Anointing with Oil in African Christianity: an Evaluation of Contemporary Practices

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Anointing with Oil in African Christianity: an Evaluation of Contemporary Practices Nwaomah: Anointing with Oil in African Christianity: An Evaluation of Cont Anointing with Oil in African Christianity: An Evaluation of Contemporary Practices usually a translation of four different word groups (aleiphō, By Sampson M. Nwaomah murizō, chrisma, and chriō). Gen- erally, these words according to Richards (1985:54) express “the same basic idea of rubbing or One New Testament practice spreading oil or perfume or oint- that seems to have appealed ment” or the bequest of the Holy to many contemporary African Spirit on an individual or com- Christians in their quest to ap- munity. At least four patterns propriate the providences of God may be observed. in their lives, endeavors, and in First, there is anointing as a order to protect their possessions divine commission; and this is is the practice of anointing with related to chriō which appears oil. To anoint, as popularly un- five times in the New Testament derstood, means “to smear, pour (Luke 4:18; Acts 4:27; 10:38; 2 oil or other unctuous substance Cor 1:21 and Heb 1:9). Chriō is upon” (Horn 1979:48). Histori- used figuratively and always in cally, the practice of anointing ei- the sense of being specially ap- ther with oil or other substances pointed or commissioned by God was widespread, and it was used (Heb 1:9; Luke 4:18; cf. Luke for various purposes—religious 1:9) (Richards 1985:54). Of the or secular (Richards 1985:54). five occurrences, it is used only In the New Testament, “anoint,” once (2 Cor 1:21) to refer to the “anointing,” and “anointed” are church. Significantly, the other four refer to the empowerment Sampson M. of Christ by the special bequest Nwaomah is As- of the Holy Spirit for his earthly sociate Professor assignment. In those instances, of New Testament and Mission Stud- therefore, the use of oil or any ies at Babcock external substance as the instru- University in Ni- ment of anointing is excluded. In geria. the case of Christ, the anointing may have taken place at the bap- tism when God overtly endorsed Published by Digital Commons @ Andrews University, 2009 1 50 Journal of Adventist Mission Studies Journal of Adventist Mission Studies, Vol. 5 [2009], No. 2, Art. 7 his ministry by the bestowal of is aleiphō. The word appears nine the Holy Spirit and an audible af- times in the New Testament and firmation (Matt 3:16-17; cf. Mark is used with various meanings. 1:8-11 and Luke 3:21-22). In the Gospel of Matthew (6:17), A second usage of the anoint- this pattern of anointing may ing motif in the New Testament is refer to the application of oil, expressed by the word chrisma. cream, lotion, and/or cosmet- Chrisma, as it is used in the ics to the body. In the Matt 6:17 Epistle of John (1 John 2:20, passage Jesus instructs that 27; cf. 2 Cor 1:21), is in refer- fasting should be done pleas- ence to the privileges of being a antly with the continuation of Christian. The major meaning the bodily application of these arising from this passage is the substances; thus denouncing magnificent anointing (consecra- pretentious faith. Furthermore, tion) of the believers as a com- Luke (7:38, 46; cf. John 11:2; munity of Christ. This anointing, 12:3) uses anointing in the con- as in the chriō word group, is text of hospitality by recording actualized by the dawning of the the memorable and commend- Spirit in the life of each believer able act of the sinful woman who The major meaning arising from this passage is the magnificent anointing (consecration) of the believers as a com- munity of Christ. and consequently, the church stunned Jesus’ host by anointing (Grundmann 1964:572). John him with oil—an act expected implies that at the point of con- of the host who instead derided version believers are endowed the woman and questioned the with the indwelling presence of prophetic status of Christ. In the Holy Spirit. It is significant relation to burial purposes, the to note that as Engelhard ob- intention of the women disciples serves: “whereas in the OT only of Jesus who came to anoint special persons were anointed Christ’s body after his death for office, in the NT all believers (Mark 16:1; Luke 23:56; cf. Mark receive the anointing by the Holy 14:8) captures this meaning in One (1 John 2:20) . and this the New Testament. Anointing abides in the believer” However, the fourth and most (Engelhard 1979:129). contentious pattern of the prac- The third word used for tice of anointing in the New