DOCSLIB.ORG

Duke University Dissertation Template

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Duke University Dissertation Template An Aesthetic Disposition: Art, Social Reproduction, and Feminist Critique by Shannan Lee Hayes Graduate Program in Literature Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Michael Hardt, Advisor ___________________________ Kathi Weeks ___________________________ Mark Hansen ___________________________ Pricilla Wald Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate Program in Literature in the Graduate School of Duke University 2020 i v iv ABSTRACT An Aesthetic Disposition: Art, Social Reproduction, and Feminist Critique by Shannan Lee Hayes Graduate Program in Literature Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Michael Hardt, Advisor ___________________________ Kathi Weeks ___________________________ Mark Hansen ___________________________ Pricilla Wald An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate Program in Literature in the Graduate School of Duke University 2020 Copyright by Shannan Lee Hayes 2020 Abstract This project focuses on the question: how might we understand the politics of contemporary art? Grounding my research in feminist political theory, I argue that art’s most critical function—in the US-based context of neoliberalism—may be found in art’s ability to perform the work of social reproduction. I draw the concept of social reproduction from feminist and critical theory to mean two things. First, regarding social reproduction as a paradigm for social change, I ask how works of art participate in building subjects and structures that prefigure alternative, life sustaining worlds. Second, regarding social reproduction as the labor of care, I develop a theory of art as a source of critical hope and sensible rejuvenation. My work thus complicates the common belief—held for example in critical theory—that sensible stimulation obscures critical awareness and encourages apolitical escape. To the contrary, I find art to offer needed resources for critical world- building precisely through the aesthetic dispositions that artworks prompt. I build this argument through close attention to the work of three US-based women artists: Simone Leigh, Roni Horn, and Mika Rottenberg. By foregrounding the work of these artists in conversation with recent feminist thinking on affect and political economy, my research reorients the discourse on aesthetics and politics away from an emphasis on knowledge and subject representation, toward the undervalued work of somatic care and subject formation. iv Dedication I dedicate this dissertation to my dear friend, Kelly Rae. v Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................................................... iv Acknowledgements ..................................................................................................................................... viii Introduction.................................................................................................................................................... 1 Social Reproduction: Three Connected Definitions ........................................................................... 4 Social Reproduction and Feminist Theory ........................................................................................... 6 Affective Labor ..................................................................................................................................... 15 Social Reproduction and Art ............................................................................................................... 19 An Aesthetic Disposition ..................................................................................................................... 22 Chapters ................................................................................................................................................. 24 Affective Mapping ....................................................................................................................................... 27 Representations of the Real ................................................................................................................. 28 Women’s Work ..................................................................................................................................... 33 - NoNoseKnows - ................................................................................................................... 43 - Cosmic Generator - .............................................................................................................. 48 - Affect - ................................................................................................................................. 56 The Crisis in Care ................................................................................................................................. 61 - Neoliberalism’s Dual Logic of Gendered Labor - .................................................................. 68 Returning to Rottenberg’s Work ......................................................................................................... 81 - ASMR - ................................................................................................................................. 