The Global Climate Crisis: a Child Rights Crisis

Home , Climate change education, Climate crisis, Paris Agreement

November 2019

POLICY BRIEF CHILD RIGHTS The Global Climate Crisis: NOW! A Child Rights Crisis

“Acknowledging that climate change is a common concern of humankind, Parties should, when taking action to address climate change, respect, promote and consider their respective obligations on human rights, the right to health, the rights of indigenous peoples, local communities, migrants, children, persons with disabilities and people in vulnerable situations and the right to development, as well as gender equality, empowerment of women and intergenerational equity.”

UNFCCC Paris Agreement, 2015

“This is all wrong. I shouldn’t be up here. I should be back in school on the other side of the ocean. Yet you all come to us young people for hope. How dare you. You have stolen my dreams and my childhood with your empty words.”

Greta Thunberg, 16-year old climate activist, UN Climate Action Summit, 2019 2 CHILD RIGHTS NOW! • The global climate crisis: a child rights crisis

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

• Climate change arguably poses the single greatest challenge to the realisation of children’s rights, and threatens to undercut decades of hard-won progress to improve their lives. • Despite being least responsible for this unfolding crisis, children bear the brunt of the climate-related impacts, while possessing the fewest resources to respond and cope. At its core, climate change represents a shocking abdication of one generation’s responsibility to the next, violating principles of intergenerational equity. Drought, flooding, extreme weather events, rising temperatures, and desertification directly undermine a broad spectrum of children’s rights, from access to food and safe water, to housing, education, freedom from exploitation, violence and abuse, and – too frequently – their right to survive and thrive. Moreover, because resilience to climate change is shaped by broader socio-economic factors, such as gender inequality and poverty, the situation is particularly fraught for marginalised girls and other highly-vulnerable groups of children, compounding the multiple hardships that they face. • Tackling climate change demands urgent attention to equity, across borders and generations. The countries that have contributed least to the accumulation of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere tend to be the most vulnerable and to have limited capacity for adaptation. Because they also tend to have proportionately large and rapidly-growing child populations, their vulnerability to climate change puts ever-greater numbers of children at risk. • Despite the catastrophic implications for children’s rights posed by climate change, as well as the growing global movement of children and youth calling for ambitious climate action, recognition of children’s rights barely feature in key international, regional and national decision-making frameworks related to climate change, including the Paris Agreement and workstreams under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), as well as the SDGs. This oversight is a violation of the guiding principles of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UN CRC), notably that the best interest of the child – as well as their right to be heard – should be primary considerations in any decision that affects them. CHILD RIGHTS NOW! • The global climate crisis: a child rights crisis 3

Critical data and Children face problem analysis disproportionate and

Since the adoption of the UN CRC in 1989, cascading forms of climate unprecedented gains have been made in children’s health, nutrition, access to education, harm and formal protections in laws and policies. Yet this progress risks being undermined by the Children are disproportionately vulnerable escalating climate crisis, which poses an acute to the impacts of climate change threat to children’s survival, development and largely because the early stage of their wellbeing. physiological and cognitive development makes them less-equipped to deal with Average global temperatures have already climate-related shocks and stresses. This surpassed 1ºC above pre-industrial levels, is particularly the case between birth and exposing millions of children, particularly the age of 5. For example, by 2100, 75% among the most disadvantaged communities, of the world’s people are projected to be to significant and severe threats to their rights. exposed to heatwaves so extreme they can Even the “best-case” scenario (limiting global kill.4 Young children are more vulnerable warming to 1.5ºC) would effectively put millions than adults to the life-threatening effects of children at risk of life-threatening climate- of heatwaves, since they are less able to related impacts.1 regulate their body temperature, and must rely on others to control the temperature of the surrounding environment.5 Children are Children are one of the also more likely than adults to be injured, to experience psychological trauma, or be largest groups affected by killed by natural hazard-related disasters.6 climate change Children are also more likely to experience health complications due to the impacts of Many of the countries that are most climate change on water and food security, vulnerable to climate change also have such as drought, crop failure, and decreased a higher proportion of children in their nutritional value of staple crops due to populations,2 with demographic trends higher carbon dioxide concentrations. suggesting that many of these countries are Nearly half of all deaths among children also those in which child populations tend under the age of 5 are associated with to be growing most rapidly. According to undernutrition, which also places children UNICEF data, over half a billion children live at greater risk of dying from infections and in areas with extremely high risk of flooding; diseases.7 Undernutrition in the first two 115 million are at high or extremely high years of life can lead to irreversible stunting, risk from tropical cyclones, and almost 160 with negative effects on children’s physical million are exposed to high or extremely and cognitive development, impacting high drought severity. 3 their health, educational performance, and economic productivity later in life.8 The WHO estimates that climate change will lead to nearly 95,000 additional deaths per year due to undernutrition in children aged 5 and under by 2030, and an additional 24 million undernourished children by 2050.9 Furthermore, climate change is expected to lead to an additional 7.5 million children under the age of 5 who are moderately or severely stunted by 2030.10 4 CHILD RIGHTS NOW! • The global climate crisis: a child rights crisis

