DOCSLIB.ORG

Ethics and Climate Change a Study of National Commitments

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Ethics and Climate Change a Study of National Commitments Ethics and Climate Change: A Study of National Commitments Ethics and Climate Change A Study of National Commitments Donald A. Brown and Prue Taylor (Eds.) IUCN Environmental Law Programme Environmental Law Centre Godesberger Allee 108-112 53175 Bonn, Germany Phone: ++ 49 228 / 2692 231 Fax: ++ 49 228 / 2692 250 [email protected] IUCN Environmental Policy and Law Paper No. 86 www.iucn.org/law IUCN World Commission on Environmental Law Ethics and Climate Change A Study of National Commitments Ethics and Climate Change A Study of National Commitments Donald A. Brown and Prue Taylor (Eds.) IUCN Environmental Policy and Law Paper No. 86 The designation of geographical entities in this book, and the presentation of the material, do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of IUCN concerning the legal status of any country, territory, or area, or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect those of IUCN. Published by: IUCN, Gland, Switzerland in collaboration with the IUCN Environmental Law Centre, Bonn, Germany Copyright: © 2015 International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources Reproduction of this publication for educational or other non-commercial purposes is authorized without prior written permission from the copyright holder provided the source is fully acknowledged. Reproduction of this publication for resale or other commercial purposes is prohibited without prior written permission of the copyright holder. Citation: Donald A. Brown and Prue Taylor (Eds.) (2015). Ethics and Climate Change. A Study of National Commitments IUCN, Gland, Switzerland. xxx + 170 pp. ISBN: 978-2-8317-1709-8 DOI: 10.2305/IUCN.CH.2015.EPLP.86.en Cover design by: IUCN Environmental Law Centre Cover photo: © shutterstock Layout by: layout & more, Bonn Available from: IUCN Publications Services Rue Mauverney 28 1196 Gland Switzerland Tel +41 22 999 0000 Fax +41 22 999 0010 [email protected] www.iucn.org/publications Contents Foreword .................................................................. vii Acknowledgements .......................................................... ix Editors .................................................................... xi Contributors ............................................................... xiii Introduction ................................................................ xvii A Change in the Weather? Australia and Climate Change Politics 2007–2014 Peter D. Burdon 1 The Plurinational State of Bolivia’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Beth Jean Evans 15 Canada’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Anne D. Fouillard 25 China’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Sanna Kopra 53 Ethics and Justice in Climate Change Policies – Report on Italy Alessandra Solazzo and Massimiliano Montini 63 Japan’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Kathryn A. Gwiazdon 77 Kenya’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Martin Oulu 87 New Zealand’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Chris Hadley 95 The Netherlands’ Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Vivian Ike 109 Concerns of Ethics and Justice in Russian Climate Politics Katia Vladimirova 115 v South Africa’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Radhika Perrot 123 An Overview of South Korea’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice in its Climate Policy Sun-Jin Yun and Rakhyun E. Kim 135 Thailand: Shirking Away from Ethical Responsibility to Respond to Climate Change Danny Marks 143 Uganda’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Policies Akampurira Andrew 149 The United States of America’s Consideration of Ethics and Justice Issues in Formulating Climate Change Policies Donald A. Brown 159 vi National Climate Change Commitments Foreword Climate change is the most significant moral and environmental issue of our time. The collapse of the 2009 Copenhagen negotiations lead many to question whether the international community really had a moral compass to follow, beyond shallow declaratory statements and ambiguous phrases. The critical 2015 Paris negotiations will again put the actions and inactions of states squarely before the world’s peoples. To use the jargon of the negotiations, what will it take to get states to lift the level of moral and legal ambition and deliver a result that meets the criteria required by the IPCC’s 5th Assessment Reports? The IUCN’s conservation mission and work programmes have included climate change for many years across a number of Commissions. The World Commission on Environmental Law (‘WCEL’), for example, has a Specialist Working Group on Energy Law and Climate Change and the Environmental Law Programme works with a number of partner organisations on climate change issues. The IUCN and the WCEL have a strong commitment