Cracking the Cubic: Cardano, Controversy, and Creasing Alissa S
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Load more
Recommended publications
-
On Popularization of Scientific Education in Italy Between 12Th and 16Th Century
PROBLEMS OF EDUCATION IN THE 21st CENTURY Volume 57, 2013 90 ON POPULARIZATION OF SCIENTIFIC EDUCATION IN ITALY BETWEEN 12TH AND 16TH CENTURY Raffaele Pisano University of Lille1, France E–mail: [email protected] Paolo Bussotti University of West Bohemia, Czech Republic E–mail: [email protected] Abstract Mathematics education is also a social phenomenon because it is influenced both by the needs of the labour market and by the basic knowledge of mathematics necessary for every person to be able to face some operations indispensable in the social and economic daily life. Therefore the way in which mathe- matics education is framed changes according to modifications of the social environment and know–how. For example, until the end of the 20th century, in the Italian faculties of engineering the teaching of math- ematical analysis was profound: there were two complex examinations in which the theory was as impor- tant as the ability in solving exercises. Now the situation is different. In some universities there is only a proof of mathematical analysis; in others there are two proves, but they are sixth–month and not annual proves. The theoretical requirements have been drastically reduced and the exercises themselves are often far easier than those proposed in the recent past. With some modifications, the situation is similar for the teaching of other modern mathematical disciplines: many operations needing of calculations and math- ematical reasoning are developed by the computers or other intelligent machines and hence an engineer needs less theoretical mathematics than in the past. The problem has historical roots. In this research an analysis of the phenomenon of “scientific education” (teaching geometry, arithmetic, mathematics only) with respect the methods used from the late Middle Ages by “maestri d’abaco” to the Renaissance hu- manists, and with respect to mathematics education nowadays is discussed. -
Cracking the Cubic: Cardano, Controversy, and Creasing Alissa S
Cracking the Cubic: Cardano, Controversy, and Creasing Alissa S. Crans Loyola Marymount University MAA MD-DC-VA Spring Meeting Stevenson University April 14, 2012 These images are from the Wikipedia articles on Niccolò Fontana Tartaglia and Gerolamo Cardano. Both images belong to the public domain. 1 Quadratic Equation A brief history... • 400 BC Babylonians • 300 BC Euclid 323 - 283 BC This image is from the website entry for Euclid from the MacTutor History of Mathematics. It belongs to the public domain. 3 Quadratic Equation • 600 AD Brahmagupta To the absolute number multiplied by four times the [coefficient of the] square, add the square of the [coefficient of the] middle term; the square root of the same, less the [coefficient of the] middle term, being divided by twice the [coefficient of the] square is the value. Brahmasphutasiddhanta Colebook translation, 1817, pg 346 598 - 668 BC This image is from the website entry for Brahmagupta from the The Story of Mathematics. It belongs to the public domain. 4 Quadratic Equation • 600 AD Brahmagupta To the absolute number multiplied by four times the [coefficient of the] square, add the square of the [coefficient of the] middle term; the square root of the same, less the [coefficient of the] middle term, being divided by twice the [coefficient of the] square is the value. Brahmasphutasiddhanta Colebook translation, 1817, pg 346 598 - 668 BC ax2 + bx = c This image is from the website entry for Brahmagupta from the The Story of Mathematics. It belongs to the public domain. 4 Quadratic Equation • 600 AD Brahmagupta To the absolute number multiplied by four times the [coefficient of the] square, add the square of the [coefficient of the] middle term; the square root of the same, less the [coefficient of the] middle term, being divided by twice the [coefficient of the] square is the value. -
22. Newton's Method.Pdf
