The Myth and Reality of the CSI Effect
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Load more
Recommended publications
-
The Potential Impact of Television on Jurors Prepared for August 2010 Impression and Pattern Evidence Symposium
Kimberlianne Podlas, JD Associate Professor University of North Carolina at Greensboro [email protected]; (336) 334-4196 The Potential Impact of Television on Jurors Prepared for August 2010 Impression and Pattern Evidence Symposium Introduction Because television is society’s most pervasive medium, we all have experience with and opinions about it. Our experiences, however, are not the same as expertise in the production of the medium, and our opinions cannot substitute for empirical facts about its effects. Particularly when forecasting the impact of television on juror pre- conceptions, biases, and decision-making, adjusting trial strategies accordingly, and/or making evidentiary decisions in response, justice requires that we privilege the facts about television above the perceptions and myths about it. To help separate fact from fiction and to guide practitioners, the following materials synopsize the main research findings regarding the influences of televisual depictions of law. First, to provide a foundation for understanding television’s effects and how they may operate in individual cases, the materials outline the primary theories of television impact. Next, the materials summarize the research on contemporary law television programs (in particular judge shows, crime procedurals, and lawyer dramas), and analyze the impacts these shows may or may not have. The Importance of Television to the Law Television’s power is undeniable: It is one of society’s primary conduits of information and agents of socialization (Shrum 1998). Indeed, much of what people know comes from television. Sometimes it supplements information from other sources, such as family, school, and work; other times it substitutes for direct experience, taking us into worlds with which we would otherwise have no contact (Signorielli 279-80; Podlas 2008, 11-14). -
CSI Effect’ Impacts Justice in Tucson
‘CSI effect’ impacts justice in Tucson Juries demand the Crime scenes: impossible of TV vs. reality investigators By Enric Volante and Kim Smith ARIZONA DAILY STAR May 8, 2005 Some Pima County jurors take longer to deliberate because they expect evidence to be as clear-cut and stunning as on hit TV shows like "CSI: Crime Scene DNA results Investigation." • TV: DNA results come back in a few hours. Because of the so-called "CSI effect." judges and attorneys are being more • REALITY: Nuclear DNA can take several selective when they choose jurors and days to a week to process, and the present cases, and some exasperated cops samples are normally tested in batches that are worrying that such TV shows could take about a month. It can take a month just to lead to criminals avoiding prison. get enough of a sample to test in mitochondrial DNA because it can be so Courts across the country are difficult to get enough matter from bone, teeth scrambling to deal with the phe- or hair. nomenon, according to news reports. In Phoenix, several criminal cases appear to have turned on the lack of such TV- inspired evidence, said Barnett Lotstein, a special assistant Maricopa County attorney. In Peoria, Ill., investigators matched the DNA from saliva on a rape victim's breast to the DNA of a gang member who said he never touched her. But jurors said police also should have tested the soil at the rape scene, and refused to convict Fingerprints the man. • TV: Fingerprints can be retrieved from And in San Francisco, homicide nearly any surface in nearly every case. -
Teacher Notes
