ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd

Proposed Residential Development Fairview Inn, Preliminary Ecological Appraisal

Produced for:

August 2017

This page is intentionally blank

Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

CONTENTS

1 INTRODUCTION 1 1.1 The Scheme 1 1.2 Scope of this Report 1 2 METHODOLOGY 2 2.1 Desk Study 2 2.2 Extended Phase 1 Habitat Survey 2 2.3 Bat Detector Survey 3 2.4 Assessment of Ecological Value 3 2.5 Limitations 3 3 RESULTS 5 3.1 Desk Study 5 3.2 Phase 1 Habitat Survey 6 3.3 Protected Species 7 3.4 Notable Species 9 3.5 Invasive Species 10 3.6 Key Ecological Receptors 10 4 DISCUSSION 11 4.1 Proposed Development 11 4.2 Likely Impacts 11 4.3 Recommendations 11 5 CONCLUSION 13 6 REFERENCES 15

APPENDIX A Phase 1 Habitat Map Proposed Development Layout APPENDIX B Site Photographs APPENDIX C Biological Records

Quality Assessment Record

Report Version Written by Date Reviewed by Date 1.0 Russell Grey 30 August 2017 Maddy Warriner 30 August 2017

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd (i) www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

1 INTRODUCTION

1.1 The Scheme 1.1.1 Etive Ecology Ltd was commissioned by Caulmert Ltd. in July 2017 undertake an ecological appraisal of Fairview Inn and surrounding land in Llanddulas, Conwy. The site is centred on National Grid Reference SH 9066 7826.

1.1.2 The application site boundary includes the existing public house (Fairview Inn), the adjoining first‐floor residential flat, pub car park and beer garden. The site is surrounded by residential properties and the A547 Road runs immediately adjacent to the southern site boundary. The proposed scheme comprises two elements. The first is the demolition of single storey extensions to the pub, and to convert the main building into a single residential property. The second element is the construction of a 24 unit apartment building on part of the pub car park footprint. There would also be new landscaping and parking arrangements to the rear of the site.

1.2 Scope of this Report 1.2.1 The site assessment is based on the Guidelines for Preliminary Ecological Appraisal (Institute of Ecology and Environmental Management, 2012).

1.2.2 The aim of the assessment is to obtain data on existing ecological conditions, and to conduct a preliminary assessment of the likely significance of ecological impacts on the proposed development site. To achieve this, the following steps were taken:

 The desk study area and field survey area (including the ‘zone of influence’ of the scheme) have been identified  A desk study has been undertaken, including the purchase of biological records from the Local Records Centre (Cofnod)  Baseline information on the site and surrounding area has been recorded through an ‘extended Phase 1 survey’, including a Phase 1 habitat survey (JNCC 2010) and consideration of notable and/or protected habitats and species  The ecological features present within the survey area have been evaluated, where possible (IEEM, 2006)  Invasive plant and animal species (such as those listed on Schedule 9 of the Wildlife & Countryside Act [WCA]) have been identified  Potential constraints to the proposed development have been identified  Recommendations for further survey have been made  Mitigation recommendations have been provided based on current information.

1.2.3 The Phase 1 Habitat Map of the survey area is in Appendix A with target notes used to link features of note to the report text. Photographs taken during the survey are presented in Appendix B.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 1 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

2 METHODOLOGY

2.1 Desk Study 2.1.1 A desk study was undertaken to identify any nature conservation sites and/or any relevant protected or notable species records within 1km of the site.

2.1.2 The following sources of information were utilized:

 MAGIC website (http://www.magic.gov.uk/MagicMap.aspx)  Biodiversity Partnership (https://www.biodiversitywales.org.uk/)  Natural Resources Wales website (https://naturalresources.wales/)

2.1.3 A data search enquiry to the North Wales Environmental Information Service (Cofnod) was made, for all designated nature conservation sites and all protected and/or notable species within 1km of the centre of the site. 2.2 Extended Phase 1 Habitat Survey 2.2.1 The site visit was made on 4th August 2017.

2.2.2 The survey comprised an extended Phase 1 Habitat Survey. This survey method follows the habitat assessment and classification procedure outlined by the Handbook for Phase 1 Habitat Survey (JNCC, 2010), whereby all habitats are identified, described and mapped using a standard classification.

2.2.3 The extended component of the survey is developed from the methodology described in Guidelines for Baseline Ecological Assessment (IEA, 1995). All habitats and features within the survey area are assessed for their potential to support legally protected or notable species (nationally or locally).

2.2.4 These species include:

 Amphibians: ponds within 250m of the site were considered for their suitability to support a range of amphibians, including great crested newts (GCN).  Reptiles: the site was assessed for suitable habitats including rough grassland, allotments, brownfield sites and habitat edges in general which would provide cover, basking and foraging habitat for reptile species.  Otters: watercourses within 100m of the site were checked for signs of otter and assessed for their suitability to support the species.  Water voles: watercourses on site were checked for signs of water vole presence and assessed for their potential to support the species.  Bats: all trees and structures on site were assessed as to their suitability to support roosting bats at any point during the year. Trees and structures were then categorised for their potential to support roosting bats as per the Bat Surveys for Professional Ecologists – Good Practice Guidelines (Collins, J., 2016).  Birds: the site was assessed for suitable habitats for nesting birds, including habitats suitable for ground‐nesting species.  Badgers: all habitats within 30m of the site were surveyed where possible to identify the presence of any setts or signs of badger activity.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 2 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

 Invasive plant species: this assessment does not constitute a full Schedule 9 species survey. The potential for any Schedule 9 species was assessed and any species that were encountered were mapped and noted.

2.3 Bat Detector Survey 2.3.1 Bat surveys were undertaken in full accordance with the guidance set out by Collins, J. (ed.) (2016). This includes a determination of survey effort based on the value of a given site for roosting bats, determined during the initial site visit. In this instance the terraced building of the pub was assessed to be of Low potential, therefore a single dusk bat detector survey was proposed to be carried out during the active season (May to August inclusive).

2.3.2 The dusk survey commenced 15 minutes prior to sunset and ceased not earlier than 90 minutes following sunset, when survey conditions were too dark for the surveyors to accurately and definitively identify bat emergence and flight. The locations of surveyors and a summary of bat activity during the survey are described in Section 3.3.

2.3.3 The dusk survey was undertaken on the 15th August and was led by Russell Grey, a licensed bat surveyor in Wales. The surveyors were using an Echo Meter Touch and a Bat Scanner detector. Bat activity was recorded and analysed using Analook software.

2.4 Assessment of Ecological Value 2.4.1 The value and sensitivity of ecological features was determined based on the guidance given in Guidelines on Ecological Impact Assessment (CIEEM, 2016). Individual ecological receptors (habitats and species that could be affected by the development) were assigned levels of importance for nature conservation in one of the following categories:

• International / European • National / UK • Metropolitan / County • Local, or • within the immediate zone of influence or site only.

2.4.2 For a given receptor, determination of value includes consideration of the size, secondary or supporting value/function, conservation status and quality of the species or feature.

2.5 Limitations 2.5.1 The Phase 1 Habitat survey was undertaken within the recommended survey season. However, such is the nature of the site, its current land‐use and its recent management, that no significant or rare species of flora are likely to be present.

2.5.2 Access was permitted to all land within the application site boundary but access could not be gained into the residential flat or the loft space above to inspect for protected species potential and evidence. No access was permitted onto any third party land adjacent to the site, although much of the adjacent land was visible.

2.5.3 There are considered to be no significant limitations to the undertaking or accuracy of the Extended Phase 1 Habitat survey.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 3 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

2.5.4 It is acknowledged that, although the bat detector survey effort was in line with the published guidelines, surveys can provide just a snapshot into the use of a site by bats. However, the survey was conducted within the core active period (May to August) and during suitable conditions for bat flight. The surveyors also had excellent visual coverage of the building throughout the survey period. As a result the survey findings are considered to be accurate and robust.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 4 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

3 RESULTS

3.1 Desk Study

Designated Sites 3.1.1 There are two statutory sites for nature conservation located within 1km of the site:

 Liverpool Bay Special Protection Area (SPA); located 450m to the north of Fairview Inn and on the opposite side of the busy A55 dual carriageway. The site is designated on the basis of its wintering populations of red‐throated diver and common scoter, as well as its assemblage of waterfowl species.  Llanddulas Limestone and Gwrych Castle Wood Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI); located 460m to the south of Fairview Inn. The site is designated due to the UK Priority Habitats present (calcareous grassland, calcareous heathland and broadleaved woodland) and the rich assemblage of fauna also known to be present (lesser horseshoe bat, four other species of bat and a rich lepidoptera assemblage including the silver‐studded blue). 3.1.2 There are two Local Wildlife Sites (LWS) located within 1km of the site;

 St Cynbryd’s Church Verge; located 200m to the east of Fairview Inn and designated due to its rich roadside verge/grassland.  Ffordd Llyndir; located 430m to the south of Fairview Inn and designated on the basis of its calcareous grassland habitat. 3.1.3 There are also six blocks of ancient woodland located within 1km of the site. These include one ancient semi‐natural woodland located 410m to the southeast of Fairview Inn and five restored ancient woodland blocks to the south and east of the site (none closer than 200m).

Species Records 3.1.4 A summary of the protected and notable species records provided by Cofnod is given below. Full details of biological records returned from the search are given in Appendix C.

 Amphibians; palmate newt  Bats; common pipistrelle, soprano pipistrelle, Daubenton’s, greater horseshoe, lesser horseshoe, brown long‐eared and Noctule bats  Birds; bullfinch, house sparrow, song thrush and starling  Mammals; badger, hedgehog, otter and polecat  Invasive Species; Himalayan balsam, Japanese knotweed and American mink

Environment (Wales) Act 3.1.4 The Environment (Wales) Act 2016 replaces the Natural Environment and Rural Communities (NERC) Act 2006. The legislation change still places a duty of care for all public bodies to ‘seek to maintain and enhance biodiversity’. This is commonly referred to as the ‘Biodiversity duty’. 3.1.5 The Section 7 list under the new Act has been produced to identify those habitats and species of Principal Importance in Wales. The following relevant habitats and species are found on this list:

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 5 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

Table 3.1.1 Relevant Section 7 Habitats/Species Habitats Species Hedgerows Various bird species Lowland Mixed Deciduous Woodland Roosting bats Hedgehog

3.2 Phase 1 Habitat Survey 3.2.1 The walkover survey was undertaken by Russell Grey (BSc, CEnv, MCIEEM). The survey was undertaken on a dry and sunny day, with no constraints to the survey of the site itself. Access beyond the site boundary was not permitted as it is within private ownership, but all surrounding land‐use was at least visible.

3.2.2 The site is located in the village of Llanddulas, approximately 2.5km to the east of Colwyn Bay. Fairview Inn is situated on the north side of Abergele Road, just 200m east of the A55 junction. The application area includes the existing public house, a paved seating area and grassland area to the rear, a car park to the side (east) and a residential flat above the pub. There are no ponds within the planning application boundary and none located within 250m of the site shown on the Ordnance Survey map.

Habitats 3.2.3 A total of 9 habitats/features were identified within, or immediately adjacent to, the site boundary. These habitats are mapped in Figure 1 (Appendix A), shown in the site photographs (Appendix B) and summarised below;

3.2.4 The site is located on the corner of Abergele Road and Station Road. The residential flat (Building 1) above the pub (Building 2) is access on Abergele Road whilst the car park to the pub is located off Station Road (Target Note 1). The car park comprises entirely of hard‐standing (bare ground) and is edged along its northern boundary by amenity grassland and a timber panel fence (Target Note 2). The eastern boundary of the car park comprises a narrow border of tall ruderal vegetation including greater willowherb, valerian and ragwort (Target Note 3) alongside a post and mesh fence. The southern side of the car park comprises a short but steep embankment rising to Abergele Road, covering in amenity grassland and with scattered broadleaved trees and occasional introduced shrubs, including sycamore and cypress (Target Note 3).

3.2.5 Fairview Inn itself is located on the western side of the car park and comprises the lower level of the adjacent terraced building and a number of single‐storey extensions. There is a small paved area immediately outside the pub entrance (Target Note 5), a series of steps rising up to the level of Abergele Road (Target Note 6) and the front door to the residential property (Target Note 7), with a frontage of a low wall and a species‐poor native hedgerow. The rear of the pub comprises further paved areas (Target Note 8) surrounded by low red‐brick walls stepping down to a large beer garden (Target Note 9). The beer garden comprises amenity grassland, with a bed of tall ruderal vegetation (common nettle and bindweed) in the southwest corner (Target Note 10) and some scattered scrub and occasional broadleaved trees (elder and plum).

3.2.6 Land surrounding the site is primarily residential, with properties on the opposite side of both Abergele Road and Station Road, and adjoining residential properties to the terrace ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 6 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

above the Inn. To the north of the site is a relatively new residential development and a number of semi‐mature sycamores, forming a loose area of semi‐natural habitat (Target Note 11).

3.3 Protected Species 3.3.1 The following text describes the suitability of the site to support various legally protected species, including any direct observations made during the site survey.

Amphibians 3.3.2 There are no ponds located within the application site boundary and no ponds located within 250m of the site. This means that there is an absence of any potentially suitable breeding sites for amphibians within close proximity to the application site.

3.3.3 The application site was found to comprise very little semi‐natural habitat, instead being dominated by buildings and made‐ground. As a result, there is negligible value associated with the site for amphibians. The site is also surrounded on two sides by main roads and on the other two sides by residential properties, meaning that the site is also relatively isolated.

3.3.4 The only species of amphibian recorded within 1km of the site is palmate newt; recorded in the adjacent grid square at least 700m to the southwest. Based on the composition of the site and the absence of any nearby ponds or records, amphibians are considered to be absent from the site boundary.

Badgers 3.3.5 The application site lies within a residential area and is surrounded on all sides by roads and/or residential properties. There is an absence of any extensive semi‐natural habitat that could be of value to badgers either for sett‐building or as a foraging resource. In addition, the site is currently a public house, with frequent disturbance being created by human activity during dusk and the early hours of darkness. In this context the site is considered to be of negligible value to badgers.

3.3.6 During the walkover survey of the site, no evidence of any badger activity could be found, either on site or within 30m of it. There were no setts, no mammal pathways or evidence of any foraging activity. There are 1km records for badger in grid squares to the site, including open countryside and extensive areas of semi‐natural habitat. It is therefore concluded that badgers are absent from within 30m of the development area and also absent from the immediately surrounding land.

Bats Bat Roost Potential

3.3.7 There are no mature or semi‐mature trees found within the application site. Therefore there are no natural structures present which could support roosting bats.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 7 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

3.3.8 There is one building present within the application site boundary; the existing pub and adjoining residential property. The building has been divided into four distinct sections and each is described below and assessed as to their Bat Roost Potential (BRP1):

 Building 1; an end of terrace building with a slat tile roof, a chimney stack and an un‐converted loft space. From an external appraisal, the building appears to be in good condition, with all fascia boarding in place and well‐secured, and a gable end that shows no signs of damage or decay. There are a couple of slate tiles on the northern side of the roof ridge which have slipped and therefore offer potential access points into the loft space or at least beneath existing tiles. The BRP is assessed to be Low.  Building 2; an extended element to the property, comprising the main body of the public house. This is a single‐storey building with a flat roof and concrete edging, all of which was in good condition with no evidence of damage or decay. As a result, there are no PRFs for bats and therefore the BRP is assessed to be Negligible.  Building 3; an extended element to the property, comprising part of the public house. This is a single‐storey building with a flat roof which is forms a terrace which is accessed by the tenant of the residential property. There are no eaves or fascia, just concrete edging. Therefore the BRP is assessed to be Negligible.  Building 4; an extended element to the pub; a glass conservatory‐style building linking the patio area to the internal area. The extension is comprised of glass windows on all three external sides and has a pitched slate tile roof which was in good condition with no PRFs visible. There is also uPVC fascia and guttering around the eaves of the extension, all in very good condition. As a result of the building’s good condition, the BRP is Negligible.

Foraging / Commuting Value

3.3.9 The land within the application site is assessed to be of low value to foraging bats, due to the prevalence of bare ground, buildings and amenity habitats. The beer garden area to the rear of the pub offers some foraging potential and is also connected to the semi‐mature broadleaved trees adjacent to the north. The site is not thought to be of any significance in terms of its commuting value.

Bat Detector Survey

3.3.10 The bat survey took place on 15th August. Weather conditions were excellent for bat activity; 14°C, 10mph southerly, dry and less than 10% cloud cover.

3.3.11 Sunset was at 20.40 and the survey commenced at 20.25. One surveyor was located on the opposite side of Abergele Road, viewing the southern aspect of the roof and with good visibility of the eastern gable end. The other surveyor was located on the edge of the beer garden to the rear of the Inn, with visual coverage of the north facing roof and the single‐storey extension buildings.

3.3.12 During the survey, with extended until 90 minutes after sunset, no bats were seen to emerge from any part of any of the buildings found on site. Roosting bats were therefore confirmed to be absent.

1 Medium = structures with one or more potential roost sites that could be used by bats but unlikely to support a roost of high conservation status. Low = structures with one or more potential roost sites that could be used by individual bats opportunistically, but are not suitable to be used on a regular basis by larger numbers of bats. Negligible = negligible features likely to be used by roosting bats (Collins, J., 2016). ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 8 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

3.3.13 A total of 17 common pipistrelle bat passes were recorded, the first of which was at 20.48, which was flying over land to the north of the site. The first common pipistrelle was seen at 21.01, flying onto site from the north, towards the rear of the pub and turning west to fly along the rear of the terrace. All subsequent common pipistrelle activity was recorded to the rear (north) of the site. A total of two soprano pipistrelle bats were recorded during the survey effort, both to the rear (north) of the site.

3.3.14 There are records for at least nine species of bat within 1km of the site. However, the site itself is of very low value to bats, with no activity recorded during the survey at the front of the site. Overall, roosting bats are considered to be absent and the value of the site for foraging and commuting bats is low.

Birds 3.3.15 There are very few opportunities for nesting birds within the application site boundary, associated with the buildings and the scrub vegetation in the southwest part of the beer garden. Although no evidence of any nesting birds was found during the walkover survey, there is still low potential for these areas to support common and widespread species of garden bird, as well as declining species such as house sparrow or dunnock. Numerous house martins were observed during the bat survey flying over the site and surrounding residential properties, indicating likely breeding in the local area. Overall the site is considered to be of low value to nesting birds.

Reptiles 3.3.16 The entirety of the site is found to be of negligible value to reptiles due to the absence of any extensive semi‐natural vegetation and the disturbed nature of the land‐use, i.e. residential / amenity use. The surrounding land use is also likely to experience high levels of disturbance from residential activities and vehicle traffic.

3.3.17 There are no records for any species of reptiles within 1km of the site. In summary, reptiles are considered to be absent from the development footprint and likely absent from the immediately surrounding area.

Riparian Mammals 3.3.18 There are no water‐courses found within the application boundary. The nearest water‐course is the Afon Dulas, located 260m to the east and on the opposite side of a block of residential properties. Therefore there is no suitable habitat on site or within close proximity of the site, for riparian mammals such as water vole or otter.

3.3.19 There are records for otter and for American mink on the Afon Dulas. However, it is concluded that all species of riparian mammal are absent from the application site and likely absent from the immediately surrounding land.

3.4 Notable Species 3.4.1 The application site and immediately surrounding land has no potential to support any notable species listed on Section 41 of the NERC Act.

3.4.2 No nationally rare or locally important species of flora were identified during the site visit. None are anticipated as being likely to be present owing to the amenity use of the site.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 9 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

3.5 Invasive Species 3.5.1 No non‐native invasive species (NNIS) of flora listed on Schedule 9 of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (as amended), were found to be present on site during the survey.

3.6 Key Ecological Receptors 3.6.1 The extended Phase 1 Habitat Survey found no significant ecological value associated with the application site. Therefore no ‘key’ ecological receptors are identified.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 10 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

4 DISCUSSION

4.1 Proposed Development 4.1.1 The proposed scheme is to retain and refurbish the existing end of terrace property, to demolish the existing extension buildings to the Inn and to construct a new residential apartment building. The proposed site layout is shown on Figure 2.

4.1.2 The development will entail an improved access to the site, parking and an enhanced landscape scheme to improve the visual amenity of the site.

4.1.3 The proposed construction works are likely to take approximately 12 months to complete.

4.2 Likely Impacts 4.2.1 The site survey and desk study have identified no significant features of ecological value associated with the application site. Therefore no specific impacts are posed on any protected / priority habitats or species. However, a number of generic impacts are anticipated as a result of the proposed development:

 The small pockets of semi‐natural habitat which are found on site (amenity grassland, tall ruderal, scattered trees, scattered scrub) will be lost to the proposed development. Whilst these habitats are not assessed to be of any significant value, the loss represents a very minor loss of ecological value.  The scheme is likely to result in disturbance impacts to foraging/commuting bats by the residential occupancy of land that is currently undeveloped. Residential use is likely to bring additional noise and artificial lighting, as a well as a simplification of habitats and land‐use.  The proposed scheme will result in the permanent loss of a small number of potential nesting sites for a range of predominantly common bird species. The construction of the scheme also poses the risk of harming/disturbing active nests and young birds if works commence during the nesting period.

4.2.2 The scale of these impacts is relatively minor and are certainly not significant. However, a number of simple measures could be undertaken to avoid and/or minimise these impacts, as detailed below.

4.3 Recommendations 4.3.1 It is recommended that the proposed site layout makes adequate provision for the retention and/or creation of semi‐natural habitats of potential ecological value and function. Considering the nature of the scheme and the proposed development layout, it is recommended that these measures take the form of native broadleaved tree planting and hedgerow creation. A new mixed hedgerow should be planted along the southern and eastern boundaries of the site, comprising at a mix of least three native broadleaved hedgerow species and comprising at least one oak tree per 10m length, planted as standards within the hedge. Tree planting is shown on the proposed site layout plan and it is recommended that these trees are all native species and that they are sourced locally wherever possible to ensure local provenance.

4.3.2 To minimise potential disturbance impacts on bats, it is recommended that any artificial lighting proposed for the site is carefully located so as to minimise potential impacts. As a

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 11 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

general rule, all lighting should be triggered by motion sensors and should comprise LED sources. Directional lighting should also be used to ensure that no artificial light splashes onto any boundary features or areas of semi‐natural vegetation. No lighting should be installed at a height greater than 2.5m.

4.3.3 To avoid impacts to active nests, nesting birds and eggs or young birds, it is recommended that all vegetation clearance is undertaken outside of the nesting bird season, taken as March to August inclusive. If the works commence within this period, they must be preceded by a nest check undertaken by an experienced ecologist. Only once the area has been confirmed clear of nesting birds can such works be undertaken within the nesting season.

4.3.4 To mitigate for the permanent loss of bird nesting habitat, and the minor impacts on bats, it is also recommended that two integrated bat tubes and two integrated nesting boxes are installed into each of the buildings. These will provide long term opportunities for roosting bats and nesting birds. The Schwegler 1FR bat tube and Schwegler 1SP Sparrow Terrace would be suitable.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 12 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

5 CONCLUSION

5.1 Etive Ecology Ltd was commissioned by Caulmert Ltd to undertake an ecological appraisal of Fairview Inn and surrounding land, Llanddulas, Conwy. The site is proposed for residential redevelopment.

5.2 The assessment comprised an extended Phase 1 Habitat survey, a desk study, a single dusk bat detector survey, a summary of likely impacts on the ecological value of the site and recommendations for any further survey and/or enhancing the ecological value of the site post‐development.

5.3 A desktop data search identified two statutory nature conservation sites and two locally designated nature conservation sites within 1km of the development footprint. Protected species records obtained for within 1km of the site included a large number of bat and bird species, as well as otter, badger and palmate newt. The vast majority of these records related to the designated sites.

5.4 The site comprises an end of terrace property with numerous single‐storey extensions to the rear, forming a residential unit and the public house of Fairview Inn respectively. The Inn is surrounded by car parking to the east and areas of paving and amenity grassland to the rear (north). Adjacent to the application site boundary are residential properties on all sides, with main roads to the east and south. There are no ponds within the site boundary and none within 250m.

