Arxiv:1908.00918V3 [Cond-Mat.Stat-Mech] 21 Oct 2019 17 Netically Ordered ; Collective Density Excitations in Supercon- Group on the Ensuing Dispersion Relation Ωk
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Higgs and Goldstone Modes in Crystalline Solids Marco Vallone1, a) Dipartimento di Elettronica e Telecomunicazioni, Politecnico di Torino, corso Duca degli Abruzzi 24, 10129 Torino, Italy. In crystalline solids, the acoustic phonon can be described either as a Goldstone or as a non-Abelian gauge boson. However, the non-Abelianity of the related gauge group apparently makes the acoustic phonon a frequency-gapped mode, in contradiction with the other description. In a different perspective overcoming this contradiction, both acous- tic and optical phonon – the latter never appearing following the other two approaches – emerge respectively as the gapless Goldstone (phase) and the gapped Higgs (amplitude) fluctuation mode of an order parameter arising from the spontaneous breaking of a global symmetry, without invoking the gauge principle. In addition, the Higgs mechanism describes all the phonon-phonon interactions, including a possible perturbation of the acoustic phonon’s frequency dispersion relation induced by the eventual optical phonon, a peculiar behavior able to produce mini-gaps inside the phonon Brillouin zone. I. INTRODUCTION and correspond to Goldstone modes emerging from the break- ing of a continuous spatial symmetry, the translational invari- 21,22 The spontaneous breakdown of a continuous symmetry im- ance, broken by the presence of the crystal lattice . It is plies the emergence of a massless bosonic particle for each said that all these collective excitations originate from one of broken generator of the involved symmetry group. This is the the so-called emergence principles, in this case the Goldstone Nambu-Goldstone theorem1,2 in a nutshell, forming the ba- theorem, since they emerge from the very beginning. sis of the Standard Model of the fundamental interactions. In Nevertheless, in condensed matter systems as well as in addition, the Higgs mechanism3, described as a case of spon- high energy particle physics, interactions are mediated by taneous symmetry breaking (SSB), plays a prominent role in gauge bosons, appearing when local gauge invariance with re- the Standard Model, providing the mass for the gauge bosons spect to a given symmetry group is requested for the system’s of the electroweak interactions and for the fermions4. Lagrangian density23. These concepts are seemingly far removed from physics In a seemingly similar way, it has been shown24 that by of conventional semiconductors and metals commonly em- gauging the spatial translational group T(3) in crystal lattice, ployed in electronics and optoelectronics industry. However, three gauge bosons appear to provide the local gauge invari- the Higgs mechanism, as described by P. W. Higgs in 1964 ance for the Lagrangian under the action of T(3). They can for particle physics3, is the relativistic analog of the plas- be identified with the three acoustic phonons and, as a major mon phenomenon described by P. W. Anderson one year be- feature of this approach, the elastic properties of solids and fore in superconductivity5, and the existence of Anderson- the acoustic phonon’s dynamical equations can be described Higgs modes in condensed matter physics – in superconduc- in close analogy with General Relativity field equations. In tors, cold-atoms in periodic lattices, in Bose-Einstein conden- fact, it turns out that the acoustic phonon travels in the crystal sates, in antiferromagnets, in charge density waves6–8 etc. – acting as a wavelike perturbation of the lattice, similarly to the seems pervasive. However, beside plasmons phenomenology5 graviton in vacuum, that travels as a wavelike perturbation of and related plasmonics9,10, presently the Higgs mechanism a locally flat differentiable manifold, both obeying very sim- has been acknowledged in semiconductors physics only in ilar field equations25–30. Acoustic phonons arise in this case somehow exotic materials, like e.g. in topological insulators, not as Goldstone, but as gauge bosons. Weyl semimetals, cuprates11–16, etc., although its role could A major concern regards whether the two descriptions be much more diffuse even in standard semiconductors. could possibly be in contradiction and to what extent. On the other hand, the Goldstone theorem is very general Ref. [24] describes in detail the linear limit of the acous- and it holds also in the non-relativistic condensed state of mat- tic phonon’s gauge theory, where the two descriptions ap- ter, where the massless bosons correspond to collective exci- pear in agreement, in particular providing in the long wave- tations with wavevector k and gapless frequency dispersion length limit (k ! 0) the same gapless frequency dispersion relation wk, that is wk!0 ! 