Latin America URBAN DESIGN GROUP URBAN
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Winter 2016 Urban Design Group Journal 13URBA 7 N ISSN 1750 712X DESIgn LATIN AMERICA URBAN DESIGN GROUP URBAN DESIGN GROUP NewsUDG NEWS Both the UK’s National Planning Policy must offer in order to provide consistent VIEW FROM THE Framework and the Farrell Review promoted high standards of advice. CHAIR Design Reviews to provide assessment and Independent support, and ensure high design standards • Expert at both national and local levels. David • Multidisciplinary Recently a number of announcements have Tittle from the Design Network and Made, • Accountable been made in the built environment press and David Waterhouse from Design Council • Transparent about the appointment of design review CABE recently addressed the House of Lords • Proportionate groups tasked with improving the quality of Select Committee on the Built Environment • Timely high profile development proposals. The last to discuss how effective design reviews are. • Advisory were Design Council CABE, appointed to The conclusion was that more schemes • Objective set up and manage a Planning, Landscape, need to be reviewed at an earlier stage in • Accessible Architecture, Conservation and Engineering the design process. • Review Group (PLACE) for the Oak and Park Design reviews can sometimes be seen I have the benefit of currently sitting on the Royal Development Corporation. as a negative process. In the past David London Borough of Wandsworth Design Design Reviews originated in England Tittle has reflected on how design review Review Panel and enjoy the process of sup- in 1924 with the Royal Fine Art Commission originated from the old gentlemen’s club porting and encouraging good design. It reviewing building proposals. The respon- of the Royal Fine Art Commission, and the also offers me the opportunity to develop sibility for assessing major projects was Spanish inquisition that often came from my knowledge on considering and mediat- moved to CABE in 1999, with several other starchitects on the original CABE panel. ing what is design quality. I recommend that smaller local design review panels support- Luckily, design review panels today typi- all built environment professionals get in- ing local planning authorities and regional cally provide clear independent advice. The volved in such panels, both through joining panels emerging in 2002. These formed the Design Council CABE 2013 document Design them and taking schemes to review. national Design Network which still runs Review: Principles and Practice establishes • today (www.designnetwork.org.uk/). the following ten principles that a review Katy Neaves undertake work that they are competent to and other associated professionals and THE DIRECTOR’S do, ensuring that knowledge has remained specialists not infrequently adopt with each MUSINGS up to date and covered all relevant develop- other’. He urged better mutual respect and ments. Most codes of conduct are similar, collaboration between these professional and the requirements rational and just. But groups. How should professional organisations publishing a code is one thing; implement- This remains the way forward: good ensure that good practice is brought into ing it is quite another. urban design is about multi-disciplinary the built environment? For example, there Former UK Government adviser Paul teamwork and partnership between profes- are strong arguments in favour of keep- Morrell, speaking at the 2015 National Ur- sionals, politicians and public. There would ing speeds below 20mph in urban areas ban Design Conference, asked ‘Has anyone be great benefits if institutions and the to reduce the risk of death and injury and EVER been thrown out of an institution for wide research community could support create better conditions for walking and acting (within the law but) against the pub- one another to develop robust, rational, cycling. Should professionals designing lic interest?’ The reality is that professionals evidenced-based practice, and aid practi- residential developments with 40mph who put public interest above those of their tioners in implementing it. I hope the 2015 streets be expelled from their institutions paymasters will find themselves quickly out National Urban Design Conference, which for misconduct? of a job. But if considering the public inter- brought together eight professional or- To become a member of a profession est is too much to expect of individuals or ganisations in partnership, has helped this an individual must agree to abide by its single professional institutions in isolation, cause. I would like to thank the members of code of conduct. The Royal Town Planning what about greater collaboration? the Urban Design Group who worked tire- Institute demands that each member acts The first edition of Urban Design (August lessly and selflessly to make it happen.