www.captiveinsurancetimes.com
The primary source of global captive insurance news and analysis 06 January 2021 - Issue 214
The gold standard
of the southTennessee’s director of captive insurance Belinda Fortman discusses the state’s latest milestone of 700 risk bearing entities
District of Columbia | New and Emerging Risks | 2021 Predictions | Industry Appointments The World’s Leading Independent Captive Manager
SRS Europe is changing the Face of European Captive Management
Specialist focus on captive insurance management and consultancy... It’s all we do
Offering impartial advice and bespoke solutions without conflicting internal vested interests... It’s how we do it
Driven by client service excellence underpinned by flexible, innovative and solid delivery... It’s focused on you
Our Services European Operations
Captive management Ireland Feasibility studies Liechtenstein Program management Luxembourg and underwriting services Malta Governance, risk & Netherlands compliance consulting Sweden Strategic reviews Switzerland
Find out why over 500 captive clients trust SRS
strategicrisks.com Captive Insurance Times
Issue 214
www.captiveinsurancetimes.com
Published by Black Knight Media Ltd 16 Bromley Road, New Beckenham Beckenham, BR3 5JE
Editorial Editor: Becky Bellamy [email protected] Tel: +44 (0)208 075 0927
Reporter: Maria Ward-Brennan [email protected] Tel: +44 (0)208 075 0923
Contributor: Maddie Saghir [email protected]
Designer: James Hickman [email protected]
Marketing and sales Publisher: Justin Lawson [email protected]
Associate Publisher: John Savage [email protected] Tel: +44 (0)208 075 0932
Office Manager: Chelsea Bowles Tel: +44 (0)208 075 0930
Follow us on Twitter: @CITimes
Copyright © 2021 Black Knight Media Ltd All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without permission in writing from the publisher. Company reg: 0719464
www.captiveinsurancetimes.com WE KNOW CAPTIVE INSURANCE.
For more than 70 years, no firm has had a more complete understanding of the captive and self- insured market than Milliman. With our global reach, we routinely advise multinationals on cross-border transactions and how to meet each domicile’s unique requirements—key in today’s captive environment.
milliman.com/captives [email protected]
1349PCP_Captive Review_20200211.indd 1 2/12/20 12:09 PM Contents
News Focus
page 7
In this issue Tennessee Focus
Tennessee’s director of captive insurance
Belinda Fortman discusses the state’s latest
milestone of 700 risk bearing entities
page 15
District of Columbia
With a ‘very active’ captive market in 2020, DC
plans to launch a financial services regulatory
sandbox this year that will include captives
page 19
2021 Predictions
As a new year begins, the captive industry
anticipates another year of growth
page 24
New and Emerging Risks Industry Appointments There has been an increase in business interruption coverage after The latest people moves in the captive the COVID-19 pandemic caused large disruption for many firms page 21 insurance industry page 28
Set up an EU based protected cell with the independent experts Capital, time & cost efficient alternative to a standalone insurer or captive Direct access to the UK and EU market
People you can trust
Contact us on t: +356 2343 5221 | e: [email protected] | www.atlaspcc.eu
Atlas Insurance PCC Limited is a cell company authorised by the Malta Financial Services Authority to carry on general insurance business.
5 www.captiveinsurancetimes.com News Focus
WRCIC to host in-person captive conference in June
The Western Region Captive Insurance opportunities, and sessions in advanced topics stated: “We are honoured to continue to be Conference (WRCIC) is moving forward with that focus on hot topics, trends, and the next part of this great conference and look for- plans for a multi-state in-person conference level in captive insurance. ward to having the 2021 conference in Salt scheduled for 14 to 16 June, in Salt Lake City, Lake City.” Utah. Last year’s conference was cancelled Brandy Alderson, president of the Utah Captive due to the COVID-19 pandemic. According to Insurance Association, and WRCIC conference “The WRCIC committee works hard to create con- WRCIC, organisers will monitor and assess the chair, said: “We are very eager to host the 2021 ference sessions that are structured to provide safety of an in-person event being possible WRCIC conference in Utah in June if it is safe to substantive captive education for owners, pro- and keep all registered attendees updated as do so. The WRCIC continues to serve the entire viders, regulators, and friends.” summer approaches. western US, working together to enhance collab- oration, cooperation, and best practices.” “We invite you to attend this outstand- At next year’s event, WRCIC said new educational ing conference and share insights and content will be offered including an enhanced Rae Brown, president of the Arizona Captive challenges with your peers and industry experts,” captive 101 boot camp, more networking Insurance Association, and WRCIC board chair, Brown added. ■
WHAT CAN SPRING DO FOR YOU?
