DOCSLIB.ORG

V. J. Carroll and the Essence of Journalism the Oldest Rule Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
V. J. Carroll and the Essence of Journalism the Oldest Rule Of V. J. Carroll and the essence of journalism The oldest rule of journalism – and the most forgotten – is to tell the customers what is really going on - Stanley Cecil (Sol) Chandler. Monday 22 April 2013: to Macquarie University with Max Suich to observe the installation of Vic (The Sorcerer) Carroll, as Doctor of Letters (honoris causa). In his address to graduates, Dr Carroll said: “That CV the vice chancellor just read to you in no way prepared me for how to respond to the letter I received from him last November telling me that the University Council had decided to confer on me a Doctor of Letters honoris causa in recognition of my contributions to journalism. “I have been ever conscious of what journalism has done for me in providing me with a living wage for an important phase of my life and particularly for driving my continuing education for the last 60 years. But what I had done for journalism? “That was a foreign country I had not risked exploring. Fortunately, help was at hand. I had been reading a review of a new book containing letters written around 1903 by the German poet Rainer Maria Rilke [1875-1926]. “Rilke had gone to Paris to soak up the culture and write about the sculptor [Auguste] Rodin [1840-1917]. Rilke was shocked. Rodin didn’t wait around for inspiration. Rodin worked all the time. And he worked on the special thing that he saw in everything. Rilke got the message. Der Ding, the Thing, to be observed in everything, was paramount.” Michael Egan, Chancellor of Macquarie University, and Honorary Doctor Victor Carroll. (Credit: Effy Alexakis.) Dr Carroll’s remarks prompted some thoughts on journalism via his career and bits of mine. I asked him: What is the essence of journalism? He said: “The essence? der Ding? In journalism I think it's basically curiosity. It's what's lacking in big institutions like ASIC [Australian Securities and Investment Commission –supposed to regulate companies ], APRA [Australian Prudential Regulation Authority – supposed to regulate banks, insurance etc.], the law etc. It's why journalists are basically outsiders.” The Times noted a product of curiosity in 1852. “The duty of the journalist,” the organ thundered, “is the same as that of the historian – to seek out the truth above all things, and to present to his readers … the truth as near as he can attain it … The press lives by disclosure.” History I and II at Queensland University in the 1950s helped me in the 1970s at a weekly started by Vic. He started as a stockbroker at a Brisbane firm, Corser, Henderson and Hale in 1950. The Korean War helped the share market, but Treasurer Artie Fadden ended the boomlet in 1952. Vic thought he wasn’t earning his keep. T. S. Eliot mused on the effect of chance in our lives in a passage from Four Quartets beginning “Footfalls echo in the memory”. In Vic’s case, the chance seems to have been a phone call from Colin Bednall, an executive at Queensland Press, in 1952. Seeking an infusion of outside blood for The Courier-Mail, Bednall rang Vic and offered him a job. He accepted on condition that he was in the general news section. * * * At a basic level, journalism is quite simple; no training is required. You telephone a string of people and say: “What’s happening?” But then it gets tricky; pre-publication censorship imposed from outside or inside, can make it hard to tell the truth. As George Orwell said, the most powerful lie is the omission. Corrupt libel law is anti-truth, unfair and unjust; it can paralyse reporters and get money for liars and criminals. Editors who do not relentlessly campaign for change betray customers and shareholders. Internal pre-publication censorship can take a number of forms: No opinions. Facts by themselves are often meaningless. Reporters may not be allowed explain what they mean. “Objective” journalism has made much US journalism useless. No context. Justice Russell Fox said an understanding of facts depends heavily on context. Reporters may not be allowed to put facts into their context. Balance. Fairness means truth. “On the other hand” reports can leave customers unsure of the truth. Prisoner of the