Media Series - TV Teacher Notes Television in the Global Age Teachers’ Notes The resources are intended to support teachers delivering on the new AS and A level specifications. They have been created based on the assumption that many teachers will already have some experience of teaching Media Studies and therefore have been pitched at a level which takes this into consideration. Other resources are readily available which outline e.g. technical and visual codes and how to apply these. There is overlap between the different areas of the theoretical framework and the various contexts, and a “text-out” teaching structure may offer opportunities for a more holistic approach. Slides are adaptable to use with your students. Explanatory notes for teachers/suggestions for teaching are in the Teachers’ Notes. The resources are intended to offer guidance only and are by no means exhaustive. It is expected that teachers will subsequently research and use their own materials and teaching strategies within their delivery. Television as an industry has changed dramatically since its inception. Digital technologies and other external factors have led to changes in production, distribution, the increasingly global nature of television and the ways in which audiences consume texts. It is expected that students will require teacher-led delivery which outlines these changes, but the focus of delivery will differ dependent on texts chosen. THE JINX: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst Episode Suggestions Episode 1 ‘The Body in the Bay’ is the ‘set’ text but you may also want to look at others, particularly Episode 6 with its “shocking” conclusion. -
P25tv Layout 1
THURSDAY, AUGUST 31, 2017 TV PROGRAMS And Cat Noir 14:15 Future-Worm! 21:00 Ancient Aliens 05:48 SpongeBob SquarePants 19:30 Less Than Perfect 19:30 Food Factory USA 14:30 EastEnders 11:55 Disney Mickey Mouse 14:40 Kirby Buckets 22:00 Bible Secrets Revealed 06:12 SpongeBob SquarePants 20:00 The Tonight Show Starring 19:55 Food Factory USA 15:00 Death In Paradise 12:00 Welcome To The Ronks 15:05 Lab Rats: Bionic Island 23:00 How 2 Win 06:36 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Jimmy Fallon 20:20 How Do They Do It? 15:55 Doctor Who 12:15 Hank Zipzer 15:30 Walk The Prank 07:00 The Loud House 21:00 Seinfeld 20:45 Food Factory 16:45 Stella 12:40 Dog With A Blog 15:55 Right Now Kapow 07:24 Rabbids Invasion 21:30 Seinfeld 21:10 Science Of The Movies 17:30 New Tricks 00:00 Escaping Polygamy 13:05 Star Darlings 16:25 K.C. Undercover 07:48 Get Blake 22:00 Modern Family 22:00 Food Factory USA 18:20 Carters Get Rich 01:00 Celebrity Ghost Stories 13:10 Good Luck Charlie 16:50 Kirby Buckets Warped 08:12 Harvey Beaks 22:30 Modern Family 22:25 Food Factory USA 18:45 EastEnders 02:00 My Haunted House 13:35 Austin & Ally 17:15 Mech-X4 08:36 Sanjay And Craig 23:00 The Big C 19:15 Death In Paradise 03:00 My Haunted Vacation 14:00 Jessie 17:40 Gravity Falls 09:00 Rank The Prank 23:30 Late Night With Seth Meyers 20:10 Holby City 04:00 Escaping Polygamy 14:25 Lolirock 18:05 Disney Mickey Mouse 00:20 Counting Cars 09:24 Henry Danger 21:00 Carters Get Rich 05:00 Celebrity Ghost Stories 14:50 The Zhuzhus 18:10 Milo Murphyʼs Law 00:45 Counting Cars 09:48 100 Things To Do Before 21:30 Mum 06:00 It Takes A Killer 15:15 Whisker Haven Tales With 18:35 Disney11 01:10 Forged In Fire High School 22:00 Uncle 08:00 The First 48 The Palace Pets 19:00 Disney11 02:00 Hunting Hitler 10:12 Game Shakers 09:00 Homicide Hunter 15:20 Miraculous Tales Of Ladybug 19:25 K.C. -
TV Listings Aug21-28
SATURDAY EVENING AUGUST 21, 2021 B’CAST SPECTRUM 7 PM 7:30 8 PM 8:30 9 PM 9:30 10 PM 10:30 11 PM 11:30 12 AM 12:30 1 AM 2 2Stand Up to Cancer (N) NCIS: New Orleans ’ 48 Hours ’ CBS 2 News at 10PM Retire NCIS ’ NCIS: New Orleans ’ 4 83 Stand Up to Cancer (N) America’s Got Talent “Quarterfinals 1” ’ News (:29) Saturday Night Live ’ Grace Paid Prog. ThisMinute 5 5Stand Up to Cancer (N) America’s Got Talent “Quarterfinals 1” ’ News (:29) Saturday Night Live ’ 1st Look In Touch Hollywood 6 6Stand Up to Cancer (N) Hell’s Kitchen ’ FOX 6 News at 9 (N) News (:35) Game of Talents (:35) TMZ ’ (:35) Extra (N) ’ 7 7Stand Up to Cancer (N) Shark Tank ’ The Good Doctor ’ News at 10pm Castle ’ Castle ’ Paid Prog. 9 9MLS Soccer Chicago Fire FC at Orlando City SC. Weekend News WGN News GN Sports Two Men Two Men Mom ’ Mom ’ Mom ’ 9.2 986 Hazel Hazel Jeannie Jeannie Bewitched Bewitched That Girl That Girl McHale McHale Burns Burns Benny 10 10 Lawrence Welk’s TV Great