Socioeconomic Impact of Gambling on Iowans a Study for the Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Socioeconomic Impact of Gambling on Iowans a Study for the Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission Socioeconomic Impact of Gambling on Iowans A Study for the Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission Prepared by Strategic Economics Group Spectrum Gaming Group May 23, 2014 The Socioeconomic Impact of Gambling on Iowans, 2014 Table of Contents Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................1 Economic and Fiscal Impacts: A Summary............................................................................................... 1 Social Impacts: A Summary ..................................................................................................................... 5 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................8 1. Literature Review.................................................................................................................. 10 Economic Impact Studies ...................................................................................................................... 12 Employment Literature Review ............................................................................................................. 15 Impacts on Local Community Services .................................................................................................. 25 Impacts on State and Local Government Finances, Charitable Organizations ...................................... 29 Casinos and Crime ................................................................................................................................. 32 Household Financial Impact Studies ...................................................................................................... 41 Health Impact Studies ........................................................................................................................... 44 Social Services Impact Studies ............................................................................................................... 50 Summary and Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 51 References ............................................................................................................................................ 52 2. History and Overview of Casino Gambling in Iowa ................................................................. 58 History of Gaming Legislation................................................................................................................ 58 The Growth and Evolution of Casino Gambling in Iowa ........................................................................ 65 Statistical Profile of Casino Gambling in Iowa ....................................................................................... 69 Geography of Racetrack and Casino Impacts ........................................................................................ 75 3. Statewide Economic Impact Model Analysis .......................................................................... 82 Description of Economic Indicators ....................................................................................................... 82 Impact of the Iowa Casinos ................................................................................................................... 83 4. Impact of Casinos on the Economies of Host Communities ..................................................... 90 Data and Data Sources .......................................................................................................................... 90 Statewide Economic Trends .................................................................................................................. 92 Economic Impacts in Casino Counties ................................................................................................. 102 5. Comparison of the Economies of Casino and Non-Casino Counties ....................................... 132 Data and Data Sources ........................................................................................................................ 133 Population Changes............................................................................................................................. 135 Personal Income Changes ................................................................................................................... 137 Employment Changes .......................................................................................................................... 151 Retail Sales Changes ............................................................................................................................ 161 Property Valuation Changes ................................................................................................................ 167 Local Views on the Economic Impact of Casinos ................................................................................. 174 6. Community Services Impacts ............................................................................................... 179 Community Services Budget Impacts .................................................................................................. 179 Summary of Comments from Local Officials ....................................................................................... 191 7. Impact of Casino Gambling on Crime ................................................................................... 192 Methodology ....................................................................................................................................... 192 Summary ............................................................................................................................................. 193 Overall Crime Rate (Category A Offenses) ........................................................................................... 194 Illegal Gambling, Gambling by Minors ................................................................................................. 200 Embezzlement, Insurance Fraud ......................................................................................................... 201 Strategic Economics Group / Spectrum Gaming Group i The Socioeconomic Impact of Gambling on Iowans, 2014 8. Impacts on Household Finances........................................................................................... 204 Consumer Credit ................................................................................................................................. 206 Financial Institutions ........................................................................................................................... 208 Problem Gambling............................................................................................................................... 209 Bankruptcy .......................................................................................................................................... 211 Social Services ..................................................................................................................................... 222 9. Impacts on Household and Community Health and Social Issues .......................................... 231 Family .................................................................................................................................................. 233 Homelessness ...................................................................................................................................... 239 Education ............................................................................................................................................ 241 Gambling Addiction ............................................................................................................................. 246 Substance Abuse ................................................................................................................................. 255 Health and Life Expectancy ................................................................................................................. 256 10. Fiscal Impacts ..................................................................................................................... 261 Charitable Contributions ..................................................................................................................... 261 State and Local Gambling Fees and Taxes ........................................................................................... 262 Casino Property Assessments and Taxes ............................................................................................. 265 Hotel-Motel Tax .................................................................................................................................. 268 State and Local Option Sales Taxes ..................................................................................................... 270 Personal Income Tax ........................................................................................................................... 271 Summary of Fiscal Impacts .................................................................................................................. 272 Appendix ......................................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Chapter 3: Pathological and Problem Gamblers in the United States The
    Chapter 3: Pathological And Problem Gamblers In The United States The perception of increased pathological and problem gambling is currently driving interest and concern among policymakers, treatment professionals, industry officials, gambling researchers, and the public. Data describing the extent of pathological and problem gambling are useful for many purposes, including planning public health services and medical services. This chapter discusses the prevalence of pathological and problem gamblers among the general U.S. population and specific subpopulations. As limited by the available data, the discussion is often framed in terms of the proportion of pathological and problem gamblers reported in studies of U.S. residents. Of particular concern is determining prevalence among reportedly vulnerable demographic groups, such as men, adolescents, the poor, the elderly, and minorities (including American Indians). We also attempt to examine trends in relation to the increased availability of legal gambling opportunities in the last decade. This chapter also makes comparisons with the prevalence rates of alcohol and drug abusers, to help put the magnitude of excessive gambling and related problems into perspective. LIMITATIONS OF PREVALENCE RESEARCH In Chapter 2 we described the difficulties involved in defining and measuring pathological gambling using various assessment instruments. Here it is important to note that comparing and interpreting prevalence findings is problematic when different studies use different screening and/or diagnostic instruments or criterion levels to measure differing levels of intemperate gambling and associated problems. Unfortunately, such differences are common in the research literature on pathological and problem gambling (Volberg, 1998b) which creates problems in estimating prevalence rates in the United States.
