ECON 782: Economics of the Family Instructor Course Overview
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UMass Amherst, Fall 2013 ECON 782, Murray-Close ECON 782: Economics of the Family Fall 2013 Monday 1:00-3:30 Thompson Hall, Room 919 Instructor Marta Murray-Close Office: Thompson 1018 E-mail: [email protected] Telephone: 413-545-3412 Office hours: Mo 9:30-10:30, Th 1:30-2:30, and by appointment Course overview This course provides an introduction to the \economic" approach to family re- search. I put \economic" in scare quotes because we will take as our point of departure a particular economic approach: the rational choice approach pio- neered by Gary Becker in his Treatise on the Family and related work. We will examine the assumptions underlying rational choice models of family behavior, assess the plausibility of those assumptions, and discuss whether and to what extent rational choice models can help us understand the form and function- ing of families. We will also examine critiques of the economic approach from feminist, sociological, and other perspectives. You may already have an opinion about rational choice models in general, the application of rational choice mod- els to the family in particular, or Gary Becker. By the end of the semester, you may or may not have changed your opinion, but you will be a more nuanced and sophisticated fan or critic than many commentators on the family. Family economics is a fascinating field because it touches on issues with which we all have personal experience and because it provides theoretical and empirical insight into current controversies over modern families. This class will ask and provide at least partial answers to the following sorts of questions: How have families changed over the last century? Do family members behave selfishly or altruistically toward one another? How do they made decisions when their interests diverge? Why do people get married? Why don't they get married? What kinds of people marry each other and why? Why have men and women traditionally played different roles in the family? Is the sexual division of labor a great idea for everyone? A bad idea for women? How do people decide whether or not to have children and how many children to have? Why are they having fewer children than they used to? How do public policies influence family behavior? 1 This version: September 9, 2013 UMass Amherst, Fall 2013 ECON 782, Murray-Close In addition to introducing you to substantive content in the field of family economics, this course offers opportunities to develop your own research interests and to strengthen your research and presentation skills. My specific objectives for you this semester are the following. • Describe demographic trends and changes in the family over the last cen- tury. • Explain the \economic" approach to family research and how the economic approach differs from other approaches. • Critically evaluate the economic approach and give your own assessment of its strengths and limitations. • Summarize studies from the foundation and frontier of family research and use those studies to motivate your own research. • Present, clearly and concisely, the motivation, methods, and results of your own research and research by others. • Make substantial progress on an original research project that may become a part of your dissertation or a publishable paper. Class format This will be an interactive, discussion-oriented class. Depending on the material, I may take some time at the beginning of class to highlight key terms or concepts from the readings, but we'll spend most of each meeting discussing the readings and your reactions to them. A student will lead the discussion most weeks, and I'll fill in as needed depending on enrollment. I'll also reserve a few minutes at the end of each class to discuss questions I've prepared for us in advance of the readings for the following week. To do high-quality research, it is essential to familiarize yourself with the research frontier in your area of interest. But to do creative research, it is also advisable to do some thinking about a topic yourself before you read too much about what others have been thinking. Having framed the issues or questions for yourself, you may be surprised at the framing others have used { and you may find that your own approach contains insights that others have missed. Prerequisites This course is open to graduate students in economics and other social and be- havioral science fields. Because students from different departments will have different backgrounds, my expectations regarding the form { but not the rigor 2 This version: September 9, 2013 UMass Amherst, Fall 2013 ECON 782, Murray-Close or quality { of your work will depend to some extent on your field. Eco- nomics students should have completed graduate-level microeconomic theory and econometrics, and students from other departments should have completed a graduate-level theory course and a statistics or quantitative methods course. Course components Response papers (35%). Starting