On Analytic Formulas of Feynman Propagators in Position Space *
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CPC(HEP & NP), 2010, 34(10): 1576{1582 Chinese Physics C Vol. 34, No. 10, Oct., 2010 On analytic formulas of Feynman propagators in position space * ZHANG Hong-Hao(Ü÷Ó)1;1) FENG Kai-Xi(¾mU)1 QIU Si-Wei(£d)1 ZHAO An(ëS)1 LI Xue-Song(oÈt)2 1 School of Physics and Engineering, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou 510275, China 2 Science College, Hunan Agricultural University, Changsha 410128, China Abstract We correct an inaccurate result of previous work on the Feynman propagator in position space of a free Dirac field in (3 + 1)-dimensional spacetime; we derive the generalized analytic formulas of both the scalar Feynman propagator and the spinor Feynman propagator in position space in arbitrary (D + 1)- dimensional spacetime; and we further find a recurrence relation among the spinor Feynman propagator in (D+1)-dimensional spacetime and the scalar Feynman propagators in (D+1)-, (D−1)- and (D+3)-dimensional spacetimes. Key words Feynman propagator, Klein-Gordon field, Dirac field, arbitrary dimensional spacetime PACS 11.10.Kk, 03.70.+k, 02.30.Gp 1 Introduction language of quantum field theory, the Feynman prop- agator in position space can be physically understood Although one cannot adopt the extreme view that as the energy due to the presence of the two external the set of all Feynman rules represents the full the- sources located at two different points in space and ory of quantized fields, the approach of the Feynman acting on each other (See Ref. [1] Chapt.I.4). graphs and rules plays an important role in pertur- It has been mentioned in Refs. [1{8] that in (3+1)- bative quantum field theories. For a generic quan- dimensional spacetime, after integrating over momen- tum theory involving interacting fields, the set of its tum, the Feynman propagator of a free Klein-Gordon Feynman rules includes some vertices and propaga- field can be expressed in terms of Bessel or modified tors. While for a free field theory there is only one Bessel functions, which depends on whether the sep- graph, that is, the Feynman propagator, in the set aration of two spacetime points is timelike or space- of its Feynman rules. Thus the Feynman propagator like. By changing variables to hyperbolic functions describes most, if not all, of the physical contents of and using the integral representation of the Hankel the free field theory. It is true that the real world is function of the second kind, the authors of Ref. [2] not governed by any free field theory. However, this derived the full analytic formulas of the Feynman kind of theory is the basis of a perturbatively inter- propagors of free Klein-Gordon and Dirac fields in acting field theory, and the issues of a free theory are (3+1)-dimensional spacetime. The expressions of the usually in the simplest situation and thus their study Feynman propagators of a free Klein-Gordon field in will be attempted at the first step of investigations. (1+1)- and that in (2+1)-dimensional spacetime can In statistical field theory, the Feynman propagator is be found in Refs. [9] and [10], respectively. How- usually called the correlation function. We need to ever, in Ref. [2] the expression for the Feynman prop- know its formula in position space to figure out the agator of a Dirac spinor field is inaccurate, since critical exponent η and the correlation length ξ, which there is at least a redundant term in their results. is related to another exponent ν. In the path integral In this paper we will show that the term actually Received 20 November 2009, Revised 21 January 2010 * Supported by Specialized Research Fund for Doctoral Program of Higher Education (SRFDP) (200805581030) and Sun Yet- Sen University Science Foundation and Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities 1) E-mail: [email protected] ©2010 Chinese Physical Society and the Institute of High Energy Physics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the Institute of Modern Physics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and IOP Publishing Ltd No. 10 ZHANG Hong-Hao et al: On analytic formulas of Feynman propagators in position space 1577 vanishes and we will give the correct expression. Fur- Thus, we can obtain the analytic formula of the Feyn- thermore, we will generalize the results of previous man propagator in position space by integrating over work and derive the full analytic formulas of the Feyn- the