Time crystals: a review Krzysztof Sacha and Jakub Zakrzewski1 1Instytut Fizyki imienia Mariana Smoluchowskiego and Mark Kac Complex Systems Research Center, Uniwersytet Jagielloński ulica Profesora Stanisława Łojasiewicza 11 PL-30-348 Kraków Poland (Dated: January 19, 2018) Time crystals are time-periodic self-organized structures postulated by Frank Wilczek in 2012. While the original concept was strongly criticized, it stimulated at the same time an intensive research leading to propositions and experimental verifications of discrete (or Floquet) time crystals – the structures that appear in the time domain due to spontaneous breaking of discrete time translation symmetry. The struggle to observe discrete time crystals is reviewed here together with propositions that generalize this concept introducing condensed matter like physics in the time domain. We shall also revisit the original Wilczek’s idea and review strategies aimed at spontaneous breaking of continuous time translation symmetry. PACS numbers: 11.30.Qc, 67.80.-s, 73.23.-b, 03.75.Lm, 67.85.Hj, 67.85.Jk CONTENTS properties. Crystals are formed due to mutual interac- tions between atoms that self-organize and build regular I. Introduction1 structures in space. This kind of self-organization is a quantum mechanical phenomenon and is related to spon- II. Time crystals: original idea and perspectives2 A. Origin of space crystals: spontaneous breaking of space taneous space translation symmetry breaking (Strocchi, translation symmetry2 2005). It is often neglected that a probability density B. Origin of time crystals: spontaneous breaking of for measurement of a position of a single particle in a continuous time translation symmetry3 system of mutually interacting particles cannot reveal a C. Excited states as a resource?6 crystalline structure unless continuous space translation III. Spontaneous breaking of discrete time translation symmetry is broken. Quantum mechanics tells us that symmetry: idea and experiments7 the center of mass of interacting atoms behaves like a A. Discrete time crystal for atoms bouncing on an free massive particle and in the ground state it must be oscillating mirror8 B. Discrete time crystals in spin systems 11 totally delocalized. The translationally invariant Hamil- C. Experiments 14 tonian leads to quantum eigenstates that are also tran- D. Effect of disorder 16 sitionally invariant. To observe a crystalline structure in the single particle probability density, this translational IV. Condensed matter physics in time crystals 17 symmetry must be broken – in other words we do not A. Space periodic systems versus periodically driven systems 17 know where a crystal is unless we perform a measure- B. Anderson localization in the time domain 19 ment or a system is perturbed by an infinitesimally weak 1. Anderson localization in time crystals 20 external perturbation. Let us repeat, this process occurs 2. Anderson localization in time without crystalline spontaneously and in the real world one deals with the structures 21 symmetry broken state already. After the symmetry is C. Mott insulator in the time domain 22 D. Many-body localization with temporal disorder 23 broken the quantum effects do not give up. However, E. Time crystals with properties of multi-dimensional they are extremely slow and even if a space crystal were systems 23 isolated it would take thousand of years to see quantum arXiv:1704.03735v5 [quant-ph] 18 Jan 2018 blurring of the crystalline structure. It should be noted V. Conclusions 23 that if one was able to measure relative distances be- Acknowledgments 24 tween particles (not particles positions themselves) in a solid state system prepared in the ground state, signa- References 24 tures of regular arrangement of atoms would be observed and such a measurement would not break the continuous space translational symmetry. I. INTRODUCTION Spontaneous symmetry breaking is a general property Crystals are everywhere ranging from jewelery to salt of Nature that surrounds us and it is responsible for in the kitchen. They are built of atoms in a regular a wide class of phenomena like magnetization of ferro- arrangement in space and they have distinct mechan- magnetic materials (rotational symmetry breaking) or ical properties as well as heat or electric conductance Higgs mechanism (breaking of gauge symmetries) (Stroc- 2 chi, 2005). It is related to a situation where equations switch to the consideration of possibility of spontaneous describing a system possess a symmetry but a system time translation symmetry breaking and the idea of time chooses spontaneously a solution that breaks this sym- crystal. We will report on the on-going research in time- metry. The effect can be identified with a vulnerability of independent systems and in systems that are periodically exact symmetric eigenstates to any infinitesimally weak driven and are able to reveal discrete time crystal phe- perturbation. nomena. Next, the research on a possible realization of In 