Newton's Method In this section we will explore a method for estimating the solutions of an equation f(x) = 0 by a sequence of approximations that approach the solution. Note that for a quadratic equation ax2 +bx+c = 0, we can solve for the solutions using the quadratic formula. There are formulas available to find the zeros of cubic and quartic polynomials, however they are more difficult (and tedious) to apply than the quadratic formula. Some notes on the history of the solutions have been included at the end of the lecture. It can be shown that the derivation of such a formula is impossible for polynomials with degree 5 or higher and there is no such systematic method to find their solutions. The methods below apply to all polynomial functions and a wide range of other functions. Procedure for Newton's Method To estimate the solution of an equation f(x) = 0, we produce a sequence of approximations that approach the solution. We find the first estimate by sketching a graph or by guessing. We choose x1 which is close to the solution according to our estimate. The method then uses the tangent line to the curve at the point (x1; f(x1)) as an estimate of the path of the curve. We label the point where this tangent to the graph of f(x) cuts the x-axis, x2. Usually x2 is a better approximation to the solution of f(x) = 0 than x1. We can find a formula for x2 in terms of x1 by using the equation of the tangent at (x1; f(x1)): 0 y = f(x1) + f (x1)(x − x1): The x-intercept of this line, x2, occurs when y = 0 or 0 0 f(x1) + f (x1)(x2 − x1) = 0 or − -
THE CUBIC CHRONICLES Cast of Characters
The Italian Connection THE CUBIC CHRONICLES Cast of Characters Omar Khayyam (1048‐1131). A great Persian mathematician working in the Seljuk (Turkish) empire. Solved cubic equations numerically by intersection of conic sections. Stated that some of these equations could not be solved using only straightedge and compass, a result proved some 750 years later. Luca Pacioli (1445‐1509) His Suma (1494) summarized all that was known on equations. He discusses quartic equations stating what in modern notation would be: x4 = a + bx2 can be solved as a quadratic equation but x4 + ax2 = b and X4 +a = bx2 are impossible at the present state of science. Cast of Characters Continued There may not be any Scipione dal Ferro (1465‐1526). Professor at reliable portrait of Bologna. Around 1515 figured out how to Scipione dal Ferro on solve the equation x3 + px = q by radicals. the web. One that pops Kept his work a complete secret until just up is really Tartaglia. before his death, the revealed it to his student Antonio Fior. Antonio Fior (1506‐?). Very little information No portrait of seems to be available about Fior. His main claim Antonio Fior seems to fame seems to be his challenging Tartaglia to to be available. a public equation ``solvathon,’’ and losing the challenge. Cast of Characters Continued Nicolo of Brescia who adopted the name Tartaglia (Stutterer) (1499‐1557). Hearing a rumor that cubic equations had been solved, figured out how to solve equations of the form x3 +mx2 = n, and made it public. This made Fior think that Tartaglia would not know how to deal with the equations del Ferro knew how to solve and he challenged Tartaglia to a public duel. -
History of Mathematics Mathematical Topic Ix Cubic Equations and Quartic Equations
HISTORY OF MATHEMATICS MATHEMATICAL TOPIC IX CUBIC EQUATIONS AND QUARTIC EQUATIONS PAUL L. BAILEY 1. The Story Various solutions for solving quadratic equations ax2 + bx + c = 0 have been around since the time of the Babylonians. A few methods for attacking special forms of the cubic equation ax3 +bx2 +cx+d = 0 had been investigated prior to the discovery and development of a general solution to such equations, beginning in the fifteenth century and continuing into the sixteenth century, A.D. This story is filled with bizarre characters and plots twists, which is now outlined before describing the method of solution. The biographical material here was lifted wholesale from the MacTutor History of Mathematics website, and then editted. Other material has been derived from Dunham’s Journey through Genius. 1.1. Types of Cubics. Zero and negative numbers were not used in fifteenth cen- tury Europe. Thus, cubic equations were viewed to be in different types, depending on the degrees of the terms and there placement with respect to the equal sign. • x3 + mx = n “cube plus cosa equals number” • x3 + mx2 = n “cube plus squares equals number” • x3 = mx + n “cube equals cosa plus number” • x3 = mx2 + n “cube equals squares plus number” Mathematical discoveries at this time were kept secret, to be used in public “de- bates” and “contests’. For example, the method of depressing a cubic (eliminating the square term by a linear change of variable) was discovered independently by several people. The more difficult problem of solving the depressed cubic remained elusive. 1.2. Luca Pacioli. -
Solving Polynomial Equations
