Expansion of Disability Across Successive Mexican Birth Cohorts: A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Research report J Epidemiol Community Health: first published as 10.1136/jech-2019-212245 on 20 July 2019. Downloaded from Expansion of disability across successive Mexican birth cohorts: a longitudinal modelling analysis of birth cohorts born 10 years apart Collin F Payne, 1 Rebeca Wong2,3 ► Additional material is ABSTRact health and increasing chronic conditions among published online only. To view, Background Life expectancy (LE) in Mexico has risen older adults. The prevalence of hypertension, please visit the journal online (http:// dx. doi. org/ 10. 1136/ rapidly since the 1950s. In high-income contexts, these diabetes and hypercholesterolaemia all increased jech- 2019- 212245). increases have coincided with a compression of disability markedly in prevalence among older individuals to later ages. However, little evidence on trends in between 2000 and 2012,4 and diabetes prevalence 1 School of Demography, disability-free LE (DFLE) exist from Mexico or elsewhere among those aged 60+ years has continued to rise.5 Australian National University, in Latin America. Canberra, Australian Capital Rising trends in obesity have been implicated in a Territory, Australia Methods Using data from the Mexican Health and substantial burden of excess mortality among the 2Department of Preventive Aging Study, we compare changes in LE and DFLE in population aged 60+ years,6 and are projected to Medicine and Community ages 50–59, 60–69 and 70–79 using birth-cohort- have negative effects on future trends in LE.7 Rates Health, The University of Texas specific multistate lifetable models across successive of dementia incidence are high in Mexico compared Medical Branch, Galveston, 8 Texas, USA 10-year birth cohorts. Disability was measured using the with higher-income populations, and dementia 3WHO/PAHO Collaborating Katz activities of daily living (ADL) index, and limitation cases are set to rise rapidly across Latin America Center on Aging and Health, was measured using a seven-item questionnaire on in the coming decades due to demographic and Galveston, Texas, United States physical functioning. health transitions.9 Gains in LE have also stagnated Results Overall, Mexican adults born in 1953–1962 in Mexico, in recent years, due to persistently high Correspondence to lived 0.87 (p<0.001) fewer active years between ages Dr Collin F Payne, School rates of interpersonal violence and a rapid increase 10–13 of Demography, Australian 50 and 59 than individuals born in 1942–1951, a in obesity and diabetes mellitus. National University, Canberra, difference comprised of a 0.54-year (p<0.001) increase In the classical epidemiological transition, expan- copyright. ACT 0200, Australia; Collin. in physically limited LE and a 0.27-year (p<0.001) sion in LE was thought to result in a compression Payne@ anu. edu. au increase in ADL-disabled LE. Active LE declined by 1.13 of disability to a smaller portion of late life, with (p<0.001) years in ages 60–69, and by 0.93 (p<0.001) Received 6 February 2019 medical advances and improved health behaviours Revised 30 May 2019 years in ages 70–79, across successive 10-year birth increasing the age of onset of morbidity or disability Accepted 19 June 2019 cohorts. No substantial changes in total LE were seen in more quickly than rises in LE.14 Evidence suggests any age group, and the magnitude of the expansion of that this compression is broadly occurring in many disability was larger in females than in males. high-income contexts,15–18 though evidence is mixed Conclusions Our results indicate that more recently 19–21 in the USA, particularly at late-middle ages. born cohorts of Mexican adults are spending more years A different theoretical viewpoint, predicting an of life with physical limitations and disabilities. These expansion of disability or morbidity, has also been http://jech.bmj.com/ results foreshadow a need to closely monitor adult put forward.22 This theory posits that reductions in health in middle-income contexts, as the epidemiological early-life mortality may lead individuals with worse conditions under which disability has expanded in health to survive longer than they would have in the Mexico are similar to those seen in many other countries. past. This second viewpoint needs consideration in the case of Mexico. Prior research on Latin America has found that over half of the post-1945 mortality INTRODUCTION decline was associated directly with the adoption of on September 24, 2021 by guest. Protected The population of older adults in Mexico is one medical technologies that reduced infant and child of the most rapidly growing in the world.1 Life mortality (eg, antibiotics, vaccination and pesticides expectancy (LE) has risen rapidly over the last for malaria control), as opposed to resulting from 23 