2012 Frank Wilczek proposed an idea of time crys- condensed matter phenomena in the time domain will be tals (Wilczek, 2012). He posed a question whether there described. exist systems which break spontaneously time transla- tion symmetry. In other words if it is possible that a many-body system self-organizes in time and starts II. TIME CRYSTALS: ORIGINAL IDEA AND spontaneously to undergo a periodic motion. This kind PERSPECTIVES of self-organization is a quantum effect and should not We introduce here a concept of time crystals which is be mixed with classical self-organization processes that related to spontaneous breaking of time translation sym- occur in many systems in nature ranging from flash- metry in analogy to spontaneous space translation sym- ing Asian fireflies to synchronized clapping of an audi- metry breaking in the formation of space crystals. We ence that expresses appreciation for an impressive per- begin with the description of space crystals that allows formance (Glass and Mackey, 1988; Neda Z. et al., 2000). us to explain phenomena that can also be observed in the Wilczek considered a time-independent system and sug- time domain when a many-body system switches spon- gested that it can spontaneously turn to periodic mo- taneously to periodic motion realizing the time crystal. tion even in the lowest energy state. It is already known that the original Wilczek idea cannot be realized (Bruno, 2013c; Watanabe and Oshikawa, 2015). However, it be- A. Origin of space crystals: spontaneous breaking of space came an inspiration to other physicists and a novel re- translation symmetry search field has been opened. Exploration of this time territory started immedi- Formation of space crystals relies on periodic self- ately and soon a new version of time crystals was pro- organization of atoms due to their mutual interactions. posed, that is, a discrete or Floquet time crystals (Sacha, Under certain conditions atoms arrange themselves in a 2015b). That time crystals are related to quantum self- periodic lattice that manifests itself in a periodic behav- organization of motion of a many-body system that is pe- ior in space of a probability density for a measurement of riodically driven by an external force. Soon other propo- a single particle (an electron or an ion). Strictly speaking sitions of Floquet time crystals emerged in driven spin such a state cannot be the ground state of a many-body systems (Else et al., 2016; Khemani et al., 2016). While atomic system because it breaks the translation symme- one would expect that in a stationary state a system try (assuming a typical nondegenerate ground state). To should follow an external driving it turns out that due see this, let us consider a solid state Hamiltonian, to the mutual interaction between particles, the system prefers to move on its own and spontaneously switches to N 2 N X pi 1 X a periodic motion with a different period than a period H = + Uij(ri − rj); (1) 2mi 2 of driving. This kind of time crystallization has been re- i=1 i6=j cently realized in laboratories (Choi et al., 2017; Zhang that describes N interacting particles in a finite volume et al., 2017). V with periodic boundary conditions. If we shift all po- In condensed matter physics properties of space crys- sitions ri by the same vector R, the Hamiltonian does tals are often analyzed with the help of space periodic not change because it depends on relative distances be- potentials — it is assumed that a space crystal is already tween particles only. It means that the system possesses formed, i.e. a crystalline structure has emerged. Systems continuous (i.e. vector R can be arbitrary) space transla- that are periodically driven in time by an external force tion symmetry; the corresponding (unitary) space trans- not only can reveal spontaneous breaking of a discrete lation operator TR commutes with H and eigenstates time translation symmetry but can also show solid state n(r1;:::; rN ) of H are also eigenstates of TR, phenomena in the time domain. This research has been i' already initiated and shows that Anderson localization or TR n(r1;:::; rN ) = e n(r1;:::; rN ): (2) Mott insulator phase in the time domain can be observed (Sacha, 2015a). Taking into account Eq. (2) and the fact that In this review article we describe the present status TR n(r1;:::; rN ) = n(r1 + R;:::; rN + R); (3) of the time crystal research. We start with an introduc- tion to the phenomenon of spontaneous space transla- it is easy to show that the probability density for the tion symmetry breaking in solid state systems. Then, we measurement of a single particle must be uniform in space 3 if a system is prepared in the ground state (or any other its lifetime exceeds easily thousands of years. It can be nondegenerate eigenstate), estimated assuming that the center of mass is described −11 Z by a wave-packet localized on a length scale σ ≈ 10 m, h2 ρ(r1 + R) = d(r2 + R) : : : d(rN + R) then, the corresponding kinetic energy is Ek = 2mNσ2 .