    [Show full text]
  • Harveys Kanesville Queen
    Table of Contents 2 Letter to Governor EXCURSION BOATS 10 Commission Meetings 26 All Iowa Excursion Boat Totals RACETRACKS 27 Harveys Casino Hotel 13 Bluffs Run Casino 28 Ameristar Casino & Hotel 14 Dubuque Greyhound Park & Casino 29 Isle of Capri-Marquette 15 Prairie Meadows Racetrack & Casino 30 Diamond Jo Casino 17 Laboratory Testing 31 Catfish Bend Casino 18 Iowa Breeder's Fund 32 Mississippi Belle II RACETRACK CASINOS 33 Belle of Sioux City 20 All Iowa Racetrack Casino Gaming Totals 34 The President 21 Bluffs Run Casino 35 Isle of Capri-Bettendorf 22 Dubuque Greyhound Park & Casino 36 Lakeside Casino Resort 23 Prairie Meadows Racetrack & Casino 37 Excursion Boat Revenue 24 Pari-Mutuel Revenue and Expenditures and Expenditures 25 Iowa's Wagering Dollar 2 IOWA RACING AND GAMING COMMISSION March 1, 2001 The Honorable Thomas J. Vilsack Governor of Iowa State Capitol Des Moines, Iowa 50319 Dear Governor Vilsack: I: RACING AND GAMING GROWTH IN THE 1990's: SPECTACULAR ECONOMIC SYNERGY For more than four decades (1931-1976), only one state legalized casino gambling. In 1976, New Jersey voters approved gaming in Atlantic City. Then in 1989, the Iowa Legislature authorized riverboat casinos, which is reputed to have been the genesis for gambling activity's most significant growth of the past century, with the number of states permitting casinos rising to eleven by the conclusion of the 1990's decade. Beyond that action, the legislature in 1994 lifted the legal limit on betting and afforded racetrack operations the opportunity to have casinos. That change marked a dramatic impact in activity levels with a resultant astronomical increase in state gaming revenues of 1822%.
    [Show full text]
  • Getting Ready to Fly!
    Getting Ready to Fly! Commercial opportunities in the USA, the world’s biggest online gaming market. Scenarios. Forecasts. Milestones. Enter Executive Market Forecasts – How will Business Models Key Industry & Contacts Summary Size the Market Evolve? and Value Chains Market themes Contents Section One: Executive Summary . 3 Section Four: Business Models and Value Chains . 26 Market Barriers. 26 Section Two: Market Size . 8 Cannibalisation. 29 By State. By Population. 9 Strategic Models. 32 Land-Based. 9 KPIs . 39 Mobile/Tablet. 15 Social Gaming . 39 Product. 16 Land-based. 43 Section Three: Forecasts – How will the Market Evolve? 17. Section Five: Key Industry & Market themes . 47 New Jersey. 17 State-by-State. 47 Nevada. 18 Geo-location. 53 Delaware . 19 Compacts. 53 Federal. 20 Federal Law . 55 The Axes of Uncertainty. 22 Mobile/Tablet. 25 Section Six: Contacts . 58 2 Executive Market Forecasts – How will Business Models Key Industry & Contacts Summary Size the Market Evolve? and Value Chains Market themes Section One: Executive Summary Forecasts Exhibit 1: New Jersey Forecasts GGY licensed online gaming 334 The U.S. licensed online gaming market will be worth $285m GGY in 2014, significantly higher should compacts be created. The New Jersey licensed online gaming market will be worth $186m GGY in 2014, significantly lower than official 0 State forecasts. This will rise to around $214m if interstate 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 compacts are created. n GGY ($Ms) n With Compacts ($Ms) The licensed U.S. online gaming market will require California 2014 186 214 to push through proposed poker regulations and roll-out licensed web-sites to push through the $1bn GGR barrier.
