DOCSLIB.ORG

In David Lodge's Novels

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
In David Lodge's Novels Science and Education a New Dimension. Philology, V(35), Issue: 125, 2017 www.seanewdim.com Sexuality as ‘universal illness’ in David Lodge’s novels O. V. Uzlova Kyiv National Linguistic University Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected] Paper received 25.03.17; Revised 30.03.17; Accepted for publication 01.04.17. Abstract. The paper tackles the problem of correlation between sexuality and illness in the writings by contemporary British author David Lodge. In his novels body is represented in the narrative, discursive and aesthetic strategies, as well as underlying semantic structures of the text. Drawing upon the novels Therapy, Thinks, Author, Author, Deaf Sentence and A Man of Parts, it is argued that sexuality is regarded as a ‘universal illness’. The analysis of the texts under consideration shows that sex in the novels of former Catholic David Lodge is often considered to be a sin or a moral crime that should be followed by punishment. Keywords: D. Lodge, body, illness, disease, sexuality Introduction. Scientific theories as well as fiction of the of life. Different diseases, including erectile dysfunction, late 20th century give special attention to the problem of not only point to physical degradation as a result of natu- representation of sexuality, as well as ill and deviant bod- ral processes, but function to represent the idiosphere of ies. In modernist texts body was a repository for I- the texts under consideration. consciousness and controversial desires, but in postmod- As a matter of fact, D. Lodge used the representation ernist fiction it is mostly regarded as deviant, performa- of erectile dysfunction in his earlier novels, too. In Small tive or virtual. Moreover, sexual behaviour is often re- World Arthur Kingfisher’s sexual and intellectual sterility garded as a reflection of moral health or illness. The symbolizes ‘a very un’ealthy condition’ of ‘the whole common feature of David Lodge’s novels taken into con- profession of academic literary studies’ [6, p. 119]. It is sideration is their peculiar interest in such corporal and also significant that the protagonists of two novels (Ther- sociocultural experiences as sex, ageing and illness. apy and Deaf Sentence) face erectile dysfunction exactly Overview of related works. Although there had been when their careers and personal relationships are going earlier studies, the poetic features of D. Lodge’s recent downhill. As S. Žižek aptly notes, the “symptom arises novels have not yet become the object of focused scholar- where the world failed, where the circuit of the symbolic ly interest. European critics and literary scholars communication was broken” [10, p. 73]. (B. Bergonzi, R. Todd, M. Goch, E. L. Bjork, A. Quinn, Quite often one partner’s affliction can cause the inver- H. Mantel, L. Lerner, F. Holmes, J. Mellors) pay attention sion of gender roles. That is exactly what happens to the mostly to D. Lodge’s novels written in the period of main character of Deaf Sentence and his wife. Having 1960-1984 regarding them as a complex symbiosis of taken early retirement because of progressive loss of hear- fictional and theoretical discourses. ing, former professor of linguistics Desmond Bates be- The object of investigation of the majority of Ukraini- comes a kind of a housewife. The improvement of his an and Russian scholars are certain poetic features of spouse’s appearance and her business success that seem to Lodge’s campus trilogy (O. Bandrovska, O. Luxembourg, run parallel to the protagonist’s physical and social de- V. Novikov, N. Solovyova, O. Masliaeva, V. Horolskiy, cline make him aware not only of the age gap, but also of O.Sydorova, O. Tolstyh), as well as certain aspects of his the increasing estrangement between them. At the begin- theoretical works representing the development of West- ning of the novel his wife seems to take the lead in the ern literary process in the final decades of the 20th century relationship with a submissive man. “When he accompa- (I. Ilyin, N. Vladimirova, I. Kabanova, V. Strukov, nied her to this or that social event he sometimes felt like Y. Muratova). Therefore, the comprehensive analysis of a royal consort escorting a female monarch, walking a D. Lodge’s latest fiction and theory is one of important pace or two behind her with his hands joined behind his tasks facing present-day English studies. Despite a great back, a