85 - Spaghetti Blockchain -........................................................................................................... 89 Realism in the Balance .......................................................................................................................... 94 vi This Work Was Needed ............................................................................................................................ 101 “1990: L.A., ‘The Gold Field’” .......................................................................................................... 102 - Contraction, Dilation - ........................................................................................................ 108 Horn’s Art ........................................................................................................................................... 113 - Material Presence - .............................................................................................................. 118 - The Paradox of Androgyny - ............................................................................................... 123 - Doubling/Twinning - ......................................................................................................... 126 - Water Doubles - .................................................................................................................. 127 The Historical Sensorium................................................................................................................... 136 - Phantasmagoric Technoaesthetics - ..................................................................................... 138 - Neoliberal Contraction: Mania and Depression -................................................................. 147 The “New Aesthetics” of Dilation .................................................................................................... 161 Wanting More ............................................................................................................................................. 170 Feminist Art ........................................................................................................................................ 171 The Waiting Room ............................................................................................................................. 177 Institutional Intersectionality ............................................................................................................. 192 Utopian Desire .................................................................................................................................... 206 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................................. 212 Bibliography................................................................................................................................................ 217 vii Acknowledgements I joked with my friend and grad colleague, Carolyn Laubender, that I would dedicate this dissertation to the now-over one hundred thousand dollars of student loans that it has taken me to put myself through school from when I started undergraduate studies in 2001. Some part of me had the strong desire to render visible and put on public record the cost of being a not-independently-wealthy student of higher education within our current social structure. But I reconsidered. It is an ongoing practice of subject-formation to refuse the tempting, individualizing affects of resentment and indebtedness. I frame these acknowledgements instead as an expression of deep appreciation for the joy, growth, endurance, and power that has been enabled by the many new, short-term, and lasting relationships that animate the pages of this dissertation. I would like to first thank Duke’s Graduate Program in Literature (GPL), the Gender, Feminist, and Sexuality Studies certificate program (GSFS), the Nasher Museum of Art at Duke University, and the Thompson
Load more

Recommended publications
  • SIMONE LEIGH B. 1968, Chicago, IL Lives and Works in Brooklyn, NY
    SIMONE LEIGH b. 1968, Chicago, IL Lives and works in Brooklyn, NY EDUCATION 1990 BA in Art and Philosophy, Earlham College, Richmond, IN SOLO AND TWO-PERSON EXHIBITIONS 2016 Psychic Friends Network with Simone Leigh, Tate Exchange, Tate Modern London, UK Hammer Projects: Simone Leigh, The Hammer Museum Los Angeles, CA The Waiting Room, New Museum, New York, NY Simone Leigh: I ran to the rock to hide my face the rock cried out no hiding place, H&R Block Artspace at the Kansas City Art Institute, Kansas City, MO 2015 Moulting, Tilton Gallery, New York, NY Crop Rotation, Kentucky Museum of Art and Craft, Louisville, KY 2014 Free People’s Medical Clinic, commissioned by Creative Time, Stuyvesant Mansion, Brooklyn, NY Gone South, Atlanta Contemporary Art Center, organized by Stuart Horodner Atlanta, GA Simone Leigh and Wolfgang Paalen, Gallery Wendi Norris, San Francisco, CA 2013 I Always Face You Even When It Seems Otherwise, Tiwani Contemporary, organized by Bisi Silva, London, England (catalogue) 2012 What's Her Face, Gavlak, Palm Beach, FL You Don’t Know Where Her Mouth Has Been, curated by Rashida Bumbray, The Kitchen, New York, NY jam packed and jelly tight, Jack Tilton Gallery, New York, NY 2009 The Gods Must Be Crazy, for In Practice, SculptureCenter, Queens, NY Queen Bee, G Fine Art Project Room, Washington, D.C. 2008 Scratching the Surface Vol 1, organized by Gabi Ngcobo and Mwenya Kabwe, L'appartement 22, Rabat, Morocco if you wan fo' lick old woman pot, you scratch him back (Jamaican proverb), Rush Arts Gallery Project Space, New
