Sequential Products on Effect Algebras
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SEQUENTIAL PRODUCTS ON EFFECT ALGEBRAS Stan Gudder Richard Greechie Department of Mathematics Department of rvIathematics U niversity of Denver Louisiana Tech University Denver Colorado 80208 Rusto且, Louisiana 71272 [email protected] [email protected] Abstract A sequential effect algebra (SEA) is an effect algebra on which a sequential product with natural properties is defined. The propertíes of sequential products on Hi1bert space effect algebras are discussed. For a general SEA, relationships between. sequential independence. coexistence and compatibility are given. It is shown that the sharp elements of a SEA form an orthomodular poset. The sequential center of a SEA is discussed and a characterization of when the sequential center ís isomorphic to a fuzzy set system is presented. It is shown that the existence of a sequential product is a strong restriction that eliminates many effect algebras frorn being SEA's. For example, there are no finite nonboolean SEA's. A measure of sharpness called he sharpness index is studied. The existence of horizontal sums of SEA's is characterized and exarnples of horizontal sums and tensor products are presented. 1 Introd uction Two measurement5 αand b cannot .be performed 5imultaneously in generaL 50 they are frequently executed 5equentially. 飞斗飞~ denote by α 。 b a sequen tial measurement in whichαis performed first and b second. \Ve cal1 α 。 b l the sequential product of αand b. \Ve shal1 restrict our attention to yes-no measurements. called effects, which have only two possible results. For gen erality, we do not 臼sume that effects are perfectly accurate me臼urements. That is. they may be fuzzy or unsharp. :也5 we shall see, the sharp effects are those that satisfy α 。 α=α. A paradigm situation is an optica1 bench in which abeam of partic1es prepared in a certain state is injected at the left and then impinge first upon a filterαand then upon a filter b. Particles that p臼s through both filters enter a detection device at the right of b. Because of quantum interference. the order of placement of αand b usually makes a difference and we have α 。 b#b 。 α. 1f it happens thatα 。 b = boa we say thatαand b are sequentially independent and writeαI b. 1n recent years quantum effects have been studied within a general a1ge braic frame 飞;\'ork called an effect algebra. 1n Section 2 we sha11 summarize the basic de且 nitions concerning effect algebras and the properties of sequential products on Hilbert space effect a1gebras. The simplest of these properties are employed as a.xioms in Section 3 for a sequential effect algebra (SE.-\). A SE:\. is an effect algebra on which a sequential product with natural proper ties is defined. \Ve be1ieve that the a.xioms for a SEA are physically motivated and can be tested, for example, in the optical bench situation. Various prop erties of a SE人 are proved in Section 3. For instance, relationships between sequential independence, coexistence and compatibility are given. 1t is also sho\\'n that the sharp elements form an orthomodular poset. The sequential center C(E) of a SEA E is the set of elements αε E such thatαI b for every b ε E. 1n Section 4 it is shown that C(E) coincides with the set of sharp central elements which has previously been studied. :\loreover. a characterization is given for when C(E) is isomorphic to a fuzzy set system. Section 5 shows that the existence of a sequentia1 product is a strong restriction that eliminates many effect algebras from being SEA 's. It is shown' that a Boolean algebra admits a unique sequentia1 product and that certain effect algebras admit a sequential product only if they are Boolean. ~Ioreover. it is prO\'ed that if a map preserves the sequential product then it completely preseryes the effect algebra structure of the sharp elements. Section 6 defines the sharpness index of an effect. 1t is demonstrated that if E is isotropically 且 ni 2 tions 8 and 9. The existence of horizontal sums is characterized and some examples of horizontal sums and tensor products are given. 