Performances ’ This Land Is Your Land (My Music) Bee Gees: One Night Only ’ Agatha and Murders 11 Father Brown ’ Shakespeare Death in Paradise ’ Professor T Unforgotten Rick Steves: The Alps ’ 12 12 Stand Up to Cancer (N) Shark Tank ’ The Good Doctor ’ News Big 12 Sp Entertainment Tonight (12:05) Nightwatch ’ Forensic 18 18 FamFeud FamFeud Goldbergs Goldbergs Polka! Polka! Polka! Last Man Last Man King King Funny You Funny You Skin Care 24 24 High School Football Ring of Honor Wrestling World Poker Tour Game Time World 414 Video Spotlight Music 26 WNBA Basketball: Lynx at Sky Family Guy Burgers Burgers Burgers Family Guy Family Guy Jokers Jokers ThisMinute 32 13 Stand Up to Cancer (N) Hell’s Kitchen ’ News Flannery Game of Talents ’ Bensinger TMZ (N) ’ PiYo Wor. -
“DOA for a Day”
“DOA for a Day” Episode #415 Written By John Dove & Peter M. Lenkov DIR: Christine Moore © MMVIII SHOOTING SCRIPT 2/29/08 CBS Broadcasting Inc. and Entertainment AB Funding LLC All Rights Reserved No portion of this material may be copied or distributed without the prior consent of CBS Broadcasting, Inc. Ep. #415 – “DOA for a Day” Shooting Script – 2/29/08 “DOA for a Day” Ep. #415 CASTU LIST MAC TAYLOR STELLA BONASERA DANNY MESSER DR. SHELDON HAWKES DET. DON FLACK LINDSAY MONROE DET. JESSICA ANGELL ADAM ROSS DR. SID HAMMERBACK SUSPECT X RUSS MCHENRY (War hero and son of one of Suspect X’s previous vics, Judge McHenry) JORDAN GATES (the Mayor’s Criminal Justice Coordinator Mac’s helped before; Kelly’s boss) BARTENDER (At Club Random, the Cosplay club) TAYLOR AVATAR (Is killed by Suspect X’s Avatar at the club) SUSPECT X AVATAR (Let’s our team know she’s watching) FeaturedU Characters (non-speaking only) Male (V.O. only) (NY Crime Catchers) Unis Kelly Mann (Vic made to look like Suspect X; Jordan Gates’ assistant) ND Techs M.E. Techs Detectives Mayor’s Protection Detail Sound Techs Club Random Patrons Dr. Joseph Kirkbaum (made Kelly Mann look like Suspect X as payback to her but then became her vic as well) ESU Officers Sergeants Williams and Clark (on teleconference) FBI Special Agents Steve Beck and Kevin Halinan (on teleconference) ND Woman (Disguised as Suspect X sent in by her to make sure it’s not a trap) Uniformed Officer ESU Officers Pedestrians Ep. #415 – “DOA for a Day” Shooting Script – 2/29/08 “DOA for a Day” Ep. -
Global Upfront New and Returning Series
GLOBAL ANNOUNCES STAR-STUDDED 2021/22 PRIMETIME LINEUP FILLED WITH THE MOST IN-DEMAND NEW PICK- UPS AND RETURNING HIT BLOCKBUSTERS New Global Original Family Law and Franchise Expansions CSI: Vegas, NCIS: Hawai’i, and FBI: International Lead Global’s Fall Schedule The Highly-Anticipated Return of Survivor Joins New Seasons of Hits The Equalizer, Tough As Nails, New Amsterdam, and More New Comedy Ghosts and Audience Favourite United States of Al Bring the Laughs to Global This Fall Stream Anytime with STACKTV or the Global TV App Additional photography and press kit material can be found here. Follow us on Twitter at @GlobalTV_PR To share this release: https://bit.ly/3w3lm3x #CorusUpfront For Immediate Release TORONTO, June 8, 2021 – Ahead of the #CorusUpfront on June 9, Global unveils its 2021/22 programming lineup loaded with exciting series pick-ups and returning established hits. Global’s fall offering promises to deliver a dynamic and diverse schedule filled with thrilling dramas, hilarious comedies, captivating reality television, and much more. Adding 10 new series, including five new primetime series debuting this fall, Global’s schedule features 18 hours of simulcast with four out of seven days entirely simulcast in primetime. Corus’ conventional network offers Canadians a full suite of options for TV lovers looking to stream its blockbuster franchises and hottest new shows in every genre, anytime they want on STACKTV and the Global TV App. “After an unprecedented year, Global is back in full force this fall with a jam-packed schedule of prestigious dramas, powerhouse franchises, and laugh-out-loud comedies,” said Troy Reeb, Executive Vice President, Broadcast Networks, Corus Entertainment. -
Subscribe to the Press & Dakotan Today!
