Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel s5

PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION REGULATORY PANEL

7th March, 2013

Meeting commenced: 9.30 a.m. “ adjourned: 11.15 a.m. “ reconvened: 11.30 a.m. “ adjourned: 1.45 p.m. “ reconvened: 3.15 p.m. “ ended: 4.15 p.m.

PRESENT: Councillor Mashiter - in the Chair Councillors Antrobus, E. Burgoyne, Clague, K. Garrido, McIntyre, Ord, Pugh, G. Wilson and R. Wilson

Councillor Kean during consideration of all items except planning applications 12/62470/COU (9 Tootal Grove, Salford M6 8DN), 12/62582/EIAHYB (Land Bounded By Lower Broughton Road, Great Clowes Street, Cumberland Street and Wheaters Street, Lower Broughton, Salford M7 1QE), 12/62420/FUL (Car Park, West Riverside, New Bailey Street, Salford) and agenda items 8 (Site of the Former Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital), 9 (Planning Appeals) and 10 (Traffic Management Unit)

Councillor Critchley during consideration of all items except planning application 12/62420/FUL (Car Park, West Riverside, New Bailey Street, Salford) and agenda items 8 (Site of the Former Royal Manchester Children’s Hospital), 9 (Planning Appeals) and 10 (Traffic Management Unit)

Councillor J. Murphy during consideration of all items except planning application 12/62470/COU (9 Tootal Grove, Salford M6 8DN)

ALSO IN ATTENDANCE:

Councillors Collinson and R. Garrido in respect of planning applications 13/62728/FUL and 13/62732/ADV (11 Chaddock Lane, Worsley M28 1DH)

Please note that a list of persons in attendance in respect of matters referred to in Minutes 122, 124 and 125 is attached at Appendix A.

119. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

Apologies for absence were submitted on behalf of Councillor Potter and Mr. Jim Wheelton. D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 2

120. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

Councillor K. Garrido declared interests in respect of planning applications 12/62621/FUL (Land at Hulton Avenue and Westwood Avenue, Worsley M28 0HN) and 12/62470/COU (9 Tootal Grove, Salford M6 8DN) and did not take part in the Panel’s deliberations or vote on those applications.

Councillor Kean declared an interest in respect of planning application 12/62621/FUL (Land at Hulton Avenue and Westwood Avenue, Worsley M28 0HN) and did not take part in the Panel’s deliberations or vote on that application.

121. MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS

RESOLVED: THAT the minutes of the meetings of the Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel, held on 7th February and 21st February 2013, were agreed as correct records.

122. APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

(Full details of the matters referred to in this Minute are contained in the report of the Strategic Director for Environment & Community Safety, as amended, in the case of the applications marked * in the supplementary report).

RESOLVED: (1) THAT it be noted that planning application 12/62679/OUT (Land on South Side of Holyoake Road, Walkden, Worsley) had been withdrawn from the agenda.

(2) THAT, following consideration by the Panel, the under-mentioned applications for planning permission were determined, subject to the conditions, as indicated below:-

Application Number/ Site Development Decision Applicant

13/62728/FUL 111 Chaddock Change of use of part Granted, subject to Mr. Mohammed Lane of the ground floor to (a) the revision of Yousaf Worsley shop, replacement condition 1 M28 1DH shop front and amending the hours installation of roller of use to between shutters 8.00 a.m. to 9.30 p.m., and (b) the addition of a condition restricting levels of background noise. D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 3

The Panel made an urgent request for Building Control to liaise with the applicant and objector regarding the alterations that have taken place, the results of which are to be reported back to the Chair of the Panel.

The Panel also requested that the Enforcement Team investigate the reported storage of chillers/refrigerators at the rear of the building to establish whether any further planning permission is required.

13/62732/ADV 111 Chaddock Retrospective planning Granted, subject to Mr.Mohammed Lane application for the the addition of a Yousaf Worsley display of seven non condition requiring M28 1DH illuminated signs and the submission of a one externally scheme and any illuminated sign mitigation that may be required that demonstrates that the illumination associated with the advert does not result in adverse light spillage. The signs shall not be illuminated until such a scheme has been submitted, approved and D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 4

implemented.