source. Reporters who rely on particular sources for information – detectives or lawyers, for example –may neglect to report the sources’ misdeeds. This is akin to “regulatory capture”, where a regulator acts in the interests of an industry it is supposed to be regulating rather than in the public interest. The proprietor’s view. Proprietors make their views known in various ways. Rupert Murdoch (b. 1931) now uses Twitter; prudent reporters do not have to guess what line they should take. * * * The Courier-Mail was part of a Melbourne-based group partly owned by John Wren (1871- 1953), a prominent Catholic, organised criminal and entrepreneur of boxing and wrestling. The group was run by Sir Keith Murdoch (1885-1952), father of Rupert Murdoch. The group did not allow opinion or context, but did support retailers, the Catholic Church and the politics of paranoia: Communists, all 3000 of them, would take over Australia unless people voted for an habitual liar and war criminal, Bob Menzies. Carroll recalls: “I did a year's condensed cadetship; wrote leaders telling people how to vote; and when the finance editor had a nervous breakdown filled in.” After nine months ‘leave without pay to see Europe in 1953-54, he returned as finance editor. He said: “The finance page was a one-man job - getting the news, writing, subbing and seeing the page through the composing room. I expressed no opinions in my stories. Once, at a 6 pm meeting with the news editor, I said the main story was a drop in profits for Finney Isles. “’Christ’, he said, ‘We can't lead with that. What else is in their report?" “Well’, I said, ‘their assets increased. They're still expanding.’ “’That's the lead,’ he said. “DJs took over Finneys soon afterwards. I learnt a lot.” Carroll let himself be talked into joining management, but found it a “dry gully”. He says: “I waited for the chance to get out, and early in 1960 came to Sydney as finance editor of The Sun-Herald and a contributor to the Australian Financial Review.” Warwick Fairfax (1901-87), chairman of Fairfax from 1930, imposed the same pre- publication censorship as Keith Murdoch. The flagboat, The Sydney Morning Herald, boasted that “facts” were in the news columns and that the organ’s [or Warwick’s] opinions were in the leaders. Bob Askin, who said “We’re in the tart shop now, boys” when he became Premier of NSW in 1965, procured a knighthood for Warwick in 1967. (Sir Warwick assured me in 1983 he did not then know Askin was corrupt when he accepted. That would have made him almost unique in Sydney.) In 1964, Carroll was appointed editor of the Fin, and became known as The Sorcerer from the number of able apprentices he recruited. He contrived to break the censorship, and so became the most important journalist of his generation. He spoke of being called up to the 14th floor to “get the cuts” from Warwick. * * * After a period as a schoolteacher, I got a job on a bush newspaper, The Toowoomba Chronicle, in 1964, and moved to Rupert Murdoch’s Melbourne Truth in January 1966. Something of what happened to Carroll me in the next 20 years is at pp. 8-35 of Amazing Scenes: Adventures of a Reptile of the Press on this website [http://netk.net.au/WhittonAmazing.asp]. This is a short version: Sol Chandler (1911-69), Fleet Street genius, increased Truth’ circulation from 220,000 to 400,000 from July 1966 to May 1967. Murdoch got rid of him in January 1968 after he ran a piece showing that the Prime Minister, John Gorton, was a thief. Eight months later, Murdoch used the profits of Truth and an Adelaide paper as collateral in negotiations to buy the News of the World. He rang Gorton and got permission to get money out of Australia. In 1971, Carroll invented The National Times and became editor-in-chief of the Fin and the NT, and I was sent to Sydney to a short-lived Murdoch organ, The Sunday Australian. In 1972, Noela and I collected material in Adelaide confirming that in 1959 Max Stuart, an aboriginal, had been wrongly convicted of murdering a small girl, but the editor, Bruce Rothwell, told me he had instructions from “higher up” not to print anything about the case. Noela wrote a piece in The [Dirty] Digger which led to Stuart’s release. [http://netk.net.au/StuartHome.asp] I sent Carroll a letter in 1973 saying he wouldn’t remember me, but in 1948 