Rising temperatures are increasing the © Philip Maher - Kenya incidence of water- and vector-borne diseases, such as malaria and dengue fever. Children under the age of 5 already bear the global burden of these diseases, accounting for almost 80% of all deaths from malaria in 2014.11 It is anticipated that by 2030, climate change will result in an additional 60,000 deaths from malaria among children under the age of 15. Diarrhoeal disease is another leading cause of death among children, and is also set to increase as a result of drought, flooding and changing precipitation patterns, threatening safe water supplies and hygiene practices. By 2030, climate-related increases in diarrhoeal disease are anticipated to lead to Gender dimensions of the death of an additional 48,000 children under the age of 15.12 climate change Beyond children’s rights to life, survival, development and health, climate change The impacts of climate change, as well as the also threatens their right to education. measures that are adopted to address these, Extreme weather events destroy schools, frequently exacerbate gender inequalities. while climate-related impacts on nutrition For example, adolescent girls are and physical and mental health affect particularly affected by threats to safe water children’s ability to learn. Loss of family supplies, since they are often responsible livelihoods and income due to climate stress for water collection. They may be required is also correlated with loss of education as to travel further to find sufficient quantities of children are obliged to assist with household water in a changing climate, representing tasks, or to seek work, leading to increases a significant physical and time-consuming in child labour, child marriage, and other burden, with implications for their education, violations of their rights.13 leisure time and wellbeing. In addition, during long journeys to fetch water or other Children are acutely vulnerable in the household resources, such as firewood, context of climate-related migration and girls may be exposed to risks such as sexual displacement.14 For example, climate violence. A lack of water also raises clear change can lead to internal migration of sexual and reproductive health concerns, as families to urban areas where children may girls need access to water and hygiene and be forced into labour. The disruptive effects sanitation purposes during menstruation and of migration on family networks can be pregnancy15. particularly harmful for young children aged 0-3 who are often left at home alone or in Climate stress also leads to negative coping the care of young siblings while their parents mechanisms. Human Rights Watch has seek or go to work. documented how families facing repeated climate-related shocks in their communities due to river erosion, loss of crops or cyclones, were more likely to marry off their daughters at a young age, before they were displaced. Boys meanwhile may be at increased risk of child labour and exploitation in conflict areas16 CHILD RIGHTS NOW! • The global climate crisis: a child rights crisis 5

More than 1.2 billion people live in Poor families are more likely to occupy extreme poverty – a third of these are land that is highly-exposed to the impacts children under the age of 13. In low-income of climate change, and to have less access countries, more than 50 per cent of all to adequate housing and climate-resilient children live in extreme poverty.17 Climate services such as water and sanitation, change has a disproportionate impact on increasing their vulnerability to climate those already facing chronic poverty and shocks.20 The World Bank estimates that hunger and inhibits the ability of parents climate change impacts could push an and caregivers to meet the basic needs of additional 100 million people into poverty their children. Seventy-five percent of food by 2030.21 insecure people are smallholder farmers in developing countries who depend on The implications for children are grave, agriculture as a main source of food and given that they are globally twice as likely as income. Smallholder agriculture is a natural adults to be poor, and account for half of all resource-based economic activity that is people who remain in extreme poverty. 22 increasingly challenged by drought, saline intrusion, flooding, land degradation and desertification.18

