: 1 :
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 19 th DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2013
PRESENT
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE K.L.MANJUNATH
AND
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE A.N.VENUGOPALA GOWDA
C.C.C. NO.3458 –3518 OF 2013 (CIVIL)
BETWEEN:
1. SHANKRAPPA S/O VEERABASAPPA NEGALI AGE:71 YRS, RETD ON 30/06/1998 AS H.M. S.A.V. HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG, R/O.KOTAMUCHGI, TQ: DIST: GADAG
2. N.M.BYALI, AGE:72 YRS, RETD ON 30/05/1997 AS H.M., V.F.PATIL HIGH SCHOOL RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O RON, DIST:GADAG.
3. G.D.HUILGOL AGE:71 YRS, RETD CRAFT TR., S.A.HIGH SCHOOL NIDAGUNDI, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O NAREGAL, TQ:RON, R/ONAREGAL, TQ: RON, DIST:GADAG. : 2 :
4. S.G.PALLED AGE:71 YRS, RETD A.M, S.A.V.HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O ABBIGERI, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG
5. B.S.BHOPALAPUR AGE:71 YRS, RETD CRAFT TEACHER, S.A.V.HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O ANNADANESHWAR NAGAR KODIKOPPA, NAREGAL, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG
6. SMT. B.K.KALAGI W/O LATE K.G.KALAGI, AGE:66 YRS, RETD TEACHER, S.A.V.HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O ABBIGERI, TQ:RON,DIST: GADAG,
7. SMT. SHAKUNTALA W/O LATE BASAPPA NIDAGUNDI, AGE:64 YRS, RETD TEACHER, S.A.V.HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O ABBIGERI, TQ:RON,DIST:GADAG,
8. SHARANAMMA S. NAREAL W/O. LATE S.A. NAREGAL AGE: 71 YEARS, RETD. TEACHER S.M. BHOOMAREDDY COMP. JR. COLLEGE GAJENDRAGAD, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG, R/O. NAVANAGAR, GAJENDRAGAD TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG : 3 :
9. B.R.BATAKHANI, AGE:71 YRS, RETD H.M., S.J.F.C.HIGH SCHOOL YALAVATTI, TQ:SHIRAHATTI, DIST:GADAG, R/O. KOTI ONI, MULGUND, DIST: GADAG
10. H.B.CHARANTIMATH AGE:73 YRS, RETD PRINCIPAL., S.J.J.M.COMP. JR. COLLEGE, MULGUND, TQ & DIST:GADAG, R/O TIGADIKERI, MULGUND,TQ & DIST:GADAG.
11. M.A.HIREWADEYAR AGE:69 YRS, RETD TEACHER., S.A.V.GIRLS HIGH SCHOOL, NAREGAL, TQ & DIST:GADAG, R/O KODIKOPPA, , VIA NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG.
12. R.Y.SHIRASAGI, AGE:71 YRS, RETD A.M., K.K.NANDIKOL HIGH SCHOOL HIREWADDATTI, TQ: MUNDARGI, DIST:GADAG, R/O A.D.NAGAR, MUNDARGI, DIST:GADAG.
13. V.S.CHAVADI AGE:69 YRS, RETD P.E.TR., S.A.V.HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O H.M.NAGAR, KOPPAL ROAD, MUNDARGI, DIST:GADAG.
14. A.C.BHIXAVATIMATH AGE:63 YRS, RETD TR., S.A.V.HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O KODIKOPPA, : 4 :
TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG.
15. B.S.KOPPAD AGE:71 YRS, RETD TR., S.A.V.HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O NIDAGUNDI, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG.
16. H.Y.MALSURE AGE:73 YRS, RETD H.M., S.S.HIGH SCHOOL, TUMMARIKATTI, TQ:RANEBENNUR, DIST:HAVERI, R/O BACK SIDE OF GOVT. HOSPITAL, SHIRAHATTI, DIST:GADAG.
17. SMT. SUDHA W/O LATE R.N.SHINDHE AGE:54 YRS, RETD P.E. TEACHER., BASEL MISSION COMP. JR. COLLEGE, DHARWAD R/O. C/O. PRAVEEN R. SHINDHE, LAXMI NARAYAN NILAYA, NEAR SANGH DHAMA, TELANG COMPUND, BANAVASI ROAD, SIRSI. (U.K.)