D-dimensional momentum in the expression of man propagators in position space of, respectively, D( t ;~x). This integral in D-dimensional Euclidean j j the Klein-Gordon scalar and the Dirac spinor in arbi- space can be evaluated by changing the variables from trary (D + 1)-dimensional spacetime. Eventually we Cartesian coordinates to spherical coordinates. Since will find an interesting recurrence relation between the angular integral parts look a little different in the spinor Feynman propagator in (D+1)-dimensional (1+1)-, (2+1)- and general (D +1)-dimensional (for spacetime and the scalar Feynman propagators in D > 3) spacetimes, in order to be more careful in our (D + 1)- and alternate-successive dimensional space- derivation, let us consider these situations case by time. case. Eventually we will show that the general result This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, of (D+1)-dimensional spacetime holds for D = 1;2 as we will briefly review the derivation of the analytic well. formulas of the Feynman propagators of a free Klein- 2.1 (1+1)-dimensional spacetime Gordon field in (1+1)- and (2+1)-dimensional space- time, and we will compute, once and for all, the When the spatial dimension D = 1, Eq. (3) be- scalar Feynman propagator in (D + 1)-dimensional comes +1 spacetime. After completion of this work, we became dp 1 −i(Ejt|−pr) DF(t;r) = π e ; (4) aware of the analytic formula of the scalar Feynman Z−∞ 2 2E propagator in position space in arbitrary dimensional with E = pp2 +m2. Using the substitution E = m spacetime which is also given in Ref. [11]. We will cosh η, p = m sinh η (with < η < ) in the above demonstrate that our result exactly agrees with that −∞ 1 integral, we have of Ref. [11] in this section. In Section 3 we will make 1 +1 use of the obtained formula of the scalar Feynman D (t;r) = dηe−im(jtj cosh η−r sinhη): (5) F π Z propagator to compute the expression of the spinor 4 −∞ Feynman propagator in (D+1)-dimensional spacetime Due to the Lorentz invariance, the Feynman propa- and obtain a recurrence relation. We will also com- gator can depend only on the interval x2 t2 r2. ≡ − pare our result for D = 3 with that of Ref. [2], and we If the interval is timelike, x2 > 0, we can make a will show that one additional term in Ref. [2] actually Lorentz transformation such that x is purely in the has no contribution and that the method they used time-direction, x0 = θ(t)pt2 r2 i, r = 0. Note − − to prove the term nonzero was inappropriate. The that ps is not a single-valued-function of s and here last section is devoted to conclusions. and henceforth the cut line in the complex plane of s is chosen to be the negative real axis. The nega- tive infinitesimal imaginary part, i, is because of 2 Feynman propagator of Klein- − the Feynman description of the Wick rotation, i.e., Gordon theory x2 x2 i in position space and correspondingly ! − k2 k2 +i in momentum space. Thus, ! Following the notation of Refs. [1, 4], we write +1 1 −impt2−r2−i cosh η the Feynman propagator of a free Klein-Gordon field DF(t;r) = π dηe 4 Z−∞ φ(x) φ(t;~x) in (D+1)-dimensional spacetime as the i ≡ = H (2)(mpt2 r2 i); (6) time-ordered two-point correlation function, −4 0 − − (2) DF(x) 0 T φ(x)φ(0) 0 where H0 (x) is the Hankel function of the second ≡ h j j i kind, and where we have used the identity in # 3.337 = θ(x0)D(x)+θ( x0 )D( x) ; (1) − − of Ref. [12], +1 with the unordered two-point correlation function, −iβ cosh η π (2) π dηe = i H0 (β); ( < argβ < 0): (7) Z−∞ − − dDp~ 1 −i(Ep~t−p~·~x) 2 D(x) 0 φ(x)φ(0) 0 = D e : (2) Likewise, if the interval is spacelike, x < 0, we have ≡ h j j i Z (2π) 2Ep~ +1 1 impr2−t2+i sinhη Combining the above two equations gives DF(t;r) = π dηe 4 Z−∞ dDp~ 1 −i(Ep~jt|−p~·~x) 1 D (t;~x) = D( t ;~x) = e : (3) 2 2 F π D = K0(mpr t +i); (8) j j Z (2 ) 2Ep~ 2π − 1578 Chinese Physics C (HEP & NP) Vol. 34 1 2 where K0(x) is the modified Bessel function, and + θ( x2) e−mp−x +i: (16) − 4πp x2 +i where we have used the identity in # 3.714 of − Ref. [12], Eqs. (13) and (16) agree well with the results of pre- 1 π π vious work [9, 10]. dη cos(β sinhη) = K0(β); < argβ < : (9) Z0 − 2 2 2.3 (D+1)-dimensional spacetime (for D > 3) It is worthwhile noting that the i description as- − sures the proper phase angles of px2 i in Eq. (6) Now, let us proceed to compute the scalar Feyn- − and p x2 +i in Eq. (8), respectively, so that the man propagator in (D+1)-dimensional spacetime (for − mathematical identities (7) and (9) can be applied D > 3).