5.5 The site was found to be of negligible ecological value. There are no habitats of any significant value. However, the terraced building was considered to offer Low BRP, meaning that a single bat detector survey was required to be undertaken. This survey was carried out within the optimum survey period and no roosting bats were found to be present within any of the buildings on site. Only common pipistrelle and soprano pipistrelle bats were recorded foraging around the northern part of the site. There is low value nesting potential in the small pockets of scrub and trees on site, but no potential for any other legally protected or notable species of fauna.

5.6 The proposed development is to demolish the existing extension buildings to the Inn and to convert the Inn for use as a residential property. The scheme also includes the construction of a new residential apartment building. This will result in the demolition of the various single‐storey extensions and the loss of the majority of the existing site to the construction of the new residential properties. The general layout of the site will be significantly changed, although the same access will be utilised. There will be new car parking provided and landscaping works undertaken to external areas surrounding the new properties. The development will result in the loss of amenity grassland and small pockets of scrub and trees. However all such impacts are of very minor scale and are not significant.

5.7 It is recommended that new hedgerows and trees are planted as part of the proposed development layout, to retain some ecological value such as resources for foraging bats and birds. It is also recommended that clearance works take place outside of the nesting bird season and that two artificial bat boxes and two artificial bird boxes are installed into each of the buildings on site. These measures will offset habitat loses and disturbance impacts.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 13 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

5.8 In conclusion, the application site has been found to be of very low ecological value. There are no significant ecological impacts identified but a number of mitigation measures are recommended to ensure there are no residual ecological impacts arising from the scheme.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 14 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk Proposed Residential Development Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Fairview Inn, Llanddulas

6 REFERENCES

Collins, J., (2016), Bat Surveys for Professional Ecologists; Good Practice Guidelines, 3rd edition. Bat Conservation Trust, London.

English Nature (2001), Great Crested Newt Mitigation Guidelines. August 2001.

Institute of Environmental Assessment, (1995), Guidelines for Baseline Ecological Assessment. E & FN Spon. London.

Joint Nature Conservation Committee, (2010), Handbook for Phase 1 Habitat Survey – a technique for environmental audit.

Oldham R.S., Keeble J., Swan M.J.S. & Jeffcote M. (2000), Evaluating the suitability of habitat for the Great Crested Newt (Triturus cristatus). Herpetological Journal 10 (4), 143‐155.

ETIVE ECOLOGY Ltd Page 15 of 15 www.etiveecology.co.uk

Appendix A ‐ Figure 1 Phase 1 Habitat Plan

Figure 1 – Phase 1 Habitat Map

This page is intentionally blank

Appendix A ‐ Figure 2 Proposed Development Layout

S TECT. 5 3NS 5 SV A3 .agarchitects.co.uk A 14/04/16 JGE d & Wales No.4187948 Wales & d Birkenhead CH41 6JN CH41 Birkenhead DP CIRCULATION 5P3B HOUSE = 1no. = HOUSE 5P3B 9no. = APARTMENT 2P1B 15no. = APARTMENT 3P2B PLANNING 08/03/16 DATE DRAWN CHECKED @A3 03/04/2017 13:02:23 UNIT MIX KEY MIX UNIT request TOTAL = 24 APARTMENTS & 1 HOUSE 1 & APARTMENTS 24 = TOTAL 1 : 500 A client to amendments Minor REVDESCRIPTION DATE BY THE OLD POLICE STATION, 15 GLYNNE WAY, HAWARDEN, CH HAWARDEN, WAY, GLYNNE 15 STATION, POLICE OLD THE JOB No DRAWING No REVISION THIS DRAWING IS THE COPYRIGHT OF AINSLEY GOMMON OFDRAWINGTHIS COPYRIGHT ISAINSLEY THE DRAWING. FROMDOWORK TO THIS SCALE NOT ARCHITECTS. CHECKFIGURED ON DIMENSIONS ONLY. ALL DIMENSIONS ARCHITO DISCREPANCIESANY THE BE NOTIFIED TO SITE. AND STRUCTURE SHOWNOF INDICATIVE FORARE ELEMENTS GUIDANCE.ASFINAL ENGINEER DESIGNBE STRUCTURALTO ANDDETAILS SPECIFICATION. Registered Office: 1 Price Street, Hamilton Square, Hamilton Street, Price 1 Office: Registered Ainsley Gommon Architects Ltd. Registered in Englan in Registered Ltd. Architects Gommon Ainsley Tel: 01244 537 100 | [email protected] | www | [email protected] | 100 537 01244 Tel: PROPOSED SITE LAYOUT SITE PROPOSED SCALE PRINTED: DRAWING STATUS C896 53 PROJECT DRAWING TITLE FAIR VIEW SITE VIEW FAIR SEDDON for

D NORTH A

O

n R

o

i

r

i E T

s L a i P E a 2 t G R S l E o B

P A

k

o

o

N

y

s

i

a

D 1 Shelter

19

DRIVE

PRIVATE

4 1

1 2

7 2 1

PO

n

a f y r T

LB

e

s

u

o

H

1

n 0

1 : 500 : 1 o t

s a r C PROPOSEDPROPOSED SITESITE LAYOUT LAYOUT SCALE PROPOSEDPROPOSED SITESITE LAYOUT LAYOUT 1 1 11

This page is intentionally blank

Appendix B ‐ Site Photographs

This page is intentionally blank

Target Note 1 Target Note 3

Target Note 7 Target Note 8

Target Note 9 Target Note 10

Building 1 Buildings 2 + 4

Appendix C – Biological Records

This page is intentionally blank

Cofnod Environmental Information Search (PUBLIC VERSION) Our Reference E05823 Your Reference 629 Requested By Etive Ecology Data Users Russell Grey, Ecologist, Etive Ecology Ltd None Search Date 31/07/2017 Expiry Date 31/07/2018 Search Type Chargeable

Important Issues

• Use of the data is governed by Cofnod's Terms & Conditions. • Data marked as confidential or sensitive must not be released into the public domain, with the exception of the Public Version of the PDF report, which has had sensitive information removed or restricted. • You should not amend any part of the downloaded records. • Unless otherwise agreed, use of the data is valid until the Expiry Date (31/07/2018). • The data was generated on the Search Date (31/07/2017) and is not live. • The Dataset ID associated with each record can be used to find information about the provenance of the data. See the Data We Hold page on our website for more information. • Quality Assurance (QA) levels are given for each record. For further information see our Data Quality Policy, available from our website. • Please contact us if you have any questions about using the data or wish to add further Data Users.

Notes

• Cofnod uses a search system which optionally reports species (usually high priority or protected species) within a specified search radius or buffer. Where required a search will also include high priority 'Mobile Species', such as bats, otters, amphibians and certain invertebrates, which lie outside the specified search radius. These species are highlighted on the report with (Mobile) next to the distance. They have been selected as 'Mobile Species' as their territory (possibly due to foraging activity or life cycle) could intersect with the search radius. • Records with 4 figure grid references are displayed as 1km squares on any relevant maps. They are highlighted with (1km) next to the distance. • Records shown in bold typeface are sensitive species- records,PUBLIC and some details have been restricted inVERSION this public version of the report. -

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 1 of 51 Data Description

Distance Indicates the distance, in metres, between the GRID REFERENCE of the record (using the central point of the grid square) and the search location. For any Sensitive Species Records, this cannot be released into the Public Domain. Species Name Name of the taxon (usually identified to species level) using the binomial system. Grid Reference Full grid reference based on the Ordnance Survey grid system. For any Sensitive Species Records, this cannot be released into the Public Domain. Date Date on which the record was made. In some cases this might be a date range, or a vague date such as 'Summer 2010'. Recorder(s) One or more people who made the original observation and recorded it in some way. It may have subsequently been included in a data collation by another person or it may have been submitted to Cofnod directly. Abundance Number of individuals recorded. Where not specified it is assumed that at least one was present. Record Type The recording methods used (only where specified). Site Name The site name (if one has been supplied). For any Sensitive Species Records, this cannot be released into the Public Domain. Comments Any additional notes about the sighting, including any information on habitat or substrate if this is available. For any Sensitive Species Records, this cannot be released into the Public Domain. Dataset ID ID of this dataset. See 'Important Issues' for more details. Lists Any local, national or international conservation statuses or legal protection which apply to this species and whether it is included in any Local Biodiversity Action Plans. See 'Abbreviations' for more details. QA Summarised record Verification Level. The following codes are used: 1 - Unassessed, 2 - Unconfirmed, 3 - Considered Correct by Cofnod, 4 - Considered Correct by Expert. See our Data Quality policy, available from the Cofnod website for more details.

Abbreviations

ANG - County Council Local Biodiversity Action Plan, AONB - Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, AW - Ancient Woodland, BAP - UK Biodiversity Action Plan, BDir1 - EU Birds Directive Annexe 1, BDir2.1 - EU Birds Directive Annexe 2.1, BDir2.2 - EU Birds Directive Annexe 2.2, Bern - Bern Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats, Bonn - Bonn Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals, CITES - Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora, CON - Council Local Biodiversity Action Plan, DEN - Denbighshire County Council Local Biodiversity Action Plan, EPS - European Protected Species, FLI - Flintshire County Council Local Biodiversity Action Plan, GWY - Gwynedd County Council Local Biodiversity Action Plan, HDir - EU Habitats Directive, INNS - Invasive Non-native Species, LBAP - Local Biodiversity Action Plan species for the listed area, LI - Locally Important within the listed area, LNR - Local Nature Reserve, MNR - Marine Nature Reserve, NNR - National Nature Reserve, NRW - Natural Resources Wales Priority Species, NWWT - North Wales Wildlife Trust Reserve, PBA - Protection of Badgers Act 1992, RD1(UK) - Red Data Book listing for the UK based on IUCN guidelines, RD1(Wales) - Red Data Book listiing for Wales based on IUCN guidelines, RD2(UK) - Red Data Book listing for the UK not based on IUCN guidelines, RIGS - Regionally Important Geodiversity Site, S42 - Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act 2006 (Section 42), SAC - Special Area of Conservation, SNP - Snowdonia National Park Local Biodiversity Action Plan, SPA - Special Protection Area, SSSI - Site of Special Scientific Interest, UKBA - RSPB UK Birds Amber List (not based on IUCN criteria), UKBR - RSPB UK Birds Red List (not based on IUCN criteria), VC48 - Locally Important within Vice-County 48: Meirionethshire, VC49 - Locally Important within Vice-County 49: Caernarfonshire, VC50 - Locally Important within Vice- County 50: Denbighshire, VC51 - Locally Important within Vice-County 51: Flintshire, VC52 - Locally Important within Vice-County 52: Anglesey, WBA - RSPB Welsh Birds Amber List (not based on IUCN criteria), WBR - RSPB Welsh Birds Red List (not based on IUCN criteria), WCA1.1 - Wildlife & Countryside Act 1981 Schedule 1.1 (Birds which are protected at all times), WCA1.2 - Wildlife & Countryside Act 1981 Schedule 1.2 (Birds which are protected at certain times), WCA5 - Wildlife & Countryside Act 1981 Schedule 5 (Animals which are protected from killing and taking, possession, disturbance and sale), WCA8 - Wildlife & Countryside Act 1981 Schedule 8- (Plants PUBLIC which are protected), WCA9 - Wildlife & CountrysideVERSION Act 1981 Schedule 9 (Non-native animals and- plants which are established in the wild), WRE - Wrexham County Council Local Biodiversity Action Plan, WS - Wildlife Site, WVP - IUCN Threat Listing of Welsh Vascular Plants

Contact Us

Cofnod - Gwasanaeth Gwybodaeth Amgylcheddol Gogledd Cymru/North Wales Environmental Information Service Intec, Ffordd y Parc, Parc Menai, Bangor, Gwynedd. LL57 4FG Tel: (01248) 672603 Email: [email protected] Website: www.cofnod.org.uk Facebook: facebook.com/Cofnod Twitter: twitter.com/Cofnod

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 2 of 51 Search Location Grid Reference Fairview Inn SH90667826

Birds Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Accipiter nisus SH912778 5 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1 Male Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 22/08/2005 and Lyons (Sparrowhawk / Gwalch 29/04/2008 Glas) Accipiter nisus SH9077 2 records, between Carol 1 Female; 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 13/01/2006 and Richardson;David Valley (Sparrowhawk / Gwalch 20/01/2008 Richardson Glas) Accipiter nisus SH9178 30/12/2007 Carol 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 Richardson;David (Sparrowhawk / Gwalch Richardson Glas) Accipiter nisus SH9177 25/08/2005 M Lyons 1 Male Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 Valley, E (Sparrowhawk / Gwalch Glas) Accipiter nisus SH8977 4 records, between Jonathan Groom 2; 1 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 CITES, LBAP[CON] 1 14/10/2011 and Marian (Sparrowhawk / Gwalch 27/11/2011 Glas) Aegithalos caudatus SH912778 7 records, between M Lyons; Edward 3; 1; 2 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA 3 04/09/2005 and Lyons (Long-tailed Tit / Titw 06/10/2007 Cynffon-Hir) Aegithalos caudatus SH9078 3 records, between Susan Morris; Mr W R 6+; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, WBA 3 23/09/2006 and Myerscough Breeding Status: H (Long-tailed Tit / Titw 25/04/2015 D1297/020/01 Cynffon-Hir) Aegithalos caudatus SH9077 19 records, between Susan Morris; Edward 1; 2; 12+; 6; 12; 3; 4 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, WBA 3 27/02/2004 and Lyons; Carol Valley (Long-tailed Tit / Titw 15/05/2010 Richardson;David D0062/003/01 Cynffon-Hir) Richardson; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Aegithalos caudatus SH9177 5 records, between Carol 6; 2; 5; 4 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA 3 14/01/2007 and Richardson;David Valley, E (Long-tailed Tit / Titw 09/01/2009 Richardson; M Lyons; Cynffon-Hir) Edward Lyons Aegithalos caudatus SH8978 2 records, between Susan Morris; Carol 1; 2 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA 3 28/04/2007 and Richardson;David (Long-tailed Tit / Titw 30/12/2007 Richardson Cynffon-Hir) Aegithalos caudatus SH8977 3 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+ Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 WBA 1 14/10/2011 and Marian (Long-tailed Tit / Titw 27/11/2011- PUBLIC VERSION - Cynffon-Hir) Aix galericulata SH9077 28/04/2015 Mr H R A Cook 3 Conwy - Llandulas BTO Breeding Status: H D1297/020/01 INNS, WCA9 1 (Mandarin Duck / Hwyaden Gribog) Alauda arvensis SH9078 23/05/2010 Jim Hulse, Val Hulse 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 WBA, LBAP[ANG, (Skylark / Ehedydd) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Alauda arvensis SH8978 28/04/2007 Susan Morris 3 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 WBA, LBAP[ANG, (Skylark / Ehedydd) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 3 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Alca torda SH902787 19/02/2013 Hughes, R D 8 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 Bern, RD2(UK), 4 UKBA, LBAP[ANG, (Razorbill / Llurs) CON] Alca torda SH9078 9 records, between Kevin Smith; Megan 40+; 1; 2; 5; 3; 8 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), 4 14/10/2004 and Bagguley;Roger UKBA, LBAP[ANG, (Razorbill / Llurs) 20/02/2013 Bagguley; Neil D0062/003/01, CON] Hughes; Robin D1297/012/01 Sandham; Clarkson, G Alca torda SH9178 07/11/2015 Mr G Jones 12+ Llanddulas D1297/020/01 Bern, RD2(UK), 4 UKBA, LBAP[ANG, (Razorbill / Llurs) CON] Alca torda SH9079 17/02/2008 Kevin Smith 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, RD2(UK), 3 UKBA, LBAP[ANG, (Razorbill / Llurs) CON] Alcedo atthis SH9178 21/02/2010 Ray Teesdale 1+ Llanddulas, E Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 1 WBA, WCA1.1, (Kingfisher / Glas y Dorlan) LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Anas crecca SH9178 23/02/2015 Mr R Teesdale Llandulas/Abergele D1297/020/01 BDir2.1, CITES, 1 UKBA, WBA, (Teal / Corhwyaden) LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Anas crecca SH8978 06/03/2004 David Owen Jones 4 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.1, CITES, 3 UKBA, WBA, (Teal / Corhwyaden) LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Anas penelope SH97 02/11/2015 Mr R D Hughes 6 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/020/01 BDir2.1, CITES, 1 UKBA, WBA, (Wigeon / Chwiwell) LBAP[CON, GWY] Anas platyrhynchos SH9071278650 04/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 15 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) Anas platyrhynchos SH9071478659 08/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 27+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) Anas platyrhynchos SH9071578660 4 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 3 Female; 4 Male; 6 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 01/11/2009 and Male LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) 04/11/2009 Anas platyrhynchos SH9072278660 12/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 8 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) Anas platyrhynchos SH9113278070 2 records, both on Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 14 Male; 3 Female Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 20/09/2009 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) Anas platyrhynchos SH910786 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris 1 River, East of the field record D0969/001/04 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 1 footbridge, Llandulas LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) beach, Denbighshire Anas platyrhynchos SH9078 33 records, between Susan Morris; Megan 30; 6 Male; 2 Male; 7 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; Female with D0062/001/01, BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 23/11/2004 and Bagguley;Roger Female; 10 Male; 1 3 ducklings in flooded quarry. BTO LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) 15/12/2015 Bagguley; Carol Female; 10 Juvenile; 1 Breeding Status: FL; BTO D0062/003/01, Richardson;David Male; 3 Female; 3 Breeding Status: T D1297/020/01 Richardson; Jim Male; 2 Juvenile; 7 Hulse, Val Hulse; Male; 4 Male; 2 Megan Bagguley, Female; 20 Female; - PUBLICRoger Bagguley; Carol 15 Male; 8 Female; 1;VERSION - Richardson, David 1+; 2 Richardson; Mr W R Myerscough Anas platyrhynchos SH9077 19 records, between Carol 10 Female; 4 Male; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 25/01/2004 and Richardson;David Female; 4 Female; 6 Valley Breeding Status: P LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) 28/04/2015 Richardson; Carol Male; 4; 12; 30+; 1 D0062/003/01, Richardson, David Female; 1 Male; 2 D1297/020/01 Richardson; Mr H R A Male; 5 Cook

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 4 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Anas platyrhynchos SH9178 12 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 1 Female; 1 Male; 8; 6 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/003/01, BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Susan Morris; Megan Juvenile; 13 Male; 3; flew to shoreline LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) 23/02/2015 Bagguley;Roger 1+ D0062/001/01, Bagguley; Ray D1297/002/01, Teesdale; John Bishop Murray; Mr R D1297/005/01, Teesdale; Mr T.J. Revill D1297/020/01 Anas platyrhynchos SH9177 24/04/2010 Carol Richardson, 2 Male Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 David Richardson Valley, E LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) Anas platyrhynchos SH8978 3 records, between Mr D Sulway; Mr W R 2; 1 LLanddulas flooded At least 2 small ducklings in D1297/020/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 1 26/02/2015 and Myerscough; Mr J.P. quarry flooded quarry with female. BTO LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) 27/06/2015 Hughes Breeding Status: FL Anas platyrhynchos SH9079 04/03/2011 Megan Bagguley, 10 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 3 Roger Bagguley LBAP[CON, GWY] (Mallard / Hwyaden Wyllt) Anas strepera SH9078 18/01/2015 Mr R D Hughes 2 Mobile-SH9078 D1297/020/01 BDir2.1, UKBA, WBA, 1 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Gadwall / Hwyaden Lwyd) Anser brachyrhynchus SH9078 16/11/2007 Megan 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 3 Bagguley;Roger RD2(UK), UKBA (Pink-footed Goose / Gwydd Bagguley Troetbinc) Anser brachyrhynchus SH8978 02/12/2006 Susan Morris 30+ Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 3 RD2(UK), UKBA (Pink-footed Goose / Gwydd Troetbinc) Anthus petrosus SH9078 19/12/2009 Kevin Smith 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[ANG, 3 CON] (Rock Pipit / Corhedydd y Graig) Anthus petrosus SH9178 17/05/2009 John Bishop Murray 2 Llanddulas, E D1297/002/01 Bern, LBAP[ANG, 1 CON] (Rock Pipit / Corhedydd y Graig) Anthus pratensis SH9078 7 records, between Susan Morris; Megan 1; 4; 2; 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 04/11/2006 and Bagguley;Roger LBAP[CON] (Meadow Pipit / Corhedydd y 08/03/2015 Bagguley; Council, R D1297/012/01, Waun) P; Mr W R D1297/020/01 Myerscough; Mr J N Williams Anthus pratensis SH9178 6 records, between Megan 10; 4; 1; 1+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger LBAP[CON] (Meadow Pipit / Corhedydd y 22/10/2015 Bagguley; Susan D1297/002/01, Waun) Morris; Ray Teesdale; D1297/020/01 Mr R Teesdale Anthus pratensis SH8977 2 records, between Jonathan Groom 5; 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 1 14/10/2011 and Marian LBAP[CON] (Meadow Pipit / Corhedydd y 15/10/2011 Waun) Anthus trivialis SH9077 07/04/2007 Stuart Newson 1 Llanddulas, Dulas D1297/002/01 Bern, S7, UKBR, 1 - PUBLIC VERSIONValley - WBA, LBAP[CON, (Tree Pipit / Corhedydd y DEN, FLI, GWY] Coed) Apus apus SH9077 17/07/2004 Edward Lyons 5 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 UKBA, WBA 3 Valley (Swift / Gwennol Ddu) Arenaria interpres SH9071678659 2 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 23; 9 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 23/10/2009 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y 25/10/2009 Traeth)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 5 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Arenaria interpres SH9071578660 3 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 2; 18; 7 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 01/11/2009 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y 05/12/2009 Traeth) Arenaria interpres SH9072278660 13/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 12 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y Traeth) Arenaria interpres SH9078 44 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 4; 20; 2; 11; 8+; 3; 1; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 13/03/2004 and Megan Bagguley, 7; 30; 50+; 15; 2+; LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y 29/12/2015 Roger Bagguley; Neil 10+; 60+; 6; 50; 1+; D0062/001/01, Traeth) Hughes; Malcolm 19; 18; 12; 5+ D1297/012/01, Down; Carol Richardson;David D1297/020/01 Richardson; Kevin Smith; Norman Hallas; Susan Morris; Megan Bagguley;Roger Bagguley; Jim Hulse;V... Arenaria interpres SH9077 10/03/2007 Carol 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 Richardson;David Valley LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y Richardson Traeth) Arenaria interpres SH9178 24 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 11; 6+; 10; 12; 20; 1; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/003/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Susan Morris; Edward 44+; 45+; 2; c71; 1+; BirdTrack; BirdTrack flew and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y 07/11/2015 Lyons; Megan 80; 28; 120; 63; 7; 3; 6 landed on shoreline; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, Traeth) Bagguley;Roger flew in to shoreline; BirdTrack on D1297/012/01, Bagguley; Teesdale, shoreline R; Ray Teesdale; John D1297/002/01, Bishop Murray; Mr G Jones D1297/005/01, D1297/020/01 Arenaria interpres SH8978 2 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse 5; 41 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 30/08/2011 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y 01/10/2011 Traeth) Arenaria interpres SH9079 4 records, between Kevin Smith 10+; 20; 30; 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 23/12/2005 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Turnstone / Cwtiad y 16/03/2008 Traeth) Asio flammeus SH87 15/10/2011 Jonathan Groom 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/005/01 BDir1, Bern, CITES, 1 UKBA, WBR, (Short-eared Owl / Tylluan LBAP[CON, DEN, Glustiog) GWY] Aythya ferina SH97 04/11/2015 Mr R D Hughes 7 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/020/01 BDir2.1, UKBR, WBR, 1 LBAP[CON] (Pochard / Hwyaden Bengoch) Aythya marila SH904788 14/02/2013 Hughes, R D 1 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Scaup / Hwyaden Benddu) - PUBLIC VERSION - GWY] Aythya marila SH9078 9 records, between Marc Hughes; Robin 1 Female; 5; 8; 9; 14; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BirdTrack; D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 3 21/12/2009 and Sandham; Per Anon 7 BirdTrack #BG#784551#BG# WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Scaup / Hwyaden Benddu) 18/02/2013 Birdguides; Anon - D0062/003/01, GWY] Birdguides D1297/005/01, D1297/012/01 Aythya marila SH9178 02/01/2011 Ray Teesdale 11 Llanddulas, E BirdTrack D1297/005/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Scaup / Hwyaden Benddu) GWY] Aythya marila SH8977 11/03/2013 Anon - Birdguides 3 Llysfaen D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Scaup / Hwyaden Benddu) GWY]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 6 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Branta canadensis SH9078 03/03/2005 Carol 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.1, INNS, WCA9 3 Richardson;David (Canada Goose / Gwydd Richardson Canada) Buteo buteo SH909777 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris 1 South of Llandulas, field record D0969/001/04 CITES, LBAP[CON] 1 Denbighshire (Buzzard / Bwncath) Buteo buteo SH912778 3 records, between Edward Lyons; E. 1; 3 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld; In garden. D0062/001/01, CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 25/09/2004 and Lyons field record (Buzzard / Bwncath) 18/06/2006 D0969/001/04 Buteo buteo SH9078 2 records, between Carol 1; 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 22/03/2004 and Richardson;David (Buzzard / Bwncath) 02/03/2013 Richardson; Council, R D1297/012/01 P Buteo buteo SH9077 9 records, between Carol 40+; 2; 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 17/07/2004 and Richardson;David Valley (Buzzard / Bwncath) 15/05/2010 Richardson; Edward D0062/003/01 Lyons; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Buteo buteo SH9178 3 records, between John Bishop Murray; 2; 1+; 1 Llanddulas, E BirdTrack flew over caravan park; D1297/005/01, CITES, LBAP[CON] 1 03/01/2010 and Ray Teesdale; Mr A Birdtrack: (Buzzard / Bwncath) 01/02/2015 Humphreys-Jones D1297/020/01 Buteo buteo SH9177 4 records, between Edward Lyons 5; 3; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 10/08/2004 and Valley, E (Buzzard / Bwncath) 17/08/2008 Buteo buteo SH8978 7 records, between Susan Morris; Ian M 1 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, CITES, LBAP[CON] 3 01/12/2006 and Spence; Mr A Breeding Status: T (Buzzard / Bwncath) 01/11/2015 Humphreys-Jones; Mr D1297/020/01 W R Myerscough Buteo buteo SH8977 8 records, between Jonathan Groom; 2; 1; 3 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01, CITES, LBAP[CON] 1 30/12/2010 and Groom, J D Marian (Buzzard / Bwncath) 26/08/2013 D1297/012/01 Calidris alba SH9078 13/03/2004 Carol 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 Richardson;David LBAP[CON] (Sanderling / Pibydd y Richardson Tywod) Calidris alba SH9178 21/08/2008 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON] (Sanderling / Pibydd y Tywod) Calidris alpina SH97 3 records, between Carol 142; 20; 2 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBR, 3 13/03/2004 and Richardson;David LBAP[CON, GWY] (Dunlin / Pibydd y Mawn) 30/12/2007 Richardson; Megan Bagguley;Roger Bagguley Calidris alpina SH97 5 records, between Megan 50; 100; 1+ Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, UKBA, WBR, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger LBAP[CON, GWY] (Dunlin / Pibydd y Mawn) 06/12/2009 Bagguley; Ray D1297/002/01 Teesdale Caprimulgus europaeus SH8977 30/08/2015 Anon Llysfaen #bg#1113230#bg# D1297/020/01 BDir1, Bern, S7, 1 UKBA, WBA, (Nightjar / Troellwr Mawr) - PUBLIC VERSION - LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Carduelis carduelis SH9071578660 04/11/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 9 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[ANG, 3 CON] (Goldfinch / Nico) Carduelis carduelis SH9078 4 records, between Carol 1; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[ANG, 3 30/12/2007 and Richardson;David Breeding Status: P CON] (Goldfinch / Nico) 25/04/2015 Richardson; Jim D0062/003/01, Hulse, Val Hulse; Mr D1297/020/01 W R Myerscough; Mr J N Williams