in the second week of the semester and continuing through the twelfth week, students will submit a 2-3 page response paper that provides a brief summary of each assigned reading and describes your reactions to the readings. You may discuss strengths and weaknesses of the individual readings, themes and connections between the readings, or some combination of both. Summarizing the readings is a way to ensure that you've identified the main points, but your reactions are more important than your summaries. Accordingly, you should allocate no more than one page of each reaction paper to the summaries and should be sure to allocate at least one page to your reactions. Please post your response paper to Moodle at least 24 hours before class. Discussion leading (15%). Each student will lead our class discussion twice during the semester. The discussion leader will present a short summary of each reading and prepare a list of at least eight discussion questions for the class. Presenting material is one of the best ways to master it, and strong presentation skills are a tremendous asset in a research or teaching career. Research proposal (35%). Students will prepare a 10-20 page proposal for a research project on a topic in family economics. Your proposal should include the motivation for your project, including the gap in the existing literature that you will fill; a statement of your research question; and a description of the data and methods you will use to answer the question. You should also include at least one of the following (1) a set of preliminary results or (2) a summary of your expected results. A one-page outline of the proposal is due in class on October 15, and the full proposal is due on the last day of class. Presentation of research proposal (15%). Students will present their re- search proposals on the last day of class. Presentations should cover each ele- ment of the proposal (motivation, question, data, methods, and preliminary or expected results) and should be no more than 25 minutes long. 3 This version: September 9, 2013 UMass Amherst, Fall 2013 ECON 782, Murray-Close Contacting me E-mail is the best way to reach me. During the week, I try to respond to messages within a day. Sometimes, if I'm really busy, I may need two days. If you don't hear back from me within two work days, please feel free to send me a reminder. I don't always check e-mail over the weekend, so I may not respond to messages you send on Friday until the following Monday. Course schedule This is a tentative schedule of the topics we'll cover during the semester, along with a list of required readings for each topic. I've listed the readings in the order I think it makes most sense to read them. I suggest that you purchase a copy of Becker's A Treatise on the Family because we will read several chapters of the book and because it is an essential reference for social scientists who study the family. Most of the remaining readings are available in electronic format through the library system, and I will post readings that are not easily accessible on Moodle. Depending on our pace and your level of interest, I may spend more or less time than indicated on some topics. I may also make substitutions in the readings. If I make substantial changes to the schedule, I will provide you, via e-mail or the course website, with updated an syllabus that reflects the changes. Week Date Topics Readings 1 09/09 Demographic trends and Lundberg and Pollak(2007) family change 2 09/16 The \economic" approach Becker(1993) to family research Bergmann(1996) Pollak(2003) 3 09/23 Empirical methods in Moffitt(2005) family research Waite(1995) Angrist and Evans(1998) 4 09/30 Gains from marriage Weiss(1997), Sections 1-2 Stevenson and Wolfers(2007) Polikoff(2003) 5 10/07 Household specialization Becker(1991), Chapter 2 and the sexual division of Hadfield(1999) labor Badgett and Folbre(1999) 4 This version: September 9, 2013 UMass Amherst, Fall 2013 ECON 782, Murray-Close Week Date Topics Readings 6 10/15 Models of household Lundberg and Pollak(1996) behavior Becker(1991), Chapter 8 Due: outline of Lundberg and Pollak(2003) research proposal 7 10/21 Gender and household Lundberg and Pollak(1993) bargaining Agarwal(1997) Stevenson and Wolfers(2006) 8 10/28 Marriage markets and Becker(1991), Chapter 4 assortative mating Lam(1988) Jepsen and Jepsen(2002) 9 11/04 Fertility, contraception, Becker(1991), Chapter 5 and investments in Bailey(2006) children Lam and Duryea(1999) 10 11/13 Non-marital fertility Akerlof et al.(1996) Willis(1999) Gibson-Davis et al.(2005) 11 11/18 Non-traditional and Black et al.(2007) non-marital households Xie et al.(2003) TBD 12 11/25 Intergenerational ties Lillard and Willis(1997) Rainer and Siedler(2009) Folbre(1994) 13 12/02 Presentations of research proposals Due: final draft research proposal 5 This version: September 9, 2013 UMass Amherst, Fall 2013 ECON 782, Murray-Close Full references Agarwal, Bina (1997) \`Bargaining' and Gender Relations: Within and Beyond the Household," Feminist Economics, Vol.