vague unfocused smile on his face” [5, p. 33]. The number of works exploring D. Lodges earlier texts, the dominant role played by female characters surrounding functions of ill body in his novels have never been the Desmond is exaggerated by the male forms of their names focus of special academic research. (wife Fred and PhD student Alex). It is symptomatic that Purpose of the study. The paper sets out to explore the protagonist is the only one in the novel who reduces the relations between illness and sexuality in contempo- his wife’s name ‘Winnifred’ to ‘Fred’. rary British fiction. In D. Lodge’s novels the process of reconstructing the Materials and methods. Traditional academic meth- characters’ split identity is implemented in complex inter- ods of literary studies have been combined with strategies action with other people, including sexual relationships of such interdisciplinary branches as sociology, body the- that sometimes have ‘perverse’ nature. Therefore, due to ory and disability studies. its particular importance in the power discourse, BDSM Results and discussions. So much has now been writ- as a variety of erotic role playing involving bondage, dis- ten on sexual discourse in all its ambiguities and com- cipline, dominance, submission, sadomasochism, and plexities that, rather than being the taboo subject it once other related interpersonal dynamics has got special was, the issue has tended to become overdetermined. That meaning in Deaf Sentence. In her e-mail PhD student is why, although D. Lodge’s five latest novels break down Alex suggests that Desmond should punish her for mak- taboos concerning sexuality among Catholics and the el- ing “irremovable marks in a library book” [5, p. 128]. She derly, it can be argued that any representation of body offers professor Bates to see her “bent over the table”, behaviour in his texts should be regarded, first and fore- “naked from the waist down”, with her “head on a cush- most, in its metaphoric meaning. In fiction human body ion” and to “spank” her “butt” using just “the flat of [his] and sexuality are not autonomous phenomena since they hand” without direct sexual intercourse [5, p. 129]. are used to introduce a broader range of problems. In Though Desmond refuses to come to the student’s D. Lodge’s novels, especially Therapy, Deaf Sentence and apartment, her suggestion evokes his sexual desire. The A Man of Parts, elderly subjects are not depicted as hav- protagonist uses proposed role play to vary sexual rela- ing lost their sexual identities. Moreover, sexuality is tionship with his spouse. Their intercourse is structured transferred to the ontological sphere of the terminal stages around a powerful imaginative configuration since touch- 55 Science and Education a New Dimension. Philology, V(35), Issue: 125, 2017 www.seanewdim.com ing Fred Desmond imagines himself in the ‘red-lit room’ doing that since Messenger and I became lovers. I didn’t spanking Alex [5, p. 132]. In this case Winnifred’s body want to record my behavior because I was afraid that loses its individual features and becomes a collective fe- scrutinizing it and analyzing it might awaken scruples of male body. It symbolizes generalized image of the Other conscience and inhibit my pleasure. (In fact I still shrink over whom Desmond has to get temporary control. How- from examining this experience with the straight unflinch- ever, the process of learning is oriented not to the Other ing gaze of the first person. Let me try it another way…) represented by a woman, but to himself. It appears to be <…> For that was what she had become, a woman of the process of self-discovering. Use of the first-person pleasure, a scarlet woman, a woman of easy virtue, a narration in this textual segment shows the character’s woman no better than she should be – or so she would narcissistic identification with the male narrator. As have been described in the pages of an old novel” [8, G. Brame notes, if “you’re an ordinary person having p. 258]. ordinary intercourse, there are a lot of questions you never In Lodge’s novels the interaction between sex and ill- have to address about who you are, who your partner is, ness is ambivalent. On the one hand, sex can sometimes what issues of control [exist]. When you leave the world cure characters from depression and help them to retrieve of vanilla sex <…> you have to start asking [such] ques- their gender and social roles. On the other hand, the nov- tions of yourself. Doing so opens up the opportunity, or els illustrate common point of view that seriously ill or presents the problem of consciousness, of growing in self- injured bodies cannot be considered as vessels of sexuali- knowledge” [1, p. 89]. ty. That is why ill people are often treated as asexual or In BDSM practice D. Lodge’s character needs to re- even worse, deviant and disgusting. At a certain stage in a trieve the role of a dominant partner for a while, but not to grave illness’ progress the termination of sexual life be- cause or receive pain. It is desire to feel emotional satis- comes a kind of experience that precedes the end of life faction stemming from the power he has over another itself.