PROPERTY & EMPLOYEE RISK CASUALTY BENEFITS MANAGEMENT
WHO WE ARE WHAT WE DO ACTUARIAL An industry leading Develop customized SERVICES insurance, employee solutions that assist benefits, risk organizations with employee health and management and productivity, compliance, INSURANCE actuarial consulting firm. health plan design, and risk funding and BROKERAGE mitigation.
ABSENCE FUNDING & BENCHMARKING MANAGEMENT CAPTIVES
Get in touch 617-589-0930 30 Federal Street, Boston MA www.springgroup.com
6 www.captiveinsurancetimes.com News Focus
GFSC introduces scheme for pre- authorisation for insurance cells
The Guernsey Financial Services Commission (GFSC) has introduced a pilot scheme for pre-authorisation for insurance cells. Artex in Guernsey has already implemented a captive cell solution within 48 hours of its introduction.
The scheme applies to insurance-licensed PCCs owned by an insurance manager and is avail- able for captive cells writing a single line of general insurance business to meet an urgent business need.
It must meet the standard formula mini- mum capital requirement and prescribed
capital requirement, with no regulatory cycle. Guernsey’s proactive approach to cell for- ESG is rising up the agenda of European adjustments available. mation works,” he added. captive owners
GFSC consulted with the Guernsey insur- Kate Storey, partner at law firm Walkers in Environmental, social and governance (ESG) con- ance industry and the Guernsey International Guernsey, who was involved, as part of GIIA, siderations are rising up the corporate agenda of Insurance Association (GIIA). in the initiative, said: “We proposed this new, captive owners amid increased scrutiny from con- swift-authorisation regime in response to the sumers and regulatory authorities, according to The pilot is expected to run until the end of huge increase in demand for captive insurance an A.M. Best report on European captives. this year. vehicles, particularly over the last 12 months, due to commercial insurers raising their rates The report explained that a captive’s approach to The GFSC, said: “We are happy to work with and restricting available cover in the so-called ESG is often closely linked with that of its parent. industry on this type of initiative in instances ‘hard market’.” where it can be done without endangering pol- In Europe, the implementation of the EU icyholder protections.” She continued: “Using a captive vehicle, a Directive 2014/95/EU sets out the disclosure business can self-insure in a way tailor-made requirements of non-financial and diversity infor- GIIA chairman, Mike Johns, noted that the pilot to its business, and more cost-effectively than mation for large companies. would give managers a route to act quickly and through commercial insurers.” avoid missed opportunities to assist clients The directive does not apply directly to captives, with urgent issues. “Guernsey is already a global leader in the but A.M. Best revealed an increasing number captives market and now offers the ability to are considering incorporating ESG factors into “This flexible approach to regulation enables set up and start writing insurance in as little their operations. brokers and their clients to react to adverse as 48 hours on a pre-authorised basis, pro- market developments right up until the vided the documentation complying with the The report suggested there has been a rise in the renewal date. This will be an invaluable tool to regime is provided to the Guernsey regulator number of captives owners that have integrated enable buyers to increase their control over dif- within 14 days of commencement of business,” ESG factors in their operations, influencing areas ficult renewals during the current hard market Storey added. ■ such as corporate governance and investments.