to global ethics as evident in the 1980 World Conservation Strategy and in the IUCN’s endorsement of the Earth Charter in 2008. This publication continues the important task of specifically relating considerations of ethics and justice to climate change. Donald Brown and Prue Taylor are world-renowned experts in the field of climate change ethics and leading members of the WCEL Ethics Specialist Group. They initiated this project and its publication. Their leadership attracted experts from fifteen nations who investigated moral and ethical considerations underpinning the climate commitments of their respective governments. The fundamental question asked of all states is this: to what extent do their national climate change commitments take into account responsibility (for those most vulnerable) and fairness (a fair share of global greenhouse gas emissions)? It is well recognized that transparent answers to these fundamental questions will be central to the success of any future global climate change agreement. In the interests of creating necessary transparency and in bringing considerations of ethics and justice to the fore, this book contains fifteen highly informative country reports. The reports concern China, the United States, Australia and Canada, together with three African states (South Africa, Kenya and Uganda), three European states (Italy, Netherlands and Russia), a selection from the Asia Pacific Region (Japan, South Korea, Thailand and New Zealand) and one South American state (Bolivia). The authors were asked to report against a standard set of questions to facilitate comparability between states. It is intended that this initial selection of reports will be added to (and in some instances updated) in the coming months via the project website: www.nationalclimatejustice.org. The objective is to create a repository of country reports that reveals the moral position of nations when determining their national commitments. This book makes an important contribution to the task of relating ethics and justice to climate change in a manner that is timely and practical. Global cooperation can only be built on trust and this in turn requires the highest attention to the moral imperatives of climate change. This book tells us how vi vii committed states have really been. It also provides guidance for ongoing climate negotiations, for the further development of national policies and laws, for decision-makers in public and private sectors and indeed for everyone concerned with our common destiny. Professor Klaus Bosselmann Chair, Ethics Specialist Group IUCN World Commission on Environmental Law viii National Climate Change Commitments Acknowledgements This project owes its existence to a determination to make considerations of ethics and justice integral to climate change policy in a way that is practical, transparent and accessible. It is our objective to shine a light on the justifications that states currently use for developing mitigation and adaptation policy, and measure those justifications against some basic criteria agreed upon by most states. The fifteen reports published in this book are the first in what we hope will become a comprehensive series covering as many nation states as possible. Our thanks go to all the authors with reports in this current collection. We have been energized by their interest and enthusiasm and we acknowledge their generosity in volunteering to research and write reports. Hopefully their efforts will inspire others to join us by contributing more national reports. This project began with a workshop run at the IUCN Academy of Environmental Law Colloquium, Tarragona, in July 2014. It was through this vehicle that we were able to present our project to colleagues, solicit helpful suggestions on the research template, and gauge support. Our thanks go to all those who participated in this workshop. Financial support was provided by our home Universities: Widener University School of Law (US) and the School of Architecture and Planning, University of Auckland (New Zealand). We are grateful for this assistance. Finally, we would like to thank the wonderful team at the IUCN Environmental Law Centre in Bonn for working with us. The efforts of the director Alejandro Iza, together with Ann DeVoy and Anni Lukács, has enabled us to deliver this project as an e-book
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Climate Change, Consequentialism, and the Road Ahead