• with competence, honesty and integrity, 1980), quotes the late Francis Tibbalds and exercises independent professional calling for an end to ‘the dictatorial, ar- Robert Huxford judgement at all times. The Institution of rogant and divisive attitudes that architects, Civil Engineers requires its members only to planners, engineers, landscape architects UDG LONDON MILAN AND TURIN DIARY OF EVENTS WEDNESDAy 13 JANUARY UDG Study Tour 21-25 April 2016 Film Night – Urban Agriculture – Brooklyn Fully booked but if interested check with Farmer – Followed by Q and A [email protected] Unless otherwise indicated, all LONDON events are held at The Gallery, 70 Cowcross WEDNESDAy 10 FEBRUARY BYZANTINE PELOPONNESE Street, London EC1M 6EJ at 6.30 pm. Public Space – led by Philip Cave UDG Study Tour 4–12 June 2016 We shall be visiting places of medieval Note that there are many other events TUESDAy 15 MarCH Byzantine urbanism in the Peloponnese, run by UDG volunteers throughout the UK. Latin America Máni, Monemvasía and Loúsios Gorge. For the latest details and pricing, please The price of £710 (£660 for UDG check on the UDG website www.udg.org.uk/ UDG SOLENT members) includes travel and accommoda- events/udg THURSDAy 21 JANUARy 2016 tion. Further information is available from Update on Garden Cities – 4.00pm Alan Stones, phone 01376 571351 or email David Rudlin,Urbed, Savills offices, [email protected] 2 Charlotte Place Southampton. The last booking date is Friday 4 March. URBAN DESIGN ― WINter 2015 ― ISSUe 137 1 Winter 2016 Urban Design Group Journal 13 7 ISSN 1750 712X UrbaN 171 We all love to be in beautiful and well designed places that are full LatiN aMerica of life and richness! S o , w h y d o s o m a n y p l a c e s l a c k t h e s e q DesiGN u a l i t i e s ? Contents THE PLACE COMES FIRST At Urban Initiatives Studio we see the ‘place’ as our true client. We always look at the bigger picture. We think strategically and long term, and we aim to add quality to people’s lives. Our goal and passion is to create the right conditions for urban life to flourish. We love the complexity of urban environments where our urban design and masterplanning skills can come to the fore and where there is potential for many actors to play a role in shaping change. This issue has been generously sponsored FRANCIS TIBBALDS AWARDS locAL We like to work collaboratively with our clients, and with stakeholders and local people to develop a by Urban Initiatives Studio AUTHORITIES SHORTList 2016 common vision, to establish critical design moves and to set out a realistic path to delivery. Through this approach we aim to create places that 40 — Stockton High Street Regeneration, are successful and stand the test of time. COVER Stockton Borough Council 16th Century Plan of Cuzco, Peru, Georg 42 — People, Places, Projects, The 171 Braun and Frans Hagenberg’s Civitates Orbis Corporation of the City of London Terrarum, Cologne 1597, Bibliothèque Royale 44 — Brierley Hill Town Centre Urban Initiatives Studio Ltd. URBAN Exmouth House, 3-11 Pine Street London, EC1R 0JH, United Kingdom DESIGN +44 203 567 0715 / [email protected] GROUP de Belgique, Brussels Supplementary Planning Document, www.uistudio.co.uk URBAN DESIGN Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council GROUP FUTURE ISSUES Urban Design Group UD 138 Industrial urban design FRANCIS TIBBALDS AWARDS BOOKS CHAIR Katy Neaves UD 139 Tall buildings SHORTLIST 2016 PATRONS Irena Bauman, Alan Baxter, UD 140 Food and the city 46 — Emergent Urbanism: Urban Planning Dickon Robinson, Helle Søholt, Lindsey & Design in Times of Structural and Whitelaw and John Worthington UPDATE Systemic Change, Tigran Haas & Krister 03 — Underground Urbanism Olsson, Editors Office 03 — Learning from Europe 46 — Touching the City: Thoughts on Urban Urban Design Group 04 — The UDG Annual Conference Scale, Timothy Makower 70 Cowcross Street 06 — The Urban Design Library #16 47 — Young – Old, Urban Utopias of an London EC1M 6EJ 07 — My Favourite Plan Aging Society, Deane Simpson Tel 020 7250 0892 47 — Tactical Urbanism, Short Term Action Email [email protected] TOPIC: LATIN AMERICA for Long Term Change, Mike Lydon and Website www.udg.org.uk 08 — Latin America, Sebastian Loew Anthony Garcia 10 — The Laws of the Indies, Laura Alvarez 48 — Weather and the City: How Design Editorial Board 11 — Asuncion’s Historic Centre, Mabel Shapes the Urban Climate, Sanda Matthew Carmona, Richard Cole, Causarano Lenzholzer Alastair Donald, Tim Hagyard, 14 — Punta del Este: The Aparicio Saravia 48 — Designing for Hope: Pathways to Joe Holyoak, Sebastian Loew, Daniela Plan, Lucía and Jorge Pieri Regenerative Sustainability, Dominique Lucchese, Jane Manning, Chris Martin, 16 — The Role of Public Space in Mexican Hes and Chrisna du Plessis Malcolm Moor, Judith Ryser, Louie Sieh, Cities, Mauricio Hernández Bonilla 49 — The City as Resource: Text and Louise Thomas 19 — Vía Cordillera in Monterrey, Mexico, Projects 2005-2014, Chair of Prof. Kees Pedro Pesci Christiaanse, ETH Zurich, Tim Rieniets, Editors 22 — Metropolitan Development Plan Nicolas Kretschmann, Myriam Perret, Sebastian Loew (this issue) for Lima and Callao, Carlos Alberto Chair of Prof.