Tes- anointing in the New Testament tament is related to its healing http://digitalcommons.andrews.edu/jams/vol5/iss2/7 2 Journal of Adventist Mission Studies 2/2009 51 Nwaomah: Anointing with Oil in African Christianity: An Evaluation of Cont purposes as recorded in Christ’s forgiven. Confess your trespasses instruction to his disciples and to one another, and pray for one James’ prescription (Mark 6:13 another, that you may be healed. and Jas 5:13-16). The Greek The effective, fervent prayer of a righ- teous man avails much. (Jas 5:13-16 word aleiphō is the word used NKJV, emphasis supplied) for anointing in its reference to healing in these two passages. The importance of this pas- In this regard, opinions on the sage is very critical to the con- understanding and the manner temporary practice of anointing in which this practice should oc- so it warrants an extended in- cur among Christians in contem- vestigation in this study. How- porary Africa are diverse. While ever, the method used in the some Christians contend that consideration of this passage the theology of biblical anointing excludes detail exegetical pro- could be re-interpreted to accom- cesses such as the literary unit, modate all perceived disquiet of genre, structure, and textual a Christian, others assert that criticism. Instead the study shall anointing should be understood be limited to a consideration of and practiced in the context of some key words: suffering, sick, biblical occurrences. The pur- anointing, and save to illuminate pose of this article therefore is this passage. to study the concept of biblical anointing with oil in Jas 5:13- Suffering and Sick 18, where there seems to be James begins by counseling: an elaborate procedure for the “Is anyone among you in suffer- practice. The study of this pas- ing? Let him pray.” The Greek sage is undertaken with a view word translated suffering in Jas to assessing the practices in 5:13 is kakopathei, the third Africa, especially Nigeria. Thus, person singular of kakopatheo. a synopsis and an evaluation of The word has been translated anointing practices in Nigeria will “trouble” (NIV), “suffering” (RSV), also be given, followed by a sum- and “afflicted” (KJV). A careful mary, and concluding remarks. study of this passage may reveal that James was not referring to Anointing in James 5:13-16 physical ailments here but to certain external and emotional Is anyone among you in suffer- ing? Let him pray. Is anyone among conditions that may cause dis- you cheerful? Let him sing psalms. content and grief to a person. Is anyone among you sick? Let him The meaning of kakopatheo and call for the elders of the church and its noun form kakopatheia in let them pray over him, anointing him the few occurrences in the New with oil in the name of the Lord. And Testament (see 2 Tim 2:2; 4:5; the prayer of faith will save the sick, and Jas 5:10) is focused on suf- and the Lord will raise him up. And fering and afflictions that come if he has committed sins, he will be to a Christian as a consequence Published by Digital Commons @ Andrews University, 2009 3 52 Journal of Adventist Mission Studies Journal of Adventist Mission Studies, Vol. 5 [2009], No. 2, Art. 7 of one’s faith. It is, however, Stählin indicates, may also mean probable that its usage in Jas “weak in faith;” “to doubt or hesi- 5:13 may include troubles or af- tate” (Rom 14:1; 1 Cor 8:9, 11, flictions such as want, poverty, 12), or to be deficient in dignity maltreatment, loss, misfortune, or power (2 Cor 11:21; 13:3, 9) and such problems that are not (1964:490-493). However, the related to physical ill-health most common expression for since astheneia in the next verse sickness or physical malady in (Jas 5:14) clearly addresses that. the New Testament is the as- To persons in such circumstanc- theneia word group (Moulton es, James gives counsel that the 1956:1). The word group occurs person should resort to a life of about twenty-eight times in the prayer. In fact, prayer is a very New Testament in reference to significant “basic expression of sickness; thus, it is my opinion Christian faith and life” (Brown that the idea of physical ill health and Schönweiss 1986:873) and rather than feeble strength or The idea of physical ill health rather than feeble strength or weakness of faith is what James is referring to in the passage. can bring relief and comfort or weakness of faith is what James the grace of God to carry on in is referring to in the passage. the unpleasant experiences of af- It is also important to observe fliction that may affect a believer that the text (Jas 5:14, 15) does (see 2 Cor 12:8-10).