    Chicago Journal of International Law Volume 13 Number 2 Article 8 1-1-2013 Climate Change, Consequentialism, and the Road Ahead Dale Jamieson Follow this and additional works at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cjil Recommended Citation Jamieson, Dale (2013) "Climate Change, Consequentialism, and the Road Ahead," Chicago Journal of International Law: Vol. 13: No. 2, Article 8. Available at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cjil/vol13/iss2/8 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Chicago Unbound. It has been accepted for inclusion in Chicago Journal of International Law by an authorized editor of Chicago Unbound. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Climate Change, Consequentialism, and the Road Ahead Dale Jamieson* Abstract In this paperI tell the stoy of the evolution of the climate change regime, locating its origins in "the dream of Rio," which supposed that the nations of the world would join in addressing the interlocking crises of environment and development. I describe the failure at Copenhagen and then go on to discuss the "reboot" of the climate negoiations advocated by Eric A. Posner and David Weisbach. I bring out some ambiguides in their notion of InternationalPareianism, which is supposed to effectively limit the influence of moral ideals in internationalaffairs, and pose a dilemma. I go on to discuss the foundations of their views regarding climate justice, arguing that the most reasonable understandings of their favored theoretical views would not lead to some of their conclusions. Finaly, I return to the climate regime, and make some observations about the road ahead, concluding thatfor theforeseeable future the most important climate change action will be within countries rather than among them.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Equitably Ending the Fossil Fuel Era: Climate Justice, Capital, & The
    Equitably Ending the Fossil Fuel Era: Climate Justice, Capital, & the Carbon Budget Georges Alexandre Lenferna A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Washington 2019 Reading Committee: Stephen Gardiner, Chair Carina Fourie Aseem Prakash Michael Blake Program Authorized to Offer Degree: Department of Philosophy 1 ©Copyright 2019 Georges Alexandre Lenferna 2 University of Washington Abstract Equitably Ending the Fossil Fuel Era: Climate Justice, Capital, & the Carbon Budget Georges Alexandre Lenferna Chair of the Supervisory Committee: Stephen Gardiner Department of Philosophy This dissertation makes the moral case for equitably transitioning away from fossil fuels in line with keeping global warming as close as possible to the Paris Climate Agreement’s more stringent target of keeping global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. It argues that we should do so while relying as little as possible on risky and uncertain negative emissions and geoengineering technologies, as doing so might prolong the fossil fuel era and pose grave potential costs both to the present and future generations. The dissertation addresses a central objection to the moral imperative to transition away from fossil fuels, namely that it will detrimentally impact the poor and vulnerable. It argues in response that protecting the interests of the poor and vulnerable is best achieved through a rapid yet just transition away from fossil fuels. Based on the moral case to transition away from fossil fuels in line with 1.5°C the dissertation also explores what personal moral responsibility individuals have to take action to reduce fossil fuel usage and act on climate change.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 3 Japan's Foreign Policy to Promote National and Worldwide
    Japan’s Foreign Policy to Promote National and Worldwide Interests Chapter 3 Chapter 3 Japan’s Foreign Policy to Promote National and Worldwide Interests 1. Efforts for Peace and Stability of Japan and the International Community Current Status of the Security Environment Surrounding Japan Korea nevertheless proceeded to conduct its third The security environment surrounding Japan is nuclear tests in February 2013. North Korea’s continued becoming increasingly severe. Amid progressively nuclear and missile development further exacerbates the greater presence of emerging countries in the threat to security in the region, seriously undermining international community, the power balance has been the peace and stability of the international community, changing, and this has substantially influenced the and cannot be tolerated. China’s moves to strengthen dynamics of international politics. The advancement its military capabilities without sufficient transparency, of globalization and rapid progress in technological and its rapidly expanded and intensified activities at innovation have invited a change in the relative influence sea and in the air, are matters of concern for the between states and non-state actors, increasing threats region and the international community. In January of terrorism and other crimes by non-state actors 2013, there was an incident in which a Chinese warship that undermine national security. The proliferation of directed its fire control radar at vessel of JMSDF (Japan weapons of mass destruction and other related materials Maritime Self-Defense Force), and in November, China also remains a threat. In addition, risks, to the global unilaterally established and announced the “East China commons, such as seas, outer space and cyberspace, Sea Air Defense Identification Zone.” These actions have been spreading and becoming more serious.