we were in opposing teams in a minor Rugby match at Queensland University; perhaps it was time for a Silver Anniversary drink. He gave me a job at The National Times. Max Suich was the editor. Frank Williams wrote in his history of journalism, Dangerous Estate (1957): “The journalist is traditionally an entertainer; he must entertain or find another trade ... one of the most profound of all journalistic truths [is] that whosoever would influence the public must first learn to entertain it.” Or, as Suich put it: “If you have to cut, leave in the jokes.” Suich had me look into a 1954 event not adequately covered at the time, the Petrov affair. The essays required for History I and II suddenly became useful; a narrative giving the context can reveal a pattern and the truth.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Origins of the Royal Commission on Intelligence and Security
    Origins of the Royal Commission on Intelligence and Security CJ Coventry LLB BA A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts (Research) School of Humanities and Social Sciences UNSW Canberra at ADFA 2018 i Table of Contents Acknowledgements iii Introduction & Methodology 1 Part I: ASIO before Whitlam 9 Chapter One: The creation of ASIO 9 Chapter Two: Bipartisan anti-communism 23 Chapter Three: ASIO’s anti-radicalism, 1950-1972 44 Part II: Perspectives on the Royal Commission 73 Chapter Four: Scholarly perspectives on the Royal Commission 73 Chapter Five: Contemporary perspectives on ASIO and an inquiry 90 Part III: The decision to reform 118 Chapter Six: Labor and terrorism 118 Chapter Seven: The decision and announcement 154 Part IV: The Royal Commission 170 Chapter Eight: Findings and recommendations 170 Conclusion 188 Bibliography 193 ii Acknowledgements & Dedication I dedicate this thesis to Rebecca and our burgeoning menagerie. Most prominently of all I wish to thank Rebecca Coventry who has been integral to the writing of this thesis. Together we seek knowledge, not assumption, challenge, not complacency. For their help in entering academia I thank Yunari Heinz, Anne-Marie Elijah, Paul Babie, the ANU Careers advisors, Clinton Fernandes and Nick Xenophon. While writing this thesis I received help from a number of people. I acknowledge the help of Lindy Edwards, Toni Erskine, Clinton Fernandes, Ned Dobos, Ruhul Sarkar, Laura Poole-Warren, Kylie Madden, Julia Lines, Craig Stockings, Deane-Peter
    [Show full text]
  • Marijuana Australiana
    Marijuana Australiana Marijuana Australiana: Cannabis Use, Popular Culture, and the Americanisation of Drugs Policy in Australia, 1938 - 1988 John Lawrence Jiggens, BA Centre for Social Change Research Carseldine Campus QUT Submitted in requirement for the degree, Doctor of Philosophy, April 2004 1 Marijuana Australiana KEY WORDS: Narcotics, Control of—Australia, Narcotics and crime—Australia, Cannabis use— Australia, Popular Culture—Australia, Drugs policy—Australia, Organised crime— Queensland, New South Wales, Cannabis prohibition—Australia, Police corruption—Queensland, New South Wales, the counter-culture—Australia, Reefer Madness—Australia, the War on Drugs—Australia, Woodward Royal Commission (the Royal Commission into Drug Trafficking), the Williams Royal Commission (Australian Royal Commission into Drugs), the Fitzgerald Inquiry, the Stewart Royal Commission (Royal Commission into Nugan Hand), Chlorodyne, Cannabis— medical use, cannabis indica, cannabis sativa, Gough Whitlam, Richard Nixon, Donald Mackay, Johannes Bjelke- Petersen, Terry Lewis, Ray Whitrod, Fast Buck$, Chris Masters, John Wesley Egan, the Corset Gang, Murray Stewart Riley, Bela Csidei, Maurice Bernard 'Bernie' Houghton, Frank Nugan, Michael Jon Hand, Sir Peter Abeles, Merv Wood, Sir Robert Askin, Theodore (Ted) Shackley, Fred Krahe, James (Jimmy) Bazley, Gianfranco Tizzoni, Ken Nugan, Brian Alexander. 2 Marijuana Australiana ABSTRACT The word ‘marijuana’ was introduced to Australia by the US Bureau of Narcotics via the Diggers newspaper, Smith’s Weekly, in 1938. Marijuana was said to be ‘a new drug that maddens victims’ and it was sensationally described as an ‘evil sex drug’. The resulting tabloid furore saw the plant cannabis sativa banned in Australia, even though cannabis had been a well-known and widely used drug in Australia for many decades.
