Thermodynamic Analysis for Improving Understanding and Performance of Hybrid Power Cycles Using Multiple Heat Sources of Different Temperatures

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Thermodynamic Analysis for Improving Understanding and Performance of Hybrid Power Cycles Using Multiple Heat Sources of Different Temperatures University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations 2017 Thermodynamic Analysis For Improving Understanding And Performance Of Hybrid Power Cycles Using Multiple Heat Sources Of Different Temperatures Ting Yue University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations Part of the Mechanical Engineering Commons, and the Oil, Gas, and Energy Commons Recommended Citation Yue, Ting, "Thermodynamic Analysis For Improving Understanding And Performance Of Hybrid Power Cycles Using Multiple Heat Sources Of Different Temperatures" (2017). Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations. 2658. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2658 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2658 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Thermodynamic Analysis For Improving Understanding And Performance Of Hybrid Power Cycles Using Multiple Heat Sources Of Different Temperatures Abstract Past studies on hybrid power cycles using multiple heat sources of different temperatures focused mainly on case studies and almost no general theory about this type of systems has been developed. This dissertation is a study of their general thermodynamic performance, with comparisons to their corresponding single heat source reference systems. The method used in the dissertation was step-wise: to first analyze the major hybrid power cycles (e.g. Rankine, Brayton, Combined Cycles, and their main variants) thermodynamically, without involving specific operation parameter values, and develop some generalized theory that is at least applicable to each type of system. The second step was to look for commonalities among these theories and develop the sought generalized theory based on these commonalities. A number of simulation case studies were performed to help the understanding and confirm the thermodynamic esults.r Exergo-economic analysis was also performed to complement the thermodynamic analysis with consideration of externalities, and was compared to the conventional economic analysis method. The generalized expressions for the energy/exergy efficiency differences between the hybrid and the corresponding single heat source systems were developed. The results showed that the energy and exergy efficiencies of the hybrid systems are higher than those of their corresponding single heat source reference systems if and only if the energy/exergy conversion efficiency (defined in the dissertation) of the additional heat source (AHS, can be any heat source that has lower temperature) is larger than that of the original heat source. Sensitivity analysis results showed the relations between the temperature and heat addition rate of the AHS and the energy/exergy efficiency of the hybrid systems. Other big advantages of hybrid systems, i.e. the effects on replacement of fossil fuel by renewable, nuclear and waste energy, lower emissions and depletion of fossil fuel, were revealed in the economic analysis, by considering the cost reduction from fuel saving and carbon tax. Simple criteria were developed to help compare the hybrid and reference systems and determine under which conditions the hybrid systems will have better thermodynamic or economic performance than the reference ones. The results and criteria can be used to help design the hybrid systems to achieve higher energy and/or exergy efficiencies and/or lower vle elized electricity cost (LEC) before detailed design or simulation or experiment. So far, 3 archival journal papers and 3 conference papers were published from this dissertation work. Degree Type Dissertation Degree Name Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) Graduate Group Mechanical Engineering & Applied Mechanics First Advisor Noam Lior Keywords Exergo-economic analysis, Multiple heat sources with different temperatures, Power systems simulation, Thermal hybrid power cycles, Thermochemical hybrid power cycles, Thermodynamic analysis Subject Categories Engineering | Mechanical Engineering | Oil, Gas, and Energy This dissertation is available at ScholarlyCommons: https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2658 THERMODYNAMIC ANALYSIS FOR IMPROVING UNDERSTANDING AND PERFORMANCE OF HYBRID POWER CYCLES USING MULTIPLE HEAT SOURCES OF DIFFERENT TEMPERATURES Ting Yue A DISSERTATION in Mechanical Engineering and Applied Mechanics Presented to the Faculties of the University of Pennsylvania in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2017 Supervisor of Dissertation _________________________ Dr. Noam Lior Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering and Applied Mechanics Graduate Group Chairperson _________________________ Dr. Kevin T. Turner, Professor, Mechanical Engineering and Applied Mechanics and Materials Science and Engineering Dissertation Committee Dr. Haim H. Bau, Professor, Committee Chair, Department of Mechanical Engineering and Applied Mechanics, University of Pennsylvania Dr. Warren D. Seider, Professor, Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, University of Pennsylvania Dr. Gerard F. Jones, Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Villanova University THERMODYNAMIC ANALYSIS FOR IMPROVING UNDERSTANDING AND PERFORMANCE OF HYBRID POWER CYCLES USING MULTIPLE HEAT SOURCES OF DIFFERENT TEMPERATURES COPYRIGHT 2017 Ting Yue This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution- NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License To view a copy of this license, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/us/ DEDICATION To my loving parents, especially my Mother for their support and caring, persistently and endlessly iii ACKNOWLEDGMENT First and foremost, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my beloved academic advisor, Professor Noam Lior. It was a great honor to work under the guidance of Dr. Lior, at one of best universities in the world for the past years. With the help of his decades of experience in the field of power generation and many other related fields, Dr. Lior helped me define the topic, objective and scope of this dissertation and provided much guidance continuously over the years assisting me to overcome the many difficulties that were encountered during my research, with patience and immense knowledge. Dr. Lior also helped me improve my English pronunciation and writing skills, as well as my presentation skills. What’s more, he also taught me about the culture in the US and invited me many times for leisure trips and holiday dinners, making my research life a little easier. There is an old saying in my country as “once a teacher, always a father”, and Dr. Lior is like my father and will always be. Besides my advisor, I would like to thank the rest of my thesis committee: Professor Haim Bau, Professor Warren Seider, and Professor Gerard Jones, for their time in reviewing my proposal and dissertation, and for their insightful comments and encouragement. I would also like to thank all the professors who taught me courses at the University of Pennsylvania, including Dr. Lior, Dr. Lukes, Dr. Ayyaswamy, Dr. Carchidi, Dr. Kumar, Dr. Castañeda, Dr. Kothmann and Dr. Mylovanov. iv Also, thank all the staff in the MEAM office, especially Maryeileen, Peter and Sue, who helped me many kinds of things, which are hard to count. I would like to thank my fellow labmates, especially Yuejun, for the stimulation discussions, for all the work we have been working together, and for all the fun we had in the past years. Also, I would like to thank Professor Zhang Na for teaching me how to use the software and for all other help, such as accompanying my mom when she felt lonely in the US while I was working on my research and could not spend too much time with her. What’s more, I would like to thank the University of Pennsylvania, for admitting me as a PhD student, with the help of Dr. Lior. The university is one of the oldest and best university in the US. It provides modern and comprehensive facilities that made my research and life easier. To name a few, there are numerous food trucks all around the campus, providing cheap and tasty foods from all over the world. It also provides several modern playgrounds so that I can play soccer in the weekend for fun and to keep healthy. One of the playgrounds is even covered with an air tent in the winter so that people can play in there even there is heavy snow outside. Besides the infrastructures, the university is embedded with its unique culture, influencing all its students. For the past many years, I not only studied here but also lived here. This was a priceless experience for me and will surely positively influence my future life. I am really proud of being about to graduate as a PhD student from Penn and hope that Penn will be proud of me as one of her students in the future. v Last but not the least, I would like express my earnest appreciations to my parents. This dissertation is dedicated to them. Without their support, I could not have finished this dissertation. Their support is unconditional and persistent. I will do my best to pay back their love after graduation and make them happy. Ting Yue Philadelphia, PA vi ABSTRACT THERMODYNAMIC ANALYSIS FOR IMPROVING UNDERSTANDING AND PERFORMANCE OF HYBRID POWER CYCLES USING MULTIPLE HEAT SOURCES OF DIFFERENT TEMPERATURES Ting Yue Dr. Noam Lior Past studies on hybrid power cycles using multiple heat sources of different temperatures focused mainly on case studies and almost no general theory about this type of systems has been developed. This
Recommended publications
  • Water Treatment for Fossil Fuel Power Generation
    WATER TREATMENT FOR FOSSIL FUEL POWER GENERATION Report No. COAL R300 DTI/Pub URN 06/705 January 2006 by Dr Alan Paton, Paul McCann and Nick Booth E.ON UK plc, Power Technology Centre, Ratcliffe on Soar, Nottingham, NG11 OEE Tel: 0115 936 2000 Fax: 0115 936 2711 www.eon-uk.com The work described in this report was carried out under contract as part of the DTI Cleaner Coal Technology Transfer Programme. The programme is managed by Future Energy Solutions. The views and judgements expressed in this report are those of the contractor and do not necessarily reflect those of the DTI or Future Energy Solutions First published 2005 © Crown copyright 2005 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY A ‘Technology Status Review of Water Treatment Associated with Fossil Fuel Based Power Generation and Related Processes’ has been completed for AEA Technology plc (AEAT), on behalf of the UK Department of Trade and Industry (DTI). The aims of the review were to:- • Assess objectively the current state of development and application of water treatment technologies relating to fossil fuel power generation world-wide. • Critically assess the strengths and shortcomings of existing technologies in relation to commercial or near-commercial needs and to provide information on manufacturers, suppliers, developers, consultants and major users. • Review current activities and capabilities of companies/organisations working in the water treatment technology sector, with particular emphasis on the UK. • Identify priority areas in which UK RD&D activities could/should be focused to meet future demands. • Recommend means for enhancing the market opportunities for UK companies and organisations specialising in water treatment technologies.