*12/62582/EIAHYB Land Bounded by Full planning Granted Countryside Lower Broughton permission for the Properties (UK) Ltd. Road, Great demolition of 31 Great and Salford City Clowes St., Clowes Street and Council Cumberland St Mocha Parade and the and Wheaters St, erection of 189 Lower Broughton dwellings with Salford associated works. M7 1QE Outline application with all matters reserved except for access for the redevelopment of Mocha Parade Neighbourhood Centre (use class A1 to A5 and D1) for up to 4500sqm of gross retail floorspace and 225 car parking spaces together with associated works 12/62670/HH 39 Radcliffe Park Retrospective planning Refused Mr. Mike Branagan Road application for the Salford erection of a boundary M6 7WP wall 12/62621/FUL Land at Hulton Demolition of existing Granted, subject to City West Housing Avenue and properties and erection the addition of Trust – Mrs. Claire Westwood Avenue of six bungalows, five conditions relating to Kelly Worsley dwellings and one (a) the submission M28 0HN shop with two flats of a scheme above, together with regarding the car parking and provision of roller landscaping shutters, the housing of which should be incorporated into the fabric of the building, (b) the hours of use of the retail unit being restricted to the hours currently D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 5

operated by the existing shop trader (Monday to Friday 6.00 a.m. to 7.00 p.m., and Saturday and Sunday 7.00 a.m. to 9.00 p.m.), and (c) alternative community provision (this will involve, in the first instance, an investigation as to whether such provision can be provided within the immediate local area taking into account the timing of the development and demand at that time, and secondly, should it not be possible for alternative provision to be made in the immediate area, a scheme for the transport of community users to Tyne Court, or other such alternative location, is provided).

*12/62420/FUL Car Park Erection of a 14 storey Granted Hotel La Tour and West Riverside high 223 bedroomed Bruntwood Ltd. New Bailey St hotel Salford *12/62470/COU 9 Tootal Grove Continued use as a Granted, subject to Mr. A. Mannan Salford commercial laundry (a) condition 1 being M6 8DN (Class B1) with amended to reduce variation of Condition 2 the hours of attached to planning operation to Monday permission to Friday 9.00 a.m. D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 6

09/58028/COU to to 9.00 p.m., and allow opening hours Saturday/ 9am-11pm Monday- Sunday/Bank Sunday including Bank Holidays 9.00 a.m. Holidays to 8.00 p.m., and (b) the addition of conditions in respect of the proposed limitations set out in the supplementary report.

*12/62660/REM Former Gus Home Details of reserved Granted, subject to Bellway Homes Shopping Ltd. matters application for consultation taking North West Worsley Road the labout, scale, place with the local Eccles appearance, and community with M30 8NR landscaping in relation regard to the to the erection of 175 considerate dwellings pursuant of contractors planning permission condition (12) 10/59727/OUT attached to the outline approval prior to submission, following which the condition be agreed with the Chair of the Panel prior to issue.

12/62703/HH 310 Leigh Road Retention of existing Refused Mr. Tony Camilleri Worsley garage with modified M28 1LH roof design and landscaping

123. PLANNING APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY

The Strategic Director for Environment & Community Safety submitted a report containing details of planning applications which he had determined under delegated authority during January and February 2013 and were not, therefore, for consideration by the Panel.

Clarification was sought with regard to the meaning of some of the terms contained within the report.

RESOLVED: (1) THAT a glossary of terms be included in future reports. D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 7

(2) THAT the decisions in respect of the under-mentioned applications be noted:-

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision 13/62804/ART16 Article 16 Article 16 consultation No objections Bury Council – Tom Drinkwater received from Bury 15th February 2013 Beirne Park Council for the Clifton Road construction of all Prestwich weather pitch, Manchester floodlighting, 4m high ball fence and 2.4m high security fencing around all weather pitch and car park

13/62848/ART16 Article 16 Article 16 consultation No objections Ms. V. Ward – Carrington received from Trafford 22nd February 2013 Trafford Council Power Station Council for approval of Manchester details reserved by Road condition in respect of Carrington conditions 9 and 11 of Manchester the Section 36 M31 4AY Consent for the Carrington Power Station Project

12/62674/FUL 407-409 Installation of a new Approved Mr. W. Majid Liverpool Rd shop front 15th February 2013 Eccles M30 7HB

12/62675/ADV 407-409 Display of externally Approved Mr. W. Majid Liverpool Rd illuminated fascia sign 11th February 2013 Eccles M30 7HB

13/62829/DEMCON 1 Lewis Street Prior notification for the No objections Childrens Services – Eccles demolition of 1 Lewis 22nd February 2013 Mr. G. Durkin M30 0PU Street

12/62606/HH 67 Lymefield Erection of a part Refused Mrs. R. Backhouse Drive single part two storey 29th January 2013 Worsley rear extension M28 1WA

D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 8

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision 12/62616/HH 4 Ridgmont Erection of a pitched Approved Mrs. L. Seddon Drive roof and construction 4th February 2013 Worsley of front dormer (re-sub M28 1JN of 12/62337/HH)

12/62687/DISCON Land to Rear of Request for Part Discharge of Windmill Rise SPV 253 to 257 confirmation of Condition Ltd Mosley compliance of 6th February 2013 Common Road conditions Worsley 1,2,3,45,7,9,10,11,12 attached to planning permission 11/59895/FUL