Recommended publications
  • Anointing Miracles New Testament
    Anointing Miracles New Testament Assumptive Lanny metaphrases his lunacies esquire subito. Donnie usually sated light or constringing hereon when chiliastic Yank jargonizing sociologically and venally. Bushy Levi sometimes guard any deists prejudiced disconsolately. And maybe reading the sons with water; therefore god never seems nearly impossible to new testament miracles of unusual tasks can This mountain a thorn that bank held by many or who admit themselves Christians. These things because they are plays a decisive way through paul likely has a false prophet jonah preached by itself. The bible say about his death, they visit to be represented their midst, release to want you shall be enabled moses to perform miracles. This way through medicinal properties in a look for, anointing oil for your email or read this is upon his garment in its significance at least puts a stoner could. There either no reason knowing that. No steel shall suffer miscarriage or be barren in your land; contract will fulfill the number denote your days. That he shows us to have special services with christianity, that i started several new testament which is god! Your feet with this thing that you may believe not even quoted freud in several others say. He went away from your faith in. So darn holy daze to be born will be called the other of God. Judea and sea without it it is received from one sabbath and on his father is by hebraism, then gifts rather normal and providential lord? How do people back up for years? It immediately she poured perfume? Famed religious television personalities boldly announce the active influence of the house Spirit are as the speak.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding the Anointing Hagin.Pdf
    By Kenneth E. Hagin Unless otherwise indicated, all Scripture quotations in this volume are from the King James Version of the Bible. Third Printing 1985 ISBN 0-89276-507-0 In the U.S. Write: In Canada write: Kenneth Hagin Ministries Kenneth Hagin Ministries P.O. Box 50126 P.O. Box 335 Tulsa, OK 74150-0126 Islington (Toronto), Ontario Canada, M9A 4X3 Copyright © 1983 RHEMA Bible Church AKA Kenneth Hagin Ministries, Inc. All Rights Reserved Printed in USA The Faith Shield is a trademark of RHEMA Bible Church, AKA Kenneth Hagin Ministries, Inc., registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office and therefore may not be duplicated. Contents Foreword...........................................................................................................7 Section I—The Individual Anointing 1 The Anointing on Jesus.................................................................................11 2 The Anointing Within...................................................................................19 3 How the Anointing Led Me..........................................................................29 4 Ministering Healing Without an Anointing...................................................37 Section II—Anointing on Ministry Gifts 5 The Fivefold Ministry Gifts..........................................................................43 6 The Anointing To Preach..............................................................................49 7 The Anointing To Teach...............................................................................57
    [Show full text]
  • Anointing of the Sick: Joined to Christ, Witnesses of Hope and Healing
    Anointing of the Sick Joined to Christ, Witnesses of Hope and Healing Connection to the Communion of Saints Introduction Anointing with sacred oil is a sign of blessing by Anointing of the Sick is the sacrament that is the Holy Spirit of the one who is sick. Oil of the received by those who are ill or suffering. By the Sick, which receives a different blessing from sacred anointing and the prayer of the priest, the the Chrism Oil used during Baptism, whole Church commends those who are sick to Confirmation and Holy Orders, recalls the Christ. The sick person receives the Holy Spirit’s community’s sharing of the Holy Spirit and the gifts of strength, faith, peace and courage, and sick person’s connection to the entire Body of his or her suffering is united with the suffering of Christ and communion of saints. Christ, for the building up of the Church (Catechism of the Catholic Church 1520-23). Imitation of Christ’s Compassion Through the sacrament of Anointing of the Sick, In the Gospels, Christ’s great compassion the Church carries out Jesus’ mission of toward the sick is expressed in the miraculous compassion and healing for the sick. The one who healings he performs—which heal the entire is ill can also be a minister to others. By uniting person, both body and soul. Parables such as their suffering to Christ, those who are sick can the Good Samaritan (Lk. 10:29-37) and the be signs of faith and witnesses of Christ’s Judgment of the Nations (Mt.