    [Show full text]
  • Queensland State Archives - 1972 Cabinet Documents
    - 1 - Queensland State Archives - 1972 Cabinet Documents A report by Jonathan Richards, Consultant Historian Table of contents Introduction ......................................................................................................................................1 Issues - Aboriginal and Islander Affairs.........................................................................................4 Issues - Beach Erosion on the Gold Coast....................................................................................6 Issues - Brisbane ..........................................................................................................................7 Issues - Censorship ......................................................................................................................9 Issues - Coalmines .....................................................................................................................10 Issues - Daylight Saving..............................................................................................................11 Issues - Electricity.......................................................................................................................12 Issues - Environment ..................................................................................................................13 Issues - Gladstone Smelter.........................................................................................................14 Issues - Greenvale Nickel Mine and Yabulu Treatment Plant......................................................15
    [Show full text]
  • The Wrong Crowd
    THE WRONG CROWD An online documentary and Analytical contextualisation Debra Beattie BA(UQ), Dip Ed (UNSW), Grad Dip Film (Swinburne), MA (QUT) Creative Industries Research and Applications Centre CIRAC Queensland University of Technology Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy June 2003 TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract i Statement of Originality iii Acknowledgements iv Chapter One – History, Documentary, Memory 2 History and Popular Memory (a) Background 9 (b) Buried Histories 11 (c) Trauma, Narrative and History 25 (d) History and the document(ary) as evidence 30 (e) So whose memories make documentary history? 36 Chapter Two – Documentary in the Age of New Media Digitised reality and non-linear history in a navigable narration 49 (a) Simulation as evidence 50 (b) Narrative and non-linearity 53 (c) Digital realism 59 The New Age of New Media (d) Screen theory online 63 (e) Spatial montage 70 (f) Cinematic apparatus on the net 74 Chapter Three – The Wrong Crowd – Documentary Online 81 Conclusion 93 Reference List 99 Filmography 107 ABSTRACT The Wrong Crowd the theory and the practice of creating a personal history-documentary online. This doctoral study comprises two parts. 75 per cent of the total weight of the submission consists of the creative component, the writing, directing and producing of a moving- image documentary in an online environment (supplementary material includes the script). Cutting edge technology (QTVR ‘movies’ and Live Stage Professional software) was used to create an immersive cinematic experience on the net. The Wrong Crowd can be viewed either online at www.abc.net.au/wrongcrowd or offline via a CD Rom (the latter includes the radio play ‘Death of a Prostitute’ which was excised from the version published via ABC Online because of legal concerns on the part of the ABC lawyers).
    [Show full text]
  • Free Subscription to E-Newsletter Notifications / Membership & Donation Forms
    By Kerry White (a student of Evan Whitton in 1961)” Pressreader: (by Chilla Johnson) https://www.pressreader.com/australia/the-chronicle8992/20180803/283583811202301 Toowoomba Chronicle: (by Kerry White) https://www.thechronicle.com.au/news/rugby-pioneers-leave-lasting-mark/3484060/ The Saturday Paper: (by Richard Ackland – The Gadfly) In his regular “Diary” section on the 21st July 2018, Richard wrote: ‘The death of Journalist Evan Whitton has been widely reported along with his investigatory work on justice and injustice. He was a big presence in the field of reporting and an inspiration to many cubs, including Gadfly. One of the aspects of his career less noted in the encomiums was his campaign to replace the entire adversarial system of litigation with the inquisitorial (Napoleonic – Germanic) system of justice. In other words courts would turn into miniroyal commissions of inquiry, pressing for the truth with minimal interference from the rules of evidence. Judges would be specifically schooled and not necessarily drawn from the ranks of long-winded barristers. They would sit on the bench alongside lay jurors. No doubt these ideas started percolating during the long, dry days he sat as areporter in the Toowoomba courthouse. He tirelessly peddled his inquisitorial approach in the law journal Justinian and elsewhere. It was so shocking that the rank and file of the legal profession became incandescent with his attack on the perfection of the ‘Rolls Royce’ justice system. He also gave some of the human rights lawyers a swipe when he wrote: “The adversary system is solid for human rights; its firm position is that criminals have a human right not to be convicted, and their victims have a human right to like it or to lump it.” It’s not often that the death of a journalist leaves an empty spacein human affairs.