Progress towards a Marginalised children are first rights-based approach and worst-affected to climate action appears Predictably, marginalised children that are to be faltering most at risk of being left behind in global development efforts, are also those that are disproportionately vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. Girls, poor children, indigenous children, minorities, children on the move, and children with disabilities, are first and worst-affected by climate change. For example, girls are more likely to be removed from school to help with household tasks, such as fetching water and firewood, and are more likely to suffer from domestic violence, trafficking, exploitation and abuse in the wake of climate-related disasters.19

Despite the evidence of the severe consequences of climate change for children, international and national frameworks on climate change largely ignore children’s right to be heard and for their best interests. Children are conspicuously absent from key policy processes under the UNFCCC, including core workstreams, decisions, and the possibility to participate in the yearly annual negotiations, which is highly restricted for children under the The passion and activism of the global age of 18. movement of children’s Fridays for Future climate strikes has helped to challenge this status quo, While recognition of youth in these processes catapulting children’s concerns into the political has increased, with a Children and Youth arena. constituency providing a platform, in reality children are overlooked and barely However, the capacity of millions of children, represented.23 Although children are technically especially the most marginalised, to contribute part of this group, and certain issues that children meaningfully to discourse and action on climate and youth face overlap, children have a specific change remains limited by the incomplete set of concerns and needs, which continue to go implementation of states’ obligations under the unheard. UN CRC to provide environmental education to all children (Article 29). Quality environmental The inclusion of children’s rights in the preamble and climate change education and access of the Paris Agreement represents a critical to information are essential for empowering step forward but, this promise has yet to be children to protect themselves from climate- operationalised, and progress towards a rights- related threats, to exercise their rights to be based approach to climate action more broadly heard on climate change policies and action, appears to be faltering.24 Targets under SDG and to seek remedy for harm. 25 13 on Climate Action include a welcome focus on youth as a group that should be considered, but this is not sufficient to ensure that children’s Promoting children’s rights in specific rights, needs and vulnerabilities are addressed, and that no child is left behind. climate action: what works in At both international and national levels, a key practice challenge is that decision-making on climate change tends to be led by Ministries with limited Unsurprisingly, children’s absence from key knowledge of children’s rights. A pervasive climate governance frameworks limits effect on lack of disaggregated data with respect to age the development of child-centred public climate and gender and the impacts of climate change policies and action. Nonetheless, exceptions further hinders the attention that this receives in exist that provide important models of best climate policies and action. practice to governments and other actors. CHILD RIGHTS NOW! • The global climate crisis: a child rights crisis 7

© Philip Maher - Ethiopia The Philippines’ 2016 Children’s Emergency Relief and Protection Act mandates the provision of emergency relief and protection for children before, during, and after disaster and other emergency situations threatening their survival and development. The Act was developed in collaboration with children and is guided by the UN CRC, as well as the Children’s Charter for Disaster Risk Reduction,26 and clarifies the responsibilities of various government sectors to ensure that children’s basic needs are met in emergency settings. The Act is particularly pertinent in a country that consistently ranks among the world’s most vulnerable to climate-related disasters, such as Typhoon Haiyan, one of the most powerful cyclones ever recorded.27 In Zambia, the Ministry of Education and the In Germany, the Government has a Wildlife and Environmental Conservation Society of Zambia have partnered commitment to protecting the best interests with UNICEF to empower children with of the child in its development cooperation knowledge and advocacy skills through the policy and across all projects, ensuring that child-led Unite4Climate programme.31 this principle informs assessment, planning, implementation and evaluation, including More than 1,000 Climate Ambassadors have been trained, who in turn reach funding for climate change adaptation, thousands more through media, disaster risk reduction, and resilience- programmes, debates, advocacy for building projects that involve children and community-based projects, and through youth.28 conservation efforts. Since its inception in 2009, young people from 210 schools have In the United States, children are using the planted more than 30,000 trees nationwide.

