Peter Jansen Framing Nature

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Peter Jansen Framing Nature framing nature framing Searching for (implicit) religious elements in the communication about nature Searching for (implicit) religious elements in the communication about nature framing nature Peter Jansen framing nature Searching for (implicit) religious elements in the communication about nature Peter Jansen framing nature Searching for (implicit) religious elements in the communication about nature THESIS COMMITTEE Peter Jansen Promotor Prof. Dr H. Jochemsen Special Professor Reformational Philosophy Wageningen University & Research Co-promotors Prof. Dr F.W.J. Keulartz Emeritus Professor Environmental Philosophy Radboud University Nijmegen THESIS Dr J. van der Stoep submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of doctor Professor Journalism and Communication at Wageningen University Ede Christian University of Applied Sciences by the authority of the Rector Magnificus, Prof. Dr A.P.J. Mol, Other members in the presence of the Prof. Dr M.N.C. Aarts, Wageningen University & Research Thesis Committee appointed by the Academic Board Dr M.A.M. Drenthen, Radboud University Nijmegen to be defended in public Dr A.C.M. Roothaan, VU Amsterdam on Wednesday 14 June 2017 Prof. Dr M.G.C. Schouten, Wageningen University & Research at 4 p.m. in the Aula. This research was conducted under the auspices of the Wageningen School of Social Sciences 2 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents 1 GENERAL INTRODUCTION 9 1.1 Introduction 11 1.2 Government communication and changing society 15 1.3 Nature experiences and religious subtexts 17 1.4 Casestudy Tiengemeten 19 1.5 Outline of the thesis 20 2 THEORIZING GOVERNMENT COMMUNICATION WITH REGARD TO THE DUTCH NATURE POLICY 23 2.1 Introduction 25 2.2 Contextual turn 27 2.3 Closer examination of communication 33 2.4 Discussion 44 3 GOVERNMENT COMMUNICATION AS A NORMATIVE PRACTICE 49 3.1 Introduction 51 3.2 Normative structure of practices 53 3.3 Structural analysis of government communication 57 3.4 Discussion 68 Peter Jansen framing nature 4 IN SEARCH OF RELIGIOUS ELEMENTS Searching for (implicit) religious elements in the communication about nature IN THE DUTCH NATURE POLICY 73 200 pages 4.1 Introduction 75 PhD thesis Wageningen University, Wageningen, the Netherlands (2017) 4.2 Socio-historical context of the Dutch nature policy 76 With references, with summaries in English and Dutch 4.3 Theorizing views of nature 85 4.4 Discussion 95 ISBN 978-94-6343-132-3 DOI 10.18174/409678 4 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS 5 WISTFUL WILDERNESS: COMMUNICATION ABOUT ‘NEW’ NATURE IN THE NETHERLANDS 97 5.1 Introduction 99 5.2 Theoretical framework 103 5.3 Methodological approach 106 5.4 Results discourse of key actors 112 5.5 Results of visitors’ opinions 117 5.6 Discussion 120 6 NOTIONS OF THE SUBLIME: A CASE STUDY INTO LAYERS OF DEPTH IN EXPERIENCES OF NATURE 125 6.1 Introduction 127 6.2 Theoretical framework 129 6.3 Experiences 132 6.4 Surface frames 134 6.5 Deep frames 140 6.6 Discussion 144 7 GENERAL DISCUSSION 153 7.1 Introduction 155 7.2 Evaluative and methodological reflection 156 7.3 Normative character of communication 158 7.4 Religious subtexts in the communication 160 7.5 Paradox in nature experiences 163 7.6 Nature experiences and secular spirituality 166 7.7 Final Conclusion 169 REFERENCES 171 SUMMARY 185 SAMENVATTING (IN DUTCH) 190 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 197 CURRICULUM VITAE 199 6 7 5 WISTFUL WILDERNESS: COMMUnication ABOUT ‘NEW’ natURE IN THE N7ETHerlands 9 1 General Introduction 8 9 1 GENERAL INTRODUCTION General Introduction `Tiengemeten (…) It falls outside our order. And that changes everything. The traditional residents of Tiengemeten were farmers, families who had lived there since time immemorial and who knew everything about timelessness and patience. Then the creators came alongside God, the engineers of meadows, marshes, flowers and birds, enforcers of order in its most extreme form, the tamers and divers of Circus Nature.’ ~ GEERT MAK ~1 1.1 INTRODUCTION For more than one thousand years, the Dutch have wrested land from the sea. The Dutch transformed their country from a swampy river delta into an ordered land with a significant agricultural image. ‘Cattle instead of sheep have been Dutch rural icons since van Ruysdael’s 17th century paintings,’ Lowenthal (2007) argues, ‘a dappled hide against a green landscape is more a logo of the Neth- erlands than the tulip’ (646). However, on 7 March 1993, The New York Times published an article with the intriguing title: ‘Dutch Do the Unthinkable: Sea Is Let In’. The journalist notes with some surprise that the Dutch intend to make holes in dikes and flood their fertile country (again). 1 Quote taken from the preface to the book Over het Vuile Gat This ‘flooding of the country’ is a result of a more (2007) by Ton van der Graaf. offensive approach by the Dutch government that 10 11 1.1 INTRODUCTION 1 GENERAL INTRODUCTION was launched as part of the Nature Policy Plan presented in 1990 (Zwannikken, In this PhD thesis, I will argue that the government is primarily juridically qual- 2001). The period up to 1990 was characterized by increasing attention for nature ified (cf. Zwart, 1994), and nature conservation NGOs are value-oriented and, conservation and the adoption of a so-called defensive policy. Attempts were therefore, rather morally qualified. However, in the collaboration between the made to retain what existed but, at the same time, it became clear that terrain was government and the NGOs, the government supports with its instruments (laws being consumed, and nature was losing out (Kockelkoren 2000). In other words, and regulations, including budget) the (moral) value orientation of the NGOs, a more offensive approach was deemed necessary as the number of plants and an- i.e., the realization of the values of the NGOs. At the same time, the NGOs execute imals was shrinking, biodiversity was decreasing, and the land devoted to nature the nature policy of the government. A good example of such a synergistic relation- in the Netherlands was dwindling (Hajer, 2003). An important consequence of ship involving an intermingling of governmental and nongovernmental actors is the this more offensive approach is the achievement of a National Nature Network, following quotation from page 5 of the vision document 2010 - 2022 of Tiengemeten: known as the Ecologische Hoofdstructuur before 2013 and generally abbreviated as EHS. Within this national nature network, the conservation, restoration, and Natuurmonumenten wants to develop the concept of nature island development of nationally and internationally important ecosystems are given Tiengemeten together with the provincial and local government and with shape. As a consequence, in recent decades, the Dutch government has purchased the several operators on the island: a guided natural freshwater tidal a substantial amount of land to give ‘back to nature’. In a sense, this is a second landscape, with distinctive culturalhistorical opportunities for nature and transformation, i.e., from agriculture into nature. Communication about this landscape experiences, where the visitor experiences space and quiet. second transformation is my topic of interest and is central to this PhD thesis. This Natuurmonumenten is dependent on support from governments, business study concentrates on government communication. However, it appears that NGOs companies and individuals to durable maintain nature island Tiengemeten. are intimately involved in the realization of the new nature policy and the commu- nication about it. This situation requires clarification. Similar to, for instance, the Dutch private broadcasting organisations with the money they receive from the government, nature conservation NGOs function as In the so called Natuurakkoord, established at the end of 2011, it was agreed that delegated executors of the Dutch policy. Otherwise stated, established Dutch na- the central government of the Netherlands is responsible for the framework (laws ture policy is de facto executed through nature conservation NGOs, leaving them and regulations) and ambitions of nature policy. Based on the Wet Natuurbescher­ a degree of freedom within the contours of government policy. As a consequence, ming, effective since the beginning of 2017, the central government is obliged to although the focus of this study is on communication that is actually produced by compose a national nature vision whereby the government broadly describes the an NGO (chapters 4 – 6), the synergistic relationship of this NGO and the gov- Dutch nature policy. However, the provincial governments are responsible for the ernment, at least in the example of Tiengemeten, implies that the communication completion, i.e., concretising and implementing the nature policy in the Neth- can actually be considered as (also) government communication on that iconic erlands. This is mostly accomplished in collaboration with nature conservation example of the new nature policy of the Dutch government. This, in my opinion, NGOs such as Natuurmonumenten, Staatsbosbeheer, and the various Provinciale justifies that we analyse that communication as government communication Landschappen.The involvement of nature conservation NGOs is, according to (chapters 2 and 3) and as governmental nature policy (chapter 4). Van der Zouwen (2006), a traditional characteristic of the Dutch nature policy. Hence, she speaks about the intermingling of governmental and nongovernmen- As mentioned above, the focus of this PhD thesis is on communication that is tal actors. With regards to the Veluwe, a well-known forest-rich nature reserve in actually produced by NGOs. In the communication of NGOs, a sharp distinction the Netherlands, she concluded that, although the national government brought is made between ‘real’ nature and landscapes that are influenced by man. Met- in budget and designated the area as an important core area with regards to aphorical words and images are used, e.g., ‘where you hear the silence, feel the the realization of the EHS, the national government has no dominant position emptiness’ or, as illustrated in the quotation below: because of the dependency of what she refers to as ‘diverse landowning actors’ (199).
Recommended publications
  • De Oostvaardersplassen Nature Reserve
    Renewal EDPA expert report 3rd renewal Oostvaardersplassen NR The Netherlands Prof. Dr. Maurice Hoffmann www.inbo.be © Jasja Dekker, aerial view of the marshland area of the Nature Reserve Oostvaardersplassen Oostvaardersplassen NR - • 1968 impoldering Flevoland history• 1974 construction of quay to preserve marsh • 1982 construction of railway • 1983 introduction heck cattle • 1984 introduction of konik horses • 1986 designation as a natural monument • 1989 designation as a Birds Directive • 1989 designation as Wetland under the Ramsar Convention • 1992 introduction of red deer • 1996 in management Staatsbosbeheer • 1999 Appraisal of the European diploma for protected areas (EDPA) • 1999 Establishing Ethical Guidelines • 2000 Establishing the Guidelines for Large Grazers by the House of Representatives • 2004 Renewal of the European diploma for protected areas (EDPA) • 2005 Parliamentary debate on winter mortality in OVP • 2006 ICMO report on Oostvaardersplassen management • 2007 Court of Appeal ruling on the big grazers • 2009 Second renewal European diploma for protected areas (EDPA) • 2010 Final designation decision Natura 2000 published • 2010 ICMO report evaluation management • 2010 Parliamentary debate about bringing forward the evaluation of nature policy • 2011 First helicopter count of large grazers • 2013 Film “De Nieuwe Wildernis” is presented and attracts over 700 000 visitors • 2016 Natura 2000 management plan is established • 2017 Agreement between the Ministry of Economic Affairs and GS Province Flevoland • 2017 Province of Flevoland: initiative proposal Oostvaardersplassen area • 2018 50 years of Oostvaardersplassen and 100 years of Zuiderzee law • 2018 Commission van Geel: advice management Oostvaardersplassen 3 www.inbo.bec Management 4 Large herbivore management www.inbo.be 5 Condition 1 In the context of the development of the Lelystad airport ensure that the flight paths as determined in 2016 exclude overflights of the Oostvaarderplassen Nature Reserve.