    [Show full text]
  • Proper Care and Feeding of Your Deaerating Feedwater Heater
    PROPER CARE AND FEEDING OF YOUR DEAERATING FEEDWATER HEATER The deaerating feedwater heater is one of the most important components of the steam generation cycle in a boiler plant. Besides heating the feedwater, it also liberates and removes the non-condensable gases (primarily Oxygen and Carbon Dioxide) present in the water. These gases would cause pitting and corrosion if allowed to enter the boiler with the feedwater. A good quality deaerator should be constructed to conform to the requirements of the “Deaerator Standard” from the Heat Exchange Institute (HEI). HEI is acknowledged worldwide as the leading standards development organization for heat exchange and vacuum apparatus. By understanding how the deaerator works and knowing what to check regarding its operation, the owner can very easily monitor the deaerator’s efficiency and react accordingly when operating conditions go awry. The feedwater heater is an ASME Code pressure vessel where condensate and soft make-up water enter the top of the shell and are distributed through spray nozzles traveling downward through a series of distribution trays. The combination of the action of the spray nozzles and the water cascading through the very small openings in the distribution trays breaks the water down into minute droplets. As low pressure steam introduced at the bottom of the vessel flows upward through the spray water the water and the steam come into direct contact with each other. This direct contact of water and steam serves two purposes: 1) The water absorbs heat from the steam, thus raising its temperature 2) The hot steam drives off corrosive gases (Oxygen and Carbon Dioxide) entrained in the water, removing them through an atmospheric vent at the top of the heater shell.
    [Show full text]
  • Coal-Fired Advanced Supercritical Retrofit with CO2 Capture
    Coal-Fired Advanced Supercritical Retrofit with CO2 Capture Contract No.: C/08/00393/00/00 URN 09D/739 June 2009 Coal-Fired Advanced Supercritical Retrofit with CO2 Capture Contract No.: C/08/00393/00/00 URN 09/739 Contractor Doosan Babcock Energy Limited The work described in this report was carried out under contract, initially as part of the DTI Emerging Energy Technologies Programme and latterly under the Technology Strategy Board. It is one of a number of energy projects managed by AEA Technology. The views and judgments expressed in this report are those of the contractor and do not necessarily reflect those of DECC, the Technology Strategy Board or AEA Technology. First Published 2007 © Crown Copyright 2007 i Lead Contractor Doosan Babcock Energy Limited Porterfield Road Renfrew PA4 8DJ Tel: +44 (0) 141 886 4141 Fax: +44 (0) 141 885 3370 E-mail: [email protected] Web: www.doosanbabcock.com Collaborators Alstom E.ON UK Air Products plc Imperial College London Fluor Ltd Sponsors E.ON UK Drax Power Ltd EDF Energy Scottish and Southern Energy RWEnpower ScottishPower Prepared by R S Panesar Doosan Babcock Energy Limited Porterfield Road Renfrew PA4 8DJ Tel: +44 (0)141 885 3921 www.doosanbabcock.com M R Lord Alstom Power Ltd. Newbold Road Rugby Warwickshire CV21 2NH Tel: +44 (0)1788 531045 www.power.alstom.com S T Simpson E.ON UK PLC Power Technology Ratcliffe-on-Soar Nottingham NG11 0EE Tel: +44 (0) 2476 192479 www.eon-uk.com V White Air Products PLC Hersham Place Molesey Road Walton-on-Thames Surrey KT12 4RZ Tel: +44 (0)1932
    [Show full text]
  • Perspectives for Power Generation from Industrial Waste Heat Recovery
    Perspectives for Power Generation from Industrial Waste Heat Recovery Fanny Blanquart Master of Science Thesis KTH School of Industrial Engineering and Management Energy Technology EGI_2017-0010 MSC EKV 1176 Division of Heat & Power SE-100 44 STOCKHOLM Master of Science Thesis EGI_2017-0010 MSC EKV 1176 Perspectives for Power Generation from Industrial Waste Heat Recovery Fanny Blanquart Approved Examiner Supervisor 2017-04-25 Miroslav Petrov - KTH/ITM/EGI Miroslav Petrov Commissioner Contact person Siemens AG Thomas Schille Abstract This thesis work was carried out at Siemens in Germany in the department of Steam Turbines, and aims to raise awareness of the potential for broader deployment of waste heat recovery (WHR) from industrial processes for power generation. Technologies available to recover heat are presented and sorted out according to the features of the heat source. In particular, ORC and water-based cycles are compared in terms of efficiency and other advantages and their sensitivity to variable parameters. As far as the efficiency is concerned, the type of technology does seem to have less impact than the size of the installation. Organic fluid cycles have properties that could encourage their selection, like smaller size of equipment, better efficiency during off- design operations or no make-up water supply. This study also presents different segments where WHR systems are possible. In the short term, cement, electric arc furnace and glass industries are the sectors that offer the best opportunities for WHR integrated with power generation. In a long-term view, future large systems for power generation tend to disappear with the expected optimization of the industrial processes.