7 images by bonandbon/stock.adobe.com and mimadeo/stock.adobe.com www.captiveinsurancetimes.com Truist Corporate Trust & Escrow Services Our Advantage
Truist has a long history of trust, escrow and risk management excellence with both domestic and international coverage. If you’re choosing a cost effective and convenient collateral trust as part of Collateral your captive and reinsurance solution, we have a broad range of specialties that can help mitigate risk in your insurance business: • Collateralized Reinsurance Trust Services • Regulation 114 Trusts • Captives • Surety Bonds • Insurance-Linked Securities • Deductible Trusts
Our expertise is only one aspect of what differentiates our reinsurance trust business from other firms. Additionally, we excel because of: • Single Point of Contact • Comprehensive Servicing • Rapid Response Times • Team of Reinsurance Specialists • Extensive Carrier Relationships
To learn more about how Truist can support and enhance your collateral posting requirements, please contact:
Donny Tong Senior Vice President 212-590-0976 [email protected]
Barbara Aubry Senior Vice President 212-303-4164 [email protected]
Joseph Monaco Vice President 212-303-1746 [email protected]
SunTrust Private Wealth Management is a marketing name used by Truist Financial Corporation and the following affiliates: Banking products and services, including loans and deposit accounts, are provided by SunTrust Bank and Branch Banking and Trust Company, both now Truist Bank, Member FDIC. Trust and investment management services are provided by SunTrust Bank and Branch Banking and Trust Company, both now Truist Bank and SunTrust Delaware Trust Company. Securities, brokerage accounts and /or insurance (including annuities) are offered by SunTrust Investment Services, Inc., BB&T Securities, LLC, and P.J. Robb Variable Corp., which are SEC registered broker-dealers, members FINRA, SIPC, and a licensed insurance agency where applicable. Investment advisory services are offered by SunTrust Advisory Services, Inc., GFO Advisory Services, LLC, BB&T Securities, LLC, Sterling Capital Management, LLC, Precept Advisory Group, LLC, and BB&T Institutional Investment Advisors, Inc., each SEC registered investment advisers. BB&T Sterling Advisors, BB&T Investments and BB&T Scott & Stringfellow are divisions of BB&T Securities, LLC. Mutual fund products are advised by Sterling Capital Management, LLC. © 2020 Truist Financial Corporation. SunTrust®, the SunTrust logo and Truist are service marks of Truist Financial Corporation. All rights reserved. News Focus
Zurich set to acquire MetLife’s US P&C A.M. Best said: “This has an indirect effect on captives, with many of them holding a large Zurich Insurance Group subsidiary Farmers Following the transaction, Zurich’s capital part of their investments in inter-company Group has agreed to acquire MetLife’s prop- position is expected to remain strong with loans, with the underlying assets invested by erty and casualty (P&C) business in the US the pro-forma Swiss Solvency Test ratio as of their parents.” together with the Farmers Exchanges for September 30, 2020, at around 190 percent. $3.94 billion. A change in a captive parent’s operations, in an Completion of the transaction is subject to reg- effort to manage transition risk in industries such Zurich will contribute $2.43 billion through ulatory approvals and is anticipated to occur in as oil and gas, can have a knock-on effect on their Farmers Group and the Farmers Exchanges the Q2 2021. The purchase price is subject to insurance needs. $1.51 billion. certain adjustments. “Ultimately, this would require a captive to adapt The transaction is said to give Farmers In November last year, Zurich confirmed it was accordingly,” the rating firm added. Exchanges a nationwide presence and access in discussions to acquire MetLife’s US P&C busi- to new distribution channels with the potential ness. At the time, they refused to comment on Captives might also consider including ESG into to accelerate growth. the cost of the transaction. their operations because of the growing number of commercial (re)insurers formally integrating The transaction also includes a 10-year Commenting on the transaction, Mario Greco, ESG factors in their strategy. exclusive distribution agreement through Zurich Group CEO, said: “The acquisition sig- which the Farmers Exchanges will offer nificantly increases the potential for growth at The report explained that a consequence of their personal lines products on MetLife’s the Farmers Exchanges and will further boost this might be capacity shortages in some lines US group benefits platform, which the share of Zurich’s profits linked to stable fee- of business or sectors, which could create busi- today reaches 3,800 companies and 37 based earnings.” ness opportunities for captives in so-called million employees. “toxic” industries. He continued: “Together with the continued Farmers Exchanges stated that they expect increase in rates in commercial insurance, It was noted that captives should assess ESG to become the sixth-largest personal lines this transaction will strengthen our ability to exposures as part of their risk management insurer in the US with access to MetLife’s achieve our 2022 targets.” activities and be able to recognise, measure and network of agents. The business to be address the impact on their business. acquired includes 2.4 million policies, $3.6 ”The acquisition of MetLife’s P&C business is a billion net written premiums in 2019 and unique opportunity to accelerate growth and A.M. Best suggested that failure to do so can 3,500 employees. to achieve a significant presence in all 50 states,” “present significant risks”, be they financial said Jeff Dailey, CEO of Farmers Group. or reputational. The acquisition is expected to contribute