    [Show full text]
  • Marker Wadden - a Laboratory for Living with Nature the 9Th Emila Summer School | 25 August–2 September 2017 | Amsterdam, the Netherlands Colophon
    Marker Wadden - A Laboratory for Living with Nature The 9th EMiLA Summer School | 25 August–2 September 2017 | Amsterdam, the Netherlands colophon Teachers EMiLA design studio: ESALA - Lisa Mackenzie, Tiago Torres Campos ETSAB - Luis Maldonado ENSP - Karin Helms LUH - Martin Pominsky, Kendra Busche Academy of Architecture: Yuka Yoshida, Maike van Stiphout Thanks to: Natuurmonumenten, Staatsbosbeheer, Provincie Flevoland, Urban Campsite Amsterdam, Volkshotel, gemeente Amsterdam Academy of Architecture Amsterdam 31 October 2017 source: www.natuurmonumenten.nl - John Gundlach Foreword The EMiLA summer of 2017 began with sailing on a historic ship from the centre of boat at the island was overwhelming, awakened by shore swallows, chatting on Amsterdam to the Marker Wadden. It is the study site of the summer school, and the mooring ropes of our sailing ship. We loved the place! Welcoming people will a part of the newly created ‘Nieuw Land National Park’. We spent two nights on definitely create support for this adventurous project. this new island and took a tour guided by ‘Natuurmonumenten’ (the Society for the Preservation of Nature in the Netherlands). The next day, we took a bus tour Natuurmonumenten is developing a settlement, a walking track and a beach to through the National Park road around the Markermeer lake, visiting unique Dutch seduce the people to love the place. We studied the settlement with architecture, landscape sites such as the Houtribdijk, Oostvaardersplassen and De Realiteit. urbanism and landscape architecture students. Designers were tasked with These experiences provided inspiration and knowledge to make a design for the making a settlement and improving the conditions for nature at the same time.
    [Show full text]
  • Amsterdam City Card by Using the START at Amsterdam Central Station
    Bus Centrum Bus stop 34 35 Public Transport Map 25 Railway 3 Batavia Stad A6 Bicycle route Bataviahaven A 0 1 2 3 4 5 km 3 37 9 Lelystad Station Lelystad Train Station Almere Centrum 25 3 7 148 Almere Festival- plein Landdrostdreef r Schoutstraat e Wijsgeerbaan Bankierbaan e 7 Spoordreef r m 148 Natuurpark e Lelystad Cinemadreef k Schrijverstraat r Hospitaaldreef a Natuurpark Grote M Markt Stadhuisplein Glazenier- Stadhuisstr. Oostvaarders straat Spoordreef Lelystad Airport Korte Promenade Plassen Aviodrome 7 148 De Diagonaal busbaan Belfort Schutter- straat De Corridor Hospitaaldreef g e w Cita- b i r Wagenmakerbaan del t 67 IJsselmeerdijk u busbaan o Forum Bordes H Flevostr. Flevoziekenhuis Blekerstraat Forum B 20 min Traverse 97 Markerwaarddijk 55 Koetsier- Esplanade Deventerpad Esplanade Meeresteinkade baan Ma Doesburgkade Lelystad rke PIT 98 rwa 68 Museumweg ard Veiligheids- dijk museum Schouwburg r 64 Almere e Almere Oostvaarders a t Museumweg Hengelostraat We e r w Oostvaardersdijk 53 Lommerrijk 59 er Almere Buiten A6 me we lu 52 e Amsterdam Central Station V 50 Batavia Stad Fashion Outlet Batavia Almere Museumweg Almere Almere B Parkwijk Replica Visitor Centres & Highlights Pampus Centrum Museum Houtribweg Muiderpoort I J Almere I amsterdam Visitor Centre m Exposure (2010) Museum Central Station or Amsterdam Airport Schiphol Science Park Muziekwijk Bus stop e Batavialand iamsterdam.com/area e Lelybaan Citybus 3 r Almere and shuttle not valid O Strand o A VVV Lelystad (vvvlelystad.nl) in ARTT s t v VVV Almere a B (visitalmere.com)
    [Show full text]
  • T-Pvs/De(2019)
    Strasbourg, 8 March 2019 T-PVS/DE (2019) 11 [de11e_2019.docx] CONVENTION ON THE CONSERVATION OF EUROPEAN WILDLIFE AND NATURAL HABITATS Standing Committee 39th meeting Strasbourg, 3-6 December 2019 __________ REPORT ON THE SPOT EXPERT APPRAISAL OF THE DE OOSTVAARDERSPLASSEN NATURE RESERVE (NETHERLANDS) 30-31 August 2018 Document prepared by Mr Maurice Hoffmann (Belgium) This document will not be distributed at the meeting. Please bring this copy. Ce document ne sera plus distribué en réunion. Prière de vous munir de cet exemplaire. T-PVS/DE (2019) 11 - 2 - Table of contents 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. - 4 - 2. Visit programme ......................................................................................................................................... - 5 - 3. Summarized original motivation for application for an EDPA for Oostvaardersplassen ............................ - 6 - 3.1 Vegetation .......................................................................................................................................... - 6 - 3.2 Ornithological features ....................................................................................................................... - 6 - 4. Description of the present Nature Reserve .................................................................................................. - 7 - 4.1 History of the Nature Reserve ...........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Wild’ What the Oostvaardersplassen Can Tell Us About Dutch Constructions of Nature
    Meghan Buurmans Debating the ‘wild’ What the Oostvaardersplassen can tell us about Dutch constructions of nature Master’s thesis in Global Environmental History Abstract Buurmans M. 2021. Debating the ‘wild’: What the Oostvaardersplassen can tell us about Dutch constructions of nature. Uppsala, Dept of Archaeology and Ancient History. This thesis discusses key conflicts in the Oostvaardersplassen. These conflicts include the contestation of the Oostvaardersplassen as wilderness, the debate on grazer mortality, and the debate on culling. Through Actor Network Theory, the actors involved in the Oostvaardersplassen are discussed. A number of documents are selected for the different actors to do a qualitative analysis of communication on the Oostvaardersplassen. The Oostvaardersplassen is a unique area, claimed from the sea and fully manmade, with a management philosophy with aspects from rewilding theories. Recurring themes in the actor documents are studied, such as the definitions of the terms ‘nature’ ‘wilderness’ and the use of interventions. In addition, the documents are analysed on their use of rhetoric tools and the way they discuss the general public in the Oostvaardersplassen debates. The nature of the Oostvaardersplassen as an experiment, the strong presence of emotions in the debates and the unclear definition of goals and purposes lead to a more fractured stage for the actors and the debate. While the Oostvaardersplassen is successful as an area for experimentation, learning, and as a nature reserve in the midst of the Netherlands, these concluding issues are an important consideration in making the Oostvaardersplassen’s debate less volatile. Keywords: The Oostvaardersplassen, Construction of nature, Nature management, Intervention, Culling, Grazers, Wilderness, Bird reserve.
    [Show full text]
  • How to Develop a Hotel in the Metropolitan Region Amsterdam Contents
    How to develop a hotel in the Metropolitan Region Amsterdam Contents 1 Introduction page 5 1.1 Background page 5 1.2 Reading Guide page 5 2 The Netherlands and the MRA page 7 2.1 The Netherlands page 7 2.2 The Metropolitan Region Amsterdam page 8 2.3 Accessibilty and connectivity page 9 3 The European Hotel Classification System page 11 4 The Hotel Market in the MRA page 13 5 Leisure Attractions page 15 6 Potential partners to work with page 17 7 Collaboration within the MRA, Province and Municipality page 19 7.1 Municipality page 19 7.2 MRA page 19 7.3 Province page 19 7.4 In Short page 19 8 Starting a new business in the MRA page 21 8.1 Registering your business page 21 8.2 Legal entities page 21 8.3 Working Permits page 21 8.4 Taxes page 22 9 Hotel development process page 23 10 Potential development areas in the MRA Region page 25 11 Glossary page 65 12 Overview hotel and leisure real-estate events page 67 13 Colophon page 71 2 Foreword 1 The number of people visiting the Metropolitan Region Amsterdam (MRA) will keep on growing in the years to come. Because of the economic interest the MRA, consisting of 32 municipalities, two provinces and the Transport Authority Amsterdam, will facilitate this growth. With its 2.5 million inhabitants, 11 million hotel guests, 250,000 companies and 102 data centers, combined with excellent connections and two airports, the MRA can be seen as one of the most attractive business- and leisure areas in the world.
    [Show full text]