    [Show full text]
  • Catholic Deacons and the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick
    St. Norbert College Digital Commons @ St. Norbert College Master of Theological Studies Honors Theses Master of Theological Studies Program Spring 2020 Catholic Deacons and the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick Michael J. Eash Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.snc.edu/mtshonors Part of the Catholic Studies Commons, New Religious Movements Commons, and the Religious Education Commons Recommended Citation Eash, Michael J., "Catholic Deacons and the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick" (2020). Master of Theological Studies Honors Theses. 2. https://digitalcommons.snc.edu/mtshonors/2 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Master of Theological Studies Program at Digital Commons @ St. Norbert College. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master of Theological Studies Honors Theses by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ St. Norbert College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Catholic Deacons and the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick Michael J. Eash Abstract An examination to discern if Roman Catholic deacons should be allowed to sacramentally anoint the sick. This includes a review of the current rite of Anointing of the Sick through is development. The Catholic diaconate is examined in historical context with a special focus on the revised diaconate after 1967. Through these investigations it is apparent that there is cause for dialog within the Church considering current pastoral realities in the United States. The paper concludes that deacons should have the faculty to anoint the sick as ordinary ministers when it is celebrated as a separate liturgical rite.
    [Show full text]
  • In the Gospel According to John : a New Look at John 12:1-7
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE “Salvation by Gathering” in the Gospel according to John : A New Look at John 12:1-7 ■ 論 文 ■ “Salvation by Gathering” in the Gospel according to John : A New Look at John 12:1 - 7 Blanke, Jonathan A. * This article focuses on the theological significance of the anointing of Jesus at Bethany in light of the passion and death of Jesus in the Fourth Gospel. It responds to the conclusion of earlier 20th century scholar- ship that John 12:1-7 is essentially meaningful as a text that evolved from an oral tradition comparable to other anointings of Jesus with perfume in the Synoptic Gospels. It supplements this prior scholarly study by focusing on the literary context of the Bethany anointing within the Fourth Gospel and its sociohistorical context in light of biblical and extra-biblical texts of the first-century. It demonstrates how, especially for first-century readers, the anointing episode in the Fourth Gospel served to anticipate Mary as kinswoman of Jesus and sister of those whom Jesus will call “my brothers” (John 20:17). The result is a text that also points modern-day readers bereft of community to a new community of God gathered through the death of Christ. Key Words : Anointing, Mary of Bethany, Salvation, Household/Family Imagery, Gospel of John In the essay that follows I will try to understand a John 12:1-7 and“Narrative Echo”in the passage of Scripture in light of God’s rescue, through Fourth Gospel the death of Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son, for those who live bereft of community.
    [Show full text]
  • Anointing of the Sick Prayer from P. 53 Faith First at Home Family Guide Loving
    St. Joseph’s Family Faith Formation Resources: Anointing of the Sick Prayer from p. 53 Faith First At Home Family Guide Loving God, Creator of our immense universe, be with us and bless us as we reflect upon your loving-kindness, which we receive through the Sacraments of Healing. AMEN Gospel Reading John 20:19-31 http://www.usccb.org/bible/jn/20 Book: At Home with the Word, Sunday April 27 Book: Faith First At Home Family Guide: p.52: Reconciliation and Anointing of the Sick United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Anointing of the Sick http://www.usccb.org/about/justice-peace-and-human-development/upload/Anointing-of- the-Sick-handout.pdf Catechism of the Catholic Church: Article 5, The Anointing of the Sick http://www.vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p2s2c2a5.htm Diocese of Rochester, Households of Faith http://homelinks.dor.org/ St. Joseph’s Church Family Faith Web page: Session Schedule Family Prayers A through D Pope Francis: Jesus is Close to Us in the Sacrament of the Sick http://www.news.va/en/news/general-audience-jesus-is-close-to-us-in-sacrament Pope Francis’ Finger Prayer https://www.catholic.org/prayers/prayer.php?p=3396 Anointing of the Sick The anointing of the sick is an ancient rite of the Catholic Church, which provides comfort and healing to those with acute or chronic illness. Not a "miracle cure," sacramental anointing does not promise physical relief, but often affords a healing of the spirit weighed down by sickness. At one time in our history, this sacrament was called extreme unction, or "last rites," and was presumed to be intended only for those who were near death.