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 7 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Carduelis carduelis SH9178 9 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 2; 1; 1+; 6 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/003/01, Bern, LBAP[ANG, 3 04/11/2006 and Susan Morris; Ray CON] (Goldfinch / Nico) 21/06/2015 Teesdale; Teesdale, D0062/001/01, R; Dr T Giles; Mr T.J. D1297/002/01, Revill D1297/005/01, D1297/012/01, D1297/020/01 Carduelis carduelis SH9177 24/04/2010 Carol Richardson, 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 Bern, LBAP[ANG, 3 David Richardson Valley, E CON] (Goldfinch / Nico) Carduelis carduelis SH8978 30/08/2011 Jim Hulse, Val Hulse 5 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 Bern, LBAP[ANG, 3 CON] (Goldfinch / Nico) Carduelis carduelis SH8977 10 records, between Jonathan Groom; 1+; 24; 20 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01, Bern, LBAP[ANG, 1 14/10/2011 and Groom, J D Marian CON] (Goldfinch / Nico) 20/09/2013 D1297/012/01 Certhia familiaris SH912778 2 records, between M Lyons 1 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 21/10/2005 and (Treecreeper / Dringwr 16/08/2006 Bach) Certhia familiaris SH9078 3 records, between Susan Morris; Mr W R 1; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; Possibly D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 23/09/2006 and Myerscough collecting & carrying food but too (Treecreeper / Dringwr 25/04/2015 far away to be sure. BTO Breeding D1297/020/01 Bach) Status: P Certhia familiaris SH9077 20/01/2008 Carol 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 Richardson;David Valley (Treecreeper / Dringwr Richardson Bach) Certhia familiaris SH9177 12/02/2009 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 Valley, E (Treecreeper / Dringwr Bach) Certhia familiaris SH8977 3 records, between Jonathan Groom 1; 1+ Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 06/11/2011 and Marian (Treecreeper / Dringwr 27/11/2011 Bach) Charadrius hiaticula SH9078 6 records, between Carol 2; 1; 10 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, S7, UKBR, 3 13/03/2004 and Richardson;David WBA, LBAP[CON, (Ringed Plover / Cwtiad 07/12/2010 Richardson; Megan D0062/003/01 GWY] Torchog) Bagguley;Roger Bagguley; Susan Morris; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Neil Hughes Charadrius hiaticula SH9178 3 records, between David Owen Jones; 5; 3 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, S7, UKBR, 3 06/03/2004 and Megan WBA, LBAP[CON, (Ringed Plover / Cwtiad 15/01/2015 Bagguley;Roger D1297/020/01 GWY] Torchog) Bagguley; Mr T.J. Revill Charadrius hiaticula SH9079 04/03/2011 Megan Bagguley, 1 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 Bern, S7, UKBR, 3 - PUBLICRoger Bagguley VERSION - WBA, LBAP[CON, (Ringed Plover / Cwtiad GWY] Torchog) Chloris chloris SH9078 5 records, between Susan Morris; Megan 2+; 1; 10; 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 02/05/2007 and Bagguley;Roger (Greenfinch / Llinos Werdd) 30/06/2010 Bagguley; Jim Hulse, D0062/003/01 Val Hulse Chloris chloris SH9077 2 records, between Mr H R A Cook 1 Conwy - Llandulas BTO Breeding Status: T; BTO D1297/020/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 18/03/2015 and Breeding Status: H (Greenfinch / Llinos Werdd) 28/04/2015

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 8 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Chloris chloris SH9178 6 records, between Ray Teesdale; Carol 1+; 1 Male; 1 Llanddulas, E BirdTrack; Comments Withheld D1297/005/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 13/07/2008 and Richardson;David (Greenfinch / Llinos Werdd) 21/06/2015 Richardson; Teesdale, D0062/001/01, R; Dr T Giles D1297/012/01, D1297/002/01, D1297/020/01 Chloris chloris SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 8; 1+; 2; 3 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 30/12/2010 and Marian (Greenfinch / Llinos Werdd) 24/12/2011 Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9069278658 2 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 3; 6+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 12/08/2009 and WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan 16/08/2009 Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9071778656 18/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 20+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9071478659 08/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9071678659 25/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 20 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9071578660 4 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 15+; 16+; 33+; 25+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 01/11/2009 and WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan 05/12/2009 Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9071878664 25/11/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 16 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH905787 12/03/2013 Groom, J D Llanddulas Shore D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 1 Road WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9113278070 20/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 20+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan Benddu) Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9078 51 records, between Carol 50+; 500+; 15; 1000; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; Beach car D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 27/01/2004 and Richardson;David 20; 4+; 1; 50; 21+; 4 park coming to scraps WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan 29/12/2015 Richardson; Susan Firstwinter; 7; 27+; D0062/003/01, Benddu) Morris; Megan 25+; 17; 18; 10+; 60+; D1297/012/01, Bagguley;Roger 30+; 20+; 8+; 11; 5; Bagguley; Jim 30; 8; 23+; 300+; 35+; D1297/020/01 Hulse;Val Hulse; 40; 34; 2+; 2 Robin Sandham; Jim - PUBLICHulse, Val Hulse; VERSION - Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Halsey, S A; Council, R P; Bou... Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9077 19/11/2009 Carol 4 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 Richardson;David Valley WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan Richardson Benddu)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 9 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH9178 30 records, between Julie Rogers; Megan 1+; 30; 200; 6; 5; 3; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger 20+; 2; 40; 50; 100+ BirdTrack WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan 16/12/2015 Bagguley; Susan D0062/003/01, Benddu) Morris; Jim Hulse, Val D1297/005/01, Hulse; Ray Teesdale; Morris, G E; Teesdale, D1297/002/01, R; Mr J.F. Jones; Mr G Jones; Mr W R D1297/012/01, Myerscough; Mr R D1297/020/01 Teesdale; Mr T.J. Revill Chroicocephalus ridibundus SH8978 3 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 10+; 35+; 12 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBA, 3 01/10/2011 and Mr D Sulway WBR, LBAP[GWY] (Black-headed Gull / Gwylan 26/02/2015 D1297/020/01 Benddu) Cinclus cinclus SH909777 2 records, both on E. Lyons 1 Craig-Y-Forwen, field record D0969/001/04 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 1 23/09/2004 Rhyd-Y-Foel, LBAP[CON] (Dipper / Bronwen y Dwr) Llandulas Cinclus cinclus SH9078 5 records, between Susan Morris; Kevin 1; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; On the river D0062/001/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 02/05/2007 and Smith; Miss S J Morris; dulas; Carrying food near last LBAP[CON] (Dipper / Bronwen y Dwr) 01/10/2015 Mr W R Myerscough years nest site. BTO Breeding D1297/020/01 Status: FF; Pr both collecting moss and building(renovating?)in same nest hole as used last year. BTO Breeding Status: B Cinclus cinclus SH9077 40 records, between Robin Sandham; Jim 1; 1 Female; 1 Male; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/003/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 09/05/2004 and Hulse, Val Hulse; Valley Breeding Status: P; BTO Breeding LBAP[CON] (Dipper / Bronwen y Dwr) 28/04/2015 Carol Richardson, Status: FF D0062/001/01, David Richardson; D1297/020/01 Carol Richardson;David Richardson; Edward Lyons; Mr H R A Cook Cinclus cinclus SH9177 01/10/2006 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 Valley, E LBAP[CON] (Dipper / Bronwen y Dwr) Clangula hyemalis SH902787 19/02/2013 Hughes, R D 1 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)VU, 4 UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1 (Long-tailed Duck / Hwyaden Gynffon-Hir) Clangula hyemalis SH9078 10 records, between Robin Sandham; Anon 1 Male; 2; 4; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir2.2, RD1(UK)VU, 3 18/12/2011 and - Birdguides; Weldrick, UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1 (Long-tailed Duck / Hwyaden 03/03/2013 J; Clarkson, G D1297/012/01 Gynffon-Hir) Clangula hyemalis SH8978 01/02/2013 Hughes, M 1 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)VU, 1 UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1 (Long-tailed Duck / Hwyaden Gynffon-Hir) Columba oenas SH9077 10/01/2005 Edward Lyons 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 3 Valley RD2(UK), UKBA, (Stock Dove / Colomen LBAP[GWY] Wyllt) Corvus corax SH9078 4 records, between Susan Morris; Carol 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 23/09/2006- andPUBLICRichardson;David VERSION - (Raven / Cigfran) 15/12/2015 Richardson; Mr W R D1297/020/01 Myerscough Corvus corax SH9077 3 records, between Edward Lyons; Carol 2; 4 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 12/04/2005 and Richardson, David Valley (Raven / Cigfran) 09/01/2011 Richardson D0062/003/01 Corvus corax SH9178 5 records, between Megan 1; 1+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack: D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger (Raven / Cigfran) 21/03/2015 Bagguley; Susan D1297/002/01, Morris; Ray Teesdale; D1297/005/01, John Bishop Murray; Mr J Davies D1297/020/01