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Consciousness and the Novel 2
    Contents Cover About the Book Also by David Lodge Dedication Title Page Preface 1. Consciousness and the Novel 2. Literary Criticism and Literary Creation 3. Dickens Our Contemporary 4. Forster’s Flawed Masterpiece 5. Waugh’s Comic Wasteland 6. Lives in Letters: Kingsley and Martin Amis 7. Henry James and the Movies 8. Bye-Bye Bech? 9. Sick with Desire: Philip Roth’s Libertine Professor 10. Kierkegaard for Special Purposes 11. A Conversation about Thinks . Notes Index Copyright About the Book Human consciousness, long the province of literature, has lately come in for a remapping – even rediscovery – by the natural sciences, driven by developments in Artificial Intelligence, neuroscience, and evolutionary biology. But as the richest record we have of human consciousness, literature, David Lodge suggests, may offer a kind of knowledge about this phenomenon that is complementary, not opposed, to scientific knowledge. Writing with characteristic wit and brio, and employing the insight and acumen of a skilled novelist and critic, Lodge here explores the representation of human consciousness in fiction (mainly English and American) in the light of recent investigations in cognitive science, neuroscience, and related disciplines. How, Lodge asks, does the novel represent consciousness? And how has this changed over time? In a series of interconnected essays, he pursues this question down various paths: how does the novel's method compare with that of other creative media such as film? How does the consciousness (and unconscious) of the creative writer do its work? And how can criticism infer the nature of this process through formal analysis? In essays on Charles Dickens, E.M.
    [Show full text]
  • Gendered Spaces Domesticity in the Novels of David Lodge Yuliia Terentieva Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary
    Gendered Spaces Domesticity in the Novels of David Lodge Yuliia Terentieva Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary Abstract. The paper examines a number of novels written by David Lodge to find out if the representation of women had changed throughout Lodge’s works written in different decades. Since it is often the case that women are represented through domestic, private spaces in Lodge’s novels, the paper inspects the places female characters occupy in the structure of the narratives and the places women inhabit in the fictional worlds of the novels. While closely investigating the chosen four novels that seem the most relevant to such an analysis, the research also includes some other novels by the same author in which the presence of domestic spaces is significant. Keywords: domestic space, David Lodge, home, gender With the emergence of feminist literary criticism, David Lodge acknowledged the relevance of this approach’s assessment in regard to one of his early works, Ginger, You’re Barmy (1962) (213). In the novel’s afterword written in 1983, he attributed the behaviour and underlying views of the main character of his novel to the effect of the times in which the novel was written (saying that “neither [the main character] nor his creator had heard of ‘sexism’” in 1962) and further added that, in any case, the presence of a certain amount of sexist views in the narrative was necessary due to the nature of the main character’s environment (military service) in the story (Ginger 213). Without aiming to answer the question of whether Lodge’s novels are indeed sexist (moreover, it would not be correct to judge on the basis of the opinions alluded to or expressed by the characters or the narrator of the book), this paper aims to examine a number of novels written by Lodge to find out if the representation of women had changed throughout Lodge’s works written in different years.
