Arxiv:1706.04027V2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Interactions between Silica Particles in the Presence of Multivalent Coions Biljana Uzelac, Valentina Valmacco,∗ and Gregor Trefalt† Department of Inorganic and Analytical Chemistry, University of Geneva, Sciences II, 30 Quai Ernest-Ansermet, 1205 Geneva, Switzerland (Dated: July 25, 2017) Forces between charged silica particles in solutions of multivalent coions are measured with col- loidal probe technique based on atomic force microscopy. The concentration of 1:z electrolytes is systematically varied to understand the behavior of electrostatic interactions and double-layer prop- erties in these systems. Although the coions are multivalent the Derjaguin, Landau, Verwey, and Overbeek (DLVO) theory perfectly describes the measured force profiles. The diffuse-layer potentials and regulation properties are extracted from the forces profiles by using the DLVO theory. The de- pendencies of the diffuse-layer potential and regulation parameter shift to lower concentration with increasing coion valence when plotted as a function of concentration of 1:z salt. Interestingly, these profiles collapse to a master curve if plotted as a function of monovalent counterion concentration. I. INTRODUCTION in the case of multivalent coion systems. Force pro- files across solutions containing multivalent counterions Interactions between charged objects in electrolyte so- are usually exponential, which is typical for double-layer lutions are important for many biological systems [1], and forces. Interestingly, their coion counterparts invoke non- in processes such as paper making [2], waste water treat- exponential and soft long-ranged forces, which can be ment [3], ceramic processing [4], ink-jet printing [5], par- well described with the PB theory [21, 27]. Extreme case ticle design [6], and concrete hardening [7]. Electrostatic of such non-exponential force profiles can be induced by interactions across such solutions are strongly influenced like-charged polyelectrolytes, which can be modelled as by the type of ions present and their concentration. One coions with extremely high effective valence [28, 29]. This of the most important ion properties in this respect is non-exponential behavior is induced by the expulsion of the ionic valence. Furthermore, it is important whether the multivalent coions from the slit between two charged the multivalent ions are counterions, which are oppositely surfaces. At large-separation distances, both counterions charged than the surface, or coions, which carry the same and coions enter in the slit. When distance between the charge as the surface. surfaces is reduced, the electrostatic repulsion between The forces between charged colloidal particles or the surface and multivalent coions is increased, which fi- charged surfaces across aqueous solutions can now be rou- nally leads to the expulsion of the latter from the slit and tinely measured with variety of experimental techniques only monovalent counterions are left between the charged such as surface force apparatus (SFA) [8, 9], colloidal surfaces. These counterion-only double-layer results in a probe atomic force microscopy (AFM) [10, 11], total in- power-law dependence of the force [21, 30, 31]. There- ternal reflection microscopy (TIRM) [12, 13], and optical fore, the forces in multivalent coion systems are exponen- tweezers [14, 15]. tial only at large distances and transition to a power-law Direct force measurements in the presence of multiva- behavior at smaller separations. Furthermore, the influ- lent counterions received increased attention lately, es- ence on these type on interactions on the aggregation pecially in the view of the validity of their description of colloidal particles can have non-expected results. For within the mean-field Poisson-Boltzmann theory[16–24]. example, for aggregating suspension critical coagulation Multivalent counterions typically strongly influence the ionic strength (CCIS) strongly decreases with increasing electrostatic forces already at very minute concentra- counterion valence [32]. This behavior is known for over tions [17–19, 21–23]. These studies showed that mean- a century and is referred to as the classical Schulze-Hardy rule. Surprisingly, if one uses the multivalent coions as arXiv:1706.04027v2 [cond-mat.soft] 24 Jul 2017 field PB theory can be used with confidence at larger separation distances, while at smaller separations of few an aggregating agent as opposed to the counterions, an nanometers, the experimental forces deviate from the PB inversion is observed as it was shown recently [33]. In description. These deviations can be caused by ion-ion multivalent coion systems the CCIS is increasing with correlations and/or other short-range forces [18, 21, 24– increasing valence, i.e. coagulating power of coions de- creases with increasing valence. Due to this inversion, the 26]. inverse While systems containing multivalent counterions are phenomenon was given a name: