 16 PART II. THE RANCH HOUSES . ................. .. 2? CHAPTER V. PETE KITCHEN RANCH HOUSE, 1856 (SANTA CRUZ COUNTY) ............ ...... 2o VI. TAIIQUS VERDE RANCH HOUSE, 1862 (PIMA COUNTY) ........................... 41 VII. SIERRA BONITA RANCH HOUSE, 1872 (COCHISE AND GRAHAM COUNTIES) ..... 54 VIII. SAN BERNARDINO RANCH HOUSE, 1886 (COCHISE COUNTY)............ ........ 6? IX. BA3AC0MAEI RANCH HOUSE, iSS? (COCHISE COUNTY) ................................ 79 iv V TABLE OF CONTENTS— Continued Page X. FARAWAY RANCH HOUSE, 1668-1889 (COCHISE COUNTY) .............. 86 XI. SINGING VALLEY RANCH HOUSE, 1900 (COCHISE COUNTY) ....................... 99 XII. SAN RAFAEL RANCH HOUSE, 1900 (SANTA CRUZ COUNTY)........................... 102 XIII. CONCLUSION ........................... 126 GLOSSARY OF SPANISH-AMERICAN TERMS .................... 131 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY....................... 133 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Figure Page 1 . Indian Pueblo, Taos, New Mexico, 1540 (Morrison, 1952) ......................... 6 2 . Potrero Jacal, 1&54 (Arizona Pioneers* Historical Society /APHS/) ....... 6 3• Governor’s Palace at Santa Fe, 1610-1614 (Sanford, 1950) 10 4 . Plans of Pete Kitchen, IS5 6 ................... 12 5. Plans of Tanque Verde, 1 S 6 2 .............. .. 12 6 . Courtyard, Sierra Bonita, l 6 ' 7 2 .............. 14 7. Aguirre House, San Diego, 1825-1830 (Morrison, 1 9 5 2 ) .............. .... 14 8 . “House of the Greek,” Nassau, The Bahamas (waterman, 1947) ................ 17 9. nKme. John’s Legacy, 11 New Orleans, c. 1727 (Morrison, 1 9 5 2 ) .......... ............. 19 10. Parlange, Pointe Couoee Parish, 1750 (Kane, 1945) . ' . ............... 21 11. Larkin House, Monterey, 1834 (Morrison, 1952)" . .............. 21 1 2 . Front Elevation, San Rafael, 1900 24 13 • San Rafael, North, 1900 24 14. "Old Main," University of Arizona, c. 1887, Southwest ...".............. .......... 25 15. Pete Kitchen Jacal, Undated Photograph (APHS) . 29 1 6 . 1854 Jacal at Pres e n t ........ .... ............ 29 17• Plan of Pete Kitchen House, 1656....... 32 vi vii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS— Continued Figure Page id. Entrance (East) Facade (APRS) .................. 33 19* East Facade, Pete Kitchen House, at Present . 33 20. Interior Door, West Wa l l ........................ 35 21. Interior, Pete Kitchen House .................... 35 22. Patio from W e s t .............. 37 23. Northwest E l l ................................... 37 2 4 . East Facade, 1915 (APRS) ............. 3o 25. Northwest Ell, 1924 ( A P R S ) ............ .. 38 26. Portales and Tile Floor, and North Extension ~ Added, 1947 ............................... 40 27. Plan of Tanque Verde, 1862 ..................... 42 28. Tanque Verde, 3.862 .......... .......... .. 42 29 • Tanque Verde from Southwest . ................... 43 30. West Facade, Tanque Verde ....................... 43 31• Original Construction of Beamed Ceiling, South R o o m .............. .................. 46 32. East Facade, Original Adobe Brick Construction . 48 33• Original Adobe Brick Construction, North Wall . 48 34* Original Lies quite C o r r a l e s ........ ............ 50 35• Vest Facade of 1926 A d d i t i o n ................... 53 36. Corredor of Mesquite Cratchets and Beams, 1926 addition . .......................... 53 37• Plan of Sierra Bonita, 1872 ........ ............ 57 3 8 . Parapeted Courtyard.......... .................. 57 39* Carriage Houses ( A P R S ) ........ .. ........... 58 viii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS— Continued Figure Page 40. Carriage Houses at Present, South ................. 56 41. Shake Roof of Portales Surrounding Courtyard . 60 42. Colonel Hooker’s D e s k ............................. 60 43• Colonel Hooker’s B e d ......................... 6l 44 • Original Barn ............................... 6l 45♦ Detail of Figure 4 6 . Facade, Northeast, Main House .................................. 65 4 6 . Sierra Bonita Ranch Drawing (Elliott, I6S4 ) . 65 47• Eureka Springs Stock Ranch Drawing (Elliott, 1664) ....................... 66 4 6 . San Bernardino, South Facade ..................... 71 49. Aerial View of House and Dependencies (APHS) . 71 50. San Bernardino c. 1920, Original Shingle Roof (APHS) ................................. 72 51* Three Dependencies behind Main House (APHS) . 74 52. Eclectic Window, Living Room ................. 76 53• Pine-plank Flooring ....................... 76 54. Plan of San Bernardino, 1SS6 ..................... 76 55• Slaughter House at Present, Southwest ...... 76 56. Gateway and walls which Surround Babacomari . 60. 57* Plan of Babacomari, 1667 Si 56. Original House (Renovated) ............... Si 59* Foreman’s House, East of Original Ranch House, c. 1920 ......................... 83 60. Present San Ignacio del Babacomari, 1941, Southwest F a c a d e ............ S3 ix LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS— -Continued Figure Page 61. Lounge with Beamed Ceiling and Corner Fireplace .................................. 85 62. Faraway, Southeast.................. 8? 63. Exterior Staircase, South ............ .... 8? 64- Plan of Faraway, Ground Floor ................ 89 65. Plan of Faraway, Second F l o o r ................. 89 66. Back of House and the Veil Dug by Erickson . 90 6 7 . Interior of c. 1881 Room ....................... 92 68. Dining Room Door and Cabinet................... 94 6 9 . Dining Room China C l o s e t ................ 94 70. “Garfield” Fireplace ......... ........ 95 71- Dormer vJindow and Exterior Staircase.......... 97 72. Singing Valley, c. 1900, S o u t h ............ .. 101 73- Undated Kinder Collection Photograph ........... 104 74- San Rafael ”Kew Ranch House" (Kinder Collection, Undated) ..................... 106 75. San Rafael, 1888 ( A P H S ) .................. 106 76. Gable End (APHS)............................ 107 77- San Rafael and Dependencies, 1888 ....... 108 78. San Rafael, 1900, North . .... Ill 79- Redwood Door, Ground-floor Bedroom ............ Ill 80. Veranda, N o r t h ............................. .. 113 Si. Front Elevation, San Rafael, 1900 . 114 82. Front Elevation, Parlange, 1750 . 114 X LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS— Continued Figure Page S3. "Old Main" (c. 1 8 8 ? ) .......... .. ..........