18. MALLARI DIXIT AGE:63 YRS, RETD. TEACHER, PVSBC HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET, (D), BELLARY. R/O SPANDANA OPP-AIR, VIDAYARANNAYA EXTENSION, HOSPET, BELLARY
19. P. LAKSHMI NARAYANA SHETTY AGE:63 YRS, RETD. TEACHER, PVSBC HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET, (D), BELLARY. R/O 12TH WARD DEVINGAR, II CROSS, CHITWADGI, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY : 5 :
20. D. VASANTHA RAO AGE:68 YRS, RETD. H.M., PVSBC HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET,DIST: BELLARY. R/O VENKATAPADMANJALI, BASAVESHWARA, EXTENSION, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
21. Y.M.RAVIDRANATH AGE:57 YRS, AM. PVSBC HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY. R/O SRI. SIDDALINGA PRASAD, AMARAVATHI, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
22. H.S.DEVANDRA AGE:57 YRS, AM.PVSBC HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY. R/O SRINIVASA NILAYA, RANIPET NEAR BYALU HANUMANTAPPA TEMPLE HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
23. G.VENKANNA AGE:62 YRS, RETD. TEACHER., PVSBC HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY. R/O SRINIVASA NILAYA, NEAR NOORANI MASJID, JAMBUNATH ROAD, MAHABOOB NAGAR, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
24. J. BHEEMAPPA AGE:57 YRS, H.M., VALMIKI HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET, (D), BELLARY. R/O PARAVATHI NAGAR, 35TH WARD, HOSPET (D) BELLARY.
25. H.F.MOHAMMED NABI AGE:59 YRS, A.M. VALMIKI HIGH : 6 :
SCHOOL, HOSPET, (D), BELLARY. R/O.C/P. MOHAMMED YOUNIS, NEAR KOTTURSWAMY D.ED. COLLEGE, JAMBUNATH ROAD, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
26. K. SHANMUKAPPA AGE:57 YRS, A.M. VALMIKI HIGH SCHOOL, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY. R/O. AKSHAYA NILAYA, 29TH WARD, RAJIV NAGAR, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
27. G.N.HERIMATH AGE:63 YRS, RETD. H.M, SRI.KATTA MANJAPP HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY,R/O KANCHAGARPETI, NEAR LINGMATH WELL, 25TH WARD, HOSPET DISTL: BELLARY
28. S. RAMESH RAO AGE: 63 YEARS, RETD., TR. SRI KATTA MANJAPPA HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY R/O. CHITRAKERI, NEAR TAGORE SCHOOL, 14TH WARD, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
29. M.M. VIRUPAKSHAYYA AGE: 56 YEARS, A.M. LITTLE FLOWER KANNADA MEDIUM HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY, R/O. DARUKA NILAYA, BDCC COLONY,M.J. NAGAR, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY : 7 :
30. H. SUDHABAI AGE: 66 YEARS, RETD., TR. LITTLE FLOWER KANNADA MEDIUM HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY R/O.M.S. KULKARNI, 16/362 FORT, HOSPET DIST: BELLARY
31. A. SHANKARAMMA AGE:69 YRS, RETD. TR, LITTLE FLOWER KANNADA MEDIUM HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL, HOSPET (D), BELLARY, R/O. DATTU RAO, 5TH CROSS, M. J. NAGAR, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