12/62153/FUL Beis Hatalmud Change of use from Approved Beis Hatalmud High School existing modular 4th February 2013 School for Boys Land off buildings to school, Wellington erection of a link Street West/ building and external Back Hilton St cladding to existing Salford modular buildings, and M7 2ED erection of a cycle store

12/62540/FUL Footpath at Installation of a 17.5m Approved Telefonica UK Ltd. Corner of Ellis high Telefonica 15th February 2013 Street and telecommunication Trafalgar St pole with 3no. Broughton antennas, together M8 9TZ with 4no radio equipment cabinets and 1 no meter pillar

12/62579/FUL Various Erection of 14 poles Approved Manchester Eruv locations within with a maximum height 15th February 2013 Committee – Mr. S. an area of 8m, provision of 5 Lopian encompassed new archways with a by Back maximum height 3.8m Roman Road, all associated with the Great creation of a Eruv Cheetham St. East, Basten Drive, Bennett Drive, Leicester Walk, Hartis D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 9

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision Ave, Devonshire St, Norton Street Gainsborough Street Broughton Salford

13/62790/DISCON 488 Great Request for Discharge of Geraldine Hickey Cheetham confirmation of Condition Street East compliance with of 8th February 2013 Salford condition 3 (Colour M7 4TW Treatment) attached to planning permission 12/61999/FUL

12/62530/FUL Opal Installation of four GRP Approved Mr. Steven Mildren Telecommunic enclosure which would 15th February 2013 ations house three electrical Brinell Drive switch panels, one Irlam transformer and one M44 5BL 1250kva Generator

12/62565/FUL Omega Construction of Approved Omega Engineering Engineering additional 56no car 6th February 2013 Ltd. Limited Phase parking spaces 1 together with erection Omega Drive of a single storey Cadishead extension to front M44 5BD elevation

13/62792/DISCON Irlam and Request for Not discharging Mr. A. Hewitt Cadishead confirmation of 12th February 2013 Leisure Centre compliance of Liverpool Road condition 8 Irlam (Landscaping) attached to planning permission 10/59679/FUL

12/62515/TPO Winstanley Crown reduce to leave Approved Mrs. L. Needham Close a height of 9m two 20th February 2013 Salford silver birch trees (T1 M6 7EZ and T3). Crown reduce to leave a height of D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 10

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision 14m two silver birch trees (T2 and T4). Crown reduce to leave a height of 8m one silver birch tree (T5). Crown reduce to leave a height of 10m one silver birch tree (T6).

12/62639/HH 47 May Road Demolition of existing Approved Mr. Gareth Hadfield Swinton garage and erection of 6th February 2013 M27 5FS a two storey side and rear extension and erection of an detached garage, together with raised decking and balustrade to the rear (re-sub of 12/62406/HH)

13/62714/HH 14 Woodfield Erection of a single Approved Peter Wright Road storey rear extension 22nd February 2013 Salford M6 7QE

13/62798/DISCON The Lodge Request for Part Discharge of Mr. P. Fleury Former Royal confirmation of Condition Manchester compliance of 21st February 2013 Childrens conditions 3.1 and 3.2 Hospital attached to planning Hospital Road permission Pendlebury 12/61329/FUL Swinton

12/62386/TEL56 Pavement at Prior notification for the No objections BT PLC the Rear of 13 installation of one BT 22nd February 2013 Half Edge Lane DSLAM cabinet Eccles M30 9AY

12/62635/TPO Ashbank Prune branches as Approved Mr. Thomas J.B. 9 Half Edge indicated on the 30th January 2013 Evans Lane attached photograph Eccles one sycamore tree (T7) D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 11

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision 13/62803/TREECA Highway Prune the branches of Split decision Mr. Thomas J.B. adjacent to one horse chestnut 21st February 2013 Evans Ashbank tree (T1) two sycamore 9 Half Edge trees (T4 and T5) and Lane two lime trees (T2 and Eccles T3) and fell one cypress tree (T6)

12/62620/FUL College Croft Alterations to external Approved City West Housing Eccles elevations to include 14th February 2013 Trust – Mrs. Victoria M30 0AN over-cladding, glazed Briscoe enclosures to balconies, new entrance and roof terrace. Demolition of concrete bridge links at first floor level, part change of use of ground floor to A1 use and installation of low emission LED lighting strips to the South East and South West elevations from first floor up to roof level, continuing to the underside and around the ‘floating’ frame

12/62640/FUL Former Barn Change of use of Refused Mr. Nicholas Garage vacant land to car 4th February 2013 Whatmore 20 Wellington wash together with Road installation of a Eccles portacabin and M30 0NP erection of a 2.4m high fence and gates

12/62665/HH 55 Park Road Erection of a single Approved Mr. Wayne Parish Eccles storey side extension 4th February 2013 M30 9JJ

13/62742/TPO 7 Westminster Crown raise to 6m and Approved Mr. G. Hughes Road 20% crown thin four 11th February 2013 Eccles sycamore trees (T1, M30 9HF T2, T4 and T6) and D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 12