to Zurich’s earnings from the first full year after He concluded: “MetLife’s distribution channels Cyber risk and environmental liability are completion and is expected to deliver Zurich a complement the Farmers Exchanges’ exist- just some of the new areas of coverage for return on investment of approximately 10 per- ing strength in the exclusive agent channel, captives,and as such will require a fresh consid- cent from 2023. deepen their presence in the fast-growing eration of ESG factors for operators. independent agent channel and provides Zurich expects to fund Farmers Group’s por- entry into the worksite marketing channel “Captives will need to be conversant with the tion of the acquisition through a roughly via a leading platform, with the 10-year exclu- potential impact of aspects like these on equal combination of internal resources and sive distribution agreement through MetLife underwriting and investment exposures,” A.M. hybrid debt. group benefits.” ■ Best added. ■
9 www.captiveinsurancetimes.com Industry Appointments
News Focus
brings 40 years of actuarial experience in the re/insurance industry to Aspen. Maiden Holdings forms new solution led by former SOBC DARAG specialists Prior to managing his own consulting firm, Maiden Holdings, a Bermuda-based hold- The GLS team has extensive experience in the andhe served effective as claimsexecutive management vice president services, and but ing company, has formed Genesis Legacy finality and legacy solutions segment, most itgroup will also chief increase actuary our at asset Validus base Groupthrough from the Solutions (GLS). recently at SOBC DARAG, and specialises in solu- addition2010 to of2019. blocks He of alsoreserves held or various companies senior- that tions-oriented for smaller insurance companies. canlevel be roles successfully for Fireman’s wound down.” Fund, Endurance, and KPMG. GLS will specialise in providing a full range of
legacy services to small US insurance entities, Maiden’s co-CEO Patrick Haveron stated: “The for- HaveronMark Cloutier, added: “Thisexecutive should furtherchairman enhance and particularly those in run-off or with blocks of mationAndrew of GLSKudera is highly has complementary been appointed to our ourgroup ability chief to pursueexecutive the officer,asset and commented: capital man- reserves that are no longer core, working with overallexecutive longer-term vice presidentstrategy. GLS, and along group with agement“Welcoming pillars an of ourindustry-leading strategy. The GLS expert team clients to develop and implement finality solu- otherchief recent actuary insurance of industry Aspen investments, Insurance are bringsof Andy a wealth Kudera’s of knowledge, quality experienceto our team and Holdings (Aspen), effective 3 increases our capabilities, allowing us tions including acquiring entire companies. enabling Maiden to leverage its knowledge base well-known market presence that should enable February 2020. to transform our business, simplify and while not re-entering active underwriting and them to quickly activate its strategy.” enhance our operations, and increase The new team will be led by Brian Johnston as maintainingAspen’s previous an efficient group operatingchief actuary, profile.” Paul accountability across these functions.” CEO and chief financial officer, joined by Tom Frydas, will assume the new role of chief “We are excited to have the GLS team join Maiden Hodson as deputy CEO and general counsel and Lawrenceanalytics Metz,officer Maiden’s and will co-CEO, lead noted: strategic “We and“Kudera’s look forward capabilities to supporting Brianand Johnston,fresh Stephanie Mocatta as executive vice-president, believepricing, the aggregation GLS team will management not only enhance and Tomperspective, Hodson, Stephanie paired Mocattawith andPaul the Frydas’ team in modelling. Frydas will remain chief actuary considerable expertise and experience, leading GLS’s business development. Maiden’s profitability through both fee income developing and growing GLS,” Metz concluded. ■ for Aspen Insurance UK, Aspen Managing will create a strong partnership across Agency and Aspen Bermuda.Kudera complementary disciplines,” he adds.
In Utah, we understand that Utah is recognized as an innovative Utah Captive Insurance, companies are sophisticated and state, fostering and supporting able to take greater control of their innovative solutions. If you are 3110 State Office Building, own insurance risks. It is our goal looking for an on-shore domicile to to provide affordable, diverse and form a captive insurance company, a flexible solutions that protect against Utah domiciled captive is the choice Salt Lake City, any company’s dynamic business for you, where Risk Management, Cost environment. Control, and Regulation connect. UT 84114
40 Captive Insurance Times - Issue 192 10 www.captiveinsurancetimes.com B++ Good News Focus
EIOPA: Solvency II needs a number of adjustments
The Solvency II framework is “working well and insurance and reinsurance undertakings under obligations of the captive insurance or captive no fundamental changes are needed at this point Article 35 following a risk-based approach. reinsurance undertaking do not relate to any in time”, according to the European Insurance compulsory third party liability insurance. and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA), but Limitations included reporting on invest- it has said a number of adjustments are required ments and derivatives; reporting assets and EIOPA added that with regard to further pro- to ensure that the regulatory framework contin- liabilities by currency; reporting Information portionality measures applicable to reinsurance ues as a well-functioning risk-based regime. on annuities stemming from non-life Insurance undertakings may only be used if captive