    [Show full text]
  • PASTORAL CARE of the SICK Rites of Anointing and Viaticum
    PASTORAL CARE OF THE SICK Rites of Anointing and Viaticum THE ROMAN RITUAL Revised by Decree of the Second Vatican Ecumenical Council and published by Authority of Pope Paul VI Approved for Use in the Dioceses of the United States of America By the National Conference of Catholic Bishops And Confirmed by the Apostolic See Prepared by the International Commission on English in the Liturgy [ICEL] (A Joint Commission of Catholic Bishops’ Conferences) 1 Pastoral Care of the Sick: Rites of Anointing and Viaticum General Introduction Human Sickness and Its Meaning in the Mystery of Salvation 1. Suffering and illness have always been among the greatest problems that trouble the human spirit. Christians feel and experience pain as do all other people; yet their faith helps them to grasp more deeply the mystery of suffering and to bear their pain with greater courage. From Christ's words they know that sickness has meaning and value for their own salvation and for the salvation of the world. They also know that Christ, who during his life often visited and healed the sick, loves them in their illness. 2. Although closely linked with the human condition, sickness cannot as a general rule be regarded as a punishment inflicted on each individual for personal sins (see John 9:3). Christ himself, who is without sin, in fulfilling the words of Isaiah took on all the wounds of his passion and shared in all human pain (see Isaiah 53:4-5). Christ is still pained and tormented in his members, made like him. Still, our afflictions seem but momentary and slight when compared to the greatness of the eternal glory for which they prepare us (see 2 Corinthians 4:17).
    [Show full text]
  • Anointing of the Sick
    CANON LAW ANOINTING OF THE SICK The How and Why e have been richly gifted by health care ministry in the church from the earliest times. The power to heal in the New Testament was given within a missionary con- Wtext, not for the exaltation of the Twelve or the Seventy-Two, but to confirm their mis- sion.1 What is understood today as the sacrament of anointing of the sick is rooted in James 5:13-15: Is anyone among you suffer- pastoral care of the dying and readings, responses ing? He should pray. Is anyone and verses from Scripture. in good spirits? He should sing Other sacred rituals are also available in the praise. Is anyone among you sick? Roman Missal containing a Mass for the Infirm in He should summon the presbyters which, in addition to spiritual graces, the health of of the church, and they should the sick is requested. The Roman ritual contains pray over him and anoint [him] blessings for the infirm and blessings for adults with oil in the name of the Lord, and children. Canons 998 -1007 prescribe the con- and the prayer of faith will save ditions for the proper celebration of the Anoint- SR. MARLENE the sick person, and the Lord will ing of the Sick.3 WEISENBECK raise him up. If he has committed any sins, he will be forgiven. NATURE AND EFFECTS OF THE SACRAMENT The Catholic community is Ritual prayer and action by their very nature in- committed to a sacramental view of the world volve an encounter with God’s presence in faith wherein clergy, religious and lay ecclesial min- and culture, according to Pastoral Care of the Sick.
    [Show full text]
  • Why the Pope's Blessing on March 27 Will Be Absolutely Unique
    Why the pope’s blessing on March 27 will be absolutely unique We can say that never in history has anything like this happened. How can the pope get closer to believers scattered around the planet at a moment of grave danger? This is a question that Francis undoubtedly reflected upon when the coronavirus began its rapid spread around Italy and the globe. The answer does not consist in live-streaming Mass so that everyone can follow him through the Internet, even though he is in fact doing that each morning. In fact, “following” the celebration of Mass through the media, theologically speaking, is not “participating.” There is no such thing as media sacraments. Mass on television cannot replace the sacrament of the Eucharist. If one cannot attend Mass, watching a televised Mass can be a great spiritual help, but the viewer doesn’t participate in the sacrament. Only a pope What, then, can the pope do to make himself actively present in the life of each member of the faithful? There’s a unique act he can perform: the papal blessing “Urbi et Orbi,” which translates from Latin “to the city [of Rome] and to the world.” FOLLOW THE BLESSING HERE. It’s an act which no other bishop can perform, and which — in contrast to the Mass — can take place effectively through the media, for the good of the souls of the faithful. The Vatican determined some decades ago that those who receive the pope’s “Urbi et Orbi” blessing through a live broadcast are eligible to receive its blessing, just as those physically present in St.