2 Hilbert Space Sequential Products This section summarizes the b臼 ic definitions concerning effect algebr臼 [1 , 6, 7, 8, 14, 15] and the properties of sequential products on Hilbert space effect algebr出 [2. 3. 10, 12, 13]. If EÐ is a partial binary operation, we write α -L b ifαEÐ b is defined. .\n effect algebra is a system (E, 0, 1, EÐ) where 0, 1 are distinct elements of E and EÐ is a partial binary operation on E that satisfies the following conditions. (E1) If a • b, then b 1. αand bEÐ a =αEÐ b. (E2) If α -L b and c -L (αEÐ b) , then b 1. c , α 1. (b EÐ c) andαEÐ(bEÐc)= (αEÐ b) EÐ c. (E3) For every αE E there exists a unique a' E E such that α 1. a' and αEÐ a' = 1. (E4) 1fα -L 1, then α=0. 1n the sequel ,飞,yhenever we writeαEÐ b we are implicit!y assuming that α -L b. 飞飞,~e define α ~ b if there exists a c E E such that αEÐ c = b. If such a c E E exists then it is unique and we write c = b e α. It can be shown that (E , 三,') is a partially ordered set with 0 ~二 α 三 1 for all αεE.α"α. and α 三 b implies b' ~ a'. Moreover, we have α 1. b if and only ifα 三 b'. If α4α we call αan isotropic element and when 0 is the only isotropic element of E, then we call E an orthoalgebra. If the n-fold orthosum a EÐα@ … @α is defined in E we denote this element of E by nα. If there is a largest ηEN such that. na is defined, then ηis the isotropic index of αand if no such n exists. then ηhas isotropic index ∞. An element αε E is sharp ifα ^a' = O. Xotice that ifα 笋 o is sharp then a has isotropic index 1. \Ve say that E is isotropically finite if everyα 笋 o in E has finite isotropic index. 飞飞'e now give some standard examples of effect algebr臼. For a Boolean al gebra 8 , defineα 1. bifα ^b = 0 and in this c臼eαEÐb=αvb. Then (8, 0, 1, EÐ) is an effect algebra that happens to be an orthoalgebra. In particular if X is a nonempty set, then (2X , 白, X , EÐ) is an effect algebra. These effect algebras correspond to classicallogic and set theory. For the function space [0 , 1]''\ 3 on the inten.al [0, 1] ç lR define the functions fo , h by fo(x) = O. fI (x) = 1 for all x εX. For f , 9 ç [0, 1]'\, we define f 1. 9 if f(x) + g(x) 三 1 for all Z εX and in this case (J æ g)(x) = f(x) + g(x). Then ([0, l]X,fo ,h ,æ) is the effect algebra of fuzzy subsets of X. A particularly simple effect algebra is the interval [0, 1] ç R. For α , b ε[0 , 1] we defineα 1. b ifα 十 b 三 1 and in this case α æb= α +b. In this section we are mainly concerned with the set ê(H) of all self adjoint operators on a Hilbert space H that satisfy 0 三 (Ax , x) 三位 , x) for all x E H. For .4., B ε ê(H) we define A 1. B if A + B E ê(H) and in this case .4 EÐ B = A + B. Then (ê(H), O,!, æ) is an effect algebra that we call a Hilbert space effect algebra. This effect algebra is important in studies of the foundations of quantum physics and quantum measurement theory [2 , 3. 4 ,而, 17]. The quantum effects A ε ê (H) correspond to yes-no measurements that may be unsharp. The set of projection operators P(H) on H form an orthoalgebra that is a sub-effect algebra of ê(H). The elements of P( H) correspond to sharp quantum effects. If E and F are effect algebras, we say that rþ: E • F is additive ifα 1. b implies rþ( α) 1.功 (b) and rþ( αæ b) = φ(α) EÐ rþ(b). If rþ: E • F is additive and 0(1) = 1, then φis a morphism. If 4>: E • F is a morphism and φ(α) 1. rþ(b) implies that α 1. b, then φis a monomorphism. .\ surjective monomorphism is an isomorphism. It is easy to see that a morphism d> is an isomorphism if and only if rþ is bijective and φ-1 is a morphism. .\ state on E is a morphism s: E → [O~ 1]. \Ve interpret s( α) as the probability that the effectαis observed (has answer yes) when the system is in the state s. We denote the set of states on E by n(E). A set of states S ç n(E) is order determining if s( α) 三 s(b) for all s ε S implies thatα 三 b. The sequential product on ê(H) is defined by A 0 B = .-1 1/ 2 BA 1/2 1 2 where .-1 / is the unique positive square root of A. [2, 3, 10, 12, 13]. We have that .-1 0 B ε ê (H) because 。三 (.-1 1 / 2 BA 1 / 2 X , X) = (B 川 2 X , 川 2X) 三 (A 1/2 ι .4 1 / 2 x) = (Ax, x) 空 (x , x) for all x E H.