    [Show full text]
  • Climate Litigation and Atmospheric Ethics: a Case Study of Juliana V
    CLIMATE LITIGATION AND ATMOSPHERIC ETHICS: A CASE STUDY OF JULIANA V. UNITED STATES Mark Ortiz A thesis submitted to the faculty at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Department of Geography. Chapel Hill 2017 Approved By: Elizabeth Olson Elizabeth Havice Scott Kirsch ©2017 Mark Ortiz ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT Mark Ortiz: Climate Litigation and Atmospheric Ethics: A Case Study of Juliana v. United States (Under the Direction of: Drs. Elizabeth Olson and Elizabeth Havice) This thesis offers an account of climate change lawsuits as ethical experiments which endeavor to develop legal and ethical norms and principles suited to a world remolded by cumulative human actions. It offers a theorization of the ‘what’ and the ‘why’ of the growing, global wave of climate litigation by situating it within the dynamic landscape of contemporary climate politics. Through a case study of Juliana v. United States, a first-of-its-kind constitutional climate lawsuit against the United States federal government, this thesis examines how legal narrative is mobilized to give ethical shape and significance to the problem of climate change and to conceptualize responsibility across vast sweeps of space and time. Interweaving insights from climate ethics, environmental humanities, legal geography and science and technology studies, this research offers a set of meditations on atmospheric ethics iii TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: CLIMATE LITIGATION AS ETHICAL EXPERIMENTATION ................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Methods, Approach and Plan of the Present Work ....................................................... 5 1.3 Climate Ethics: Sculpting the Climatic Citizen ...........................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Need for Virtue in an Age of Climate Change a Thesis Presented
    The Need for Virtue in an Age of Climate Change A thesis presented to the faculty of the College of Arts and Sciences of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts in Philosophy Zachary R. Allison August 2018 © 2018 Zachary R. Allison. All Rights Reserved. 2 This thesis titled The Need for Virtue in an Age of Climate Change by ZACHARY R. ALLISON has been approved for the Philosophy Department and the College of Arts and Sciences by Scott Carson Associate Professor of Philosophy Joseph Shields Interim Dean, College of Arts and Sciences 3 ABSTRACT ALLISON, ZACHARY R., M.A., August 2018, Philosophy The Need for Virtue in an Age of Climate Change Director of Thesis: Scott Carson Dale Jamieson, Stephen Gardiner, Allen Thompson, and Byron Williston are four of the most prominent philosophers who have written on the role that virtue plays in an age of climate change. None of them, however, consider how valuable virtue can be in serving preventative ends. Climate change is, in part, a moral failure and part of the task of mitigating climate change should be acknowledging this failure and working to make sure we do not commit the same mistakes of the past. In this thesis, I argue for the cultivation of a virtue that I call “holism” that I believe can help humanity achieve this end. In chapter one, I discuss the arguments of the aforementioned philosophers and identify how their views of virtue in the Anthropocene are not identical to my own. In chapter two, I spell out the virtue of holism and argue for how it can help humanity work towards not allowing another climate catastrophe to happen once the present crisis is mitigated.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethics and the Economist: What Climate Change Demands of Us
    GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENT INSTITUTE WORKING PAPER NO. 11-02 Ethics and the Economist: What Climate Change Demands of Us J. A. Nelson May 2011 Tufts University Medford MA 02155, USA http://ase.tufts.edu/gdae This working paper is also available as an E3 (Economists for Equity and the Environment, e3network.org/) White Paper. A revised version will be published in Ecological Economics. Copyright 2011 Global Development and Environment Institute, Tufts University GDAE Working Paper No. 11-02: Ethics and the Economist: What Climate Change Demands of Us Abstract: Climate change is changing not only our physical world, but also our intellectual, social, and moral worlds. We are realizing that our situation is profoundly unsafe, interdependent, and uncertain. What, then, does climate change demand of us, as human beings and as economists? A discipline of economics based on Enlightenment notions of mechanism and disembodied rationality is not suited to present problems. This essay suggests three major requirements: first, that we take action; second, that we work together; and third, that we focus on avoiding the worst, rather than obtaining the optimal. The essay concludes with suggestions of specific steps that economists can take as researchers, teachers, and in our other roles. Keywords: climate change; ethics; catastrophe; uncertainty; interdependence; Enlightenment; responsibility; embodied reason 1 GDAE Working Paper No. 11-02: Ethics and the Economist: What Climate Change Demands of Us Ethics and the Economist: What Climate Change Demands of Us J. A. Nelson Climate change is changing our world. Not only is it changing our physical world, but also our intellectual, social, and moral worlds, in ways that we could not have imagined a generation or two ago.