32. G. BASAPPA AGE:58 YRS, H.M., SMIORE VYASAPURI HIGH SCHOOL, VYASANAKERI, HOSPET (D), BELLARY R/O NEAR OMKARESHWARA TEMPLE, DAM ROAD, HOSPET, DIST:BELLARY
33. D.B.VIRUPAKSHA GOUDA AGE:58 YRS, A.M., SMIORE VYASAPURI HIGH SCHOOL, VYASANAKERI, HOSPET (D), BELLARY, R/O BASAVA NILAYA, SADASHIVA NAGAR, BDCC COLONY,GANESH TEMPLE ROAD, HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
34. R. CHANDRAPPA AGE:51 YRS, P.T. TR., SMIORE VYASAPURI HIGH SCHOOL, VYASANAKERI, HOSPET (D), BELLARY,
35. M.S. BILAGI AGE:59 YRS, A.M, SMIORE VYASAPURI HIGH SCHOOL, VYASANAKERI, HOSPET (D), : 8 :
BELLARY, R/O MP PRAKASH NAGAR, TEACHERS COLONY, NEAR CAMOM. HOSPET, DIST: BELLARY
36. BASAVARAJ T. AGE:54 YRS, H.M., KARTHIKESHWARA HIGH SCHOOL, THARANAGAR, HOSPET, BELLARY. R/O. CHAPPARADAHALLI, TARANAGAR, TQ: SANDUR, DIST: BELLARY
37. M.V.HURAKADLI AGE:50 YRS, H.M., SRB HIGH SCHOOL, TORANAGALLU, TQ:SONDUR, R/O H/C COLONY TORANAGALLU, TQ: SANDUR, DIST: BELLARY
38. R. NAIK AGE: 53 YEARS, DRAMING TR. S.R.B. HIGH SCHOOL TARANGALLU, TQ: SANDUR, DIST: BELLARY, R/O. TORANGALLU VILLAGE, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY
39. K. SATYANARAYANCHARYA AGE: 58 YEARS, SDA SRB HIGH SCHOOL TORANGALLU, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY, R/O. TORANGALLU VILLAGE, TQ: SONDUR DIST: BELLARY
40. T. PARAMESHWARAPPA AGE: 69 YRS, RETD. H.M. SRB HIGH SCHOOL TORANGALLU, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY R/O. TORANGALLU VILLAGE, TQ: SONDUR, : 9 :
DIST: BELLARY
41. H. THIMMAKRISHNA RAO AGE: 66 YEARS, RETD. ASST.TR. SRB HIGH SCHOOL TORANGALLU, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY, R/O. OPT. ISHWAR TEMPLE, S.N. PET DIST: BELLARY
42. V.B. SUNKAD, AGE: 62 YEARS, RETD. AST. TR. SRB HIGH SCHOOL TORANGALLU, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY, R/O. TORANGALLU (RS) TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY
43. K. VENKATESHULU AGE: 64 YEARS, RETD. HINDI TR. S.B. HIGH SCHOOL TORANGALLU, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY, R/O. TORANGALLU (RS) TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY
44. G.M. RUDRAMUNI AGE: 61 YEARS, RETD., P.E.TR. SRB HIGH SCHOOL TORANGALLU, TQ: SONDUR DIST: BELLARY, R/O. TORANGALLU TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY
45. SAVAYYA SOPPIMATH AGE: 65 YEARS, RETD. TR. SRB HIGH SCHOOL TORANGALLU, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY R/O. S. BASAPPA VILLAGE VADDU POST, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY
46. NARASINHA V. AGE: 49 YEARS, KARTHIKESHWAR HIGH SCHOOL : 10 :
TORANAGER, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY R/O. N.H.P. COLONY, AT & POST : TORANGER, TQ: SONDUR, DIST: BELLARY
47. M.T. MALLANGOUDA, AGE 70 YRS. RETD. ON 31.01.1998 AS AM. KES COMPENSATION JR. COLLEGE, KONNUR, TQ. NARGUND, DIST.: GADAG. R/O. C/O. B.S.VIRAKTAMATH, VIKAS NAGAR, PHQ, DHARWAD-8
48. B.S. METI, AGE: 62 YEARS, RETD. ON 30.04.2006 AS AM SRI ARD HIGH SCHOOL, GOLASANGI, TQ.: BASAVAN BAGEWADI, DIST.: BIJAPUR, R/O. HALLUR, TQ. DIST.: BAGALKOT.