    [Show full text]
  • S.B. Dems the Big Winners
    Fall Dining Guide SBHS in GIUIC finals Standing guard Looking for a new dining experience? Vikings to face Bears for The change of seasons Check out this month's selection of conference title is reflected in area restaurants Davidson's Mill Pond Pages 14*15 Page 25 Page 3 Tv~~A co (/• SentineServing South Brunswick l NOVEMBER 5,1998 40 cents VOLUME 6, NUMBER 2 S.B. Dems the big winners Van Hessen lone Republican winner; one Dem seat still too close to call BY CHARLES W KIM While Democratic incumbent Staff Writer Debra Johnson captured the mayor's seat, Democratic emocrats held on to incumbent Mayor Edmund their strong 4-1 munici- Luciano was the top vote-getter D pal government majori- in the nine-way race for four ty Tuesday, capturing the council seats, garnering 4,206 mayor's and three council seats. votes. Voters also gave their stamp Democratic incumbent of approval to the lour incum- Deputy Mayor Frank Gambatese bent candidates, including the came in second, collecting 4,003 lone Republican winner. votes, followed by incumbent The fifth seat on the new Republican Committeeman Ted Township Council — which wilt Van Hessen, with 3,840, replace the Township Commit- Antisell, with 3,756, and Barrett tee in January — is still undecid- with 3,752. ed, with Democratic newcomer The other Republican council Frank Antisell holding a slim 4- candidates, Larry Gildenberg, vote lead over his running mate Joann Kagan and Joe Del and fellow newcomer, Carol Guercio, received 3,535, 3,380 Barrett. Provisional votes, which and 3,349 votes, respectively, won't be available until tomor- followed by lone independent South Brunswick's first elected mayor Debra Johnson makes her triumphant entrance into the row or Monday, could erase that Democrats' post-election party at Pierre's Deli in Dayton Tuesday.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 7. Gambling's Impacts on People and Places
    poor or undeveloped methodology, or CHAPTER 7. GAMBLING’S researchers’ biases. IMPACTS ON PEOPLE AND It is evident to this Commission that there are PLACES significant benefits and significant costs to the places, namely, those communities which embrace gambling and that many of the impacts, “Gambling is inevitable. No matter what both positive and negative, of gambling spill is said or done by advocates or over into the surrounding communities, which opponents in all its various forms, it is an often have no say in the matter. In addition, activity that is practiced, or tacitly those with compulsive gambling problems take endorsed, by a substantial majority of significant costs with them to communities 1 Americans.” throughout the nation. In an ideal environment, citizens and policy-makers consider all of the Even the members of the previous federal study relevant data and information as part of their would be astounded at the exponential growth of decisionmaking process. Unfortunately, the lack gambling, in its availability, forms and dollars of quality research and the controversy wagered, in the 23 years since they chose the surrounding this industry rarely enable citizens words above to begin their work. Today, the and policymakers to truly determine the net various components of legalized gambling have impact of gambling in their communities, or, in an impact¾in many cases, a significant one¾on some cases, their backyards. numerous communities and almost every citizen in this nation. The principal task of this Many communities, often those suffering Commission was to examine the “social and economic hardship and social problems, consider economic impacts of gambling on individuals, gambling as a panacea to those ills.
    [Show full text]
  • Casino Development: How Would Casinos Affect New England's
    C Horn C A Symposium Sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston Robert Tannenwald, Editor Special Report No. 2 Published in October 1995 Preface / iii Welcome and introduction / v Cathy E. Minehan Panel I: impact on income and Jobs The extent to which casino development fosters the economic growth of a state or local area has been vigorously debated. What evidence of the economic effects of casino development do we have, based on both theory and empirical research? What can New England ]earn from regions where casinos are more widespread? What are the methodological issues in estimating casinos’ impact on jobs and income? Introduction Robert Tannenwa]d The Impact of Casino Gambling on income and Jobs / 3 Ear] L. Grino]s Gambling and the Law®: Endless Fields of Dreams® I. Nelson Rose indian Gaming’s impact on income and Jobs / 47 S. Timothy Wapato High=Stakes Casinos and Economic Growth / 52 Arthur W. Wright Panel ll: Implica~ons for Public Sector Revenues Casinos pay substantial taxes and fees to state and local governments. What is the optimal way to tax casinos? To what extent do taxes and fees collected from casinos displace public revenue generated by other forms of state-sponsored gambling, such as lotteries and parimutuel betting? Do revenues from casino taxes displace revenues from sales taxes? Who ultimately bears the burden of casino taxes? introduction / 59 Gary S. Sasse The Promise of Public Revenue from Casinos Charles T. Clotfelter Steven D. Gold Finances: The Case of New Jersey / 74 Ran3ana G. Madhusudhan Perspective of the Treasurer of Massachusetts / 87 The Honorable Joseph D.