    [Show full text]
  • JAPAN Auf Einen BLICK Nr. 171: Februar 2013
    JAPAN AUF EINEN BLICK Februar 2013 Das Monatsmagazin des Konsulats von Japan in Hamburg Ausgabe 171 / Februar 2013 Japan lädt ein Sayonara Berichte zum Empfang anlässlich des Mai Fujii, Researcher/Adviser, blickt Geburtstages S.M. des Kaisers sowie auf ihre zweijährige Dienstzeit in über den Neujahrsempfang…..Seite.02 Hamburg zurück.……………..Seite.05 Wahlergebnisse Ankurbeln Unterhauswahlen vom 16.12.2012 Die japanische Regierung bringt Kon- und neues Kabinett unter junkturpaket auf den Weg, um zum Premierminister Shinzo Abe…Seite.08 Wachstum zurückzukehren…Seite.10 Neujahrsfeste Stromnetz Hakuba-Club, DJG Winsen und DJG Mitsubishi und TenneT investieren in Hannover feiern Shinnenkai …Seite.11 Offshore-Netzanbindungen ..Seite.13 WAS ÜBRIG BLEIBT, Ehrung Termine BRINGT GLÜCK Hideki Fujii wird für seine vielfältigen http://www.hamburg.emb- Verdienste ausgezeichnet ..…Seite.15 japan.go.jp/downloads/termine.pdf Nokorimono niwa fuku ga aru JAPAN AUF EINEN BLICK Kultur- & Informationsbüro des Konsulats von Japan in Hamburg, Rathausmarkt 5, 20095 Hamburg, [email protected], www.hamburg.emb-japan.go.jp, Tel.: 040 333 0170, Fax: 040 303 999 15 REDAKTION Konsul Tomio Sakamoto (verantwortlich), Konsul Tatsuhiko Ichihara; Udo Cordes, Helga Eggers, Sabine Laaths, Marika Osawa, Saori Takano. JAPAN AUF EINEN BLICK erscheint zehnmal im Jahr und ist kostenlos als E-Letter zu beziehen. Alle hier veröffentlichten Artikel entsprechen nicht unbedingt der Meinung der japanischen Regierung oder des Konsulats von Japan in Hamburg. Redaktionsschluss ist der 15. des jeweiligen Vormonats. JAPAN AUF EINEN BLICK // Ausgabe 171 / Februar 2013 2 LEITARTIKEL Japan bittet zum Empfang Zwei große Empfänge im Hotel Vier Jahreszeiten in Hamburg, zu dem eng mit Japan verbundene Persönlichkeiten aus ganz Norddeutschland sowie das Hamburger Konsularkorps geladen waren, prägten das gesellschaftliche Leben Anfang Dezember des letzten Jahres und zum Jahresbeginn.
    [Show full text]
  • Souhrnná Terirotální Informace Japonsko
    SOUHRNNÁ TERITORIÁLNÍ INFORMACE Japonsko Souhrnná teritoriální informace Japonsko Zpracováno a aktualizováno zastupitelským úřadem ČR v Tokiu (Japonsko) ke dni 31. 8. 2016 18:03 Seznam kapitol souhrnné teritoriální informace: 1. Základní charakteristika teritoria, ekonomický přehled (s.2) 2. Zahraniční obchod a investice (s.13) 3. Vztahy země s EU (s.18) 4. Obchodní a ekonomická spolupráce s ČR (s.20) 5. Mapa oborových příležitostí - perspektivní položky českého exportu (s.29) 6. Základní podmínky pro uplatnění českého zboží na trhu (s.35) 7. Kontakty (s.48) 1/53 http://www.businessinfo.cz/japonsko © Zastupitelský úřad ČR v Tokiu (Japonsko) SOUHRNNÁ TERITORIÁLNÍ INFORMACE Japonsko 1. Základní charakteristika teritoria, ekonomický přehled Japonsko patří mezi vyspělé světové ekonomiky se stabilním právním prostředím. Je třetí největší světovou ekonomikou (po USA a Číně) a trhem s nejvyšším počtem bohatých domácností na světě. Japonsko skýtá dlouhou řadu exportních příležitostí, které dosud nebyly plně využity. Podkapitoly: 1.1. Oficiální název státu, složení vlády 1.2. Demografické tendence: Počet obyvatel, průměrný roční přírůstek, demografické složení (vč. národnosti, náboženských skupin) 1.3. Základní makroekonomické ukazatele za posledních 5 let (nominální HDP/obyv., vývoj objemu HDP, míra inflace, míra nezaměstnanosti). Očekávaný vývoj v teritoriu s akcentem na ekonomickou sféru. 1.4. Veřejné finance, státní rozpočet - příjmy, výdaje, saldo za posledních 5 let 1.5. Platební bilance (běžný, kapitálový, finanční účet), devizové rezervy (za posledních 5 let), veřejný dluh vůči HDP, zahraniční zadluženost, dluhová služba 1.6. Bankovní systém (hlavní banky a pojišťovny) 1.7. Daňový systém 1.1 Oficiální název státu, složení vlády Oficiální název státu: • Japonsko (japonsky: Nippon-koku či Nihon-koku, anglicky: Japan) Japonsko je konstituční monarchií s nejstarším parlamentním systémem ve východní Asii.