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 10 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Corvus corax SH9177 3 records, between Carol 1; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 10/08/2004 and Richardson;David Valley, E (Raven / Cigfran) 24/04/2010 Richardson; Edward D0062/003/01 Lyons; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Corvus corax SH8978 3 records, between Mr W R Myerscough; 3; 1 Llanddulas, beach W Sitting bird in the same nest as D1297/020/01 LBAP[CON] 1 22/03/2015 and Mr J.P. Hughes used last year. A Fulmar appears (Raven / Cigfran) 06/07/2015 to be sitting in what looks like an older Ravens nest, slightly above this nest in the quarry?. BTO Breeding Status: ON Corvus corax SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 1; 1+; 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; BirdTrack Two feeding D1297/005/01 LBAP[CON] 1 13/10/2011 and Marian on sheep carcass (Raven / Cigfran) 24/12/2011 Cyanistes caeruleus SH9067877996 Summer 2010 Sam Dyer Nest Plas Dulas, Pencoed Surveys on 30th May & 5th June, D0174/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 Road, Llanddulas, 2010. Located in section G. (Blue Tit / Titw Tomos Las) (Supplied by Original Conwy LL22 8LS Recorder (Checked)) Cyanistes caeruleus SH9078 9 records, between Susan Morris; Megan 10+; 5; 2+ Juvenile; 2; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; 2 pairs D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 23/09/2006 and Bagguley;Roger 3; 1; 4 fighting. BTO Breeding Status: P (Blue Tit / Titw Tomos Las) 13/08/2015 Bagguley; Bourne, A; D1297/012/01, Mr W R Myerscough D1297/020/01 Cyanistes caeruleus SH9077 11 records, between Carol 4; 10+; 2; 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 13/01/2006 and Richardson;David Valley Breeding Status: H (Blue Tit / Titw Tomos Las) 28/04/2015 Richardson; Susan D0062/003/01, Morris; Jim Hulse, Val D1297/020/01 Hulse; Carol Richardson, David Richardson; Mr H R A Cook Cyanistes caeruleus SH9178 4 records, between Susan Morris; Ray 4+ Juvenile; 2; 1+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 02/05/2007 and Teesdale; Mr T.J. (Blue Tit / Titw Tomos Las) 15/01/2015 Revill D1297/005/01, D1297/020/01 Cyanistes caeruleus SH9177 2 records, between Carol 4; 10 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 27/07/2004 and Richardson;David Valley, E (Blue Tit / Titw Tomos Las) 14/01/2007 Richardson; Edward Lyons Cyanistes caeruleus SH8977 10 records, between Jonathan Groom 16; 1+; 5; 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 30/12/2010 and Marian (Blue Tit / Titw Tomos Las) 24/12/2011 Cygnus cygnus SH9078 29/12/2015 Mr J N Williams Llandulas D1297/020/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 4 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Whooper Swan / Alarch y GWY] Gogledd) Cygnus olor SH9178 2 records, between Megan 6; 19 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger LBAP[CON] (Mute Swan / Alarch Dof) 21/06/2015 Bagguley; Dr T Giles D1297/020/01 Cygnus olor SH8978 12/11/2015 Mr R D Hughes 4 Mobile-SH8978 In off the sea. D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 1 LBAP[CON] (Mute Swan / Alarch Dof) Delichon urbicum SH9071478659 08/09/2009- PUBLICJim Hulse;Val Hulse 16+ VERSIONLlanddulas Comments Withheld - D0062/001/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON] (House Martin / Gwennol y Bondo) Delichon urbicum SH9078 8 records, between Susan Morris; Jim 2; 4; 20+; 8+; 3; 6 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 02/05/2007 and Hulse;Val Hulse; Jim LBAP[CON] (House Martin / Gwennol y 07/08/2011 Hulse, Val Hulse D0062/003/01 Bondo) Delichon urbicum SH9178 2 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 11/08/2011 and Dr T Giles LBAP[CON] (House Martin / Gwennol y 21/06/2015 D1297/020/01 Bondo)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 11 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Delichon urbicum SH8978 19/05/2015 Mr W R Myerscough c20 Llanddulas, beach W Feeding over flooded quarry. D1297/020/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 1 LBAP[CON] (House Martin / Gwennol y Bondo) Dendrocopos major SH912778 31 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1 Male; 1; 1 Juvenile; Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 18/05/2005 and Lyons 2; 1 Female; 2 (Great Spotted Woodpecker 05/05/2008 Juvenile / Cnocell Fraith Fwyaf) Dendrocopos major SH9078 08/03/2015 Mr W R Myerscough 1 Llanddulas D1297/020/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 (Great Spotted Woodpecker / Cnocell Fraith Fwyaf) Dendrocopos major SH9077 10 records, between Carol 1; 1 Female; 1 Male Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 23/11/2004 and Richardson;David Valley (Great Spotted Woodpecker 14/05/2011 Richardson; Edward D0062/003/01 / Cnocell Fraith Fwyaf) Lyons; Susan Morris; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Dendrocopos major SH9178 11/12/2010 Robin Sandham 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 (Great Spotted Woodpecker / Cnocell Fraith Fwyaf) Dendrocopos major SH9177 27 records, between Edward Lyons; M 2; 1 Juvenile; 1; 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 01/07/2004 and Lyons Male; 1 Female; 1 Valley, E (Great Spotted Woodpecker 08/06/2009 Adult / Cnocell Fraith Fwyaf) Dendrocopos major SH8978 16/01/2013 Weldrick, J 1 Llysfaen D1297/012/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 (Great Spotted Woodpecker / Cnocell Fraith Fwyaf) Dendrocopos major SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 1; 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack:; BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 30/12/2010 and Marian Two calling from different areas. (Great Spotted Woodpecker 24/12/2011 One seen. / Cnocell Fraith Fwyaf) Egretta garzetta SH9071578660 02/11/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, CITES, 3 RD2(UK), LBAP[CON, (Little Egret / Creyr Bach) GWY] Egretta garzetta SH9078 2 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 1; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir1, Bern, CITES, 3 03/01/2010 and Mr E M Ab Owain & RD2(UK), LBAP[CON, (Little Egret / Creyr Bach) 14/06/2015 Ms H Kidd D1297/020/01 GWY] Falco columbarius SH87 09/02/2013 Hughes, M 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, CITES, 1 UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Merlin / Cudyll Bach) LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Falco peregrinus SH97 5 records, between Wales Rare Breeding 3 eggs, 3 hatched, 3 Nest Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0036/001/04 BDir1, Bern, CITES, 3 1992 and 1997 Birds and Raptor fledged; 2 eggs, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[ANG, (Peregrine / Hebog Tramor) Study Group - North hatched, 1 fledged; 4 CON, GWY] East eggs, 4 hatched, 3 fledged; 3 eggs, 3 hatched, 2 fledged Falco peregrinus SH97 23/09/2006 Susan Morris 1 Female Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, CITES, 3 - PUBLIC VERSION - WCA1.1, LBAP[ANG, (Peregrine / Hebog Tramor) CON, GWY] Falco peregrinus SH87 27/01/2006 Susan Morris 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, CITES, 3 WCA1.1, LBAP[ANG, (Peregrine / Hebog Tramor) CON, GWY] Falco tinnunculus SH9078 13/03/2005 Carol 1 Male Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, CITES, S7, 3 Richardson;David UKBA, WBR, (Kestrel / Cudyll Coch) Richardson LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Falco tinnunculus SH9077 17/08/2008 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, CITES, S7, 3 Valley UKBA, WBR, (Kestrel / Cudyll Coch) LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 12 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Falco tinnunculus SH9178 2 records, between Megan 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, CITES, S7, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger UKBA, WBR, (Kestrel / Cudyll Coch) 23/12/2005 Bagguley LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Falco tinnunculus SH9177 2 records, between Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, CITES, S7, 3 23/06/2007 and Valley, E UKBA, WBR, (Kestrel / Cudyll Coch) 17/02/2008 LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Falco tinnunculus SH8977 8 records, between Jonathan Groom 1; 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; BirdTrack Pair being D1297/005/01 Bern, CITES, S7, 1 17/08/2011 and Marian mobbed by a crow. UKBA, WBR, (Kestrel / Cudyll Coch) 24/12/2011 LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Fratercula arctica SH904786 26/10/2015 Mr R D Hughes 1 Llanddulas D1297/020/01 UKBR, WBR, 4 LBAP[ANG, GWY] (Puffin / Pal) Fringilla montifringilla SH9078 08/01/2010 Robert Hughes 1 Female Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] 3 (Brambling / Pinc y Mynydd) Fringilla montifringilla SH9178 2 records, between Ray Teesdale 10; 2 Llanddulas, E BirdTrack D1297/005/01, WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] 1 31/12/2009 and (Brambling / Pinc y Mynydd) 02/01/2011 D1297/002/01 Fulmarus glacialis SH9078 16 records, between Carol 8; 1; 4; 7; Present; 2; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; 10.40am. 50 D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), UKBA 3 26/01/2001 and Richardson;David 20; 1+; 12+; 3; 10+ per cent cloud, cold. Seen on the (Fulmar / Aderyn Drycin y 15/12/2015 Richardson; Robin A55. In the morning; On ledges in D0062/003/01, Graig) Sandham; Norman flooded quarry. BTO Breeding D1297/002/01, Hallas; Ron Davies; Status: T; On ledges at back and Council, R P; Weldrick, sides of flooder quarry. D0969/001/04, J; Clarkson, G; Bourne, A; Mr W R D1297/012/01, Myerscough; Mr D D1297/020/01 Sulway; Mr J N Williams Fulmarus glacialis SH9178 3 records, between Helen Stone; Mr J.F. 1+; 1 Llanddulas, E D1297/002/01, Bern, RD2(UK), UKBA 1 16/01/2009 and Jones; Dr T Giles (Fulmar / Aderyn Drycin y 16/12/2015 D1297/020/01 Graig) Fulmarus glacialis SH8978 9 records, between Susan Morris; Davies, 1; 2; 8; c6; 3 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld; Llysfaen D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), UKBA 3 27/04/2007 and S; Mr W R Quarry; Including 1 still present in (Fulmar / Aderyn Drycin y 06/07/2015 Myerscough; Mr Ian an old Raven's nest. See earlier D1297/012/01, Graig) Spence & Dr Anne records. BTO Breeding Status: D1297/020/01 Brenchley ON; On and around quarry ledges; BTO Breeding Status: ON; 3 apparently occupied nests in quarry. 1 in an old Raven's nest. BTO Breeding Status: ON; One appears to be sitt... Fulmarus glacialis SH9079 3 records, between Kevin Smith; Carol 1 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, RD2(UK), UKBA 3 22/06/2005 and Richardson;David (Fulmar / Aderyn Drycin y 02/05/2007 Richardson; Susan Graig) Morris Gavia SH9078 2 records, between Mr D Sulway; Mr R 2 Wern road beach D1297/020/01 WCA1.1 1 03/01/2015 and Halsey llanddulas (Indet. Diver) 26/02/2015 Gavia arctica SH9078 4 records, between Carol 1; 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 4 05/03/2004- andPUBLICRichardson;David VERSION - WBA (Black-throated Diver / 07/02/2015 Richardson; Anon - D1297/012/01, Trochydd Gyddfddu) Birdguides; Bourne, A; D1297/020/01 Mr J N Williams Gavia immer SH9078 2 records, between Norman Hallas; Mr J N 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 4 11/02/2004 and Williams WBA, WCA1.1, (Great Northern Diver / 29/12/2015 D1297/020/01 LBAP[CON, GWY] Trochydd Mawr) Gavia immer SH9178 08/12/2011 Ray Teesdale 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 4 WBA, WCA1.1, (Great Northern Diver / LBAP[CON, GWY] Trochydd Mawr)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 13 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Gavia immer SH9079 17/10/2009 Carol 3 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 3 Richardson;David WBA, WCA1.1, (Great Northern Diver / Richardson LBAP[CON, GWY] Trochydd Mawr) Gavia stellata SH905788 05/01/2013 Clarkson, G 22 Llanddulas (offshore) D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Red-throated Diver / GWY] Trochydd Gyddfgoch) Gavia stellata SH904788 15/02/2013 Hughes, R D 6 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Red-throated Diver / GWY] Trochydd Gyddfgoch) Gavia stellata SH9078 25 records, between Kevin Smith; Norman 4; 3+; 2; 1; 10; 1+; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir1, Bern, WBA, 3 18/03/2004 and Hallas; Neil Hughes; 189; 9; 8; 60+; 33; 5; WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Red-throated Diver / 29/12/2015 Steve Collins; Marc 30; 12; 15+; 3 D0062/003/01, GWY] Trochydd Gyddfgoch) Hughes; Robin D1297/012/01, Sandham; Malcolm Down; Steven Davies; D1297/002/01, Bourne, A; Weldrick, J; Wren, P; Council, R P; D1297/020/01 Halsey, S A; Mr A Humphreys-Jones; Mr J ... Gavia stellata SH9178 7 records, between David Owen Jones; 3; 1+; 1; 6; 11 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, BDir1, Bern, WBA, 3 18/01/2004 and Bob Edwards; Julie BirdTrack WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Red-throated Diver / 07/11/2015 Rogers; Ray Teesdale; D1297/005/01, GWY] Trochydd Gyddfgoch) Mr G Jones D1297/002/01, D1297/020/01 Gavia stellata SH8978 16/01/2013 Weldrick, J 1 Llysfaen D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Red-throated Diver / GWY] Trochydd Gyddfgoch) Gavia stellata SH9079 8 records, between Carol 1; 10; 3; 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir1, Bern, WBA, 3 13/03/2004 and Richardson;David WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Red-throated Diver / 04/03/2011 Richardson; Kevin D0062/003/01 GWY] Trochydd Gyddfgoch) Smith; Hilary Nash; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley Haematopus ostralegus SH9069278658 2 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 42; 61 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 12/08/2009 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) 16/08/2009 Haematopus ostralegus SH9071778656 18/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 19 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) Haematopus ostralegus SH9071678659 2 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 300+; 70+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 23/10/2009 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) 25/10/2009 Haematopus ostralegus SH9071478659 08/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) Haematopus ostralegus SH9071578660 4 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 30+; 20; 29; 18 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 01/11/2009 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) - PUBLIC VERSION - 05/12/2009 Haematopus ostralegus SH9072278660 12/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 28+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) Haematopus ostralegus SH905787 12/03/2013 Groom, J D Llanddulas Shore D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 1 Road LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) Haematopus ostralegus SH9113278070 20/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 65+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) Haematopus ostralegus SH906788 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris 2 Llandulas Beach, field record D0969/001/04 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 1 Denbighshire LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 14 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Haematopus ostralegus SH9078 52 records, between Kevin Smith; Carol 30; 50+; 500+; 250+; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; Breeding D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 18/03/2004 and Richardson;David 50; 500; 4; 40+; 200+; status: Flying over LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) 29/12/2015 Richardson; Megan 90; 34+; 150+; 15; 14; D0062/003/01, Bagguley;Roger 2; 6; 20+; 22; 1; 27; D1297/012/01, Bagguley; Jim 31; 130+; 7; 100; 21; Hulse;Val Hulse; Neil 30+; 32+; 100+; 450+; D1297/020/01 Hughes; Edward 24+; 250; 12 Lyons; Hilary Nash; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Malcol... Haematopus ostralegus SH9178 39 records, between Megan 500; 50; 1; 200+; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack on D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger 110+; 9; 2; 30+; 350+; shoreline; Birdtrack:; BirdTrack LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) 16/12/2015 Bagguley; Susan 1+; 20; 300; 100; 150; D0062/003/01, Morris; Edward Lyons; 60; 160; 15; 82; 6; D1297/002/01, Carol c100; 8 Richardson;David D1297/012/01, Richardson; Carol Richardson, David D1297/005/01, Richardson; Jim D1297/020/01 Hulse, Val Hulse; Ray Teesdale; Teesdale, R; Morris, G E; John Bis... Haematopus ostralegus SH8978 3 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 47+; 5+; 85+ Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 30/08/2011 and Davies, S LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) 23/02/2013 D1297/012/01 Haematopus ostralegus SH9079 3 records, between Kevin Smith; Carol 50; 60+; 200 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 17/02/2008 and Richardson;David LBAP[CON, GWY] (Oystercatcher / Pioden Fôr) 04/03/2011 Richardson; Megan D0062/003/01 Bagguley, Roger Bagguley Hirundo rustica SH9069278658 16/08/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) GWY] Hirundo rustica SH9071478659 08/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) GWY] Hirundo rustica SH9072278660 12/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) GWY] Hirundo rustica SH9125077890 09/03/2012 Catharine Wuster 6 Nest Craig Yr Ogof Clip Old nests found in buildings. D0174/001/01 Bern, WBA, 4 Terfyn Abergele LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) (Supplied by Original Conwy LL22 8EH GWY] Recorder (Checked)) Hirundo rustica SH9078 12 records, between Carol 1; 2; 50; 3+; 3; 15 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, Bern, WBA, 3 13/04/2007 and Richardson;David Breeding Status: H LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) 25/04/2015 Richardson; Susan D0062/003/01, GWY] Morris; Megan D1297/020/01 Bagguley;Roger Bagguley; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Mr W R - PUBLICMyerscough VERSION - Hirundo rustica SH9178 2 records, between Susan Morris; John 3+; 4 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, Bern, WBA, 3 02/05/2007 and Bishop Murray LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) 24/09/2011 D1297/005/01 GWY] Hirundo rustica SH9177 24/04/2010 Carol Richardson, 4 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 Bern, WBA, 3 David Richardson Valley, E LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) GWY] Hirundo rustica SH8978 19/05/2015 Mr W R Myerscough c20 Llanddulas, beach W Feeding over flooded quarry. D1297/020/01 Bern, WBA, 1 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) GWY] Hirundo rustica SH8977 14/10/2011 Jonathan Groom 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, WBA, 1 Marian LBAP[ANG, CON, (Swallow / Gwennol) GWY]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 15 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Hydrobates pelagicus SH9078 02/10/2008 Megan 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 4 Bagguley;Roger WBA, LBAP[GWY] (Storm Petrel / Pedryn Bagguley Drycin) Hydrocoloeus minutus SH9078 2 records, both on Anon - Birdguides; 1 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, WBA, 1 06/02/2013 Hughes, R D WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] (Little Gull / Gwylan Fechan) Larus argentatus SH9071678659 25/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 3 UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH9071578660 5 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 5; 2; 4 Juvenile; 3; 7 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 3 01/11/2009 and UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y 05/12/2009 LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH905787 12/03/2013 Groom, J D Llanddulas Shore D1297/012/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 Road UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH908787 06/09/2012 Martyn Harris Present Llanddulas Beach, Quite a few. field record D0969/001/04 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 Denbighshire UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH906788 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris Present Llandulas Beach, A few. field record D0969/001/04 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 Denbighshire UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH899781 04/01/2015 Mr M Hughrs 800 Mobile-SH8978 D1297/020/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH911788 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris Present Beach near the river Quite a few. field record D0969/001/04 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 outlet at Llandulas, UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y Denbighshire LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH899785 08/02/2013 Hughes, M 2000 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH9078 56 records, between Megan 500; 300; 200+; 1; 9; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; Near the D0062/001/01, BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 3 23/11/2004 and Bagguley;Roger 300+; 22; 10+ river dulas estuary. tide in.; BTO UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y 29/12/2015 Bagguley; Neil Juvenile; 1000; 3 ; Breeding Status: ON; BTO D0062/003/01, LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Hughes; Jim Hulse;Val 500+; 2+; 2000; 50; 6; Breeding Status: X D1297/012/01, Hulse; Kevin Smith; 40+; 30+; 150+; 18+; Carol 20+; 3; 25+; 100; 8+; D1297/020/01 Richardson;David 5+; 5; 100+; 35+; 320; Richardson; Susan 1500+; c250; 1+; 10 Morris; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Megan Bagguley, Roger - PUBLICBagguley; Halsey, S A; VERSION - Counci... Larus argentatus SH9077 18/03/2015 Mr H R A Cook 6 Conwy - Llandulas BTO Breeding Status: X D1297/020/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 16 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Larus argentatus SH9178 33 records, between Susan Morris; Megan 30+; 500; 1000; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger 2000+; 1+; 6; 12+; BirdTrack; Feeding frenzy, UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y 07/11/2015 Bagguley; Julie 100; 500+; c2500 presumed fish shoal?; Large D1297/005/01, LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Rogers; Ray Teesdale; numbers widely dispersed either D0062/003/01, Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; side of mouth of R Dulas in a low Morris, G E; Teesdale, tide roost. D1297/002/01, R; Mr J Davies; Mr T.J. Revill; Dr T Giles; Mr R D1297/012/01, Teesdale; Mr G Jones; D1297/020/01 Mr W R Myer... Larus argentatus SH9177 15/04/2008 Edward Lyons 170+ Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 3 Valley, E UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH8978 10 records, between Wheeler, M J; Davies, 20+; 7; 1+; 2; 8; 100+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D1297/012/01, BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 30/08/2011 and S; Jim Hulse, Val Breeding Status: NY; On ledge in UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y 06/07/2015 Hulse; Mr W R flooded quarry. BTO Breeding D0062/003/01, LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Myerscough; Mr J.P. Status: NY; BTO Breeding Status: D1297/020/01 Hughes; Mr D Sulway ON Larus argentatus SH9079 04/03/2011 Megan Bagguley, 30 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 3 Roger Bagguley UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus argentatus SH8977 8 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+ Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; BirdTrack Overhead; D1297/005/01 BAP, BDir2.2, S7, 1 30/12/2010 and Marian Birdtrack: UKBR, WBR, (Herring Gull / Gwylan y 24/12/2011 LBAP[CON, GWY] Penwaig) Larus canus SH916783 09/03/2013 Hughes, M 4000 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 1 (Common Gull / Gwylan y Gweunydd) Larus canus SH9078 14 records, between Carol 400+; 200+; 4; 3; 2; 1; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 06/03/2005 and Richardson;David 12; 66 (Common Gull / Gwylan y 26/02/2015 Richardson; Neil D0062/003/01, Gweunydd) Hughes; Megan D1297/012/01, Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Davies, S; D1297/020/01 Halsey, R; Council, R P; Weldrick, J; Mr D Sulway; Mr A Humphreys-Jones; Mr R Halsey Larus canus SH9178 11 records, between Megan 50; 1; 1+; 60; 12 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 23/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger (Common Gull / Gwylan y 22/10/2015 Bagguley; Susan D1297/002/01, Gweunydd) Morris; Julie Rogers; D1297/005/01, Ray Teesdale; Teesdale, R; Mr R D1297/012/01, Teesdale; Mr T.J. Revill D1297/020/01 Larus canus SH8978 26/02/2015 Mr D Sulway 8 LLanddulas flooded D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 1 quarry (Common Gull / Gwylan y Gweunydd) - PUBLIC VERSION - Larus fuscus SH911788 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris Present Beach near the river Quite a few. field record D0969/001/04 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 1 outlet at Llandulas, LBAP[CON, GWY, (Lesser Black-backed Gull / Denbighshire SNP] Gwylan Gefnddu Leiaf) Larus fuscus SH9078 11 records, between Edward Lyons; Megan 1; 6; c40; 1+; 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 03/03/2006 and Bagguley;Roger Breeding Status: X LBAP[CON, GWY, (Lesser Black-backed Gull / 13/08/2015 Bagguley; Carol D1297/012/01, SNP] Gwylan Gefnddu Leiaf) Richardson;David D1297/020/01 Richardson; Bourne, A; Council, R P; Halsey, R; Mr W R Myerscough; Mr D Sulway; Mr J N Williams Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 17 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Larus fuscus SH9178 2 records, between Mr J.F. Jones; Mr G 350+ Lllanddulas Feeding frenzy, presumed fish D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 1 07/11/2015 and Jones shoal? LBAP[CON, GWY, (Lesser Black-backed Gull / 16/12/2015 SNP] Gwylan Gefnddu Leiaf) Larus fuscus SH8978 3 records, between Mr W R Myerscough 2; c4; 4 Llanddulas, beach W BTO Breeding Status: H; One on D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 1 19/05/2015 and nest on ledge in quarry. BTO LBAP[CON, GWY, (Lesser Black-backed Gull / 06/07/2015 Breeding Status: ON; BTO SNP] Gwylan Gefnddu Leiaf) Breeding Status: P Larus marinus SH9071778656 18/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 (Great Black-backed Gull / Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Larus marinus SH9071678659 25/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 (Great Black-backed Gull / Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Larus marinus SH9071578660 2 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 2; 16 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 04/11/2009 and (Great Black-backed Gull / 05/12/2009 Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Larus marinus SH899781 04/01/2015 Mr M Hughrs 97 Mobile-SH8978 D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 1 (Great Black-backed Gull / Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Larus marinus SH897786 06/09/2012 Martyn Harris 1 Old jetty between On the old jetty. field record D0969/001/04 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 1 Llanddulas and OLd (Great Black-backed Gull / Colwyn, Denbighshire Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Larus marinus SH9078 34 records, between Carol 4; 10; 6; 8; 3; 20; 1; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 13/03/2004 and Richardson;David 50+; 2; 5; c5; 2+; 9; Breeding Status: X (Great Black-backed Gull / 29/12/2015 Richardson; Megan 22+; 4+ D0062/003/01, Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Bagguley;Roger D1297/012/01, Bagguley; Neil Hughes; Jim Hulse;Val D1297/020/01 Hulse; Kevin Smith; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Davies, S; Halsey, R; Halsey, S A... Larus marinus SH9178 30 records, between Megan 20; 2; 1; 1+; 4; 10; 3; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 23/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger 5; 6; 30+ BirdTrack; Feeding frenzy, (Great Black-backed Gull / 16/12/2015 Bagguley; Susan presumed fish shoal? D0062/003/01, Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Morris; Julie Rogers; D1297/012/01, Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Morris, G E; Teesdale, D1297/002/01, R; Ray Teesdale; John Bishop Murray; Mr J D1297/005/01, Davies; Mr T.J. Revill; D1297/020/01 Dr T Giles; Mr G Jones; Mr R T... Larus marinus SH8978 7 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 2; 3; 23 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 30/08/2011- andPUBLICMr J.P. Hughes; Mr W VERSION - (Great Black-backed Gull / 27/06/2015 R Myerscough; Mr D D1297/020/01, Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Sulway; Wheeler, M J; D1297/012/01 Davies, S Larus marinus SH9079 5 records, between Carol 1; 6; 15; 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBR 3 14/01/2007 and Richardson;David (Great Black-backed Gull / 12/12/2009 Richardson; Kevin Gwylan Gefnddu Fwyaf) Smith Larus melanocephalus SH916783 09/03/2013 Hughes, M 2 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 1 WBA, WCA1.1, (Mediterranean Gull / LBAP[CON] Gwylan Môr y Canoldir)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 18 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Larus melanocephalus SH97 13/03/2008 Julie Rogers 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 3 WBA, WCA1.1, (Mediterranean Gull / LBAP[CON] Gwylan Môr y Canoldir) Larus melanocephalus SH97 16/03/2008 Kevin Smith 1 Secondsummer Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 3 WBA, WCA1.1, (Mediterranean Gull / LBAP[CON] Gwylan Môr y Canoldir) Limosa limosa SH9178 2 records, between John Bishop Murray 12; 3 Llanddulas, E Birdtrack: D1297/005/01, BAP, BDir2.2, UKBR, 1 25/09/2009 and WBA, WCA1.1, (Black-tailed Godwit / 26/07/2010 D1297/002/01 LBAP[CON, GWY] Rhostog Gynffonddu) Linaria cannabina SH900784 14/06/2015 Mr E M Ab Owain & 2 LLanddulas Beach D1297/020/01 Bern, S7, UKBR, 1 Ms H Kidd WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Linnet / Llinos) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Linaria cannabina SH9078 4 records, between Kevin Smith; Megan 1; 5 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, Bern, S7, UKBR, 3 30/01/2011 and Bagguley, Roger WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Linnet / Llinos) 07/02/2015 Bagguley; Mr J N D1297/020/01 CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Williams; Mr R P Council Linaria cannabina SH9178 8 records, between Susan Morris; Edward 1; 5; 4; 1+; 3 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, S7, UKBR, 3 23/09/2006 and Lyons; Jim Hulse, Val WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Linnet / Llinos) 07/11/2015 Hulse; Ray Teesdale; D0062/003/01, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Mr T.J. Revill; Mr G D1297/002/01, Jones D1297/020/01 Linaria cannabina SH9079 12/04/2005 Kevin Smith 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, S7, UKBR, 3 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Linnet / Llinos) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Linaria flavirostris SH97 (Approximate) 05/03/2000 Paul Morris 2 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0061/001/01 Bern, S7, UKBR, 4 WBR, LBAP[CON, (Twite / Llinos y Mynydd) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Melanitta fusca SH907785 13/03/2013 James, W M 2 Llandulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 1 UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Melanitta fusca SH905787 12/03/2013 Groom, J D 15+ Llanddulas Shore D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 1 Road UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Melanitta fusca SH904788 2 records, between Hughes, R D 8; 4 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 1 14/02/2013 and UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- 15/02/2013 LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Melanitta fusca SH902787 19/02/2013 Hughes, R D 5 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 1 UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Melanitta fusca SH9078 (Approximate) 51 records, between Gareth Jones; Carol 2; 1; 30+; 4 Male; 3 Outside COS Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0061/008/01, BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 4 25/01/2004 and Richardson;David Female; 7; 8; 6; 40; Boundary: Llanddulas #BG#772245#BG#; BirdTrack UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- 07/11/2015- PUBLICRichardson; Robin 1+; 4; 3; 5; 14; 12 VERSION#BG#780628#BG#; BirdTrack;- D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Sandham; Per Anon #bg#1105513#bg#; D0062/003/01, Birdguides; Anon - #bg#1132682#bg#; Birdguides; Weldrick, #bg#1088136#bg# D1297/005/01, J; Wren, P; Council, R P; Clarkson, G; Anon; D1297/012/01, Mr R D Hughes; Mr A D1297/020/01 Chambers; Mr A Humphr...

