1. COMMENT: from Spreadsheet INSERT Original Comment Here

January 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.11-08/0055r0 IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs

TGp LB 110 Comment Resolution –Clause 3 – Additional Comments

Date: 2008-01-09

Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email ARINC, Inc. Francois Simon US DOT 2551 Riva Road 410-266-4531 [email protected] Annapolis, MD 21401

Abstract This paper addresses the comments addressing “Clause 3 Additional” comments. It includes responses to CR#: 45, 47, 58, 69, and 73

Submission page 1 Francois Simon, ARINC January 2008 doc.: IEEE 802.11-08/0055r0

LB110 Comment Resolution

1. COMMENT: [From Spreadsheet] INSERT Original Comment Here:

ID Commenter Clause Pg Ln Type Comment Suggested Remedy Recommended Resolution 45 Hart, Brian 3 2 19 TR Note QBSS is deprecated -a Replace WBSS by a better WAVE BSS needs to QBSS is a BSS with QoS term. Define relationship of remain defined as a features added, so WBSS is QBSS to BSS, especially what distinct type of BSS probably also deprecated. services, frames, fields and elements should not be used, and what policy should be adopted if they are received?

47 Caam- 3 2 19 TR Note QBSS is deprecated -a Replace WBSS by a better WAVE BSS needs to Winget, QBSS is a BSS with QoS term. Define relationship of remain defined as a Nancy features added, so WBSS is QBSS to BSS, especially what distinct type of BSS probably also deprecated. services, frames, fields and elements should not be used, and what policy should be adopted if they are received? 58 Jiang, Daniel 3 2 20 TR Why does a WBSS have one Remove the phrase "a single Accepted - (accepted in and only one provider? It WAVE service provider" from principal). A new seems to be a case of mixing the sentence and reconsider definition of WAVE up the need to define one and the definition. basic service set is only one initiator in a WBSS proposed. See Clause with the number of STAs 2 - CID# 52 of allowed to advitise for it. The document 2966r2. current definition might be sufficient for a roadside infrastruture oriented service provision point of view but will restrict the uses for peer to peer vehicular groups in terms of group forming, maintenance

and split operations. For example, if the STA that starts such a WBSS decides to leave (e.g. to join another WBSS for some more important services), should the current WBSS simply close?

69 Roy, Richard 3 2 24 ER Remove advertisement Replace: "3.168b WAVE Accepted in principle – service information element It is proposed to (WSIE): An information element remove the word that contains information advertisement from the specified by the upper layers. It amendment. It is also may be included as a field in a proposed to re-define WAVE Advertisement frame the WAVE information using the On-demand element (WIE) management frame." with definition. Refer to "3.168b WAVE information Clause 2 – CID# 62 in element (WIE): An information document 07-2947r2 element that contains for the definitions information specified by upper proposed for WAVE layers. It may be included as an mode. information element in a WAVE action frame or an on-demand beacon frame." Then, change all occurrences in the document of WSIE to WIE and change the text if necessary to eliminate the word "service".

73 Roy, Richard 3 2 27 TR CALM information element is Add 3.168c CALM information TGp task group is missing. element (CIE): An information hesistant to give CALM element that contains a separate IE. A more information specified by upper appropriate solution layers. It may be included as an might be to give CALM information element in a WAVE a subtype within the action frame or an On-demand WIE beacon frame."

2. Background, Explanation, Discussion, etc.:

These Comments are associated with comments related to “Clause 3 - Additional” comments classification.

3. Recommended Resolution of the Comments:

See the right column above for the resolutions of the individual comments.

References:

07/11-07-2481-06-000p-lb110-tgp-comment-resolution-master.xls

IEEE P802.11p/D3.0

Submission page 4 Francois Simon, ARINC