A Major-Capsid-Protein-Based Multiplex PCR Assay for Rapid
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Archives of Virology (2019) 164:819–830 https://doi.org/10.1007/s00705-019-04148-6 ORIGINAL ARTICLE A major‑capsid‑protein‑based multiplex PCR assay for rapid identifcation of selected virulent bacteriophage types Yannick Born1 · Leandra E. Knecht1,2 · Mirjam Eigenmann1 · Michel Bolliger1 · Jochen Klumpp2 · Lars Fieseler1 Received: 27 September 2018 / Accepted: 14 December 2018 / Published online: 23 January 2019 © The Author(s) 2019 Abstract Bacteriophages represent a promising alternative for controlling pathogenic bacteria. They are ubiquitous in the environment, and their isolation is usually simple and fast. However, not every phage is suitable for biocontrol applications. It must be virulent (i.e., strictly lytic), non-transducing, and safe. We have developed a method for identifying selected types of virulent phages at an early stage of the isolation process to simplify the search for suitable candidates. Using the major capsid pro- tein (MCP) as a phylogenetic marker, we designed degenerate primers for the identifcation of Felix O1-, GJ1-, N4-, SP6-, T4-, T7-, and Vi1-like phages in multiplex PCR setups with single phage plaques as templates. Performance of the MCP PCR assay was evaluated with a set of 26 well-characterized phages. Neither false-positive nor false-negative results were obtained. In addition, 154 phages from enrichment cultures from various environmental samples were subjected to MCP PCR analysis. Eight of them, specifc for Salmonella enterica, Escherichia coli, or Erwinia amylovora, belonged to one of the selected phage types. Their PCR-based identifcation was successfully confrmed by pulsed-feld gel electrophoresis of the phage genomes, electron microscopy, and sequencing of the amplifed mcp gene fragment. The MCP PCR assay was shown to be a simple method for preliminary assignment of new phages to a certain group and thus to identify candidates for biocontrol immediately after their isolation. Given that sufcient sequence data are available, this method can be extended to any phage group of interest. Introduction for application as a biocontrol agent. In general, biocontrol phages need to be virulent (i.e., strictly lytic) and non-trans- Bacteriophages (phages) are viruses that infect only bacte- ducing, and they should not carry genes known to encode ria. Due to the rise of antibiotic resistance in many relevant toxins. They also must be stable during storage and appli- bacterial pathogens, interest in phage research is steadily cation. Finally, they need to be propagatable to high titers increasing. Because of their unique properties, phages are on non-pathogenic production strains [2]. Phage biocontrol promising alternatives for the control of bacteria. The major has been successfully applied in food pre- and postharvest advantage is their host specifcity, which enables a targeted to control the major foodborne pathogens Salmonella enter- treatment of a pathogen. In addition, phages are self-lim- ica, shiga-toxin-producing E. coli (STEC), Campylobacter iting and natural [1]. However, not every phage is suited jejuni, Listeria monocytogenes, and Staphylococcus aureus [2]. Likewise, phages have been used to control plant infec- tions caused by Xanthomonas spp. or Erwinia amylovora Handling Editor: Tim Skern. [3], and they have been applied in aquaculture to treat bacte- Electronic supplementary material The online version of this rial infections of fsh and shellfsh [4]. article (https ://doi.org/10.1007/s0070 5-019-04148 -6) contains The total number of phages on Earth is enormous and supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. exceeds an estimated 1031 virions [5, 6]. Given this vast * Lars Fieseler number, it is likely that there is a phage specifc for any [email protected] host that meets all the demands on a biocontrol phage. In general, phages can be easily isolated from environmental 1 Institute of Food and Beverage Innovation, Zurich University samples. Protocols for isolation of tailed phages (members of Applied Sciences, 8820 Wädenswil, Switzerland of the order Caudovirales) typically involve an enrichment 2 Institute of Food, Nutrition and Health, ETH Zurich, Zurich, step followed by plating using the soft-agar overlay method Switzerland Vol.:(0123456789)1 3 820 Y. Born et al. [7, 8]. Standard enrichments are usually performed with a the virulent Vi1-like phages share a myovirus morphology, single bacterial strain, while protocols adjusted towards iso- with genomes of ca. 155-160 kb in size, and they belong to lation of polyvalent phages include sequential enrichment the new family Ackermannviridae [28, 29]. The Vi1-like with several host strains [7, 9]. Both methods normally yield phage LIMEstone1 has been shown