Solving Polynomial Equations Part II Cubic Equations Babylonian clay tablets have been found with tables of cubes of numbers. Such tables could be used to solve cubic equations and it has been suggested that they were used for this purpose.1 Cubic equations arise in the geometric problem of “duplicating the cube” and these can be solved geometrically by finding the intersection of two conics. Such solutions have been credited to the Greek mathematician Menæchmus (c. 350 B.C.)2. Archimedes, in his monumental work The Sphere and Cylinder, considers the problem of cutting a sphere by a plane so that the two segments shall have a given ratio. This leads to a cubic equation which Eutocius (c. 560) says Archimedes solved by finding the intersection of two conics3. Omar Khayyam Nothing more is known about the cubic equation among the Greeks, but the problem of Archimedes was taken up by the Arabs and Persians of the 9th Century. Much of this work is cited by Omar Khayyam. Umar ibn Ibrāhīm al Khayyāmī (1048-1131) was a Persian mathematician, astronomer, philosopher and poet (best known in the West for his poetic work the Rubaiyat). His major mathematical work, Treatise on Demonstrations of Problems of al- Jabr and al-Muqābala, is primarily devoted to the solution of cubic equations. The work is geometric in the Greek tradition, in fact he says that the reader should be familiar with Euclid's Elements and Data as well as Apollonius' Conics since cubic equations can only be solved geometrically using conic sections. Omar Khayyam He would have liked to provide algebraic algorithms that solved cubic equations a la al-Khwārizmī, but as he says: When, however, the object of the problem is an absolute number, neither we, nor any of those who are concerned with algebra, have been able to solve this equation – perhaps others who follow us will be able to fill the gap.4 For al-Khayyāmī, as with his predecessors, all numbers were positive and so he classified cubics into 14 cases and analyzed each case in terms of which conic sections were needed for their solutions. -
A Simple Method to Solve Quartic Equations
Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 6(6): 331-336, 2012 ISSN 1991-8178 A Simple Method to Solve Quartic Equations 1Amir Fathi, 2Pooya Mobadersany, 3Rahim Fathi 1Department of Electrical Engineering, Urmia branch, Islamic Azad University, Urmia, Iran 2Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran 3Department of Electrical Engineering, Urmia branch, Islamic Azad University, Urmia, Iran Abstract: Polynomials of high degrees often appear in many problems such as optimization problems. Equations of the fourth degree or so called quartics are one type of these polynomials. Since now there is not any simple method to solve the general forms of quartic equations. In this paper we propose a novel, simple and precise analytical method to solve quartic equations without any constraints. Key words: Polynomials, Quartics, Equations of the Fourth Degree INTRODUCTION A quartic function is a polynomial of degree four. The general form of a quartic function is as follows: 432 f ()xaxbxcxdxe, a 0 (1) Setting f ()x 0 results in a quartic equation of the form written below: 432 ax bx cx dx e 0 , a 0 (2) The quartic is the highest order polynomial equation that can be solved by radicals in the general case (I. Stewart, 2004) (i.e., one where the coefficients can take any value). In 1540 Lodovico Ferrari discovered the solution to the quartic equation (J.J. O'Connor and E. F. Robertson). Like all algebric solutions of the quartic equations, this method required the solution of a cubic equation to be found. The general form of a cubic equation is as follows: 32 ax bx cx d 0 ,a 0 (3) Gerolamo Cardano proved that the solution of the general cubic function in equation (3) is (N. -
Definition 1. a Group Is an Ordered Pair (G, Μ)
SOME HISTORICAL CONTEXT We begin1 with the abstract definition of a group; Definition 1. A group is an ordered pair (G; µ), where G is a set and µ : G × G ! G is a binary operation, satisfying the following axioms: (1) (associativity) µ(µ(a; b); c) = µ(a; µ(b; c)) for any a; b; c 2 G (2) (identity) there exists e 2 G such that for any a 2 G we have µ(a; e) = µ(e; a) = a (3) (inverses) for any a 2 G, there is an element a−1 2 G such that µ(a; a−1) = µ(a−1; a) = e. As we saw in class, a few basic examples are: • the integers Z = f:::; −2; −1; 0; 1; 2;::: g, with the binary operation µ : Z×Z ! Z given by ordinary addition of integers • the nonzero rational numbers Q× := Q n f0g, with the binary operation given by ordinary multiplication of rational numbers • the nonzero complex numbers C× := C n f0g, with the binary operation given by multiplication of complex numbers, etc. We also saw that Z equipped with ordinary multiplication is not a group, since most elements do not have an inverse within the integers. Another very important family of groups are the permutation groups. Recall that for n 2 Z≥1, Sn is the set of permutations of the set f1; : : : ; ng, i.e. invertible maps from the set f1; : : : ; ng to the set f1; : : : ; ng. The natural binary operation µ : Sn × Sn ! Sn is given the composition of set maps, i.e. -
MATHEMATICS HISTORY in the CLASSROOM Katie S
