Solitary Confinement, Section 350, Evin Prison in Tehran
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
96 PERSPECTIVES Solitary confinement, Section 350, Evin prison in Tehran S. M. Khodaei I was born in 1985 in Tehran, Iran. I started witness the widespread use of these methods my political and human rights activism at in Iran, particularly associated to unofficial university by founding a secular student detention centers. This also goes against association and publishing student maga- international law and the Mandela rules zines. Because of this, the university discipli- regarding minimum conditions of detention, nary committee did not allow me to study which consider that any isolation that lasts for two semesters. I was arrested by intelli- for more than 15 days can by itself be gence officials in 2008 and spent 38 days in considered torture (Mendez, 2015; Penal solitary confinement in Evin prison (Teh- Reform International, 2002). ran). That was the first time I was faced with In recent years, with an increasing psychological torture. During the repression number of political prisoners and prisoners after the presidential election in 2009, I was of conscience in Iran (in particular after the arrested for a second time. It was by the elections that took place in 2009), the discus- Revolutionary Guards (‘Sepah-e- Pasdaran’) sions about the type of treatment prisoners and this time I spent about nine months in are exposed to, including solitary confine- solitary confinement. This time marked me ment is the subject of public debate. Readers in many senses. Finally, because of those two can have access to memories of political incidents, I was convicted by the Revolution- prisoners, such as Iranian prisoners, Eza`t ary Court and sentenced to prison. After Shahi, Bozorg Alavi, Safar Ghahramanian, about six years in Section 350, Evin Prison, I Taghi Shahram, Vida Hajebi and the was freed in 2014. European writers Miguel Benasayag and Solitary confinement is in fact not Arthur Koestler. allowed under state or religious law in Iran. Many people will have in mind the Article 38 of the constitution of Iran traditional methods of torture in their minds, explicitly states that, "Any kind of torture to where physical pain and suffering is used. extort confession or acquiring information is They may find it difficult to understand forbidden. Compulsion of individuals to psychological torture in general and the testify, confess or give a forced oath are not suffering of solitary confinement, in part as allowed. Such evidence, confession or oath, they are not visible. Both types of scars, is lacking credibility." i However, we still physical and psychological, can be traced many years later. In his seminal review, Shalev i Similar statements can be found in Article 9 of the 2004 (2008) pointed out that long-term psychologi- Act for Respecting Legitimate Freedoms and Protection cal damage is mainly due to social isolation. of Civil Rights, Article 129 of the Code of Criminal Reduced environmental stimuli, and loss of Procedure Act of 1999 and 578 and 579 of the Islamic Penal Code, adopted section 1996. Additionally, the control in daily needs. The absence of external Court of Administrative Justice in judicial precedent No. stimuli leads to the brain stimulating itself, 435/2004 explicitly prohibits defendants and convicts through dreams and hallucinations (Grassian, being housed in solitary confinement. TORTURE Volume 27, Number 2, 2017 Correspondence to: [email protected] 1983). White torture can lead to permanent 97 PERSPECTIVES impairments in brain activity including solitary confinement was 7.2 months on damage to the brain tissue (O'Mara, 2009). average. They were all young men (average Human Rights Watch and others have age 38.6, maximum 54, minimum 22) reported to the US Senate Judiciary Commit- detained for political and non-political tee that a large number of people who reasons. Half of them had had a previous remained in solitary confinement are mentally experience of solitary confinement. ill, even though they did not have a history of We define solitary confinement in Iran, at mental illness, and that there are more least among the people whom I interviewed suicides in solitary confinement (Human and in my own experience, as being held in Rights Watch, 2009; United Nations Special complete isolation with only contact with Rapporteur, 2007; Grassian, 2014). guards and sometimes interrogators for long It is not the purpose of this paper to periods of time, or being permanently held in review the existing medical and psychiatric a cell with less than one hour of access to a literature on solitary confinement. It would be yard while being blindfolded. simply impossible. Big book sellers, including Amazon, do not serve Iran. We do not have Conditions of detention access to medical databases and only partial The physical space and facilities of solitary access to Internet providers. This paper wants confinement vary, but there were some key to add to the existing literature on solitary elements that configure the experience of confinement by describing the experience and detainees (in brackets is the number of the impacts in a sample of 16 Iranian survivors. interviewee): • Size of room and bathroom: "The first few Talking with others who have days, my cell was relatively large, so that in experienced solitary confinement the morning I could walk around it, in a Method corner of the cell, the bathroom was During the period 2013 and 2014, and while separated by a wall, but then I was I had been transferred from solitary confine- transferred to a tiny cell that was about 2 ment to the communal ward, I spoke with 16 feet by 4 feet without a wash basin and male prisoners who had also been in Ward toilet. Each time I wanted to go to the 350 of Evin Prison and had also experienced toilet, I should drop out paper for this solitary confinement during the preceding purpose from under the door until the five years. I talked to them following a brief guards realized..." semi-structured interview and tried to • No human interaction: "Loneliness too systematize information in as far as my own bothered me, I wanted to talk to someone. I TORTURE Volume 27, Number 2, 2017 conditions of access to pen and paper and talked to the officer who was in charge of security concerns with the materials obtained food distribution, about receiving more or allowed. These conditions were not optimal less food until eventually he was forced to but the information during these talks was speak. Sometimes I would tell a lie that I straight and honest among co-detainees. needed the toilet which would force a prison Thus, the data lacks the accuracy of an officer to talk to me, at least, one sentence, academic study, but gives unique insights as but talking was very hard and sometimes it has been done and written, in many senses, they did not answer my questions”. by prisoners within the prison. • Social isolation: "I was 42 days in solitary The period of time that they had been in confinement. During this period, only two 98 PERSPECTIVES or three times for less than five minutes was piece of fabric that was used as a blindfold. I able to talk with my family. After I was I felt very bad, could not see anything. transferred to the general ward, I realized Everywhere I went, someone took my arm that I was lucky that I had that possibility firmly, dragging and leading me. Later, I because others - even over a period of learned I could do up my blindfold enough months had no contact with their family." to see the front of my foot. After many • Cultural isolation:“The first two-three times of nearly falling over and hitting the months, not even religious books were in ground, the guard allowed me to use the my cell. It was very bad. In the yard or in blindfold only in the yard and, when I went the trash outside the cell, I looked for a into the bathroom, I did not have to be piece of paper so I could sneak away with blindfolded inside the cell." myself. It was the fourth month after • Natural light: “During the nearly three repeatedly insisting, I got once a newspa- years that I was in solitary confinement I per and in the last month I was allowed to was moved to a different cell several times. go to the cell where there was a television." The worst was that the cells had no • Lack of intimacy: “Once in a cell, behind the windows facing out and there was no sink, I found a pack of matches and turned natural light into the cell.” This was not a one of them to for entertainment (sic). After general experience and it was used as a a few minutes the guards rushed into my special way of punishment. "There was a cells and asked how did I get matches?...then fairly large window near the ceiling of my I realized that in the cells, there must be a cell covered with lattice steel. Sunlight camera … and, after searching, I found a came into my cell. Sometimes I heard the small camera somewhere near the ceiling." sound of doves and threw grains of rice • Sensory overload - Troubling sounds: The through the window. Trying to give them detainees reported highly disturbing food, was a kind of entertainment for me." sounds: voices and screaming in the • System of rewards: Food quality and buying hallway, the sound of the religious Ashura things were conditioned and only possible mourning ceremonies, and the sound of with the authorization of the interrogation the air conditioner. “We had to hear the team. “I was detained in several detention religious ceremonies that were broadcasted centers.