Sanctity of Life
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Sanctity of Life Catholic Church Teaching Jewish Teaching - All life is sacred - All life is sacred - All life is created by God - All life is created by God - Life begins at conception - Life begins at conception - ‘Before I formed you in the womb I knew you…’’ - ‘Before I formed you in the womb I knew you…’’ (Jer 1:5) (Jer 1:5) - ‘… you saw me before I was born.’ - ‘… you saw me before I was born.’ - Humans are made in the image of God - Humans are made in the image and likeness of God – Imago - Pikuach Nefesh – preservation of human life overrules any Dei other religious law or teaching e.g. eating unclean food. Abortion - Absolutist stance - Life is a gift from God and should be protected - Abortion is always wrong Agree - However abortion is acceptable for some Jews - God made life so only God - Woman’s choice - Tolerated more within the first 40 days can take life - God gave humans’ freewill - ‘once the head has come forth..’ – this means the - Life begins at conception so - In the case of rape it may be harmful to child may not be harmed after birth (Mishnah abortion is classed as murder the woman Oholot 7:6) - All life is sacred Disagree - Orthodox – wrong unless in serious - Alternatives to abortion – - God alone can take life circumstances e.g the mother’s life is in danger adoption, fostering etc. - Life begins at conception so abortion is - Reform – no absolutist stance, accepted if the pregnancy is a result of rape or there is a risk of - SPUC – anti-abortion murder charity - Alternatives to abortion disability - Absolutist stance Euthanasia - Life is a gift from God and should be - Euthanasia is always wrong Agree protected – classed as murder - We should all have control over our own lives - ‘One who is in a dying condition is - God made life so only God - God gave humans’ freewill regarded as a living person in all can take life - Humans should have the right to die painlessly respects’ (Talmud, Semachot 1:1) - All life is sacred - Humans should be able to die with dignity - Orthodox - all types of Euthanasia - Alternatives to euthanasia Disagree are wrong as it would be classed as e.g. hospice care - God alone can take life murder - Through suffering we can - Reform - would not promote - Euthanasia is classed as murder grow to know God - Hospices can provide a painless death euthanasia but may allow the removal - Start of a ‘slippery slope’ of medical care keeping someone alive SJHS Catholic Church Teaching The World Jewish Teaching - All creation was created by an omnipotent God - Orthodox – literal understanding of Genesis - Church takes a non-literal approach – reconciles Genesis Creation Story - Reform – non-literal understanding of Genesis, science with scripture accepted alongside science - Accepts the Big Bang Theory but understands that - The creation of the world reflects a good God God is responsible - Thus all he has created is holy so cannot be destroyed - God gave humans dominion over the world - Humans must then look after the world as stewards - This means that humans are stewards of the world. Blind Evolution Planned Evolution - No need for a designer God. All living things have - The existence of the world and adaptations point simply adapted and evolved over time to a plan and thus a designer God. Big Bang Theory - Church agrees with the Big Bang Theory - Orthodox – literal understanding of Genesis – - Scientific theory for the - Creation points towards a designer it is the only explanation for creation existence of the world - That designer is God - Reform – non-literal understanding of Genesis, - States that the world was - Creationists – take a literal stance on Genesis accepted alongside science created from a single point Stewardship - God made humans stewards of the world - God made humans stewards of the world. - Bal Tashchit – do not destroy anything needlessly - They are responsible for the environment Environmental – linked to the non-destruction of trees in war - It is the duty of all Catholics to care for the world Responsibility - Tikkun Olam – to fix the world – responsibility to - Laudato Si (Care for out Common Home) – the - Responsibility of fix as well as not further damage the world world belongs to everyone and we must work humans towards the - Gemilut Hasadim – responsibility to the world and together to repair and prevent further harm world all those in it. CAFOD ‘Catholics should look after the world’ Discuss this statement. - Catholic Agency for Overseas Development Agree - Works to tackle environmental and social issues - Duty as Catholics - Works in emergencies such as natural disasters - God gave them dominion over the world - Works to tackle