half-century, and currently, stands at 79 years for broad social and economic development. This females and 73 years for males,1 up from 50 and legacy of improved survivorship, but slow develop- © Author(s) (or their 47 years, respectively, in 1950. In Mexico, and ment, may lead to successive cohorts at higher risk employer(s)) 2019. Re-use throughout Latin America, population ageing is of morbidity and disability in Latin America, as the permitted under CC BY-NC. No occurring at a much faster pace than economic delayed effects of poor childhood conditions have commercial re-use. See rights a lasting imprint on underlying health.24–26 Indeed, and permissions. Published development, resulting in severe restrictions on the 2 by BMJ. pool of resources available to care for older adults. the continued effects of these poor early-life condi- Providing care and support for this growing elderly tions may in part be behind the rapid rises in cardio- To cite: Payne CF, Wong R. J population is one of the largest public health chal- vascular disease, obesity and diabetes observed in Epidemiol Community Health 3 27 28 Epub ahead of print: [please lenges facing Latin America today. the region. include Day Month Year]. Though the long-term trend in survival of older In this paper, we use data from the Mexican doi:10.1136/jech-2019- Mexicans shows marked improvements, a growing Health and Aging Study (MHAS), a long-run- 212245 body of evidence finds a recent pattern of declining ning longitudinal sample survey of older adults in Payne CF, Wong R. J Epidemiol Community Health 2019;0:1–6. doi:10.1136/jech-2019-212245 1 Research report J Epidemiol Community Health: first published as 10.1136/jech-2019-212245 on 20 July 2019. Downloaded from Mexico,29 to examine whether successive birth cohorts in the DFLE in ages 50–59 for those born in 1942–1951 (who were Mexican population are living more of their life with physical aged 50–59 in the 2001 MHAS) and those born in 1953–1962 limitations and/or disability. Our analyses focus on measuring (the new sample of 50–59 year-olds added in the 2012 MHAS). disability-free LE (DFLE) across birth cohorts in the Mexican We model the conditional annual probability of experiencing a population. DFLE distinguishes between years that are free transition between the four modelled states (active, physically of limitations and years with activity limitations or disability, limited, ADL disabled and deceased) as a function of age and providing a metric that combines mortality and disability into gender, separately by birth cohort and observation period (2001– a single measure. We compare cohort changes in disability and 2003 and 2012–2015, outlined in the dark dashed line), using a longevity using data from two distinct periods (2001–2003 and cumulative logistic regression model with a relaxed proportional 2012–2015) to understand whether the Mexican population is odds assumption on gender,34 and stratified by initial health experiencing a compression or expansion of disability. state. Transitions between health states are assumed to occur at a random time between observations. Transition probability METHODS estimates were obtained using PROC SURVEYLOGISTIC in SAS Study participants V.9.4. In all analyses, in this paper, the cohorts are distinct—that Data came from the MHAS.29 MHAS is a Health and Retire- is, there are no individuals contributing person-years of obser- ment Study, sister study of adults aged 50+ years, with waves of vation to the two different cohorts compared in each age-range. These observed transition probabilities are then used as the data in 2001, 2003, 2012 and 2015. Our analyses use individ- 35–37 uals who were interviewed in both 2001 and 2003 or who died input for a microsimulation-based multistate life table model. between waves (N=14 250, response rate 93%), and individ- To calculate LE and DFLE, we create synthetic cohorts of 100 uals who were interviewed in both 2012 and 2015 or who died 000 individuals with the same initial gender and health state between waves (N=15 168, response rate 88%). A refresher distribution as the study population in a given age-range and sample of 6259 new individuals (primarily aged 50–59) was cohort. We then ‘age’ these individuals forward year by year via added in 2012. microsimulation, applying the age-specific and gender-specific mortality rates and probabilities of transitioning in and out of disability estimated from the data. This process is then repeated Measures until the end of the age-range under study—that is, when inves- We conceptualise disability within the framework of the disable- 30 tigating DFLE for a given cohort in ages 50–59, the model will ment process, with disability defined as a gap between an microsimulate the life-courses of 100 000 individuals starting at individual’s capacities and the demands of a given activity. Indi- age 50 and ending at exact age 60.