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision two lime trees (T3 and T6)

13/62766/TPO Abbeydale Remove any branches Approved Mrs. M. Pender Nursing Home overhanging 13 The 22nd February 2013 11 The Polygon back to the Polygon boundary fence one Eccles hawthorn tree (T1) M30 0DS 12/62651/HH 5 Paturegreen Erection of a two Approved Mr. K. Taylor Way storey side extension 30th January 2013 Irlam M44 6TE

12/62270/DISCON Former Land Request for Part Discharge of W. Maher and Sons Hercules Ltd. confirmation of Condition Ltd. Langley Road compliance of 18th February 2013 Pendlebury conditions 4,6,8,9 and Swinton 10 attached to planning permission 09/58060/FUL

12/62614/ADV Ashworth Display of two non- Approved University of Salford Building illuminated totem pole 28th January 2013 – Mr. D. Wong University of signage Salford 3 Cockcroft Road Salford M5 4NT

13/62733/DISCON Forest Request for Discharge of Mr. Dave Foster Upholstery Ltd. confirmation for Condition Newbury compliance of 1st February 2013 House condition 3 and 4 Greenwood attached to planning Street permission Salford 12/62217/FUL M6 6PD

13/62755/DEMCON 26-34 Eagle Prior notification for the No objections Salford City Council Drive demolition of 26-34 11th February 2013 Salford Eagle Drive M6 6EY

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision 13/62774/DEMCON 35-41 Condor Prior notification for the No Objections Salford City Council Place demolition of 35-41 11th February 2013 Salford Condor Place M6 6FU

13/62770/DEMCON 1-9 Delft Walk Prior notification for the No Objections Salford City Council Salford demolition of 1-9 Delft 11th February 2013 M6 6FF Walk

13/62775/DEMCON 49-52 Parsons Prior notification for the No Objections Salford City Council Field demolition of 49-52 11th February 2013 Salford Parsons Field M6 6EZ

13/62827/NMA Duchy Stores Application for a non- Refused Mr. P. Patel 33-35 Duchy material amendment to 21st February 2013 Road planning permission Salford 12/62026/FUL for M6 7LB raising the sill height on the front elevation, repositioning of the bathroom windows to the rear elevation, an additional bathroom to the first and second floor and two additional windows to the side elevation

12/62478/HH 58 Upper Park Erection of a first floor Approved Mr. L. Reich Road rear extension 18th February 2013 Salford M7 4JA

12/62578/FUL Mesnesfield Erection of 2no poles Approved Manchester Eruv Road height of 5m 15th February 2013 Committee – Salford associated with the Mr. S. Lopian M7 3QD creation of a Eruv

12/62673/TPO 8 New Hall Crown lift to provide a Approved Mr. Wilks Road 5.5m clearance over 20th February 2013 Salford the highway and a M7 4EL 2.5m clearance over the footway one sycamore tree (T1) D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 14

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision

12/62693/TPO Site on Corner Crown reduce to leave Approved Mr. McKenna of Singleton & a height of 11/12m 8th February 2013 Holden Road (high pollards) nine 22-26 lime trees within group Singleton Road (G1) Salford M7 4WL

12/62456/FUL Humphrey Erection of 50 new Approved Mr. J. Saltman Booth Gardens dwellings and 30th January 2013 Sandy Lane associated car parking Salford and landscaping M6 8RU

12/62546/FUL Land Bounded Erection of a drive Approved Salford Estates No.2 by Rossall Way through restaurant with 30th January 2013 Ltd and Hankinson associated parking and Way (To The landscaping, and minor North of amendments to the Salford adjacent car park Shopping Centre Pendleton Salford

12/62554/OUT Land Adjacent Demolition of existing Refused Mr. H. Woodward to 52 Derby garage and outline 4th February 2013 Road application with all Salford matters reserved for M6 5YD the erection of two dwellings (re-sub of 12/62147/OUT)

12/62572/FUL Land Between Erection of affordable Approved Great Places 38 and 48 housing scheme 21st February 2013 Housing Group – Fitzwarren comprising of 23 Ms. Katherine Street dwellings together with Kitchener Salford associated landscaping, car parking and construction of new vehicular and pedestrian access D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 15

13/62751/NMA Land at the Application for a non- Approved Ms. K. Kitchener Corner of material amendment to 11th February 2013 Langworthy planning permission Road and 11/61035/FUL for Lower Seedley addition of canopies to Road rear entrance doors of Salford plots 2 to 10 inclusive M6 rWW 12/62662/FUL Land Bounded Erection of 7 dwelings, Approved Ekantika Ltd. – Mrs. by Kenyon one convenience store 14th February 2013 Sunita Kanji Way and with 2 apartments at Parkway first floor level, Little Hulton together with access, Salford parking and landscaping