    [Show full text]
  • Serial Liars by Evan Whittonserial-Liars Ebook[1]
    Evan Whitton received the Walkley Award for National Journalism five times and was Journalist of the Year 1983 for ‘courage and innovation’ in reporting a corruption inquiry. He was editor of The National Times, Chief Reporter and European Correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald, and Reader in Journalism at the University of Queensland. He is now a columnist on the online legal journal, Justinian. www.justinian.com.au Praise for Evan Whitton’s Work ‘Whitton QC not here? What a pity.’ - NSW Premier Neville Wran QC, 1983 “Evan Whitton is exactly the right person to write about any subject that interests him, because of the rare insight that sets him apart from all other Australian journalists.” - Michael English, 1987 Can of Worms (1986) ‘No decent person could read it without being possessed of utter rage at the way our public institutions have been corrupted over the past 15 years or so by criminal elements in politics, the police and even the courts.’ - Senator (Australia) John Stone. Amazing Scenes (1987) ‘... combines literary elegance with real sinew.’ - Denis Butler, The Newcastle Herald ‘Australia’s premier journalist …’ - Mike Ryan, Sunday Press, Melbourne The Hillbilly Dictator (1989) ‘ ... compelling reading, a popular history with a light touch but a serious moral message ... a wealth of anecdotes, humorous, scandalous, shocking, surprising ...’ - Dr Mark Finnane, The Sydney Morning Herald ‘Evan Whitton is a dazzling writer, incisive and addictive; a master journalist, prodigious in his knowledge and effort.’ - Dr George Miller, film director. ‘The Whitton wit is evident … but the tragedy of it all was also evident to him.’ - Christopher Masters, The Herald, Melbourne 2 Trial by Voodoo (1994) ‘The only book in the language that critically examines the law as a whole.’ - Law Professor Alex Ziegert, University of Sydney.
    [Show full text]
  • Hansard 30 May 1991
    Legislative Assembly 8144 30 May 1991 NOTE: There could be differences between this document and the official printed Hansard, Vol. 318 THURSDAY, 30 MAY 1991 Mr SPEAKER (Hon. J. Fouras, Ashgrove) read prayers and took the chair at 10 a.m. PAPERS The following papers were laid on the table— Orders in Council under— Employment, Vocational Education and Training Act 1988-1990 Rural Training Schools Act 1965-1990 and the Statutory Bodies Financial Arrangements Act 1982-1989 Supreme Court Act of 1921 Industrial Development Act 1963-1987 Regulations under the Workplace Health and Safety Act 1989-1990 By-laws under the Chiropractors and Osteopaths Act 1979-1990 Proclamation under the Queensland Small Business Corporation Act 1990. MINISTERIAL STATEMENT Business Investment in Queensland Hon. K. E. De LACY (Cairns—Treasurer) (10.03 a.m.), by leave: The purpose of my statement is to set the record straight on the state of business investment in Queensland. The latest Queensland Economic Review clearly demonstrates that Queensland's share of business investment in Australia has grown steadily over the past year or so and the investment outlook is likely to be less recessed in Queensland than in other States. Treasury figures show that Queensland's share of business investment next year should rise to over 14 per cent, up from 13 per cent at the beginning of 1990. Private sector analysts confirm this more optimistic picture for Queensland. For example, Rider Hunt, construction industry consultants, last month described Queensland as the "investment State of the 1990s", saying we "will lead Australia out of this recession".