legal system to enforce their rights and The programme has raised the voices guarantee a safe climate. The Juliana et al. of children to the national level through v. United States of America et al. case is led engagement with Government, Members by a group of 21 plaintiffs aged 9-20 filing of Parliament, and traditional leaders, to suit against the US Federal Government influence national and international climate for its failure to adequately address climate policies. change, representing a violation of their constitutional rights to, inter alia, life, liberty At the programmatic level, best practice and property.29 Similar child-led cases are examples exist. For example, a ChildFund underway around the world, including a Korea project focusing on eco-system based, youth-led disaster risk reduction in Sri recent complaint to the UN Committee on Lanka involves children and youth in climate the Rights of the Child under the Optional change adaptation. The project is enhancing Protocol for a Communications Procedure.30 the resilience of the community through a youth-led approach to disaster management, building their capacity to cope with and avert disasters, including through eco-system restoration, and linking child and youth groups to district, divisional and community level service providers to undertake advocacy and resource mobilisation efforts over the long-term.32 8 CHILD RIGHTS NOW! • The global climate crisis: a child rights crisis

Children’s voices Here are some responses to a global poll asking children the question: what action do you want world leaders to take with respect to children’s rights and the environment?33 They emphasised the importance and need for environmental education to empower children, and for more avenues to be made available for children to participate in decision-making processes.34

“Accept that we are facing a new challenge and if we don’t work together our planet won’t survive. The children won’t have a home. We have to work together. Raise our voices and help each other to do better for us and our planet.”

“I would like world leaders to stop fooling around. Children are the number one priority because their future needs to be protected. Let children be leaders…Enable children to attend COP with world leaders”

“Allow young people to play a more integral part in policy making as it relates to environmental preservation and global sustainable development in general”

“Globally move to a carbon neutral society and 100% renewable energy. A transition and phase- out of coal, oil and gas (fossil fuels). A circular economy. Prioritise the future of my generations, and younger generations over everything else.”

“Ask [children’s] opinion about what measures to take. Even if they are not implemented, children will have already established that their voice matters and will be more aware of their future decisions while teaching people close to them about what is happening”

“Create programmes with the sole purpose of educating people regarding the climate crisis, create a mandatory one-year course in schools for young children in which children will be taught the dangers of climate crisis in detail and how they can help reverse it”

Governments’ obligations to children necessitate limiting warming to a maximum of 1.5ºC, along with a significant increase in investments in adaptation measures which protect the rights of all children. Governments and the vast majority of other actors working on climate change or children’s rights agendas have been far too slow to recognise that the climate crisis represents a human rights crisis, and one in which children’s rights will be most at risk. This artificial separation must end. Without urgent and aggressive action on climate change – taken in the rapidly- closing window that scientists say we have to act – there will simply be no liveable world for children. And without a significant scaling-up of investment in adaptation – currently the recipient of just twenty per cent of global public climate finance – millions of children will suffer from the irreversible impacts that have already been set in motion. Industrialised countries that have a unique responsibility for the problem should ensure that poorer countries are supported to transition to net-zero carbon economies, to adapt, and to prepare for loss and damage.

Adequate safeguards for children’s rights must be integrated in climate action, ensuring that climate projects respect, protect, promote and fulfil, rather than undermine, children’s rights. In parallel, information on the impacts of climate change on children must be collected so as to enable interventions to be tailored to their specific needs.

Children’s right to be heard must be upheld, by engaging them fully in strategies and action to meet the climate crisis. This will entail a much greater focus on creating mechanisms for consultation with children and young people, and empowering them to protect themselves from climate risks and to participate meaningfully in decision-making.

In particular, children’s right to information on climate change and related policies, as well as their right to climate and environmental education, must be recognised. Governments should take measures to integrate climate change in formal and informal education, including green skills, to ensure that children can meaningfully participate in decision-making, and that they are not left behind in the transition to a sustainable economy. Specific entry pointsfor governments to live up to their promises to children’s rights under the CRC, 2030 Agenda and the Paris Agreement include:

Adopting and advocating for the strongest possible ambition in countries’ revised national climate plans (Nationally Determined Contributions), in order to align with the Paris Agreement targets.

Fulfilling climate finance pledges to poorer countries and commit to invest in child-centred climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction measures.

Integrating a stronger focus on children’s rights as a cross-cutting priority in UNFCCC decision- making processes and at the national level, including commitment to protecting the best interests of the child and their right to be heard.

Ensuring that children’s right to environmental education is reflected and embedded in decisions under the Action for Climate Empowerment (ACE) UNFCCC dialogue and associated decisions.