    [Show full text]
  • An Interview with David Lodge at Cambridge
    Volume 5, No. 2-3 132 An Interview with David Lodge at Cambridge INTERVIEWEE: David Lodge (1935- ) is a distinguished contemporary British novelist as well as a critic. He is particularly well known for his campus trilogy - Changing Places, Small World and Nice Work and his works of literary criticism such as The Language of Fiction, Working with Structuralism and After Bakhtin. His literary creation represents the literary tendency of the post-war British neo-realism and his literary criticism reflects the successive impact of New Criticism, Structuralism and Bakhtin‘s theory of fiction on British critical circle. Though 75 years old, Lodge is still active in English literary arena and had his last work Deaf Sentence published in 2008 and will have a new novel about H. J. Wells published next April. Among Chinese readers, Lodge is very popular, for his Small World is often ranked with Qian Zhongshu‘s The Fortress Besieged which is the favorite of most of Chinese educated readers. INTERVIEWER: Rong Ou, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou 310036, China; E-mail: [email protected] OU: It seems that most of your novels draw to a large extent upon your own experience. How much do you think a writer can make use of his own experience without being read auto- biographically? DL: I think readers tend to connect a writer‘s work with anything they know about the writer‘s life. You know something you cannot change is this kind of curiosity. But I think it's something that as a writer you should not worry about.
    [Show full text]
  • The Campus Trilogy, David Lodge
    The Campus Trilogy, David Lodge 912 pages, 144812980X, 9781448129805, David Lodge, The Campus Trilogy, 2012, Random House, 2012, 'One of the very best English comic novelists of the post-war era' Time OutThe plot lines of The Campus Trilogy, radiating from its hub at the redbrick University of Rummidge, trace the comic adventures of academics who move outside familiar territory. Beginning in the late 60sChanging Places follows the undistinguished English lecturer Philip Swallow and hotshot American professor Morris Zapp as they exchange jobs, habitats and eventually wives. Small World sees Swallow, Zapp, Persse McGarrigle and the beautiful Angelica Pabst jet-set about the international conference scene, combining academic infighting and tourism, esoteric chat and romance. And finally, the feminist lecturer Robyn Penrose swaps the industrial novel for a hard hat in Nice Work as she shadows the factory boss Victor Wilcox. Sparks fly when their beliefs and lifestyles collide. file download henow.pdf 128 pages, David Lodge, Home Truths: a Novella, Fiction, Adrian Ludlow, a novelist with a distinguished reputation and a book on the 'A' level syllabus, is now seeking obscurity in a cottage beneath the Gatwick flight path. His, Mar 31, 2012, ISBN:9781448137213 ISBN:9781448129850, David Lodge, The Practice of Writing, Literary Criticism, In this absorbing volume, David Lodge turns his incisive critical skills onto his own profession, salutes the great writers who have influenced his work, wonders about the, 352 pages, Feb 29, 2012 Feb 29, 2012, ISBN:9781446496718, When it isn't prison, it's hell. Or at least that's the heartfelt belief of conscripts Jonathan Browne and Mike 'Ginger' Brady.
    [Show full text]
  • Diplomarbeit
    1 Diplomarbeit Titel der Diplomarbeit “David Lodge as a Catholic Novelist” Verfasserin Judith Terezija Pimperl angestrebter akademischer Grad Magistra der Philosophie (Mag.phil) Wien, im Oktober 2008 Studienkennzahl lt. Studienblatt: A 344 020 Studienrichtung lt. Studienblatt: LA Anglistik und Amerikanistik Betreuer: Univ.-Prof. Dr. Rudolf Weiss 2 Thanks Be To God 1… …and Professor Weiss… …and My Family… …for their patience, forbearance and support. for Sarah and Sophie 1 1 Kor 15:57. 3 List of abbreviations AAS ………………………. Acta Apostolicae Sedis Vat II / Vatican II …………. Second Vatican Council HV ………………………… Humanae Vitae GS ………………………… Gaudium et Spes SC ………………………… Sacrosanctum Concilium CIC ……………………….. Codex Iuris Canonici, i.e. Code of Canon Law CCC ………………………. Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church DH ………………………… Dignitatis Humanae 4 Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 1 1 Catholic novelist? ............................................................................................................... 2 2 History .............................................................................................................................. 12 2.1 History of Catholicism in England ............................................................................ 12 2.1.1 Ultramontanism .................................................................................................. 21 2.2 From Dusk till Dawn – Developments in the Church ..............................................