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 19 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Melanitta fusca SH9178 (Estimated 5 records, between Anon; Ray Teesdale; 6; 2; 1 Off Pensarn/Llandulas BirdTrack; Flew in at 13.30, D0285/139/01, BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 1 December 2000 Teesdale, R; Mr G solitary. UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- (Centroid of Site)) approx and Jones D1297/005/01, LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) 07/11/2015 D1297/002/01, D1297/012/01, D1297/020/01 Melanitta fusca SH8978 01/02/2013 Hughes, M 7 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 1 UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Melanitta fusca SH9079 2 records, both on Carol 1 Female; 1 Male Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 3 27/01/2004 Richardson;David UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- Richardson LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Melanitta fusca SH8977 3 records, between Anon - Birdguides 3 Llysfaen D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, RD1(UK)EN, 1 06/04/2013 and UKBR, WBA, WCA1.1, (Velvet Scoter / Môr- 08/11/2013 LBAP[CON] Hwyaden y Gogledd) Melanitta nigra SH905786 13/03/2013 James, W M 10000 Llandulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 1 WBA, WCA1.1, (Common Scoter / Mor- LBAP[ANG, CON, Hwyaden Ddu) DEN, FLI, GWY] Melanitta nigra SH905787 12/03/2013 Groom, J D Llanddulas Shore D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 1 Road WBA, WCA1.1, (Common Scoter / Mor- LBAP[ANG, CON, Hwyaden Ddu) DEN, FLI, GWY] Melanitta nigra SH905788 05/01/2013 Clarkson, G c5500 Llanddulas (offshore) D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 1 WBA, WCA1.1, (Common Scoter / Mor- LBAP[ANG, CON, Hwyaden Ddu) DEN, FLI, GWY] Melanitta nigra SH9078 54 records, between Carol 300+; 200+; 1000; Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 25/01/2004 and Richardson;David 250; 100; 5; 10+; #BG#784551#BG#; Not my count, WBA, WCA1.1, (Common Scoter / Mor- 29/12/2015 Richardson; Norman 700+; 11; 100+; 1+; but an estimate by local birders of D0062/003/01, LBAP[ANG, CON, Hwyaden Ddu) Hallas; Kevin Smith; 150; 8000+; c200; a phenomenal sight.; D1297/005/01, DEN, FLI, GWY] Megan 1500+; 3000+; 3000; #bg#1105513#bg# Bagguley;Roger 40+; 10000; 8000; D1297/012/01, Bagguley; Neil 500+; 200; 6000+; Hughes; Steve Collins; 5000+; 5000; c2000; D1297/020/01 Marc Hughes; Robin 15800; 20000; Sandham; Malcolm 10000+; 15000; c2600; Down; Megan 1000+; 6000; 2... Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Per ... Melanitta nigra SH9178 (Estimated 28 records, between Anon; David Owen 50+; 1+; 6; 500+; 80+; Off Pensarn/Llandulas Huge flocks; Comments Withheld; D0285/139/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 1 December 2000 Jones; Julie Rogers; 300+; 300; 1000; 40; Birdtrack:; BirdTrack WBA, WCA1.1, (Common Scoter / Mor- (Centroid of Site)) approx and Megan 500; 1000+; c500; D0062/001/01, LBAP[ANG, CON, Hwyaden Ddu) 16/12/2015 Bagguley;Roger 1500+; 1 D1297/005/01, DEN, FLI, GWY] Bagguley; Ray Teesdale; Carol D0062/003/01, Richardson, David Richardson; Teesdale, D1297/002/01, - PUBLICR; Mr J.F. Jones; Mr G VERSION - D1297/012/01, Jones; Mr T.J. Revill; Mr J Davies; Mr E M D1297/020/01 Ab Ow... Melanitta nigra SH8978 4 records, between Wheeler, M J; Davies, c500; 25000; 6000 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 1 16/01/2013 and S; Hughes, M; WBA, WCA1.1, (Common Scoter / Mor- 07/12/2013 Weldrick, J LBAP[ANG, CON, Hwyaden Ddu) DEN, FLI, GWY]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 20 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Melanitta nigra SH9079 15 records, between Kevin Smith; Carol 50+; 1000+; 2000+; Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 10/07/2005 and Richardson;David 10; 5; 400+; 1000; 1 WBA, WCA1.1, (Common Scoter / Mor- 11/10/2011 Richardson; Hilary Male; 20; 800+; 40; 7 D0062/003/01 LBAP[ANG, CON, Hwyaden Ddu) Nash; Megan DEN, FLI, GWY] Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Mergus merganser SH9071478659 08/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Female Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, LBAP[CON] 3 (Goosander / Hwyaden Ddanheddog) Mergus merganser SH9113278070 20/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Female Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, LBAP[CON] 3 (Goosander / Hwyaden Ddanheddog) Mergus merganser SH9078 3 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse 1 Female; 9+; 6+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir2.2, LBAP[CON] 3 24/12/2010 and (Goosander / Hwyaden 12/03/2011 Ddanheddog) Mergus merganser SH9077 2 records, between Carol 1 Male; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, LBAP[CON] 3 19/11/2004 and Richardson;David Valley Breeding Status: P (Goosander / Hwyaden 18/03/2015 Richardson; Mr H R A D1297/020/01 Ddanheddog) Cook Mergus merganser SH9178 2 records, between Louise Jones;Elvet 3; 1+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, LBAP[CON] 3 12/11/2005 and Jones; Ray Teesdale (Goosander / Hwyaden 07/12/2008 D1297/002/01 Ddanheddog) Mergus serrator SH905788 05/01/2013 Clarkson, G 2 Llanddulas (offshore) D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, WBA, 1 LBAP[CON] (Red-breasted Merganser / Hwyaden Frongoch) Mergus serrator SH9078 31 records, between Kevin Smith; Steven 15; 1; 3 Male; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir2.2, WBA, 3 27/01/2004 and Davies; Carol Female; 1 Male; 2; 5; LBAP[CON] (Red-breasted Merganser / 29/12/2015 Richardson;David 3; 1 Female; 6; 12; 20; D0062/001/01, Hwyaden Frongoch) Richardson; Norman 14; 35 D1297/012/01, Hallas; Megan Bagguley;Roger D1297/020/01 Bagguley; Neil Hughes; Robin Sandham; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Weldrick, J; Bourne, A; Clarkson, G; Coun... Mergus serrator SH9178 7 records, between Julie Rogers; Ray 1+; 4; 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, WBA, 3 13/03/2008 and Teesdale; Mr J Davies; BirdTrack LBAP[CON] (Red-breasted Merganser / 07/11/2015 Mr G Jones D1297/002/01, Hwyaden Frongoch) D1297/005/01, D1297/020/01 Mergus serrator SH8978 2 records, between Davies, S; Wheeler, M 1 Llanddulas, W D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, WBA, 1 23/02/2013 and J LBAP[CON] (Red-breasted Merganser / 07/12/2013- PUBLIC VERSION - Hwyaden Frongoch) Mergus serrator SH9079 10 records, between Kevin Smith; Hilary 1; 13; 3 Female; 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, WBA, 3 23/12/2005 and Nash; Carol Male; 2; 20; 1 Female; LBAP[CON] (Red-breasted Merganser / 04/03/2011 Richardson;David 1 Male D0062/003/01 Hwyaden Frongoch) Richardson; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley Milvus milvus SH87 26/08/2013 Groom, J D 2 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/012/01 BDir1, CITES, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, WCA9, (Red Kite / Barcud) LBAP[CON, GWY]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 21 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Morus bassanus SH9078 5 records, between Kevin Smith; Norman 2; 2 Juvenile; 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, UKBA, WBA, 3 06/10/2004 and Hallas; Robin LBAP[CON, GWY] (Gannet / Hugan) 12/07/2015 Sandham; Mr J N D0062/003/01, Williams D1297/020/01 Morus bassanus SH9178 8 records, between Susan Morris; Ray 2 Adult; 4; 1+; 40; 6; 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, UKBA, WBA, 3 23/09/2006 and Teesdale; John Bishop BirdTrack fishing just offshore; LBAP[CON, GWY] (Gannet / Hugan) 07/11/2015 Murray; Dr T Giles; Mr BirdTrack fishing offshore D1297/002/01, G Jones D1297/005/01, D1297/020/01 Morus bassanus SH9079 3 records, between Neil Hughes; Robin 2; 40+; 1 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, UKBA, WBA, 3 23/09/2006 and Sandham; Carol LBAP[CON, GWY] (Gannet / Hugan) 11/10/2011 Richardson, David D0062/003/01 Richardson Motacilla alba SH9178 15/01/2015 Mr T.J. Revill Llanddulas Coastal D1297/020/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 Path (Pied Wagtail / Siglen Wen) Motacilla cinerea SH912778 05/10/2005 M Lyons 1 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, RD2(UK), 3 UKBR, LBAP[CON] (Grey Wagtail / Siglen Lwyd) Motacilla cinerea SH9078 14 records, between Susan Morris; Steve 3; 1; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 23/09/2006 and Collins; Carol Breeding Status: P; Female nest UKBR, LBAP[CON] (Grey Wagtail / Siglen Lwyd) 15/12/2015 Richardson;David building amongst tangle of D0062/003/01, Richardson; Jim exposed tree roots just below D1297/012/01, Hulse, Val Hulse; bridge over river. BTO Breeding Kevin Smith; Carol Status: B D1297/020/01 Richardson, David Richardson; Bourne, A; Mr W R Myerscough; Mr J N Williams Motacilla cinerea SH9077 20 records, between Edward Lyons; Carol 2; 1; 1 Female; 1 Male; Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 21/03/2005 and Richardson;David 4 Valley Breeding Status: P; BTO Breeding UKBR, LBAP[CON] (Grey Wagtail / Siglen Lwyd) 28/04/2015 Richardson; Susan Status: H D0062/003/01, Morris; Carol D1297/020/01 Richardson, David Richardson; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Mr H R A Cook Motacilla cinerea SH9178 4 records, between Susan Morris; John 1; 4 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack: D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 04/11/2006 and Bishop Murray; Mr G UKBR, LBAP[CON] (Grey Wagtail / Siglen Lwyd) 07/11/2015 Jones; Dr T Giles D1297/005/01, D1297/020/01 Motacilla flava SH9178 23/12/2005 Megan 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, Bern, S7, UKBR, 4 Bagguley;Roger WBR, LBAP[CON, (Yellow Wagtail / Siglen Bagguley DEN, FLI] Felen) Numenius arquata SH9069278658 16/08/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Numenius arquata SH9071778656 18/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) - PUBLIC VERSION - CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Numenius arquata SH9071578660 2 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 5; 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 01/11/2009 and WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) 02/11/2009 CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Numenius arquata SH9072278660 12/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 22 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Numenius arquata SH9078 20 records, between Kevin Smith; Carol 3; 11; 2; 1; 20; 40+; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 06/10/2004 and Richardson;David 20+; 5+; 5 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) 29/12/2015 Richardson; Jim D0062/003/01, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, Hulse;Val Hulse; D1297/012/01, SNP] Megan Bagguley;Roger D1297/020/01 Bagguley; Neil Hughes; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Malcolm Down; Davies, S; Halsey, ... Numenius arquata SH9178 25 records, between Megan 10; 150; 127; 78; 1; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger 16; 88; 5; 20+; 75+; BirdTrack WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) 07/11/2015 Bagguley; Edward 1+; 60; 25 D1297/005/01, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, Lyons; Susan Morris; D1297/002/01, SNP] M Lyons; Ray Teesdale; Morris, G E; D1297/012/01, Teesdale, R; Mr J Davies; Mr T.J. Revill; D1297/020/01 Mr G Jones; Mr R Teesdale Numenius arquata SH9177 02/03/2006 Edward Lyons 78+ Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 Valley, E WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Numenius arquata SH8978 4 records, between Davies, S; Jim Hulse, 5; 3; 1; 33 Llanddulas, W Comments Withheld D1297/012/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 1 28/04/2007 and Val Hulse; Susan WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) 05/09/2015 Morris; Mr E M Ab D0062/003/01, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, Owain & Ms H Kidd D0062/001/01, SNP] D1297/020/01 Numenius arquata SH9079 3 records, between Kevin Smith; Carol 4; 50+ Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 17/02/2008 and Richardson;David WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Curlew / Gylfinir) 04/03/2011 Richardson; Megan D0062/003/01 CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, Bagguley, Roger SNP] Bagguley Numenius phaeopus SH97 23/11/2006 Edward Lyons 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 4 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON, (Whimbrel / Coegylfinir) GWY] Oceanodroma leucorhoa SH9078 17/09/2010 Per Anon Birdguides 15 Llanddulas Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 1 WBA, WCA1.1, (Leach's Petrel / Pedryn LBAP[CON] Cynffon-Fforchog) Oenanthe oenanthe SH9078 6 records, between Neil Hughes; Steve 1; 2 Female; 1 Male; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, WBA, 3 23/09/2006 and Collins; Megan Female LBAP[CON] (Wheatear / Tinwen y Garn) 27/09/2011 Bagguley;Roger D0062/003/01 Bagguley; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse Oenanthe oenanthe SH9178 5 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 4; 1; 1 Female; 2; 6 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, Bern, WBA, 3 02/05/2007 and Susan Morris; LBAP[CON] (Wheatear / Tinwen y Garn) 08/10/2013 Teesdale, R; Ray D0062/001/01, - PUBLICTeesdale VERSION - D1297/012/01, D1297/002/01 Oenanthe oenanthe SH8978 28/04/2007 Susan Morris 1 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON] (Wheatear / Tinwen y Garn) Parus major SH9078 5 records, between Susan Morris; Mr W R 2+; 2; 1+ Juvenile; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 23/09/2006 and Myerscough (Great Tit / Titw Mawr) 08/03/2015 D1297/020/01

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 23 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Parus major SH9077 4 records, between Carol 2; 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 13/01/2006 and Richardson;David Valley (Great Tit / Titw Mawr) 15/05/2010 Richardson; Susan D0062/003/01 Morris; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Parus major SH9177 2 records, between Carol 8; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 14/01/2007 and Richardson;David Valley, E (Great Tit / Titw Mawr) 24/04/2010 Richardson; Carol D0062/003/01 Richardson, David Richardson Parus major SH8977 9 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+; 1; 2; 3 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 30/12/2010 and Marian (Great Tit / Titw Mawr) 24/12/2011 Passer domesticus SH9071478659 08/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 40+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 S7, UKBR, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, FLI, (House Sparrow / Aderyn y GWY] To) Passer domesticus SH9113278070 20/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 6+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 S7, UKBR, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, FLI, (House Sparrow / Aderyn y GWY] To) Passer domesticus SH9078 18 records, between Susan Morris; Carol 5+; 6+; 8; 1; 3 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; Breeding D0062/001/01, S7, UKBR, WBA, 3 04/11/2006 and Richardson;David Juvenile; 3; 20+; 4+; status: Singing male; BTO LBAP[CON, FLI, (House Sparrow / Aderyn y 25/04/2015 Richardson; Jim 10+; 20; 5; 1+ Breeding Status: N D0062/003/01, GWY] To) Hulse;Val Hulse; Jim D1297/012/01, Hulse, Val Hulse; Davies, S; Halsey, R; D1297/020/01 Halsey, S A; Mr W R Myerscough Passer domesticus SH9077 31/05/2009 Carol 8 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 S7, UKBR, WBA, 3 Richardson;David Valley LBAP[CON, FLI, (House Sparrow / Aderyn y Richardson GWY] To) Passer domesticus SH9178 9 records, between Megan 1 Female; 10; 1+; 8 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, S7, UKBR, WBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger LBAP[CON, FLI, (House Sparrow / Aderyn y 21/06/2015 Bagguley; Ray D1297/002/01, GWY] To) Teesdale; Teesdale, D1297/012/01, R; Dr T Giles; Mr R Teesdale; Mr T.J. D1297/020/01 Revill Passer domesticus SH9177 2 records, between Edward Lyons 3; 4 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 S7, UKBR, WBA, 3 03/05/2007 and Valley, E LBAP[CON, FLI, (House Sparrow / Aderyn y 02/01/2009 GWY] To) Passer domesticus SH8977 9 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+; 5 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 S7, UKBR, WBA, 1 30/12/2010 and Marian LBAP[CON, FLI, (House Sparrow / Aderyn y 24/12/2011 GWY] To) Periparus ater SH9078 2 records, between Susan Morris 2; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 23/09/2006 and LBAP[CON] (Coal Tit / Titw Penddu) 04/11/2006 Periparus ater SH9177 24/12/2008- PUBLICEdward Lyons 6 VERSIONLlanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld - D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 Valley, E LBAP[CON] (Coal Tit / Titw Penddu) Periparus ater SH8977 4 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+ Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, WBA, 1 14/10/2011 and Marian LBAP[CON] (Coal Tit / Titw Penddu) 06/11/2011 Phalacrocorax aristotelis SH9078 6 records, between Kevin Smith; Megan 2; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 14/10/2004 and Bagguley, Roger UKBR, LBAP[CON, (Shag / Mulfran Werdd) 29/12/2015 Bagguley; Clarkson, D0062/003/01, GWY] G; Mr J N Williams D1297/012/01, D1297/020/01

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 24 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Phalacrocorax aristotelis SH9178 2 records, between Susan Morris; Mr G 1; 14 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 23/09/2006 and Jones UKBR, LBAP[CON, (Shag / Mulfran Werdd) 07/11/2015 D1297/020/01 GWY] Phalacrocorax aristotelis SH8978 26/02/2015 Mr D Sulway 1 LLanddulas flooded D1297/020/01 Bern, RD2(UK), 1 quarry UKBR, LBAP[CON, (Shag / Mulfran Werdd) GWY] Phalacrocorax carbo SH9069278658 2 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 2; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 12/08/2009 and GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) 16/08/2009 Phalacrocorax carbo SH9071678659 3 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Juvenile; 2; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 23/10/2009 and GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) 25/10/2009 Phalacrocorax carbo SH9071578660 3 records, between Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 4; 2; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 01/11/2009 and GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) 05/12/2009 Phalacrocorax carbo SH9072278660 12/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 5 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Phalacrocorax carbo SH9071878664 2 records, both on Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Juvenile; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 25/11/2009 GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Phalacrocorax carbo SH9113278070 20/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 3 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Phalacrocorax carbo SH908787 06/09/2012 Martyn Harris 1 Llanddulas Beach, field record D0969/001/04 WBA, LBAP[CON, 1 Denbighshire GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Phalacrocorax carbo SH906788 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris 1 Llandulas Beach, field record D0969/001/04 WBA, LBAP[CON, 1 Denbighshire GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Phalacrocorax carbo SH905788 05/01/2013 Clarkson, G 30 Llanddulas (offshore) D1297/012/01 WBA, LBAP[CON, 1 GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Phalacrocorax carbo SH911788 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris 12 Beach near the river field record D0969/001/04 WBA, LBAP[CON, 1 outlet at Llandulas, GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Denbighshire Phalacrocorax carbo SH897786 06/09/2012 Martyn Harris 8 Old jetty between On the old jetty. field record D0969/001/04 WBA, LBAP[CON, 1 Llanddulas and OLd GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) Colwyn, Denbighshire Phalacrocorax carbo SH9078 52 records, between Carol 15+; 5; 2; 6; 1; 8; 3; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 27/01/2004 and Richardson;David 40+; 4+; 10; 1 GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) 29/12/2015 Richardson; Kevin Juvenile; 4; 9; 33+; 15; D0062/003/01, Smith; Megan c20 D1297/012/01, Bagguley;Roger Bagguley; Neil D1297/020/01 Hughes; Jim Hulse;Val Hulse; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Robin Sandham; Davies, S; Halsey,... Phalacrocorax carbo SH9178 24 records, between Megan 6; 20; 1; 1+; 3; 2 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger flying along shoreline; Birdtrack:; GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) 16/12/2015- PUBLICBagguley; Carol VERSIONBirdTrack - D1297/002/01, Richardson;David D1297/005/01, Richardson; Susan Morris; Ray Teesdale; D1297/012/01, John Bishop Murray; Teesdale, R; Mr R D1297/020/01 Teesdale; Dr T Giles; Mr J Davies; Mr J.F. Jones; Mr G Jones

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 25 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Phalacrocorax carbo SH8978 6 records, between Carol 4; 25; 86; 70+; 60 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 30/12/2007 and Richardson;David GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) 07/12/2013 Richardson; Robin D0062/003/01, Sandham; Jim Hulse, D1297/005/01, Val Hulse; John Bishop Murray; D1297/012/01 Wheeler, M J Phalacrocorax carbo SH9079 6 records, between Carol 1; 2+; 6; 30; 11; 5 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, WBA, LBAP[CON, 3 14/01/2007 and Richardson;David GWY] (Cormorant / Mulfran) 11/10/2011 Richardson; Susan D0062/003/01 Morris; Kevin Smith; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Phoenicurus ochruros SH9078 15/03/2015 Anon Llanddulas #bg#1076754#bg# D1297/020/01 Bern, UKBR, WBA, 4 WCA1.1, LBAP[GWY] (Black Redstart / Tingoch Du) Phoenicurus phoenicurus SH8977 30/07/2011 Jonathan Groom 1 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 1 Marian LBAP[CON, GWY, (Redstart / Tingoch) SNP] Phylloscopus collybita SH9078 5 records, between Norman Hallas; Susan 1; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 17/03/2004 and Morris; Steve Collins; Breeding Status: S (Chiffchaff / Siff-Siaff) 25/04/2015 Mr W R Myerscough D1297/020/01 Phylloscopus collybita SH9077 6 records, between Edward Lyons; Susan 1; 2; 7 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 26/03/2005 and Morris; Carol Valley Breeding Status: T (Chiffchaff / Siff-Siaff) 28/04/2015 Richardson, David D0062/003/01, Richardson; Mr H R A D1297/020/01 Cook Phylloscopus collybita SH9178 5 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 1; 1+; 2; 3 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack in D0062/003/01, LBAP[CON] 3 18/07/2009 and Ray Teesdale; John Beach caravan park; Birdtrack: (Chiffchaff / Siff-Siaff) 21/03/2015 Bishop Murray; Mr J D1297/002/01, Davies D1297/005/01, D1297/020/01 Phylloscopus collybita SH9177 24/04/2010 Carol Richardson, 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 LBAP[CON] 3 David Richardson Valley, E (Chiffchaff / Siff-Siaff) Phylloscopus collybita SH8978 3 records, between Mr J.P. Hughes; Mr W 1 Llanddulas quarry BTO Breeding Status: T; BTO D1297/020/01 LBAP[CON] 1 22/03/2015 and R Myerscough Breeding Status: S (Chiffchaff / Siff-Siaff) 27/06/2015 Phylloscopus trochilus SH9077 5 records, between Carol Richardson, 2; 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, UKBA, WBR, 3 19/04/2005 and David Richardson; Valley LBAP[CON] (Willow Warbler / Telor yr 27/04/2011 Edward Lyons; Carol D0062/001/01 Helyg) Richardson;David Richardson; Susan Morris Picus viridis SH912778 2 records, between M Lyons 1 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 22/06/2006 and LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Green Woodpecker / 05/10/2007 GWY, SNP] Cnocell Werdd) Picus viridis SH9177 3 records, between M Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 02/07/2004 and Valley, E LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Green Woodpecker / 13/08/2008 GWY, SNP] Cnocell Werdd) - PUBLIC VERSION - Plectrophenax nivalis SH906786 (Estimated February 2000 approx Anon Llandulas Flock D0285/139/01 Bern, WBA, WCA1.1, 1 LBAP[CON] (Snow Bunting / Bras yr Eira) (Centroid of Site)) Plectrophenax nivalis SH9078 28/10/2015 Anon 1 Llanddulas #bg#1130844#bg# D1297/020/01 Bern, WBA, WCA1.1, 1 LBAP[CON] (Snow Bunting / Bras yr Eira) Podiceps auritus SH9078 23/02/2013 Anon - Birdguides 1 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBR, 4 WBA, WCA1.1 (Slavonian Grebe / Gwyach Gorniog)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 26 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Podiceps auritus SH9178 20/04/2006 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBR, 3 WBA, WCA1.1 (Slavonian Grebe / Gwyach Gorniog) Podiceps cristatus SH904788 15/02/2013 Hughes, R D 20 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 LBAP[CON] 1 (Great Crested Grebe / Gwyach Fawr Gopog) Podiceps cristatus SH9078 35 records, between Carol 2; 1; 11; 7+; 10; 4; 5; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 27/01/2004 and Richardson;David 1+; 124; 3; 1 Male; 20; (Great Crested Grebe / 29/12/2015 Richardson; Norman 28; 30+; 190; 80+; D0062/003/01, Gwyach Fawr Gopog) Hallas; Kevin Smith; 20+; 16; 60; 9 D1297/002/01, Megan Bagguley;Roger D1297/012/01, Bagguley; Neil Hughes; Steve Collins; D1297/020/01 Marc Hughes; Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; Robin Sandham; Clarkson, G; Halsey, S A; Co... Podiceps cristatus SH9178 18 records, between Julie Rogers; Susan 1+; 5; 15 +; 9; 49; 4; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; BirdTrack D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 13/03/2004 and Morris; Bob Edwards; 25; 2; 35+; 3 just beyond tideline; Birdtrack:; (Great Crested Grebe / 07/11/2015 Teesdale, R; Ray BirdTrack D1297/012/01, Gwyach Fawr Gopog) Teesdale; John Bishop D1297/002/01, Murray; Mr J Davies; Dr T Giles; Mr G D1297/005/01, Jones; Mr W R Myerscough D1297/020/01 Podiceps cristatus SH8978 2 records, between Wheeler, M J; 1 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 LBAP[CON] 1 16/01/2013 and Weldrick, J (Great Crested Grebe / 07/12/2013 Gwyach Fawr Gopog) Podiceps cristatus SH9079 7 records, between Kevin Smith; Robin 10; 250; 3; 4; 20; 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, LBAP[CON] 3 12/04/2005 and Sandham; Megan (Great Crested Grebe / 04/03/2011 Bagguley, Roger D0062/001/01 Gwyach Fawr Gopog) Bagguley; Carol Richardson;David Richardson Poecile palustris SH9177 01/01/2007 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 4 Valley, E S7, UKBR, WBR, (Marsh Tit / Titw'r Wern) LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, GWY] Prunella modularis SH912778 2 records, between Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 19/12/2006 and S7, UKBA, (Dunnock / Llwyd y Gwrych) 12/01/2008 LBAP[CON] Prunella modularis SH9078 4 records, between Edward Lyons; Jim 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; Breeding D0062/001/01, BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 14/04/2007 and Hulse, Val Hulse; status: Singing male S7, UKBA, (Dunnock / Llwyd y Gwrych) 02/03/2013 Halsey, S A; Bourne, A D0062/003/01, LBAP[CON] D1297/012/01 Prunella modularis SH9077 7 records, between Carol Richardson, 1; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/003/01, BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 14/04/2007 and David Richardson; Valley Breeding Status: S S7, UKBA, (Dunnock / Llwyd y Gwrych) 18/03/2015 Edward Lyons; Susan D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] - PUBLICMorris; Mr H R A Cook VERSION - D1297/020/01 Prunella modularis SH9178 9 records, between Susan Morris; Megan 1; 2; 1+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack: D0062/001/01, BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger S7, UKBA, (Dunnock / Llwyd y Gwrych) 21/06/2015 Bagguley; Ray D1297/005/01, LBAP[CON] Teesdale; Teesdale, D1297/002/01, R; Dr T Giles; Mr T.J. Revill D1297/012/01, D1297/020/01 Prunella modularis SH9177 12 records, between Edward Lyons; M 2; 1; 3 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 24/01/2006 and Lyons Valley, E S7, UKBA, (Dunnock / Llwyd y Gwrych) 07/03/2009 LBAP[CON]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 27 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Prunella modularis SH8978 30/12/2007 Carol 1 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 Richardson;David S7, UKBA, (Dunnock / Llwyd y Gwrych) Richardson LBAP[CON] Prunella modularis SH8977 11 records, between Jonathan Groom; 1+; 2; 3 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack:; Comments D1297/005/01, BAP, Bern, RD2(UK), 1 01/04/2007 and Edward Lyons Marian Withheld S7, UKBA, (Dunnock / Llwyd y Gwrych) 24/12/2011 D0062/001/01 LBAP[CON] Puffinus puffinus SH9178 17/09/2011 Ray Teesdale 1+ Llanddulas, E BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 1 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Manx Shearwater / Aderyn Drycin Manaw) Puffinus puffinus SH9079 22/05/2011 Robin Sandham 5 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Manx Shearwater / Aderyn Drycin Manaw) Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax SH87 20/09/2013 Groom, J D 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/012/01 BDir1, Bern, S7, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, WCA9, (Chough / Brân Goesgoch) LBAP[ANG, CON, GWY, SNP] Pyrrhula pyrrhula SH905781 August 2007 Christina Worley Ty Gwyn, Minffordd Garden Wildlife Record. Grid D1117/001/01 BAP, S7, UKBA, WBR, 4 Road, Llanddulas reference calculated from post LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Bullfinch / Coch y Berllan) code LL22 8EW, using Streetmap. GWY] Pyrrhula pyrrhula SH9078 02/10/2008 Megan 1 Male Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, S7, UKBA, WBR, 3 Bagguley;Roger LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Bullfinch / Coch y Berllan) Bagguley GWY] Pyrrhula pyrrhula SH9077 2 records, between Robin Sandham; 3; 1 Female Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BAP, S7, UKBA, WBR, 3 18/12/2005 and Edward Lyons Valley LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Bullfinch / Coch y Berllan) 24/06/2011 D0062/001/01 GWY] Pyrrhula pyrrhula SH9178 13/03/2008 Julie Rogers 4 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, S7, UKBA, WBR, 3 LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Bullfinch / Coch y Berllan) GWY] Pyrrhula pyrrhula SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 2; 1; 3 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 BAP, S7, UKBA, WBR, 1 30/12/2010 and Marian LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Bullfinch / Coch y Berllan) 27/11/2011 GWY] Recurvirostra avosetta SH97 (Estimated 1996 Anon 2 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0285/138/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 1 WBA, WCA1.1 (Avocet / Cambig) (Centroid of Site)) Regulus ignicapilla SH97 2 records, between Mr R D Hughes 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/020/01 Bern, WBA, WCA1.1, 4 24/10/2015 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Firecrest / Dryw 26/10/2015 Penfflamgoch) Regulus ignicapilla SH97 2 records, between Anon 1; 3 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1297/020/01 Bern, WBA, WCA1.1, 4 23/10/2015 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Firecrest / Dryw 30/10/2015 Penfflamgoch) Regulus regulus SH912778 12 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1; 2 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld; field record D0062/001/01, Bern, WBA, 3 26/09/2004 and Lyons; M. Lyons LBAP[CON] (Goldcrest / Dryw Eurben) 05/03/2008 D0969/001/04 Regulus regulus SH9078 6 records, between Susan Morris; Mr W R 1+; 1; 2 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, Bern, WBA, 3 23/09/2006 and Myerscough Breeding Status: S LBAP[CON] (Goldcrest / Dryw Eurben) 13/08/2015 D1297/020/01 Regulus regulus SH9077 8 records, between Carol 1; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, WBA, 3 09/02/2005- andPUBLICRichardson;David VERSIONValley - LBAP[CON] (Goldcrest / Dryw Eurben) 15/05/2010 Richardson; Edward D0062/003/01 Lyons; Susan Morris; Carol Richardson, David Richardson Regulus regulus SH9178 21/03/2015 Mr J Davies Llanddulas D1297/020/01 Bern, WBA, 1 LBAP[CON] (Goldcrest / Dryw Eurben) Regulus regulus SH9177 10 records, between Edward Lyons; Carol 1; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 26/09/2004 and Richardson;David Valley, E LBAP[CON] (Goldcrest / Dryw Eurben) 14/01/2009 Richardson; M Lyons Regulus regulus SH8978 30/12/2007 Carol 1 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, WBA, 3 Richardson;David LBAP[CON] (Goldcrest / Dryw Eurben) Richardson Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 28 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Regulus regulus SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+; 3; 1 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, WBA, 1 14/10/2011 and Marian LBAP[CON] (Goldcrest / Dryw Eurben) 27/11/2011 Saxicola rubicola SH9078 6 records, between Megan 2 Female; 1 Male; 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, RD2(UK), 3 10/03/2007 and Bagguley;Roger Female; 1 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Stonechat / Clochdar y 01/03/2008 Bagguley; Carol DEN, FLI, GWY] Cerrig) Richardson;David Richardson Saxicola rubicola SH9178 4 records, between Edward Lyons; Ray 1 Female; 1 Male; 1+ Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, Bern, RD2(UK), 3 15/11/2007 and Teesdale LBAP[ANG, CON, (Stonechat / Clochdar y 03/01/2009 D1297/002/01 DEN, FLI, GWY] Cerrig) Scolopax rusticola SH903774 (Estimated 2005 approx BASC Recorder Shoot Size Range: 0-3km D0132/001/02 BDir2.1, UKBR, WBA, 1 (160021323-3) LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Woodcock / Cyffylog) (Centroid of Site)) GWY] Scolopax rusticola SH9178 27/11/2010 Carol Richardson, 1 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir2.1, UKBR, WBA, 3 David Richardson LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Woodcock / Cyffylog) GWY] Scolopax rusticola SH8977 18/12/2010 Stuart K Thomas 1 Llanddulas, Mynydd Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir2.1, UKBR, WBA, 3 Marian LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Woodcock / Cyffylog) GWY] Sitta europaea SH905781 03/09/2007 Christina Worley Ty Gwyn, Minffordd Garden Wildlife Record. Grid D1117/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 4 Road, Llanddulas reference calculated from post (Nuthatch / Delor y Cnau) code LL22 8EW, using Streetmap. Sitta europaea SH908783 25/08/2012 Martyn Harris 1 Llandulas, field record D0969/001/04 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 Denbighshire (Nuthatch / Delor y Cnau) Sitta europaea SH912778 23 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1; 2; 1 Juvenile Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 16/08/2005 and Lyons (Nuthatch / Delor y Cnau) 22/11/2007 Sitta europaea SH9077 5 records, between Edward Lyons; Susan 1; 2 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 28/05/2005 and Morris; Mr H R A Cook Valley Breeding Status: N (Nuthatch / Delor y Cnau) 18/03/2015 D1297/020/01 Sitta europaea SH9177 7 records, between Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 3 07/07/2004 and Valley, E (Nuthatch / Delor y Cnau) 06/12/2008 Sitta europaea SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 1; 1+; 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd Birdtrack:; BirdTrack D1297/005/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 30/12/2010 and Marian (Nuthatch / Delor y Cnau) 27/11/2011 Spinus spinus SH9078 15/12/2015 Mr W R Myerscough 1+ Llanddulas D1297/020/01 Bern, LBAP[CON] 1 (Siskin / Pila Gwyrdd) Sterna hirundo SH9178 24/09/2011 John Bishop Murray 4 Llanddulas, E BirdTrack D1297/005/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 4 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Common Tern / Môr- CON, GWY] Wennol Gyffredin) Sterna paradisaea SH9178 17/05/2009 John Bishop Murray 4 Llanddulas, E D1297/002/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 4 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Arctic Tern / Môr-Wennol y CON, GWY] Gogledd) Sterna sandvicensis SH9069278658 12/08/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 4+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 3 WBA, LBAP[ANG, (Sandwich Tern / Môr- - PUBLIC VERSION - CON, GWY] Wennol Bigddu) Sterna sandvicensis SH9078 7 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 2; 1; 80; 120+; 3; 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 3 16/09/2006 and Megan Bagguley, WBA, LBAP[ANG, (Sandwich Tern / Môr- 27/09/2011 Roger Bagguley; Carol D0062/001/01 CON, GWY] Wennol Bigddu) Richardson;David Richardson; Susan Morris; Megan Bagguley;Roger Bagguley