NOTES 1 UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2018), Special Report on Global Warming of 1.5ºC 2 OHCHR (2017) Analytical Study on Child Rights and Climate Change 3 UNICEF (2015), op. cit. 4 Nature Climate Change (2017). Global risk of deadly heat 5 American Academy of Pediatrics, Children & Disasters, Disaster Preparedness to meet Children’s Needs 6 Child Rights Now! (2019), ‘A Second Revolution: Thirty Years of Child Rights and the Unfinished Agenda” 7 UNICEF, Malnutrition, https://data.unicef.org/topic/nutrition/malnutrition/ 8 WHO, Nutrition: Stunting in a Nutshell: https://www.who.int/nutrition/healthygrowthproj_stunted_videos/en/ 9 WHO (2014), Quantitative Risk Assessment of the Effects of Climate Change on Selected Causes of Death, 2030s and 2050s. 10 Ibid. 11 WHO World Malaria Report, 2014, http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/world_malaria_report_2014/wmr-2014-key-points.pdf. 12 WHO (2014), op. cit. 13 UNICEF (2015), Unless We Act Now: The impact of climate change on children 14 UNICEF UK (2017), No Place to Call Home: Protecting Children’s Rights when the Changing Climate forces Children to Flee. 15 Plan International Thailand and Stockholm Environment Institute research (2018): Climate chance young women and girls: Vulnerability, impacts and adaptation in Northern Thailand 16 Human Rights Watch (2016), Marry Before your House is Swept Away: Child Marriage in Bangladesh 17 P. Olinto, K. Beegle, C. Sobrado and H. Uematsu (2013), The State of the Poor: Where are the Poor, Where is Extreme Poverty Harder to End, and What is the Current Profile of the World’s Poor? 18 FAO (2015), The State of Food and Agriculture: Social Protection and Agriculture: Breaking the Cycle of Rural Poverty. http://www.fao.org/3/a-i4910e.pdf 19 Global Gender and Climate Alliance, Gender and Climate Change: A Closer Look at Existing Evidence (2016) 20 UN Special Rapporteur on Extreme Poverty (2019), Report on Climate Change and Poverty, A/HRC/41/39 12 CHILD RIGHTS NOW! • The global climate crisis: a child rights crisis

21 World Bank (2015), Shockwaves: Managing the Impacts of Climate Change on Poverty 22 Child Rights Now! (2019), op. cit. 23 The UN defines youth as those between the ages of 15 and years. 24 Centre for International Environmental Law (December 2018), ‘Katowice COP24 Outcome Incompatible with Paris Agreement: Ambition, Equity and Human Rights Left Behind in Poland Talks’, https://www.ciel.org/news/katowice-cop24-outcome- incompatible-with-paris-agreement/ 25 UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and the Environment (2018), Child Rights and the Environment, A/HRC/37/58 26 Children in a Changing Climate Coalition (2011), Children’s Charter: An Action Plan for Disaster Risk Reduction for Children by Children 27 Germanwatch (2018) Global Climate Risk Index 2019 28 Input from Government of Germany (2016) to OHCHR Analytical Study on the Impacts of Climate Change on the Rights of the Child 29 www.ourchildrenstrust.org/us/federal-lawsuit/ 30 Reuters (2019), ‘Young climate activists accuse world leaders of violating child rights through inaction’, https://cutt.ly/2eokwB7 31 UNICEF UK (2015), Children and the Changing Climate: Taking Action to Save Lives 32 ChildFund International (Sri Lanka) program 33 The poll is being conducted as part of the Global Initiative for Advancing Children’s Right to a Healthy Environment. The Initiative is taking place under the auspices of the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and the Environment, in collaboration with core partner organizations: https://www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Environment/SREnvironment/Pages/environmentandrightschild.aspx 34 Excerpts extracted from joint submission by Project Dryad and Terre des Hommes (2019) to the UNSR on Human Rights and the Environment questionnaire on safe climate and human rights: https://cutt.ly/weokcB9

“The Global Climate Crisis: A Child Rights Crisis” is a product of Child Rights Now!, an initiative of the Joining Forces alliance. Joining Forces is an alliance of the six largest international NGOs working with and for children to secure their rights and end violence against them. The development of this policy brief was led by Jonas Schubert of Terre des Hommes International Federation, on behalf and with the support of the six agencies of the Joining Forces alliance. Many thanks also to the Joining Forces Secretariat.