    [Show full text]
  • Simone Leigh: the Waiting Room
    SIMONE LEIGH THE WAITING ROOM JUNE 22 SEPT 18 For artist Simone Leigh, what happens within the duration and space of waiting is active, personal, political, and, in turn, an opportunity for reflection brimming with revolutionary potential. By way of introducing audiences to such a sense of lim- inal, yet urgent, possibility, the artist is apt to tell the disturbing story of Esmin Green. On June 18, 2008, the forty-nine-year-old woman was forcibly admitted to the psychiatric emergency depart- ment of Kings County Hospital Center, in Brooklyn, New York, due to “psychosis and agitation,” and subsequently waited for nearly twenty-four hours to receive treatment that never came. Instead, at 5:42 a.m. the following day, Green collapsed in her waiting room chair, falling to the floor—where she lay for more than an hour, unattended by employ- ees who nevertheless stood by and looked on as she died. Adding to this tragedy was the fact that those who presumed themselves Green’s caretakers sought to skew documentation of this event: Contrary to what was recorded from four different angles by the hospital’s video cameras, her medical records say that at 6 a.m. she stood up and went to the bathroom—when in truth she was already lying on the floor—and that at 6:20 a.m. she was “sitting quietly in the waiting room.” And so while Green—a Jamaican native who lived in Brownsville, and who, according to a neighbor, kept to herself except for her regular visits to church—was claimed to have died due to a “deep venous thrombosis of lower extremities due to physical inactivity,” she could best be said to have died from waiting.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Art of Healing Simone Leigh’S the Waiting Room
    tema On the Art of Healing Simone Leigh’s The Waiting Room Elke Krasny Elke Krasny, cultural theorist and curator. Professor at the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna Her body’s and her mind’s health have been made both a risk and a responsi- bility. What do I mean by this paradoxical statement? And, who is she? And, who cares about her risks, her responsibilities, her health and hear healing? The following essay will engage with these questions as it centers on artist Simone Leigh’s work The Waiting Room which took place at the New Museum in New York in 2016. The analytical reflections presented here connect the description of the social and aesthetic strategies of The Waiting Room, a key example of health activism and black feminist practice in contemporary art making, to the broader context of the politics of health, the crisis of social reproduction under neolibe- ralism, and the gendered and racialized body. Simone Leigh’s chose The Waiting Room as a title for her work to refer to the emergency waiting room at Kings County Hospital in Brooklyn, where in 2008 a Jamaican immigrant to the United States, who had been involuntarily admit- ted to the hospital, died from neglect after she had waited for nearly twenty-four hours.1 “The patient, Esmin Green, died in the waiting room at the city-run psychiatric facility in 2008. A security video released by the New York Civil Liberties Union and other lawyers showed Ms. Green, 49, collapsing to the floor and lying there while workers ignored her.
    [Show full text]
  • Aesthetics, Imagination, and Radical Reciprocity: an Interview with Girl
    Simone Leigh, Chitra Ganesh, and Uri McMillan ALTERNATIVE STRUCTURES: AESTHETICS, IMAGINATION, AND RADICAL RECIPROCITY: AN INTERVIEW WITH GIRL n the spring of 2012, on a visit to New York City, I took the train up to the Upper West Side on an explicit mission to visit the Jack Tilton I Gallery. In a striking turn of fate, the gallery was running not one Simone Leigh. Photograph by Paul Mpagi Sepuya. Chitra Ganesh. Photograph by C. Ganesh. ASAP/Journal, Vol. 2.2 (2017): 241-252 © 2017 Johns Hopkins University Press. but two of my friends’ solo exhibitions simultaneously: CHITRA GANESH’s The For Leigh “and Ganesh, art Ghost Efect in Real Time and SIMONE and friendship are delicately LEIGH’s jam packed and jelly tight. intertwined and mutually Traversing elegant narrow mansions with transformative. pristine balustrades and faded facades in the upper 70s, I eventually entered a large ” space where I was immediately greeted by one of Leigh’s arresting sculptures: a sinuous and slender wood tree trunk reaching toward the ceiling, where it cradled one of Leigh’s large ceramic glazed cowrie shells covered in a brilliant appliqué of gold leaf. Upstairs, as I traversed Leigh’s sculptures—chandeliers of pendulous glass containers flled with salt; a row of six fgurines with headdresses made out of voluptuous confgurations of cobalt blue ceramic roses—I encountered Ganesh’s large-scale black-and- white charcoal drawings of scenes inspired by early cinema productions in India, Germany, and the United States. Ganesh’s drawings contained imagery culled from science fction, histories of Orientalism, and epic myth.