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 29 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Sterna sandvicensis SH9178 7 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse; 4; 6; 1+; 23 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/003/01, BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 3 21/08/2008 and Edward Lyons; WBA, LBAP[ANG, (Sandwich Tern / Môr- 21/06/2015 Teesdale, R; Ray D0062/001/01, CON, GWY] Wennol Bigddu) Teesdale; Dr T Giles D1297/012/01, D1297/002/01, D1297/020/01 Sterna sandvicensis SH8978 2 records, between Jim Hulse, Val Hulse 2 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 BDir1, Bern, UKBA, 3 01/10/2011 and WBA, LBAP[ANG, (Sandwich Tern / Môr- 15/10/2011 CON, GWY] Wennol Bigddu) Strix aluco SH912778 09/10/2005 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, CITES, UKBA, 3 LBAP[CON] (Tawny Owl / Tylluan Frech) Strix aluco SH9077 08/02/2007 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 Bern, CITES, UKBA, 3 Valley LBAP[CON] (Tawny Owl / Tylluan Frech) Strix aluco SH9177 27 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; Calling. field D0062/001/01, Bern, CITES, UKBA, 3 03/07/2004 and Lyons; E. Lyons Valley, E record; On sea defence rocks. field LBAP[CON] (Tawny Owl / Tylluan Frech) 15/02/2008 record D0969/001/04 Strix aluco SH8977 22/11/2011 Jonathan Groom 1 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack Calling - heard from D1297/005/01 Bern, CITES, UKBA, 1 Marian garden (18 Cynfran Road) LBAP[CON] (Tawny Owl / Tylluan Frech) Sturnus vulgaris SH9071778656 18/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 4 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Starling / Drudwen) WBR, LBAP[CON, FLI, GWY] Sturnus vulgaris SH9078 4 records, between Megan 100; 70 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 02/10/2008 and Bagguley;Roger RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Starling / Drudwen) 08/03/2015 Bagguley; Megan D0062/003/01, WBR, LBAP[CON, FLI, Bagguley, Roger D1297/012/01, GWY] Bagguley; Council, R P; Mr W R D1297/020/01 Myerscough Sturnus vulgaris SH9077 31/05/2009 Carol 15+ Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 Richardson;David Valley RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Starling / Drudwen) Richardson WBR, LBAP[CON, FLI, GWY] Sturnus vulgaris SH9178 5 records, between Megan 30; 50 Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Starling / Drudwen) 23/02/2015 Bagguley; Ray D1297/002/01, WBR, LBAP[CON, FLI, Teesdale; Mr R D1297/020/01 GWY] Teesdale; Mr T.J. Revill Sturnus vulgaris SH8977 5 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+ Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 1 30/12/2010 and Marian RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Starling / Drudwen) 24/12/2011 WBR, LBAP[CON, FLI, GWY] Sylvia atricapilla SH912778 7 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1 Juvenile; 1 Male; 1 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 LBAP[CON] 3 27/04/2005 and Lyons Female (Blackcap / Telor Penddu) 29/12/2006 Sylvia atricapilla SH9078 2 records, between Mr W R Myerscough 1 Llanddulas BTO Breeding Status: S D1297/020/01 LBAP[CON] 1 25/04/2015 and (Blackcap / Telor Penddu) 13/08/2015- PUBLIC VERSION - Sylvia atricapilla SH9077 9 records, between Edward Lyons; Susan 2; 1 Male; 7; 3 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 15/05/2005 and Morris; Carol Valley Breeding Status: T (Blackcap / Telor Penddu) 28/04/2015 Richardson;David D0062/003/01, Richardson; Carol D1297/020/01 Richardson, David Richardson; Mr H R A Cook Sylvia atricapilla SH9177 7 records, between Edward Lyons 1 Male; 1; 2 Male; 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 LBAP[CON] 3 22/01/2005 and Female Valley, E (Blackcap / Telor Penddu) 08/03/2007 Sylvia atricapilla SH8978 14/06/2015 Mr W R Myerscough 1 Llanddulas, beach W BTO Breeding Status: S D1297/020/01 LBAP[CON] 1 (Blackcap / Telor Penddu)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 30 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Sylvia atricapilla SH8977 26/08/2013 Groom, J D 2 Llysfaen & Mynydd Breeding status: Pair D1297/012/01 LBAP[CON] 1 Marian LNR (Blackcap / Telor Penddu) Sylvia borin SH9077 5 records, between Edward Lyons; Carol 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, WBA, LBAP[CON] 3 12/04/2005 and Richardson;David Valley (Garden Warbler / Telor yr 14/05/2011 Richardson; Carol D0062/003/01 Ardd) Richardson, David Richardson Sylvia communis SH900784 14/06/2015 Mr E M Ab Owain & 1 LLanddulas Beach D1297/020/01 WBA, LBAP[CON] 1 Ms H Kidd (Whitethroat / Llwydfron) Sylvia communis SH8977 01/08/2011 Jonathan Groom 1 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 WBA, LBAP[CON] 1 Marian (Whitethroat / Llwydfron) Sylvia curruca SH8978 28/04/2007 Susan Morris 2 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI] 3 (Lesser Whitethroat / Llwydfron Fach) Tadorna tadorna SH9078 07/02/2015 Mr J N Williams Llandulas D1297/020/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 1 LBAP[CON, GWY] (Shelduck / Hwyaden yr Eithin) Tadorna tadorna SH9178 2 records, between Ray Teesdale 1+ Llanddulas, E D1297/002/01 Bern, UKBA, WBA, 1 03/01/2009 and LBAP[CON, GWY] (Shelduck / Hwyaden yr 28/11/2009 Eithin) Tringa totanus SH9071778656 18/10/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Redshank / Pibydd GWY] Coesgoch) Tringa totanus SH9071578660 01/11/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Redshank / Pibydd GWY] Coesgoch) Tringa totanus SH9072278660 12/09/2009 Jim Hulse;Val Hulse 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Redshank / Pibydd GWY] Coesgoch) Tringa totanus SH9078 17 records, between Carol 144; 3; 15+; 150+; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 13/03/2004 and Richardson;David 120+; 100; 30+; 30; 6; LBAP[ANG, CON, (Redshank / Pibydd 29/12/2015 Richardson; Kevin 5; 1+; 1; 50+; 10; 4 D0062/003/01, GWY] Coesgoch) Smith; Megan D1297/012/01, Bagguley;Roger Bagguley; Neil D1297/020/01 Hughes; Steve Collins; Megan Bagguley, Roger Bagguley; Malcolm Down; Bourne, A; Davies, S; Mr J N Williams Tringa totanus SH9178 15 records, between Megan 200; 50; 5; 1+; 32+; Llanddulas, E Comments Withheld; Birdtrack:; D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 08/12/2005 and Bagguley;Roger 30; 26; 60 BirdTrack LBAP[ANG, CON, (Redshank / Pibydd 23/02/2015- PUBLICBagguley; Susan VERSION - D1297/002/01, GWY] Coesgoch) Morris; Ray Teesdale; D1297/012/01, Teesdale, R; Mr R Teesdale D1297/005/01, D1297/020/01 Tringa totanus SH8978 23/02/2013 Davies, S 2 Llanddulas, W D1297/012/01 BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 1 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Redshank / Pibydd GWY] Coesgoch) Tringa totanus SH9079 3 records, between Kevin Smith; Megan 2; 5; 4 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, BDir2.2, UKBA, WBA, 3 23/12/2005 and Bagguley, Roger LBAP[ANG, CON, (Redshank / Pibydd 04/03/2011 Bagguley D0062/003/01 GWY] Coesgoch) Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 31 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Turdus iliacus SH9078 08/03/2015 Mr W R Myerscough 15+ Llanddulas Singing communally. D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] (Redwing / Coch Dan Adain) Turdus iliacus SH9077 23/12/2004 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 3 Valley WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] (Redwing / Coch Dan Adain) Turdus iliacus SH9178 02/01/2011 Ray Teesdale 1+ Llanddulas, E BirdTrack D1297/005/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 1 WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] (Redwing / Coch Dan Adain) Turdus iliacus SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 1; 10; 4; 1+; 7 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 1 30/12/2010 and Marian WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] (Redwing / Coch Dan Adain) 24/12/2011 Turdus philomelos SH912778 2 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1; 3 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 24/10/2006 and Lyons RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Song Thrush / Bronfraith) 09/04/2008 WBA, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Turdus philomelos SH9078 3 records, between Susan Morris; Mr W R 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 23/09/2006 and Myerscough Breeding Status: S RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Song Thrush / Bronfraith) 25/04/2015 D1297/020/01 WBA, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Turdus philomelos SH9077 20 records, between Edward Lyons; Susan 1; 2; 3 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/001/01, BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 23/12/2004 and Morris; Carol Valley Breeding Status: S; BTO Breeding RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Song Thrush / Bronfraith) 28/04/2015 Richardson;David Status: FF D1297/020/01 WBA, LBAP[ANG, Richardson; Mr H R A CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, Cook SNP, WRE] Turdus philomelos SH9177 7 records, between Edward Lyons; M 1; 1 Juvenile Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 14/01/2007 and Lyons; Carol Valley, E RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Song Thrush / Bronfraith) 14/03/2009 Richardson;David WBA, LBAP[ANG, Richardson CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Turdus philomelos SH8978 23/02/2013 Davies, S 1 Llanddulas, W D1297/012/01 BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 1 RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Song Thrush / Bronfraith) WBA, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Turdus philomelos SH8977 4 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+ Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack; Birdtrack: D1297/005/01 BAP, BDir2.2, Bern, 1 30/12/2010 and Marian RD2(UK), S7, UKBR, (Song Thrush / Bronfraith) 27/11/2011 WBA, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Turdus pilaris SH9177 08/01/2009 Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 3 Valley, E WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] (Fieldfare / Socan Eira) Turdus pilaris SH8977 06/11/2011 Jonathan Groom 10 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 BDir2.2, UKBR, WBA, 1 Marian WCA1.1, LBAP[CON] (Fieldfare / Socan Eira) Turdus torquatus SH9078 31/10/2015 Anon Llanddulas #bg#1131991#bg# D1297/020/01 Bern, S7, UKBR, 1 WBR, LBAP[CON, (Ring Ouzel / Mwyalchen y DEN, FLI, GWY] Mynydd) Turdus viscivorus SH912778 2 records, between Edward Lyons 1 Llanddulas, garden Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 3 07/10/2005 and RD2(UK), UKBR (Mistle Thrush / Brych y 30/10/2005- PUBLIC VERSION - Coed) Turdus viscivorus SH9078 2 records, between Carol Richardson, 1 Llanddulas Comments Withheld; BTO D0062/003/01, BDir2.2, Bern, 3 17/01/2010 and David Richardson; Mr Breeding Status: A RD2(UK), UKBR (Mistle Thrush / Brych y 08/03/2015 W R Myerscough D1297/020/01 Coed) Turdus viscivorus SH9077 5 records, between Susan Morris; Carol 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 3 27/02/2004 and Richardson;David Valley RD2(UK), UKBR (Mistle Thrush / Brych y 10/01/2009 Richardson Coed)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 32 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Turdus viscivorus SH9177 14/01/2007 Carol 1 Llanddulas, Dulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 3 Richardson;David Valley, E RD2(UK), UKBR (Mistle Thrush / Brych y Richardson Coed) Turdus viscivorus SH8978 22/03/2015 Mr W R Myerscough 1 Llanddulas, beach W BTO Breeding Status: T D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 1 RD2(UK), UKBR (Mistle Thrush / Brych y Coed) Turdus viscivorus SH8977 6 records, between Jonathan Groom 1+; 1; 2 Llanddulas, Mynydd BirdTrack D1297/005/01 BDir2.2, Bern, 1 14/10/2011 and Marian RD2(UK), UKBR (Mistle Thrush / Brych y 24/12/2011 Coed) Tyto alba SH97 23/02/2013 Allan Brandon 1 Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1117/001/01 Bern, CITES, 4 RD2(UK), WBA, (Barn Owl / Tylluan Wen) WCA1.1, WCA9, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Tyto alba SH97 (Estimated 2005 approx BASC Recorder Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0132/001/02 Bern, CITES, 1 (160021323-3) RD2(UK), WBA, (Barn Owl / Tylluan Wen) (Centroid of Site)) WCA1.1, WCA9, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Tyto alba SH97 (Approximate) February 2008 Brian Iddon 1 Adult Male Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0061/004/01 Bern, CITES, 4 RD2(UK), WBA, (Barn Owl / Tylluan Wen) WCA1.1, WCA9, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Upupa epops SH9178 20/12/2013 Teesdale, R 1 Llandulas/Abergele D1297/012/01 Bern, WCA1.1 4 (Hoopoe / Copog) Uria aalge SH905786 14/03/2015 Mr A Humphreys- 1 Mobile-SH9078 D1297/020/01 UKBA, WBA, 4 Jones LBAP[CON] (Guillemot / Gwylog) Uria aalge SH905788 05/01/2013 Clarkson, G 2 Llanddulas (offshore) D1297/012/01 UKBA, WBA, 4 LBAP[CON] (Guillemot / Gwylog) Uria aalge SH902787 19/02/2013 Hughes, R D 1 Llanddulas D1297/012/01 UKBA, WBA, 4 LBAP[CON] (Guillemot / Gwylog) Uria aalge SH9078 11 records, between Kevin Smith; Carol 100+; 1; 15; 6; 2; 10; Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01, UKBA, WBA, 4 14/10/2004 and Richardson;David 18 LBAP[CON] (Guillemot / Gwylog) 29/12/2015 Richardson; Steve D0062/003/01, Collins; Robin D1297/012/01, Sandham; Council, R P; Clarkson, G; Mr J N D1297/020/01 Williams Uria aalge SH9178 07/11/2015 Mr G Jones 4+ Llanddulas D1297/020/01 UKBA, WBA, 4 LBAP[CON] (Guillemot / Gwylog) Uria aalge SH8978 15/10/2011 Jim Hulse, Val Hulse 3 Llanddulas, beach W Comments Withheld D0062/003/01 UKBA, WBA, 4 - PUBLIC VERSION - LBAP[CON] (Guillemot / Gwylog) Uria aalge SH9079 2 records, between Norman Hallas; Kevin 1; 2 Llanddulas, offshore Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 UKBA, WBA, 3 11/02/2004 and Smith LBAP[CON] (Guillemot / Gwylog) 15/01/2009 Vanellus vanellus SH9078 21/12/2009 Marc Hughes 500+ Llanddulas Comments Withheld D0062/001/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 3 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Lapwing / Cornchwiglen) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Vanellus vanellus SH9178 07/11/2015 Mr G Jones 2 Llanddulas Shoreline D1297/020/01 BDir2.2, S7, UKBR, 1 WBR, LBAP[ANG, (Lapwing / Cornchwiglen) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 33 of 51 Butterflies and Moths Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Agrochola lychnidis SH912778 14/10/2009 Michael Hubbard 10 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 Terfyn, Llanddulas Trap (Beaded Chestnut / Castan Leiniog) Apamea remissa SH912778 13/06/2011 Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 Terfyn, Llanddulas MV Trap (125W) (Dusky Brocade / Brithyn Llwydolau) Argynnis adippe SH909783 1940 - 1949 Gordon Ellis Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)CR, S7, 3 WCA5, LBAP[CON] (High Brown Fritillary / Britheg Frown) Boloria euphrosyne SH915777 (Estimated 2 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard; Rob 1 Cefn yr Ogof Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)EN, S7, 3 1996 and 04/06/1998 Whitehead type: Field record / observation WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Pearl-bordered Fritillary / (Centroid of Site)) D0217/001/03 DEN, FLI] Britheg Berlog) Boloria euphrosyne SH9078 1943 Anon Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)EN, S7, 3 WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Pearl-bordered Fritillary / DEN, FLI] Britheg Berlog) Boloria euphrosyne SH9177 (Estimated 2 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard; M.J. 10 Adult SH9177 Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)EN, S7, 3 04/06/1974 and June Hubbard type: Field record / observation WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Pearl-bordered Fritillary / (Centroid of Site)) 1993 D0217/001/03 DEN, FLI] Britheg Berlog) Boloria selene SH913777 14 records, between D C Hinde; M.J.S. 2; 4; 17 Adult; 14 Cefn yr Ogof Quarry, Daytime observation. Habitat: D1373/001/03, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 01/06/1997 and Hubbard; Rob W Adult; 6 Adult; 1; 3; 14; Llanddulas Quarry: disused; Daytime LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Small Pearl-bordered 01/07/2014 Whitehead; Michael 6; 7; 17 observation. Habitat: Grassland: D0127/001/02, GWY, SNP] Fritillary / Britheg Berlog Hubbard calcareous; Breeding: No. Habitat: D1643/001/01, Quarry: disused. Mature: Yes. Fach) Record type: Field record / D1642/001/01 observation Boloria selene SH906773 2 records, between Chris Thomas; Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 1983 and July 1983 BRC:Thomas, C. LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Small Pearl-bordered D1161/001/01 GWY, SNP] Fritillary / Britheg Berlog Fach) Boloria selene SH907773 (Estimated 02/06/1992 Rob W Whitehead 3 Craig y Forwen Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 type: Field record / observation LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Small Pearl-bordered (Centroid of Site)) GWY, SNP] Fritillary / Britheg Berlog Fach) Boloria selene SH97 2 records, between BRC:Thomas, C.; Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 1983 and July 1983 Chris Thomas LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Small Pearl-bordered D0217/001/03 GWY, SNP] Fritillary / Britheg Berlog Fach) Boloria selene SH915777 (Estimated 41 records, between Rob W Whitehead; L. 3; 1; 10; 2; 7; 6; 1 Cefn yr Ogof Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 02/07/1986- andPUBLICRawsthorne; Dchinde; Adult; 2 Adult; 6 Adult; VERSIONtype: Field record / observation;- LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Small Pearl-bordered (Centroid of Site)) 05/07/2012 M.J.S. Hubbard; Ian R. 5 Adult; 4 Adult; 15 Daytime observation; Field record / D1373/001/03, GWY, SNP] Fritillary / Britheg Berlog Wynne; D C Hinde; M Adult; 15; 8; 4; 5 observation D1643/001/01, Bellingham; M.S. Fach) Hubbard D1642/001/01, D1161/001/01 Boloria selene SH97 10/06/1999 Ian R Wynne Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Small Pearl-bordered GWY, SNP] Fritillary / Britheg Berlog Fach)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 34 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Boloria selene SH97 1997 M J S Hubbard Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Small Pearl-bordered GWY, SNP] Fritillary / Britheg Berlog Fach) Celastrina argiolus SH97 2 records, between BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 LBAP[CON] 3 16/04/1981 and (Holly Blue / Glesyn Celyn) 01/08/1981 Celastrina argiolus SH97 11 records, between BRC:Hubbard, M.J.; 2 Adult; 1 Adult; 3 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 1984 and 09/05/2006 M.J.S. Hubbard Adult (Holly Blue / Glesyn Celyn) D1373/001/03 Celastrina argiolus SH 6 records, between Michael Hubbard; D C 1; 4; 5 Adult; 2 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1643/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 17/05/1998 and Hinde; M.J.S. (Holly Blue / Glesyn Celyn) 22/08/2013 Hubbard; Rob W D1373/001/03, Whitehead D0127/001/02 Celastrina argiolus SH907773 (Estimated 17/05/1998 Rob W Whitehead 1 Craig y Forwen Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02 LBAP[CON] 3 type: Field record / observation (Holly Blue / Glesyn Celyn) (Centroid of Site)) Celastrina argiolus SH 13 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard; D C 1; 2 Adult; 1 Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1643/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 08/05/1998 and Hinde (Holly Blue / Glesyn Celyn) 27/03/2012 D1373/001/03, D0127/001/02 Chiasmia clathrata SH912778 2 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Daytime D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 16/05/2010 and Terfyn, Llanddulas observation (Latticed Heath / Seffyr 24/05/2010 Delltog) Coenonympha pamphilus SH97 6 records, between Ian R Wynne Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 04/06/1999 and LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn 30/07/1999 Bach y Waun) Coenonympha pamphilus SH913777 23 records, between D C Hinde; Rob W 3; 21 Adult; 12; 1 Cefn yr Ogof Quarry, Daytime observation. Habitat: D1373/001/03, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 30/05/1994 and Whitehead; M.J.S. Adult; 2 Adult; 3 Adult; Llanddulas Quarry: disused; Field record / LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn 25/06/2013 Hubbard; Ian R. 4 Adult; 2; 4; 10; 20 observation. Habitat: Quarry: D0127/001/02, Bach y Waun) Wynne; Mike Howe; disused; Daytime observation. D0217/001/03, Michael Hubbard Habitat: Grassland: calcareous; Breeding: No. Habitat: Quarry: D1643/001/01 disused. Mature: Yes. Record type: Field record / observation; Breeding: No. Habitat: Grassland: calcareous. Mature... Coenonympha pamphilus SH97 29/04/1980 BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn Bach y Waun) Coenonympha pamphilus SH907773 (Estimated 02/06/1992 Rob W Whitehead 15 Craig y Forwen Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 type: Field record / observation LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn (Centroid of Site)) Bach y Waun) Coenonympha pamphilus SH915777 (Estimated 39 records, between Rob W Whitehead; 2; 2 Adult; 3; 1; 10; 8; Cefn yr Ogof Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 02/07/1986 and Dchinde; L. 9; 1 Adult; 10 Adult; 4 type: Field record / observation; LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn (Centroid of Site)) 08/07/2010- PUBLICRawsthorne; M Adult; 20 Adult; 15 VERSIONDaytime observation; - Field record / D1373/001/03 Bach y Waun) Bellingham; M.J.S. Adult; 28 Adult; 5 Adult observation Hubbard; Ian R. Wynne; D C Hinde; D C Hinde & M Bellingham; M.S. Hubbard Coenonympha pamphilus SH97 10/06/1999 Ian R Wynne Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn Bach y Waun)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 35 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Coenonympha pamphilus SH9178 Before 31/12/1981 M.J. Hubbard Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn Bach y Waun) Coenonympha pamphilus SH9177 (Estimated 5 records, between S.H. Hind; 1 SH9177 Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 04/06/1974 and BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S.; type: Field record / observation LBAP[GWY] (Small Heath / Gweirlöyn (Centroid of Site)) 09/07/1998 Liz Howe;Mike Howe; D1161/001/01, Bach y Waun) Joan Morgan D0217/001/03 Ecliptopera silaceata SH912778 2 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 03/05/2008 and Terfyn, Llanddulas MV Trap (125W) (Small Phoenix / Ffenics 23/05/2010 Bach) Ennomos erosaria SH912778 21/09/2008 Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7 3 Terfyn, Llanddulas MV Trap (125W) (September Thorn / Carpiog Medi) Ennomos fuscantaria SH912778 2 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 18/08/2009 and Terfyn, Llanddulas Trap; Garden: rural. Method: (Dusky Thorn / Carpiog 31/08/2011 Robinson MV Trap (125W) Tywyll) Erynnis tages SH913777 22 records, between D C Hinde; M.A. 1; 3; 16; 1 Adult; 26 Cefn yr Ogof Quarry, Daytime observation. Habitat: D1373/001/03, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 30/05/1994 and Howe; Rob W Adult; 10; 3 Adult; 2 Llanddulas Quarry: disused; Field record / LBAP[CON, FLI, (Dingy Skipper / Gwibiwr 09/06/2014 Whitehead; M Adult; 5; 2; 4 observation. Habitat: Grassland: D0127/001/02, GWY] Llwyd) Bellingham; M.J.S. calcareous; Field record / D0217/001/03, Hubbard; Ian R. observation. Habitat: Quarry: Wynne; Mike Howe; disused; Daytime observation. D1643/001/01 Michael Hubbard Habitat: Grassland: calcareous; Breeding: No. Habitat: Quarry: disused. Mature: Yes. Record type: Field record / obser... Erynnis tages SH907773 (Estimated 02/06/1992 Rob W Whitehead 1 Craig y Forwen Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 type: Field record / observation LBAP[CON, FLI, (Dingy Skipper / Gwibiwr (Centroid of Site)) GWY] Llwyd) Erynnis tages SH915777 (Estimated 40 records, between Dchinde; Rob W 2; 6; 10; 1 Egg; 4; 1; 2 Cefn yr Ogof Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 02/07/1986 and Whitehead; M Adult; 1 Adult; 24; 31; type: Field record / observation; LBAP[CON, FLI, (Dingy Skipper / Gwibiwr (Centroid of Site)) 20/06/2012 Bellingham; M.J.S. 3 Breeding: No. Mature: No. Record D1373/001/03, GWY] Llwyd) Hubbard; D C Hinde; type: Field record / observation; D1643/001/01 Ian R. Wynne; M.S. Daytime observation; At 8.00pm. Hubbard; D C Hinde & Daytime observation; Field record / M Bellingham observation Erynnis tages SH9178 Before 31/12/1981 M.J. Hubbard Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 LBAP[CON, FLI, (Dingy Skipper / Gwibiwr GWY] Llwyd) Euxoa nigricans SH912778 2 records, between Michael Hubbard 2 Adult; 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 01/08/2009 and Terfyn, Llanddulas Trap; Garden: rural. Method: (Garden Dart / Dart y 19/06/2011 Robinson MV Trap (125W) Gerddi) Favonius quercus SH 3 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard; Rob 1 Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1642/001/01, LBAP[CON] 3 25/07/2002 and W Whitehead (Purple Hairstreak) 19/08/2002- PUBLIC VERSION - D1373/001/03 Hepialus humuli SH909783 20/06/1970 Hugh N. Michaelis 1 Adult Llandulas Grassland: calcareous. Method: D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 Netted (Ghost Moth / Chwimwyfyn Rhithiol) Hepialus humuli SH912778 2 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Female. Garden: rural. Method: D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 30/06/2010 and Terfyn, Llanddulas Robinson MV Trap (125W); (Ghost Moth / Chwimwyfyn 24/07/2010 Garden: rural. Method: Robinson Rhithiol) MV Trap (125W) Hipparchia semele SH913777 2 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard 3 Adult; 1 Cefn yr Ogof Daytime observation. Habitat: D1373/001/03, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 25/08/2009 and Grassland: calcareous LBAP[GWY] (Grayling / Gweirlöyn Llwyd) 01/07/2014 D1643/001/01

