Gender Preferences and Science Career Choice
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Women & Science 3rd International Conference on Hands-on Science © 2006 H-Sci ISBN 989 9509 50 7 After the presentation of the best-practice 1. Introduction projects we will discuss their approaches and results. There are possibly contributions and The choice of an occupation or career is an experiences from other countries working with important decision for every school Ie aver. At the mentioned age groups. We are interested in the end of compulsory schooling, students decide getting information about their proceedings and whether they want to start working or further previous results. their education. Vocational choice is the Last but not least, we would like to set up outcome of a synthesis of factors. This study criteria for improving teaching methods with focuses on the role of science education m regards to gender aspects. influencing the choice of a science career. Keywords. Gender, Hands-on Science. The total number of students at the University of Malta and the number of undergraduate students following science courses have Gender Preferences and Science increased by 34% from 1995 to 2003. According Career Choice to the Labour Force survey, (March 2001), graduate employees in science related Claire Micallef1 and Suzanne Gatt2 professions make up 12% of the total number of 1 St. Monica School Gzira, Malta. professional employees in Malta. Moreover, 2 Department of Primary Education, Faculty compared to other countries, (Science and of Education, University of Malta. Malta. Engineering Indicators, 2002), Malta ranks [email protected]; among the countries which produce the smallest [email protected] percentage of science graduates. The faculty with the largest student population at the Abstract. Statistics show that the percentage University of Malta during the academic year number of females in science courses at the 2002/03 was the Faculty of Economics, University of Malta is low when compared to Management and Accounts (FEMA), with 24.6% other undergraduate courses. The ratio of males of the total student population. During the same to females varies according to the science academic year, undergraduates in science-related undergraduate course. This paper aims to courses made up only 17.6% (1,569 out of 8,920 identify reasons for gender differences in science University students, 57% males and 43% undergraduate courses, lecturing staff and females). This is a low percentage compared to employees in science related professions. A other countries (except for Norway and New questionnaire was addressed to two hundred and Zealand), Table 1, with Malta ranking among twenty three (223) undergraduate students those countries producing the least number of following science related courses at the science professionals. University of Malta. They were asked about their experience of science at Primary, Secondary and F' n 1 unh't1"u.;· d~ ff>e5 &, nl~ o11if'll u nj\'~ &lJ't ~f ";M .& Sc;IMC~ & E' 'IO' M<!r;'-,qI,ME) Post Secondary levels and about their choice of d¢!Jf~ I,,· ~~ · ve;\ f~ ~.. I~m. In S<elet·1~ ,,,,,kiM 3M lOC'lIi@! : 1 m o r m<l'Sl te<.:<:fTi course/career. Personal interest in science was "..• !~;:_ ! :i_! ·:.f '~~i;;.L .O::-~~.:" . '... :;:: > A found to be the key factor that determines the t :-::; ·, ,-Tt. :;~'\ -'~i/'-'-' decision in whether to pursue a science career or not. No gender difference was found to be statistically significant in this regard. Based on these [mdings, suggestions are made about how to improve science education with a view of increasing the number of students, both male and ~ ·.f female, following a science career. Keywords. Gender Preferences, Science Career. The Labour Force Survey, March 2002 reveals that at the end of September 2001, the 648 3rd International Conference on Hands-on Science Women & Science © 2006 H-Sci ISBN 989 9509 50 7 labour supply totalled 144,692 of which 1969 i.e. amount of publicity, promotion and exposure to 1A %, were found to be graduate employees in science in order to engage in such a job. science related professions. This is also The aim of this paper is to identify gender considerably low when compared to the differences in science-related courses at the proportion of students for the 12 European University of Malta. It also reports results of a Member States in 1992/93 (Key data on survey conducted among science undergraduates Education in the European Union, 1996), Table about their interest in a science career. In view of 2. These statistics show that there is need for these [mdings, actions that need to be taken in more science graduates in Malta. order to attract more students, particularly females, to science are proposed. T~ tl~ z~ P ... .::enl.1!je Nil m~ or Slu<lo!nts. ln HklhN (du~~ n ~. ~~": ~oeI.-,t OO !ltlld & by. U..,ml>er SI~ e . 199·,,' '1J 2. Theoretical background. I~" il (;ji ~; II!..! .. I ,\j., .