    [Show full text]
  • Simone Leigh
    SIMONE LEIGH Born in Chicago to Jamaican parents, 1968 Lives and works in Brooklyn, New York Education 1990 BA in Art, minor in Philosophy, Earlham College, Richmond, IN Solo and Two-Person Exhibitions 2016 Hammer Projects: Simone Leigh, The Hammer Museum, Los Angeles, CA The Waiting Room, New Museum, New York, NY Simone Leigh: I ran to the rock to hide my face the rock cried out no hiding place, Kansas City Art Institute, Kansas City, KS 2015 Moulting, Tilton Gallery, New York, NY Crop Rotation, Kentucky Museum of Art and Craft, Louisville, KY 2014 Free People’s Medical Clinic, commissioned by Creative Time, Stuyvesant Mansion,Brooklyn, NY Gone South, Atlanta Contemporary Art Center, organized by Stu art Horodner, Atlanta, GA Simone Leigh and Wolfgang Paalen, Gallery Wendi Norris, San Francisco, CA 2013 I Always Face You Even When It Seems Otherwise, Tiwani Contem porary, organized by Bisi Silva, with catalogue, London, UK 2012 What’s Her Face, Gavlak Gallery, West Palm Beach, FL jam packed and jelly tight, Tilton Gallery, New York, NY You Don’t Know Where Her Mouth Has Been, The Kitchen, New York, NY, curated by Rashida Bumbray 2010 Divine Horsemen, with Chitra Ganesh, Mason Gross Galleries, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, curated by Latoya Ruby Frazier 2009 The Gods Must Be Crazy, for In Practice, Sculpture Center, Queens, NY Queen Bee, G Fine Art Project Room, Washington, D.C. 2008 Rush Arts Gallery Project Space, New York, NY 2005 Momenta Art Gallery, Brooklyn, NY Selected Group Exhibitions 2016 In the Power of your Care, The
    [Show full text]
  • New Museum Announces Free Public Event with Black Women Artists for Black Lives Matter, in Association with Artist-In-Residence Simone Leigh
    New Museum Announces Free Public Event with Black Women Artists for Black Lives Matter, in Association with Artist-in-Residence Simone Leigh September 1, 2016, 4:30–8:30 PM New York, NY…On Sunday, July 10, over one hundred black women artists gathered at the New Museum to form a collective force underground, known as Black Women Artists for Black Lives Matter (BWA for BLM). Simone Leigh, the New Museum’s current artist in residence, whose exhibition “The Waiting Room” is on view through September 18, convened this group in response to the continued inhumane institutionalized violence against black lives in the US. The group will hold a free public event in solidarity with Black Lives Matter at the New Museum on September 1 from 4:30 to 8:30 p.m. This evening will feature collectively organized healing workshops, performances, digital works, participatory exchanges, displays, and the distribution of materials throughout the New Museum Theater, Lobby, Fifth Floor, and Sky Room. BWA for BLM focuses on the interdependence of care and action, invisibility and visibility, self- defense and self-determination, and desire and possibility in order to highlight and renounce pervasive conditions of racism. Simone Leigh’s “The Waiting Room” is the inaugural exhibition in the Department of Education and Public Engagement’s annual research and development residency and exhibition program that foregrounds the New Museum’s year-round commitment to community partnerships and to public dialogue at the intersection of art and social justice. Since its founding in 1977, the New Museum has been committed to presenting the work of diverse artists and viewpoints, and to championing art as a vital social force.
    [Show full text]
  • Works in Exhibition
    www .realartways.org 1 Curated by: Kristina Newman-Scott and Yona Backer 06 Foreword by Will K. Wilkins 08 Curatorial Statement by Yona Backer and Kristina Newman Scott 12 Untitled Poem by Muhammad Muwakil 14 To the WIRL (WORLD)! by Annie Paul 20 God the Boy by Muhammad Muwakil 22 That is Mas by Nicholas Laughlin 28 Some Trinity by Muhammad Muwakil 30 A Shared Vision A Shared Vision: Notes On Developing A Black Diaspora Visual Arts Programme In Barbados by David Bailey and Allison Thompson Rockstone & Bootheel: Contemporary West Indian Art 36 Poem by Muhammad Muwakil © 2010 Real Art Ways All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, 38 The Dancehall Story – Exploring Male Homosexuality stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form, or by by Donna P. Hope any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission of the publisher. contents 44 A Letter To Prince Charles by Muhammad Muwakil Published by REAL ART WAYS Edited by Kristina Newman-Scott and Yona Backer 3 46 Interview with Filmmakers Horace Ové and Maria Govan 56 Arbor St., Hartford, CT 06106 by Melanie Archer T:860.232.1006 F: 860.233.6691 [email protected] 52 Hungry for Words Cover Design, Page Design and Composition by by Nicholas Laughlin Richard Mark Rawlins • artzpub.com Printed in Singapore 58 Works in the Exhibiiton CS Graphics 142 Biographies Rockstone and Bootheel was made possible through the gen- erous support of The National Endowment for the Arts, the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, the Edward C.
    [Show full text]