    [Show full text]
  • Kansas Star.Pdf
    Table of Contents Vision …………………………………………………………………………………….. 3 Key Parties & Gaming Management Experience..…………………….………………….. 4 Management Profiles …………………………………………………………………….. 7 Proposed Project ……………………………..………………………………………………….. 9 Infrastructure Improvements …………………………………………………………………… 18 Site Utilities ……………………………………………………………………………… 19 Emergency Services Facility ……………………………………………………………... 20 Project Budget …………………………………………………………..……………………….. 21 Project Financing ………………………………………………………………………… 22 Benefit to Sumner County ……………………………………………..…………….…… 23 Kansas All-Star Scholars Fund “Ad Astra” ………………………………………………….. 24 Summary ...……………………………………………………………………………….. 25 2 Vision Kansas Star Casino, Hotel, and Event Center will be a regional destination attraction, offering first-class gaming and non-gaming amenities, with experiences tailored specifically for the people of Sumner County, South Central Kansas, and the entire state. It has been designed with the customer in mind, to meet and even beat their expectations of Kansas fun, excitement, friendliness and value. The vision for the resort is to offer world-class gaming entertainment, fine dining, and Las Vegas-style entertainment combined with Midwestern friendliness and warmth. Along with gaming amenities that include 1,850 state-of-the-art gaming machines, 42 table games, and a 5 table poker room, our project will include a 115-seat steakhouse and cocktail bar; a 250-seat live action buffet, a 40-seat food court, a sports bar, and a casino bar offering live music and Las Vegas-style entertainment.
    [Show full text]
  • SENATE, No. 1565 STATE of NEW JERSEY 215Th LEGISLATURE
    LEGISLATIVE FISCAL ESTIMATE [Second Reprint] SENATE, No. 1565 STATE OF NEW JERSEY 215th LEGISLATURE DATED: AUGUST 22, 2012 SUMMARY Synopsis: Authorizes Internet gaming at Atlantic City casinos under certain circumstances. Type of Impact: Revenue Increase: State General Fund; Casino Revenue Fund; Casino Control Fund. Agencies Affected: Department of Law and Public Safety, Division of Gambling Enforcement; Department of the Treasury, Casino Control Commission. Office of Legislative Services Estimate Fiscal Impact FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 State Revenue Indeterminate – See comments below • This bill authorizes casino games in Atlantic City to be offered through the Internet to residents of New Jersey and to be accepted from certain persons who are outside of New Jersey as determined by the Division of Gambling Enforcement. • The Office of Legislative Services (OLS) cannot reliably estimate the increase in State revenue that could result from Internet gambling on authorized casino games offered by Atlantic City Casinos due to a lack of data. • Internet gambling in New Jersey would provide a new method of wagering on authorized casino games in Atlantic City. No current data exists for actual online gambling to provide the necessary economic, demographic, and consumer behavior information needed to make an estimate and any online gambling data that is available is limited and dated. BILL DESCRIPTION Senate Bill No. 1565 (2R) of 2012 authorizes Internet wagering at Atlantic City casinos to Office of Legislative Services Legislative Budget and
    [Show full text]
  • Creating a Resort from a Resort
    Spectrum Gaming Group LLC 1001 Tilton Road, Suite 201 Northfield NJ 08225 March 10, 2006 Economic Study, Feasibility Report Regarding proposed Pocono Manor casino/hotel complex Prepared for Matzel and Associates Acquisition LLC Executive Summary..................................................................................................................... 4 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 6 Background: Capital investment ............................................................................................... 8 Working with public sector: parallel interests......................................................................... 9 Construction estimates.............................................................................................................. 11 Projecting gaming revenue....................................................................................................... 12 Core markets...........................................................................................................13 Gaming revenue model: assumptions...........................................................................13 Number of slots: Initial installation of 3,000 units.....................................................13 Determining optimal level of machines..................................................................... 17 Peak‐period analysis: Justifying 5,000 slots ...........................................................18
    [Show full text]
  • Vol 9 No 6 Report