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 36 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Hipparchia semele SH914777 2 records, between Mike & Liz Howe; 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 July 1983 and Chris Thomas LBAP[GWY] (Grayling / Gweirlöyn Llwyd) 27/07/1991 Hipparchia semele SH97 1983 BRC:Thomas, C. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Grayling / Gweirlöyn Llwyd) Hipparchia semele SH915777 (Estimated 8 records, between Rob W Whitehead; 2; 1; 2 Adult; 1 Adult Cefn yr Ogof Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 10/08/1992 and M.J.S. Hubbard; M.S. type: Field record / observation; LBAP[GWY] (Grayling / Gweirlöyn Llwyd) (Centroid of Site)) 08/07/2010 Hubbard Field record / observation; Daytime D1373/001/03 observation Hipparchia semele SH9178 Before 31/12/1981 M.J. Hubbard Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Grayling / Gweirlöyn Llwyd) Hipparchia semele SH9177 2 records, between Joan Morgan; Hugh Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 1970 and 27/07/1991 Michaelis LBAP[GWY] (Grayling / Gweirlöyn Llwyd) Hoplodrina blanda SH909783 1881 G.T. Porritt 1 Adult Llandulas Grassland: calcareous. Method: D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 Unknown (Rustic / Llwyd Llyfn) Hydraecia micacea SH912778 2 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 18/08/2009 and Terfyn, Llanddulas Trap; Garden: rural. Method: (Rosy Rustic / Gwladwr 09/08/2010 Robinson MV Trap (125W) Gwridog) Lasiommata megera SH 11/08/2013 Janet Brewer 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1643/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) Lasiommata megera SH97 3 records, between BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 28/05/1979 and LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) 01/08/1981 Lasiommata megera SH97 October 1980 BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) Lasiommata megera SH97 2 records, between BRC:Hubbard, M.J. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 1984 and 05/05/1986 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) Lasiommata megera SH97 2 records, between BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 29/04/1980 and LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) 28/06/1980 Lasiommata megera SH97 30/07/1999 Ian R Wynne Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) Lasiommata megera SH913777 7 records, between M Bellingham; Adrian 1; 2 Cefn yr Ogof Quarry, Field record / observation. Habitat: D1373/001/03, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 16/08/1994 and Fowles; Rob W Llanddulas Quarry: disused; Breeding: No. LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) 09/08/2014 Whitehead; Ian R. Habitat: Grassland: calcareous. D0127/001/02, Wynne; Michael Mature: Yes. Record type: Field D1643/001/01 Hubbard; M.J.S. record / observation; Breeding: No. Hubbard Habitat: Quarry: disused. Mature: Yes. Record type: Field record / observation Lasiommata megera SH907773 (Estimated 02/06/1992 Rob W Whitehead 5 Craig y Forwen Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 type: Field record / observation LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) (Centroid of Site)) Lasiommata megera SH914777 16/08/1994 Adrian Fowles Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) - PUBLIC VERSION - Lasiommata megera SH97 01/08/1980 BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) Lasiommata megera SH915777 (Estimated 10 records, between Rob W Whitehead; 1; 2; 1 Adult Cefn yr Ogof Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 02/07/1986 and Dchinde; M.J.S. type: Field record / observation; LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) (Centroid of Site)) 07/06/2006 Hubbard Daytime observation D1373/001/03 Lasiommata megera SH9178 Before 31/12/1981 M.J. Hubbard Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) Lasiommata megera SH97 4 records, between BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S.; 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01, RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 28/08/1971 and Steve McWilliam; Joan LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) 27/07/1991 Morgan D0217/001/03 Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 37 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Lasiommata megera SH8977 22/08/2000 Ian R. Wynne 2 Mynydd Marian Field record / observation D1373/001/03 RD1(UK)NT, S7, 3 LBAP[GWY] (Wall / Gweirlöyn y Cloddiau) Mniotype adusta SH912778 31/05/2010 Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 Terfyn, Llanddulas MV Trap (125W) (Dark Brocade) Plebejus argus SH909783 2 records, between R.C.R. Crewdson; 2-5 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 25/06/1953 and R.A. Hughes WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / 22/07/1956 DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Plebejus argus SH97 28/06/1980 BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Plebejus argus SH97 5 records, between Ian R Wynne Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 05/06/1999 and WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / 30/07/1999 DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Plebejus argus SH 16 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard; Via C 1; 25; 12; 3; 6; 10; 36; Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1643/001/01, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 06/06/2002 and Thomas; M.A. Howe; 30; 9; 13 WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / 09/07/2014 Howe, Dr M.A.; D C D1642/001/01 DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Hinde; Michael Hubbard Plebejus argus SH906773 2 records, between Chris Thomas; Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 1983 and July 1983 BRC:Thomas, C. WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / D1161/001/01 DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Plebejus argus SH913776 2 records, between Chris Thomas; Owen Adult; 134 Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 July 1983 and Lewis WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / 16/06/1997 DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Plebejus argus SH97 20/06/1995 M Bellingham Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Plebejus argus SH97 1983 BRC:Thomas, C. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Plebejus argus SH 30 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard; M.S. 15; 40; 30; 8; 4; 6; 20; Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1643/001/01, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 15/06/1999 and Hubbard; P Summers; 5; 10 WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / 29/06/2012 M Bellingham; D C D1642/001/01, DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Hinde D1161/001/01 Plebejus argus SH 5 records, between Hinde, Mr D.C.; R.L.H. 2 Adult; 90 Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1642/001/01, RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 June 1942 and Dennis; Liz Howe;Mike WCA5, LBAP[CON, (Silver-studded Blue / 10/06/2004 Howe; Anon; R.A. D0217/001/03 DEN, FLI, SNP] Glesyn Serennog) Hughes Plebejus argus subsp. SH913777 22 records, between D C Hinde; Rob W 13 Adult; 4 Adult; 9 Cefn yr Ogof Quarry, Daytime observation. Habitat: D1373/001/03, BAP, RD1(UK), 3 23/06/1994 and Whitehead; M.J.S. Adult; 12 Adult; 6 Llanddulas Quarry: disused; Field record / RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, caernensis 05/07/2009 Hubbard; M.A. Howe; Adult; 3 Adult; 1; 72; observation. Habitat: Quarry: D0127/001/02, LBAP[DEN, FLI, SNP] - PUBLICIan R. Wynne; Mike 100 Adult; 30; 4; 60; VERSIONdisused; MV Light Trap.- Habitat: (Silver-studded Blue) D0217/001/03 Howe 40; 10; 2; 20 Quarry: disused; Daytime observation. Habitat: Grassland: calcareous; Field record / observation. Habitat: Grassland: calcareous; Breeding: No. Habitat: Quarry: disused. Matur...

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 38 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Plebejus argus subsp. SH915777 (Estimated 41 records, between Rob W Whitehead; L. 50; 1; 30; 6; 40; 10; 10 Cefn yr Ogof Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, BAP, RD1(UK), 3 02/07/1986 and Rawsthorne; Dchinde; Adult; 2 Adult; 1 Adult; type: Field record / observation; RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, caernensis (Centroid of Site)) 17/06/2010 M Bellingham; M.J.S. 30 Adult; 6 Adult; 8 Field record / observation; >30 & D1373/001/03 LBAP[DEN, FLI, SNP] (Silver-studded Blue) Hubbard; D C Hinde; P Adult; 40 Adult; 5 <100 = highest ever count by Summers; M.S. Adult; 100 Adult; 20 MJSH. Field record / observation; Hubbard Adult; 60 Daytime observation; At SH914779 per record card. Daytime observation; At 8.00pm. Daytime observation Plebejus argus subsp. SH9178 Before 31/12/1981 M.J. Hubbard Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 BAP, RD1(UK), 3 RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, caernensis LBAP[DEN, FLI, SNP] (Silver-studded Blue) Plebejus argus subsp. SH9177 3 records, between D.C. Hinde; Anon; 72 Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 BAP, RD1(UK), 3 1970 and 28/02/2017 Hugh Michaelis RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, caernensis LBAP[DEN, FLI, SNP] (Silver-studded Blue) Pyrgus malvae SH909783 1940 Gordon Ellis occasional Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 LBAP[DEN, FLI] (Grizzled Skipper / Gwibiwr Brith) Pyrgus malvae SH97 04/06/1974 BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)VU, S7, 3 LBAP[DEN, FLI] (Grizzled Skipper / Gwibiwr Brith) Satyrium w-album SH911778 20/06/2006 Edward Lyons 1 Bron-y-Graig, Indoors. Record type/ Method: D0054/001/02 RD1(UK)EN, S7, 4 Llanddulas Field observation WCA5, LBAP[FLI] (White-letter Hairstreak / Brithribin W Wen) Satyrium w-album SH912778 2 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn garden Daytime observation D1373/001/03 RD1(UK)EN, S7, 3 30/07/2004 and WCA5, LBAP[FLI] (White-letter Hairstreak / 18/07/2006 Brithribin W Wen) Satyrium w-album SH97 01/07/1982 BRC:Hubbard, M.J.S. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1161/001/01 RD1(UK)EN, S7, 3 WCA5, LBAP[FLI] (White-letter Hairstreak / Brithribin W Wen) Satyrium w-album SH9177 (Estimated 2 records, between M.J.S. Hubbard; Hugh 2 Adult SH9177 Breeding: No. Mature: Yes. Record D0127/001/02, RD1(UK)EN, S7, 3 1980 and July 1993 Michaelis type: Field record / observation WCA5, LBAP[FLI] (White-letter Hairstreak / (Centroid of Site)) D0217/001/03 Brithribin W Wen) Scotopteryx bipunctaria SH909783 1947 R.A.Hughes 1 Adult Llandulas Grassland: calcareous. Method: D1285/001/02 BAP, S7, LBAP[DEN] 3 Unknown subsp. cretata (Chalk Carpet) Scotopteryx bipunctaria SH915777 2 records, between R.A.Hughes 1 Adult Cefn yr Ogof Method: Unknown D1285/001/02 BAP, S7, LBAP[DEN] 3 July 1947 and June subsp. cretata 1953 (Chalk Carpet) Scotopteryx bipunctaria SH9177 5 records,- between PUBLICR.A. Hughes Common Adult VERSIONSite Name Withheld Comments Withheld - D0217/001/03 BAP, S7, LBAP[DEN] 3 1947 and June 1953 subsp. cretata (Chalk Carpet) Scotopteryx chenopodiata SH915777 27/07/1991 M.J. Morgan 1 Adult Cefn yr Ogof Method: Unknown D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 (Shaded Broad-bar / Rhesen Lydan Dywyll) Scotopteryx chenopodiata SH9077 2 records, both on Joan Morgan; Mike 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 27/07/1991 Hull (Shaded Broad-bar / Rhesen Lydan Dywyll)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 39 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Spilosoma lubricipeda SH912778 4 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Male. Garden: rural. Method: D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 23/05/2008 and Terfyn, Llanddulas Robinson MV Trap (125W); (White Ermine / Ermin 05/05/2011 Garden: rural. Method: Robinson Gwyn) MV Trap (125W) Spilosoma lutea SH912778 14 records, between Michael Hubbard 2 Adult; 4 Adult; 10 Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 09/06/2008 and Adult; 1 Adult; 7 Adult; Terfyn, Llanddulas MV Trap (125W); Garden: rural. (Buff Ermine) 15/06/2011 5 Adult; 15 Adult Method: Robinson Trap Timandra comae SH912778 3 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: Robinson D1285/001/02 S7 3 22/06/2009 and Terfyn, Llanddulas MV Trap (125W); Garden: rural. (Blood-Vein / Gwyfyn 28/07/2010 Method: Robinson Trap Gwythïen Goch) Tyria jacobaeae SH912778 2 records, between Michael Hubbard 1 Adult Pendyffryn, Clip Garden: rural. Method: In flight; D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 31/05/2008 and Terfyn, Llanddulas Garden: rural. Method: Daytime (Cinnabar / Teigr y Benfelen) 03/06/2009 observation Tyria jacobaeae SH913777 07/06/2005 D C Hinde 1 Adult Cefn yr Ogof Quarry, Quarry: disused. Method: Daytime D1285/001/02 S7, LBAP[GWY] 3 Llanddulas observation (Cinnabar / Teigr y Benfelen)

- PUBLIC VERSION -

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 40 of 51 Fish Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Anguilla anguilla SH909781 06/10/2005 Anon - Environment River DULAS Survey type: No Information D1702/001/01 RD1(UK)CR, S7, 3 Agency (CONWY), AT LBAP[CON, GWY] (Eel / Llysywen) LLANDULAS Salmo trutta SH909781 06/10/2005 Anon - Environment River DULAS Survey type: No Information D1702/001/01 S7, LBAP[CON, GWY] 3 Agency (CONWY), AT (Brown/Sea Trout / Siwin; LLANDULAS Brithyll)

- PUBLIC VERSION -

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 41 of 51 Mammals Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Chiroptera SH9077 (Estimated 2005 approx BASC Recorder Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0132/001/02 EPS, S7, WCA5, 4 (160021323-3) LBAP[ANG, DEN, FLI, (Unknown Bat / Ystlum (Centroid of Site)) SNP] Anhysbys) Chiroptera SH9177 01/03/2003 Anon @ Clwyd Bat 1 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0098/001/02 EPS, S7, WCA5, 3 Group LBAP[ANG, DEN, FLI, (Unknown Bat / Ystlum SNP] Anhysbys) Erinaceus europaeus SH905781 August 2007 Christina Worley Ty Gwyn, Minffordd Garden Wildlife Record. Grid D1117/001/01 Bern, S7, LBAP[ANG, 4 Road, Llanddulas reference calculated from post CON, FLI, GWY] (Hedgehog / Draenog) code LL22 8EW, using Streetmap. Lutra lutra SH9078 (Supplied by 2 records, between Volunteer Surveyors 1 spraint Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1433/002/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 1 15/04/2011 and HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) Original Recorder 30/09/2011 WCA5, LBAP[ANG, (Map)) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Lutra lutra SH9078 (Supplied by 2 records, between Volunteer Surveyors 1 spraint Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1433/002/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 1 15/04/2011 and HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) Original Recorder 30/09/2011 WCA5, LBAP[ANG, (Map)) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Lutra lutra SH9078 (Supplied by 2 records, between Volunteer Surveyors 1 spraint Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1433/002/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 1 15/04/2011 and HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) Original Recorder 30/09/2011 WCA5, LBAP[ANG, (Map)) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Lutra lutra SH9077 (Supplied by 30/09/2011 Volunteer Surveyors 1 spraint Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1433/002/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 1 HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) Original Recorder WCA5, LBAP[ANG, (Map)) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Lutra lutra SH9077 31/05/2009 Rob Strachan 1 spraint Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1558/001/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 3 HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) WCA5, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Lutra lutra SH9077 (Supplied by 15/04/2011 Volunteer Surveyors 1 spraint Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1433/002/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 1 HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) Original Recorder WCA5, LBAP[ANG, (Map)) CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Lutra lutra SH9178 16/08/2005 Cardiff University & Sub-adult Female Dead on road Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0120/001/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 3 Environment Agency HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) WCA5, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Lutra lutra SH9178 (Estimated 5 records, between Ceri Morris; Anon Spraint; Spraint Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1651/001/01 Bern, CITES, EPS, 3 10/04/2011 and Female HDir, RD2(UK), S7, (Otter / Dyfrgi) (Centroid of Site)) 30/09/2011 WCA5, LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Meles meles SH9077 12 records, between Clwyd Badger Group Badger Sett Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0059/001/01 Bern, PBA, 3 21/03/2000- andPUBLIC(CBG) VERSION - LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Badger / Mochyn Daear) 10/11/2007 WRE] Meles meles SH9177 3 records, all on Clwyd Badger Group Badger Sett Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0059/001/01 Bern, PBA, 3 18/02/2003 (CBG) LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Badger / Mochyn Daear) WRE] Meles meles SH8977 4 records, between Clwyd Badger Group Badger Sett Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0059/001/01 Bern, PBA, 3 23/08/2003 and (CBG) LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, (Badger / Mochyn Daear) 10/11/2007 WRE] Mustela erminea SH898776 02/10/2006 Becky Groves 1 Llysfaen Seen being mobbed by crows, D1117/001/01 Bern, NRW, 4 seen from car LBAP[ANG, CON, FLI] (Stoat / Carlwm)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 42 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Mustela putorius SH906784 (Selected 21/10/2012 Ceri Morris 1 A55 Llanddulas Dead on road, on section of A55 D1117/001/01 Bern, HDir, RD2(UK), 4 eastbound eastbound where there are S7, LBAP[CON, FLI, (Polecat / Ffwlbart) from Interactive Map) concrete crash barriers on either GWY, SNP] side - frequent roadkill Myotis daubentonii SH9177 6 records, between Anon @ Clwyd Bat 1; 2; 3 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0098/001/02 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 02/12/1995 and Group RD2(UK), WCA5, (Daubenton's Bat / Ystlum y 17/01/1998 LBAP[ANG, CON, Dwr) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Myotis mystacinus SH97 20/01/2001 Mr K. Davies 1 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1681/001/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 RD2(UK), WCA5, (Whiskered Bat / Ystlum LBAP[ANG, DEN, FLI, Barfog) GWY, SNP] Myotis mystacinus/brandtii SH9177 6 records, between Anon @ Clwyd Bat 1 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0098/001/02, Bern, Bonn, EPS, 3 04/12/1993 and Group HDir, WCA5, agg. 15/01/2017 D0098/002/01 LBAP[ANG, CON, (Whiskered/Brandt's Bat DEN, FLI, SNP] agg.) Myotis nattereri SH9177 3 records, between Anon @ Clwyd Bat 1 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0098/001/02 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 05/03/2005 and Group RD2(UK), WCA5, (Natterer's Bat / Ystlum 05/12/2010 LBAP[ANG, CON, Natterer) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Neovison vison SH909778 31/05/2009 Rob Strachan Tracks Afon Dulas, Site number: Co 34 D1558/001/01 INNS, WCA9 3 Llanddulas (American Mink / Minc) Nyctalus noctula SH9078 (Supplied by 30/05/2009 Anon- North Wales Bat Bat Detector Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0174/001/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 Services RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Noctule Bat / Ystlum Mawr) Original Recorder LBAP[ANG, CON, (Checked)) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Nyctalus noctula SH9077 (Supplied by Summer 2010 Sam Dyer Bat Detector Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0174/001/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Noctule Bat / Ystlum Mawr) Original Recorder LBAP[ANG, CON, (Checked)) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Pipistrellus pipistrellus SH9078 (Supplied by 30/05/2009 Anon- North Wales Bat Bat Detector Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0174/001/01 Bern, Bonn, EPS, 1 Services HDir, RD2(UK), (Common Pipistrelle / Ystlum Original Recorder RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, Lleiaf Cyffredin) (Checked)) LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Pipistrellus pipistrellus SH9078 05/06/2010 Sam Dyer 2 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1543/001/01 Bern, Bonn, EPS, 3 HDir, RD2(UK), (Common Pipistrelle / Ystlum RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, Lleiaf Cyffredin) LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Pipistrellus pipistrellus SH9077 (Supplied by Summer 2010 Sam Dyer Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0174/001/01 Bern, Bonn, EPS, 1 HDir, RD2(UK), (Common Pipistrelle / Ystlum Original Recorder RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, Lleiaf Cyffredin) (Checked)) LBAP[ANG, CON, DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Pipistrellus pygmaeus SH9078 30/05/2009 Anon- North Wales Bat 2 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0174/001/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 Services RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Soprano Pipistrelle / Ystlum LBAP[ANG, DEN, FLI, Lleiaf Uchelsain) - PUBLIC VERSION - GWY, SNP] Plecotus auritus SH9177 (Supplied by 03/04/1997 Anon - CCW Bat Rescue Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1306/002/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Brown Long-eared Bat / Original Recorder LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Hirglust) (Unchecked)) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Plecotus auritus SH9177 3 records, between Anon @ Clwyd Bat 1 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0098/001/02 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 21/01/1989 and Group RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Brown Long-eared Bat / 02/03/1996 LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Hirglust) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP] Plecotus auritus SH9177 (Supplied by 08/04/1962 John Denton Blore 1 Female Ringing/Tagging Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0288/003/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 record RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Brown Long-eared Bat / Original Recorder LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Hirglust) (Unchecked)) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP]

