Legislative Assembly Hansard 1986
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Queensland Parliamentary Debates [Hansard] Legislative Assembly TUESDAY, 2 SEPTEMBER 1986 Electronic reproduction of original hardcopy Papers 2 September 1986 647 TUESDAY, 2 SEPTEMBER 1986 Mr SPEAKER (Hon. J. H. Warner, Toowoomba South) read prayers and took the chair at 11 a.m. ASSENT TO BILLS Assent to the following Bills reported by Mr Speaker— Govemment Loan BUI; Land Act Amendment BiU; Off-shore Facilities BiU; Pyramid Selling Schemes (Elimination) Act Amendment BUI; Roman Catholic Church Lands Act Amendment Bill; Workers' Compensation Act Amendment Bill. AUDITOR-GENERAL'S REPORT Public Accounts Mr SPEAKER announced the receipt from the Auditor-General of his report on his audit of the Public Accounts for the year ended 30 June 1986. Ordered to be printed. PETITIONS The Clerk announced the receipt of the foUowing petitions— Railway Staff Levels, Bundaberg From Mr Powell (108 signatories) praying that the Parliament of Queensland will not implement the proposed reduction in railway staff levels at Bundaberg. [A similar petition was received from Mr CampbeU (111 signatories).] One Vote, One Value Legislation From Mr Bums (82 signatories) praying that the Parliament of Queensland wiU revoke present legislation on electoral boundaries and replace it with legislation based on one vote, one value. Bayside Bus Company, Wynnum and Manly Services From Mr Bums (463 signatories) praying that the Parliament of Queensland will review the licence to the Bayside bus company if adequate services cannot be provided in Wynnum and Manly. Housing Commission Estate, Morris and Gynther Roads, Rothwell From Mr White (291 signatories) praying that the Pariiament of Queensland wiU take action to ensure that 50 per cent of the Housing Commission estate at Morris and Gynther Roads, RothweU is sold on the open market. Petitions received. PAPERS The following paper was laid on the table, and ordered to be printed— Report. Departmental Accounts Subsidiary to the Public Accounts for the year ended 30 June 1986. 648 2 September 1986 Ministerial Statements The following papers were laid on the table— Proclamation under the Diseases in Plants Act 1929-1972 Orders in Council under— Constitution Acts Amendment Act 1971-1983 Financial Administration and Audit Act 1977-1981 Queensland Intemational Tourist Centre Agreement Act 1978 City of Brisbane Market Act 1960-1985 and the Statutory Bodies Financial Artangements Act 1982-1984 Meat Industry Act 1965-1984 Primary Producers' Organisation and Marketing Act 1926-1985 Primary Producers' Organisation and Marketing Act 1926-1985 and the Statutory Bodies Financial Arrangements Act 1982-1984 Urban Public Passenger Transport Act 1984 and the Statutory Bodies Financial Arrangements Act 1982 Regulations under— Marine Parks Act 1982 Public Service Act 1922-1978 Agricultural Standards Act 1952-1981 Brands Act 1915-1979 Diseases in Plants Act 1929-1972 Fishing Industry Organization and Marketing Act 1982-1985 Poultry Industry Act 1946-1984 Reports— Barley Marketing Board (Qld) for the year ended 30 June 1985 Queensland Fish Board for the year ended 30 June 1985 Bread Industry Committee of Queensland for the year ended 30 June 1986. MINISTERIAL STATEMENTS Auditing of Queensland Day Committee Accounts Hon. Sir JOH BJELKE-PETERSEN (Barambah—Premier and Treasurer) (11.3 a.m.), by leave: Mr Speaker, since the House rose last Tuesday aftemoon, the Leader of the Opposition has seen fit to make numerous statements to the media, which have received wide publicity, alleging that I misled the House in an answer that I gave on Tuesday moming, 26 August 1986, on Govemment auditing of the Queensland Day Committee. I most certainly have not misled the House. The basis of the claim by the Leader of the Opposition appears to be that the Crown prosecutor in the District Court trial of Judith Anne Callahan, Mr D. Bullock, made a statement that no audit was conducted in relation to the Queensland Day Committee up to the year 1984-85, whereas I had informed the House that it was untme that no audit of the financial activities of the Queensland Day Committee had been carried out by the Auditor-General's Department between the time when the committee began operation in May 1981 and 1984-85. The facts speak for themselves. I hope that the representatives of the media here today will give as much publicity to my remarks as they have given to the misleading statements of the Leader of the Opposition in recent days. Mr R. J. Gibbs interjected. Mr SPEAKER: Order! The honourable member for Wolston. Ministerial Statements 2 September 1986 649 Sir JOH BJELKE-PETERSEN: In a miiusterial statement that I made to the House on Tuesday, 18 Febmary 1986, I stated, amongst other things, that "ftmds are allocated to the committee in the Estimates of my department and these fiinds are audited annuaUy