    [Show full text]
  • Roster of Winners in Single-Seat Constituencies No
    Tuesday, October 24, 2017 | The Japan Times | 3 lower house ele ion ⑳ NAGANO ㉘ OSAKA 38KOCHI No. 1 Takashi Shinohara (I) No. 1 Hiroyuki Onishi (L) No. 1 Gen Nakatani (L) Roster of winners in single-seat constituencies No. 2 Mitsu Shimojo (KI) No. 2 Akira Sato (L) No. 2 Hajime Hirota (I) No. 3 Yosei Ide (KI) No. 3 Shigeki Sato (K) No. 4 Shigeyuki Goto (L) No. 4 Yasuhide Nakayama (L) 39EHIME No. 4 Masaaki Taira (L) ⑮ NIIGATA No. 5 Ichiro Miyashita (L) No. 5 Toru Kunishige (K) No. 1 Yasuhisa Shiozaki (L) ( L ) Liberal Democratic Party; ( KI ) Kibo no To; ( K ) Komeito; No. 5 Kenji Wakamiya (L) No. 6 Shinichi Isa (K) No. 1 Chinami Nishimura (CD) No. 2 Seiichiro Murakami (L) ( JC ) Japanese Communist Party; ( CD ) Constitutional Democratic Party; No. 6 Takayuki Ochiai (CD) No. 7 Naomi Tokashiki (L) No. 2 Eiichiro Washio (I) ㉑ GIFU No. 3 Yoichi Shiraishi (KI) ( NI ) Nippon Ishin no Kai; ( SD ) Social Democratic Party; ( I ) Independent No. 7 Akira Nagatsuma (CD) No. 8 Takashi Otsuka (L) No. 3 Takahiro Kuroiwa (I) No. 1 Seiko Noda (L) No. 4 Koichi Yamamoto (L) No. 8 Nobuteru Ishihara (L) No. 9 Kenji Harada (L) No. 4 Makiko Kikuta (I) No. 2 Yasufumi Tanahashi (L) No. 9 Isshu Sugawara (L) No. 10 Kiyomi Tsujimoto (CD) No. 4 Hiroshi Kajiyama (L) No. 3 Yoji Muto (L) 40FUKUOKA ① HOKKAIDO No. 10 Hayato Suzuki (L) No. 11 Hirofumi Hirano (I) No. 5 Akimasa Ishikawa (L) No. 4 Shunpei Kaneko (L) No. 1 Daiki Michishita (CD) No. 11 Hakubun Shimomura (L) No.