PAGE 10B PRESS & DAKOTAN n FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 20, 2013 WEDNESDAY PRIMETIME/LATE NIGHT SEPTEMBER 25, 2013 3:00 3:30 4:00 4:30 5:00 5:30 6:00 6:30 7:00 7:30 8:00 8:30 9:00 9:30 10:00 10:30 11:00 11:30 12:00 12:30 1:00 1:30 BROADCAST STATIONS Arthur Å WordGirl Wild The Martha Nightly PBS NewsHour (N) (In Earthflight, A Nature NOVA Vikings con- Skeletons of the Sa- Last of BBC Charlie Rose (N) (In Tavis Smi- Well Read NOVA Vikings con- PBS (DVS) Å (DVS) Kratts Å Electric Speaks Business Stereo) Å Special Presenta- structed the Ulfberht hara (N) (In Stereo) Å Summer World Stereo) Å ley (N) Å Å structed the Ulfberht KUSD ^ 8 ^ Company Report tion (N) sword. Å Wine News sword. Å KTIV $ 4 $ Queen Latifah Ellen DeGeneres News 4 News News 4 Ent Revolution Å Law & Order: Special Victims Unit Å News 4 Jay Leno Jimmy Fallon Daly News 4 Extra (N) The Doctors (In Ste- Judge Judge KDLT NBC KDLT The Big Revolution The ef- Law & Order: Special Victims Unit “Surrender KDLT The Tonight Show Late Night With Last Call (Off Air) NBC reo) Å Judy Å Judy Å News Nightly News Bang fects of turning off the Benson; Imprisoned Lives” The search for De- News With Jay Leno (N) (In Jimmy Fallon (N) (In With Car- KDLT % 5 % (N) Å News (N) (N) Å Theory power. Å tective Benson. Å (N) Å Stereo) Å Stereo) Å son Daly KCAU ) 6 ) Dr. -
The Hung Jury: Scholarly Consensus on the Value of the CSI Effect in the Future of American Justice
Intersect, Volume 3, Number 1 (2010) The Hung Jury: Scholarly Consensus on the Value of the CSI Effect in the Future of American Justice Luke Francis Georgette Stanford University Fiction is the medium through which cultures imagine their past, present, and future through new and unique lenses, reflecting our former identity and future hopes and fears. Fiction also influences our expectations for the present and our future directions; touch-panel computers, space exploration, and instantaneous wireless communication, once prophesied by science-fiction writers, are now commonplace. Naysayers may point to our lack of planetary colonization and flying cars, but these too linger in our imagination as technology continues to bring us closer to their realization. While much of fiction is art, some fiction serves merely to entertain. Some fictional universes in television are distorted for the viewer’s pleasure to tell a more intriguing story, while relying on the “suspension of disbelief.” No disclaimer is given, however, that would enable viewers to recognize which components are verisimilar and which—to put it lightly—consider reality merely a jumping-off point. Likewise, no law or moral code obligates fiction to portray the true world. These licenses, however, mean little to viewers whose understandings, beliefs, and expectations are being subconsciously molded. The American television serial drama, C.S.I.: Crime Scene Investigation, is one of such universes in which the rules of reality are bent in the name of entertainment and narrative. Since its inception in 2000, it has remained one of the most popular programs on American and international television, generating two spin-off series and inspiring several other forensic crime shows, therefore representing a true social phenomenon. -
Influences of CSI Effect, Daubert Ruling, and NAS Report on Forensic Science Practices Timothy Patrick Scanlan Walden University
Walden University ScholarWorks Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies Collection 2015 Influences of CSI Effect, Daubert Ruling, and NAS Report on Forensic Science Practices Timothy Patrick Scanlan Walden University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/dissertations Part of the Criminology Commons, Criminology and Criminal Justice Commons, Law Commons, and the Public Policy Commons This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies Collection at ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Walden Dissertations and Doctoral Studies by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Walden University College of Social and Behavioral Sciences This is to certify that the doctoral dissertation by Timothy Scanlan has been found to be complete and satisfactory in all respects, and that any and all revisions required by the review committee have been made. Review Committee Dr. Stephen