12/61843/DISCON Land Bounded Part Discharge of 15th February 2013 Mr. T. Tubb by Derwent Condition Street, Ordsall Lane, South Hall St and The River Irwell Salford M5 4SZ

12/61912/DISCON Land Bounded Request for Part Discharge of Mr. T. Tubb – by Derwent confirmation of Condition Renaker Build Ltd. Street, Ordsall compliance of 15th February 2013 Lane, South conditions 5 and 20 Hall Street and attached to planning The River Irwell permission Salford 10/58558/FUL M5 4SZ

12/62371/FUL Unit 2A Removal of existing Approved Mr. F. Khalifa 400 Ordsall fence and installation 29th January 2013 Lane of security bollards, Salford construction of M5 3BU mezzanine floor to building to provide storage, office and staff room

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision 12/62493/FUL Primrose Hill Erection of 2.4m high Approved Mrs. Michelle Community access gate together 1st February 2013 Midgley Primary School with provision of new Phoebe Street footpath Salford M5 3PJ

12/62608/FUL The Bijou Club Erection of a bin store Approved Mr. D. Wride – 1-7 Chapel St 15th February 2013 Salford City Council Salford M3 7NJ

12/62649/ADV Maud Works Display of two Approved Mr. Jon Crouch King William St internally illuminated 11th February 2013 Salford fascia signs and one M50 3UQ internally illuminated other sign 13/62712/ADV Multi-storey Display of three Approved Mr. M. Carroll Car Park internally illuminated 6th February 2013 Media City advertisement Broadway hoardings Salford M50 2EQ

13/62723/ADV 1-2 Dakota Display of 6 non- Approved John Walls Avenue illuminated 18th February 2013 Salford advertisements M50 2PU

12/62637/HH 54 Ellesmere Erection of a first floor Approved Mr & Mrs. Fernhead Street side extension 6th February 2013 Swinton M27 0JS

12/62643/HH 2 Wheatley Extension to existing Approved Mr. Michael Hodgins Road front dormer window 1st February 2013 Wardley Swinton M27 9RW

12/62647/HH 6 Chendre Erection of a front Approved Mr. Lee Grundy Close porch 8th February 2013 Swinton M27 6HJ D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 17

12/62658/HH 54 Moss Lane Erection of a detached Approved Mr. Neil Watkiss Wardley garage 8th February 2013 Swinton M27 9RZ

13/62707/HH 30 Woodford Erection of a first floor Approved Mrs. Donna Fairhurst Drive side extension 15th February 2013 Swinton M27 9UA

12/62365/DISCON Morrisons Request for Part Discharge of Mr. Gareth Wilkinson Supermarket confirmation of Condition 49 Swinton Hall compliance of 6th February 2013 Road conditions 2,4,5,6,10 Swinton attached to planning M27 4BT permission 12/61426/FUL

12/62627/DISCON St. Marys Request for Discharge of St. Marys Roman Roman confirmation of Condition Catholic Primary Catholic compliance of 28th January 2013 School Primary School condition 3 attached to Milner Street planning permission Swinton 12/62079/FUL M27 4AS

12/62646/ADV Wm Morrison Display of one totem Approved Mr. Gareth Wilkinson Supermarkets pole and three fascia 8th February 2013 plc signs internally 49 Swinton Hall illuminated Road Swinton M27 4BT

12/62648/FUL Wm Morrison Retrospective planning Approved Mr. Gareth Wilkinson Supermarkets for the installation of 8th February 2013 plc two ATM machines 49 Swinton Hall Road Swinton M27 4BT

12/62689/ADV Swinton Erection of a 48 sheet Refused Mr. James Smith Angling Centre advertisement 15th February 2013 D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 18

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision 57 Worsley hoarding on gable Road elevation Swinton M27 5NE

12/61934/FUL Oaklands Erection of a three Approved Ramsay Health Care Hospital storey infill front 30th January 2013 Ltd. UK Operations 19 Lancaster extension, two and a Ltd. Road half storey side Salford extension, first floor M6 8AQ rear extension, two single storey rear extensions, alterations to elevations and creation of 6 additional parking spaces

12/62641/FUL De La Salle Erection of side and Approved De La Salle Sports/ Sports and rear extensions, new 8th February 2013 Social Club Social Club face brickwork to outer Lancaster walls and new tiled Road roof together with Salford alterations to the M6 8AQ elevations

12/62589/FUL Laura James Installation of new Approved Ms. Laura James Hair Studio shop front 30th January 2013 536 Liverpool Road Eccles M30 7JA

12/62668/HH 8 Grange Road Erection of a Approved Mr. Craig Cottrell Eccles conservatory to side 11th February 2013 M30 8JQ elevation