    [Show full text]
  • NEWSLETTER ISSN 1443-4962 No
    Few country newspapers have equalled the Border Watch, Mount Gambier, South Australia, for the excellence of its newspapers file room. When your editor visited, on 3 February 2003, the file room was not only spotless but well organised and comprehensive. Alan Hill, general manager at the time, is in the picture. AUSTRALIAN NEWSPAPER HISTORY GROUP NEWSLETTER ISSN 1443-4962 No. 87 May 2016 Publication details Compiled for the Australian Newspaper History Group by Rod Kirkpatrick, PO Box 8294 Mount Pleasant Qld 4740. Ph. +61-7-400 031 614. Email: [email protected]/ Contributing editor and founder: Victor Isaacs, of Canberra, is at [email protected]/ Back copies of the Newsletter and some ANHG publications can be viewed online at: http://www.amhd.info/anhg/index.php Deadline for the next Newsletter: 15 July 2016. Subscription details appear at end of Newsletter. [Number 1 appeared October 1999.] Ten issues had appeared by December 2000 and the Newsletter has since appeared five times a year. 1—Current Developments: National & Metropolitan Housekeeping: ANHG editor Rod Kirkpatrick is moving from Mackay to Brisbane on 23 April. Initially he will not have a fixed residential address. Mail will be forwarded from his Mount Pleasant (Mackay) PO Box to the appropriate postal address. His email address and Mobile phone number (see Page 1) will remain unchanged. 87.1.1 Fairfax Media slashes 120 editorial jobs in Sydney, Melbourne Fairfax Media journalists voted on 17 March to strike until 21 March, after the company told staff it was planning to slash 120 editorial jobs—about one-fifth of the 700 to 750 staff—across its Sydney and Melbourne newsrooms.
    [Show full text]
  • Eulogy for Noela Whitton, by Her Son Hugh O'brien
    Eulogy for Noela Whitton, by her son Hugh O’Brien At Linden, NSW, 15th April 2021 Mum was born in the small Queensland country town of Murgon, Queensland, just three weeks after the greatest stock market crash in history. She was a poster child of the depression and was into recycling and conservation before Al Gore was even born! It led to her eldest daughter Jane becoming a sculptor using recycled paper pulp, to her middle daughter Claire becoming a whiz at making meals go further and to her youngest daughter Lizzie becoming a United Nations award winning environmentalist. Mum grew up in the back of her father’s electrical goods shop which sold mainly radios - His Master’s Voice HMV was their big brand - and then later TVs. Grandad and grandma encouraged their five kids – Ivy, Noela, Colleen, Kevin and Bryan – to be involved in music and performance. Mum learned the violin and played and sang at dances. In 1942 with the Japanese forces threatening Brisbane, the students of St Rita’s Clayfield were moved to live at the convent in Murgon, further inland and supposedly safer. With a manpower shortage they needed a responsible person to ride each day to the bakers and take a load of bread to the convent for the boarder’s lunches. 12-year-old Noela was the only girl entrusted with this job and she did it, rain, hail or shine. Later when the Australian army set up camp outside Murgon, all the McMahon girls provided musical entertainment at Saturday afternoon dances. Mum had a love of Shakespeare and became a speech and drama teacher.