to signifcantly reduce numerous isolates. However, the subsequent characterization the incidence and severity of soft rot on potato tubers caused of all isolates to avoid redundancy and to identify virulent by Dickeya solani [30]. Likewise, contamination with E. coli candidates is time consuming and laborious. O157:H7 on various foods has been shown to be reduced The increase in the number of completely sequenced by EcoShield™, a commercial product composed of three phage genomes in the past years has enabled comparisons phages, one of which (ECML-4) is a member of the genus of whole genome sequences, which has revealed evolution- Vi1virus [31, 32]. However, some Vi1-like phages have been ary relationships among diferent phage groups. Although reported to be generalized transducers [33] – a characteristic clearer parameters to defne genera, subfamilies, and fami- that is incompatible with its use in phage biocontrol and lies still need to be established, new phage subfamilies and needs to be clarifed beforehand. genera have been proposed on the basis of molecular rela- The established groups of FO1-, GJ1-, N4-, SP6-, T4-, tionships (e.g., phages with 40% homologous proteins are T7-, and Vi1-like phages all comprise strictly lytic phages, members of the same genus) [10]. Importantly, members and representatives of each group have been successfully of the same subfamily or genus usually share a lifestyle applied to control pathogenic bacteria. An early assignment and approximate genome size [11]. For example, a group of a new phage to one of these groups could therefore enable of strictly lytic phages is formed by myoviruses related preselection to accelerate phage isolation and characteriza- to Salmonella phage Felix O1 (FO1) with genomes of ca. tion. Genome sequencing allows identifcation of the phylo- 85-90 kb in size. They are classifed as members of the sub- genetic relationships of a new isolate, but it is still associated family Ounavirinae [12]. The FO1-like Salmonella phages with high costs and complex data analysis. In order to cir- Mushroom and FO1a are components of commercially cumvent the need for complete sequencing, molecular mark- available phage cocktails (IntestiPhage™ and PhageGuard ers (signature genes) could be studied instead. These mark- S™, respectively) [13, 14]. GJ1-like phages are also viru- ers should be universally encoded by all tailed phages, and, lent myoviruses. ΦEcoM-GJ1 infects enterotoxigenic E. coli more importantly, the phylogenetic groups formed by com- O149:H10:F4 strains [15]. Other phages related to GJ1, such parisons of whole genome sequences and the corresponding as the E. amylovora phage vB_EamM-Y2 or Pectobacte- markers need to be identical. There are several candidates rium carotovorum phage PM1 have similar genome sizes for such signature genes, and their usefulness as molecular of ca. 55 kb as well as broad host ranges and have been markers has already been demonstrated. For example, the shown to efectively limit the growth of their target bacteria grouping of Vi1-like phages has been corroborated by phy- in vitro as well as in vivo [16, 17]. The strictly lytic N4-like logenetic analysis of single signature genes (major capsid phages belong to the family Podoviridae and have genomes protein [MCP], DNA polymerase, DNA ligase, terminase of approximately 70-75 kb in size [18]. The N4-like Escheri- large subunit) [29]. A phylogenetic tree of the former sub- chia phage EC1-UPM reduces the severity of colibacillosis family “Felixounavirinae” constructed by analysis of con- in chickens caused by E. coli O78:K80 strains [19]. SP6- catenated protein sequences (MCP, tail sheath protein, portal like phages are virulent podoviruses of one genus (Sp6virus) protein) also confrmed clustering based on whole-genome with genomes of ca. 45 kb in size [20]. The SP6-like Salmo- comparisons [34]. Signature genes have also been used to nella phage UAB_Phi78, which displays a broad host range study viral diversity in environmental samples. For exam- on strains of Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica serovars ple, the diversity of T7-like cyanoviruses has been analyzed Typhimurium and Enteritidis, was part of a cocktail that with the help of three signature genes (DNA polymerase, greatly reduced Salmonella contamination on various food MCP, photosynthesis gene psbA), and these viruses have surfaces [21]. The relatively small and strictly lytic T7-like been specifcally isolated using degenerate primers targeting viruses (ca. 40 kb) also belong to one genus (T7virus) in the DNA polymerase gene [35]. In a comprehensive study the family Podoviridae. At their tail spikes, many T7-like of phages infecting enterobacteria, Grose and Casjens [11] phages have enzymes that hydrolyze bacterial exopolysac- showed that the chance of assigning