Schulze-Hardy relatively well investigated, literature is much scarcer rule [32–34]. Although, some information about these forces exists, to the best of our knowledge there are no studies which systematically investigate the forces and properties of the ∗ Current Address: Firmenich SA, Corporate R&D Division, Rue double-layer in a large range of concentrations for differ- de la Bergre 7, 1217 Geneva, Switzerland ent coion valences. In particular, no detailed information † E-mail: [email protected] exists on the regulation of charged surfaces in these sys- 2 tems. scope (Olympus IX70). The quartz slides and cantilevers In this work we focus on interactions between silica with attached probes were rinsed with water and ethanol, particles across solutions containing multivalent coions. dried in air, and plasma-treated for 20 min. The quartz We systematically study the influence of the concentra- substrate was glued (Pattex 100% Repair Gel) onto the tion and valence of the coions on double-layer forces. glass slide sealing the AFM cell. The AFM fluid cell We further examine the properties of the electric double- was mounted and flushed thoroughly with the respective layer, such as diffuse-layer potential and regulation pa- electrolyte solution. The particle on the cantilever was rameter, and try to pinpoint crucial factors which deter- centered above one particle on the substrate with the mine its behavior. Furtheremore a direct comparison of precision of about 100 nm. The deflection of the can- force curves at same salt concentration, counterion con- tilever was recorded for 100-200 approach-retract cycles centration, and ionic strength reveals how the structure with the sampling rate of 5 kHz and cantilever velocities of the double-layer changes when the valence of the coion of 300 nm/s, cycling frequency was 0.5 Hz. The zero sep- changes. aration distance was assumed when the force reached a value of 10 mN/m for repulsive curves, and 4 mN/m for attractive curves. Cantilever deflection was converted to II. EXPERIMENTAL the force using Hook’s law, where the spring-constant of the cantilever was determined by the method described A. Materials by Sader et al. [36]. The approach part of the raw force curves obtained with the procedure described above were For force measurements spherical silica particles averaged. The averaging of about 150 curves leads to the (Bangs Laboratories Inc., USA) were used. The producer noise level of about 2 pN. Only such averaged force pro- reports an average size of 5.2 µm. Before the measure- files are used in subsequent analysis. For each condition ments particles were heated at 1200 ◦C for 2 hours. Dur- forces between 3-5 different pairs of particles were mea- ing heat treatment the particles shrink for about 15 % sured. which yields an average diameter of 4.4 µm as reported earlier [35]. The root mean square (RMS) roughness of III. CHARGING OF THE SILICA SURFACE 0.63 nm was measured by AFM imaging in liquid [35]. Forces were measured in aqueous solutions of KCl (Sigma Basic Stern model is used to model the surface charge Aldrich), K2SO4 (Acros Organics), K3Fe(CN)6 (Sigma of silica particles at different solution compositions. For Aldrich), and K4Fe(CN)6 (Sigma Aldrich). The pH was kept at 10 ± 0.5 with addition of 1 mM KOH (Acros simplicity we just use 1-pK model, where only one type Organics) and was checked before and after each mea- of silanol groups can undergo deprotonation according to surement. Mili-Q water (Millipore) was use throughout. the following reaction [37–39] SiOH ⇋ SiO− + H+ . (1) B. Force Measurements The equilibrium between bulk protons and silanol groups is established according to the following equation, Force measurements were carried out with colloidal + βe0ψ0 [H ]e Γ − probe technique in the symmetric sphere-sphere geom- K = SiO , (2) etry [24]. The particles were first glued to the tip-less ΓSiOH cantilevers (MikroMasch, Tallin, Estonia) which were be- where K (pK = − log K) is the equilibrium constant, forehand cleaned in air plasma (PDC-32G, Harrick, New [H+] (pH = − log[H+]) is the bulk concentration of pro- York) for 5 min. Tiny drop of glue (Araldite 2000+) tons, e0 is the elementary charge, β = 1/(kBT ) is the and few silica particles were placed on a glass slide. The inverse thermal energy, ψ0 is the surface potential, and cantilever was mounted in the AFM head and manipu- ΓSiO− and ΓSiOH are the surface densities of deproto- lated to touch the glue then a silica particle was picked nated and protonated silanol groups, respectively. The up and glued on the cantilever. The particles were sep- total number of silanol groups on the surface is given by arately spread on a quartz substrate (Ted Pella inc.), which was cleaned with piranha solution (3:1 mixture of Γ0 =ΓSiO− +ΓSiOH . (3) H SO (98 %) and H O (30 %)). Both a quartz slide 2 4 2 2 The surface charge density can be calculated from the and a cantilever were then heated side-by-side in an oven number of deprotonated silanol groups as at 1200 ◦C for 2 h.