    [Show full text]
  • Obituary: Evan Whitton 5 March 1928 - 16 July 2018
    Obituary: Evan Whitton 5 March 1928 - 16 July 2018 My father Evan Whitton died at the age of 90 last month and this is my first chance to say goodbye to him and honour his memory. LEAD Action News was privileged to have had Evan as a Guest Editor and Editorial / Defamation / Legal / Media / Advocacy Advisor for nearly three decades so this publication is a fitting place for one more obituary. Many of his journalist colleagues have written obituaries (see below) and thanked Evan for mentoring them, and because Evan was a history and English literature teacher before becoming a journalist and author, his ex-students have also published a whole newsletter full of accolades for Evan as a teacher and a good man. My experience of Evan as my father began when I was 9 years old, 53 years ago without notice, well, none that I can recall. A year before, my mother Noela had taken on the role of both mother and father, but late in 1965, Evan moved in with us (I have three older siblings) and I can recall thinking “my home has become a classroom – this guy is a born teacher but nothing like a father”. Picture this, early-on in the new living arrangements: four children seated around a map of Vietnam on the wall, being instructed on troop movements and famous battle locations – Evan standing, used a long ruler to point to the map to describe Australia’s involvement in the war - in chronological order, as was his wont. We each had to put up our hand to ask a question! By the time I was 10, I realized Evan was a walking dictionary so I always asked him for word definitions while reading or listening to the radio or TV current affairs - this was on for approximately three hours a day! He referred me to the actual dictionary over-and-over before I took up the habit and stopped asking him.
    [Show full text]
  • Biography Vic Carroll
    BIOGRAPHY VIC CARROLL: MEDIA MAN Evan Jones Print media people have a habit of saying how significant is their influence. And they have a ready vehicle for their self-congratulations. One person who deserves the accolades is newspaperman Victor Carroll. Carroll gained recognition in 2006 by being interviewed for posterity by the National Library of Australia (National Library of Australia, 2006). In 2013 he was awarded an Honorary Doctor of Letters by Macquarie University (Powell, 2013). This kudos would have eluded the general public. If at all, the reading public would know Vic Carroll as an inveterate columnist and letter writer to the Fairfax press. Over more than two decades, sometimes every second week, he would be in the Sydney Morning Herald or Australian Financial Review. This man has had multiple bees in his bonnet. Our subject had inauspicious beginnings in small town Queensland. As compensation for war service, he gained entry to Queensland University via the Labor Government’s Commonwealth Reconstruction Training Scheme and he graduated with a degree in economics and history. Carroll’s entry into the print media was fortuitous. Lacking the old school tie, there was the rugby connection. Thus he landed his first job in 1950 in a stockbroking firm. Briefly, he writes as a stringer for the arriviste weekly Australian Financial Review (launched on 16 August 1951). With the rugby connection again, he landed his first journalism job with the Courier Mail in 1952 – covering the then narrowly conceived reporting of stockmarket activity. Courtesy of the rarety of stockmarket journalists, Carroll moved to Fairfax and Sydney in 1960, becoming finance editor of the Sun Herald Jones, E.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Queensland Shelter. Maree Janine Stanley BA, Cert. Ed
    From Pressure to Participation: The Role of Queensland Shelter. Maree Janine Stanley BA, Cert. Ed, MGPP A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at The University of Queensland in 2015 School of Historical & Philosophical Inquiry Abstract Political support for the inclusion of social policy advocacy groups in the development of public policy is underpinned by a broad belief in the right of citizens to participate in or at least contribute to government decision making. Governments and state agencies consult widely on social issues when they see accountability and transparency as politically attractive, a form of both useful advice and risk management. While scholars have theorised on the benefits of non-state participation, empirical research on the role of policy advocacy groups in the development of Australian public policy is limited. This thesis examines the role of Queensland Shelter Inc., a state based social housing policy peak, in the development of Queensland social housing policy (1987-2012). While consultation processes are open and inclusive of a wide range of stakeholders, participation remains restricted to a select few. Why are some interest groups able to directly participate in the development of public policy while others are only consulted or even ignored? The influence of Queensland Shelter over housing policy has fluctuated over its twenty-five year history. Three factors were examined in relation to this oscillation: the organisational capacity of Queensland Shelter, the willingness of the housing ministry to engage and the broader political context. While the main focus of the study is to assess and analyse shifts in the relationship between Queensland Shelter and the state housing ministry, attention is also given to the connections between Queensland Shelter and other stakeholders, including the bureaucracy, other policy advocacy groups and the Australian federal government.
    [Show full text]