Citation Book
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
XIX ALL INDIA CONFERENCE OF DIRECTORS OF FINGER PRINT BUREAUX AT DR.MCR-HRD INSTITUTE OF TELANGANA, HYDERABAD ON 21st& 22nd JUNE, 2018 'AWARD OF EXCELLENCE IN FINGER PRINT IDENTIFICATION / SCIENCE COMPETITION – COMPILATION OF CASES' CENTRAL FINGER PRINT BUREAU NATIONAL CRIME RECORDS BUREAU MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS GOVERNMENT OF INDIA महानिदेशक भारत सरकार, गृह मंत्रालय डॉईश कुमार ., आई॰पी॰एस॰ राष्ट्रीय अपराध ररकाडड 녍यूरो Director राष्ट्रीय राजमागड-8, मनहपालपुर, िई दद쥍ली-110 DR ISH KUMAR IPS , 037 Government of India Ministry of Home Affairs National Crime Records Bureau NH-8, Mahipalpur, New Delhi-1100 037 FOREWORD CFPB, NCRB instituted awards for the good work done by Finger print experts working in States/UTs in the year 2016. A total of 16 cases have been received for this competition from 12 States/UTs. The winners of first, second, third prizes are Sh. N. Somashankar from Karnataka, Kumari. G. Swarna Jyothy from Telangana and Sh. T. Ramachandra Rao from Andhra Pradesh. Efforts and techniques adopted in developing chance prints, time taken to solve the case, and compulsory conviction are the important parameters based on which these winners are decided. The work done by other participants is also commendable and therefore we are circulating all these cases to the participants of 19th All India Conference of Directors of Finger Print Bureaux. Since, on this occasion, only 12 States/UTs have participated in this competition, therefore, it is my sincere request to all the States/UTs to take part in this competition in the coming years to showcase good work done by them in Finger Print Science. (Dr. Ish Kumar) New Delhi INDEX Cr. No./FIR No., Year & Page Sl. State Finger Print Expert No. Sections No. Criteria for Selection of Entries for Award of Excellence in Finger Print Science / Identification i-iv 34/2013, 1. Karnataka Shri. N. Somashankar 1-2 U/S 394 IPC 6/2016 , A) Kr. G. Swarna Jyothy U/S 457/380 IPC 2. Telangana 3-6 37/2016, B) B. Naresh U/S 454/380 IPC 315/2017, 3. Andhra Pradesh Shri. T. Ramachandra Rao 7-8 U/S 457/380 IPC 265/2013 , 4. Mizoram Shri. KC Hmingthanga 9-10 U/S 302/201 IPC 3398/2007, U/S 302/307/121AIPC & 3/4/5 5. Uttar Pradesh Smt. Vimla Singh 11 Explosive Act & 15/16 Prevention of Unlawful activities Act 18/2014, A) Shri Vinayak Garode U/S 397 IPC, 235(2) CrPC 6. Maharashtra 86/2014, 12-15 B) Smt. Gaikwad Rupali U/S 397, 394, 458, 342, 427, 34 Avinash IPC R/W 37(1), 135 B.P. Act 375/2018, U/S 457/380 IPC 7. Tamilnadu Shri. G. Siva 16-19 2566/2017, U/S 454,380 IPC 396/2016, 8. Madhya Pradesh Shri. O.P. Batham 20 U/S 302 IPC Shri. Bhagaban Sahoo, Shri. 46/2017, 9. Odisha 21-22 A.B. Das & Shri.C.R. Nayak U/S 449/302/380 IPC Finger Print Expert, FPB, 57/2017, 10. Punjab 23 Phillaur U/S 302/201/511/34 IPC A) Smt. Rikhi 38/2015, U/S 395/397/376 IPC Bhattacharya 11. West Bengal 565/15, 24-25 B) Sh. Saibal Dutta U/S 302/34 IPC 69/2017, 12. Goa Shri. Sudesh Hari Shetye 26 U/S 454/457/380 IPC CENTRAL FINGER PRINT BUREAU, NATIONAL CRIME RECORDS BUREAU CRITERIA FOR SELECTION OF ENTRIES FOR AWARD OF EXCELLENCE IN FINGER PRINT SCIENCE / IDENTIFICATION In order to encourage finger print experts of States/UTs, the then DG, NCRB Smt Archana Ramasundaram, IPS, in January, 2016, decided to institute three awards for excellence in the field of finger print science. The awards included Cash prizes and a Certificates of Excellence for those securing top three positions. Cash prizes and certificates were distributed for the first time in XVII All India Conference of Directors of Finger Print Bureaux held on 2 & 3rd February, 2016 at PHQ, MP Police, Bhopal. Cash Prize of Rs. 10,000/-, 7,500/- and 5,000/- for 1st, 2nd and 3rd position was also decided for the top three rankers, respectively. The committees constituted for selection of candidates for award given in the year 2016 and 2017, followed the approved guidelines / rules which are as under The guidelines included the following criteria: 1. F.P. Experts’ intervention / role in comparison and identification. 2. Only criminal cases where conviction was achieved will be eligible for consideration of reward. (The criminal case brief/citation should clearly mention the role / importance of fingerprint comparison leading to conviction) 3. Finger print development at the Scene of Crime / comparison should have played a crucial role in solving the case. 4. Maximum number of nominations for each State/UT will be 02 (two), and shall not be above the rank of Dy. SP (FP). Only those in-service with accreditation as Finger Print Expert from Central Finger Print Bureau will be eligible. 