inequality e.g. poverty, injustice etc. - It is not just for now but for future generations - Works to promote global citizenship - Looking after the world makes it better for us - Educate across the world to tackle these issues and Disagree get people working together to tackle the global - All humans should have responsibility issues - Life for today and do not worry about the future SJHS - Humanists believe they have responsibility too – H4BW Catholic Church Teaching Jewish Teaching - Humans are made up of the body and soul Death and the - Humans are made up of the body and soul - Body = mortal – ends at death Afterlife - Most Jews believe that when you die, the soul and body - Soul = immortal – lives on after death will separate and join again on the day of judgement Afterlife hbnjjj - Catholics believe in heaven, hell and purgatory - No one definitive belief in Judaism - Heaven is eternity in the presence of God - Generally there is a belief in Gan Eden, Gehenna and Sheol - Hell is eternity in the absence of God - Gen Eden/ Olam haBa refers to heaven or the world to - Purgatory is a place of cleansing and purification come from sin – Masses are said for the dead to shorten - Gehenna refers to hell their time in purgatory - Sheol has come to mean a place of purification or waiting - Individuals will either go straight to hell or heaven, - Jews believe that they do not need to worry about what is to or to heaven after their soul has been cleansed in come, but that it is up to God. purgatory Judgement b njjj - Catholics believe in 2 judgements – Individual and - When people are judged by G-d their body and soul are Final reunited. The soul will blame the body for its actions. - At the moment of death all humans are judged on - Judgement will take place after the coming of the Mashiach how they have lived – individual judgement (Messiah). - At the end of time all humans will be raised, body - Many Jews believe that they will be punished or rewarded and soul will be united and all humanity will be after death for the way in which they have lived their lives judged. - Jews believe that the importance of life is the way in which it is lived on earth. Funerals b njjj - Catholic funerals are split into 5 parts - The Jewish funeral ritual has several stages 1. Reception of the Body – the body is 1. As soon as possible the body is washed and dressed in tachrichim (white taken into the church shroud). Men are wrapped in the tallith 2. Liturgy of the Word – readings and 2. Body is placed and sealed in a plain wooden coffin – the body is not left gospel alone until burial 3. Liturgy of the Eucharist – holy 3. Act of Keriah – before burial mourners make a tear in their garments – communion display of grief 4. Final Commendation – the person is 4. Shiva – after the burial the family return home to sit Shiva. This is a 7 commended into God’s hands, coffin is day period of mourning where a candle is kept burning and mirrors are blessed with Holy Water covered. 5. Committal – the body is cremated or 5. Kaddish – prayer of mourning which is said 3 times a day for 11 months. SJHS buried with final prayers 6. A tombstone is placed on the grave just before the first anniversary Catholic Church Teaching Forgiveness Jewish Teaching - We must forgive in order to be forgiven - Forgiveness is important in Judaism and is a duty, or a - Our Father – ‘Forgive us our trespasses as we mitzvah, that Jews should try their best to obey. forgive those who trespass against us.’ - ‘Do not hate your brother in your heart.’ Leviticus 19:17 - Must forgive ‘seventy times seven’ times - Jews place great emphasis on teshuva, or repentance. - Parable of the Prodigal Son tells us about God as a This is when Jews will actively try to make amends for forgiving father the wrongs they have committed. They do this by: - If we do not forgive we cannot expect forgiveness off - reflecting on their wrongs God - seeking forgiveness for their wrongs - Catholics will turn to the Sacrament of - praying Reconciliation to confess their sins. - turning to the Torah for guidance Atonement h bnjjj Sacrament of Reconciliation Yom Kippur (Day of Atonement) - Catholics can receive this sacrament as - Yom Kippur is one of the most important days for Jews often as deemed necessary - These ten days, the Days of Awe, are a period of repentance when Jews ask 1. The individual will confess their sins to God's forgiveness for the previous year's sins. the priest - Some may walk together to a river or the sea and empty their pockets into the 2. The priest will then (acting on behalf of water, symbolically casting out their sins. God) absolve them of their sins - Jews believe that on Yom Kippur, God makes the final decision on what the 3.