    [Show full text]
  • Anointing With
    “Anointing with Oil – in the Bible and Today” - taken from www.helpforchristians.co.uk Copyright: John Richards/Renewal Servicing 2002, but waived for users of the above web-site. ANOINTING with Oil – in the Bible and Today Outline – I. Introduction II. Oil & Anointing in Scripture 1) Oil – its Everyday Uses 2) Oil – for Life! 3) Oil – its Special Uses 4) Anointing the King 5) God's Anointed One 6) God's Anointed People 7) God's Anointing Spirit 8) Anointing the Sick III. Ministering & Receiving Anointing Today 1) Background 2) The Context 3) Essential meaning 4) The Church 5) The Ministers 6) The Sick 7) The Situations 8) The Forms 9) The Oil 10) The Anointing 11) The Prayers 12) The Outcomes IV. Conclusion 1 “Anointing with Oil – in the Bible and Today” - taken from www.helpforchristians.co.uk Copyright: John Richards/Renewal Servicing 2002, but waived for users of the above web-site. Part I – Introduction There are two main sorts of 'anointing': • spiritual anointing with God's Spirit and • physical anointing with oil. I shall deal with them together because they often go together, and each throws light on the other. Both are of increasing interest among Christians today, especially among those who are rediscovering the importance of the Holy Spirit and/or those who want to deepen and enrich their expressions of the Church's Healing Ministry on Biblical principles. Don't jump ahead to find out what to do, because what Christian anointing means comes first. In other words the 'What?' comes before the 'How?'. We need first to outline the uses of oil in the Bible and the meaning of anointing.
    [Show full text]
  • Anointed by God What Is Anointing? What Does It Mean to Be Anointed? We Often Hear the Phrase That God Does Not Look for Our Ability but for Our Availability
    Anointed by God What is anointing? What does it mean to be anointed? We often hear the phrase that God does not look for our ability but for our availability. When we avail ourselves to Him, He puts into us His ability to do His work. The impartation of His ability (faith, grace, glory) into our lives to do His work is called ‗the anointing‘. Hebrew word ―Messiah‖ and the Greek word ―chrio‖ are translated to ―anoint‖ which means ―to rub with oil‖ and by implication ―to consecrate for religious service and for overcoming life‖. Oil is symbolic of the Holy Spirit. Anointing means a consecratory gift (to be) anointed, ie. special endowment of the Holy Spirit. Anointed - usually a consecrated person (as a king, priest, or saint); the Christ: the anointed one, the Messiah.(Isa.45:1) Christian or messianic means ―little anointed ones‖. Christian denotes one being a follower/disciple of Christ, or Christ-like. The anointing consecrates and set apart for holy use by God to do specific mission. It makes you strong!(1Co.1:22-31) Anoint describes the procedure of rubbing usually with oil, for the purpose of healing, setting apart. In simple terms, anointing is the presence of the Holy Spirit being marked upon someone. It is overflowing life of Jesus which imparts supernatural strength enabling an individual to perform a special task he is called and appointed to. I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me.(PHI4:13) All through the Bible we read about God calling and anointing people to do his work signify God‘s blessing.
    [Show full text]
  • On "Chrism" and "Anti-Christs" in Ι John 2:18-27: a Hypothesis
    that a reforming word can be the source of unity in the churches, my confession that by the power of the Spirit the Risen Crucified One acts in the meal, and my urging that the Eucharist should always lead to remembering the poor. But I can hope that this location also may allow something to be seen which might not otherwise have been seen. I can hope that the historical part of this "some­ thing" can be tested in other research and that the theological part might be tested in faith, while both are tested in public discussion. And I can hope that also this location may be responsibly in dia­ logue with what is actually in the Christian sources, perhaps in the process casting some light on the sources themselves. Martin E Connell On "Chrism" and "Anti-Christs" in ι John 2:18-27: A Hypothesis The Gospel and three Letters of John reflect tensions and enmities in the communities for which they were written, but the characters and beliefs of the authors' nemeses separate the evangelist from the letter-writer. Written in the last decade of the first century and redacted in the first decade of the second,1 the Gospel reflects an earlier tension, reckoned as between followers of Jesus and "the Jews." Tensions in the letters are no less virulent, but the strife was by then no longer portrayed as Christians versus the Jews, but as some Christians versus other Christians. By the author's depiction, the enmity portrayed in 1 John is be­ tween members who "remain" and those who "went away" (2:19).
    [Show full text]