13/62736/DISCON Former Gus Request for Part Discharge of Bellway Homes Home confirmation of Condition North West Shopping compliance of 18th February 2013 Warehouse conditions Worsley Road 1,2,3,5,6,7,9, Eccles 10,11,13,14 and 15 M30 8NR attached to planning permission 10/59727/OUT D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 19

12/62559/HH 13 Ladywell Erection of a two Approved Mrs. L. Kiseliova Avenue storey side extension 31st January 2013 Little Hulton M38 9GN

12/62567/DISCON Blockbuster Request for Part Discharge of Video Express confirmation of Condition 35-37 New compliance of 30th January 2013 Ellesmere conditions 2,3,5,6,7,11, Approach 15,16,17,18,19,20,21 Worsley attached to planning M28 3EE permission 11/60807/FUL

12/62634/FUL Unit 152 Alterations to rear Approved AEW Architects – Ellesmere elevation to install a 4th February 2013 Mr. Gareth Jones Shopping new shop front Centre Bolton Road Worsley M28 3ZH

12/62146/COU 246 Leigh Change of use of land Approved Mr. R. Hannant Road from golf course to 31st January 2013 Worsley private garden M28 1LE

12/62583/FUL 32 Roe Green Extension of time limit Approved Dr. V. Joshi Worsley for implementation of 4th February 2013 M28 2RF planning permission 09/57495/FUL for the demolition of existing dwelling and erection of a new dwelling and construction of a vehicular access

12/62591/HH 11 Mulgrave Erection of a single Approved Mr. & Mrs. Anthony Road storey side and rear 15th February 2013 Lee Worsley extension M28 2RW

12/62629/HH 4 Brentwood Erection of a rear Approved Mr. Lee Hancock Road conservatory 15th February 2013 D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 20

Application Number/ Site Development Decision and Date Applicant of Decision Swinton M27 0EE

12/62685/HH 44 Chatsworth Erection of a part Approved Mr. & Mrs. M. Road single part two storey 14th February 2013 Howard Worsley front extension, first M28 2WT floor extension over dormer garage and single storey side extension

12/62691/TPO Worsley Lodge Prune to provide a 2m Approved Hc-One Care Centre clearance from the 11th February 2013 119 Worsley building the trees Road within group (V3) Worsley M28 2WG

12/62431/FUL Robin Hall Erection of a single Approved Mr Sam Addison Opticians storey rear extension 15th February 2013 3 Bridgewater Road Worsley M28 3JE

13/62806/DISCON Ellesmere Golf Request for Discharge of Mr. Michael Lewis Club confirmation of Condition Old Clough compliance of Lane conditions 3 and 4 Worsley attached to planning M28 7HZ permission 12/61941/FUL

124. HIGH HEDGES AT 23 GILLERS GREEN, WORSLEY

Consideration was given to a report of the Strategic Director for Environment and Community Safety with regard to a complaint that had been received in respect of high hedges at 23 Gillers Green, Worsley.

A representation was made to the Panel with regard to the above complaint.

RESOLVED: THAT the landowner be served with a remedial notice requiring the hedge to be initially reduced in height to 4m within 2 months of the date of the notice with an ongoing requirement to ensure the height does not exceed 4.9m in height. D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 21

(It was noted that the owner of the hedge would receive a copy of the High Hedge Arboricultural Assessment Report explaining the decision and the calculations).

125. SITE OF THE FORMER ROYAL MANCHESTER CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL – RESPONSE TO REMARKS SUBMITTED BY MR. G. UREY AT THE PANEL MEETING HELD ON 10 TH JANUARY, 2013

Consideration was given to a report of the Strategic Director for Environment and Community Safety which (a) explained the enforcement action that had been taken in relation to Mr. Urey’s complaint, (b) outlined responses to his points raised at the Panel meeting held on 10th January, 2013 and (c) set out recommendations as to how the Non Material Amendment case and the enforcement case were intended to be concluded.

Mr. Urey addressed the Panel with regard to the issues raised within the report.

RESOLVED: (1) THAT the content of the report be noted and the recommendations made in the background submissions be agreed.

(2) THAT Mr. Urey be thanked for the work he had undertaken in respect of this matter.

126. PLANNING APPEALS

A report of the Strategic Director for Environment and Community Safety was submitted which set out details of appeals that had been received and determined during February 2013.

RESOLVED: THAT the content of the report be noted.

127. TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT UNIT

A report of the Strategic Director for Environment and Community Safety was submitted which detailed recommendations that had been made by the Traffic Management Unit in respect of the matters indicated.

Reference was made to the report that had been submitted in respect of (B) Priestley Road, Walkden. It was indicated that the Community Committee had since decided not to fund the proposed traffic regulation order and it was suggested that contact be made with the local businesses in the area to establish whether they would be willing to fund the proposed order.

RESOLVED: (1) THAT with regard to (B) Priestley Road, Walkden, contact be made with the local businesses in the area in order to establish whether they would be willing to fund the proposed order.