5. Any other criteria found suitable by the approved selection committee. i | P a g e CENTRAL FINGER PRINT BUREAU, NATIONAL CRIME RECORDS BUREAU 6. In the event of tie for positions committee’s decision will be final. 7. Amount of cash prize for First position will be 10,000/- , second will get 7500/- while person securing third position will be eligible for Rs. 5000/- Previous committees also felt that: 8. Cases selected for award should not have date of FIR not earlier than 10 years from the decided cut of date. 9. Heinous crimes (i.e. murder, rape, etc) solved through fingerprints from the citations received should be given priority consideration for award. As the rules/guidelines frame for selection of awards were not very exhaustive, same individual / person Shri G. Manohar Babu, Inspector, FPU, CID, Tirupathy, AP, won the award(first prize) for 2 years consecutively i.e. in 2016 and 2017. In view of not very strict / water tight guidelines for deciding the nominations for award for excellence in FP Science, it was decided unanimously in the XVIII Directors Conference held at HPA, Madhuban Haryana on 30-31 March, 2017, that a committee should be constituted to look into various agenda points discussed, including the selection of nomination for award for excellence. Awards for Excellence in Finger Print Science/Identification for the year- 2018 A committee headed by the IGP, SCRB Tamil Nadu, Chennai Shri Sumit Saran, IPS was constituted, which had eight other members, which were Shri R.K. Vajpayee, Delhi, Shri N.K. Vadhera, Shri S.Mandal, CFPB, Smt. S. Indira Sudha, CFPB, Shri A. Mohapatra, Odisha, Manish Chaubey, MP, G. Krishnamurthy, TN, and AK Sahu, CFSL, CBI Delhi. The criteria for selection of winners for Excellence in FP Science were given by the above committee. ii | P a g e CENTRAL FINGER PRINT BUREAU, NATIONAL CRIME RECORDS BUREAU CRITERIA FOR SELECTION OF WINNERS OF THE EXCELLENCE IN FINGER PRINT SCIENCE TO BE AWARDED IN CONFERENCE Participants NCRB will invite nominations from the state FPBx in September each year asking to nominate the cases identified using finger print for this competition where identification happened between to 31st August. Judgement Director NCRB will constitute a committee every year for selection of 3 winners based on the criteria listed below. Prizes First, Second and third prizes Other rules 1. Concerned director FPB or any other authorized officer must enclose a certification stating that case is identified during this period. 2. Name(s) of the FP expert involved and the crime details must be provided. Scheme of the event-competition Case Intensity- 15 Value Involved- 5 Inter-se cases- 5 Off-shoot cases- 5 Identification made through Single Digit Record- 6 Identification made through own collection- 6 Identification made through AFIS- 6 Identification made through suspects slips / daily arrest- 6 Cross examination in the court- 6 Effort on development on chance print- 30 Time taken in giving report- 10 iii | P a g e CENTRAL FINGER PRINT BUREAU, NATIONAL CRIME RECORDS BUREAU The Director, NCRB has nominated 04 members of CFPB for evaluation of cases received from 12 States / UTs: 1. Director / Incharge, CFPB Shri B. Roy : Ex officio Chairman 2. Dy. Supdt. (F.P.), CFPB Shri S.P. Singh : Member 3. Dy. Supdt. (F.P.), CFPB Shri P.S. Gulati : Member 4. Inspector (FP), CFPB Shri Shibajee Tripathy : Member *** iv | P a g e CENTRAL FINGER PRINT BUREAU, NATIONAL CRIME RECORDS BUREAU KARNATAKA Finger Print Expert: Sh. N. Somashankar C.R. No: 34/2013, U/S 394 IPC Date: 07/02/2013 Police Station: Malur, Kolar District Case description: SOC and chance print photographs: Highlight of case: Smt. Rajamma resident of Lakkur village, Malur Taluk was assaulted by 04 unknown persons and was robbed of Rs.8, 00,000/- cash with 400 grams of Gold ornaments amounting to a total of Rs.16,00,000/-. : This is a case of robbery. Experts role – Special techniques used in development of Chance Prints: N.Somashankar, Finger Print Expert, was able to develope the Chance Print on the Cellophane Parcel Tape (sticky side) because of the Advanced Latent Finger Print Training attended by him during 16/5/2011 to 20/5/2011 organised by CDTS Kolkata and trained by the professionals of Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), U.S.A. FP expert was able to develop the Chance Print on the spot by using the mixing liquid of hair shampoo and available Graphite Powder on his own. This is 1 | P a g e CENTRAL FINGER PRINT BUREAU, NATIONAL CRIME RECORDS BUREAU the first case in India where the chance print on the Cellophane parcel Tape (sticky side) was developed and the case was detected using Finger print science.