0, where k = jkj. As a few exam- law wk = csk, where cs is the sound velocity in the given ples, spin waves in the Heisenberg model are bosons arising medium. However, the cited work does not explore in depth when the ground state of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian is mag- the consequences of the non-Abelianity of the involved gauge arXiv:1908.00918v3 [cond-mat.stat-mech] 21 Oct 2019 17 netically ordered ; collective density excitations in supercon- group on the ensuing dispersion relation wk. ductors arise from the spontaneous breaking of the electronic When more than one ion is present in the lattice elementary phase rotational U(1) symmetry18,19. Finally, as a more com- cell, another kind of phonon – the optical phonon20 – consti- mon example, in crystalline solids, collective excitations asso- tutes a further and independent vibration mode. In polar semi- ciated to lattice vibration modes are the acoustic phonons20, conductors, the electron–longitudinal optical (LO) phonon emission is the dominant intersubband scattering mechanism responsible for electrons thermalization. However, although LO-phonons are of crucial importance in semiconductors a)Electronic mail: e-mail [email protected] transport theory and electron dynamics31–35, in the gauge the- 2 20 ory of crystal lattice’s interactions they are left apart, not aris- a Bravais lattice translation vector R. UT may be written j ing as gauge bosons. as UT = 1 − e p j, where e j are real parameters, and the mo- In order to clarify these important points, in section II we mentum components p j = −ih¯¶ j are the three generators of give a short recap about the emergence of acoustic phonon as T(3), whose Lie algebra is described by [pi; p j] = 0. Similar Goldstone boson. In section III, after an introduction about considerations could be made for the other two subgroups. the issues behind gauging a spatial symmetry, we go beyond The underlying crystal lattice can be described38 as a po- the linear limit of the theory, finding that the obtained disper- tential −V(f) to be inserted into L and eventually depending j sion relation may result gapped (that is, wk!0 6= 0), in sharp from several fields f = ff g. If f0 is a the value of f that contrast with the gapless dispersion relation characteristic of minimizes V(f), the system’s ground state (the system’s true Goldstone bosons. vacuum) is the state for which f = f0. We can expand the po- In section IV we present a different and more general ap- tential V around its minimum, obtaining at the second order proach, showing that both acoustic and optical phonons may arise from a SSB which sets out an order parameter f. It 1 k j V(f) = V(f0) + (f − f0) (f − f0) Mk j; (2) follows that the Higgs mechanism plays an important role: 2 the amplitude fluctuations of f are Higgs modes, for which where a mass-like term appears in the Lagrangian, that makes the mode gapped, and we identify them with the optical phonons. ¶ 2V M = (3) Conversely, the phase fluctuations of f (Goldstone modes) are k j ¶f k¶f j the acoustic phonons, here revisited in a much more general f0 way that also sheds light on the seeming contradiction arisen is a symmetric matrix that in the Lagrangian plays the role of when interpreting the acoustic phonon either as Goldstone or a mass term, whose eigenvalues give the eventual masses of as gauge boson. Finally, in section VI main ideas and findings the fields ff jg. are summarized. The crystal lattice breaks both translational and rotational a In this work A and Bb are contravariant and covariant invariance making the system’s ground state not symmetric, m four-vectors, ¶m is the partial derivative ¶=¶x , where stan- and this can happen even if the Lagrangian is symmetric. To dard Greek indices a;b; m;::: = 0;:::3 are indices of space- be more clear, if we again consider the translations, the fields j j j j time coordinates on a four-dimensional differentiable man- f transform under the action of UT as f ! f + a(f)p , a ifold with metric gmn and connection Gmn , latin indices where a(f) is an infinitesimal parameter. Nevertheless, the (i; j;k;::: = 1;2;3) mark spatial components, whereas Greek symmetry of the Lagrangian can remain exact, provided indices with an “hat” mˆ ;nˆ ;::: = 0;:::3 are used for indices of local four-dimensional frames (vierbeins or tetrad indices) on V(f j) = V(f j + a(f)p j): (4) a flat Lorentzian space-time with Minkowski metric hmˆ nˆ = diag(+1;−1;−1;−1). The Einstein’s summation over re- Taylor expanding the Eq. (4), the same condition can be writ- peated index is always understood, and not-italicized “i” is ten as the imaginary unit. ¶V(f) a(f) = 0; (5) ¶f j II. GOLDSTONE THEOREM AND ACOUSTIC PHONONS and differentiating the Eq. (5) with respect to f k around the potential minimum f , we obtain Apart from superconductivity and exotic materials, things 0 are quite complicated even in the well-known world of solid- ¶a(f) ¶V ¶ 2V state crystals.