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 43 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Rhinolophus ferrumequinum SH9177 06/03/2013 Anon @ Clwyd Bat 1 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0098/001/02 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 Group RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Greater Horseshoe Bat / LBAP[ANG, DEN, FLI, Ystlum Pedol Mwyaf) SNP] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9078 05/06/2010 Sam Dyer 4 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1543/001/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9077 (Supplied by Summer 2010 Sam Dyer 3 Droppings Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0174/001/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / Original Recorder LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) (Checked)) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9077 2 records, between Anon 270 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0216/001/03, Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 1993 and 05/06/1994 RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / D1486/001/01 LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9177 120 records, between Anon @ Clwyd Bat 1; 2; 7; 21; 22; 24; 3; Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0098/001/02, Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 03/12/1988 and Group 14; 6; 27; 5; 12; 9; 29; RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / 26/02/2017 19; 10; 28; 13; 25; 4; D0098/002/01 LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) 30; 20; 35; 26; 16; 8; DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, 32; 37; 15; 17 WRE] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9077 (Estimated 4 records, between Anon 205 Adult; 160 Adult; Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0827/001/02 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 23/05/1993 and 209 Adult; 270 Adult RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / (Centroid of Site)) 16/06/1994 LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9077 4 records, between Anon 205; 270; 160; 209 Bat Roost Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1684/001/02 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 23/05/1993 and RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / 16/06/1994 LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9177 (Supplied by 6 records, between John Denton Blore 1 Male; 1 Female Ringing/Tagging Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0288/003/01 Bern, EPS, HDir, 1 08/04/1962 and record RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / Original Recorder 18/02/1963 LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) (Unchecked)) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Rhinolophus hipposideros SH9077 1987 Schofield, Henry Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1072/001/02 Bern, EPS, HDir, 3 RD2(UK), S7, WCA5, (Lesser Horseshoe Bat / LBAP[ANG, CON, Ystlum Pedol Lleiaf) DEN, FLI, GWY, SNP, WRE] Sorex araneus SH915779 06/04/1964 Morris, P. Llanddulas D1072/001/02 Bern, LBAP[ANG, 3 CON] (Common Shrew / Llyg Cyffredin) - PUBLIC VERSION -

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 44 of 51 Other Invertebrates Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Austrominius modestus SH900787 24/09/2002 - CCW Phase 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1156/004/01 INNS 3 18/07/2003 Intertidal Team Cryptocephalus bipunctatus SH913777 08/06/2004 Mike Howe several Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD2(UK)NB, 3 RD2(UK)S Drymus (Drymus) latus SH8977 14/09/2005 John Harold Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD2(UK)NB 3 Meligethes solidus SH914775 08/06/2004 Adrian Fowles 2 Adult Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D0217/001/03 RD2(UK)N, 3 LBAP[DEN] Sabellaria alveolata SH91247886 2 records, between Phil Capper, Vickie Llanddulas West reef: SH91247886 to D1117/001/01 LBAP[CON] 1 12/02/2008 and Hickin, Paul Brazier, SH91517574 (Honeycomb Worm) (Supplied by Original 30/07/2008 Gabriel Wyn, Virginia Recorder) Prieto Sabellaria alveolata SH91547873 2 records, between Phil Capper, Vickie Llanddulas Mid reef: SH91547873 to D1117/001/01 LBAP[CON] 1 12/02/2008 and Hickin, Paul Brazier, SH91607865 (Honeycomb Worm) (Supplied by Original 30/07/2008 Gabriel Wyn, Virginia Recorder) Prieto

- PUBLIC VERSION -

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 45 of 51 Plants Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Allium ampeloprasum SH9078 2000 Anon Llanddulas D1169/004/02 RD2(UK)NS, 3 RD2(UK)S, (Leek / Cenhinen Wyllt) LBAP[CON], LI[VC50, VC52] Aloina aloides SH9177 1970 - 1991 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LBAP[CON, FLI], (Common Aloe-moss) LI[VC48] Antennaria dioica SH914778 2 records, both in 2000 Anon Rhyd y Foel D0216/001/03, RD1(UK)VU, 1 LBAP[CON], LI[VC48, (Mountain Everlasting / D1169/004/02 VC49, VC50, VC51, Edafeddog y Mynydd) VC52] Apometzgeria pubescens SH9177 1973 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LBAP[CON], LI[VC48, (Downy Veilwort) VC51] Atriplex glabriuscula SH9178 14/09/2015 Stead, M.O. Llanddulas D1169/004/02 LI[VC48, VC50, VC51] 3 (Babington's Orache / Llygwyn y Tywod) Atriplex prostrata x SH9178 14/09/2015 Stead, M.O. Llanddulas Voucher specimen D1169/004/02 LI[VC50] 3 glabriuscula (Orache) Brachythecium glareosum SH9177 1970 - 1988 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LBAP[CON], LI[VC48, (Streaky Feather-moss) VC49, VC52] Brassica oleracea SH914779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 1 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 RD2(UK)NS, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes RD2(UK)S, (Wild Cabbage / Bresychen (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, LBAP[ANG, CON], Wyllt) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, LI[VC49, VC50, VC52] Carrie Rimes Brassica oleracea SH915779 2 records, both in 2000 Anon Terfyn D0216/001/03, RD2(UK)NS, 1 RD2(UK)S, (Wild Cabbage / Bresychen D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON], Wyllt) LI[VC49, VC50, VC52] Brassica oleracea SH9177 3 records, all on Surry, K. Terfyn SH9149077951. Tan yr Ogof, D1169/004/02 RD2(UK)NS, 3 17/07/2012 woodland unit of Gwrych RD2(UK)S, (Wild Cabbage / Bresychen SSSI.Scattered pop on cliff base, LBAP[ANG, CON], Wyllt) within clefts on face, in grassland LI[VC49, VC50, VC52] on top, in woodland adjacent; SH9155877905. small pop at cliff base & in pockets on cliff adj to the roman steps; SH9184977639. Scattered pop within chimney at W end of cliff bene... Bromopsis erecta SH907772 (Estimated 05/07/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 2 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LBAP[CON], LI[VC49, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes VC50, VC51, VC52] (Upright Brome / Pawrwellt (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Talsyth) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Bryum donianum SH9177 1973 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LI[VC49, VC50, VC52] (Don's Thread-moss) - PUBLIC VERSION - Bryum torquescens SH913777 February 1973 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LI[VC48, VC49, VC50, (Twisting Thread-moss) VC52] Bryum torquescens SH9177 1973 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LI[VC48, VC49, VC50, (Twisting Thread-moss) VC52] Campyliadelphus SH9177 1970 - 1988 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LBAP[CON], LI[VC48] chrysophyllus (Golden Feather-moss)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 46 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Cotoneaster horizontalis SH902779 (Estimated 08/09/2011 David Bennett Land off Trees/scrub D0174/002/01 INNS, WCA9 1 Pentregwyddel Road, (Wall Cotoneaster / (Centroid of Site)) Llandulas, Conwy Cotoneaster Asgwrn Pysgodyn) Cotoneaster horizontalis SH8977 28/07/2015 BSBI Mynydd Marian D1169/004/02 INNS, WCA9 3 (Wall Cotoneaster / Cotoneaster Asgwrn Pysgodyn) Cotoneaster microphyllus SH9077 21/04/2012 Williams, D. & Green, Bryn Dulas D1169/004/02 INNS, WCA9 3 J.A. (Small-leaved Cotoneaster / Cotoneaster Manddail) Crambe maritima SH913787 2 records, both in 2000 Anon Llanddulas D0216/001/03, LBAP[ANG, CON], 4 LI[VC48, VC49, VC50, (Sea-kale / Ysgedd Arfor) D1169/004/02 VC51] Crocosmia pottsii x aurea = SH902779 (Estimated 08/09/2011 David Bennett Land off Trees/scrub D0174/002/01 INNS, WCA9 1 Pentregwyddel Road, C. x crocosmiiflora (Centroid of Site)) Llandulas, Conwy (Montbretia / Crib-y-Ceiliog) Fallopia japonica SH9078 25/07/2009 Harold, J. Llanddulas SH908784. Dolydd. A Conwy D1169/004/02 INNS, WCA9 3 Urban Green Space (Japanese Knotweed / Clymog Japan) Grimmia orbicularis SH9177 1973 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LBAP[CON], LI[VC48, (Round-fruited Grimmia) VC49, VC50, VC52] Helianthemum canum SH914779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 5 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LBAP[CON] 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes (Hoary Rock-Rose) (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Helianthemum canum SH914776 2000 Anon Terfyn D0216/001/03 LBAP[CON] 2 (Hoary Rock-Rose) Helianthemum oelandicum SH914776 2000 Anon Terfyn D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON, 3 FLI], LI[VC50, VC52] (Hoary Rock-rose / Cor- Rosyn Lledlwyd) Helianthemum oelandicum SH9077 24/06/2012 Davies, A. Bryn Dulas Summit of Craig - y forwyn D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON, 3 FLI], LI[VC50, VC52] (Hoary Rock-rose / Cor- Rosyn Lledlwyd) Helictotrichon pratense SH914779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 3 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LI[VC49, VC50, VC51, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes VC52] (Meadow Oat-grass / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Ceirchwellt y Ddôl) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Helictotrichon pratense SH914778 (Estimated 01/06/1995- PUBLICDan Guest, Stuart 1 DOMIN (Estimate) VERSIONField record Rhyd y Foel Limestone - D0820/001/02 LI[VC49, VC50, VC51, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes VC52] (Meadow Oat-grass / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Ceirchwellt y Ddôl) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Helictotrichon pratense SH915779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 3 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LI[VC49, VC50, VC51, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes VC52] (Meadow Oat-grass / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Ceirchwellt y Ddôl) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Helictotrichon pratense SH907772 (Estimated 05/07/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 3 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LI[VC49, VC50, VC51, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes VC52] (Meadow Oat-grass / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Ceirchwellt y Ddôl) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 47 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Helictotrichon pubescens SH915779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 4 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LI[VC50] 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes (Downy Oat-grass / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Ceirchwellt Blewog) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Helleborus foetidus SH8977 28/07/2015 BSBI Mynydd Marian D1169/004/02 RD2(UK)NS, 3 RD2(UK)S, (Stinking Hellebore / LBAP[CON, DEN], Crafanc-yr-Arth Ddrewllyd) LI[VC51, VC52] Hippophae rhamnoides SH89787842 16/10/2015 Steve J. McWilliam occasional A55, Llysfaen, Colwyn, D1592/006/01 INNS, RD2(UK)NS, 1 North Wales RD2(UK)S, (Sea-buckthorn / LBAP[CON] Rhafnwydden y Môr) Hippophae rhamnoides SH89787842 16/10/2015 Steve J. McWilliam occasional A55, Llysfaen, Colwyn, D1592/006/01 INNS, RD2(UK)NS, 1 North Wales RD2(UK)S, (Sea-buckthorn / LBAP[CON] Rhafnwydden y Môr) Hyacinthoides hispanica SH9077 21/04/2012 Williams, D. & Green, Bryn Dulas D1169/004/02 INNS 3 J.A. (Spanish Bluebell / Clychau'r Gog Sbaenaidd) Impatiens glandulifera SH9078 25/07/2009 Harold, J. Llanddulas A Conwy Urban Green Space D1169/004/02 INNS, WCA9 3 (Himalayan Balsam / Jac y Neidiwr) Leiocolea alpestris SH9177 2 records, between Pearson, W.H.; Hill, Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 1899 and 1973 M.O. LI[VC48, VC49, VC50] (Mountain Notchwort) Malva arborea SH899784 1993 Anon Llysfaen D0216/001/03 LBAP[CON, DEN], 2 LI[VC50] (Tree-mallow) Matthiola sinuata SH9078 (Approximate) 1680 Anon Llandulas D0821/001/01 RD1(UK)VU, 3 RD2(UK)NR, (Sea Stock / Murwyll Arfor) RD2(UK)R, S7, LBAP[CON], LI[VC51] Microbryum curvicolle SH913778 27/10/1988 Battershall, G.; Yeo, Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 M.J.M. LI[VC49, VC50, VC52] (Swan-necked Earth-moss) Microbryum rectum SH9177 1973 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LI[VC49, VC50, VC52] (Upright Pottia) Orobanche hederae SH91337794 28/08/2016 Fraser, I. Terfyn D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON], 3 LI[VC48, VC50, VC52] (Ivy Broomrape / Gorfanhadlen Eiddew) Orobanche hederae SH91447802 28/08/2016 Fraser, I. Llanddulas 2 near Terfyn on way up to Cefn yr D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON], 3 Ogof LI[VC48, VC50, VC52] (Ivy Broomrape / Gorfanhadlen Eiddew) Orobanche hederae SH90797742 21/04/2012 Williams, D. & Green, Bryn Dulas 1 previous year spike,E facing D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON], 3 J.A. roadside bank LI[VC48, VC50, VC52] (Ivy Broomrape / - PUBLIC VERSION - Gorfanhadlen Eiddew) Orobanche hederae SH916781 2 records, between Osley, N.J. Llanddulas Tens of flowering spikes on R side D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON], 3 2009 and 17/07/2015 of gateway.; SH916 781 LI[VC48, VC50, VC52] (Ivy Broomrape / Llanddulas. Abundant in roadside Gorfanhadlen Eiddew) verge by north towers, Tan-yr- ogof, Llanddulas Petasites hybridus SH9078 25/07/2009 Harold, J. Llanddulas SH908784. Dolydd. A Conwy D1169/004/02 LI[VC48, VC50] 3 Urban Green Space (Butterbur / Alan Mawr) Pleurochaete squarrosa SH9177 1972 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LI[VC49, VC50, VC51] (Side-fruited Crisp-moss)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 48 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Polypodium cambricum SH90747726 21/04/2012 Williams, D. & Green, Bryn Dulas E side of track, on wall. update of D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON, FLI, 3 J.A. 18/01/09 record GWY], LI[VC48, VC49, (Southern Polypody / VC50, VC51, VC52] Llawredynen Gymreig) Populus nigra subsp. SH9091978150 1994 Trefor Thompson & 2 Male Field record Near Church Streamside D0225/001/01 LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, 4 Les Starling Llanddulas SNP, WRE], LI[VC48, betulifolia VC50, VC52] (Black Poplar) Populus nigra subsp. SH909782 2005 Rhys Thomas 1 Llanddulas Resurvey of known Black Poplar D0181/001/01 LBAP[CON, DEN, FLI, 4 sites in Conwy. Llanddulas 20m SNP, WRE], LI[VC48, betulifolia north of bridge over Afon Dulas. VC50, VC52] (Black Poplar) Porphyra purpurea SH900786 24/09/2002 - CCW Phase 1 Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1156/004/01 WCA9 3 18/07/2003 Intertidal Team Rhodobryum roseum SH914778 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 1 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes LBAP[CON, FLI], (Rose-moss) (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, LI[VC48, VC49, VC50, Map)) Morwenna Bolas, VC51] Carrie Rimes Rubia peregrina SH914777 2 records, both in 2000 Anon Terfyn D0216/001/03, LBAP[CON], LI[VC48, 2 VC50, VC51, VC52] (Wild Madder / Cochwraidd D1169/004/02 Gwyllt) Senecio cambrensis SH912784 2 records, both in 1993 Anon; Green, Dr J.A. A55 [GR given by Wigginton is D0216/001/03, RD1(UK)NT, 4 SH895782, but card supplied by RD2(UK)NR, (Welsh Groundsel / Creulys J.A. Green in 2000 gives D1169/004/02 RD2(UK)R, Gymreig) SH912784.] LBAP[CON, FLI], LI[VC51] Thalictrum minus SH914779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 1 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LI[VC50, VC51, VC52] 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes (Lesser Meadow-rue / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Arianllys Bach) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Thalictrum minus SH914778 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 2 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LI[VC50, VC51, VC52] 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes (Lesser Meadow-rue / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Arianllys Bach) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Thalictrum minus SH915779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 3 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LI[VC50, VC51, VC52] 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes (Lesser Meadow-rue / (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Arianllys Bach) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Thuidium assimile SH9177 1973 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LBAP[CON], LI[VC48, (Philibert's Tamarisk-moss) VC49, VC50] Tortella nitida SH914779 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 3 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes LBAP[CON, FLI], (Neat Crisp-moss) (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, LI[VC48, VC49, VC50, Map)) Morwenna Bolas, VC51, VC52] Carrie Rimes Tortella nitida SH9177 1972 Hill, M.O. Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 LBAP[CON, FLI], (Neat Crisp-moss) - PUBLIC VERSION - LI[VC48, VC49, VC50, VC51, VC52] Ulex gallii SH915778 (Estimated 01/06/1995 Dan Guest, Stuart 8 DOMIN (Estimate) Field record Rhyd y Foel Limestone D0820/001/02 LBAP[ANG, CON, 3 Smith, David Stevens, SSSI & Annexes SNP] (Western Gorse / Eithinen (From Recorder's Tim Blackstock, Fân) Map)) Morwenna Bolas, Carrie Rimes Ulex gallii SH8977 28/07/2015 BSBI Mynydd Marian D1169/004/02 LBAP[ANG, CON, 3 SNP] (Western Gorse / Eithinen Fân)

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 49 of 51 Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Viola canina SH9077 1971 Anon Rhyd y Foel D0216/001/03 RD1(UK)NT, 2 RD1(UK)VU, (Heath Dog-violet / Fioled y RD2(UK), LBAP[CON, Cwn) GWY], LI[VC49] Weissia longifolia var. SH9177 1984 Blackstock, T.H.; Yeo, Site Name Withheld Comments Withheld D1075/001/04 RD1(Wales)LC, 3 M.J.M. LBAP[DEN], LI[VC49, angustifolia VC50]

- PUBLIC VERSION -

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 50 of 51 Reptiles and Amphibians Species Name Grid Reference Date Recorder(s) Abundance Record Type Site Name Comments Dataset ID Lists QA Lissotriton helveticus SH8977 2 records, between Anon Llysfaen Rectory, nr D1076/001/02 Bern, WCA5, 3 April 1909 and May LBAP[ANG, CON, (Palmate Newt / Madfall 1932 DEN, FLI] Ddwr Balfog)

Statutory Sites intersecting 1000m buffer SSSI: 894: Llanddulas Limestone and Gwrych Castle Wood (479m), SPA: UK9020294: Liverpool Bay / Bae Lerpwl (Wales) (510m) Wildlife Sites intersecting 1000m buffer 97/39: St Cynbryd's Church Verge (212m), 97/50: Ffordd Llindir (466m) NWWT Reserves intersecting 1000m buffer None RSPB Reserves intersecting 1000m buffer None RIGS intersecting 1000m buffer 269: Cefn yr Ogof (764m) Ancient Woodland intersecting 1000m buffer 36769: Restored Ancient Woodland Site (169m), 34810: Ancient Semi Natural Woodland (441m), 36766: Restored Ancient Woodland Site (491m), 36768: Restored Ancient Woodland Site (713m), 29670: Restored Ancient Woodland Site (713m), 36764: Restored Ancient Woodland Site (769m) A.1.1.1: Semi-natural Broad-leaved Woodland (5.39% / 169,266 sq.m), A.1.1.2: Planted Broad-leaved Woodland (0.24% / 7,572 sq.m), A.1.2.2: Planted Coniferous Woodland (0.18% / 5,583 sq.m), Phase I Habitats intersecting 1000m buffer A.2.1: Dense Scrub (0.6% / 18,908 sq.m), B.2.2: Semi-improved Neutral Grassland (0.98% / 30,837 sq.m), B.3.2: Semi-improved Calcareous Grassland (0.2% / 6,214 sq.m), B.4: Improved Grassland (Habitat at central point shown in red, if found) (18.4% / 577,919 sq.m), C.1.1: Bracken (0.02% / 599 sq.m), D.1.2: Dry Basic Heath (0.56% / 17,579 sq.m), D.7: Basic Dry Heath/Calcareous Grassland Mosaic (1.01% / 31,651 sq.m), G.2: Running Water (0.51% / 15,916 sq.m), H.1.1: Intertidal Mud/Sand (3.86% / 121,231 sq.m), H.1.2: Intertidal Shingle/Cobbles (4.89% / 153,747 sq.m), H.1.3: Intertidal Boulders/Rocks (0.01% / 331 sq.m), H.3.2: Shingle/Gravel above MHW (1.64% / 51,396 sq.m), H.4: Boulders/Rocks above MHW (0.06% / 1,966 sq.m), I.2.1: Quarry (9.82% / 308,384 sq.m), J.1.2: Amenity Grassland (0.46% / 14,432 sq.m), J.1.3: Ephemeral/Short Perennial (0.82% / 25,826 sq.m), J.1.5: Gardens (0.28% / 8,840 sq.m), J.3.4: Caravan Site (3.6% / 113,066 sq.m), J.3.6: Buildings (13.1% / 411,528 sq.m)

- PUBLIC VERSION -

Cofnod Environmental Information Search E05823 Page 51 of 51