    [Show full text]
  • Deaerating Condenser Boosts Combined-Cycle Plant Efficiency
    Deaerating condenser boosts combined-cycle plant efficiency Studies show savings in equipment and plant space and the ability to deaerate large quantities of makeup water using only turbine exhaust steam in a new system BY R.E. ATHEY AND E. SPENCER, GRAHAM MANUFACTURING CO. new system of steam condenser dissolved oxygen control has at or near the design cooling water temperature, and then only if Afound favor in the combined-cycle cogeneration market. air leakage is reduced to 25% of tabulated values for flows up to Savings in equipment, a reduction in building size (and plant 20 scfm, and to 15% of tabulated values for flows up to 40 scfm. height), and the ability to deaerate large quantities of makeup Maximum air leakage in any case may not exceed 6 scfm. water using only turbine exhaust steam are the reasons. Reports by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) consis- In earlier days, no condenser manufacturer guaranteed condensate tently describe DO increases during start-up and at reduced load. oxygen levels of 7 parts per billion (ppb) under any operating Specifically, EPRI NP-2294 attributes high dissolved oxygen in condition. Instead, guarantees were limited to Heat Exchange steam condenser condensate to inadequate venting at reduced Institute (HEI) standards. load. This report indicates that the steam condenser air cooling section became ineffective under partial load conditions. The HEI standards promise 0.005 cc/I (7 ppb) dissolved oxygen (DO) resultant increased vapor tends to overload the vent system at the in the condensate only if (1) the air leakage is reduced to a frac- same time as the vent system capacity is reduced at lower con- tion of the tabulated leakage rates; (2) the condenser makeup is denser pressures.
    [Show full text]
  • Powerplant Chemistry® Journal
    PowerPlant Chemistry PowerPlant Chemistry Contents 1999-2000 (Volume 1 and 2) Issue Author(s) Title Key Words 1999, 1 (1) Michael Rziha Cycle Chemistry in Combined Cycle Units - Combined Cycles, HRSG, Cycle Rainer Wulff The Siemens Experience Chemistry Digby D. Macdonald Deterministic Prediction of Localized Corrosion BWR, IGSCC, Crack Growth Rate, louri Balachov Damage in Power Plant Coolant Circuits Modeling George Engelhardt Gernot Repphun Influence of Metal Addition to BWR Water on BWR, Co-58 Activity, Metal Ions Andreas Hiltpold Contamination and Corrosion of Stainless Addition Irene Mailand Steel Bernhard Stellwag James C. Bellows Chemical Processes in Steam Turbines Steam Chemistry, Thermodynamics Joachim Fahlke RO Applications and Wastewater Reuse - Two Reverse Osmosis, Wastewater Important Fossil Power Plant Contributions Reuse to Conservation of Water Resources Daniel E. Meils Performance Assessment of Chemistry On-line On-Line Monitoring Process Instrumentation Issue Author(s) Title KeyWords 1999, 1 (2) Jan Stodola Review of Conditions for Reliable Boiler Boiler Water Treatment Operation Karol Daucik Water/Steam Cycle Chemistry of Ultra Ultra Supercritical Units, Materials, Supercritical Units Condensate Polishing, Tamara I. Petrova Effect of Demineralized Water Purity on Carbon Steel Corrosion Corrosion of Carbon Steel Heinrich Maurer On-line pH Monitoring by Measuring On-Line Monitoring, pH, Differential Cation and Specific Conductivity Conductivity Rene van der Wagt On-line Analysis of Water Contamination by On-Line Monitoring,
    [Show full text]