John Carroll University Carroll Collected Masters Essays Theses, Essays, and Senior Honors Projects Summer 2015 WHO CAME UP WITH THIS? MATHEMATICS HISTORY IN THE CLASSROOM Katie S. Schneck John Carroll University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://collected.jcu.edu/mastersessays Part of the Mathematics Commons Recommended Citation Schneck, Katie S., "WHO CAME UP WITH THIS? MATHEMATICS HISTORY IN THE CLASSROOM" (2015). Masters Essays. 26. http://collected.jcu.edu/mastersessays/26 This Essay is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Essays, and Senior Honors Projects at Carroll Collected. It has been accepted for inclusion in Masters Essays by an authorized administrator of Carroll Collected. For more information, please contact [email protected]. WHO CAME UP WITH THIS? MATHEMATICS HISTORY IN THE CLASSROOM An Essay Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies College of Arts & Sciences of John Carroll University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts By Katie S. Schneck 2015 The essay of Katie S. Schneck is hereby accepted: Advisor – Robert J. Kolesar Date I certify that this is the original document Author – Katie S. Schneck Date Table of Contents 1. Introduction 2. Lesson #1 Eratosthenes and the Circumference of the Earth 3. Lesson #2 Approximating Pi, Archimedes Style 4. Lesson #3 Chances Are… The Birth of Probability 5. Lesson #4 Clash of the Cubics – A Tale of Challenges, Duels and Theft 6. Lesson #5 Ladies First – The First Computer Programmer 7. Conclusion 8. Reference Page 1 1. INTRODUCTION Ever since I was a child, I knew I wanted to be a teacher. -
Quartic Function - Wikipedia 22/09/2019, 10 03
Quartic function - Wikipedia 22/09/2019, 1003 Quartic function In algebra, a quartic function is a function of the form where a is nonzero, which is defined by a polynomial of degree four, called a quartic polynomial. Sometimes the term biquadratic is used instead of quartic, but, usually, biquadratic function refers to a quadratic function of a square (or, equivalently, to the function defined by a quartic polynomial without terms of odd degree), having the form A quartic equation, or equation of the fourth degree, is an equation that equates a quartic polynomial to zero, of the form where a ≠ 0. The derivative of a quartic function is a cubic function. Since a quartic function is defined by a polynomial of even degree, it has the same infinite limit when the argument goes to positive or negative infinity. If a is positive, then the function increases to positive infinity at both ends; and thus the function has a global minimum. Likewise, if a is negative, it decreases to negative infinity and has a global maximum. In both cases it may or may not have another local maximum and another local minimum. The degree four (quartic case) is the highest degree such that every polynomial equation can be solved by radicals. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quartic_function Page 1 of 21 Quartic function - Wikipedia 22/09/2019, 1003 Contents History Applications Inflection points and golden ratio Solution Nature of the roots General formula for roots Special cases of the formula Simpler cases Reducible quartics Biquadratic equation Quasi-palindromic equation Graph of a polynomial of degree 4, with Solution methods 3 critical points and four real roots Converting to a depressed quartic (crossings of the x axis) (and thus no Ferrari's solution complex roots). -
The Bicentennial of Evariste Galois Robert “Dr
The Bicentennial of Evariste Galois Robert “Dr. Bob” Gardner Fall 2011 [References] [“The Question” slide] [The Equation] In modern notation, this presentation is about expressing the solutions of the equation: n n 1 n 2 3 2 cnx + cn 1x − + cn 2x − + c3x + c2x + c1x + c0 = 0 − − ··· in an algebraic way. [INSERT Algebraic] That is, what does x equal? Ex- press the answer as a combination of the coefficients using the operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and extraction of roots. [Insert Radicals] An algebraic solution is also sometimes called “solving by radicals.” [Familiar Example] A familiar example of the problem is to find the roots (or zeros) of the second degree equation ax2+bx+c = 0. We want the values of x expressed in terms of a, b, and c and only with the use of addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and the extraction of roots. Of course, the values of x b √b2 4ac are given by the familiar quadratic equation: x = − ± − . 2a [Unfamiliar Example. Another example, which is likely not so familiar to you, is that of finding the values of x which result from setting a third degree polynomial equal to zero: ax3 + bx2 + cx + d = 0. Again, the values of x must be expressed in terms of the coefficients a, b, c, and d by using the algebraic operations. The reason you probably have not seen this in the past is that it is actually rather impractical and complicated. [Roots of a Cubic] Here are the solutions. Notice that x2 and x3 involve square roots of negatives.