rein- obligations; reporting information on annuities surance undertakings meet the criteria and The comments were made in EIOPA’s opinion stemming from non-life insurance obligations; other conditions. The further conditions were on the Solvency II 2020 Review to the European on Solvency Capital Requirement - non-life and noted as: the policyholders of the reinsurance Commission (EC). Health catastrophe risk; and reporting on varia- contracts are legal entities of the group (i.e. the tion analysis. parent company or other entities of the indus- On captive insurance, EIOPA stated that the trial group to which the captive belongs); loans EC should clarify the specific requirements EIOPA stated that captive insurance undertakings in place with the parent or any group company applicable to captive insurance and captive and captive reinsurance undertakings as defined do not exceed 20 percent of total assets held by reinsurance undertakings. in points (2) and (5) of Article 13 of the Solvency the captive, groups cash pools included; and II Directive may use the proportionality require- the maximum loss resulting from the exposures In its technical advice, EIOPA asked for the intro- ments if certain requirements are met. can be deterministically assessed without use duction of a new article requiring insurance and of stochastic methods (i.e. limits to losses cov- reinsurance undertakings, other than captive In relation to the insurance obligations of the ered are included in the reinsurance contracts insurance and captive reinsurance undertakings, captive insurance undertaking or captive reinsur- in place). as a minimum to subject the balance-sheet to ance undertaking, these requirements include all audit or similar requirements as decided by the insured and beneficiaries are legal entities of the EIOPA stated that it closely consulted with a relevant member state with a report submitted group or natural persons eligible to be covered wide range of stakeholders when drawing up to the supervisory authority. under the group insurance policies of which the its opinion. captive insurance or captive reinsurance under- It was highlighted that for captive insurance and taking is part, as long as the business covering Commenting on the opinion, Gabriel Bernardino, captive reinsurance undertakings member states natural persons eligible to be covered under the chairman of EIOPA, said: “EIOPA’s opinion on the should be allowed to decide if audit require- group insurance policies remains immaterial; 2020 Solvency II review achieves all the defined ments should apply or not. objectives: adapts the regime to the new interest For reinsurance obligations of the captive rate market reality; creates conditions for more Captive undertakings, “due to typical interna- insurance or captive reinsurance undertaking, long-term investment; brings a paradigm shift tional nature of their business”, most of the time requirements state that all insured and benefi- on the application of proportionality; and com- based on reinsurance, should not be required to ciaries of the insurance contracts underlying the pletes the European insurance framework with fulfil the crossborder and reinsurance criteria. reinsurance obligations are legal entities of the a macro-dimension and proposals on recovery group of which the captive insurance or captive and resolution and insurance guarantee schemes.” Regarding captives, EIOPA proposed the EC to reinsurance undertaking is part. introduce the following limitations and exemp- He added: “Most importantly, these adjust- tions into the supervisory reporting on top of Finally, the insurance obligations and the insur- ments will ensure that Solvency II will the limitations/exemptions given to captive ance contracts underlying the reinsurance continue to be a credible and fit for purpose
12 www.captiveinsurancetimes.com News Focus
regime, capable of protecting policyholders The system is based on a forward-looking and and contributing to market stability even in risk-based approach, requiring the highest risk stress situations.“ management standards and active monitor- ing and steering of the risk an insurer is facing. The Solvency II directive, which came into It ensures fair competition and consistent con- effect on 1 January 2016, is a European Union sumer protection across the EU and allows law that codifies and harmonises the EU insurers to provide their product cross-border. insurance regulation. However, Solvency II has added a lot of complex- Solvency II was a milestone for European insur- ity to the process and structures of companies ance regulation and supervision. and supervisors, presenting a significant regula- tory burden. The directive is the first common supervisory framework in the EU and sets global standards. In February 2019, the EC called for EIOPA to pro- It sets the basis for the integration of the single vide technical advice for a comprehensive review market for insurance in Europe. of the Solvency II Directive. ■
THE MIDWEST’S BEST-KEPT SECRET AT BROWN SMITH WALLACE, our comprehensive tax, insurance and audit services team helps maximize the return on investment for captive insurers. Our integrated approach includes ongoing operational reviews, tax consulting and regulatory audits.
Looking for cost-effective, high-quality services?
Let our team’s industry-leading expertise enhance the performance of your captive program. Contact us today.
BROWNSMITHWALLACE.COM | 1.888.279.2792 | A TOP 100 ACCOUNTING FIRM
13 www.captiveinsurancetimes.com abuan International Business and Financial Centre abuan IBFC offers global investors and businesses the benefits of being in a well-regulated midshore international business and financial centre, which provides fiscal neutrality and certainty, in addition to being an ideal location for substance creation.