    [Show full text]
  • Catholicism and Metaphor the Catholic Fiction of David Lodge
    MARIAN CROWE Catholicism and Metaphor The Catholic Fiction of David Lodge "WHATEVER HAPPENED TO THE CATHOLIC NOVEL?" is a question of- ten asked by lovers of the novels of Graham Greene, Evelyn Waugh, François Mauriac, and Georges Bernanos. What these readers usu- ally have in mind is not simply a novel by a Catholic or one that includes some Cathohc material, but a work of substantial liter- ary merit in which Catholic theology and thought have a significant presence, with genuine attention to the spiritual life. Such a novel often draws on Catholicism's rich liturgical and sacramental sym- bolism and is enriched by the Catholic imagination, which, accord- ing to Andrew Greeley, is one that is more analogical than dialecti- cal and sees created reality as a revelation of the presence of God. ' Cathohc novels are still being written, but they seem somehow different from the classics of the genre. More than forty years ago David Lodge, an English novehst and critic explained why: "I don't think that one can talk of the Catholic novel in quite such sharply- defined terms any more, partly because Catholicism itself has be- come a much more confused—and confusing—faith, more difficult to define, mainly in the last ten or fifteen years as a result of Pope LOGOS 1^:3 SUMMER 2OI2 THE CATHOLIC FICTION OF DAVID LODGE I31 John and the Vatican Council. The Church no longer presents that sort of monolithic, unified, uniform view of life which it once did."^ In fact. Lodge himself, one of the most interesting CathoHc nov- elists in England today, has enriched and expanded the possibilities of Catholic fiction by demonstrating that comedy, wit, and satire are legitimate modes for expressing serious rehgious themes—espe- cially as they pertain to recent developments in Catholicism.
    [Show full text]
  • Name: Joy Koopman Student Number: 4093992 Subject: Thesis MA Engelstalige Letterkunde Supervisor: Prof. Odin Dekkers Date: 12 Ju
    Name: Joy Koopman Student number: 4093992 Subject: Thesis MA Engelstalige Letterkunde Supervisor: Prof. Odin Dekkers Date: 12 July 2016 Radboud University Nijmegen, Faculty of Arts Koopman 4093992/2 Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 3 Theory and importance of the research .................................................................................. 6 Terminology ........................................................................................................................... 9 Research questions ............................................................................................................... 12 Chapter outline ..................................................................................................................... 13 Authorial Control and David Lodge’s Literary Criticism ........................................................ 15 Anxiety of reception ............................................................................................................. 17 Literary criticism as self-explication .................................................................................... 19 Self-positioning .................................................................................................................... 22 Foregrounding the Author as Character ................................................................................... 25 Return of the author within literary discourse
    [Show full text]
  • Student of Two Masters: David Lodge and the Dual Tradition of the Novel Ákos Farkas, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary
    Student of Two Masters: David Lodge and the Dual Tradition of the Novel Ákos Farkas, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary Abstract The article examines David Lodge’s indebtedness to James Joyce and Graham Greene, self-elected precursors whose Catholic sensibilities appear to be the only connecting link between them. Although Lodge has now abandoned the religious thematics relating his early The Picturegoers and The British Museum is Falling Down to Joyce and Greene, the duality of aesthetic principles emblematized by those “two masters” remains an abiding interest informing his postmillennial novels Author, Author and A Man of Parts. However, the rival poetics of “modernism” and “realism” are here represented by Henry James and H. G. Wells, with the emphasis shifting towards the latter. Keywords: David Lodge, postmillennial, bio-fiction, novel, modernism, realism “But Greene’s awfully sordid, don’t you think?” says Polly. “But Waugh’s so snobbish.” “Anyway, it said in the Observer that they’re the two best English novelists going, so that’s one in the eye for the Prods.” The eye of the beholder: Lodge’s elective affinities The exchange quoted above comes from a dialogue taking place between two young persons, Michael and Polly, during a lull in a dance party in David Lodge’s mid-career novel How Far Can You Go? Although Michael would sooner contemplate Polly’s frontal endowment than the relative merits of Graham Greene’s The Heart of the Matter and Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited, he is ready to settle for talking books to impress his pretty interlocutor with his advanced literary tastes.
    [Show full text]