by the Auditor-General. The audit has found no anomalies in the expenditure of these funds whatsoever." The Crown prosecutor—and this is what the Leader of the Opposition neglected to say—drew to the court's attention that the accounts set up by Mrs CaUaghan, without the approval of the Queensland Day Committee, were not authorised and, as a conse quence, had not been audited. I would have thought that even the Leader of the Opposition would understand that the Auditor-General could not audit accounts that he did not know existed. It is as simple as that, but the Leader of the Opposition could not work that out. For the benefit of the Leader of the Opposition, I state that the Crown prosecutor, when discussing further the audit of the books of the Queensland Day Committee, went on to say—I quote from page 147 of the transcript, Unes 19, 20 and 21, so that there cannot be any possible misunderstanding of what the Crown prosecutor informed the trial judge Mr SPEAKER: Order! At every sitting of this Parliament I have had to wam hongurable members that they will listen to ministerial statements Mr Burns interjected. Mr SPEAKER: Order! I am speaking generally at the moment. I ask honourable members to listen to ministerial statements in silence. Mr R. J. Gibbs: Surely they have to be Mr SPEAKER: Order! I wam the member for Wolston under Standing Order No. 123A. Sir JOH BJELKE-PETERSEN: The Crown prosecutor stated— "Of course there is no suggestion that the Premier's Department wasn't audited in terms of expenditure for the Queensland Day Committee." So much for the allegation by the Leader of the Opposition that I misled the House! He has been caught out once again. From the information in the ministerial statement that I made last Febmary, he knew that the departmental accounts of the Queensland Day Committee had been fully audited from the time the committee was established— he tried to mislead people on that—but he has continued to make untme statements to gain cheap publicity for his own political purposes. People are getting used to that from the Leader of the Opposition. Mr Warburton: No I haven't. Mr SPEAKER: Orderi Sir JOH BJELKE-PETERSEN: The Leader of the Opposition had his say in the media. I am having mine here. Mr Burns: That is the only place where you Mr SPEAKER: Order! I warn the member for Lytton under Standing Order No. 123A. Sir JOH BJELKE-PETERSEN: The Leader of the Opposition has continued to make untme statements to gain cheap publicity for his own poUtical purposes. All honourable members know that he does that. I also wish to comment on the media reports that continue to make reference to the Leader of the Opposition's having pursued the public fiinds scandal for more than nine months. In my ministerial statement of 18 Febmary 1986,1 pointed out that neither 650 2 September 1986 Ministerial Statements the Leader of the Opposition nor any other member of the Labor Party had anything to do with the investigation carried out. The inquiries were initiated by a very dedicated young officer of the Auditor-General's staff. When the matter was brought to my attention, I recommended that it be handed to the police. Land-rezoning, National Party Headquarters Hon. R. J. HINZE (South Coast—Minister for Local Government, Main Roads and Racing) (11.13 a.m.), by leave: The totaUy artificial and contrived so-caUed controversy which has been created about the rezoning of the site owned by the National Party at the comer of St Paul's Temace and Boundary Street, Spring HUl, exists only as a desperate exercise in cheap poUtical point-scoring. For the information of honourable members, I would like to put the record straight. About two years ago, following an approach to me from the National Party, which was seeking permission to redevelop the St Paul's Temace site which it then owned, I began discussions with the then Lord Mayor, Alderman Roy Harvey. Subsequently, officers of my Local Govemment Department and the Brisbane City CouncU continued those discussions. To try to suggest that either the former Labor council or the present Liberal councU was unaware of these continuing discussions about the proposal is complete nonsense. The National Party had proposed redevelopment plans drawn up and these were discussed with council officers. It was established in early discussions that these proposals were too ambitious for the then site and, acting on the advice of council officers, the National Party acquired the comer of the present site; that is, the area covering from 2 to 4 St Paul's Tertace, which is now occupied by a smaU barber's shop, a newsagency and an empty former bank premises. In a letter to the Town Clerk dated 21 April last, the Acting Director of Local Govemment said, among other things— "The proposed redevelopment would comprise a ground floor, five upper floors and two levels of underground car parking having a capacity for 118 vehicles.