(2) THAT approval be granted to draft and advertise the Traffic Regulation Orders detailed below and the Strategic Director for Customer and Support Services be authorised to take the necessary legal action in connection therewith:-

(A) WOODROW WAY, IRLAM

PROPOSAL A request has been received from Community Committee and also from the Police, to introduce waiting restrictions on Woodrow Way. This is to combat the problem of HGV drivers who are using all the existing space by parking for a number of days and camping out, preventing a turnover of vehicles to service local businesses.

In order to prevent the HGVs parking for prolonged periods and being mindful of the needs of local businesses, it is proposed to introduce some areas of No waiting at any time, and a number of parking bays with limited waiting for a maximum of four hours.

DECISION INTRODUCTION OF:

No Waiting at any time

Woodrow Way Irlam, north west side, from a point 68 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, for its entire length, including side road entrances.

Woodrow Way Irlam, east side, from a point 77 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, in a south-westerly and south easterly direction, for a distance of 96 metres.

Woodrow Way Irlam, east side, from a point 168 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, in a south easterly and south westerly direction, for a distance of 134 metres, including side road entrances.

Woodrow Way Irlam, south side, from a point 314 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, in a south-westerly direction, for a distance of 74 metres.

Woodrow Way Irlam, south side, from a point 388 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, in a south westerly direction, for a distance of 39 metres, including side road entrances.

Limited waiting bays: Waiting Limited to 4 hours no return within 4 hours

Woodrow Way Irlam, east side, from a point 96 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, in a south easterly direction, for a distance of 72 metres.

Woodrow Way Irlam, south side, from a point 302 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, in a south westerly direction for a distance of 12 metres.

Woodrow Way Irlam, south side, from a point 388 metres south of the southern kerbline of Fairhills Road, in a south-westerly direction, for a distance of 24 metres.

(B) PRIESTLEY ROAD, WALKDEN

See (1) above.

(C) AMBROSE BARLOW, MANCHESTER ROAD, SWINTON

PROPOSAL Plans to construct a new 750 place secondary school and 250 place sixth form college with associated facilities were approved by Salford City Council Planning Panel in September 2011. Construction work commenced in November 2011 and is due for completion by April 2013. The site will have vehicular/pedestrian accesses from Manchester Road and Ash Drive.

Manchester Road currently have a 40MPH speed limit however with the construction of the new school and college it is proposed to reduce the speed limit to 30MPH for a length in front of, and on the approaches to the new development.

School Keep Clear markings are proposed at the access locations.

It is also proposed to install a new staggered pedestrian crossing on Manchester Road. this may take the form of a Pelican or a Toucan Crossing however this and the exact location of the crossing is yet to be determined. The views of the units would be welcomed on this matter.

DECISION Introduction of School Keep Clear Order on Manchester Road, Swinton north side from a point 106m in North West of the easterly junction with Tamarin Close for a distance of 44m in a north westerly direction.

(D) STOTT LANE, CAR PARK, SALFORD

PROPOSAL On 20th March 2012, the Assistant Mayor for Strategic Planning approved the introduction of pay and display car park on the side of the existing hospital car park at Stott Lane.

In order to meet the changing demands of car park users, it is now intended to introduce ‘Pay by Phone ' facilities on this car park. Visitors to the hospital using this car park are often unsure as to how long they will need to stay and this system gives drivers the facility to register their car on arrival and pay for the time spent when they leave.

The Parking Services section have been approached by three companies offering a 12 month trial for this service and so it is intended to introduce the Pay by Phone facility for a trial period initially to assess the demand for the service.

Pay by phone parking enables drivers to pay for their parking using their mobile phone instead of having to put money in a meter or Pay and Display machine. The parking fee is simply charged to a chosen credit or debit card.

One of the main benefits is that drivers do not need to have the right change to use the car park or risk underpaying when they arrive. It is a quick, easy and secure method of paying for parking.

The pay and display machines will still be available for drivers who wish to use cash to purchase their parking ticket.

DECISION INTRODUCTION OF:

‘Pay by Phone’ facilities at the Stott Lane car park, Salford.

(E) PROPOSED INTRODUCTIONOF ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING

PROPOSAL Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM) have secured an overall funding package of £2.7million from the Office for Low Emission Vehicles (OLEV), Greater Manchester Integrated Transport Block (ITB) funding and private sector funding from Electricity North West (ENW) to provide electric vehicle charging infrastructure across Greater Manchester as well as the necessary back office management systems. The infrastructure needs to be in place and operational by the end of March 2013 in order for TfGM to be able to claim the OLEV grant. Increasing the availability of electric vehicle charging points will encourage a greater take up of electric vehicles D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th March, 2013 26

by drivers and assist in reducing vehicle emissions at source.