\1 " H ,,' I. !;.: The under representation of women in \,1 ••• _, science, sex differences in interests and achievements have been the springboard to a : ...' wide range of research in gender and science education. Sex differentiation holds its roots to school, the 'hidden' and overt curriculum apart The December 2004 labour force figures from social interactions in the wider context of published by the National Office of Statistics society. through the labour force survey indicate that the Science is perceived as a male domain in females who are working or willing to work schools. Harding (1996) argues that school within the economy as a percentage of the total science becomes masculinised through: the females of working age is still 30.6% compared predominance of males working in science; the to the 60% by 2010 target set in the Lisbon way science is 'packaged' for teaching and Convention of the European Union. learning; classroom interactions which reinforce Progress in education depends on stereotyped expectations and the way science government's investment. In 2001, the Maltese itself is conceived and practised. Another government invested 7.3 million of its capital disadvantage to females, documented in the expenditure and 46.6 million of its recurrent AAUW report (1992) states that, in America's expenditure in education. (Consolidated fund schools, girls receive an inferior education to account for 2001). With respect to science boys in terms of the amount of attention given in education, the Prime Minister stated that "unless the classroom. Thus teachers should be the country continues to invest heavily in this responsible to eradicate any issues which might sector, it will not only lose the momentum it has reserve the association of particular subjects to established in a variety of economic and social one sex only. Instead they should provide fields, but will undergo a systematic process of opportunities for girls "to participate in science deterioration, leading to economic dependence", as women, rather than substitute men", (Gilbert, Fenech Adami (1996). The shadow minister, 2001). Bartolo (2001), reinforces this initiative by Vlaeminke et al. (1997) mention the saying that if Maltese citizens leave school contextual, cooperative and student-centred without an adequate scientific literacy, Malta curriculum as being more compatible with runs the risk of falling behind in the 21 st century. femininity. Females attune more to science in a Overall, there is a demand for science social context. According to Head (1985) and professionals in Malta. The Employment Harding (1996), they seek humanisation aspects Barometer Survey 2002, indicates a shortage of and applications. mechanical engineers. The statistic is based on The responsibility for the limited number of the unemployment figures for April 2002 and on girls choosing science should not only be the demand of employers during the same peliod. attributed to the curriculum. Kelly (1981) proves In addition to graduate professionals, our society that boys liked science more than girls. In also needs employees in the industrial, technical addition to this, both sexes differ in their and health related areas which support preferences within science subjects. In a Maltese professionals and who also call for a certain study Ventura (1992) reveals that "girls avoid 649 Women & Science 3rd International Conference on Hands-on Science © 2006 H-Sci ISBN 989 9509 50 7 careers in engineering and technology for which procedural knowledge. These differences mathematics is compulsory, and prefer careers in are in favour of boys for physics contexts medicine and related subjects instead."(p.12). such as mechanics and earth and space, These findings, in no way imply that females are and in favour of females for human inferior to males or are incompetent in science. biology. A consideration of the processes In fact, Ventura found that at secondary level, used would suggest that it is the depth of girls, peIform better than boys in science processing of information that is the examinations. As Kelly (1981) claims that critical factor ". despite getting good grades, girls are not (Bell, 2001, p. 484) accepting the physical and mathematical Education and gender do not progress in a SCIences. vacuum but in the context of society at large and The gender gap due to performance in science in smaller nuclei such as the family. Bell (2001) and mathematics becomes wider as age considers activities out of school accountable for increases. Various research works suggest that different performances. He attributes the gender sex differences in scholastic attainment tend to differences mentioned above to the activities in emerge clearly and consistently after the age of which boys and girls prefer to engage and the eleven. Gafni and Beller (1996) assessed the environments made available to them by parents peIformance of 3,300 pupils (aged 9 - 13) from and by peers. 110 different schools and, found that boys' Various researchers claim that single-sex performance was on average better than girls schools and classrooms create less gender-related across all participating countries.