    Wisconsin yPdddddddd c yPddddecdecd c yPdddddddddddddddddd c yPdddddHwcecd@wfcdecd c cyPddHwccdgcdrcfcdecd c cyPddHwcecdgcdgcdecd c yPdddTuyPdddgcdgcdgcdetd c cdddddcsRddHdgcdgcdgcdeUS c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdedr c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdcgSc c cddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd c c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdcs9ddddddTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdeRdHdcsRTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdecsRTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdfcs9Tc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgxdAu c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdRTu c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdedTu c cdddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddT c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdfcs9Auc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgxddTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdcsRTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdecsRTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdfcs9Tuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgxddTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdcdTuc c cddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdfcs9Tuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgxddTuc c c Policy cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdcsRddddTuc cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcddTuc c cdddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdRdTc c yPddddHwcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdesRAu c PddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdfdT c UddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddddAc c ddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdA c ctddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcddAc c 8ddddgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcd9A c c8dd@dgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdcRAuc c cUdddrcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdecs9Tc c cddddccdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdgcdf9IcheyPTec
    [Show full text]
  • 2014 Annual Report John J
    2014 Annual Report John J. Hoffman, Acting Attorney General of New Jersey This page was intentionally left blank OAG Annual Report Overview Dear Governor Christie, members of the State Legislature and citizens of New Jersey: Greetings. At the Office of the Attorney General, we have a unique role as both New Jersey’s lead law enforcement agency and its chief provider of legal representation to state government. That is, we are a large, multi-faceted crime-fighting agency and a major law firm rolled into one. Our essential mission includes making neighborhoods safer by combating drug dealing, gun violence, gang activity and other criminal threats. It includes prosecuting public corruption and financial crime. It includes preserving civil rights and protecting consumers and investors. But the mission does not end there. We license and regulate the alcoholic beverage industry. We ensure the integrity of New Jersey’s legalized casino gaming and horse racing industries. And we work to ensure the safety of drivers, passengers and pedestrians on our streets and roads. We are responsible for the custody, care and post-custodial supervision of juvenile offenders. We handle, literally, tens of thousands of litigation matters each year that protect children, safeguard the State’s financial assets, preserve our natural resources, ensure the integrity of elections and defend the actions of state government. We assist crime victims, provide emergency management services, work to protect our state from the threat of terror, and handle many other responsibilities as well. One of the nation’s most diverse and populous states, New Jersey is also a hub of national and international commerce, air travel and shipping.
    [Show full text]
  • En Banc on October 14, 2015 Argued En Banc on February 17, 2016
    PRECEDENTIAL UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT _____________ Nos. 14-4546, 14-4568, and 14-4569 _____________ NATIONAL COLLEGIATE ATHLETIC ASSOCIATION, an unincorporated association; NATIONAL BASKETBALL ASSOCIATION, a joint venture; NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE, an unincorporated association; NATIONAL HOCKEY LEAGUE, an unincorporated association; OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF BASEBALL, an unincorporated association doing business as MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL v. GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY; DAVID L. REBUCK, Director of the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement and Assistant Attorney General of the State of New Jersey; FRANK ZANZUCCKI, Executive Director of the New Jersey Racing Commission; NEW JERSEY THOROUGHBRED HORSEMEN’S ASSOCIATION, INC; NEW JERSEY SPORTS & EXPOSITION AUTHORITY STEPHEN M. SWEENEY, President of the New Jersey Senate; VINCENT PRIETO, Speaker of the New Jersey General Assembly (Intervenors in District Court) Appellants in 14-4568 Governor of New Jersey; David L. Rebuck; Frank Zanzuccki, Appellants in 14-4546 New Jersey Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Association, Inc., Appellant in 14-4569 On Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey (District Court No.: 3-14-cv-06450) District Judge: Honorable Michael A. Shipp Argued on March 17, 2015 before Merits Panel Court Ordered Rehearing En Banc on October 14, 2015 Argued En Banc on February 17, 2016 Before: AMBRO, FUENTES, SMITH, FISHER, JORDAN, HARDIMAN, GREENAWAY JR., VANASKIE, KRAUSE, RESTREPO, RENDELL, and BARRY, Circuit Judges 2 (Opinion filed: August 9, 2016) John J. Hoffman, Esquire Acting Attorney General of the State of New Jersey Jeffrey S. Jacobson, Esquire Stuart M. Feinblatt, Esquire Peter M. Slocum, Esquire Office of Attorney General of New Jersey 25 Market Street Trenton, NJ 08625 Matthew M.
    [Show full text]