49. SMT. SANTAVVA W/O LATE SUGEERAYYA SUGEERAYYANMATH, AGE:58 YRS, RETD. A.M., ANNADANESHWAR HIGH SCHOOL, NAREGAL, TQ.RON, DIST:GADAG. R/O. KODIKOPPA, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG
50. PRABHAVATI BALAPPA JAMAKHANDI AGE:42YRS W/O LATE BALAPPA JAMAKHANDI RETD.TEACHER, S.S.HIGH SCHOOL SAVADI, TQ.RON, DIST:GADAG, R/O KANAGINAHAL TQ & DIST: GADAG
51. M.L. PAYAPPAGOUDAR AGE: 61 YEARS, RETD. TR. SKC JR. COLLEGE HOLE ALUR, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG, R/O.NEAR KEB OFFICE : 11 :
HOLEALUR, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG
52. SMT. SHIVALINGAMMA W/O LATE RUDRAGOUDA HALAKURAKI AGE:65 YRS RETD. CRAFT TEACHER, SHRI.GAVISHIDDESHWAR HIGH SCHOOL, KOPPAL R/O ABBIGERI, TQ:RON, DIST:GADAG.
53. SMT. GOURAMMA W/O LATE BASANGOUDA BUDIHAL AGE: 65 YRS RETD. TR., SAV HIGH SCHOOL, NAREGAL, TQ.RON, DIST:GADAG. R/O TOTGANTI, POST.KODIKOPPA, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG
54. A.A.HIREMATH AGE: 63 YEARS, RETD. SDC S.A. COLLEGE, NAREGAL, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG R/O. ANNADANESHWAR NAGAR, KODIKOPPA, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG
55. H.M. ITAGI, AGE: 65 YEARS, RETD. TR. VIJAYANAGAR P.U COLLEGE, TBP MUNIRABAD, TQ: & DIST: KOPPAL, R/O. ABBIGERI, TQ: RON DIST: GADAG
56. AKKAMAHADEVI W/O. LATE LINGANGOUDA PATIL AGE: 60 YEARS, RETD. TR.SAV HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG R/O. NIDAGUNDI, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG : 12 :
57. V.H. HADIMANI AGE: 64 YEARS, RETD., SDC SAV HIGH SCHOOL, NAREGAL, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG, R/O. NIDAGUNDI, TQ: RON, DIST: GADAG
58. SHIVAGANGAVVA W/O.LATE VEERAPPA ABBIGERI AGE: 50 YEARS,RETD., ASST. LIBRARIAN SAV HIGH SCHOOL NAREGAL, TQ: RON DIST: GADG, R/O. NIDAGUNDI, TQ: RON DIST: GADAG
59. REVAPPA B. HAKKANDI AGE: 62 YEARS, RETD. TR. JTC KOTE HIGH SCHOOL MUNDARGI, DIST: GADAG, R/O. RENUKA NILAYA J.H. PATEL NAGR, MUNDARGI DIST: GADAG
60. H.Y. BARKERI AGE: 63 YEARS, RETD LIBRARIAN CUM CLERK J.A. HIGH SCHOOL, MUNDARGI DIST: GADAG, R/O. ANNADANESHWAR NAGAR, H.NO. 08371 MUNDARGI DIST: GADAG
61. K.M. GOUDA AGE:57 YRS, PE.TR, JANATA VIDYALAYA COMP. JR. COLLEDGE, DANDELI, (U.K.), R/O. 296/B TOUNSHIP 14TH BLOCK, DANDELI (U.K) ... COMPLAINANTS
(BY SRI S.G. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE) : 13 :
AND:
1. THE SECRETARY (PRIMARY &SECONDARY) EDUCATION DEPARTMENT M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE-560 001.
2. THE COMMISSIONER FOR PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE.
3. THE COMMISSIONER FOR PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS DIET BUILDING, KCD ROAD DHARWAD.
4. THE COMMISSIONER FOR PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS, GULBARGA. ... ACCUSED
(BY SRI A.A. PATHAN, AGA FOR A1 TO A4)
THESE CCC ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLE 215 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, R/W. CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT, PRAYING TO INITIATE THE CONTEMPT PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE ACCUSED FOR WILLFUL DISOBEDIENCE OF THE COURTS ORDER NOs.72734-72794/2012(SR) DISPOSED ON 26/02/2013 VIDE ANNEXURE-A. : 14 :
THESE CCCs COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, K.L.MANJUNATH, J., MADE THE FOLLOWING:
O R D E R
The respondents are not present. Since, the petitioners have failed to array the proper accused, these petitions are not maintainable.
Therefore, the contempt petitions are dismissed granting liberty for the petitioners to file fresh contempt petition in accordance with law.
SD/- JUDGE
SD/- JUDGE Ct:byg/- Vnp*