Morreale, Committee Chairperson, Public Policy and Administration Faculty Dr. Karel Kurst-Swanger, Committee Member, Public Policy and Administration Faculty Dr. James Mosko, University Reviewer, Public Policy and Administration Faculty Chief Academic Officer Eric Riedel, Ph.D. Walden University 2015 Abstract Influences of CSI Effect, Daubert Ruling, and NAS Report on Forensic Science Practices by Timothy P. Scanlan MSFS, Florida International University, 2003 BCJ, Loyola University of New Orleans, 1998 Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Public Policy and Administration Walden University August 2015 Abstract The media exaggerates the capabilities of crime laboratories while it publicizes the wrongdoings of individual forensic scientists. -
Fifty Years of Media and Forensic Science
Fifty years of media and forensic science Prof Niamh Nic Daeid Professor of Forensic Science Centre for Forensic Science University of Strathclyde Fifty years of media and forensic science – is there really a CSI effect ? Prof Niamh Nic Daeid Professor of Forensic Science Centre for Forensic Science University of Strathclyde 50 Years of Forensic Science – editorial commentary from the Journal of the Forensic Science Society/Science and Justice. Forensic Science Oral History project What do we know about the effect of the media on the understanding of Forensic Science ? The idea of TV ‘influence’ is nothing new There is a suggestion that TV programs such as CSI have an influence on jurors in terms of their expectations of the police, the legal professionals and the science presented. "Sir Arthur Conan Doyle had a considerable influence on popularizing scientific crime- detection methods through his fictional character Sherlock Holmes. It was Holmes who first applied the newly developing principles of serology, fingerprinting, firearm identification, and questioned document-examination long before their value was recognized and accepted by real life criminal investigators.” The Hounds Collection Vol. 10, May 2005 “ Nurtured by novels, radio, television and the newspapers, the forensic scientist is 1957-1966 almost always an omniscient university pathologist, who pronounces with authority on all subjects ” D. Patterson, 1965 1962-1978 “Perry Mason Syndrome” - defense attorneys claimed that jurors no longer came to court requiring the prosecution to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt… 1957-1966 ……but expected the defense to prove the accused’s innocence. Google trends : CSI V V Forensic V V V Forensic Forensic science portrayed as high-tech magic, solving crimes quickly and unerringly One estimate suggests that 40% of the “science” on CSI does not exist, and most of the rest is performed in ways that are unrealistic. -
The Jinx, the Imposter, and Re-Enacting the Digital Thriller in True Crime Documentaries
University of South Florida Scholar Commons Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School 3-23-2017 "You want it all to happen now!": The inxJ , The Imposter, and Re-enacting the Digital Thriller in True Crime Documentaries Brett ichM ael Phillips University of South Florida, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the Other Film and Media Studies Commons Scholar Commons Citation Phillips, Brett ichM ael, ""You want it all to happen now!": The inxJ , The mposI ter, and Re-enacting the Digital Thriller in True Crime Documentaries" (2017). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/6743 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. “You want it all to happen now!”: The Jinx, The Imposter, and Re-enacting the Digital Thriller in True Crime Documentaries by Brett Phillips A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Film Studies Department of Humanities and Cultural Studies College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Major Professor: Amy Rust, Ph.D. Maria Cizmic, Ph.D. Andrew Berish, Ph.D. Date of Approval: March 10, 2017 Keywords: True crime, Documentary, Digital, Thriller, Reenactment, Affect Copyright © 2017, Brett Phillips ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost, thank you to Amy, Maria, and Andrew for not only helping me shape this thesis—with both tiny chisel and sledgehammer—but for guiding me through an entire discipline with kindness and understanding.