    [Show full text]
  • Geoengineering and Non-Ideal Theory,” Public Affairs Quarterly 30:1 (2016): 85-104
    This is a pre-print version of Morrow and Svoboda, “Geoengineering and Non-Ideal Theory,” Public Affairs Quarterly 30:1 (2016): 85-104. If citing, please consult the published version. Geoengineering and Non-Ideal Theory David Morrow and Toby Svoboda Abstract The strongest arguments for the permissibility of geoengineering (also known as climate engineering) rely implicitly on non-ideal theory—roughly, the theory of justice as applied to situations of partial compliance with principles of ideal justice. In an ideally just world, such arguments acknowledge, humanity should not deploy geoengineering; but in our imperfect world, society may need to complement mitigation and adaptation with geoengineering to reduce injustices associated with anthropogenic climate change. We interpret research proponents’ arguments as an application of a particular branch of non-ideal theory known as “clinical theory.” Clinical theory aims to identify politically feasible institutions or policies that would address existing (or impending) injustice without violating certain kinds of moral permissibility constraints. We argue for three implications of clinical theory: First, conditional on falling costs and feasibility, clinical theory provides strong support for some geoengineering techniques that aim to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Second, if some kinds of carbon dioxide removal technologies are supported by clinical theory, then clinical theory further supports using those technologies to enable “overshoot” scenarios in which developing countries exceed the cumulative emissions caps that would apply in ideal circumstances. Third, because of tensions between political feasibility and moral permissibility, clinical theory provides only weak support for geoengineering techniques that aim to manage incoming solar radiation. Keywords: climate change, geoengineering, climate engineering, justice, non-ideal theory 2 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Japan's Political Turmoil in 2008: Background and Implications for The
    Order Code RS22951 September 16, 2008 Japan’s Political Turmoil in 2008: Background and Implications for the United States Mark E. Manyin and Emma Chanlett-Avery Foreign Affairs, Defense, and Trade Division Summary On September 1, 2008, Japanese Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda stunned observers by resigning his post, saying that a new leader might be able to avoid the “political vacuum” that he faced in office. Fukuda’s 11-month tenure was marked by low approval ratings, a sputtering economy, and virtual paralysis in policymaking, as the opposition Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ) used its control of the Upper House of Japan’s parliament (the Diet) to delay or halt most government proposals. On September 22, the ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) will elect a new president, who will become Japan’s third prime minister in as many years. Ex-Foreign Minister Taro Aso, a popular figure known for his conservative foreign policy credentials and support for increased deficit spending, is widely expected to win. Many analysts expect that the new premier will dissolve the Lower House and call for parliamentary elections later in the fall. As a result, Japanese policymaking is likely to enter a period of disarray, which could negatively affect several items of interest to the United States, including the passage of budgets to support the realignment of U.S. forces in Japan and the renewal of legislation that authorizes the deployment of Japanese navy vessels that are refueling ships supporting U.S.-led operations in Afghanistan. This report analyzes the factors behind and implications of Japan’s current political turmoil.
    [Show full text]
  • Japanische Innenpolitik: Schwerpunkte Und Tendenzen
    Japanische Innenpolitik: Schwerpunkte und Tendenzen Japanese Domestic Policy 2008/09: Highlights and Tendencies Manfred Pohl Domestic policy in 2008 and the first half of 2009 was once again characterized by traditional as well as recent shortcomings of political culture in Japan. That is why this chapter has to discuss the desperate fight of the Asô government for political survival under the system. The growing rift in the ruling coalition of the Liberal Democratic Party and the New Kōmeitō is described as a clear signal of beginning decline of the half-century of nearly unbroken rule by the LDP. Electoral behavior of Kōmeitō (or rather Sōka gakkai) followers and electoral maneuvering of conservative stalwarts is discussed, as are relations between the LDP and the opposition party with the ministe- rial bureaucracy, which was deeply troubled in 2008 by plans both of the LDP and the DPJ to curb its predominant role. Regional and gubernatorial elections in 2008 are outlined as possible early indicators for the disastrous election defeat of both the LDP and the Kōmeitō. The chapter finally seeks to evaluate the guiding role of the imperial family in Japanese society by reflecting upon the golden anniversary of the marriage of the imperial couple. 1 Überblick Die Jahre 2008 und 2009 dürften in die Geschichte der japanischen Innenpolitik als eine Periode eines unaufhaltsamen Niedergangs der machtgewohnten Libe- 24 Innenpolitik raldemokraten verzeichnet werden. Die größte Regierungspartei LDP (Liberal- Demokratische Partei, Jiyū Minshutō) unterlag in diesem Zeitraum weiter einem inneren Zersetzungsprozess, in dem die traditionellen Herrschaftsstrukturen, die der Partei seit 1955 ein nahezu unangefochtenes Machtmonopol sicherten, zerfielen.
    [Show full text]