The funding will provide up to 160 electric charging points across Greater Manchester which will be distributed around the districts. It is expected that Salford will receive 12-16 charging points which will be installed across Salford. The sites have been chosen to provide a mix of charging locations geographically spread across the City that include on highway parking bays, off street car parks, Council buildings and local educational facilities.

A detailed appraisal and indicative design of each site has been completed with representatives from TfGM, Electricity North West (ENW) and Electromotive (the post installation/manufacturing company) who have confirmed that the sites are suitable based on their electrical connections and phone signal. The sites have also been consulted on through the Council’s Traffic Management Unit process (TMU), which includes representatives from the emergency services and TfGM, and no objections have been raised.

DECISION  Introduction of Electric Vehicle Charging Only Bays on the following car parks:

Site Name No of Bays

Cleminson Street, Salford car park 2

Civic Centre Visitors car park 2

Fit City Irlam car park 2

Corporation Road, Eccles car park 2

John William Street car park, Eccles 2

Stott Lane car park, Salford 4

Walkden Gateway car park 2

Broughton Hub car park, Salford 2

Hankinson Way car park, Salford 2

 Introduction of Electric Vehicle Charging only bays as follows:

o Quay Street, Salford, north east side, from a point 1.8

metres north west of its junction with Browncross Street for a distance of 24 metres in a north westerly direction to provide four bays.

o Crescent, Salford, south west side, from a point 97 metres south west of its junction with Irwell Place for a distance of 12 metres in a south westerly direction to provide two bays.

o Exchange Quay, Salford, east side, 48 metres from its junction with Trafford Road, for a distance of 12 metres in a southerly direction to provide two bays.

APPENDIX A

PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION REGULATORY PANEL THURSDAY – 7 TH MARCH, 2013 LIST OF ATTENDEES

9.30 A.M. SESSION

APPLICATION NO. NAME OBJECTOR/ IN FAVOUR 12/62703/HH Tony Camilleri* Applicant 310 Leigh Road Mr. Paul Tunstall* Applicant’s Agent Worsley M28 1LH

12/62621/FUL Raymond Bowker Objector Land at Hulton Avenue Mr. Willam Mulligan* Objector and Westwood Avenue Mrs. Mulligan Objector Worsley Mr. J. Harris* Objector M28 0HN Mr. C. Harris* Objector Dennis Hawkes Objector Nigel Sedman* City West Amanda Graham Architect Hannah Ness City West

Item 7 - High Hedges at Mrs. Hodgkiss* Objector 23 Gillers Green Mrs. Haslam Objector Worsley Mr. Haslam Objector

12/62660/REM Mrs. Horrocks* In favour Former Gus Home Mr. Astale* Applicant’s Agent Shopping Ltd John Barnes Applicant Worsley Road Eccles M30 8NR

12/62670/HH Mark Arrowsmith Applicant’s Agent 39 Radcliffe Park Road Salford M6 7WP

11.30 A.M. SESSION

APPLICATION NO. NAME OBJECTOR/ IN FAVOUR 12/62470/COU Karl Barber* Objecting 9 Tootal Grove Mr. Mannan* Applicant Salford M6 8DN

13/62728/FUL Maggie Cook* Objecting 111 Chaddock Lane Steven Rose Objecting Worsley Councillor Robin Garrido* Ward Councillor M28 1DH Councillor Collinson Ward Councillor Joan Stanaway Objecting Alan Stanaway Objecting Mrs. Green Objecting Thomas Green Objecting Mrs. Sinkinson* Objecting

13/62732/ADV Maggie Cook* Objecting 111 Chaddock Lane Steven Rose Objecting Worsley Councillor Robin Garrido* Ward Councillor M28 1DH Councillor Collinson Ward Councillor Joan Stanaway Objecting Alan Stanaway Objecting Mrs. Green Objecting Thomas Green Objecting Mrs. Sinkinson Objecting

12/62582/EIAHYB Les Brown* Applicant Land Bounded By Jane Aspinall Applicant Lower Broughton Road, John Jones Applicant Great Clowes Street, Andrew Whitehead Applicant Cumberland Street and Wheaters Street Lower Broughton Salford M7 1QE

Item 8 – Site of the Gerald Urey* Former Royal Frank Reid Manchester Children’s Hospital

2.30 P.M. SESSION

APPLICATION NO. NAME OBJECTOR/ IN FAVOUR 12/62420/FUL Tania Buchanan Objector Car Park Chris Aspen In favour West Riverside Brian McCardell In favour New Bailey Street Peter Crowther In favour Salford Robert Bagley* In favour Carole Maldonado* Objector Liz Henning Objector Alison Messenger Objector Sharon Penpluna Objector Peter Kienast Objector Adrian Coleman In favour Jane Schofield* In favour

* Indicates persons who made representations to the Panel.

D:\Docs\2018-04-30\0d755433342cab520f748ca46148a667.doc